Parti ve Hareket Arasında: Amerika Demokratik Sosyalistleri ve Momentum

Öz

Sosyal hareketler ve siyasi partiler, siyasi alanın şekillenmesinde kilit roller oynar. Yerleşik merkez-sol partiler içinde, parti içi fraksiyonlarla bağımsız hareketler arasındaki sınırları bulanıklaştıran örgütlenmeler ortaya çıkmaktadır. Bu makale, ABD Demokrat Partisi bağlamında Democratic Socialists of America (DSA) ile Birleşik Krallık İşçi Partisi içindeki Momentum’u inceler. Tarihsel emsalleri bulunsa da, DSA ve Momentum son dönem siyasi değişimler, dijital seferberlik olanakları ve resmî parti yapılarıyla taban aktivizmi arasında gezinme biçimleri nedeniyle özgün nitelikler sergiler. Makale, bu iki örgütün rollerini, yapılarını ve stratejilerini ortaya koymayı; ayrıca sosyalizmin tarihsel olarak ayrıksı bir konuma sahip olduğu iki Anglo- Sakson ülkede (ABD ve Birleşik Krallık) sol siyaset açısından taşıdıkları önemi incelemeyi amaçlar. Örgütsel belgeler, ikincil akademik literatür ve medya incelemesine dayalı niteliksel karşılaştırmalı metodolojiyle, bu grupların taban enerjisini koruyarak partileri üzerinde nasıl etki kurmaya çalıştıkları araştırılır. Karşılaştırmalı analiz, önemli zorluklarla karşı karşıya olsalar da bu hibrit örgütlenmelerin, kurumsal katılım ile hareket temelli seferberlik arasındaki gerilimleri yansıtarak çağdaş Batı sol siyasetinde kilit bir dinamiği temsil ettiğini göstermektedir; zira geleneksel parti modelleri baskı altındadır

Anahtar Kelimeler

• Momentum
• DSA
• Hizipler
• Toplumsal hareketler
• Siyasi partiler

Between Party and Movement: Democratic Socialists of America and Momentum

Öz

Social movements and political parties play pivotal roles in shaping political landscapes. Within established center-left parties, organizations often emerge that blur the lines between internal factions and independent movements. This article examines two prominent contemporary examples: the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA) within the context of the US Democratic Party, and Momentum within the UK Labour Party. While such formations have historical precedents, DSA and Momentum exhibit distinct characteristics shaped by recent political shifts, digital mobilization, and their navigation of the space between formalized party structures and grassroots activism. This article aims to characterize the roles, structures, and strategies of these two organizations and analyze the implications they hold for left-wing politics within two Anglo-Saxon countries (USA and UK) where the concept of socialism has historically been marginalized. Adopting a qualitative comparative methodology drawing on organizational documents, secondary academic literature, and media analysis, the research explores how these groups attempt to influence their respective parties while maintaining grassroots energy. The comparative analysis suggests that while facing significant challenges, these hybrid organizations represent a key dynamic in contemporary Western left-wing politics, reflecting tensions between institutional engagement and movement-based mobilization in an era where traditional party models are under pressure.

Anahtar Kelimeler

• Momentum
• DSA
• factions
• social movements
• political parties

Kaynakça

1. Kaynakça Ackerman S. (2016). ‘A Blueprint for a New Party’. Jacobin Available at: https://jacobin.com/ 2016/11/bernie-sanders-democratic-labor-party-ackerman (accessed 6 June 2024)
2. Ackerman S. (2018). ‘A New Party of a New Type’. Jacobin Available at: https://jacobin.com/2018/07 /electoral-rules-third-party-ballot-line-ocasio-cortez-dsa , (accessed 8 June 2024)
3. Bale T. and Webb P. and Poletti M. (2020). Footsoldiers: Political Party Membership in the 21st Century. Routledge.
4. Boucek F (2009) Rethinking factionalism: Typologies, intra-party dynamics and three faces of factionalism. Party Politics 15 (4): 455-485. https://doi.org/10.1177/1354068809334553
5. Calvo K (2020) The long shadow of activism: Podemos and the difficult choices of movement-parties. In: Cristina FF and Ramon AF (eds) Routledge handbook contemporary European social movements: Protest in turbulent times. Routledge, pp. 372-386.
6. Ceron A (2019) Leaders, factions and the game of intra-party politics. Routledge.
7. Chienkgul P (2021) Labour under Corbyn: Constraints on radical politics in the UK. Palgrave Macmillan.
8. Clemens J & Globerman S (2023) New poll reveals 50% of Canadians 18-24 favour socialism, but fewer Canadians willing to pay for it. The Fraser Institute. Available at:https://www.fraserinstitute.org/studies/perspectives-capitalism-and-socialism-polling-results-canada-united-states-australia-and (Accessed 9 August 2025).

