Struggles Over the Sea: Resistance and Blue Justice in Türkiye

Yıl 2026, Cilt: 18 Sayı: 1 , 65 - 91 , 20.02.2026

Aygün Karlı

https://doi.org/10.53376/ap.2026.03

https://izlik.org/JA27CH98RS

Öz

This article examines the emerging relevance of blue justice as an analytical lens for understanding socio-ecological conflicts in Türkiye’s marine environments. Although the concept remains largely absent from the country’s formal policy and academic debates, struggles across the Mediterranean, Aegean, Marmara, and Black Sea demonstrate how questions of distribution, recognition, and participation are embedded in everyday marine practices. Methodologically, the study combines qualitative documents analysis of policy and secondary sources with a region-based case study approach. The findings reveal that the contraction of small-scale fishing grounds, societal reactions to ecological collapse in the Marmara Sea, and contested energy projects in the Black Sea constitute distinct yet interconnected domains of marine injustice. The article highlights both the contradictions inherent in Türkiye’s alignment with blue economy agendas and the potential for blue justice to emerge as a critical framework for advancing more equitable and sustainable marine governance.

Anahtar Kelimeler

Blue Justice , Political Ecology , Marine Governance , Blue Economy , Marine Policy

Etik Beyan

During the preparation of this work, the authors used ChatGPT version 5 to assist with the translation and to improve the language and readability of the manuscript. After using this tool, the authors reviewed and edited the content as needed and take full responsibility for the content of the publication.

Deniz Üzerine Mücadeleler: Türkiye’de Direniş ve Mavi Adalet

https://izlik.org/JA27CH98RS

Öz

Bu makale, Türkiye’nin denizel çevrelerinde ortaya çıkan sosyo‐ekolojik çatışmaları anlamada mavi adalet kavramının analitik bir mercek olarak taşıdığı önemi incelemektedir. Kavram, Türkiye’nin resmi politika ve akademik tartışmalarında büyük ölçüde yer almamakla birlikte; Akdeniz, Ege, Marmara ve Karadeniz’deki mücadeleler, dağıtım, tanınma ve katılım meselelerinin gündelik denizle ilgili pratiklerine nasıl içkin olduğunu göstermektedir. Çalışma, politika belgeleri ve ikincil kaynakların nitel doküman analizi ile bölge temelli bir vaka incelemesi yaklaşımını bir araya getirmektedir. Bulgular, küçük ölçekli balıkçılık alanlarının daralması, Marmara Denizi’ndeki ekolojik çöküşe yönelik toplumsal tepkiler ve Karadeniz’deki tartışmalı enerji projelerinin, deniz adaletsizliğinin birbirinden farklı fakat birbiriyle bağlantılı alanlarını oluşturduğunu ortaya koymaktadır. Makale, Türkiye’nin mavi ekonomi gündemleriyle uyum sürecinde ortaya çıkan çelişkileri ve mavi adaletin daha adil ve sürdürülebilir bir deniz yönetişimi için eleştirel bir çerçeve olarak gelişme potansiyelini vurgulamaktadır.

Anahtar Kelimeler

Mavi Adalet , Politik Ekoloji , Deniz Yönetişimi , Mavi Ekonomi , Deniz Politikası

Etik Beyan

During the preparation of this work, the authors used ChatGPT version 5 to assist with the translation and to improve the language and readability of the manuscript. After using this tool, the authors reviewed and edited the content as needed and take full responsibility for the content of the publication.

