Karl Marx, Yahudi Sorunu Bağlamında Sivil Toplum Ve Politik Toplum

Yıl 2017, Cilt: 3 Sayı: 1, 91 - 101, 24.04.2017

Yunus Enterili

https://doi.org/10.21551/jhf.302902

Öz

Bu yazıda Marx’ın gençlik döneminde
Bauer’in düşüncelerinden hareketle yazmış olduğu “Yahudi sorunu” adlı eser
üzerinden sivil toplum ve politik toplum ilişkisi üzerinde durulacaktır. Ayrıca
burada Bauer dışında Marx’ın sivil toplum ve politik toplum ile ilgili
fikirlerini etkileyen diğer düşünürlere de (Hegel, Feuerbach vs.) yer yer
değinilecektir. Sivil toplum ve politik toplum ayrışmasına tarihsel olarak
değinilecektir. Marx’ın Yahudi sorunu adlı eserinden hareketle sivil toplum,
yurttaşlık, dinin özgürleşmesi, politik özgürleşme, devlet gibi olguların
bireylerin özgürleşmesindeki etkileri Yahudi örneği üzerinden makalede ele alınacaktır.
Ayrıca günümüz kapitalist toplumunun oluşumunda Marx’ın eserinde söz ettiği
Hıristiyanlık ve Yahudiliğin etkileri de ele alınacaktır. Bu değerlendirmeye
geçilmeden önce konunun daha iyi anlaşılması için Marx’ın genel olarak diğer
eserlerinde söz etmiş olduğu sivil toplum ve devlet ilişkisine makalede yer
verilecektir. 

Anahtar Kelimeler

Sivil Toplum, Politik Toplum, Dinin Özgürleşmesi, Devlet, Yurttaşlık, Din

Karl Marx, Civil Society And Political Community in the Context Of The Jewish Problem

Öz

Today, debates and discourses developed over the concepts of civil society and political society are usually made through religious discourses or religious identities, and the individual emerges as a problem of emancipation. In his “Jewish Question”, which Marx wrote during his youthful period with Bauer’s thoughts, it is thought that the religious identities and rhetoric accompanied the present debate about the emergence of the emancipation of individuals in social and political contexts. It is thought that this problem, which emerged as the problem of individual liberation or citizenship, and which is regarded as a Jewish problem and emerged in different forms in different geographies, is the result of the fact that the religious identities can not be torn from the religious part of the world. Another reason for the lack of emancipation of the individual is the understanding of colonialism that is at the core of the capitalist system. In today’s society, it wants to keep up with the existence of religions or to keep up with the capitalist system and wants to influence the capitalist system with state policies by making itself active in the political arena. Judaism and Christianity in this context religion, the effects of the formation of capitalist society, will be discussed from the rhetoric of Marx and Bauer. The issue of the citizenship identity of the individual in this study will be addressed through the relationship between civil society and political society. There will also be mentioned here some other thinkers (Hegel, Feuerbach etc.) that affect Marx’s ideas about civil society and political society, besides Marx and Bauer. Civil society, citizenship, liberation of religion, political emancipation, the effects of emancipation of individuals such as the state will be handled through the Jewish example. Prior to this assessment, a better understanding of the subject will be addressed to the civil society and state relationship that Marx generally refers to in his other works..

Anahtar Kelimeler

Civil Society, Politic Society, the liberation of Religion, State, Citizenship, Religion

Kaynakça

• AKTAY, Yasin (2005), Sivil Toplum Ve Demokrasi, ”Amerika’da Sivil Toplum Ve Dinin Temelleri” , Kaknüs Yayınları, İstanbul.
• ARNOLD, Ruge (1838), Preussen und die Reaktion, Zur Geschichte unserer Zeit (Prusya ve Gericilik, Çağımızın Tarihi Üzerine), Leipzig.
• AVİNERİ, Shlomo (1972), Hegel’s Theory of the Modern State, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
• CHANDHOKE, Neera (1995), State and Civil Society: Explorations in Political Theory, Yeni Delhi ve Londra: Sage Publications.
• CORNU, August (1997), “Hegel’in Hukuk Felsefesinin Elefltirisi,” Karl Marx, Hegel’in Hukuk Felsefesinin Elefltirisi, çev. Kenan Somer, Sol Yayınları, Ankara.
• MARX, Karl ( 1997), Yahudi Sorunu, Sol Yayınları, Ankara.
• ROSEN, Zvi (2012), (Çev. Doğan Barış KILIÇ), Bruno Bauer ve Karl Marx, Ankara.
• YETİŞ, Mehmet (2010), Marx ve Sivil Toplum, Praksis.
• WOOD, Ellen Meiksins (1990), “The Uses and Abuses of ‘Civil Society’,” Socialist Register 1990, der. Ralph Miliband ve Leo Panitch, Londra: The Merlin Press.