Problems of the Application of Human Rights Law instead of the Law of Occupation by the State of Israel in the Occupied Palestinian Territories in the Context of Primitive Accumulation and Settler Colonialism

Abstract

This study aims to examine the policies pursued by the State of Israel in the occupied Palestinian territories within the framework of the theories of primitive accumulation and settler colonialism and to reveal the drawbacks of the State of Israel's application of human rights law instead of the law of occupation in the occupied Palestinian territories in the given context. Primitive accumulation involves the incorporation of things into the capitalist relation and the detachment of producers from the means of production in the emergence of the capitalist mode of production. The extraterritorial aspect of primitive accumulation corresponds to colonialism. Colonial/settler colonial policies can be counted among the forms acquired by the primitive accumulation process. The structural relationship between primitive accumulation and settler colonialism shows the relationship between the settler- colonial policies carried out by the State of Israel in the occupied Palestinian territories and the capitalist mode of production. This relationship is of particular importance in the context of the State of Israel's tendency to apply human rights law instead of occupation law in the occupied Palestinian territories. The application of human rights law allows colonial policies to be disguised under legal cover. It enables the settlers to retain ownership of the lands and other things confiscated through colonial practices. The case of Beit Sourik Village Council, which we examined in the context of our study, shows how the Israeli Supreme Court justifies settler colonial land grabs through legalisation while using human rights law to protect settlers' property rights independent of their colonial nature.

Keywords

• Palestine
• Human Rights Law
• Primitive Accumulation
• Occupation Law
• Settler-Colonialism
• International Law

İlkel Birikim ve Yerleşimci Sömürgecilik Bağlamında İşgal Altındaki Filistin Topraklarında İsrail Devleti Tarafından İşgal Hukuku Yerine İnsan Hakları Hukukunun Uygulanmasının Sorunları

Abstract

Elinizdeki çalışma, İsrail Devleti’nin işgal altında tuttuğu Filistin topraklarında izlediği politikaları ilkel birikim ve yerleşimci sömürgecilik kuramları çerçevesinde incelemek ve İsrail Devleti’nin işgal atındaki Filistin topraklarında işgal hukuku yerine insan hakları hukukunu uygulamasının sakıncalarını yerleşimci sömürgecilik bağlamında ortaya koymak amaçlarını gütmektedir. Yerleşimci sömürgeci politikalar İsrail Devleti bağlamında yapısal bir özellik arz etmektedir. İlkel birikim kapitalist üretim tarzının ortaya çıkış sürecinde şeylerin sermaye ilişkisine dahli ve üreticilerin üretim araçlarından koparılmasını kapsamakta, ilkel birikimin ülke dışı veçhesi ise sömürgeciliğe tekabül etmektedir. İlkel birikim süreçlerinin sömürgecilikle olan bağı, sömürgeci politikaların ilkel birikim bağlamında değerlendirilmesini gerektirmektedir. Yerleşimci sömürgeci politikalar da bu bağlamda ilkel birikim pratiklerini bünyelerinde ihtiva etmektedirler. Ama yerleşimci sömürgeciliği klasik sömürgecilikten ayıran, İsrail Devleti’nin politikalarında da görülebileceği üzere sömürgeleştirilen toprakların yerli halkının yerinden edilmesinin ve topraklarına el konulmasının belirleyici nitelikte olmasıdır. İlkel birikim ve yerleşimci sömürgecilik arasındaki yapısal ilişki, İsrail Devleti’nin işgal altındaki Filistin topraklarında yürüttüğü yerleşimci sömürgeci politikaların kapitalist üretim tarzı ile olan ilişkisini gösterir. Söz konusu yapısal ilişki İsrail Devleti’nin işgal altında tuttuğu Filistin topraklarında kurduğu yerleşimlere ilişkin uyuşmazlıklarda işgal hukukundan ziyade insan hakları hukukunu uygulamaya yönelmesi bağlamında özel bir önemi haizdir. İşgal hukuku yerine insan hakları hukukunun uygulanması, sömürgeci politikaların hukuki bir kılıf altında gizlenmesini sağlamakta ve sömürgecilik yoluyla el konulup yerleşimcilere dağıtılan topraklar ve sair şeylerin mülkiyetinin yerleşimcilerde kalmasına olanak vermektedir. Çalışmamız kapsamında incelediğimiz Beit Sourik Köy Konseyi davası örneği bize İsrail Yüksek Mahkemesi’nin yerleşimci sömürgeci toprak gasplarını hukuksallaştırma yoluyla aklarken insan hakları hukukunu yerleşimcilerin mülkiyet haklarını sömürgeci niteliğinden bağımsız bir biçimde korumak üzerine nasıl kullandığını göstermektedir.