9. Crines AS (2015) Reforming Labour: The leadership of Jeremy Corbyn. Political Insight 6 (3): 4-7. https://doi.org/10.1111/2041-9066.12105
10. Crouch C (2009) Privitised Keynesianism: An unacknowledged policy regime. The British Journal of Politics and International Relations 11 (3): 382-399. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-856X.2009.00377.x
11. Dai A (2025) State of DSA Part One: Welcome to DSA. Democratic Left. Available at: https://democraticleft.dsausa.org/2025/02/27/state-of-dsa-part-one-welcome-to-dsa/ (accessed 8 August 2025)
12. Day M (2018) DSA chapters go for victories. Democratic Left. 46 (1): 7-9.
13. De BE and Lorenzo V (2020) Platform party between digital activism and hyper-leadership: The reshaping of the public sphere. Media and Communication 8 (4): 16-27. https://doi.org/10.17645/mac.v8i4.3230
14. Della PD and Mario D (2006) Social movements: An introduction (2nd ed.). Blackwell Publishing.
15. Democratic Socialists of America (2016a) Dump the Racist Trump; Continue the Political Revolution Down-Ballot; Build Multiracial Coalitions and Socialist Organization for Long-term Change. Democratic Socialists of America. Available at: https://www.dsausa.org/statements/ election2016/ (accessed 10 June 2203)
16. Democratic Socialists of America (2016b) We fight for socialism over barbarism. National Political Committee. Available at: www.dsausa.org/statements/we_fight_for_socialism_over_ barbarism (accessed 1 June 2023).
17. Democratic Socialists of America (2017a) 15 DSA members elected! 2017 Election. Democratic Socialists of America. Available at: www.dsausa.org/democratic-left/15_dsa_members_ elected (accessed 11 June 2023).
18. Democratic Socialists of America (2017b) DSA Priorities Resolution 2017. Democratic Socialists of America. Available at: https://www.dsausa.org/blog/dsa_priorities_resolution_2017/ (accessed 12 June 2023) Emre Önkibar – Taşkın Toprak İpek ⏺ Between Party and Movement: Democratic Socialists of America and Momentum ⏺ 19
19. Democratic Socialists of America (2018) NPC Statement on 2018 Elections. Democratic Socialists of America. Available at: https://www.dsausa.org/statements/npc-statement-on-2018-elections/ (accessed 14 June 2023)
20. Democratic Socialists of America (2019) DSA Resolutions for the 2019 Convention. Democratic Socialists of America. Available at: https://www.dsausa.org/files/2019/06/2019-Resolutions-Approved.pdf (accessed 13 June 2023)
21. Democratic Socialists of America (2020a) Beyond Bernie: A statement from the dsa national political committee. Democratic Socialists of America. Available at: www.dsausa.org/ statements/beyond-bernie-a-statement-from-the-dsa-national-political-committee (accessed 4 June 2023).
22. Democratic Socialists of America (2020b) Demand Democracy: A Statement from the National Political Committee. Democratic Socialists of America. Available at: https://www.dsausa.org/statements/demand-democracy-a-statement-from-the-national-political-committee/ (accessed 6 June 2023)
23. Democratic Socialists of America (2021a) DSA stands with Palestinians: From Sheikh Jarrah to Gaza and beyond. Democratic Socialists of America. Available at: www.dsausa.org/statements/ dsa-stands-with-palestinians-from-sheikh-jarrah-to-gaza-and-beyond (accessed 4 June 2023).
24. Democratic Socialists of America (2021b) 2021 DSA Membership Survey Report. Democratic Socialists of America Growth and Development Committee. Available at: https://www.dsanorthstar.org/uploads/1/1/8/2/118222942/2021_member_survey_gdc_report.pdf (accessed 8 June 2023).
25. Democratic Socialists of America (2021c) 2021 DSA Convention Resolutions. Democratic Socialists of America. Available at: https://convention2021.dsausa.org/2021-dsa-convention-resolutions/ (accessed 14 June 2023)
