Research Publication Ethics
Toros University Journal of Food, Nutrition and Gastronomy adopts the principles of COPE (Committee on Publication Ethics) and the criteria of ICMJE (International Committee of Medical Journal Editors) regarding publication ethics standards. (https://publicationethics.org / https://www.icmje.org)
For the studies that require permission from the Ethics Committee (studies that require the application of a questionnaire or scale, that contain interviews and observations such as documents, pictures, questionnaires etc. that are developed by others and that require permission to use) (For research in all branches of science, including social sciences and ethics Ethics committee approval must be obtained separately for studies on clinical and experimental humans and animals that require a committee decision, this approval must be stated and documented in the article.) the necessary permissions from the ethics committees or commissions must be obtained before the research is conducted, these must be stated in the article content or submitted as an appendix. In the absence of these permissions, the publication is returned to the author at the preliminary examination stage.
In studies that require ethics committee permission, information about the permission (name of the committee, date and number) should be included in the method section and also on the first/last page of the article. Studies requiring ethics committee approval and in case reports, information about signing the informed consent/consent form should be included in the article.
It is necessary to comply with the copyright regulations for the intellectual and artistic works used.
It is essential that the raw data regarding the researches in the peer-reviews be submitted when requested by the referees. It is obligatory to provide the data after the publication of the article when necessary.
Own Journal Policy on Article Similarity Report and Similarity Rate
Candidate articles should be submitted with an originality report from the academic similarity prevention program iThenticate. This rate is accepted up to 20%. Studies with a similarity rate of more than 20% will be returned at the pre-control stage.
Ethical Responsibilities of Authors
The author(s) who submit a study to our journal are expected to comply with the following ethical responsibilities:
The study sent by the author must not have been published in another journal before, and the similarity rate of the work should not be above the rate determined by our journal.
In order to determine the originality of the studies, a similarity report may be requested from the authors. The expected similarity rate from the studies should not be more than 20%.
Each author named in the study is equally responsible for the content of the study. It is unacceptable to not include the name of the researcher who contributed to the study, or to include his name unjustly even though he did not contribute.
The editorial board of the journal receives documents, information, etc. from the authors during the publication process. can request; The author is required to provide any required data.
The author(s) must keep their identities confidential in order to be able to make an impartial evaluation in accordance with the method of blind refereeing during the publication process.
The author is expected to notify the journal editor immediately if there is an error or a situation that requires correction, which she/he noticed during the publication process.
If there is an existing or potential conflict of interest between multiple authors who are stakeholders of the work, this should be reported to the editor.
The works submitted by the author(s) are expected to be original. If the author(s) benefit from or use other studies, they are required to cite and/or cite completely and accurately.
All studies submitted for publication, if any, that may constitute a conflict of interest and their relationships should be explained.
Raw data regarding their articles can be requested from the author(s) within the framework of the evaluation processes, in such a case the author(s) should be ready to present the expected data and information to the editorial board and scientific committee.
Peer Review Process
Toros University Journal of Food, Nutrition and Gastronomy adopts a double-blind peer review system. Each submitted manuscript is evaluated by at least two independent reviewers selected from different institutions. Reviewers are expected to evaluate manuscripts not only in terms of form and language, but also in terms of scientific content, methodology, and contribution to the literature. Reviews focusing solely on formatting and language corrections are not considered sufficient.
Manuscripts receiving a minor or major revision decision will be sent back to the same reviewers after the author completes the required corrections. Reviewers must evaluate the revised manuscript and provide a final acceptance or rejection decision.
If one reviewer recommends major revision while the other directly accepts the manuscript, the manuscript will be sent to a third reviewer, and the final decision will be made accordingly.
Reviewer decisions are expected to be consistent with the evaluation criteria in the review form and supported by justification.
Manuscripts submitted in English must be reviewed in English, and manuscripts submitted in Turkish must be reviewed in Turkish.
Principle of Impartiality
In order to ensure an impartial and independent review process, the following considerations are taken into account:
Reviewers should not be selected from the same institution as the authors of the manuscript they are evaluating.
Reviewers assigned to the same manuscript should not be selected from the same institution as each other.
Reviewers should not be selected from among those who have joint academic studies with the authors of the manuscript they are evaluating.
Reviewers should not be selected from among those who have a published article in the same issue.
Publishing more than one article by the same author in the same issue should be avoided.
Artificial Intelligence Use Policy
The Toros University Journal of Food, Nutrition and Gastronomy regulates the use of generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) and AI-assisted technologies in scholarly publishing in accordance with the COPE position statement “Authorship and AI Tools”, the ICMJE Recommendations, and the ethical guidelines of the Council of Higher Education of Türkiye (YÖK) on the use of generative artificial intelligence in scientific research and publication activities. This policy is reviewed at least once a year in light of developments in the field. Any updates are announced on this page together with their dates.
