Yıl 2020, Cilt 7 , Sayı 17, Sayfalar 47 - 62 2020-11-15

ALMAN DIŞ POLİTİKASININ AVRUPALILAŞMASI: AB'NİN RUSYA-UKRAYNA ÇATIŞMA DURUMUNUNDA YUMUŞAK GÜCÜ

Yusuf AVAR [1]


Çalışmada Avrupalılaşma ve yumuşak güç kavramları kullanılarak Alman Dış Politikasının Avrupalılaşması, Avrupa Birliği’nin Rusya-Ukrayna çatışmasında yumuşak güç kullanması üzerinden incelenmektedir. Çalışmanın önemi Avrupalılaşma ve yumuşak güç kavramlarını kullanarak Ukrayna krizini açıklamayı ve Almanya’nın önderliğinde AB’nin buna yönelik politikalarını değerlendirmesinden kaynaklanmaktadır. Çalışmanın temel argümanı, Almanya’nın Rusya-Ukrayna krizinde ulusal tercihlerini başarılı bir şekilde Avrupa Birliği seviyesine yüklerken, Avrupa Birliği de çatışma karşısında sert güç unsurları yerine sivil güç ve yumuşak güç birleşim unsurlarını kullanmasında etkili olduğudur. Bu bağlamda, ilk olarak, Avrupalılaşma ve yumuşak güç kavramları detaylı bir şekilde sunulmuştur. Daha sonra, çalışmanın ikinci bölümünde Avrupalılaşma boyutları üzerinden Alman dış politikasının Avrupalılaşması detaylandırılmıştır. Çalışmanın üçüncü bölümünde, Almanya’nın Rusya-Ukrayna krizindeki rolü ve Avrupa Birliği’nin krize karşı yumuşak güç kullanmasındaki etkisi incelenmektedir. Çalışmada Almanya’nın Rusya-Ukrayna krizinde ulusal politikasını başarılı bir şekilde Avrupa Birliği seviyesine yüklediği olduğu ve Avrupa Birliği’nin Rusya’ya karşı kriz boyunca sadece sivil ve yumuşak güç unsurlarını kullandığı sonucuna varılmıştır.
Avrupalılaşma, Yumuşak Güç, Rusya-Ukrayna Krizi, Alman Dış Politikasının Avrupalılaşması
  • Ash, T. G. (1994). “Germany’s Choice.” Foreign Affairs, 73(4): 65-81.
  • Ash, T. G. (2017). Think Global, Act Regional. The Berlin Pulse, Körber Stiftung, German Foreign Policy in Perspective, 26 Aralık 2018 tarihinde https://www.koarber-stiftung.de/fileadmin/user_upload/koarberstiftung/redaktion/berliner-forumassenpolitik/pdf/2017/The-Berlin-Pulse.pdf adresinden erişildi.
  • Averre, D. (2016). “The Ukraine Conflict: Russia’s Challenge to European Security Governance.” Europe-Asia Studies 68(4): 699-725.
  • Batora, J. (2012) “Europeanization of Foreign Policy: Whither Central Europe” Regional and International Relations of Central Europe (Der.), Zlatko Sabic and Petr Drulak, Palgrave Macmillan. 219-238
  • BBC, (2014). Ukraine: Putin Signs Crimea Annexation 25 Şubat 201 tarihinde https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-26686949 adresinden erişildi.
  • BBC, (2015). MH17: 'Russian-made missile parts' at Ukraine crash site. 25 Şubat 2015 tarihinde https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-33865420 adresinden erişildi.
  • Blair, D., (2014) Ukraine crisis: rebels proclaim birth of sovereign People’s Republic. 25 Şubat 2015 tarihinde https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/ukraine/10823960/Ukraine-crisis-rebels-proclaim-birth-of-sovereign-Peoples-Republic.html adresinden erişildi.
  • Bulmer, S. (2007). “Theorising Europeanization” Europeanization New Research Agendas, (Der.) Paolo Graziano and Maarten P. Vink. Palgrave Macmillan Ltd, 46-58
  • Bulmer, S. J., & Radaelli, C. M. (2004). “The Europeanisation of national policy?” (No. p0042). Queens University Belfast.
  • Casey, T. (2006). “Of Power and Plenty? Europe, Soft Power, and ‘Genteel Stagnation’.” Comparative European Politics, 4(4): 399-422.
