Orta Anadolu’daki Olası Med Yayılımının Bir Göstergesi Olarak Çift Kulplu İçki Kapları

Öz

Arkeolojik anlamda herkesi ikna edecek düzeyde kimlik kazandırılamayan Medler, Eski Yunan tarihçiliğinden gelen bilgilere göre doğuda İran platosundan batıda Kızılırmak kavsine değin uzanan geniş coğrafyada söz sahibi olmuşlardır. Ancak, bu geniş coğrafya üzerindeki kısa süreli egemenlikleri ve egemenliklerinin şekli detaylı ve eksiksiz tanımlanabilmiş değildir. Dahası Med yayılımının politik ve kültürel boyutunu tartışabileceğimiz olası arkeolojik malzeme grupları genişletilememiştir. Bu çalışma, yayılımın anlaşılması adına güçlü bir yan taşıyan Orta-Geç Demir Çağlarına tarihli iki kulplu bir içki kap formunu (“tankard”) yayılımın değişen sınırları ve politik yapısı bağlamında incelemeyi amaçlamaktadır. Tarihi kaynaklar ve diğer arkeolojik kanıtlarla birlikte, Kızılırmak kavsinde bulunan ancak ilk kez kavsin doğusunda ortaya çıktığı anlaşılan “tankard” kap grubunu ortaya koyarak, Medlerin Orta Anadolu’ya doğru ilerlettikleri politik ve kültürel yayılımın en batı ucunu Kızılırmak yerine onun bir kolu olan Delice Irmağı’nın çizdiğini önermekteyiz.

Anahtar Kelimeler

• Çift Kulplu İçki Kapları
• Medler
• Lidyalılar
• Geç Demir Çağı
• Orta Anadolu

THE TWO-HANDLED DRINKING VESSELS AS AN INDICATOR FOR POSSIBLE EXPANSION OF THE MEDES INTO CENTRAL ANATOLIA

Öz

The Medes, whose presence has not been conclusively identified yet in the archaeological record, are documented in ancient Greek historiography as having influenced a vast region stretching from the Iranian Plateau in the east to the Kızılırmak Bend in the west. However, their political organization and short governance over this vast region remain poorly understood. Additionally, the possible archaeological materials related to the political and cultural aspects of the expansion of the Medes have regrettably not been improved. This paper intends to investigate the form of a two-handled drinking vessel (“tankard”) dated to the Middle-Late Iron Ages, which seems to demonstrate significant potential for understanding the expansion of the Medes, in the context of the changing border and political structure of the expansion. By analyzing “tankard” found in the Kızılırmak Bend, which are considered to descended from the East, alongside written sources and other archaeological evidence, we suggest that the Delice River, rather than Kızılırmak River, marks the westernmost extent of Median political and cultural expansion into Central Anatolia.

Anahtar Kelimeler

• Two-Handled Drinking Vessels
• the Medes
• the Lydians
• Late Iron Age
• Central Anatolia

Kaynakça

1. Akkuzu, Zeynep, The Late Iron Age Pottery from Kaman-Kalehöyük, Bilkent University, Graduate School of Economics and Social Sciences, MA dissertation, Ankara, 2018.
2. Amandry, Pierre, “Truly Royal Persian Gold: Some Recently Found Masterpieces”, The Illustrated London News, 27, 1958, s. 23–7.
3. Bittel, Kurt-Güterbock, Hans G., Vorläufiger Bericht über die dritte Grabung in Bogazköy, Deutsche Orient-Gesellschaft, Berlin, 1933.
4. Blegen, Carl W. et al., Troy: General Introduction, The First and Second Settlements, Volume I, Part 2: Plates, Princeton University Press, Princeton, 1950.
5. Bossert, Eva-Maria, Die Keramik Phrygischer Zeit von Boğazköy, Verlag Philipp Von Zabern, Mainz, 2000.
6. Brown, Stuart C., “Media and Secondary State Formation in the Neo-Assyrian Zagros: an Anthropological Approach to an Assyriological Problem”. Journal of Cuneiform Studies, 38, 1986, s. 107–19.
7. Casabonne, Olivier, “The Formation of Cappadocia: Iranian Populations and Achaemenid Influence”, The Achaemenid Impact on Local Populations and Cultures in Anatolia (Sixth-Fourth Centuries B.C.) (ed. İnci Delemen), İstanbul, Turkish Institute of Archaeology, 2007, s. 103–6.
8. Çınaroğlu, Aykut, “Alacahöyük 2008 Kazı Raporu”, unpublished report for the Ministry of Culture and Tourism of the Republic of Türkiye, 2008.