26. Democratic Socialists of America (2022) Stand with Railworkers, Build Workers Power. Democratic Socialists of America. Available at: https://www.dsausa.org/statements/stand-with-railworkers-build-workers-power/ (accessed 8 June 2023)
27. Democratic Socialists of America (n.d.) National Electoral Committee Report to the 2021 DSA National Convention. Democratic Socialists of America. Available at: https://convention2021.dsausa.org/files/sites/23/2021/07/2021-National-Electoral-Committee-Report.pdf (accessed 2 June 2023).
28. Democratic Socialists of America (n.d.) DSA Constitution & Bylaws. Democratic Socialists of America. Available at: https://www.dsausa.org/about-us/constitution/ (accessed 13 June 2023)
29. Democratic Socialists of America International Committee (n.d.) DSA Venezuela Solidarity. DSA International Committee. Available at: https://international.dsausa.org/venezuela-solidarity/ (accessed 9 June 2023)
30. Deseriis M (2020) Two variants of the digital party: The platform party and the networked party. Partecipazione Conflitto 13 (1): 896-917. https://doi.org/10.1285/i20356609v13i1p896
31. Dornbush A and Sam L (2018) Building electoral power. Democratic Left 46 (1): 3-4.
32. Dorrien G (2021) American democratic socialism: History, politics, religion, and theory. Yale University Press. Dreyer J and Philip L (2021) Who’s who in dsa: A guide to dsa caucuses. Reform and Revolution. Available at: https://reformandrevolution.org/2021/09/08/whos-who-in-dsa-a-guide-to-dsa-caucuses/ (accessed 2 June 2023).
33. Duverger M (1954) Political parties: Their organization and activity in the modern state. Translated by Barbara North and Robert North. Methuen. Frase P and Bhaskar S (2012d) The welfare state of America. Democratic Socialists of America. Available at: www.dsaUS.org/strategy/the_welfare_state_of_america (accessed 5 June 2023).
34. Fraser N (2017) From Progressive Neoliberalism to Trump—and Beyond. American Affairs 1(4): 46-64.
35. From A (2013) The New Democrats and the Return to Power. Palgrave Macmillan. Gamble A (2010) New labor and political change. Parliamentary Affairs 63 (4): 639-652. https://doi.org/10.1093/pa/gsq031
36. Gerbaudo P (2019a) The digital party: Political organisation and online democracy. Pluto.
37. Gerbaudo P (2019b) The platform party: The transformation of political organisation in the era of big data. In: Chandler D and Fuchs C (eds) Digital objects, digital subjects: Interdisciplinary perspectives on capitalism, labour and politics in the age of big data. University of Westminster Press, pp. 187-198.
38. Gilens M and Page BI (2014) Testing Theories of American Politics: Elites, Interest Groups, and Average Citizens. Perspectives on Politics, 12(3), 564-581.
39. Hay C (2007) What’s in a name? New labor’s putative Keynesianism. British Journal of Political Science 37 (1): 187-192. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0007123407000099
40. History Achieves of Momentum [HAM] (n.d.) Our history. Momentum. Available at: https://peoplesmomentum.com/category/history/ (accessed 18 May 2023).
41. Howe I (1985) Socialism and America. Harcourt Brace Jovanovich.
42. Huckshorn R (1984) Political parties in America. Monterey: Brooks.
43. Hudson S (2018) Could this be our momentum moment in Germany? The Guardian. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/jan/26/momentum-moment-germany-nogroko-grassroots-initiative (accessed 18 May 2023).
44. Hutter S and Hanspeter K and Jasmine L (2018) Social movements in interaction with political movements. In: Snow DA, Soule SA, Kriesi H, and Holly J. McCammon HJ (eds) The wiley blackwell companion to social movements (2nd Ed.). Blackwell Publishing, pp. 322-337.
45. Isserman M. (2000). The Other American: The Life of Michael Harrington. PublicAffairs.