Kaynakça

• Akdağ, Ozan and Celaleddin Yeroğlu (2020), “An evaluation of an offshore energy installation for the Black Sea region of Turkey and the effects on a regional decrease in greenhouse gas emissions”, Greenhouse Gases: Science and Technology, 10 (3): 531-544.
• Anbleyth-Evans, Jeremy, Manuel Prieto, Jonathan Barton, Ana García Cegarra, Sandor Muslow, Emilo Ricci, Leonardo Campus and Vergara Pinto Francisca (2022), “Toxic violence in marine sacrificial zones: Developing blue justice through marine democracy”, Environment and Planning C: Politics and Space, 40 (7): 1492-1514.
• Aydın, Cem İskender (2020), “Nuclear energy debate in Turkey: Stakeholders, policy alternatives, and governance issues”, Energy Policy, 136: 111041
• Barbesgaard, Mads (2017), “Blue growth: savior or ocean grabbing?”, The Journal of Peasant Studies, 45 (1): 130-149.
• Batıda Gündem (2025), “Sinop’ta Füze Testlerine Tepki: Balıkçılar Endişeli!”, https://batidagundem.com/sinopta-fuze-testlerine-tepki-balikcilar-endiseli/ (02.10.2025).
• Bennett, Nathan James, Jessica Blythe, Carole Sandrine White and Cecilia Campero (2021), “Blue growth and blue justice: Ten risks and solutions for the ocean economy”, Marine Policy: 125.
• Blue, Gwendolyn, Kelly Bronson and Alana Lajoie-O'Malley (2021), “Beyond distribution and participation: A scoping review to advance a comprehensive environmental justice framework for impact assessment”, Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 90.
• Blythe, Jessica L., David A. Gill, Joachim Claudet, Nathan J. Bennett, Georgina G. Gurney, Jacopo A. Baggio, Natalie C. Ban, Miranda L. Bernard, Victor Brun, Emily S. Darling, Antonio Di Franco, Graham Epstein, Phil Franks, Rebecca Horan, Stacy D. Jupiter, Jacqueline Lau, Natali Lazzari, Shauna L. Mahajan, Sangeeta Mangubhai, Josheena Naggea, Rachel A. Turner and Noelia Zafra-Calvo (2023), “Blue justice: A review of emerging scholarship and resistance movements”, Cambridge Prisms: Coastal Futures, 1: e15.
• Bogadóttir, Ragnheiður (2020), “Blue Growth and its discontents in the Faroe Islands: An island perspective on Blue (De) Growth, sustainability, and environmental justice”, Sustainability Science, 15 (1): 103-115.
• Bramwell, Bill (Ed.) (2004), “Coastal Mass Tourism: Diversification and Sustainable Development in Southern Europe”, Multilingual Matters & Channel View Publications.
• Chuenpagdee, Ratana and Svein Jentoft (2015), “Interactive governance for small-scale fisheries”, Centre for Maritime Research (MARE): Springer International Publishing.
• Demircan, Pınar (2022), “Authoritarian neoliberalism and resistance of the anti-nuclear movement in Turkey”, Authoritarianism and Civil Society in Asia, (London: Routledge): 77-93.
• Demirel, Duygun Fatih and Eylül Sezer (2024), “Marmara Denizi'nde Görülen Müsilajın Ortadan Kaldırılmasına Yönelik Politikaların Sistem Dinamiği ile İncelenmesi”, KSÜ Mühendislik Bilimleri Dergisi, 27 (2): 364 - 385.
• Demirel, Nazlı, Taner Yıldız, Aylin Ulman, Mustafa Zengin, Ekin Akoğlu, İsmet Saygu, Pınar Ertor-Akyazı, Güzin Gül, Dalida Bedikoğlu and İzzet Noyan Yılmaz (2023), “Status of the Sea of Marmara ecosystem and its fishery resources: mucilage episodes and recommendations for sustainable fisheries”, Mucilage Problem in the Sea of Marmara (Istanbul: Istanbul University Press): 217-232.
• Denizeau, Aurélien (2021), “Mavi Vatan, the Blue Homeland: The Origins, Influences and Limits of an Ambitious Doctrine for Turkey’’, Études de l’Ifri: 1-30.
• Engen, Sigrid, Vera Helene Hausner, Georgina G. Gurney, Else Grete Broderstad, Rose Keller, Aase Kristine Lundberg, Murguzur Ancin, Javier Francisco, Emma Salminen, Christopher M. Raymond, Jannike Falk-Andersson and Per Fauchald (2021), “Blue justice: A survey for eliciting perceptions of environmental justice among coastal planners’ and small-scale fishers in Northern-Norway”, PloS One, 16 (5).
• Ertör-Akyazi, Pınar (2020), “Contesting growth in marine capture fisheries: the case of small-scale fishing cooperatives in Istanbul”, Sustainability Science, 15 (1): 45-62.