9. Diakonoff, Igor, M., “Media”, The Cambridge History of Iran: 2 (ed. Ilya Gershevitch), London, Cambridge University Press, 1985, 36–149.
10. Emre, Kutlu, “The Pottery of the Assyrian Colony Period According to the Building Levels of Kaniş Karum”, Anatolia, 7, 1963, s. 87–99.
11. Emre, Kutlu, Acemhöyük Seramiği, Türk Tarih Kurumu, Ankara, 1968.
12. Emre, Kutlu, “Pottery of Levels III and IV at the Karum of Kanesh”, Anatolia and the Ancient Near East: Studies in Honor of Tahsin Özgüç (eds. Kutlu Emre et al.), Ankara, Türk Tarih Kurumu, 1989, s. 111–28.
13. Emre, Kutlu, “Kantharoi from Kültepe/Kanish”, Essays on Ancient Anatolia in Second Millennium BC (ed. Takahito Mikasa), Wiesbaden, Otto Harrassowitz, 1996, s. 1–11.
14. Eslick, Christine, The Early Bronze Age Pottery of Karataş Habitations Deposits, Elmalı-Karataş 5, Archaeopress, Pennsylvania, 2009.
15. Fuchs, Andreas, “The Medes and the Kingdom of Mannea”, The Oxford History of the Ancient Near East (eds. Karen Radner et al.), Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2023, s. 674–768.
16. Genz, Hermann, Büyükkaya I: Die Keramik der Eisenzeit, Verlag Philipp Von Zabern, Mainz, 2004.
17. Genz, Hermann, “Thoughts on the Origin of the Iron Age Pottery Traditions in Central Anatolia”, Anatolian Iron Ages 5 (eds. Altan Çilingiroğlu-Garry Dabyshire), Ankara, BIAA, 2005, s. 75–84.
18. Godley, Alfred A., Herodotus, The Persian Wars, Volume I: Books 1–2, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, 1975.
19. Goff, Clare, “Excavation at Baba Jan 1967: Second Preliminary Report”, Iran, 7, 1969, s. 115–30.
20. Goff, Clare, “Excavation at Baba Jan, the Architecture of the East Mound, Levels II and III”, Iran, 15, 1977, s. 103–40.
21. Gopnik, Hilary, “The Median Citadel of Godin Period II”, On the High Road: The History of Godin Tepe (eds. Hilary Gopnik-Mitchell Rothman), Toronto, Mazda Publisher, 2011, s. 285–362.
22. Gökçe Köker, Emine, “Neo-Assyrian and Persian Periods in the Tabal / Cappadocia Region in the Light of the Topaklı Höyük Finds”, OANNES, 7/2, 2025, s. 204–24.
23. Grave, Peter-Lisa Kealhofer, “Investigating Iron Age Trade Ceramics at Kaman-Kalehöyük”, Anatolian Archaeological Studies, 15, 2006, s. 139–50.
24. Grayson, Albert K., Assyrian and Babylonian Chronicles, J. J. Agustin, New York, 1975.
25. Henrickson, Robert C. et al., “Lustrous Black Fine Ware at Gordion, Turkey: A Distinctive Sintered Slip Technology”, Materials Research Society, 712, 2011, s. 391–97.
26. Imampour, Mohammad T., “The Medes and Persians: Were the Persians ever ruled by Medes?”, Name-ye Iran-e Bastan, 2, 2003, s. 61–79.
27. Kamış, Yalçın, Acemhöyük Erken Tunç Çağı Seramiği, Ankara University, PhD dissertation, Ankara, 2012.
28. Kâmil, Turan, Yortan Cemetery in the Early Bronze Age of Western Anatolia, BAR, Oxford, 1982.
29. Kroll, Stephan, “XI. Meder in Bastam, Bastam I. Ausgrabungen in den Urartaischen Anlagen 1972-1975”, Teheraner Forschungen 5 (ed. Wolfram Kleiss), Berlin, Gebr. Mann, 1979, s. 229–34.
30. Kroll, Stephan, “Notes on Post-Urartian (Median) Horizon of NW Iran and Armenia”, Arkeolojiyle Geçen Bir Yaşam için Yazılar: Veli Sevin’e Armağan (ed. Aynur Özfırat), İstanbul, Ege Yayınları, 2014, s. 203–10.
31. Kroll, Stephan, “Archaeology between Urartu and the Achaemenids”, International Symposium on East Anatolia South Caucasus Cultures: Proceedings II (eds. Mehmet Işıklı-Birol Can), Cambridge, Cambridge Publishing Press, 2015, s. 110–17.
32. Luckenbill, Daniel D., Ancient Records of Assyria and Babylonia, Volume 1: Historical Records of Assyria from the Earliest Times to Sargon, The University of Chicago Press, Chicago, 1926.
