A Comparative Study on Yayık Butter Produced with Commercial and Endemic Yogurt Starter Culture Strains

Abstract

Starter cultures are involved in biochemical reactions during fermentation resulting in the diversity of foods. They are also used for aroma/flavor, texture, nutritional quality enhancement, and shelf-life extension. This study aimed to evaluate the effects of using four different starter culture combinations of which two were isolated starter cultures of Streptococcus thermophilus (St) and Lactobacillus delbrueckii subsp. bulgaricus (Lb) and two were commercial cultures of the same bacteria in Yayık butter characteristics. For this purpose, four different yogurt samples were prepared and then churned to obtain four different Yayık butter samples. Physico-chemical analysis, free fatty acids, volatile compounds, and sensory analysis were performed on the 1st, 30th, and 60th days of storage. No significant differences were observed in moisture, fat, titratable acidity, acid degree, and peroxide value between the samples (P>0.05). However, endemic isolated combined cultures showed better performance in terms of free fatty acid formation and sensorial attributes. The serum pH differed significantly among the samples with higher values in isolated cultures (P<0.05). Storage time was significantly effective on the titratable acidity (°SH) of all Yayık butter samples (P<0.01). The peroxide values were lower than the threshold value of 2.0 meq O2/kg fat. Acid degree varied between 1.70-1.75 mg KOH/g during the storage period. Endemic isolated cultures exhibited the highest free fatty acid accumulation. In the Yayık butter samples, a total of 31 volatile compounds were quantified. The highest number was detected in the butter samples produced with isolated strains (27St/27Lb and 27St/ALb). Yayık butter samples produced with 27St/27Lb contained 16, while with 27St/ALb had 7 compounds identified. Butyric acid and hexanoic acid were the most abundant carboxylic acids while ketones were the predominant volatile compound detected in all Yayık butter samples. This study highlights the importance of preserving traditional culture strains and offers another perspective on using them in dairy industry.

Keywords

• Yayık butter
• isolated strains
• Lipolysis
• oxidative stability
• volatile compounds
• sensory analysis.

References

1. Afzal M I, Delaunay S, Paris C, Borges F, Revol-Junelles A M & Cailliez-Grimal C (2012). Identification of metabolic pathways involved in the biosynthesis of flavor compound 3-methylbutanal from leucine catabolism by Carnobacterium maltaromaticum LMA 28. International Journal of Food Microbiology 157(3): 332-339
2. Alwazeer D, Bulut M, Ceylan M M, Çelebi Y, Kavrut E, Çetintaş Y, Hayaloğlu A A (2024). Hydrogen incorporation into butter improves its microbial and chemical stability, biogenic amine safety, quality attributes, and shelf-life. LWT 206: 116550
3. Anonymous (2005). Tereyağı, Diger Süt Yagı Esaslı Sürülebilir Ürünler ve Sadeyağ Tebliği.Yayın No: 2005/91. 25784 sayı ve 12.04.2005 tarihli Resmi Gazete.
4. AOAC (1997) Official methods of analysis, 16th ed. Association of Official Analytical Chemists, Washington, DC
5. AOAC (2000). Official methods of analysis of AOAC international (17th ed.). Gaitherburg, MD, USA:AOAC International.
6. Atamer M (1983). Ankara’da Tereyağına İşlenen Kremaların Özellikleri ve Bunlardan Elde Edilen Tereyağlarının Niteliklerinin Saptanması. Ankara Üniversitesi Ziraat Fakültesi Tarım Ürünleri Teknolojisi Süt Teknolojisi Ana BilimDalı. Fen Bilimleri Enstitüsü, Ankara
7. Atamer M & Sezgin E (1984). Tereyağlarında Lipolitik ve oksidatif bozulmaların saptanmasında yararlanılan asit ve peroksid değerleri ile aroma arasındaki ilişki. Gıda 9(6).
8. Atamer M, Şenel E & Öztekin F Ş (2004). A Traditional Product: Yayık Tereyağ Conventional Way of Manufacturing and Its Some Properties.

