The Effectiveness of Group and Individual+Group Schema Therapy on Borderline Personality Disorder: A Systematic Review

Öz

Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD) is a complex mental disorder that profoundly impacts individuals' emotional stability, interpersonal relationships, and self-regulation skills. In recent years, Group Schema Therapy (GST) and Individual + Group Schema Therapy (IGST) have received increasing attention in the treatment of BPD. The current study aims to systematically review empirically based research investigating the effects of GST and IGST on BPD. The review was prepared based on the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis (PRISMA) criteria and articles published after 2009 were searched from databases such as PubMed, ScienceDirect / Elsevier, Wiley Online Library, and PsycINFO. Additionally, some articles were manually found and included, and a total of eight studies were reviewed in terms of their therapeutic impacts. The studies were analyzed based on types of therapy, participant profiles, techniques, and treatment outcomes. The findings revealed that both approaches are effective in reducing the severity of BPD symptoms, enhancing quality of life, and improving overall functioning of individuals. IGST was found to be particularly superior in reducing suicidal ideation and alleviating symptom severity. Group therapies were noted to accelerate the recovery process through fostering a sense of social belonging and emotional sharing, while individual therapies were found to be more important for in-depth therapeutic work. In conclusion, GST and BGST appear to be promising approaches for the treatment of BPD. However, factors such as therapy duration, intensity, and the number of therapists may affect treatment outcomes. Therefore, further comprehensive research is needed in this field.

Anahtar Kelimeler

• Borderline Personality Disorder
• Group Schema Therapy
• Individual and Group Schema Therapy
• Effectiveness

Borderline Kişilik Bozukluğunun Tedavisinde Grup ve Bireysel + Grup Şema Terapisinin Etkililiği: Sistematik Bir Gözden Geçirme

Öz

Borderline Kişilik Bozukluğu (BKB), bireylerin duygusal istikrarını, kişilerarası ilişkilerini ve öz düzenleme becerilerini derinden etkileyen karmaşık bir psikolojik bozukluktur. BKB'nin tedavisinde, grup şema terapisi (GŞT) ve bireysel + grup şema terapisi (BGŞT) son yıllarda giderek daha fazla ilgi görmektedir. Mevcut çalışmanın amacı, GŞT ve BGŞT’nin BKB üzerindeki etkilerini inceleyen görgül araştırmaları sistematik bir şekilde değerlendirmektir. Derleme, Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis (PRISMA) kriterleri esas alınarak hazırlanmış, “PubMed”, “ScienceDirect / Elsevier”, “Wiley Online Library” ve “PsycINFO” gibi veri tabanlarından 2009 sonrası yayımlanmış makaleler taranmıştır. Buna ek olarak, bazı makaleler elle bulunarak dahil edilmiş ve toplamda 8 çalışma terapötik etkiler açısından değerlendirilmiştir. Çalışmalar, terapi türleri, katılımcı profilleri, uygulama teknikleri ve tedavi sonuçları çerçevesinde ele alınmıştır. Bulgular, her iki yaklaşımın da BKB semptomlarının şiddetini azaltmada, yaşam kalitesini artırmada ve bireylerin genel işlevselliğini iyileştirmede etkili olduğunu ortaya koymuştur. BGŞT, özellikle intihar düşüncelerini azaltma ve semptom şiddetini hafifletme açısından daha üstün bulunmuştur. Grup terapilerinin sosyal aidiyet hissi ve duygusal paylaşım gibi unsurlarla bireylerin iyileşme sürecini hızlandırdığı; bireysel terapilerin ise daha derinlemesine çalışmalar için önemli olduğu saptanmıştır. Sonuç olarak, GŞT ve BGŞT’nin BKB tedavisinde umut vadeden yaklaşımlar olduğu görülmektedir. Bununla birlikte, tedavi süresi, yoğunluğu ve terapist sayısı gibi faktörlerin tedavi sonuçlarını etkileyebileceği ve bu alanda daha kapsamlı çalışmalara ihtiyaç duyulduğu söylenebilir.

Anahtar Kelimeler

• Borderline Kişilik Bozukluğu
• Grup Şema Terapisi
• Bireysel ve Grup Şema Terapi
• Etkililik