33. Luckenbill, Daniel D., Ancient Records of Assyria and Babylonia, Volume 2: Historical Records of Assyria from Sargon to the End, The University of Chicago Press, Chicago, 1927.
34. Manuelli, Federico-Mielke, Dirk P. eds, Late Bronze Age Painted Pottery Traditions at the Margins of the Hittite State, Papers Presented at a Workshop Held at the 11th ICAANE (München 4 April 2018) and Additional Contributions, Archaeopress, Oxford, 2022.
35. Matsumura, Kimiyoshi, “On the Manufacturing Techniques of Iron Age Ceramics from Kaman-Kalehöyük (II): The Cultural Influence of Phrygia at Kaman-Kalehöyük”, Anatolian Archaeological Studies, 10, 2001, s. 101–10.
36. Matsumura, Kimiyoshi, Die Eisenzeitliche Keramik in Zentralanatolien aufgrund der Keramik in Kaman-Kalehöyük (text und tafeln), Freie Universität, PhD dissertation, Berlin, 2005.
37. Mellink, Machteld, “Excavations at Karataş-Semayük in Lycia, 1966”, American Journal of Archaeology, 71, 1967, s. 251–67.
38. Mellink, Machteld, “Excavations at Karataş-Semayük and Elmalı, Lycia, 1971”, American Journal of Archaeology, 76, 1972, s. 257–69.
39. Mielke, Dirk P., “Geometric Painted Pottery of the 2nd Millennium BC in the Central Black Sea Region. A Contribution to the Archaeology of Kaška”, Late Bronze Age Painted Pottery Traditions at the Margins of the Hittite State, Papers Presented at a Workshop Held at the 11th ICAANE (München 4 April 2018) and Additional Contributions (eds. Federico Manuelli-Dirk P. Mielke), Oxford, Archaeopress, 2022, s. 21–58.
40. Miller, Stella, “Two Painted Chamber Tombs of Northern Lycia at Kizilbel and Karaburun”, The Return of Colours (eds. Alexander von Kienlin-Latife Summerer), İstanbul, Yapı Kredi Kültür Yayınları, 2010, s. 318–29.
41. Omura, Masako, “Yassıhöyük Kazıları”, KST, 37/3, 2016, s. 303–14.
42. Muntz, Charles E., “Diodorus Siculus and Megasthenes: A Reappraisal”, Classical Philology, 107, 2012, s. 21-37.
43. Özgüç, Tahsin, “New Observations on the Relationship of Kültepe with Southeast Anatolia and North Syria during the Third Millennium BC”, Ancient Anatolia Aspects of Changes and Cultural Development, Essays in Honor of Machteld J. Mellink (ed. Jenny V. Canby et al.), Wisconsin, The University of Wisconsin Press, 1986, s. 31–47.
44. Özgüç, Tahsin, İnandıktepe: Eski Hitit Çağında Önemli bir Kült Merkezi, Türk Tarih Kurumu, Ankara 1988.
45. Parpola, Simo, “Assyrians after Assyria”, Journal of Assyrian Academic Studies, 13, 1999, s. 1–16.
46. Paspalas, Stavros, “A Persianizing Cup from Lydia”, Oxford Journal of Archaeology, 19, 2000, s. 135–74.
47. Radet, Georges, La Lydie et le Monde Grec au Temps des Mermnades, Paris, 1893.
48. Radner, Karen, “An Assyrian View on Medes”, Continuity of Empire (?) Assyria, Media, Persia (eds. Giovanni Lanfranchi et al.), Padova, S. a.r.g.o.n. Editrice e Libreria, 2003, s. 37–64 (text), s. 407–48 (bibliography).
49. Rehm, Ellen, “The Classification of the Objects from the Black Sea Region Made or Influenced by the Achaemenids”, Achaemenid Impact in the Black Sea (eds. Ellen Rehm-Jens Nieling), Aarhus, Aarhus University Press, 2010, s. 161–94.
50. Roaf, Michael, Sculptures and Sculptors at Persepolis, British Institute of Persian Studies, London, 1983.
51. Rollinger, Robert, “The Medes of the 7th and the 6th c. BCE: A Short-term Empire or Rather Shorted Term Confederacy?”, Short-term Empires in the World History (eds. R. Rollinger et al.), Wiesbaden, Springer, 2020, s. 187–211.
52. Roosevelt, Christopher, The Archaeology of Lydia, from Gyges to Alexander, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2009.
53. Root, Margaret C., The King and Kingship in Achaemenid Art, Peeters Publishers, Leiden, 1979.
