Rightful Resistance: A Discursive Third Realm?

Year 2018, , 196 - 209, 31.01.2018

Sümeyye Sakarya

https://doi.org/10.21547/jss.314226

Abstract

This article aims to
bring a new angle to the literature by joining ‘rightful resistance’ of O’Brien
and ‘third realm’ of Huang. It questions whether rightful resistance is a third
realm or not. The main thesis is that rightful resistance is a discursive third
realm. This thesis is expounded in five parts. After the introduction of
‘rightful resistance’ in the first part; in the second part, civil society and
public sphere as first alternatives coming to mind are examined in terms of
applicability and conceptualization. It is argued that such applications and
conceptualizations have some difficulties preventing the accurate grasp of the
reality because of the historical baggage and ambivalent definitions of the
concepts. In the third part, Huang’s concept of ‘third realm’ is delineated. In
the fourth part, it is explained how rightful resistance constructs a third
realm. It is claimed that this is a discursive third realm since the
construction is realised through the discourse. Besides, feasibility of
rightful resistance’s operationalization is discussed. Fragmented
authoritarianism is suggested to make an efficient third realm for resisters
possible. In the last part, these arguments are demonstrated through the Wukan
Incident. In the conclusion, some potential criticisms are handled.

Keywords

Rightful Resistance, O’Brien, Third Realm, Huang, China, Wukan Incident

Meşru Direniş: Söylemsel Bir Üçüncü Alan?

Abstract

Bu çalışma, O’Brien’in Çin’deki bazı toplumsal hareketleri anlamak
için ürettiği “meşru direniş” kavramıyla, Huang’ın yine Çin’deki kamusal alan
tartışmalarında yeni bir yaklaşım olarak ortaya çıkardığı “üçüncü alan”
kavramlarını beraber okuyarak literatüre yeni bir bakış açısı getirmeyi
amaçlamaktadır. Bu bağlamda makale, meşru direnişin bir üçüncü alan olup
olmadığını sorgulamaktadır. Makalenin temel tezi, meşru direnişin söylemsel bir
üçüncü alan olduğudur. Bu argüman, makalede beş bölümde ele alınmaktadır. Girişten
sonraki ilk bölümde “meşru direniş” kavramı sunulmaktadır. İkinci bölümde sivil
toplum ve kamusal alan -akla ilk gelen alternatifler olarak-
uygulanabilirlikleri ve kavramsallaştırmaları açısından tartışılmaktadır. Bu
bölümdeki temel iddia bu tarz kavramsallaştırmaların ve uygulanmaların tarihi
mirasları ve net olmayan tanımlarından dolayı gerçeği anlamayı zorlaştıracaklarıdır.
Üçüncü bölümde, Huang’ın “üçüncü alan” kavramı ele alınmaktadır. Dördüncü
bölümdeyse meşru direnişin üçüncü alanı nasıl inşa ettiği izah edilmektedir. Bu
inşa söylem yoluyla gerçekleştirildiği için meşru direnişin söylemsel bir
üçüncü alan yarattığı iddia edilmektedir. Bunlara ek olarak, meşru direnişin işlevselliğinin
mümkünatı da tartışılmaktadır. Bu bağlamda, Çin’deki bölünmüş otoriterliğin
direnişçiler için işlevsel bir üçüncü alanı mümkün kıldığı iddia edilmiştir.
Son bölümde de bu argümanlar Wukan Vakasıyla örneklendirilmiştir. Makalenin
sonuç kısmındaysa bazı muhtemel eleştiriler ele alınmıştır.

