Political Economy of Public Private Partnerships
Year 2015,
Volume: 22 Issue: 1, 19 - 40, 14.10.2015
Burak Darıcı
,
Mehmet Taşçı
Abstract
Many scholars think that Public Private Partnerships (PPP) provide major advantages when compared with traditional procurement processes. Are all these benefits leveraging of public
funds, better management and alllocation of risk, alternative revenue sources, improving effectiveness and service quality are actually real or not? What are the mistakes that are known
absolutely true in PPP processes. In our study political economy of PPPs are analysed with critical perspective.
References
- BETTIGNIES, Jean Etinne De, ROSS Thomas W. (2004), “The Economics of Public-Private Partnerships”, Canadian Public Policy/Analyse de Politiques, Vol. 30, No. 2.
- BLOOMFIELD, Pamela, GROUP, Clarus, (2006), “The Challenging Business of Long-Term Public – Private Partnerships: Reflections on Local Experience”, Public Administration Review, Volume 66, Issue 3, March-April.
- CAVELTY, Myriam Dunn and SUTER, Manuel, (2009), “Public–Private Partnerships Are No Silver Bullet: An Expanded Governance Model For Critical Infrastructure Protection”, International Journal of Critical Infastructure Protection, Volume: 2 Issue: 4.
- CLERCK, Dennis De, DEMEULEMEESTER, Erik, HERROELEN, Willy, (2012), “Public Private Partnerships: Look Before You Leap Into Marriage”, Review of Business and Economic Literature, Vol 57, 3.
- CONDE, Ana Belen Alonso, BROWN, Christine, SUAREZ, Javier Rojo, (2007), “Public Private Partnerships: Incentives, Risk Transfer And Real Options”, Review of Financial Economics, 16.
- DANIELS, Ron and TREBILCOCK Michael, (1996), "Private Provision of Public Infrastructure: An Organizational Analysis of the Next Privatization Frontier," University of Toronto Law Journal, 46.
- EPSTEIN, Wendy Netter, (2013), “Contract Theory and the Failures of Public-Private Contracting”, Cardozo Law Review, Vol. 34, Issue 6.
- FARNAM, Peter, (2005), Assessing Public–Private Partnerships in Africa, The South African Institute Of International Affairs, Nepad Policy Focus Report No. 2, SAIIA National Office Bearers.
- FLINDERS, Matthew, (2005), “The Politics of Public–Private Partnerships”, The British Journal of Politics & International Relations, Volume 7, Issue 2.
- FORRER, John, KEE James Edvin, NEWCOMER, Kathryn E., BOYER, Eric, (2010), “Public– Private Partnerships and the Public Accountability Question”, Public Administration Review, Volume70, Issue 3.
- GREVE, Carsten, HODGE, Graeme, (2012), “Public-Private Partnerships: Observations on Changing Forms of Transparency”, Transatlantic Conference on Transparency Research, Utrecht University, the Netherlands, 7-9 June.
- GRIMSEY, Darrin and LEWIS K. Mervyn, (2002), “Evaluating the Risks of Public Private Partnerships for Infrastructure Projects”, International Journal of Project Management, 20.
- HALL, David, (2008), Critique of PPPs, Public Services International Research Unit (PSIRU), European <http://www.epsu.org/IMG/pdf/PPPs-crit-finalLAYOUT-2.pdf>, (02.11.2013).
- HODGE, Graeme A., (2004), “The Risky Business Of Public–Private Partnerships”, Australian Journal of Public Administration, 63(4).
- HODGE, Graeme A., and GREVE, Carsten, (2007), “Public-Private Partnerships: An International Performance Review,” Public Administration Review, 67.
- HOOD, John, FRASER, Ian, MCGARVEY, Neil, (2006), “Transparency of Risk and Reward in U.K. Public–Private Partnerships”, Public Budgeting & Finance / Winter.
- IOB Study, (2013), Public-Private Partnerships In Developing Countries A Systematic Literature Review, Literature Review, No:78, Ministry of Foreign Affairs of The Netherlands.
- KOVANCILAR, Birol, MİYNAT, Mustafa, BURSALIOĞLU, Sibel, (2007), Kamu Maliyesinde Küresel Değişimler, Gazi Kitabevi, Ankara.