46. Jian H (2022) Democratic socialists of America provide cover for uaw and democrats as they move to shut down university of California strike. World Socialist Web Site. Available at: www.wsws.org/en/articles/2022/12/12/uoup-d12.html (accessed 19 May 2023)
47. Jones T (1996) Remaking the labor party: From Gaitskell to Blair. Routledge.
48. Judis JB (2016) The Populist Explosion: How The Great Recession Transformed American and European Politics. Columbia Global Reports.
49. Judis JB (2020) The Socialist Awakening: What’s Different Now About the Left. Columbia Global Reports.
50. Kaiser A (2022) Starbucks, socialists, and solidarity. Democratic Left 50 (2): 2. Kaderbek JP (2018) Democratic Socialist Labor Commission. Democratic Socialists of America. Available at: https://www.dsausa.org/blog/democratic-socialist-labor-commission/ (accessed 11 June 2023)
51. Emre Önkibar – Taşkın Toprak İpek ⏺ Between Party and Movement: Democratic Socialists of America and Momentum ⏺ 21
52. Katznelson I (1978) Considerations on social democracy in the United States. Comparative Politics 11 (1): 77–99. https://doi.org/10.2307/421791
53. Kitschelt H (2005) Movement parties. In: Katz RS and Crotty WJ (eds) Handbook of party politics. Sage: pp. 278-290.
54. Klug A and Emma R and James S (2016) Momentum: A new kind of politics. Renewal 24 (2): 36-44.
55. Koslowski J (2022) The amazon labor union is a problem for democrats — so they’re trying to co-opt it. Left Voice. Available at: www.leftvoice.org/the-amazon-labor-union-is-a-problem-for-democrats-so-theyre-trying-to-co-opt-it (accessed 19 May 2023)
56. Langman L (2013) Occupy: A new new social movement. Current Sociology 4 (61): 510-524. https://doi.org/10.1177/0011392113479749
57. Lawrence W (2024). ‘Conflict Could Upend DSA’s Big Tent—or Steady It’. Convergence Magazine. Available at : https://convergencemag.com/articles/conflict-could-upend-dsas-big-tent-or-steady-it/ (accessed 28 June 2023)
58. Luxemburg R (2013) Organizational questions of the Russian social democracy (Part 1). Marxist.org. Available at: www.marxists.org/archive/luxemburg/1904/questions-rsd/ch01.htm (accessed 19 May 2023)
59. Mann TE and Corrado A (2014) Party Polarization and Campaign Finance. Center for Effective Public Management at Brookings. Available at: https://www.brookings.edu/wp-content/uploads/ 2016/06/Mann-and-Corrad_Party-Polarization-and-Campaign-Finance.pdf (accessed 16 July 2023)
60. Mason R (2016) Pro-Corbyn group momentum backs remain campaign. The Guardian. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2016/may/24/pro-corbyn-group-momentum-backs-remain-campaign (accessed 24 May 2023)
61. McAdam D and Sidney T and Charles T (2001) Dynamics of contention. Cambridge University Press.
62. McCarthy JD and Mayer NZ (1977) Resource mobilization and social movements: A partial theory. American Journal of Sociology 82 (6): 1212-1241. https://doi.org/10.1086/226464
63. McIntosh D (2018) DSA chapters support labor. Democratic Left 46 (2): 13-14.
64. Meyerson H (2019) What the socialists just did—and why. American Prospect. Available at: https://prospect.org/article/what-socialists-just-did-and-why (accessed 19 May 2023).
65. Momentum (n.d.) Constitution. Available at: https://peoplesmomentum.com/constitution/ (accessed 23 May 2023)
66. Momentum (2020a) The Organiser. Momentum. Available at: https://peoplesmomentum.com/ organiser/october-1st-2020/ (accessed 22 May 2023).
67. Momentum (2020b) The Organiser. Momentum. Available at: https://peoplesmomentum.com/ organiser/theorganiser2/ (accessed 22 May 2023).
68. Momentum (2021a) The Organiser. Momentum. Available at: https://peoplesmomentum.com/ organiser/the-organiser-issue-4/ (accessed 23 May 2023).
69. Momentum (2021b) The Organiser. Momentum. Available at: https://peoplesmomentum.com/ uncategorized/the-organiser-issue-5/ (accessed 23 May 2023).