Keywords

• Filistin
• İnsan Hakları Hukuku
• İlkel Birikim
• İsrail
• İşgal Hukuku
• Yerleşimci Sömürgecilik
• Uluslararası Hukuk

References

1. Aaron PG, ‘The Idolatry of Force: How Israel Embraced Targeted Killing’ (2017) 46 Journal of Palestine Studies 75. google scholar
2. ——, ‘The Idolatry of Force (Part II): Militarism in Israel’s Garrison State’ (2019) 48 Journal of Palestine Studies 58. google scholar
3. Abbasi M, ‘The Fall of Acre in the 1948 Palestine War’ (2010) 39 Journal of Palestine Studies 6. google scholar
4. Abdel-Qader S and Roberts-Davis TL, ‘Toxic Occupation: Leveraging the Basel Convention in Palestine’ (2018) 47 Journal of Palestine Studies 28. google scholar
5. Abdulhadi Ramis, ‘Land Use Planning in the Occupied Palestinian Territories’ (1990) 19 Journal of Palestine Studies 46. google scholar
6. Abi-Saab G, ‘The Third World Intellectual in Praxis: Confrontation, Participation, or Operation behind Enemy Lines?’ (2016) 37 Third World Quarterly 1957. google scholar
7. Abu-Baker A and Farah M, ‘Established Practice: Palestinian Exclusion at the Dead Sea’ (2020) 49 Journal of Palestine Studies 48. google scholar
8. Abusalim J, ‘The Great March of Return: An Organizer’s Perspective’ (2018) 47 Journal of Palestine Studies 90. google scholar

9. Abu-Sittah G, ‘The Virus, the Settler, and the Siege: Gaza in the Age of Corona’ (2020) 49 Journal of Palestine Studies 65. google scholar
10. Achcar G, Kaynayan Orta Doğu: Marksist aynada Orta Doğu (Rida Şimşekel tr, İthaki yayınları 2004). google scholar
11. ——, Barbarlıklar çatışması (Ateş Uslu tr, 1.baskı, İthaki Yayınları 2012). google scholar
12. Ackerman S, ‘Al-Aqsa Intifada and the U.S. Media’ (2001) 30 Journal of Palestine Studies 61. google scholar
13. Ajluni S, ‘The Palestinian Economy and the Second Intifada’ (2003) 32 Journal of Palestine Studies 64. google scholar
14. Akram SM, ‘Palestinian Refugees and Their Legal Status: Rights, Politics, and Implications for a Just Solution’ (2002) 31 Journal of Palestine Studies 36. google scholar
15. Albayrak G, ‘Uluslararası İnsancıl Hukukta İşgale İlişkin Hukuki Meseleler’ (2020) 28 Selçuk Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Dergisi 445. google scholar
16. Algazi G, ‘JPS “Hidden Gems” and “Greatest Hits”: Colonial History; Invoked, Denied, Embodied’ (2021) 50 Journal of Palestine Studies 127. google scholar
17. Ali T, Fundamentalizmler çatışması (Abdullah Yılmaz tr, Everest Yayınları 2002). google scholar
18. ——, Bush Bağdat’ta:Irak’ın yeniden sömürgeleştirilmesi (Osman Akınhay tr, Agora Kitaplığı 2003). google scholar
19. ——, Komünizm düşüncesi (Osman Akınhay tr, Agora Kitaplığı 2011). google scholar
20. Althusser L, İdeoloji ve Devletin Ideolojik Aygıtları (Alp Tümertekin tr, İthaki Yayınları 2010). google scholar
21. Amara A, ‘The Negev Land Question: Between Denial and Recognition’ (2013) 42 Journal of Palestine Studies 27. google scholar
22. Amin S, ‘Le Modѐle Théorique d’Accumulation et de Développement Dans Le Monde Contemporain: La Problѐmatique de Transition’ (1972) 13 Revue Tiers Monde 703. google scholar
23. Ammar S, Die Rechtslage Der Israelischen Mauer in Den Besetzten Palästinensischen Gebieten Im Völkerrecht (Logos Verlag Berlin 2011). google scholar
24. Anderson CW, ‘State Formation from Below and the Great Revolt in Palestine’ (2017) 47 Journal of Palestine Studies 39. google scholar
25. Andoni L, ‘Redefining Oslo: Negotiating the Hebron Protocol’ (1997) 26 Journal of Palestine Studies 17. google scholar
26. Anghie A, ‘Francisco De Vitoria and the Colonial Origins of International Law’ (1996) 5 Social & Legal Studies 321. google scholar
27. ——, Imperialism, Sovereignty, and the Making of International Law (Cambridge University Press 2004). google scholar
28. Antonius R, ‘Palestine-Israël: Moments Structurants Et Droit International (1917-2015)’ [2016] Guerres mondiales et conflits contemporains 107. google scholar
29. Anziska S, ‘The Erasure of the Nakba in Israel’s Archives’ (2019) 49 Journal of Palestine Studies 64. google scholar
30. Appleby JO, Amansız devrim: kapitalizm tarihi (Ali Cevat Akkoyunlu tr, Alfa yayınları 2012). google scholar
31. Aronson G, ‘Settlement Monitor’ (1996) 26 Journal of Palestine Studies 128. google scholar
32. ——, ‘Settlement Monitor’ (1997) 27 Journal of Palestine Studies 126. google scholar
33. ——, ‘Settlement Monitor’ (1997) 26 Journal of Palestine Studies 138. google scholar
34. ——, ‘Settlement Monitor’ (1997) 26 Journal of Palestine Studies 135. google scholar
35. ——, ‘Settlement Monitor’ (1997) 26 Journal of Palestine Studies 123. google scholar
36. ——, ‘Settlement Monitor’ (1998) 27 Journal of Palestine Studies 136. google scholar