  • Chaban, N., & O’Loughlin, B. (2018). “The EU’s crisis diplomacy in Ukraine: The matrix of possibilities”. Journal of International Affairs, 71(1.5): 61-68.
  • Club, V. D. (2014). The crisis in Ukraine: Root causes and scenarios for the Future. Valdai Discussion Club Report.
  • Cohen, S. F., & Heuvel, V. K. (2014). War with Russia? Kiev’s Siege of the Donbass. The Nation, Nation Company, L.P.
  • Cowles, M. G., Caporaso, J. A., & Risse-Kappen, T. (Eds.). (2001). Transforming Europe: Europeanization and domestic change. Cornell University Press.
  • Cross, M. A. K. D., & Karolewski, I. P. (2017). “What type of power has the EU exercised in the Ukraine–Russia crisis? A framework of analysis.” JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies, 55(1): 3-19.
  • Crossley-Frolick, K. (2017) “Revisiting and Reimagining the Notion of Responsibility in German Foreign Policy” International Studies Perspectives, (18): 443-464.
  • Daehnhardt, P. (2011) “Germany in the European Union” National and European Foreign Policies Towards Europeanization, (Eds.), Reuben Wong and Christopher Hill, New York: Routledge
  • Daehnhardt, P., & Handl, V. (2018). “Germany’s Eastern Challenge and the Russia– Ukraine Crisis: A New Ostpolitik in the Making?” German Politics, 27(4): 445-459.
  • Diuk, N. (2014). “Euromaidan: Ukraine's self-organizing revolution.” World Affairs, 176(6): 9-16.
  • Dragneva-Lewers, R.,& Wolczuk, K. (2015). Ukraine between the EU and Russia: The integration challenge. Springer. Spiegel, (2014) How the EU Lost Russia Over Ukraine. 21 Mart 2019 tarihinde https://www.spiegel.de/international/europe/war-in-ukraine-a-result-ofmisunderstandings-between-europe-and-russia-a-1004706.html adresinden erişildi.
  • DW (2015). Germany Warns Against Toughter Sanctions on Russia 22 Mart 2019 tarihinde https://www.dw.com/en/germany-warns-against-tougher-sanctions-onrussia/a-18169784 adresinden erişildi.
  • European Council (2014) Timeline-EU Restrictive Measures in Response to the Crisis in Ukraine 11 Nisan 2019 tarihinde https://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/policies/sanctions/ukraine-crisis/historyukraine-crisis/ adresinden erişildi.
  • European Council (2019) EU Relations with Ukraine 11 Nisan 2019 tarihinde https://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/policies/eastern-partnership/ukraine/ adresinden erişildi.
  • European Council (2019) EU restrictive measures in response to the crisis in Ukraine 11 Nisan 2019 tarihinde https://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/policies/sanctions/ukraine-crisis/ adresinden erişildi.
  • European Union Newsroom, EU Sanctions Against Russia over Ukraine Crisis, 23 Mart 2019 tarihinde https://europa.eu/newsroom/highlights/special-coverage/eu-sanctions-againstrussia- over-ukraine-crisis_en adresinden erişildi.
  • Faundes, C. (2016). “An analysis of the crisis in Ukraine, and its three conflicts (21 of november 2013, through 23 of may 2014). Revista de Relaciones Internacionales, Estrategia y Seguridad, 11(2): 137-159.
  • Featherstone, K.,& Radaelli, C. M. (Eds.). (2003). The politics of Europeanization. OUP Oxford.
  • Fisher, J., (2015). Angela Merkel’s Moment of Truth 24 Mart 2019 tarihinde https://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/merkel-greece-ukraine-crisesby-joschka-fischer-201502?barrier=accesspaylog adresinden erişildi.
  • Fix, L. (2018). “The Different Shades of German Power: Germany and EU Foreign Policy during the Ukraine Conflict.” German Politics, 27(4): 498-515. Forsberg, T. (2016). “From Ostpolitik to “frostpolitik”? Merkel, Putin and German foreign policy towards Russia.” International Affairs, 92(1): 21-42.
  • Gardner, H. (2016). “The Russian annexation of Crimea: regional and global ramifications.” European Politics and Society, 17(4): 490-505.
  • Goldstain, J. S. and Pevehouse, J. C. (2014) International Relations, 10th edition, United States: Pearson
  • Goldthau, A.,& Sitter, N. (2015). “Soft power with a hard edge: EU policy tools and energy security.” Review of International Political Economy, 22(5): 941-965.