70. Momentum (2021c) The Organiser. Momentum. Available at: https://peoplesmomentum.com/ uncategorized/the-organiser-issue-6/ (accessed 23 May 2023).
71. Momentum (2021d) The Organiser. Momentum. Available at: https://peoplesmomentum.com/ uncategorized/the-organiser-issue-7/ (accessed 19 May 2023)
72. Momentum (2021e) The Organiser. Momentum. Available at: https://peoplesmomentum.com/ uncategorized/the-organiser-issue-8/ (accessed 21 May 2023)
73. Momentum. (2021f) The Organiser. Momentum. Available at: https://peoplesmomentum.com/ uncategorized/the-organiser-issue-9/ (accessed 21 May 2023).
74. Momentum (2021g) The Organiser. Momentum. Available at: https://peoplesmomentum.com/u ncategorized/the-organiser-issue-10/ (accessed 21 May 2023).
75. Momentum (2021h) The Organiser. Momentum. Available at: https://peoplesmomentum.com/ uncategorized/the-organiser-issue-11/ (accessed 21 May 2023).
76. Momentum (2022a) The Organiser. Momentum. Available at: https://peoplesmomentum.com/ uncategorized/the-organiser-issue-12/ (accessed 23 May 2023).
77. Momentum (2022b) The Organiser. Momentum. Available at: https://peoplesmomentum.com/ organiser/the-organiser-issue-13/ (accessed 23 May 2023).
78. Momentum (2022c) The Organiser. Momentum. Available at: https://peoplesmomentum.com/ organiser/the-organiser-issue-14/ (accessed 23 May 2023).
79. Momentum (n.d.) About. Momentum. Available at: https://peoplesmomentum.com/about/ (accessed 12 May 2023).
80. Momentum (2020) The Organiser. Momentum. Available at: https://peoplesmomentum.com/ organiser/the-organiser-3/ (accessed 24 May 2023).
81. Mosca L (2020) The five star movement’s progressive detachment from social movements. In: Flesher C and Feenstra RA (eds) Routledge handbook contemporary European social movements: Protest in turbulent times, Routledge: pp. 357-371.
82. Muldoon, J. and Rye, D. (2020) Conceptualising Party-Driven Movements. The British Journal of Politics and International Relations 22 (3). pp 485-504
83. Oltermann P (2018) SPD activists seek help of momentum to dash German coalition deal. The Guardian. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/jan/24/germany-spd-social-democratic-party-coalition-deal-momentum-cdu (accessed 26 May 2023).
84. Pew Research Center (2022) Modest declines in positive views of ‘socialism’ and ‘capitalism’ in U.S. The Pew Research Center. Available at: https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2022/09/ 19/modest-declines-in-positive-views-of-socialism-and-capitalism-in-u-s/ (accessed 9 August 2025).
85. Pickard S (2018) Momentum and the movementist ‘corbynistas’: Young people regenerating the labour party in Britain. In: Pickard S. and Bessant J (eds) Young people regenerating politics in times of crises, Palgrave Macmillan: pp. 115-137.
86. Pelling, H. (1965). The Origins of the Labour Party, 1880-1900. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
87. Powell M (2008) Introduction: modernising the welfare state. In: Powell M (eds) Modernising the welfare state: The Blair legacy, Policy: pp. 1-16.
88. Prentoulis M and Thomassen L (2020) Movement parties: A new hybrid form of politics? In Fominaya CF and Feenstra RA (eds) Routledge handbook contemporary European social movements: Protest in turbulent times, Routledge: pp. 343-356.
89. Proctor K (2019) Labour gets support from Bernie Sanders campaigners in US. The Guardian. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2019/nov/26/labour-gets-support-from-bernie-sanders-campaigners-in-us (accessed 28 May 2023).
90. Ramsay-Smith A (2019) Building DSA with Bernie. Democratic Socialists of America. Available at: https://www.dsausa.org/blog/building-dsa-with-bernie/ (accessed 11 June 2023)