• Ertör-Akyazi, Pınar and Irmak Ertör (2022), “Blue Justice and Small-Scale Fisher Mobilizations in Istanbul, Turkey: Justice Claims, Political Agency, and Alliances”, Blue Justice: Small-Scale Fisheries in a Sustainable Ocean Economy (Cham: Springer International Publishing): 569-587
• Ertör, Irmak (2023), “‘We are the oceans, we are the people!’: fisher people’s struggles for blue justice”, The Journal of Peasant Studies, 50 (3): 1157-1186.
• Ertör, Irmak and Maria Hadjimichael (2020), “Blue degrowth and the politics of the sea: rethinking the blue economy”, Sustainability Science, 15 (1): 1-10.
• Ertör, Irmak and Miquel Ortega-Cerdà (2015), “Political lessons from early warnings: Marine finfish aquaculture conflicts in Europe”, Marine Policy, 51: 202-210.
• Fiorentino, Fabio and Sergio Vitale (2021), “How can we reduce the overexploitation of the Mediterranean resources?”, Frontiers in Marine Science, 8: 674633.
• Germond-Duret, Celine, C. Patrick Heidkamp and John Morrissey (2022), “(In)justice and the blue economy”, The Geographical Journal, 00: 184-192.
• Govender, Maheshwaran, Jewel Das, Srijon Paul, Sourav Shil Shuvo, Samiya Ahmed Selim and Marion Glaser (2025), “Toward blue justice in blue growth: Insights from local discourses on coastal megaprojects in Bangladesh”, Ocean & Coastal Management: 269.
• Greenpeace (2021), Çevre STK’larından Marmara Denizi Havzası için hayati çağrı: “Ya #DenizBoğulursa?” Kampanyası başlıyor (Greenpeace Türkiye).
• Hodges, Ben (2021), “The Black Sea... Or a Black Hole?”, Center for European Policy Analysis, https://cepa.org/article/the-black-sea-or-a-black-hole/ (23.01.2026).
• Jentoft, Svein, Chuenpagdee, Ratana (2022), “Interactive Learning and Governance Transformation for Securing Blue Justice for Small-Scale Fisheries”, Administration & Society, 54 (7): 1255-1282.
• Karadeniz İsyandadır (2017), https://karadenizisyandadir.net (20.08.2025).
• Karadurmuş, Uğur and Mustafa Sarı (2022), “Marine mucilage in the Sea of Marmara and its effects on the marine ecosystem: mass deaths”, Turkish Journal of Zoology, 46 (1): 93-102.
• Karakulak, Firdes Saadet, Abdullah Ekrem Kahraman, Uğur Uzer, Benal Gül and Sadettin Doğu (2023), “Effects of mucilage on the fisheries in the Sea of Marmara. Mucilage Problem in the Sea of Marmara”, Albay, M. (Ed.), (Istanbul: Istanbul University Press): 2: 1-9.
• Karlı, Aygün (2024a), “Türkiye’deki Sürdürülebilir Mavi Ekonomi ve Deniz Yönetişimi İmkanlarının Değerlendirilmesi: Bakanlıklar Düzeyinde Bir İnceleme”, JENAS Journal of Environmental and Natural Studies, 6 (3) (In Honour of Nesrin Algan): 239-250.
• Karlı, Aygün (2024b), “Sustainable Blue Economy Policy in Turkey: Challenges and Opportunities”, SDGs in Africa and the Middle East Region: 755-775.
• Karlı, Aygün (2026), “Policy frameworks without practice? Exploring marine governance and climate integration challenges in Türkiye”, Marine Policy, 186: 107013.
• Keleş, Günay, Serpil Yılmaz and Mustafa Zengin (2020), “Possible economic effects of musilage on Sea of Marmara fisheries”, International Journal of Agriculture Forestry and Life Sciences, 4 (2): 173-177.
• Knudsen, Ståle (Ed.) (2009), Fishers and scientists in modern Turkey: The management of natural resources, (Oxford, UK: Bergahn Books).
• Marchessaux, Guillaume, Mangano, Maria Cristina, Bizzarri, Sergio, M’Rabet, Charaf, Principato, Elena, Lago, Nicola, Veyssiere, Dimitri, Garrido, Marie, Scyphers, Steven B., Sarà, Gianluca (2023), “Invasive blue crabs and small-scale fisheries in the Mediterranean sea: local ecological knowledge, impacts and future management”, Marine Policy, 148: 105461.
• Paloniemi, Riikka, Niemelä, Jari, Soininen, Niko, Laatikainen, Tiina, Vierikko, Kati, Rekola, Aino, Viinikka, Arto, Yli-Pelkonen, Vesa, Assmuth, Timo, Kopperoinen, Leena, Peltonen, Lasse, Kuokkanen, Tuomas, Kyttä, Marketta (2018), “Environmental justice for the governance of aquatic environments”, Local Environment, 23 (3): 366-377.
• Pascual-Fernández, José J., Pita, Cristina, Bavinck, Maarten (Eds.) (2020), Small-scale fisheries in Europe: Status, resilience and governance (Vol. 23) (Cham: Springer).
