Debt-Trap Diplomacy of China towards the Turkestan Republics

Öz

Following their independence in 1991, the Republics of Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, and Uzbekistan developed active relations with major global and regional actors, including the United States, Russia, Europe, Türkiye, and China. Among these, China emerged as a particularly influential partner by deepening its economic and diplomatic engagement. Kazakhstan, the largest and wealthiest of the three, holds special strategic importance due to its abundant natural resources and its geographic position as a gateway to the West. Consequently, this study first examines the dynamics of the Chinese-Kazakh relationship, focusing on China’s use of debt-trap diplomacy within the framework of the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI). The analysis adopts dependency theory to explain the nexus between debt reliance and economic growth, supported by data on bilateral trade volumes and BRI-related projects. The paper also highlights the rise of Sinophobia in Kazakhstan, reflecting growing mistrust toward Chinese influence. Before concluding, the study compares China’s debt and trade relations across Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, and Uzbekistan, assessing the broader scope of debt-trap diplomacy in the region. Using a descriptive case study and documentary analysis, the paper argues that China employs debt-trap diplomacy both to expand markets for its goods and to advance strategic goals by fostering one-sided economic dependence in Turkestan republics.

Anahtar Kelimeler

• Turkestan Republics
• China
• Debt-Trap Diplomacy
• BRI Project
• Sinophobia

Çin’in Türkistan Cumhuriyetlerine Yönelik Borç-Tuzak Diplomasisi

Öz

1991’de bağımsızlıklarını kazanmalarının ardından Kazakistan, Kırgızistan ve Özbekistan Cumhuriyetleri; Amerika Birleşik Devletleri, Rusya, Avrupa, Türkiye ve Çin dâhil olmak üzere küresel ve bölgesel aktörlerle aktif ilişkiler geliştirmiştir. Bu aktörler arasında Çin, ekonomik ve diplomatik ilişkilerini derinleştirerek özellikle etkili bir ortak hâline gelmiştir. Üç ülke arasında en büyük ve en zengin olan Kazakistan, hem bol doğal kaynakları hem de Batı’ya açılan kapı konumuyla özel bir stratejik öneme sahiptir. Bu nedenle, çalışma öncelikle Çin’in Kuşak ve Yol Girişimi (BRI) çerçevesinde borç tuzağı diplomasisini kullanarak Kazakistan ile geliştirdiği ilişkileri incelemektedir. Bu çalışma, borç bağımlılığı ile ekonomik büyüme arasındaki bağı açıklamak için bağımlılık teorisini benimsemekte ve bu teoriyi ikili ticaret hacimleri ve BRI ile ilgili projeler hakkındaki verilerle desteklemektedir. Çalışma ayrıca, Çin’in etkisine yönelik artan güvensizliği yansıtan Kazakistan’da Çin düşmanlığının yükselişini de vurgulamaktadır. Sonuç bölümünden önce, Çin’in Kazakistan, Kırgızistan ve Özbekistan ile borç ve ticaret ilişkileri karşılaştırmalı olarak ele alınmakta ve bölgede borç tuzağı diplomasisinin kapsamı değerlendirilmektedir. Betimleyici bir vaka çalışması ve doküman analizi yöntemine dayanan bu araştırma, Çin’in borç tuzağı diplomasisini hem malları için yeni pazarlar yaratmak, stratejik hedeflerini ilerletmek, diplomatik nüfuzunu artırmak hem Türkistan cumhuriyetlerinde tek yönlü ekonomik bağımlılık tesis etmek için kullandığını savunmaktadır.

Anahtar Kelimeler

• Türkistan Cumhuriyetleri
• Çin
• Borç-Tuzak Diplomasisi
• KYG Projesi
• Sinofobi