- KOVANCILAR, Birol, UĞUR, Alparslan, (2011), “Mali Konseyler ve Ülke Deneyimleri”, Maliye Dergisi, Sayı:160, Ocak-Haziran.
- LOOSEMORE, A. Ng. Martin, (2007), “Risk Allocation In The Private Provision Of Public Infrastructure”, International Journal of Project Management, 25.
- MASKIN, Eric and TIROLE, Jean, (2008), “Public–Private Partnerships And Government Spending Limits”, International Journal of Industrial Organization, 26.
- MCQUAID, Ronald, W., SCHERRER, Walter, (2008), “Public Private Partnership in the European Union: Experiences in the UK, Germany and Austria”, 65th International Atlantic Economic Conference, 9th -13th April, Warsaw.
- ROSENEU, Pauline Waillancourt, (1999), “The Strengths and Weaknesses of Public Private Policy Partnerships”, American Behavioral Scientist, 43:10.
- SADKA, Efraim, (2006), Public-Private Partnerships: A Public Economics Perspective, IMF Working Paper, Fiscal Affairs Department, WP/06/77.
- SANGER, Toby, CRAWLEY, Corina, (2009), “The Problem with Public-Private Partnerships”, partnerships>, (15.02.2014).
- SCRIBNER, Marc, (2011), The Limitations of Public-Private Partnerships Recent Lessons from the Surface Transportation and Real Estate Sectors, Issue Analysis, Competitive Enterprise Enstitute.
- SPACKMAN, Michael, (2002), “Public–Private Partnerships: Lessons From The British Approach”, Economic Systems, 26.
- UNITED NATIONS, (2008), Guidebook On Promoting Good Governance In Public-Private Partnerships, United Nations Economic Commission for Europe, New York and Geneva.
- VINING, Aidan, R., BOARDMAN, Anthony, E., (2008), “Public–Private Partnerships Eight Rules for Governments”, Public Works Management Policy, Volume 13, Number 2, Octaber.
Kamu Özel Sektör Ortaklıklarının Ekonomi Politiği
Year 2015,
Volume: 22 Issue: 1, 19 - 40, 14.10.2015
Burak Darıcı
,
Mehmet Taşçı
Abstract
Birçok bilim adamı kamu özel sektör ortaklığının geleneksel kamu alımları sürecine göre önemli faydalar sağladığını düşünmektedir. Kamusal fonlara ihtiyaç olmaması, daha iyi yönetim ve
risk dağılımı, gelir kaynaklarının farklılaştırılması, etkinliğin ve hizmet kalitesinin artırılması gibi faydalar gerçekte var mıdır? Kamu Özel Sektör Ortaklığı süreçlerinde doğru bilinen yanlışlar
nelerdir? Çalışmamızda kamu özel sektör ortaklıklarının ekonomi-politiği eleştirel bir yaklaşımla analiz edilmiştir
References
- BETTIGNIES, Jean Etinne De, ROSS Thomas W. (2004), “The Economics of Public-Private Partnerships”, Canadian Public Policy/Analyse de Politiques, Vol. 30, No. 2.
- BLOOMFIELD, Pamela, GROUP, Clarus, (2006), “The Challenging Business of Long-Term Public – Private Partnerships: Reflections on Local Experience”, Public Administration Review, Volume 66, Issue 3, March-April.
- CAVELTY, Myriam Dunn and SUTER, Manuel, (2009), “Public–Private Partnerships Are No Silver Bullet: An Expanded Governance Model For Critical Infrastructure Protection”, International Journal of Critical Infastructure Protection, Volume: 2 Issue: 4.
- CLERCK, Dennis De, DEMEULEMEESTER, Erik, HERROELEN, Willy, (2012), “Public Private Partnerships: Look Before You Leap Into Marriage”, Review of Business and Economic Literature, Vol 57, 3.
- CONDE, Ana Belen Alonso, BROWN, Christine, SUAREZ, Javier Rojo, (2007), “Public Private Partnerships: Incentives, Risk Transfer And Real Options”, Review of Financial Economics, 16.
- DANIELS, Ron and TREBILCOCK Michael, (1996), "Private Provision of Public Infrastructure: An Organizational Analysis of the Next Privatization Frontier," University of Toronto Law Journal, 46.