37. ——, ‘Settlement Monitor’ (1998) 27 Journal of Palestine Studies 135. google scholar
38. ——, ‘Settlement Monitor’ (1998) 28 Journal of Palestine Studies 133. google scholar
39. ——, ‘Settlement Monitor’ (1999) 28 Journal of Palestine Studies 135. google scholar
40. Ashworth LM, ‘Warriors, Pacifists and Empires: Race and Racism in International Thought before 1914’ (2022) 98 International Affairs 281. google scholar
41. Public and Private International Law Bulletin, 46 (1): 94–143 137 google scholar
42. İşgal altındaki Filistin’de Yerleşimci Sömürgecilik ve İnsan Hakları Hukuku Şahin & Güneysu, 2026 google scholar
43. Avineri S, The Social and Political Thought of Karl Marx (Cambridge University Press 1975). google scholar
44. Beliso-De Jesús AM, Pierre J and Rana J, ‘White Supremacy and the Making of Anthropology’ (2023) 52 Annual Review of Anthropology 417. google scholar
45. Benvenisti E, The International Law of Occupation (2nd edn, Princeton University Press 2004). google scholar
46. Bhuta N, ‘The Antinomies of Transformative Occupation’ (2005) 16 European Journal of International Law 721. google scholar
47. Bishara S and Naamnih H, Nomads Against Their Will: The Attempted Expulsion of the Arab Bedouin in the Naqab: The Example of Atir–Umm al-Hieran (Adalah – The Legal Center for Arab Minority Rights in Israel September 2011). google scholar
48. Boguslavsky BM and others, Diyalektik ve Tarihsel Materyalizmin Alfabesi (Şiar Yalçın tr, Bilim ve Sosyalizm Yayınları 1990). google scholar
49. Bond P, ‘Primitive Accumulation, Enclavity, Rural Marginalisation & Articulation’ (2007) 34 Review of African Political Economy 29. google scholar
50. Bonefeld W, ‘Primitive Accumulation and Capitalist Accumulation: Notes on Social Constitution and Expropriation’ (2011) 75 Science & Society 379. google scholar
51. Boothby WH, Conflict Law: The Influence of New Weapons Technology, Human Rights and Emerging Actors (TMC Asser Press 2014). google scholar
52. Bosch J, Pentagonizm (Babür Kuzucu tr, Ant Yayınları 1969). google scholar
53. Boyd CMJ, ‘Can a Marxist Believe in Human Rights?’ (2009) 37 Critique 579. google scholar
54. Budeiri M, Filistin Komünist Partisi 1919-1948: Enternasyonalizm Mücadelesinde Araplar ve Yahudiler (Şükrü Alpagut tr, Yordam Kitap 2012). google scholar
55. Burns AD, American Imperialism: The Territorial Expansion of the United States, 1783-2013 (Edinburgh University Press 2017). google scholar
56. Çalık Topuz Z and Arafat M, ‘Birleşmiş Milletler Güvenlik Konseyi Kararlarının Filistin-İsrail Barış Sürecine Etkisi’ (2023) 78 Ankara Üniversitesi SBF Dergisi 357. google scholar
57. Campbell C, Race and Empire: Eugenics in Colonial Kenya (Manchester University Press 2007). google scholar
58. Chomsky N, Amerikan Müdaheleciliği (Taylan Doğan and Barış Zeren tr, Aram 2002). google scholar
59. Cirhinlioğlu Z, Azgelişmişligin toplumsal boyutu (İmge Kitabevi Yayınları 1999). google scholar
60. Cleveland WL, Modern Ortadoğu tarihi (Mehmet Harmancı tr, Agora Kitaplığı 2008). google scholar
61. Cohen A and Shany Y, ‘The Switch: The Israel High Court of Justice’s Transition from Occupation Law to Human Rights Law’ (2022) 20 International Journal of Constitutional Law 1768. google scholar
62. Cohen BJ, The Question of Imperialism: The Political Economy of Dominance and Dependence (Palgrave Macmillan 1974). google scholar
63. Coulthard G, ‘From Wards of the State to Subjects of Recognition?: Marx, Indigenous Peoples, and the Politics of Dispossession in Denendeh’ in Andrea Smith (ed), Theorizing Native Studies (Duke University Press 2014). google scholar
64. Crosby A and Monaghan J, ‘Settler Colonialism and the Policing of Idle No More’ (2016) 43 Social Justice 37. google scholar
65. Crowe J and Weston-Scheuber K, Principles of International Humanitarian Law (Edward Elgar Publishing 2013). google scholar
66. Cuyckens H, Revisiting the Law of Occupation (Brill | Nijhoff 2017). google scholar
67. Dalar M, ‘İşgal Hukuku Açısından Rusya-Ukrayna Savaşı’ in Adem Özer and Fatma Taşdemir (eds), Stepler, Dinyeper ve Barut: Rusya-Ukrayna Savaşı’nın Uluslararası Hukuk Veçhesi (Adalet Yayınevi 2023). google scholar
68. Davidson NR and Hostovsky Brandes T, ‘Israeli Courts and the Paradox of International Human Rights Law’ (2022) 33 European Journal of International Law 1243. google scholar
69. Davis M, Üzerinde güneş batmayan katliam: El Nino kıtlıkları ve üçüncü dünyanın açlıkla inşası (Umut Haskan tr, Yordam Kitap 2012). google scholar
70. Dowd DF, Kapitalizm ve Kapitalizmin Iktisadı: Eleştirel Bir Tarih (Cihan Gerçek tr, Yordam Kitap 2008). google scholar
71. Drachewych O, The Communist International, Anti-Imperialism and Racial Equality in British Dominions (Routledge 2019). google scholar