Kaynakça

1. Akmataliyeva, Ainura. “Initsiativa «Odin Poyas-Odin Put’» v Tsentral’noy Azii (One Belt, One Road Initiative in Central Asia).” Comparative Politics, vol. 9, no. 4, 2018, pp. 139–46.
2. Altynbayev, Kanat. “Kazakhstan vyrazil protest Kitayu v svyazi so stat’yey, stavyashchey pod somneniye yego suverenitet (Kazakhstan protested to China in connection with an article calling into question its sovereignty).” central.asia-news.com, 2020, https://central.asia-news.com/ru/articles/cnmi_ca/features/2020/04/17/feature-02.
3. Aminjonov, Farkhod, et al. “BRI in Central Asia: Overview of Chinese Projects.” Central Asia Regional Data Review, 20, 2019, pp. 1–5.
4. Aripova, Madina. “Comprehensive Strategic Partnership between the Republic of Uzbekistan and the People’s Republic of China in a New Era.” Institute for Strategic and Regional Studies under the President of the Republic of Uzbekistan. 2024, https://isrs.uz/en/maqolalar/vsestoronnee-strategiceskoe-partnerstvomezdu-respublikoj-uzbekistan-i-knr-v-novuu-epohu.
5. Barman, Jnyanendra. “China’s Belt and Road Initiative: An Analysis.” Journal of Contemporary Politics, 2023; vol. 2, no. 3, pp. 97–102, https://doi.org/10.53989/jcp.v2i3.23.11.
6. Bitabarova, G. Assel. “Unpacking Sino-Central Asian engagement along the NewSilk Road: a case study of Kazakhstan.” Journal of Contemporary East Asia Studies, 2018, vol. 7, no. 2, pp. 149–173, https://doi.org/10.1080/24761.028.2018.1553226.
7. Brautigam, Deborah. “A Critical Look at Chinese ‘Debt-Trap Diplomacy’: The Rise of a Meme.” Area Development and Policy, vol. 5, no. 1, Jan. 2020, pp. 1–14, https://doi.org/10.1080/23792.949.2019.1689828.
8. Brautigam, Deborah, et al. “How Africa Borrows From China: And Why Mombasa Port is Not Collateral for Kenya’s Standard Gauge Railway.” Policy Brief, no. 62, 2022, China Africa Research Initiative (CARI), School of Advanced International Studies (SAIS), Johns Hopkins University, http://www.saiscari.org/publications-policy-briefs.