Scope: In this policy, the term “generative AI tools” refers to tools capable of generating text, images, code, data, or summaries (e.g., ChatGPT, Gemini, Copilot, Claude, DeepSeek, and the text-generating/rewriting features of language editing programs). The following are not within this scope:
Standard word processor features that perform only spelling and grammar checks,
Reference management software (EndNote, Mendeley, Zotero, etc.),
Statistical software (SPSS, R, Jamovi, etc.).
Machine learning and artificial intelligence models used as part of the research methodology are considered research components and must be reported in the Materials and Methods section (for details, see the “For Authors” section, item 7).
I. For Editors (Editor-in-Chief, Section Editors, and Editorial Board)
Editors must not upload all or any part of a manuscript under evaluation to generative AI tools. Doing so may violate the authors’ confidentiality and intellectual property rights and may lead to the manuscript content being stored and used before publication.
Editors must not use generative AI tools to check the language of a manuscript, to improve its readability, or to prepare decision letters by entering manuscript content.
Generative AI is not used in the preliminary evaluation, reviewer selection, or publication decision processes. Full responsibility for editorial decisions rests with the editor. Similarity checks in our journal are conducted using iThenticate reports. Similarity screenings performed during the editorial process use the option in which the text is not stored in the database (no-repository option).
II. For Reviewers
Reviewers must not upload or share all or any part of a manuscript they are reviewing with generative AI tools. Doing so may violate the authors’ confidentiality and property rights and may cause the manuscript content to be stored, the original content to become public before publication, and that content to be used.
Reviewers must not upload manuscript content to generative AI tools to check the language of the manuscript or to assess its readability.
The peer review report must be entirely the reviewer’s own original scientific evaluation. Review reports generated with generative AI tools are not accepted. Generative AI systems may give rise to ethical problems such as bias, partiality, and discrimination. The capabilities of these systems are limited by the data they were trained on and the information they can access, and they do not yet fully possess the capacity for original evaluation and critical thinking.
The legal and ethical responsibility arising from the use of generative AI in the peer review process rests with the reviewer.
III. For Authors
Authorship: AI tools cannot be listed as authors. None of the CRediT contributor roles may be assigned to AI tools. AI tools cannot be listed as references or cited.
Permitted use: Generative AI tools may be used only to improve the grammar, spelling, readability, and translation of text written by the authors themselves.
Prohibited use: Generative AI tools may not be used to generate scientific content, write literature summaries or introduction/discussion text, interpret findings, draw conclusions, or suggest or create references. The presence of references generated by generative AI that are unverified or non-existent is considered an ethical violation.
Data: In studies requiring data collection from human participants, such as questionnaires, scales, interviews, or food consumption records, generative AI may not be used to generate participant responses, impute missing data, or simulate data. Such practices are considered data fabrication.
Images: Except for articles on artificial intelligence, the use of AI tools to create or modify images is not recommended. If used, this must be disclosed beneath the image and in the declaration section. No specific feature within an image or figure may be enhanced, obscured, moved, removed, or added. Adjustments to brightness, contrast, or color balance are acceptable as long as they do not obscure or eliminate any information present in the original image; responsibility in this regard rests with the author. Graphical abstracts and artwork may not be created with generative AI.
Mandatory declaration: Authors must state whether they used AI tools in the preparation of the manuscript under the heading “Artificial Intelligence Use Statement”, placed at the end of the manuscript before the references. If AI tools were used, the name and version of the tool, the purpose of use, the section(s) in which it was used, and the date of use must be clearly stated using the declaration text provided in the manuscript template. If no AI tools were used, this must also be explicitly declared. Manuscripts without a declaration section will be returned to the authors at the preliminary review stage.
Studies in which AI is used as a research method: In studies where artificial intelligence or machine learning models are used as part of the research methodology, the following must be reported in detail in the Materials and Methods section: the model used and its version, parameters, prompts used, and validation methods. Cases in which generative AI is used as part of the study must be stated in the ethics committee application. Generative AI may be used to detect errors, inconsistencies, and bias only as part of multiple evaluation tools. The author must review all generated outputs and check them for errors. The author must also ensure that the content does not discriminate on grounds such as religion, language, or race, does not constitute plagiarism, and is properly cited.
Responsibility: All legal and ethical responsibility arising from the use of AI tools and from any content obtained through these tools rests entirely with the authors.
IV. For Technical Editors, Language Editors, Statistical Editors, and Pre-/Final Readers
Technical editors, language editors, statistical editors, and pre- and final readers must not upload all or any part of the manuscripts they evaluate to generative AI tools. Doing so may violate the authors’ confidentiality and property rights and may cause the manuscript content to be stored and used.
V. Procedures in Case of Policy Violations
When undisclosed AI use or AI use contrary to this policy is detected, action is taken in accordance with the COPE flowcharts:
Manuscripts under evaluation are returned to the authors or rejected.