72. Drew A, We Are No Longer in France: Communists in Colonial Algeria (Manchester University Press 2014). google scholar
73. Dunn RS, Sugar and Slaves: The Rise of the Planter Class in the English West Indies, 1624-1713 (The University of North Carolina Press 2000). google scholar
74. Evans J, ‘Where Lawlessness Is Law: The Settler-Colonial Frontier as a Legal Space of Violence’ (2009) 30 Australian Feminist Law Journal 3. google scholar
75. Evans J and Others, Equal Subjects, Unequal Rights: Indigenous Peoples in British Settler Colonies, 1830-1910 (Manchester university press 2003). google scholar
76. Faulkner N, Marksist Dünya Tarihi: Neandertallerden Neoliberallere (Tuncel Öncel tr, Yordam Kitap 2014). google scholar
77. Ferro M, Sömürgecilik tarihi: fetihlerden bağımsızlık hareketlerine kadar 13.-20.yüzyıl (Muna Cedden tr, İmge Kitabevi Yayınları 2002). google scholar
78. Fine B and Saad-Filho A, Marx’ın Kapital’i (Nail Satlıgan tr, Yordam Kitap 2008). google scholar
79. Fischbach MR, State, Society and Land in Jordan (Brill 2000). google scholar
80. Fraser TG, Mango A and McNamara R, Modern Ortadoğu’nun Kuruluşu (Remzi Kitabevi 2011). google scholar
81. Gardner L, Taxing Colonial Africa: The Political Economy of British Imperialism (Oxford University Press 2012). google scholar
82. Gill TD and Fleck D, Handbook of the International Law of Military Operations (Oxford University Press 2010). google scholar
83. Giustozzi A, The Art of Coercion: The Primitive Accumulation and Management of Coercive Power (Columbia University Press 2011). google scholar
84. Glassburn, ‘Settler Standpoints’ (2019) 76 The William and Mary Quarterly 399. google scholar
85. Greenstein R, ‘Colonialism, Apartheid and the Native Question: The Case of Israel/Palestine’ in Vishwas Satgar (ed), Racism After Apartheid: Challenges for Marxism and Anti-Racism (Wits University Press 2019). google scholar
86. Greer, ‘Settler Colonialism and Empire in Early America’ (2019) 76 The William and Mary Quarterly 383. google scholar
87. Grewcock M, ‘Settler-Colonial Violence, Primitive Accumulation and Australia’s Genocide’ (2018) 7 State Crime Journal. google scholar
88. Gross A, ‘Human Proportions: Are Human Rights the Emperor’s New Clothes of the International Law of Occupation?’ (2007) 18 European Journal of International Law 1. google scholar
89. ——, ‘The Righting of the Law of Occupation’ in Nehal Bhuta (ed), The Frontiers of Human Rights (Oxford University Press 2016). google scholar
90. Guernsey PJ, ‘Reframing So-Called Primitive Accumulation for Settler Colonial Contexts: Ancestral Enclosures and Spatial Conceptions of History’ (2024) 35 Capitalism Nature Socialism 138. google scholar
91. Harvey D, Der Neue Imperialismus (VSA Verlag 2005). google scholar
92. ——, Marx’ın Kapital’i için Kılavuz (Bülent O Doğan tr, Metis Yayınları 2012). google scholar
93. Hase PH, The Six-Day War of 1899: Hong Kong in the Age of Imperialism (Hong Kong University Press 2008). google scholar
94. Heller H, ‘Bodin on Slavery and Primitive Accumulation’ (1994) 25 The Sixteenth Century Journal 53. google scholar
95. Hill C, İngiltere’de Devrim Çağı: 1603-1714 (Uygur Kocabaşoğlu tr, İletişim Yayınları 2016). google scholar
96. Hobsbawm EJ, İmparatorluk Çağı 1875-1914 (Vedat Aslan tr, Dost Kitabevi Yayınları 1999). google scholar
97. ——, Sermaye Çağı 1848-1875 (Bahadır Sina Şener tr, Dost Kitabevi 2003). google scholar
98. ——, Tuhaf zamanlar: bir 20. yüzyıl hayatı (Saliha Nilüfer tr, İletişim Yayınları 2006). google scholar
99. ——, Küreselleşme, demokrasi ve terörizm (Osman Akınhay tr, Agora Kitaplığı 2008). google scholar
100. Hoell G, Tarımda Kapitalizmin Gelişmesi ve Toprak Rantı (Ahmet Doğkan tr, Bilim Yayınları 1975). google scholar
101. İnce OU, ‘Between Equal Rights’ (2018) 46 Political Theory 885. google scholar
102. ‘International Military Tribunal (Nuremberg), Judgment and Sentences: Judgment’ (1947) 41 American Journal of International Law 172. google scholar
103. Jessop B, Kapitalist devletin geleceği (Ahmet Özcan tr, Epos Yayınları 2009). google scholar
104. ——, Devlet Teorisi: Kapitalist Devleti Yerine Oturtmak (Ahmet Özcan tr, Epos 2008). google scholar
105. Johnson R, British Imperialism (Palgrave Macmillan 2003). google scholar
106. Judge EH and Langdon JW, The Struggle against Imperialism: Anticolonialism and the Cold War (Rowman & Littlefield 2018). google scholar
107. Kadri A, The Unmaking of Arab Socialism (Anthem Press 2016). google scholar
108. ——, Imperialism with Reference to Syria (Springer 2019). google scholar
109. Kalshoven F, Constraints on the Waging of War (Martinus Nijhoff Publishers). google scholar