  • Grytsaienko, O. (2014). The Crisis in Ukraine: An Insider’s View. Russia/NIS Center, Paris.
  • Hamilton, D. (2001) “A More European Germany, a More German Europe” Journal of International Affairs, 45(1): 128-149.
  • Hang N. T. T. (2011) “Europeanization: Simply a Top-Down Process?” Marmara Journal of European Studies, 19(1): 135-151.
  • Harnisch, S. (2001) “Change and Continuity in Post-Unification German Foreign Policy” German Politics, 10 (1): 35-60.
  • Haukkala, H. (2018). Crowdfunded Diplomacy? The EU’s Role in the Triangular Diplomacy Over the Ukraine Crisis. In Triangular Diplomacy among the United States, the European Union, and the Russian Federation (pp. 77-94). Palgrave Macmillan, Cham.
  • Heinsch, R. (2015). “Conflict Classification in Ukraine: The Return of the “Proxy War”?.” International Law Studies, 91(1): 9.
  • Hill, C. & Wong, R. (2011) National and European Foreign Policies: Towards Europeanization London/New York: Routledge Advances in European Politics
  • Horga, I., & Costea, A. M. (2014). The Ukrainian Crisis: Between National Preferences/Interests of EU Member States and the EU Security. Eurolimes. The Security Dimension of European Frontier vs the Legitimacy of Political Priorities of EU and EU Members States National Preferences, 18, 183-199.
  • House of Lords European Union Committee. (2015). The EU and Russia: before and beyond the crisis in Ukraine. 6th report, HL paper, 115.
  • Hyde-Price, A. (2001) “Germany in the European Union: Constructing Normality” Journal of Common Market Studies, 39(4): 689-717.
  • Karabulut, B., & Oğuz, Ş. (2018). Proxy Warfare in Ukraine. Journal of Defense Sciences/Savunma Bilmleri Dergisi, 17(1): 75-100.
  • Karaganov, S., (2014). Europe and Russia: Preventing a New Cold War. 22 Mart 2019 tarihinde https://eng.globalaffairs.ru/number/Europe-and-Russia-Preventing-a-New-Cold-War-16701 adresinden erişildi.
  • Koeth, W. (2016). “Leadership Revised: How Did the Ukraine Crisis and the Annexation of Crimea Affirm Germany‟s Leading Role in EU Foreign Policy?.” Lithuanian Annual Strategic Review, 14(1): 101-116.
  • Kostanyan, H., & Meister, S. (2016). Ukraine, Russia and the EU: Breaking the deadlock in the Minsk process. CEPS Working Document, No: 423.
  • Kuzio, T. (2018). “Russia–Ukraine crisis: The blame game, geopolitics and national identity.” Europe-Asia Studies, 70(3): 462-473.
  • Kwiatkowska-Drożdż, A., & Popławski, K. (2014) The German reaction to the Russian- Ukrainian conflict–shock and disbelief. Center for Eastern Studies, Number 132,
  • Lundin, L. E. (2014). “The Ukraine Crisis as a Challenge to Human Security in Europe.” Security and Human Rights, 25(3): 277-286.
  • Maiorova, A. (2017). Donbas in Flames: Guide to the Conflict Zone. Security environment research center, Prometheus, Canada.
  • Mazepus, H., Dimitrova, A., Toshkov, D., Chulitskaya, T., & Frear M., (2018) “Getting the Message Across: How can the EU Bolster its Soft Power in the Eastern Neighbourhood” EU-STRAT Policy Brief Series No. 3, October 2018, EU-STRAT
  • McDougal, T. (2015). A New Imperialism: Evaluating Russia's Acquisition of Crimea in the Context of National and International Law. BYU L. Rev., 1847.
  • Mearsheimer, J. J. (2014). “Why the Ukraine crisis is the West's fault: the liberal delusions that provoked Putin.” Foreign Affairs, 93(5): 77-84. Meister, S. (2014). Reframing Germany's Russia Policy: An Opportunity for the EU (p. 9).European Council on Foreign Relations (ECFR).
  • Miskimmon, A. (2002) “Europeanisation and German Foreign and Security Policy-the Case of Stability Pact for South-Eastern Europe” Institute for German Studies European Research Institute, University of Birmingham, 22 Mart 2019 tarihinde http://www.lse.ac.uk/internationalrelations/ assets/documents/efpu/conference-2002/paper- Miskimmon.pdf?from_serp=1 adresinden erişildi.