For published articles, a correction or retraction process is initiated.
Where deemed necessary, the author’s institution is notified.
The results of AI content detection tools are not used as the sole basis for a decision. In such cases, an explanation is requested from the author.
Ethical Rules for Reviewers
The evaluation of all studies with Blind Refereeing directly affects the quality of the publication. This process provides confidence through an objective and independent evaluation of the publication.
Referees cannot directly communicate with authors, evaluations and comments are transmitted through the journal management system. In this process, reviewer comments on evaluation forms and full texts are forwarded to the author(s) through the editor.
Only work related to the field of expertise should accept evaluation.
It should make an evaluation with impartiality and confidentiality.
If he thinks that he is facing a conflict of interest during the evaluation process, he should refuse to review the study and inform the journal editor.
According to the confidentiality principle, they should destroy the studies they have examined after the evaluation process. They can only use the final versions of the studies they have reviewed after they are published.
Should make the evaluation objectively only in relation to the content of the study. Nationality, gender, religious beliefs, political beliefs and commercial concerns should not influence the evaluation.
Evaluation should be done in a constructive and kind language. Do not make derogatory personal comments that include hostility, slander and insults.
They should perform the work they accept to evaluate in a timely manner and with the ethical responsibilities above.
Referees should be aware that the evaluation process is confidential and should not be shared with third parties.
Referees must submit an objective, impartial, scientific, understandable and constructive evaluation report about the work within the specified time.
Referee reports will also include an assessment of the scientific nature of the article (the subject it covers, the method used, or the appropriate use of the relevant literature). This evaluation must be made about the content, whether positive or negative.
When it is understood that the work is plagiarized or has been published elsewhere before, the referees should notify the editor.
The stages in the evaluation process must be completed within the given time.
Editors' Ethical Responsibilities
Editors should respect intellectual property rights while evaluating the works, and should strive for a qualified and rapid progress of the evaluation and publication processes of the work.
The process steps of the work evaluation processes should be published openly and transparently.
It should ensure that the process of evaluation and publication of the work is qualified and fast.
Editors should appoint referees impartially in accordance with scientific evaluation principles and provide an environment of free thought.
It is expected that the journal will bring together many academicians who are experts in different fields, and that the editor will expand the scientific committee pool of the journal by reaching these academics and inviting them to the journal.
In order to make the work of the authors easier during the publication process in the journal, the editors should share a list containing the writing rules of the journal.
Every step of the evaluation process of the work sent to the journal should be shared with the owner of the work. When a positive or negative decision is made about the work, this information should be shared with the owner of the work in detail and scientifically evaluated.
In accordance with the principle of blind refereeing, the names and information of the authors and referees should be kept confidential and should not be shared.
Publisher's Responsibilities
Toros University Journal of Food, Nutrition and Gastronomy provides open, electronic and free access. All stakeholders of the journal are independent of the publisher, and all processes related to publication are carried out independently of the publisher.
Intellectual property rights of all stakeholders who contribute to the journal with their academic publications are reserved by Toros University Journal of Food, Nutrition and Gastronomy.
At the end of the article; Matters to be included before the bibliography:
Conflict of Interest Statement:
The authors will declare their status as to whether or not there is any potential conflict of interest regarding the research, authorship and/or publication of this article.
Support/Financing Information:
The authors will declare whether or not they have received any financial support for the research, authorship and/or publication of this article.
Ethics Committee Decision:
It will declare whether or not an ethics committee decision is needed for this research.
Artificial Intelligence Use Statement:
Authors shall declare whether they used artificial intelligence tools in the preparation of this article and, if so, which tool they used, for what purpose, in which section(s), and on what date.
If you encounter any unethical behavior or content other than the ethical responsibilities mentioned above, Toros University Journal of Food, Nutrition and Gastronomy, please report it to jfng@toros.edu.tr via e-mail.
Publication Policy
Our journal is an open access, free of charge, international peer-reviewed e-journal.
The publications sent to the journal by the author are evaluated in terms of compliance with the journal template, similarity rate and suitability for the journal subject/scope at the pre-control stage. Editors can decide to accept or reject at this stage; In addition, the author can withdraw his publication at this stage.
The work, which passes the preliminary controls, is taken to the publication evaluation stage. The work is evaluated by at least 2 referees. As a result of the referee's evaluations, the owner of the work must make the necessary corrections within 15 days, and the author has the right not to make any corrections, provided that he shows a reason.
The work that makes the corrections given by the referee and receives positive feedback is included in the publication process. The work is re-examined by the editors and technical editors within the framework of grammar and spelling rules and is taken into layout processes for publication. At the last stage, the approval for publication is obtained from the owner of the work and sent for publication.
The first application of the author and the acceptance and publication process of the publication takes between 6-12 months.