• Pereira, Taryn and Kira Erwin (2023), “Surfacing solidarity praxis in transdisciplinary research for blue justice”, Ecosystems and People, 19 (1): 2260502.
• Pita, Cristina, Pascual-Fernández, Jose J., Bavinck, Maarten (2020), “Small-scale fisheries in Europe: challenges and opportunities”, Small-Scale Fisheries in Europe: Status, Resilience and Governance: 581-600.
• Republic of Türkiye (2021), “Marmara Denizi Bütünleşik Strateji Planı”, Ministry of Environment, Urbanization and Climate Change, https://webdosya.csb.gov.tr/db/cygm/icerikler/stratej-k-plan_marmara-20211216082358.pdf (02.10.2025.)
• Rigolon, Alessandro, Gibson, Stephen (2021), “The role of non-governmental organizations in achieving environmental justice for green and blue spaces”, Landscape and Urban Planning, 205: 103970.
• Said, Alicia, Pascual-Fernández, Jose, Amorim, Vanessa Iglésias, Autzen, Mathilde Højrup, Hegland, Troels Jacob, Pita, Cristina, Ferretti, Johanna, Penca, Jerneca (2020), “Small-scale fisheries access to fishing opportunities in the European Union: Is the Common Fisheries Policy the right step to equality?”, Marine Policy: 117.
• Salihoğlu, Barış and Mustafa Yücel (2025), Advancing Black Sea Research and Innovation to Co-Develop Blue Growth within Resilient Ecosystems.
• Sarı, Mustafa (2022), “Müsilaj ve Marmara Denizi Balıkçılığı”, Şehir ve Toplum, 20-21 (2): 95-110.
• Schreiber, Milena Arias, Chuenpagdee, Ratana, Jentoft, Svein (2022), “Blue Justice and the co-production of hermeneutical resources for small-scale fisheries”, Marine Policy: 137.
• Sezerel, Hakan and Deniz Karagoz (2023), “The challenges of sustainable tourism development in special environmental protected areas: Local resident perceptions in Datça-Bozburun”, Sustainability, 15 (4): 3364.
• Silver, Jennifer J., Gray, Noella J., Campbell, Lisa M., Fairbanks, Luke W., Gruby, Rebecca L. (2015), “Blue Economy and Competing Discourses in International Oceans Governance”, The Journal of Environment & Development, 24 (2): 135-160.
• Tafon, Ralph, Saunders, Fred, Zaucha, Jacek, Matczak, Magdalena, Stalmokaitė, Igne, Gilek, Michael, Turski, Jakub (2024), “Blue justice through and beyond equity and participation: a critical reading of capability-based recognitional justice in Poland’s marine spatial planning”, Journal of Environmental Planning and Management, 67 (10): 2206-2228.
• Türk Tabipleri Birliği (2022), Sinop Nükleer Güç Santrali Projesi Son Şekli Verilen ÇED Raporu’nun İnsan ve Çevre Sağlığı Açısından Değerlendirilmesi, https://www.ttb.org.tr/kollar/halk_sagligi/haber_goster.php?Guid=2b5320e8-affd-11ec-b4ce-5ab7867ddfe8 (20.08.2025).
• Türkiye Yüzyılı, https://turkiyeyuzyili.com/proje-surdurulebilir-mavi-ekonomi-eylem-plani-mavi-plan. (20.08.2025).
• Uğuz, Sabriye Çelik, Kaimuldinova, Kulyash Duisenbaevna, Yildirim, Gülsün, Kabiyev, Yerlan (2022), “Evaluation of environmental issues in the coasts of edremit gulf in terms of sustainable tourism”, Geo Journal of Tourism and Geosites, 40 (1): 302-312.
• Ünal, Vahdet and Aylin Ulman (2020), “The current status and challenges facing the small-scale fisheries of Turkey”, Small-Scale Fisheries in Europe: Status, Resilience and Governance: 83-103.
• Ünal, Vahdet and Zafer Kızılkaya (2019), “A long and participatory process towards successful fishery management of Gökova Bay, Turkey”, From catastrophe to recovery: Stories of fishery management success: 509-532.
• Voyer, Michelle, Quirk, Genevieve, McIlgorm, Alistair, Azmi, Kamal (2018), “Shades of blue: what do competing interpretations of the Blue Economy mean for oceans governance?”, Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning, 20 (5): 595-616.
• Yavan, Nuri and Mehmet Ragıp Kalelioğlu (2022), “The Blue Economy and its Geographies: The Case of Turkey”, Blue Economy (London: Routledge): 83-100.
• Yümün, Zeki, Erol Kam and Melike Önce (2023), “Marmara Denizi’nde Deniz Salyası (Müsilaj) Oluşma Nedenleri ve Alınması Gereken Önlemler”, Çevre Şehir ve İklim Dergisi, 2 (3): 98-115.