  • Miskimmon, A., & Paterson, W. E. (2006). Adapting to Europe? German Foreign Policy, Domestic Constraints, and the Limitations of Europeanization since Unification. In Germany’s uncertain power (pp. 29-46). Palgrave Macmillan, London.
  • Maull (eds), Germany’s Uncertain Power London: Palgrave Macmillan
  • Mölder, H., (2016). A Comperative Analysis of the Development of Security Narratives in Ukraine and Russia. Russian Information Campaign Against the Ukrainian State and Defence Forces. Riga and Tartu: NATO STRATCOM Centre of Excellence and Estonian National Defence College
  • Nitoiu, C. (2016). “Towards conflict or cooperation? The Ukraine crisis and EU-Russia relations.” Southeast European and Black Sea Studies, 16(3): 375-390.
  • Nye, J. (1990) “Soft Power” Foreign Policy, No 80, Twentieth Anniversary, Washingtonpost.Newsweek Interactive (LLC), published at JSTOR, www.jstor.org/stable/1148580, 153-171
  • Nye, J. (2004) Soft Power: The Means to Success in World Politics, New York: Public Affairs Olsen, J. P. (2002) “The Many Faces of Europeanization” Journal of Common Market Studies, 40(5): 921-952.
  • Otero-Iglasias, M. (2015) “Germany and Political Union in Europe: Nothing Moves Without France” Paper Presented at the 14th Biennial Conference of the European Union Studies Association (EUSA), Boston, 5-7 March 2015, 20 Şubat tarihinde http://aei.pitt.edu/79456/1/Otero-Iglesias.pdf adresinden erişildi.
  • Patalakh, A. (2017) “EU’s Soft Power in the Eastern Neighbourhood and the Western Balkans in the Context of the Crisis” Baltic Journal of European Studies, 7(2): 148-167.
  • Paterson, W. E. (2010). Does Germany still have a European vocation?. German Politics, 19(1): 41-52.
  • Paterson, W. E. (2011) “The Reluctant Hegemon? Germany Moves Centre Stage in the European Union” Journal of Common Market Studies, 49: 57-75.
  • Pond, E., (2015). Putin’s Long Away. New Statesmen
  • Quintana, V. (2009) “Germany: A look at One EU Member State’s Path to Europeanization” Miam,-Florida European Union Centre of Excellence, European Union Miami Analyses, Policy Paper, 6 (6), 2009, 21 Aralık 2018 tarihinde http://aei.pitt.edu/15023/1/QuintanaEUMA09RevEdi.pdf adresinden erişildi.
  • Raţiu, A., & Munteanu, A. (2018). “Hybrid warfare and the Russian Federation informational strategy to influence civilian population in Ukraine.” Land forces academy review, 23(3): 192-200.
  • Rehn, O. (2007). The EU's soft power and the changing face of world politics. A speech delivered at Euroklubi. Helsinki, 20.
  • Rothman, S. B. (2011) “Revising the Soft Power Concept: Where are the Means and Mechanisms of Soft Power?” Journal of Political Power, 4(1): 49-64.
  • Rutland, P. (2015). An unnecessary war: the geopolitical roots of the Ukraine crisis. Ukraine and Russia: People, politics, propaganda and perspectives, 129.
  • Sauer, T. (2017). “The origins of the Ukraine crisis and the need for collective security between Russia and the West.” Global Policy, 8(1): 82-91.
  • Shuster, S., (2014) Putin’s Man in Crimea is Ukraine’s Worst Nightmare, 25 Şubat 2019 tarihinde http://time.com/19097/putin-crimea-russia-ukraineaksyonov/ adresinden erişildi.
  • Siddi, M. (2016). “German foreign policy towards Russia in the aftermath of the Ukraine crisis: A new Ostpolitik?.” Europe-Asia Studies, 68(4): 665-677.
  • Sjursen, H., & Rosén, G. (2017). “Arguing sanctions. On the EU's response to the crisis in Ukraine.” JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies, 55(1): 20-36.
  • Speck, U. (2015). German power and the Ukraine conflict. Carnegie Europe, 26.
  • Strasheim, J. (2016). “Power-sharing, commitment problems, and armed conflict in Ukraine.” Civil wars, 18(1): 25-44.
  • Tonra, B. (1999). “The Europeanisation of Irish foreign affairs.” Irish Studies in International Affairs, 10: 149-165.