91. Rhodes A (2019) Movement-led electoral campaigning: Momentum in the 2017 general election. In Wring D, Mortimore D and Atkinson S (eds) Political communication in Britain, Palgrave Macmillan: pp. 171-186.
92. Rose R (1964) Parties, factions and tendencies in Britain. Political studies 12 (1): 33-46. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9248.1964.tb00609.x
93. Sandle G (2025). What is wrong with first past the post. Electoral Reform Society. Available at: https://electoral-reform.org.uk/whats-wrong-with-first-past-the-post/ (accessed: 9 August 2025).
94. Sartori G (2005) Parties and party systems: A framework for analysis. ECPR.
95. Schattschneider, E. (2004). Party Government: American Government in Action. Routledge.
96. Schwartz JM (2017) History. Democratic Socialists of America. Available at: www.dsausa.org/about-us/history (accessed 5 June 2023).
97. Sinwell L (2012) Transformative left-wing parties’ and grassroots organizations: Unpacking the politics of ‘top-down’ and ‘bottom-up’ development. Geoforum 43: 190-198.
98. Snow DA and Dana MM (2014) Protest on the fly: Toward a theory of spontaneity in the dynamics of protest and social movements. American Sociological Review 79 (6): 1122–1143. https://doi.org/10.1177/0003122414554081
99. Svart M (2019) March dispatch: It’s about power. Democratic Socialists of America. Available at: www.dsausa.org/news/march-dispatch-its-about-power (accessed 6 June 2023).
100. Svart M (2022) Director’s Report: After a good election, seize the chance to organize. Democratic Left. Available at: https://democraticleft.dsausa.org/issues/winter-2022/seize-the-chance-to-organize/ (accessed 6 June 2023).
101. Sunkara B (2019) The Socialist Manifesto: The Case for Radical Politics in an Era of Extreme Inequality. Verso.
102. Sunkara B (2023) Which Way Forward, Socialist?. Jacobin. Available at: https://jacobin.com/ 2023/08/democratic-socialists-of-america-convention-labor-movement (accessed 10 June 2023)
103. Tax M (2019) Climate, solidarity, and resistance: Paradigm for a socialist foreign policy. Democratic Left 47 (1): 8-9.
104. Taylor SL (2025) Trapped in a Two-Party System. Protect Democracy and New America.
105. Taylor M and Arthur N (2019) Yanis Varoufakis: Green new deal can unite Europe’s progressives. The Guardian. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/may/22/yanis-varoufakis-green-new-deal-can-unite-europes-progressives (accessed 6 June 2023).
106. Tilly C (1984) Social movements and national politics. In Mistzal B (ed.), Research in social movements, conflict and change, vol. 10, Connecticut: JAI Press.
107. Topping A (2024). ‘Disproportionate’ UK elections results boost calls to ditch first past the post. The Guardian. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/politics/article/2024/jul/08/ disproportionate-uk-election-results-boost-calls-to-ditch-first-past-the-post (accessed 9 August 2025).
108. Ward B and Guglielmo M (2021) Pop-socialism: a new radical left politics? Evaluating the rise and fall of the British and Italian left in the anti-austerity age. The British Journal of Politics and International Relations. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/13691481211044643
109. Zariski R (1960) Party factions and comparative politics: Some preliminary observations. Midwest Journal of Political Science 4 (1): 27-51.
110. Zollner BHE (2019) The metamorphosis of social movements into political parties: The Egyptian muslim brotherhood and the Tunisian al-nahda as cases for a reflection no party institutionalisation theory. British Journal of Middle Eastern Studies 3 (48): 370-387. https://doi.org/10.1080/13530194.2019.1609413
111. Zuckerman A (1975) Political clienteles in power: Party factions and cabinet coalitions in Italy. Sage Professional Papers in Comparative Politics, no. 01-55. Beverly Hills: Sage