9. International Dairy Symposium. Recent Developments in Dairy Science and Technology pp. 149-152
10. Atamer M, Şenel E & Öztekin F Ş (2005). Yoğurttan Üretilen Tereyağlarının (YayıkTereyağı) Bazı Niteliklerinin Belirlenmesi. TUBITAK, TOGTAG-3035 nolu proje.
11. Atamer M, Şenel E & Öztekin F Ş (2006). Yayık Tereyağlarında Asit, Peroksit, Tirozin Değerleri ile Titrasyon Asitligine İliskin Sınır Değerlerinin Saptanması. Ankara Üniversitesi Bilimsel Arastırma Projesi Kesin Raporu. Proje No:07–110–03–HPD, Ankara.
12. Atamer M, Şenel E & Öztekin F Ş (2007). A comparative study on some properties of butter produced from yoghurt and cream, Food Industry Milk and Dairy Products. Journal of Chemist and Technologists Association Belgrad (1-2): 18
13. Bendall J G (2001). Aroma compounds of fresh milk from New Zealand cows fed different diets. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry 49(10): 4825-4832
14. Caplice E & Fitzgerald G F (1999). Food fermentations: role of microorganisms in food production and preservation. International Journal of Food Microbiology 50(1-2): 131-149
15. Chen C, Zhao S, Hao G, Yu H, Tian H & Zhao G (2017). Role of lactic acid bacteria on the yogurt flavour: A review. International Journal of Food Properties 20(1): 316-330
16. Christensen K R & Reineccius G A (1995). Aroma extract dilution analysis of aged Cheddar cheese. Journal of Food Science 60(2): 218-220
17. Chittora D, Meena B R, Jain T & Sharma K (2022). Biopreservation: Bacteriocins and Lactic Acid Bacteria. Journal of Postharvest Technology 10(2): 1-15
18. Collins Y F, McSweeney P L & Wilkinson M G (2003). Lipolysis and free fatty acid catabolism in cheese: a review of current knowledge. International Dairy Journal 13(11): 841-866
19. Dan T, Jin R, Ren W, Li T, Chen H & Sun T (2018). Characteristics of milk fermented by Streptococcus thermophilus MGA45-4 and the profiles of associated volatile compounds during fermentation and storage. Molecules 23(4): 878
20. Deeth H C & Fitz-Gerald C H (1976). Lipolysis in dairy products: a review. Australian Journal of Dairy Technology 31: 53-64
21. Deeth H C, Fitz-Gerald CH & Snow A J (1983). A gas chromatographic method for the quantitative determination of free fatty acids in milk and milk products. New Zealand Journal of Dairy Science and Technology 18: 13-20
22. Deeth H C & Fitz-Gerald C H (2006). Lipolytic enzymes and hydrolytic rancidity. In Advanced Dairy Chemistry, Volume 2 Lipids (pp. 481- 556). Boston, MA: Springer US
23. Delgado F J, González-Crespo J, Cava R, García-Parra J & Ramírez R (2010). Characterisation by SPME–GC–MS of the volatile profile of a Spanish soft cheese PDO Torta del Casar during ripening. Food Chemistry 118(1): 182-189
24. Downey W K (1975). Butter Quality. Published by An Foras Taluntais 19 Sadyamount Avenue Dublin 4, Dairy Research & Review Series No. 7, 142 pp
25. Ergin G (1978). Tereyağının dayanıklılığına Muhafaza Sıcaklığı, Krema Asitliği ve pastörizasyonu ve Tuzlamanın Etkileri Üzerine Bir Araştırma. Fen Bilimleri Enstitüsü, Gıda Mühendisliği Anabilim Dalı, Erzurum
26. Fardet A, Dupont D, Rioux L E & Turgeon S L (2019). Influence of Food Structure On Dairy Protein, Lipid and Calcium Bioavailability: A Narrative Review Of Evidence. Critical Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition 59(13): 1987-2010
27. Gu Y, Li X, Chen H, Guan K, Qi X, Yang L & Ma Y (2021). Evaluation of FAAs and FFAs in yogurts fermented with different starter cultures during storage. Journal of Food Composition and Analysis 96: 103666
28. Gundogdu E, Cakmakci S & Hayaloglu A A (2020). Effects of starter culture and storage on volatile profiles and sensory characteristics of yogurt or cream butter. Mljekarstvo 70(3): 184-200