  • Trenin, D. (2014). The Ukraine crisis and the resumption of great-power rivalry. Washington DC: Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.
  • Turkina, E. (2015). “Russia‐Ukraine Crisis: Value‐Based and Generational Perspective.” Studies in Ethnicity and Nationalism, 15(1): 185-197.
  • United Nations (2019) Briefing Security Council on Ukraine, Under-Secretary-General Expresses Concern over Language Law, Ceasefire Violations,SC/13884, 16 Haziran 2019 tarihinde https://www.un.org/press/en/2019/sc13884.doc.htm adresinden erişildi.
  • Vasilevskytė, S. (2013) “Discussing Soft Power Theory After Nye: The Case of Geun Lee‟s Theoretical Approach” Regioninès Studijos, 7, 145-157. 28 Kasım 2018 tarihinde https://eltalpykla.vdu.lt/bitstream/handle/1/32333/ISSN2029-2074_2013_V_7.PG_145_157.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y adresinden erişildi.
  • Vilson, M. (2015). “The Foreign Policy of the Baltic States and the Ukrainian Crisis: A Case of Europeanization?.” New Perspectives, 23(2): 49-76.
  • Vrsanska, I., & Kavicky, V. (2016).”The Conflict in Eastern Ukraine-The New Geopolitical Source of Terrorism.” Int. J. Hum. Soc. Sci, 6: 95-103.
  • Wade, R. H. (2015). “Reinterpreting the Ukraine conflict: The drive for ethnic subordination and existential enemies.” Challenge, 58(4), 361-371.
  • Wagner, P. M., (2017) Peacekeepers in Donbas. JFQ 91, 4th Quarter 19 Şubat 2019 tarihinde https://ndupress.ndu.edu/Portals/68/Documents/jfq/jfq-91/jfq-91_37- 39_Wagner.pdf adresinden erişildi.
  • Wagner, W. (2005) “From Vanguard to Laggard: Germany in European Security and Defence Policy” German Politics, 14(4): 455-469.
  • Webber, D. (2001) “Introduction: German European and Foreign Policy Before and After Unification” German Politics, 10 (1): 1-18.
  • Weinstein, K. R. (2017) “How Trump Can Make Europe Great Again” The Berlin Pulse, Körber Stiftung, German Foreign Policy in Perspective, 20 Aralık 2018 tarihinde https://www.koarber-stiftung.de/fileadmin/user_upload/koarberstiftung/ redaktion/berliner-forum-assenpolitik/pdf/2017/The-Berlin-Pulse.pdf adresinden erişildi.
  • Westerlund, F.,& Norberg, J. (2016). “Military means for non-military measures: The Russian approach to the use of armed force as seen in Ukraine.” The Journal of Slavic Military Studies, 29(4): 576-601.
  • Wilson, A. (2014). Ukraine crisis: What it means for the West. Yale University Press.
  • Wilson, G. (2015). “Crimea: Some Observations on Secession and Intervention in Partial Response to Müllerson and Tolstykh.” Chinese Journal of International Law, 14(1): 217-223.
  • Wydra, D. (2014). “What Went Wrong with Crimean Autonomy?” Security and Human Rights, 25(3): 312-327.
  • Yoder, J. A. (2015). “From Amity to Enmity: German-Russian Relations in the Post Cold War Period.” German Politics and Society, 33(3): 49-69.
  • Zaborowski, M. (2002) “Europeanisation as a Consensus Building Process: The Case of Polish-German Relations” Thesis for discussion at a workshop on Europeanisation and Foreign Policy held at the London School of Economics on 5th June 2002
  • Zerkavis, P. A. (2004) “The Europeanization of the Political System and the Public Administration in Germany” Επιστήμη και Κοινωνία: Επιθεώρηση Πολιτικής και Ηθικής Θεωρίας, 13: 105-134.