9. Bureau of National Statistics of the Republic of Kazakhstan. Elektronniyye tablitsy– Byuro natsional’noy statistiki Agentstva po strategicheskomu planirovaniyu i reformam Respubliki Kazakhstan (Spreadsheets – Bureau of National Statistics Agency for Strategic Planning and Reform of the Republic of Kazakhstan). 2024, https://stat.gov.kz/ru/industries/economy/foreign- market/spreadsheets/?year=2023&name=19182&period=&type=spreadsheets.
10. Buyanov, Sergei. “Rekord postavok zerna v Kitay ustanovil Kazakhstan v 2023 godu (Kazakhstan set a record for grain supplies to China in 2023).” ElDala.kz, 6 Jan. 2024, https://eldala.kz/specproekty/17864-rekord-postavok-zerna-vkitay-ustanovil-kazahstan-v-2023-godu.
11. Carmody, Pádraig, et al. “China’s spatial fix and ‘debt diplomacy’ in Africa: constraining belt or road to economic transformation?” Canadian Journal of African Studies, vol. 56, no. 1, pp. 57–77, https://doi.org/10.1080/00083.968.2020.1868014.
12. Chase-Dunn, Christopher. “Dependency Theory.” International Encyclopedia of the Social & Behavioral Sciences: Second Edition, 2015, pp. 196–98, https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-08-097086-8.32038-4.
13. Chellaney, Brahma. “China’s Creditor Imperialism.” Project Syndicate, 20.12.2017, https://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/china-sri-lankahambantota-port-debt-by-brahma-chellaney- 2017-12.
14. Clarke, Michael. “The Belt and Road Initiative: China’s New Grand Strategy?” Asia Policy, no. 24, 2017, pp. 71-79.
15. Conway, Dennis, and Nikolas Heynen. “Dependency Theories: From ECLA to André Gunder Frank and Beyond.” The Companion to Development Studies, 2024, pp. 13–17, https://doi.org/10.4324/978.042.9282348-4.
16. Dukeyev, Berikbol. “In Kazakhstan, Generation Z on Alert Over China.” Jamestown, 2023, https://jamestown.org/program/in-kazakhstan-generation-z-on-alertover-china/.
17. Dunford, Michael. “China’s Belt and Road Initiative and Its Implications for Global Development.” Acta Via Serica, vol. 6, no. 1, 2021, pp. 91–118.
18. Dzhursunbek, Malik. “Kazahskij bars i kitajskij drakon: chej pryzhok vpechatlitel’nee (Kazakh leopard and Chinese dragon: whose jump is more impressive).” Ulysmedia.kz, 2 July 2024, https://ulysmedia.kz/analitika/33764-kazakhskii-bars-i-kitaiskii-drakon-chei-pryzhok-vpechatlitelnee/.
19. Galimova, Anastasia, et al. The Risks of China’s Loans to Uzbekistan. 2024, https://thediplomat.com/2024/07/the-risks-of-chinas-loans-to-uzbekistan/.
20. Glantz, H. Michael. “China’s One Belt, One Road (OBOR) Initiative: What a Difference a Brand Can Make.” Post-Soviet Issues, vol. 4, no. 1, 2017, pp. 8–19, https://doi.org/10.24975/2313-8920-2017-4-1-8-19.
21. Himmer, Michal, and Zdeněk Rod. “Chinese Debt Trap Diplomacy: Reality or Myth?” Journal of the Indian Ocean Region, vol. 18, no. 3, Sept. 2022, pp. 250–72, https://doi.org/10.1080/19480.881.2023.2195280.
22. Hout, Wil. “Classical Approaches to Development: Modernisation and Dependency.” The Palgrave Handbook of International Development, edited by Jean Grugel and Daniel Hammett, Palgrave Macmillan UK, 2016, pp. 21–39, https://doi.org/10.1057/978-1-137-42724-3_2.
23. Hudec, Michal. “China’s Emergence in Central Asia.” IAS Institute of Asian Studies, Bratislava, 2018, https://ceias.eu/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/Chinas-Emergence-in-Central-Asia_fin.pdf.
24. International Crisis Group. Central Asia’s Silk Road Rivalries | Crisis Group. 27 July 2017, https://www.crisisgroup.org/europe-central-asia/central-asia/245-central-asias-silk-road-rivalries.
25. Kaleji, Vali. “China’s Debt-Trap Diplomacy in Central Asia.” The Central Asia-Caucasus Analyst, 23.10.2024, https://www.cacianalyst.org/publications/analyticalarticles/item/13823-chinas-debt-trap- diplomacy-in-central-asia.html.
26. Kara, Abdulvahap. “Kazakistan Çin ile İlişkilerini Sorguluyor (Kazakhstan Questions Its Relations with China).” Türk Dünyası Tarih Kültür Dergisi, vol. 63, no. 375, 2018, pp. 12–15.
27. Khamzabekuly, Dikhan. “Kasym-Jomart Tokaev: As a forward-thinking nation, we should only look ahead.” 2024, https://egemen.kz/article/355466-qasymzhomart-toqaev-biz-ozyq-oyly-ult-retinde- tek-qana-algha-qarauymyz-kerek.
28. Khidirov, Abduaziz. “Uzbekistan – China: Strategic partnership results for the first nine months of 2024.” Uza.uz, 9 Oct. 2024, http://uza.uz/en/posts/uzbekistan-china-strategic-partnership-results-for- the-first-nine-monthsof-2024_643615.