110. Katz E, ‘The “Transfer” Option’ (1989) 18 Journal of Palestine Studies 161. google scholar
111. Kaya İ, ‘Hostile Occupation and International Humanitarian Law’ (2001) 9 Selçuk Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Dergisi 65. google scholar
112. Keskin F, ‘Silahlı Çatışmalar Hukunun B.M. Kuvvetlerine Uygulanması’ (1997) 52 Ankara Üniversitesi SBF Dergisi 447. google scholar
113. Kolb R, ‘Etude Sur l’occupation et Sur l’Article 47 de La IVème Convention de Genève Du 12 Août 1949 Relative à La Protection Des Personnes Civiles En Temps de Guerre : Le Degré d’intangibilité Des Droits En Territoire Occupé’ (2002) Volume 10 African Yearbook of International Law 267. google scholar
114. Kowalik T, Rosa Luxemburg: Theory of Accumulation and Imperialism (Jan Toporowski and Hanna Szymborska trs, Palgrave Macmillan 2014). google scholar
115. Kretzmer D, ‘The Law of Belligerent Occupation in the Supreme Court of Israel’ (2012) 94 International Review of the Red Cross 207. google scholar
116. Lacoste Y, Az Gelişmiş Ülkeler (Yaşar Gürbüz tr, Remzi Kitabevi 1965). google scholar
117. Laidlaw Z, Colonial Connections: 1815-45 Patronage, the Information Revolution, and Colonial Governement (Manchester university press 2005). google scholar
118. Lattanzi M, ‘Settler Colonialism Through the Court: Domestic Interpretations of International Law’ (2020) 24 UCLA Journal of International Law and Foreign Affairs 201. google scholar
119. Lenin Vİ, Collected Works Volume 28, July 1918 - March 1919 (Progress Publishers 1965). google scholar
120. Lenin Vİ, Ulusların Kendi Kaderini Tayin Hakkı (Muzaffer Erdost tr, Sol Yayınları 1992). google scholar
121. ——, Ulusal sorun ve ulusal kurtuluş savaşları (Yurdakul Fincancı tr, Sol Yayınları 1993). google scholar
122. Lentin R, ‘Palestine/Israel and State Criminality: Exception, Settler Colonialism and Racialization’ (2016) 5 State Crime Journal 32. google scholar
123. Public and Private International Law Bulletin, 46 (1): 94–143 139 google scholar
124. İşgal altındaki Filistin’de Yerleşimci Sömürgecilik ve İnsan Hakları Hukuku Şahin & Güneysu, 2026 google scholar
125. Lieblich E and Benvenisti E, Occupation in International Law (Oxford University Press 2022). google scholar
126. Longobardo M, ‘The Occupation of Maritime Territory Under International Humanitarian Law’ (2019) 95 International Law Studies 322. google scholar
127. ——, ‘Animals in Occupied Territory’ in Anne Peters, Jérôme de Hemptinne and Robert Kolb (eds), Animals in the International Law of Armed Conflict (Cambridge University Press 2022). google scholar
128. Loomba A, Kolonyalizm postkolonyalizm (Mehmet Küçük tr, Ayrıntı Yayınları 2000). google scholar
129. Luxemburg R, Sermaye Birikiminin Tarihsel Koşulları (Neyyir Kalaycıoğlu tr, Kaynak Yayınları 1984). google scholar
130. ——, Ulusal Ekonomiye Giriş (A. Cavidan tr, Belge Yayınları 1995). google scholar
131. ——, The Accumulation of Capital (Routledge 2003). google scholar
132. —— Rosa Luxemburg Kitabı: Seçme Yazılar (Tunç Tayanç tr, Dipnot Yayınları 2010). google scholar
133. MacKenzie JM, Propaganda and Empire: The Manipulation of British Public Opinion, 1880 - 1960 (Manchester University Press 2003). google scholar
134. Makdisi, ‘Riding the Whirlwind of Settler Colonialism’ (2010) 53 Victorian Studies 108. google scholar
135. Maloba WO, The Anatomy of Neo-Colonialism in Kenya: British Impérialism and Kenattyan, 1963-1979 (Palgrave Macmillan 2017). google scholar
136. Mamdani M, ‘Settler Colonialism: Then and Now’ (2015) 41 Critical Inquiry 596. google scholar
137. Mandel E and Freedman A, Marksist iktisat el kitabı: temel tanımlar (Yordam Kitap 2008). google scholar
138. Marriott J, The Other Empire: Metropolis, India and Progress in the Colonial Imagination (Manchester University Press 2003). google scholar
139. Martens GF von, Summary of the Law of Nations, Founded on the Treaties and Customs of the Modern Nations of Europe: With a List of the Principal Treaties, Concluded Since the Year 1748 Down to the Present Time, Indicating the Works in Which They Are to Be Found (Thomas Bradford, printer, bookseller & stationer, no 8, South Front street 1795). google scholar
140. Marx K, Ekonomi Politiğin Eleştirisine Katkı (Sevim Belli tr, Sol Yayınları 1970). google scholar
141. ——, Kapitalist Rant Üzerine (Seyhan Erdoğdu tr, Sol Yayınları 1976). google scholar
142. ——, Kapital Cilt III (Alaattin Bilgi tr, Sol Yayınları 1997). google scholar
143. ——, Artı Değer Teorileri - Birinci Kitap (Yurdakul Fincancı tr, Sol Yayınları 1998). google scholar
144. ——, Ücretli Emek ve Sermaye (Süleyman Ege tr, Bilim ve Sosyalizm Yayınları 2001). google scholar