Birincil Dil tr
Konular Sosyal
Bölüm Makale
Yazarlar

Orcid: 0000-0001-8507-9579
Yazar: Yusuf AVAR (Sorumlu Yazar)
Kurum: Kilis 7 Aralık Üniversitesi
Ülke: Turkey


Tarihler

Yayımlanma Tarihi : 15 Kasım 2020

Bibtex @araştırma makalesi { assam788587, journal = {ASSAM Uluslararası Hakemli Dergi}, issn = {2148-5879}, address = {Yakuplu Mahallesi Hürriyet Bulvarı Newport Sitesi No: 155 1. Blok Kat 7 D.55 Beylikdüzü İstanbul}, publisher = {Adaleti Savunanlar Stratejik Araştırmalar Merkezi Derneği}, year = {2020}, volume = {7}, pages = {47 - 62}, doi = {}, title = {ALMAN DIŞ POLİTİKASININ AVRUPALILAŞMASI: AB'NİN RUSYA-UKRAYNA ÇATIŞMA DURUMUNUNDA YUMUŞAK GÜCÜ}, key = {cite}, author = {Avar, Yusuf} }
APA Avar, Y . (2020). ALMAN DIŞ POLİTİKASININ AVRUPALILAŞMASI: AB'NİN RUSYA-UKRAYNA ÇATIŞMA DURUMUNUNDA YUMUŞAK GÜCÜ . ASSAM Uluslararası Hakemli Dergi , 7 (17) , 47-62 . Retrieved from https://dergipark.org.tr/tr/pub/assam/issue/57474/788587
MLA Avar, Y . "ALMAN DIŞ POLİTİKASININ AVRUPALILAŞMASI: AB'NİN RUSYA-UKRAYNA ÇATIŞMA DURUMUNUNDA YUMUŞAK GÜCÜ" . ASSAM Uluslararası Hakemli Dergi 7 (2020 ): 47-62 <https://dergipark.org.tr/tr/pub/assam/issue/57474/788587>
Chicago Avar, Y . "ALMAN DIŞ POLİTİKASININ AVRUPALILAŞMASI: AB'NİN RUSYA-UKRAYNA ÇATIŞMA DURUMUNUNDA YUMUŞAK GÜCÜ". ASSAM Uluslararası Hakemli Dergi 7 (2020 ): 47-62
RIS TY - JOUR T1 - ALMAN DIŞ POLİTİKASININ AVRUPALILAŞMASI: AB'NİN RUSYA-UKRAYNA ÇATIŞMA DURUMUNUNDA YUMUŞAK GÜCÜ AU - Yusuf Avar Y1 - 2020 PY - 2020 N1 - DO - T2 - ASSAM Uluslararası Hakemli Dergi JF - Journal JO - JOR SP - 47 EP - 62 VL - 7 IS - 17 SN - 2148-5879- M3 - UR - Y2 - 2020 ER -
EndNote %0 ASSAM Uluslararası Hakemli Dergi ALMAN DIŞ POLİTİKASININ AVRUPALILAŞMASI: AB'NİN RUSYA-UKRAYNA ÇATIŞMA DURUMUNUNDA YUMUŞAK GÜCÜ %A Yusuf Avar %T ALMAN DIŞ POLİTİKASININ AVRUPALILAŞMASI: AB'NİN RUSYA-UKRAYNA ÇATIŞMA DURUMUNUNDA YUMUŞAK GÜCÜ %D 2020 %J ASSAM Uluslararası Hakemli Dergi %P 2148-5879- %V 7 %N 17 %R %U
ISNAD Avar, Yusuf . "ALMAN DIŞ POLİTİKASININ AVRUPALILAŞMASI: AB'NİN RUSYA-UKRAYNA ÇATIŞMA DURUMUNUNDA YUMUŞAK GÜCÜ". ASSAM Uluslararası Hakemli Dergi 7 / 17 (Kasım 2020): 47-62 .
AMA Avar Y . ALMAN DIŞ POLİTİKASININ AVRUPALILAŞMASI: AB'NİN RUSYA-UKRAYNA ÇATIŞMA DURUMUNUNDA YUMUŞAK GÜCÜ. ASSAM-UHAD. 2020; 7(17): 47-62.
Vancouver Avar Y . ALMAN DIŞ POLİTİKASININ AVRUPALILAŞMASI: AB'NİN RUSYA-UKRAYNA ÇATIŞMA DURUMUNUNDA YUMUŞAK GÜCÜ. ASSAM Uluslararası Hakemli Dergi. 2020; 7(17): 47-62.
IEEE Y. Avar , "ALMAN DIŞ POLİTİKASININ AVRUPALILAŞMASI: AB'NİN RUSYA-UKRAYNA ÇATIŞMA DURUMUNUNDA YUMUŞAK GÜCÜ", ASSAM Uluslararası Hakemli Dergi, c. 7, sayı. 17, ss. 47-62, Kas. 2020