Türk Bozkır Kültüründe Cerrahi Bir Müdahale: Trepanasyon

Abstract

Paleopatolojik anlamda iskeletler üzerinde en dikkat çekici travmatik durumlardan biri olarak kabul edilen trepanasyon, antik çağlarda birçok toplum tarafından tedavi ya da ritüel gibi çeşitli amaçlar doğrultusunda uygulanmış bir yöntemdir. Kesici ve delici olmak üzere birtakım aletlerin kullanılmasıyla kafatasından kemik parçası çıkarma, kafatası üzerinde delik açma ya da kafatasını kazıma trepanasyonun en temel hali olarak kabul edilmiştir. Geçmişten günümüze bilim insanları trepanasyonun sınıflandırılmasına dair birçok görüş ileri sürmüşler ve bu kapsamda araştırmalar yapmışlardır. Dünyada birçok toplulukta izleri olduğu bilinen trepanasyonun Türkler tarafından da uygulandığı kurganlarda yapılan arkeolojik araştırmalar sonucunda tespit edilmiştir. Bu çalışmalar neticesinde trepanasyona dair elde edilen bulguların değerlendirilmesi Türk kültürü açısından oldukça önem arz etmektedir. Çalışmamızda oldukça geniş kapsamlı bir konu olan trepanasyonun ne olduğu, hangi amaçlarla yapıldığına dair genel bilgi vermeyi ve özelde Türklerde bu uygulamanın varlığını ortaya koymayı amaçlamaktayız. Bu bağlamda bilgi verdiğimiz trepanasyonun Türklere ait çeşitli kurganlardaki örneklerini vererek bunları Türk kültürü çerçevesinde değerlendirmeyi gayret edindik.

Keywords

• Trepanasyon
• Kraniyotomi
• Türk Bozkır Kültürü
• Doğu Avrupa
• Türkistan

A Surgical Intervention in Turkish Steppe Culture: Trepanation

Abstract

Trepanation, considered one of the most remarkable traumatic conditions on skeletons in the paleopathological sense, is a method applied by many societies in ancient times for various purposes such as treatment or ritual. The most basic form of trepanation is the removal of bone fragments from the skull with the use of cutting and piercing tools, drilling holes in the skull, or scraping the skull. From the past to the present, scientists have put forward many views on the classification of trepanation and have conducted research in this context. It has been determined as a result of archaeological research in the kurgans that trepanation, which is known to have traces in many communities in the world, was also practiced by the Turks. As a result of these studies, the evaluation of the findings on trepanation is very important for Turkish culture. The aim of our study is to provide general information about what trepanation is, which is a very comprehensive subject, for what purposes it is performed, and to reveal the existence of this practice among the Turks in particular. In this context, we have endeavored to give examples of trepanation in various kurgans belonging to the Turks and to evaluate them within the framework of Turkish culture.

Keywords

• Trepanation
• Craniotomy
• Turkish Steppe Culture
• Eastern Europe
• Turkestan

References

1. Balabanova, Mariya A., Pererva, Evgeniy V. “Special Rituals, Rites and Customs of Treatment of Human Bodies (A Case Study Of Sarmatian Cultures)”, The Lower Volga Archaeological Bulletin, 18/2 (2019), s. 125-144.
2. Bayat, Ali H., Tıp Tarihi, (Genişletilmiş 3. Baskı), İstanbul 2016.
3. Bereczki, Zsolt, Molnár, Erika vd., “Evidence of Surgical Trephinations in Infants from the 7th-9th Centuries AD Burial Site of Kiskundorozsma-Kettôshatár”, Acta Biologica Szegediensis, 54/2 (2010), s. 93-98.
4. Bereczki, Zsolt, Molnár, Erika vd., “Rare Types of Trephination from Hungary Shed New Light on Possible Cross-cultural Connections in the Carpathian Basin”, International Journal of Osteoarchaeology, 25/3 (2013), s. 322-333.
5. Chikisheva, Tatyana A., Zubova, Alisa V. vd., “Trepanation among The Early Nomads of Gorny Altai: A Multidisiplinary Study”, Archaeology, Ethnology& Anthropology of Eurasia, 42/1 (2014), s. 130-141.
6. Chikisheva, Tatyana A., Volkov, Pavel V. vd., “Early Iron Age Surgical Technologies: Ante-mortem Trepanation Among The Early Nomads of Gorny Altai”, Archaeology Ethnology&Anthropology of Eurasia, 42/4 (2014), s. 146-154.
7. Chikisheva, Tatyana A., Krivoshapkin, Alexey L. vd., “Craniotomy as a Prehistoric Medical Practice: A Case of Antemortem Cranial Trepanation in Southern Siberia in the Late Bronze Age”, Archaeology, Ethnology& Anthropology of Eurasia, 46/1 (2018), s. 133-143.
8. Chikisheva, Tatyana A., Volkov, Pavel V., “Sluchai vozmozhnogo ritualnogo prizhiznennogo travmirovaniya cherepov pazyrykskoy kulturı (Gornıy Altay)”, Problemı arkheologii, etnografii, antropologii Sibiri i sopredelnıh territoriy, XXIV (2018), s. 367-370.