145. ——, Ekonomi Yazıları (Ahmet Fethi tr, Hil Yayın 2004). google scholar
146. ——, Kapital Cilt II (Alaattin Bilgi tr, Sol Yayınları 2006). google scholar
147. ——, Kapital Cilt I (Alaattin Bilgi tr, Sol Yayınları 2011). google scholar
148. ——, Ücret, Fiyat ve Kar (Alaaddin Bilgi tr, Evrensel 2006). google scholar
149. ——, Kapital: I. Cilt (Mehmet Selik and Nail Satılgan tr, Yordam Kitap 2018). google scholar
150. Marx K and Engels F, Collected Works Volume 42, Letters, 1864-68 (Lawrence & Wishart Electric Book 2010). google scholar
151. Melandri M, ‘Self-Determination and State-Building in International Law: The Need for a New Research Approach’ (2015) 20 Journal of Conflict & Security Law 75. google scholar
152. Meray SL, Devletler Hukukuna Giriş: İkinci Cilt (4th edn, Ankara Üniversitesi Siyasal Bilgiler Fakültesi Yayınları 1975). google scholar
153. Millar JR, ‘A Note on Primitive Accumulation in Marx and Preobrazhensky’ (1978) 30 Soviet Studies 384. google scholar
154. Milner E and Kedar AS, ‘Squaring the Circle: Settler Colonialism, the International Law of Occupation and the Separation Barrier’ (2023) 105 Political Geography 102929. google scholar
155. Moore D, ‘The Second Age of the Third World: From Primitive Accumulation to Global Public Goods?’ (2004) 25 Third World Quarterly 87. google scholar
156. Nabudere DW, Imperialism in East Africa (Zed Press 1981). google scholar
157. Nabudere DW, Imperialism and Integration (Zed press 1982). google scholar
158. Nanni G, The Colonisation of Time: Ritual, Routine and Resistance in the British Empire (Manchester University Press 2012). google scholar
159. Narsey WL, British Imperialism and the Making of Colonial Currency Systems (Palgrave Macmillan 2016). google scholar
160. Nijhar P, Law and Imperialism: Criminality and Constitution in Colonial India and Victorian England (Pickering & Chatto 2009). google scholar
161. Ollman B, Marksizme sıra dışı bir giriş (Ayşegül Kars tr, Yordam Kitap 2015). google scholar
162. Oppenheimer FV, British Imperialism (Forgotten Books 2010). google scholar
163. Ostler, ‘Locating Settler Colonialism in Early American History’ (2019) 76 The William and Mary Quarterly 443. google scholar
164. Oto-Peralías D and Romero-Ávila D, Colonial Theories of Institutional Development: Toward a Model of Styles of Imperialism (Springer 2017). google scholar
165. Owen R and Pamuk Ş, 20. yüzyılda Ortadoǧu ekonomileri tarihi (Ayşe Edirne tr, Sabancı Üniversitesi 2002). google scholar
166. Özdemir AM, Sözün Mülkiyeti-Hukukun Ekonomi Politiği (Dipnot Yayınları 2008). google scholar
167. Özdemir AM, ‘Kolektif Emperyalizm’ in Ali Murat Özdemir (ed), Kolektif Emperyalizm: Mağribden Maşrıka Dönüşümün Ekonomi Politiği (İmge Kitabevi 2014). google scholar
168. Özsu U, ‘Grabbing Land Legally: A Marxist Analysis’ (2019) 32 Leiden Journal of International Law 215. google scholar
169. Özturanlı Şanda B, ‘İşgal Altındaki Filistin’in Denizel Kaynaklardan Yararlanmasına İlişkin Hukuki Rejim’ in Ali Kerem Kayhan and Ali Osman Karaoğlu (eds), Uluslararası Hukukta Filistin Meselesi (Adalet Yayınevi 2023). google scholar
170. Pappé I, ‘1948 : Le projet de purification ethnique en Palestine’ [2007] Revue d’études palestiniennes 72. google scholar
171. Paradies Y, ‘Colonisation, Racism and Indigenous Health’ (2016) 33 Journal of Population Research 83. google scholar
172. Pawlisch HS, Sir John Davies and the Conquest of Ireland: A Study in Legal Imperialism (Cambridge University Press 2002). google scholar
173. Pazarcı H and Denk E, Uluslararası Hukuk (23rd edn, Turhan Kitabevi 2024). google scholar
174. Pennock PE, The Rise of the Arab American Left: Activists, Allies, and Their Fight against Imperialism and Racism, 1960s-1980s (The University of North Carolina Press 2017). google scholar
175. Perelman M, ‘Comment: Primitive Accumulation in Modern China’ (2008) 32 Dialectical Anthropology 327. google scholar
176. Perugini N, ‘The Moral Economy of Settler Colonialism: Israel and the “Evacuation Trauma”’ (2014) 4 History of the Present 49. google scholar
177. Peters A, ‘Verhältnismäßigkeit Als Globales Verfassungsprinzip’ in Baade Björnstern and others (eds), Verhältnismäßigkeit im Völkerrecht (Mohr Siebeck 2016). google scholar
178. Petras JF and Veltmeyer H, Power and Resistance: US Imperialism in Latin America (Brill 2016). google scholar
179. Petrucciani S, The Ideas of Karl Marx: A Critical Introduction (Guido Parietti tr, Springer International Publishing AG 2020). google scholar
180. Porter AN, European Imperialism: 1860-1914 (Macmillan 1994). google scholar
181. Primakov Y, Rusların Gözüyle Ortadoğu (Olga Tezcan tr, Timaş Yayınları 2010). google scholar