54. Sancisi-Weerdenburg, Heleen, “Was There ever a Median Empire?”, Achaemenid History III: Methods and Theory (eds. Amelie Kuhrt-Heleen Sancisi-Weerdenburg), Leiden, Nederlands Instituut voor het Nabije Oosten, 1988, s. 197–212.
55. Sancisi-Weerdenburg, Heleen, “Medes and Persians in Early States?”, The Dynamics of the Early State Paradigm (eds. Martin van Bakel-Jarich G. Oosten), Utrecht, ISOR, 1995, s. 89–104.
56. Schmidt, Erich, Persepolis I: Structures, Reliefs, Inscriptions, OIP, Chicago, 1953.
57. Schoop, Ulf-Dietrich, “Hittite Pottery: A Summary”, Insights into Hittite History and Archaeology (eds. Hermann Genz-Dirk P. Mielke), Leuven, Peeters Publishers, 2011, s. 241–73.
58. Scurlock, Jo A., “The Euphrates Flood and the Ashes of Nineveh (Diod. II 27. 1-28.7)”, Historia: Zeitschrift für Alte Geschichte, 39, 1990, s. 382–84.
59. Sevin, Veli, “Van Bölgesinde Post-Urartu Dönemi: Yıkıntılar Üzerinde Yeni Bir Yaşam”, Belleten, 76, 2012, s. 351–68.
60. Sezer, Okan, “Central Anatolia in the 6th Century BC: Transitional Period of Achaemenid Persian Empire”, Central and Eastern Anatolia Late Iron Age: Post-Urartu, Median and Achaemenid Empires (eds. A. Özfırat et al.), İstanbul, Ege Yayınları, 2019, s. 97–157.
61. Sideris, Athanasios, “A Lydian Silver Amphora with Zoomorphic Handles”, Studia Hercynia, 20, 2016, s. 19–26.
62. Stronach, David, “Excavations at Tepe Nush-i Jan: 1967”, Iran, 7, 1969, s. 1–21.
63. Summers, Geoffrey, “The Identification of the Iron Age City on Kerkenes Dağ in Central Anatolia”, Journal of Near Eastern Studies, 52, 1997, s. 81–94.
64. Summers, Geoffrey, “Medes, Lydians, the “Battle of Eclipse” and the Historicity of Herodotus”, http://kerkenes.metu.edu.tr/kerk1/12propub/wwwpaper/eclbygds/index.html accessed 18 July 2024.11, 1999.
65. Summers, Geoffrey, “The Median Empire Reconsidered: A view from Kerkenes Dağ”, Anatolian Studies, 50, 2000, s. 55–73.
66. Summers, Geoffrey, “Phrygians East of the Red River: Phrygianisation, Migration and Desertion”, Anatolian Studies, 68, 2018, s. 99–118.
67. Summers, Geoffrey, Kerkenes Final Reports 1: Excavations at the Cappadocia Gate, OIP, Chicago, 2021.
68. Summers, Geoffrey, “Resizing Phrygia: Migration, State and Kingdom”, Altorientalische Forschungen, 50, 2023, s. 107–28.
69. Şahoğlu, Vasıf-Sotirakopoulou, Panagiota Sotirakopoulou. eds, Karşıdan Karşıya MÖ 3. Bin’de Kiklad Adaları ve Batı Anadolu, Sakıp Sabancı Müzesi, İstanbul, 2011.
70. Tarhan, Taner, “Recent Research at the Urartian capital Tushpa”, Tel Aviv, 21, 1994, s. 22–57.
71. Temizer, Raci, “Kayapınar Höyüğü Buluntuları”, Belleten, 71, 1954, s. 317–30.
72. Tiratsyan, Nora, “An Urartian Jar Burial from Nor Armavir”, Urartu and Its Neighbours: Festschrift in Honour of Nicolay Harutyunyan in Occasion of his 90th Birthday (eds. Aram Kosyan et al.), Yerevan, AJNES, 2010, s. 134–46.
73. Tuplin, Christopher, “The Medes in Anatolia: a return visit”, From Midas to Cyrus and Other Stories: Papers on Iron Age Anatolia in Honour of Geoffrey and Françoise Summers (eds. Catherine M. Draycott et al.), London, BIAA, 2023, s. 229–38.
74. Von Der Osten, Hans H., The Alishar Hüyük: Seasons of 1930-32, OIP XXIX, Chicago, 1937a.
75. Von Der Osten, Hans H., The Alishar Hüyük: Seasons of 1930-32, OIP XXX, Chicago, 1937b.
76. Yablonsky, Leonid T., “New Excavations of the Early Nomadic Burial Ground at Filippovka (Southern Ural Region, Russia)”, American Journal of Archaeology, 114, 2010, s. 129–43.
77. Young, Cuyler-Levine, Louis D., Excavations of Godin Project: Second Progress Report, Royal Ontario Museum of Art and Archaeology, Toronto, 1974.