29. Guler Z & Park Y W (2010). Evaluation of correlations between chemical compositions and sensory properties in Turkish Set-type yogurts. Journal of Dairy Science
30. Hayaloglu A A & Konar A (2001). A comparative study on physicochemical and sensorial properties of butter made from yogurt and cream. Milchwissenschaft - Milk Science International 56(12)
31. Kılıç S (2010). Maya ve küfler, Süt Mikrobiyolojisi. Sidas Medya Ltd. Şti, Izmir, Türkiye pp. 485-554
32. Kleerebezem M & Hugenholtz J (2003). Metabolic pathway engineering in lactic acid bacteria. Current Opinion in Biotechnology 14(2): 232- 237
33. Lee J H (2020). Changes in flavor compounds and quality parameters of goat cream butter during extended refrigerated storage. International Journal of Food Properties 23(1): 306-318
34. Li D, Cui Y, Wu X, Li J, Min F, Zhao T & Zhang J (2024). Graduate Student Literature Review: Network of flavor compounds formation and influence factors in yogurt. Journal of Dairy Science
35. Lozano P R, Miracle E R, Krause A J, Drake M & Cadwallader K R (2007). Effect of cold storage and packaging material on the major aroma components of sweet cream butter. J. of Agricultural and Food Chemistry 55(19): 7840-7846.
36. Maiouet I, Mahi K E, Abouloifa H & Rhallabi N (2024). Technological characterization of lactic acid bacteria isolated from raw milk. Interactions 245(1): 218
37. Mallia S (2008). Oxidative stability and aroma of UFA/CLA (unsaturated fatty acids/conjugated linoleic acid) enriched butter (Doctoral dissertation, ETH Zurich)
38. Mantzourani C, Batsika C S, Kokotou M G & Kokotos G (2022). Free fatty acid profiling of Greek yogurt by liquid chromatography-high resolution mass spectrometry (LC-HRMS) analysis. Food Research International 160: 111751
39. Moio L & ADDEO F (1998). Grana Padano cheese aroma. Journal of Dairy Research 65(2): 317-333
40. Ozcan T, Akpinar-Bayizit A, Yilmaz-Ersan L, Cetin K & Delikanli B (2016). Evaluation of fatty acid profile of Trabzon butter. International Journal of Chemical Engineering and Applications 7(3): 190-194
41. Özer B (2010). Strategies for yogurt manufacturing. Development and manufacture of yogurt and other functional dairy products pp. 47-96
42. Öztekin Öztürk F Ş (2010). Yoğurdun sulandırma oranı ve granüllerin yıkama sayısının yayık tereyağının nitelikleri üzerine etkisi
43. Pan D D, Wu Z, Peng T, Zeng X Q & Li H (2014). Volatile organic compounds profile during milk fermentation by Lactobacillus pentosus and correlations between volatiles flavor and carbohydrate metabolism. Journal of dairy science 97(2): 624-631
44. Papagianni M (2012). Metabolic engineering of lactic acid bacteria for the production of industrially important compounds. Computational and Structural Biotechnology Journal 3(4), e201210003
45. Pearson D (1974). The assessment of rancidity of oils on a common cholorfm extract with special reference to TBA values. J. of the Ass. of Public Analysts 12: 73-76
46. Peterson D G & Reineccius G A (2003). Characterization of the volatile compounds that constitute fresh sweet cream butter aroma. Flavour and Fragrance Journal 18(3): 215-220
47. Qian M & Reineccius G (2002). Identification of aroma compounds in Parmigiano-Reggiano cheese by gas chromatography/olfactometry. Journal of Dairy Science 85(6): 1362-1369
48. Rascón-Díaz M P, Tejero J M, Mendoza-Garcia P G, García H S & Salgado-Cervantes M A (2012). Spray drying yogurt incorporating hydrocolloids: Structural analysis, acetaldehyde content, viable bacteria, and heological properties. Food and Bioprocess Technology 5: 560-567
49. Sağdiç O, Arici M & Simşek O (2002). Selection of starters for a traditional Turkish yayik butter made from yoghurt. Food Microbiology 19(4): 303-312