182. Proudfoot LJ and Hall D, Imperial Spaces: Placing the Irish and Scots in Colonial Australia (Manchester University Press 2011). google scholar
183. Roberts A, ‘Transformative Military Occupation: Applying the Laws of War and Human Rights’ (2006) 100 The American Journal of International Law 580. google scholar
184. Robinson RK, ‘Unravelling Settler Ideology: Navigating Treaty Dynamics in Settler-Colonial Contexts’ Settler Colonial Studies 1. google scholar
185. Romney, ‘Settler Colonial Prehistories in Seventeenth-Century North America’ (2019) 76 The William and Mary Quarterly 375. google scholar
186. Şahin OG, Törenin Ekonomi Politiği (İmge Kitabevi Yayınları 2023). google scholar
187. ——, ‘Sınıf Egemenliği, Hukuk ve Sovyet Hukuku’ (2024) 10 Anadolu Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Dergisi 709. google scholar
188. Sanchez R and Pita B, ‘Rethinking Settler Colonialism’ (2014) 66 American Quarterly 1039. google scholar
189. Sand S, Yahudi Halkı Nasıl İcat Edildi?: Kitabı Mukaddes’ten Siyonizme (Doğan Kitap 2011). google scholar
190. Sassòli M, ‘Article 43 of the Hague Regulations and Peace Operations in the Twenty-First Century: Background Paper Prepared for Informal High-Level Expert Meeting on Current Challenges to International Humanitarian Law’ (HPCR, Harvard University 2004). google scholar
191. ——, International Humanitarian Law: Rules, Controversies, and Solutions to Problems Arising in Warfare (Edward Elgar Publishing 2019). google scholar
192. Savran S, Kod adı küreselleşme: 21. yüzyılda emperyalizm (Yordam Kitap 2008). google scholar
193. Schneer J, Balfour deklarasyonu (Ali Cevat Akkoyunlu tr, Kırmızı Kedi 2012). google scholar
194. Seeley JR, The Expansion of England: Two Courses of Lectures (Macmillan and Co 1883). google scholar
195. Shadle BL, The Souls of White Folk: White Settlers in Kenya, 1900s-1920s (Manchester University Press 2015). google scholar
196. Shoemaker, ‘Settler Colonialism: Universal Theory or English Heritage?’ (2019) 76 The William and Mary Quarterly 369. google scholar
197. Shor FR, Dying Empire: U.S. Imperialism and Global Resistance (Routledge 2010). google scholar
198. Smallwood, ‘Reflections on Settler Colonialism, the Hemispheric Americas, and Chattel Slavery’ (2019) 76 The William and Mary Quarterly 407. google scholar
199. Sorel A, Avrupa ve Fransız İhtilali VI (Nahid Sırrı Örik tr, Milli Eğitim Basımevi 1953). google scholar
200. ——, Avrupa ve Fransız İhtilali VI* (Nahid Sırrı Örik tr, Milli Eğitim Basımevi 1953). google scholar
201. ——, Avrupa ve Fransız İhtilali VII (Nahid Sırrı Örik tr, Maarif Basımevi 1955). google scholar
202. ——, Avrupa ve Fransız İhtilali VII* (Nahid Sırrı Örik tr, Maarif Basımevi 1956). google scholar
203. Sotelo Valencia A, Sub-Imperialism Revisited: Dependency Theory in the Thought of Ruy Mauro Marini (Jacob Lagnado tr, Brill 2017). google scholar
204. Spiers EM, The Victorian Soldier in Africa (Manchester University Press 2004). google scholar
205. Stalin JV, Sosyalist Ekonominin Meseleleri (M Kabagil tr, Sol Yayınları 1967). google scholar
206. Stanford J, Herkes için iktisat: kapitalist sömürüyü anlama kılavuzu (Tuncel Öncel tr, Yordam Kitap 2011). google scholar
207. Sur M, Uluslararası Hukukun Esasları (17th edn, Beta 2024). google scholar
208. Svirsky M and Ben-Arie R, From Shared Life to Co-Resistance in Historic Palestine (Rowman & Littlefield International 2018). google scholar
209. Symcox G, War, Diplomacy, and Imperialism, 1618–1763 (Palgrave Macmillan UK 1974). google scholar
210. Truett, ‘Settler Colonialism and the Borderlands of Early America’ (2019) 76 The William and Mary Quarterly 435. google scholar
211. Tzouvala N, Capitalism as Civilisation: A History of International Law (Cambridge University Press 2020). google scholar
212. Uçaryılmaz T, ‘The Principle of Proportionality in Modern Ius Gentium’ [2021] Utrecht Journal of International and European Law. google scholar
213. Vagts DF, ‘Ajuri v. IDF Commander in West Bank. Case No. HCJ 7015/02, [2002] Isr. L. Rep. 1’ (2003) 97 American Journal of International Law 173. google scholar
214. Velednitsky S, Hughes SNS and Machold R, ‘Political Geographical Perspectives on Settler Colonialism’ (2020) 14 Geography Compass e12490. google scholar
215. Veracini L, ‘Introducing’ (2011) 1 Settler Colonial Studies 1. google scholar
216. ——, ‘The Other Shift: Settler Colonialism, Israel, and the Occupation’ (2013) 42 Journal of Palestine Studies 26. google scholar
217. Vité S, ‘L’applicabilité Du Droit International de l’occupation Mititaire Aux Activités Des Organisations Internationales’ (2004) 86 Revue Internationale de la Croix-Rouge/International Review of the Red Cross 9. google scholar