- EPSTEIN, Wendy Netter, (2013), “Contract Theory and the Failures of Public-Private Contracting”, Cardozo Law Review, Vol. 34, Issue 6.
- FARNAM, Peter, (2005), Assessing Public–Private Partnerships in Africa, The South African Institute Of International Affairs, Nepad Policy Focus Report No. 2, SAIIA National Office Bearers.
- FLINDERS, Matthew, (2005), “The Politics of Public–Private Partnerships”, The British Journal of Politics & International Relations, Volume 7, Issue 2.
- FORRER, John, KEE James Edvin, NEWCOMER, Kathryn E., BOYER, Eric, (2010), “Public– Private Partnerships and the Public Accountability Question”, Public Administration Review, Volume70, Issue 3.
- GREVE, Carsten, HODGE, Graeme, (2012), “Public-Private Partnerships: Observations on Changing Forms of Transparency”, Transatlantic Conference on Transparency Research, Utrecht University, the Netherlands, 7-9 June.
- GRIMSEY, Darrin and LEWIS K. Mervyn, (2002), “Evaluating the Risks of Public Private Partnerships for Infrastructure Projects”, International Journal of Project Management, 20.
- HALL, David, (2008), Critique of PPPs, Public Services International Research Unit (PSIRU), European <http://www.epsu.org/IMG/pdf/PPPs-crit-finalLAYOUT-2.pdf>, (02.11.2013).
- HODGE, Graeme A., (2004), “The Risky Business Of Public–Private Partnerships”, Australian Journal of Public Administration, 63(4).
- HODGE, Graeme A., and GREVE, Carsten, (2007), “Public-Private Partnerships: An International Performance Review,” Public Administration Review, 67.
- HOOD, John, FRASER, Ian, MCGARVEY, Neil, (2006), “Transparency of Risk and Reward in U.K. Public–Private Partnerships”, Public Budgeting & Finance / Winter.
- IOB Study, (2013), Public-Private Partnerships In Developing Countries A Systematic Literature Review, Literature Review, No:78, Ministry of Foreign Affairs of The Netherlands.
- KOVANCILAR, Birol, MİYNAT, Mustafa, BURSALIOĞLU, Sibel, (2007), Kamu Maliyesinde Küresel Değişimler, Gazi Kitabevi, Ankara.
- KOVANCILAR, Birol, UĞUR, Alparslan, (2011), “Mali Konseyler ve Ülke Deneyimleri”, Maliye Dergisi, Sayı:160, Ocak-Haziran.
- LOOSEMORE, A. Ng. Martin, (2007), “Risk Allocation In The Private Provision Of Public Infrastructure”, International Journal of Project Management, 25.
- MASKIN, Eric and TIROLE, Jean, (2008), “Public–Private Partnerships And Government Spending Limits”, International Journal of Industrial Organization, 26.
- MCQUAID, Ronald, W., SCHERRER, Walter, (2008), “Public Private Partnership in the European Union: Experiences in the UK, Germany and Austria”, 65th International Atlantic Economic Conference, 9th -13th April, Warsaw.
- ROSENEU, Pauline Waillancourt, (1999), “The Strengths and Weaknesses of Public Private Policy Partnerships”, American Behavioral Scientist, 43:10.
- SADKA, Efraim, (2006), Public-Private Partnerships: A Public Economics Perspective, IMF Working Paper, Fiscal Affairs Department, WP/06/77.
- SANGER, Toby, CRAWLEY, Corina, (2009), “The Problem with Public-Private Partnerships”, partnerships>, (15.02.2014).
- SCRIBNER, Marc, (2011), The Limitations of Public-Private Partnerships Recent Lessons from the Surface Transportation and Real Estate Sectors, Issue Analysis, Competitive Enterprise Enstitute.
- SPACKMAN, Michael, (2002), “Public–Private Partnerships: Lessons From The British Approach”, Economic Systems, 26.
- UNITED NATIONS, (2008), Guidebook On Promoting Good Governance In Public-Private Partnerships, United Nations Economic Commission for Europe, New York and Geneva.
- VINING, Aidan, R., BOARDMAN, Anthony, E., (2008), “Public–Private Partnerships Eight Rules for Governments”, Public Works Management Policy, Volume 13, Number 2, Octaber.