9. Clower, William T., Finger, Stanley, “Discovering Trepanation: The Contribution of Paul Broca”, Neurosurgery, 49/6 (2001), s. 1417-1426.
10. Czékus, Géza “Presentation of the Trepanned Skull Labelled MO-90, Found in the Avar Cemetery on the Territory of Settlements Ómoravica-Kopláló in Serbia”, International Journal of Morphology, 36/1 (2018), s. 243-247.
11. Çoruhlu, Yaşar, Eski Türklerin Kutsal Mezarları Kurganlar, (2. Baskı), İstanbul 2019.
12. Daragan, Marina N., Gavrish, Petr A., “On Manifestations of the Cult of Human Skulls in the Knÿshovskoe Settlement Dating from the Scythian Period”, Ancient Civilizations From Scythia to Sibeia, 23 (2017), s. 251-328.
13. Feldman, Alex M., The Monotheisation of Pontic-Caspian Eurasia, UK 2022.
14. Finger, Stanley, Fernando, Hiran R., “E. George Squier and the Discovery of Cranial Trepanation: A Landmark in the History of Surgery and Ancient Medicine”, Journal of the History of Medicine and Allied Sciences, 56/4 (2001), s. 353-381.
15. Finger, Stanley, Clower, William T., “On the Birth of Trepanation: the Thoughts of Paul Broca and Victor Horsley”, Trepanation History, Discovery, Theory, (Ed. R. Arnott, S. Finger), Lisse 2003, s. 19-42.
16. González-Darder, José M., “Cranial Trepanation in Primitive Cultures”, Neurocirugía, 28/1 (2017), s. 28-40.
17. Hoştaş, Gülay, “Doğu Avrupa Türk Tarihinin Arkeolojik İmzası: Kemik Dönüşümü ve Deformasyonu”, Genel Türk Tarihi Araştırmaları Dergisi, 6/12 (2024), s. 311-330.
18. Hoştaş, Gülay, Türk Bozkır Kültüründe Gizemli Unsurlar, Basılmamış Doktora Tezi, İstanbul 2024.
19. Ilgın, Fatma A., Avarlar Avrupa’da 250 Yıllık Hâkimiyetin İzleri, İstanbul 2023.
20. Jordanov, Jordan, Dimitrova, Bistra vd., “Symbolic Trepanations of Skulls from the Middle ages (IXth-Xth Century) in Bulgaria, Acta Neurochirurgica, 92/1-4 (1988), s. 15-18.
21. Kilunovskaya, Marina Y., Leus, Pavel M. “Iskusstvo Kontsa Pervogo Tysyacheletiya Do N. E. V Tuve”, Kratkiye Soobshcheniya Instituta Arkheologii, 247 (2017), s. 87-104.
22. Király, Kitty, Váradi, Orsolya A. vd., “New Insights in The Investigation of Trepanations from The Carpathian Basin”, Archaeological and Anthropological Sciences, 14/75 (2022), s. 1-17.
23. Kitov, Yegor P., Beysenov, Arman Z., “Posmertnaya trepanatsiya cherepov v elitnıh zahoroneniyah sakskoy epokhi Tsentral'nogo Kazakhstana”, Izvestiya Altayskogo Gosudarstvennogo Universiteta, 84/4-2 (2014), s. 31-41.
24. Krivoshapkin, Alexey L., Chikisheva, Tatiana A. vd. “Trepanations in The Population of The Altai Mountains in The Vth-IIIrd Centuries B.C.”, Burdenko’s Journal of Neurosurgery, 78/3 (2014), s. 57-65.
25. Kurta, Florin, “Obraz i Arkheologiya Pechenegov”, Stratum Plus, 5 (2013), s. 203-234.
26. László, Orsolya, “Detailed Analysis of a Trepanation from the Late Avar Period (Turn of the 7th–8th Centuries—811) and its Significance in the Anthropological Material of the Carpathian Basin”, International Journal of Osteoarchaeology, 26/2 (2014), s. 359-365.
27. Lisowski, F. Peter, “Prehistoric and Early Historic Trepanation”, Diseases in Antiquity: A Survey of the Diseases, Injuries and Surgery of Early Populations, (Ed. Don Brothwell, A.T. Sandison), USA 1967, s.651, s. 651-672.
28. Mednikova, Maria B., Trepanatsii u Drevnikh Narodov Yevrazii, Moskva 2001.
29. Mednikova, Maria B., “Post-Mortem Trepanations in Central Asia: Types and Trends”, Kurgans, Ritual Sites and Settlements Esurasian Bronze and Iron Age, (Ed. J. D. Kimball, E.M. Murphy vd.), Oxford 2016, s. 269-278.
30. Missios, Symeon, “Hippocrates, Galen and The Uses of Trepanation in The Ancient Classical World”, Neurosurg Focus, 23/1 (2007), s. 1-9.
31. Murphy, Eileen M., Iron Age Archaeology and Aymyrlyg, South Siberia, Oxford 2016.
32. Nemeskéri, János, Kralovánszky, Alán vd., “Trephined Skulls from The Tenth Century”, Acta Archaeol Acad Sci Hungaricae, 17 (1965), s. 343–367.