218. ——, ‘Occupation’ in Ben Saul and Dapo Akande (eds), The Oxford Guide to International Humanitarian Law (Oxford University Press 2020). google scholar
219. Wolfe P, ‘Settler Colonialism and the Elimination of the Native’ (2006) 8 Journal of Genocide Research 387. google scholar
220. Yeandle P, Citizenship, Nation, Empire: The Politics of History Teaching in England, 1870-1930 (Manchester University Press 2015). google scholar
221. Yıldız E, ‘Postcolonial Approaches to International Human Rights Law: The TWAIL Case’ (2023) 43 Public and Private International Law Bulletin 353. google scholar
222. Yılmaz F, Hukukta Yorumun Sınıfsallığı (On İki Levha 2024). google scholar Zhang R Wei, Colonial Administration and Land Reform in East Asia (Routledge 2017). google scholar
223. Beit Sourik Village Council v 1 The Government of Israel & 2 Commander of the IDF Forces in the West Bank [2004] The Supreme Court of Israel sitting as the High Court of Justice HCJ 2056/04. google scholar
224. Case Concerning Armed Activities On The Territory Of The Congo (Democratic Republic Of The Congo V Uganda) [2005] ICJ Reports 2005 168. google scholar
225. Jam’iat Iscan Al-Ma’almoun v IDF Commander in the Judea and Samaria Area The Supreme Court of Israel sitting as the High Court of Justice HCJ 393/82. google scholar
226. Legal Consequences arising from the Policies and Practices of Israel in the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem. google scholar
227. Legal Consequences of the Construction of a Wall in the Occupied Palestinian Territory, Advisory Opinion (Danışma Görüşü) [2004] ICJ Reports. google scholar
228. Marab et al v IDF Commander in the West Bank et al Judgment The Supreme Court of Israel sitting as the High Court of Justice HCJ 3239/02. google scholar
229. US Military Tribunal, Trials of War Criminals before the Nuernberg Military Tribunals under Control Council Law No. 10 Nuernberg, October 1946-April 1949 (US Government Printing Office). google scholar
230. Absentees’ Property Law 1950. google scholar
231. ‘A1. International Crisis Group, Report on Israel’s Arab Minority and the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict, Nazareth/Jerusalem/Ramallah/Brussels, 14 March 2012 (Excerpts).’ (2012) 41 Journal of Palestine Studies 18‘A1. International Crisis Group, Report on Israel’s Arab Minority and the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict, Nazareth/Jerusalem/Ramallah/Brussels, 14 March 2012 (Excerpts).’ (2012) 41 Journal of Palestine Studies 185. google scholar
232. ‘A1. UN Special Rapporteur of the Commision on Human Rights, Report to UN General Assembly on the Human Rights Situation in the Occupied Territories, New York, 18 August 2005 (Excerpts).’ (2006) 35 Journal of Palestine Studies 178. google scholar
233. ‘A1. United Nations, Assesment of the Future Humanitarian Risks in the Occupied Palestinian Territory, New’ (2006) 35 Journal of Palestine Studies 144. google scholar
234. ‘Agreement - Declaration of Principles on Interim Self-Government Arrangements (a.k.a. “Oslo Accord”)’ (Question of Palestine) erişim tarihi 8 Nisan 2025. google scholar
235. ‘Agreement - Hebron Protocol Text - Non-UN Document’ (Question of Palestine) erişim tarihi 8 Nisan 2025. google scholar
236. Convention (IV) Respecting the Laws and Customs of War on Land and Its Annex: Regulations Concerning the Laws and Customs of War on Land 1907. google scholar
237. Geneva Convention Relative to the Protection of Civilian Persons in Time of War 1949 (UNTS, 1950). google scholar
238. Harb Zamanında Sivillerin Korunmasına Dair 12 Ağustos 1949 Tarihli Cenevre Sözleşmesi (12 Ağustos 1949) RG 30.01.1953/8322.. google scholar
239. Protocol Additional to the Geneva Conventions of 12 August 1949, and relating to the Protection of Victims of International Armed Conflicts (Protocol I) (UNTS, Vol 1125, 1979). google scholar
240. UNSC, Resolution 1483 (2003) UN Doc S/RES/2003.. google scholar
241. Second International Peace Conference, Convention (IV) Respecting the Laws and Customs of War on Land and Its Annex: Regulations Concerning the Laws and Customs of War on Land, International Conferences 1907. google scholar
242. ‘Settler Colonialism, WEX Law Dictionary’. google scholar
243. Cox A, ‘Settler Colonialism’ Oxford Bibliographies erişim tarihi 13 Aralık 2024. google scholar
244. Lehmann N, ‘Police Complete Demolition of Unrecognized Bedouin Village Umm Al-Hiran’ The Tİmes Of Israel (14 November 2024) erişim tarihi 7 Şubat 2025. google scholar
245. Seidler S, ‘Supreme Court Allows State to Replace Bedouin Village with Jewish One’ Haaretz (6 May 2015) erişim tarihi 7 Şubat 2025. google scholar