An evaluation of the efficiency of Turkic cooperation in the United Nations General Assembly

Öz

This study investigates the dynamics of voting cohesion in the United Nations General Assembly (UNGA) by conducting a comparative analysis of the European Union (EU), the Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS), and the Organization of Turkic States (OTS). The research aims to assess the external voting cohesion of OTS member states in relation to the EU and CIS, utilizing the benchmark of collective voting in the UNGA as an indicator. The historical context underscores the significance of regional organizations in fostering collaboration among member countries, particularly in the realms of economics, security, and socioeconomic growth. The focus of this study on the OTS arises from the unique geopolitical and historical circumstances of Turkic-speaking nations dispersed globally. The methodology employs a comprehensive analysis of UNGA roll-call votes, utilizing data spanning from 1992 to 2019. The study employs the voting cohesion measurement proposed by Hosli et al. (2010), incorporating a scoring system to quantify cohesion. Results indicate that, compared to the CIS, the OTS demonstrates slightly higher voting cohesion, with a discernible increasing trend over the years. The EU, exhibiting the highest level of cohesion, provides a reference point for potential advancements in the OTS's institutional structures and collaborative efforts. The findings suggest that the OTS has the potential to achieve EU-level cohesion with continued improvements in institutional frameworks and enhanced cooperation among member states. In conclusion, this study contributes to the understanding of international cooperation dynamics, emphasizing the evolving role of regional organizations in shaping voting behaviour at the global stage. The findings underscore the potential for increased cohesion within the OTS, positioning it as a significant player in international diplomacy.

Anahtar Kelimeler

• United Nations General Assembly
• Organization of Turkic States
• Voting Cohesion

Kaynakça

1. Hosli, M. O., Evelyn van K., M. Frits and Tennis, K. (2010). Voting Cohesion in the United Nations General Assembly: The Case of the European Union. Paper presented at the ECPR Fifth Pan- European Conference. Porto, Portugal.
2. Ismayilov, N.I. (2022). Library Resources: Allocation and Usage Problems (Comparative Analysis of the World and Regional Practice). Ukraine, Dnipropetrovsk: Scientific and Theoretical Almanac Grani, 1 (26), 38-43.
3. Ismayilov, N.I. Bayramova, İ. (2022). Methodology of Research and Study of Document Flow in the Field of Tourism (Based on Experience from Local Libraries).- Granі Journal, 25 (3), 70-76.
4. Ismayilov, N.I. Khalafova, S. A. (2022). General Characteristics of Local Lore Documental Network Resources of the Libraries of Azerbaijan (Based on library collection). Technium Social Sciences Journal, 33 (1), 628-637.
5. Ismayilov, N.I. Mahammadli, D., Khudiyeva, V. (2022). Methods and Means of Information Search in the Digital Environment. Granі Journal, 25 (5), 31-34.
6. Ismayilov, N.I., Aliyeva, G. (2023). Creation and Formation of Document Flow in the Field of Library-Bibliography (on the Basis of Tazkiras). Granі Journal, 26 ( 3), 165-170.
7. Ismayilov, N.I., Guliyev, O. (2022). Creation and formation of information resources for children. Technium Social Sciences , 36, 735-742.
8. Ismayilov, N.I., Khalafova S.A. (2023). The Modern Situation of Using Bibliometric Methods in Library-Information Activity in the Republic of Azerbaijan. Granі Journal, 26 (2), 106-110.

9. Ismayilov, N.I., Khudiyeva, V. (2022). Assessment of digital knowledge and research skills and overview of on going work at the national level, forecasting. Concepts of digitization. Technium Social Sciences , 35, 593-600.
10. Ismayilov, N.I., Mahammadli, D., Gasimli, H. (2023). Organization, Development and Current Situation of the Document Flow on Tourism in the Regions (Based on the Example of the Shaki-Zagatala Economic Region. Granі Journal, 26 ( 2), 122-127.
11. Ismayilov, N.I., Mammadov, A. (2023). National Libraries: Typology, Main Functions and Modern Directions of Development. Granі Journal, 26 (1), 15-20.
12. Ismayilov, N.I., Sadigova, S. (2022). Synergetic foundations of the methodology of modern bibliography. Granі Journal, 26 (5), 45-51.
13. Voeten, E., Strezhnev, A., Bailey, M. (2009). United Nations General Assembly Voting Data. https://doi.org/10.7910/DVN/LEJUQZ, Harvard Dataverse, V31.
14. Іsmayilov N.I, Khalafova S.A. (2022). The role of digital marketing in the management of library information resources. АКАДЕМІЧНИЙ ОГЛЯД, 2 (57), 194-202.