29. Kohli, Harinder. S., and Leo. M. Zucker. “An Economic Perspective on the Belt and Road Initiative: Six Years after Its Launch.” China’s Belt and Road Initiative: Potential Transformation of Central Asia and the South Caucasus, SAGE Publications, 2020.
30. Kudryavtseva, Tatyana. “Vneshniy dolg Kyrgyzstana, po poslednim dannym, sostavlyayet $4,6 milliarda (Kyrgyzstan’s external debt, according to the latest data, is $4.6 billion).” 24.kg, 2024, https://24.kg/ekonomika/294589_vneshniy_dolg_kyirgyizstana_poposlednim_dannyim_sostavlyaet_46_milliarda/.
31. Kyrgyzstan 24.kg. “Kyrgyzstan’s debt to China has increased 37 times in 15 years. What did the Republic take money for?.” 24.kg. 25.11.2023. https://24.kg/ekonomika/278192_za15let_dolg_kyirgyizstana_kitayu_vyiros_v37raz_nachto_respublika_brala_dengi/
32. Latov, Yurii. “Velikiy Shelkovyy Put’—Prolog Mirovoy Ekonomiki i Globalizatsii (k2130-Letiyu Yego «otkrytiya») (The Great Silk Road—Prologue to the WorldEconomy and Globalization (to the 2130th
33. Anniversary of Its ‘Discovery’)).” Historical and Economic Research, vol. 11, no. 1, 2010, pp. 123–40.
34. Lyu, Jiamin. “Kazakhstan i Kirgiziya v Proyekte «odin Poyas i Odin Put’»: Osnovn·yye Napravleniye Sotrudnichestva, Problemy i Perspektivy (Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan in the ‘One Belt and One Road’ Project: Main Areas of Cooperation, Problems and Prospects.).” Bulletin of Ivanovo State University. Series: Humanities, no. 3, 2022, pp. 114–24.
35. Malik, Ammar A., et al. Banking on the Belt and Road: Insights from a New Global Dataset of 13,427 Chinese Development Projects. AidData at William & Mary, 2021, https://www.aiddata.org/publications/banking-on-the-belt-and-road.
36. Mejia, Steven A. “The Effects of Debt Dependence on Economic Growth in Less-Developed Countries, 1990–2019.” Social Science Research, vol. 117, 2024, 102943, pp. 1-12, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ssresearch.2023.102943.
37. Mariani, Bernardo. “China’s role and interests in Central Asia.” Saferworld. Policy Brief 1 2016, pp. 1-17, https://www.files.ethz.ch/isn/172938/chinas-roleand-interests-in-central-asia.pdf.
38. Miguel, Diego, and Zambrano Márquez. “Decentering International Relations: The Continued Wisdom of Latin American Dependency.” International Studies Perspectives, vol. 21, no. 4, 2020, pp. 403–23, https://doi.org/10.1093/isp/ekaa007.
39. Moldagali, Beimbet. Pochemu v Kazakhstane ostayetsya sil’na sinofobiya? (Why does Sinophobia remain strong in Kazakhstan?). 2023, https://vlast.kz/politika/56043-pocemu-v-kazahstane- ostaetsa-silna-sinofobia.html.
40. Muratalieva, Nargiza. “Chinese Lending Adapts to Central Asia’s Realities.” Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, 2024, https://carnegieendowment.org/posts/2024/08/china-investment- central-asia-debt.
41. Muratalieva, Nargiza. Kyrgyzstan’s Path to Peak Repayments to China: Context and Dilemmas. 2023, https://thediplomat.com/2023/08/kyrgyzstans-path-topeak-repayments-to-china-context-and- dilemmas/.
42. Muzaparova, Leyla and Koshirowa, Swetlana. “How the BRI Spurs Chinese Migration to Kazakhstan.” Rosa Luxemburd Stiftung, 08/17/2022, https://www.rosalux.de/en/news/id/46865/how-the-bri- spurs-chinese-migration-to-kazakhstan.
43. Nazir, Humaira. “Impact assessment of Gwadar Port on ChinaPakistan economic corridor: A case study.” Journal of Art, Architecture and Built Environment, vol. 4, no. 1, 2021, pp. 69–95, https://doi.org/10.32350/jaabe.41.
44. Nem, Viktoriya, et al. “Rasshifrovyvaya Vospriyatie Kitajskogo Prisutstviya v RK: Upravlencheskoe, Social’noe i Ekologicheskoe Izmereniya (Deciphering the Perception of China’s Presence in Kazakhstan: Governance, Social and Environmental Dimensions).” Paperlab, 2022, https://paperlab.kz/china/rasshifrovyvaya-vospriyatie-kitayskogo-prisutstviya-v-kz.
45. Pannier, Bruce. “Central Asia in Focus: Kyrgyzstan Falling Deeper in Debt to China.” RadioLiberty, October 31, 2023, https://about.rferl.org/article/central-asia-in-focus-kyrgyzstan-falling-deeper-in- debt-to-china/.
46. Pereverzev, Vladimir. “Nachalo Otkrytoj Sovetsko-Kitajskoj Polemiki i Obshchestvennoe Mnenie v SSSR (The Beginning of Open Soviet-Chinese Polemics and Public Opinion in the USSR).” Magistra Vitae: Elektronnyy zhurnal po istoricheskim naukam i arkheologii, no. 12 (341), 2014, pp. 82–89.