33. Okladnikov, Aleksey P., “Tarihin Şafağında İç Asya”, (Çev. Alâeddin Şenel, Der. Denis Sinor), Erken İç Asya Tarihi, İstanbul 2003, s. 61-140.
34. Ortner, Donald J., Identification of Pathological Conditions in Human Skeletal Remains, (Second Edition), USA 2003.
35. Ögel, Bahaeddin, İslâmiyetten Önce Türk Kültür Tarihi Orta Asya Kaynak ve Buluntularına Göre, Ankara 2014.
36. Pankova, Svetlana V.; Vasiliev, Sergey S. vd., “Radiocarbon Dating of Oglakhty Grave Using a Wiggle Matching Method”, Archaeology, Ethnology& Anthropology of Eurasia, 38/2 (2010), s. 46-56.
37. Pankova, Svetlana V., “One More Culture with Ancient Tattoo Tradition in Southern Siberia: Tattoos on a Mummy from the Oglakhty Burial Ground, 3rd-4th Century AD”, Tattoos and Body Modifications in Antiquity, Proceedings of the Sessions at the EAA Annual Meetings in The Hague and Oslo, Zurich Studies in Archaeology (Ed. P. D. Casa, C. Witt), C. 9, Zurich 2013, s. 75-86.
38. Pererva, Evgeniy V., “Trepanation in The Sarmatians of The Lower Volga Region”, Archaeology and Early History of Ukraine, 36/3 (2020), s. 465-475.
39. Pererva, Evgeniy V., Berezina, Natalia vd., “Trepanations in Sauromato-Sarmatian Crania from the Lower Volga”, Archaeology, Ethnology& Anthropology of Eurasia, 48/2 (2020), s. 140-148.
40. Reşetova, Irina K., “Trephination Cases from The Early Bulgarian Population (Saltovo-Mayaki Culture)”, The European Archaeologist, 38 (2012), s. 9-14.
41. Reşetova, Irina K., “Opisaniye individov s trepanirovannymi cherepami sredi nositeley saltovo-mayatskoy kul'tury: meditsinskaya praktika ili kul't?”, Etnograficheskoye obozreniye, 5 (2012), s. 182-188.
42. Reşetova, Irina K., “Trephination of the Skull among the Population of the Khazar Kaganate”, Student Archaeology in Europe 2014, (Ed. P. Krištuf, D. Novák vd.), Pilsen 2014, s. 160-164.
43. Rubini, Mauro, Zaio, Paola “Warriors from The East. Skeletal Evidence of Warfare from a Lombard-Avar Cemetery in Central Italy (Campochiaro, Molise, 6th-8th Century AD)”, Journal of Archaeological Science, 38/7 (2011), s. 1551-1559.
44. Rudenko, Sergei I., Frozen Tombs of Siberia: The Pazyryk Burials of Iron Age Horsemen, Berkeley&Los Angeles 1970.
45. Russeva, Victoria, “Religion, Magic or Medicine? New Finds of Trepanned Skulls from Southeastern Bulgaria, 11th-13th”, Archaeologia Bulgarica, 16/2 (2012), s. 77-95.
46. Samaşev, Zaynolla, Berel, Almatı 2011.
47. Simalcsik, Angela, “New Cases of Symbolic Trepanation from the Medieval Period Discovered in the Space between Pruth and Dniester”, Anastasis Research in Medieval Culture and Art, 5/1 (2018), s. 146-174.
48. Szathmáry, László, Marcsik, Antónia, “Symbolic Trephinations and Population Structure”, Memórias do Instituto Oswaldo Cruz, 101 (2006), s. 129-132.
49. Toraman, Ali, “Türk Tarihinin Kaynakları: Altay’da Hun Maddi Kültürünün Arkeolojik Kaynaklarına Genel Bir Bakış”, Genel Türk Tarihi Araştırmaları Dergisi, 2/3 (2020), s. 11-28.
50. Tsoucalas, Gregory, “The Siberian Lancet: One More Possible Innovative Example of Scalpel’s Contribution to the Evolution of Surgical Anatomy and Neurosurgery”, World Neurosurgery, 121 (2019), s. 169-172.
51. Uchaneva, Yevgeniya N., Malyutina, Anna A. vd. “Trasologicheskoye izucheniye posmertnykh trepanatsiy na cherepakh iz tashtykskogo gruntovogo mogil'nika Oglakhty”, Sibirskiye istoricheskiye issledovaniya, 3 (2023), s. 236-271.
52. Zöllner, Henning, Ullrich, Burkart vd., “Results of Geophysical Prospection in the Scythian Settlement of Belsk (Bol'šoe Belskoe Gorodišče)”, Layers of Perception. Proceedings of the 35th International Conference on Computer Applications and Quantitative Methods in Archaeology (CAA) Berlin, (Ed. A. Posluschny, K. Lambers, vd.), Bonn 2008, s. 1-4.