Keywords

Meşru Direniş, O’Brien, Üçüncü Alan, Huang, Çin, Wukan Vakası

References

• Bayat, A. (2013). Areas and Ideas. Comparative Studies of South Asia, Africa and the Middle East, 33(3), 260-3.
• Bohman, J. (2004). Expanding Dialogue: The Internet, the Public Sphere and Prospects for Transnational Democracy. The Sociological Review, 52(1), 131-55.
• Brandtstӓdter, S. (2006). Book review of ‘Rightful Resistance in Rural China’. Journal of Peasant Studies, 33(4), 710-2.
• Calhoun, C. (1998). Community without Propinquity Revisited: Communications Technology and the Transformation of the Urban Public Sphere. Sociological Inquiry, 68(3), 373-97.
• Chakrabarty, D. (2009). Provincializing Europe: Postcolonial Thought and Historical Difference: Postcolonial Thought and Historical Difference. Princeton University Press.
• Chuang, J. (2014). China's Rural Land Politics: Bureaucratic Absorption and the Muting of Rightful Resistance. The China Quarterly, 219, 649-69.
• Dirlik, A. (2013). Thinking Modernity Historically: Is ‘Alternative Modernity’ the Answer. The Asian Review of World Histories, 1(1), 5-44.
• Hua, R., Yuxin H., & Deng, G. (2015). Instrumental Civil Rights and Institutionalized Participation in China: A Case Study of Protest in Wukan Village. VOLUNTAS: International Journal of Voluntary and Nonprofit Organizations, 1-19.
• Huang, P. CC. (1993a). Between Informal Mediation and Formal Adjudication: The Third Realm of Qing Civil justice. Modern China, 19(2), 251-98.
• Huang, P. CC. (1993b). ‘Public Sphere’/ ‘Civil Society’ in China? : The Third Realm between State and Society. Modern China, 19(2), 216-40.
• Kumar, K. (2007). Global Civil Society. European Journal of Sociology, 48, 413-34.
• Lagerkvist, J. (2015). The Unknown Terrain of Social Protests in China: ‘Exit’, ‘Voice’, ‘Loyalty’, and ‘Shadow’. Journal of Civil Society, 11(2), 137-53.
• Lee, C. K. (2007). Against the Law: Labor Protests in China's Rustbelt and Sunbelt. University of California Press.
• Li, Lianjiang. 2010. Rights Consciousness and Rules Consciousness in Contemporary China. The China Journal, 64, 47-68.
• Lie, A. C. (2014). Rethinking Rural Resistance in China: A Case Study of the 2011 Wukan Incident in Guandong Province, MA. thesis, University of Oslo.
• Lieberthal, K. (1992). Introduction: the ‘Fragmented Authoritarianism’ Model and Its Limitations. in Kenneth Lieberthal and David Lampton (eds), Bureaucracy, Politics, and Decision Making in Post-Mao China. University of California Press, 1-30.
• Lieberthal, K., & Oksenberg, M. (1988). Policy Making in China: Leaders, Structures, and Processes. Princeton University Press.
• Ma, Shu-Yun. (1994). The Chinese Discourse on Civil Society. The China Quarterly, 137, 180-93.
• Madsen, R. (1993). The Public Sphere, Civil Society and Moral Community: A Research Agenda for Contemporary China Studies. Modern China, 19(2), 183-98.
• Mertha, A. (2009). ‘Fragmented Authoritarianism 2.0’: Political Pluralization in the Chinese Policy Process. The China Quarterly, 200, 995-1012.
• Metzger, T. A. (1998). The Western Concept of a Civil Society in the Context of Chinese History. Hoover Press.
• Michelson, E. (2008). Justice from above or below? Popular Strategies for Resolving Grievances in Rural China. The China Quarterly, 193, 43-64.
• O'brien, K. (1996). Rightful Resistance. World Politics, 49(1), 31-55.
• O'Brien, K. (2013). Rightful Resistance Revisited. Journal of Peasant Studies, 40(6), 1051-62.
• O'Brien, K., & Li, L. (2006). Rightful Resistance in Rural China. Cambridge University Press.
• Perry, E. (2010). Popular Protest: Playing by the Rules. In Joseph Fewsmith (ed.), China Today, China Tomorrow: Domestic Politics, Economy, and Society, 11-28.
• Qian, G., & Bandurski, D. L. (2011). China's Emerging Public Sphere: The Impact of Media Commercialization, Professionalism, and the Internet in an Era of Transition. In Susan Shirk (ed.), Changing Media, Changing China, 38-76.
• Sima, Y. (2011). Grassroots Environmental Activism and the Internet: Constructing a Green Public Sphere in China. Asian Studies Review, 35(4), 477-97.
• Tria Kerkvliet, B. (2014). Protests over Land in Vietnam: Rightful Resistance and More. Journal of Vietnamese Studies, 9(3), 19-54.
• Vukovich, D. (2015). Illiberal China and Global Convergence: Thinking through Wukan and Hong Kong. Third World Quarterly, 36(11), 2130-47.
• Walker, K. L. M. (2008). From Covert to Overt: Everyday Peasant Politics in China and the Implications for Transnational Agrarian Movements. Journal of Agrarian Change, 8(2‐3), 462-88.
• Weintraub, J., & Krishan, K. (1997). Public and Private in Thought and Practice.  The University of Chicago Press.
• Wu, F. (2013). Environmental Activism in Provincial China. Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning, 15(1), 89-108.
• Yang, G. (2002). Civil Society in China: A Dynamic Field of Study. China Review International, 9(1), 1-16.
• Yang, G. (2003). The Co-evolution of the Internet and Civil Society in China. Asian Survey, 43(3), 405-22.
• Yang, G. (2010). Brokering Environment and Health in China: Issue Entrepreneurs of the Public Sphere. Journal of Contemporary China, 19(63), 101-18.
• Yang, G., & Calhoun, C. (2007). Media, Civil Society, and the Rise of a Green Public Sphere in China. China Information, 21(2), 211-36.
• Zakaria, F. (1994). A Conversation with Lee Kuan Yew. Foreign Affairs, 73(2), 109-26.
• Zeng, Z. (2013). Wukan: The Whole Story. The China Nonprofit Review, 5(1), 17-101.