47. Peyrouse, Sébastien. “Discussing China: Sinophilia and Sinophobia in Central Asia.” Journal of Eurasian Studies, vol. 7, no. 1, 2016, pp. 14–23, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.euras.2015.10.003.
48. Report of the Ministry of Economy and Finance Republic of Uzbekistan. Annual Report, 2024, https://api.mf.uz/media/menu_attachments/IB_2023_uz.pdf.
49. Saltybayev, Yerzhan. “BRI and Kazakhstan: Challenges and Outlooks of China’s Grand Strategy in Central Asia.” Horizons: Journal of International Relations and Sustainable Development, no. 10, 2018, pp. 76–85.
50. Satubaldina, Assel. “Close-Up Look at Kazakhstan’s Foreign Trade: China Becomes Top Trade Partner, as Non-Commodity Exports to Asia Rise.” The Astana Times, 27 Feb. 2024, https://astanatimes.com/2024/02/close-up-lookat-kazakhstans-foreign-trade-china-becomes-top-trade-partner-as-noncommodity-exports-to-asia-rise/.
51. Satubaldina, Assel, and Tatyana Kuzmina. “145-Men Fight between Chinese and Kazakh Miners in Kazakhstan, 65 Injured.” Glavnye Novosti Kazakhstana – Tengrinews, 10 July 2015, https://en.tengrinews.kz/emergencies/145-menfight-between-chinese-and-kazakh-miners-in-261159/.
52. Shamshiyev, Yerlan. “«Initsiativa Poyasa i putI» Kak Faktor Formirovaniya Tsentral’noy Yevrazii: Mesto i Rol’ Kazakhstana (The Belt and Road Initiative as a Factor in the Formation of Central Eurasia: The Place and Role of Kazakhstan).” Bulletin of the Institute of Economics of the Russian Academy of Sciences, no. 3, 2019, pp. 137–51.
53. Shulepina, Nataliya. Ekologicheskiye aspekty proyektov «Poyas i put’» v Tsentral’noy Azii (Environmental aspects of Belt and Road projects in Central Asia). 2020, https://cso-central.asia/wp- content/uploads/2020/09/2020.09.16_%D0%9E%D0%B1%D0%B7%D0%BE%D1%80-%D1%8D%D0%BA%D0%BE%D0%B2%D0%BE%D0%BF%D1%80%D0%BE%D1%81%D1%8B-%D0%9F%D0%B8%D0%9F_draft-1.pdf.
54. Singh, Ajit. “The Myth of ‘Debt-Trap Diplomacy’ and Realities of Chinese Development Finance.” Third World Quarterly, vol. 42, no. 2, 2021, pp. 239–53, https://doi.org/10.1080/01436.597.2020.1807318.
55. Statistics Agency under the President of the Republic of Uzbekistan. 2024, https://www.stat.uz/ru/ofitsialnaya-statistika/investments.
56. Stulnikova, Elina. “Sovetsko-Kitajskij Raskol Kak Prichina Kul’turnoj Revolyucii v KNR (The Sino-Soviet Split as the Cause of the Cultural Revolution in China).” Aktualnye Problemy Gumanitarnykh i Estestvennykh Nauk, no. 2–1, 2015, pp. 112–15.
57. Tajikistan invites China to invest in in its industrial, energy and transport sectors, ASIA-Plus. 01.07.2024, https://asiaplustj.info/en/news/tajikistan/economic/20240601/tajikistan-invites-china-to- invest-in-in-its-industrialenergy-and-transport-sectors.
58. TheAstanaTimes. “President Tokayev: Kazakhstan Continues Constructive, Balanced Foreign Policy Considering National Interests.” The Astana Times, 3 January 2024, https://astanatimes.com/2024/01/president-tokayev-kazakhstan-continuesconstructive-balanced-foreign-policy-considering-national-interests/.
59. The National Bank. Balance of payments and external debt of the Republic of Kazakhstan. 31 July 2024, https://www.nationalbank.kz/ru/news/platezhnyy-balans.
60. Tokayev, Kasym Zhomart. Full text of the interview of the President of the Republic of Kazakhstan Kassym-Jomart Tokayev to Xinhua. 2024, https://russian.news.cn/20240701/d85c1037b7de4e459ba7f79e5dd926f7/c.html.
61. Wang, Gungwu. “Silk Roads and the Centrality of Old World Eurasia.” Regional Connection under the Belt and Road Initiative, Routledge, 2018, pp. 3–16, https://www.taylorfrancis.com/chapters/edit/10.4324/978.042.9467172-1/silk-roads-centrality-old-world-eurasia-gungwu-wang.
62. Xinhua. Interview: Kazakhstan-China permanent comprehensive strategic partnership to usher in new chapter, says Kazakh president, Xinhua, 01.07.2024, https://english.news.cn/20240701/93c450ddc0064edda3a32f081ccf65c4/c.html.
63. Yılmaz, Serdar. “Bir Kuşak Bir Yol Projesinin Azerbaycan, Kazakistan ve Türkiye’ye Etkisi.” OPUS International Journal of Society Researches, vol. 16, no. 32, 2020, pp. 5274–5301, DOI: 10.26466/opus.774914.
64. Zhang, Xiao. Posol KNR v RK Chzhan Syao: Kitay i Kazakhstan stroyat budushcheye vmeste (Chinese Ambassador to the Republic of Kazakhstan Zhang Xiao: China and Kazakhstan are building a future together). 2 Jan. 2024, https://dknews.kz/ru/shelkovyy-put/312032-posol-knr-v-rk-chzhan-syao-kitay-ikazahstan-stroyat.