50. Sağdıç O, Dönmez M & Demirci M (2004). Comparison of characteristics and fatty acid profiles of traditional Turkish yayik butters produced from goats', ewes' or cows' milk. Food Contro 15(6): 485-490
51. Şenel E (2006). Bazı Üretim Parametrelerinin Yogurttan Üretilen Yayık Tereyağının Nitelikleri Üzerine Etkisi. Ankara Üniversitesi Fen Bilimleri Enstitüsü Süt Teknolojisi Anabilim Dalı, Doktora Tezi, 168.
52. Şenel E, Atamer M & Öztekin Ş (2010). Yayıklama parametrelerinin yayık ayranı ve yayık tereyağının bazı nitelikleri üzerine etkisi. Gıda 35(4): 267-274
53. Şenel E, Atamer M, Gürsoy A & Öztekin F Ş (2011a). Changes in some properties of strained (Süzme) goat's yoghurt during storage. Small Ruminant Research 99(2-3): 171-177
54. Şenel E, Atamer M & Öztekin F Ş (2011b). The oxidative and lipolytic stability of Yayık butter produced from different species of mammals milk (cow, sheep, goat) yoghurt. Food Chemistry 127(1): 333-339
55. Şenel E, Atamer M, Şanlı T, Kocabaş Z & Türkmen N (2016). Geleneksel Yayık Tereyağının Aroma Karakterizasyonu ve Duyusal Özelliklerinin Belirlenmesi. Ankara Üniversitesi Bilimsel Araştırma Projeleri, Proje No: 12B4347004. Ankara
56. Şenel E & Atamer M (2015). Yayik Butter Profiles from Different Species of Mammals’ Milk. In Processing and Impact on Active Components in Food (pp. 215-221). Academic Press
57. Tamime A Y & Robinson R K (1999). Yogurt Science and Technology CRC. Press. Woodhead Publishing Ltd. Cambridge, England.
58. Tian H, Yu B, Yu H & Chen C (2020). Evaluation of the synergistic olfactory effects of diacetyl, acetaldehyde, and acetoin in a yogurt matrix using odor threshold, aroma intensity, and electronic nose analyses. Journal of dairy science 103(9): 7957-7967
59. TÜİK (2023). Türkiye İstatistik Kurumu. Hayvacılık İstatistikleri. https://biruni.tuik.gov.tr/medas/?kn=79&locale=tr (August 2023).
60. Uzunsoy I (2018). Determination of suitability of Lactobacillus delbrueckii subsp. bulgaricus and Streptococcus thermophilus strains isolated from traditional J Microbiol Biotech Food Sci / Uzunsoy et al. 2023:13 (1) e9241 8 yogurt samples for industrial yogurt productions and developing starter combinations, Ph.D. thesis. Ankara: Ankara University
61. Uzunsoy I, Budak S O, Sanli T, Taban B, Aytac A, Yazihan N & Özer B (2021). Assessment of Growth and Technological Performances of Yogurt Bacteria Isolated from Local Turkish Yogurts. Food Science and Engineering pp. 52-64
62. Üçüncü M (2005). Süt ve mamulleri teknolojisi. Ege Üniversitesi Mühendislik Fakültesi. Vanbergue E, Delaby L, Peyraud J L, Colette S, Gallard Y & Hurtaud C (2017). Effects of breed, feeding system, and lactation stage on milk fat characteristics and spontaneous lipolysis in dairy cows.Journal of Dairy Science 100(6): 4623-4636
63. van Hylckama Vlieg J E T & Hugenholtz J (2007). Mining natural diversity of lactic acid bacteria for flavour and health benefits. International dairy journal 17(11): 1290-1297
64. Van Immerseel F, Ducatelle R, De Vos M, Boon N, Van De Wiele T, Verbeke K & Flint H J (2010). Butyric acid-producing anaerobic bacteria as a novel probiotic treatment approach for inflammatory bowel disease. Journal of medical microbiology 59(2): 141-143
65. Walstra P (1999). Dairy technology: Principles of Milk Properties and Processes.
66. Whetstine M C, Karagul-Yuceer Y O N C A, Avsar Y K & Drake M A (2003). Identification and quantification of character aroma components in fresh Chevre-style goat cheese. Journal of Food Science-Chicago 68(8): 2441-2447
67. Wirawati C U, Sudarwanto M B, Lukman D W, Wientarsih I & Srihanto E A (2019). Diversity of lactic acid bacteria in dadih produced by either back-slopping or spontaneous fermentation from two different regions of West Sumatra, Indonesia. Veterinary world 12(6): 823