Kaynakça

1. Amerikan Psikiyatri Birliği. (2022). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders. American Psychiatric Publishing.
2. Arntz, A., Jacob, G. A., Lee, C. W., Brand-de Wilde, O. M., Fassbinder, E., ... Farrell, J. M. (2022). Effectiveness of predominantly group schema therapy and combined individual and group schema therapy for borderline personality disorder: A randomized clinical trial. JAMA Psychiatry, 79(4), 287-299. https://doi.org/10.1001/jamapsychiatry.2022.0010
3. Assmann, N., Schaich, A., Arntz, A., Wagner, T., Herzog, P., … Fassbinder, E. (2023). The effectiveness of Dialectical Behavior Therapy compared to Schema Therapy for Borderline Personality Disorder: A randomized clinical trial. Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics, 93(4), 249-263. https://doi.org/10.1159/000538404
4. Azizi, K., Arefi, M., Moradi, O. ve Nazemi, A. (2022). Comparing the effectiveness of family-oriented schema therapy by supportive therapy on borderline personality disorder. Chronic Diseases Journal, 10(4), 46-238. https://doi.org/10.22122/cdj.v10i4.713
5. Bohus, M., Stoffers-Winterling, J., Sharp, C., Krause-Utz, A., Schmahl, C. ve Lieb, K. (2021). Borderline personality disorder. The Lancet, 398(10310), 1528-1540. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(21)00476-1
6. Brockman, R. N., Simpson, S., Hayes, C., van der Wijngaart, R. ve Smout, M. (2023). Cambridge guide to Schema Therapy. Cambridge University Press.
7. Derks, Y. P. M. J., Westerhof, G. J. ve Bohlmeijer, E. T. (2017). A Meta-analysis on the association between emotional awareness and Borderline Personality pathology. Journal of Personality Disorders, 31(3), 362-384. https://doi.org/10.1521/pedi_2016_30_257
8. Dickhaut, V. ve Arntz, A. (2013). Combined group and individual schema therapy for borderline personality disorder: a pilot study. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry, 45(2), 242-251. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbtep.2013.11.004

9. Ditrich, I., Philipsen, A. ve Matthies, S. (2021). Borderline personality disorder (BPD) and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) revisited–a review-update on common grounds and subtle distinctions. Borderline Personality Disorder and Emotion Dysregulation, 8, 1-12. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40479-021-00162-w
10. Farrell, J. M. ve Shaw, I. A. (1990). Emotional awareness training for borderline personality disorder patients: A treatment manual (Unpublished manuscript for NIH RO3), Indiana University School of Medicine, Indianapolis.
11. Farrell, J. M. ve Shaw, I. A. (1994). Emotional awareness training: A prerequisite to effective cognitive-behavioral treatment of borderline personality disorder. Cognitive and Behavioral Practice, 1(1), 71-91. https://doi.org/10.1016/S1077-7229(05)80087-2
12. Farrell, J. M. ve Shaw, I. A. (2012). Group schema therapy for borderline personality disorder: A step-by-step treatment manual with patient workbook. John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
13. Farrell, J. M., Shaw, I. A. ve Webber, M. A. (2009). A schema-focused approach to group psychotherapy for outpatients with borderline personality disorder: A randomized controlled trial. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry, 40(2), 317-328. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbtep.2018.04.001
14. Farrell, J. M., Shaw, I. A., Foreman, T. ve Fuller, K. E. (2005). Psychotherapy in the eye of the storm: A treatment program for borderline personality disorder (Symposium presented at American Psychological Association Annual Convention), Washington, D.C.
15. Farrell, J., Shaw, I. ve Reiss, N. (2012). Group schema therapy for borderline personality disorder patients: Catalyzing schema and mode change. M. Van Vreeswijk, J. Broersen ve M. Nadort (Ed.), The Wiley‐Blackwell handbook of schema therapy: Theory, research, and practice (s. 341-358) içinde. John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
16. Fassbinder, E., Schuetze, M., Kranich, A., Sipos, V., Hohagen, F., … Schweiger, U. (2016). Feasibility of group schema therapy for outpatients with severe borderline personality disorder in Germany: A pilot study with three year follow-up. Frontiers in Psychology, 7, 1851. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2016.01851
17. Ford, J. D., Fallot, R. D. ve Harris, M. (2009). Group therapy. C. A. Courtois ve J. D. Ford (Ed.), Treating complex traumatic stress disorders: An evidence-based guide (s. 415-440) içinde. The Guilford Press.
18. Giesen-Bloo, J., Van Dyck, R., Spinhoven, P., Van Tilburg, W., Dirksen, C., … Arntz, A. (2006). Outpatient psychotherapy for borderline personality disorder: Randomized trial of schema-focused therapy vs transference-focused psychotherapy. Archives of General Psychiatry, 63(6), 649-658. https://10.1001/archpsyc.63.6.649
19. Gillespie, C., Murphy, M. ve Joyce, M. (2022). Dialectical behavior therapy for individuals with borderline personality disorder: A systematic review of outcomes after one year of follow-up. Journal of Personality Disorders, 36(4), 431-454. https://doi.org/10.1521/pedi.2022.36.4.431
20. Gunderson, J. G., Herpertz, S. C., Skodol, A. E., Torgersen, S. ve Zanarini, M. C. (2018). Borderline personality disorder. Nature Reviews Disease Primers, 4, 1-20. https://doi.org/10.1038/nrdp.2018.29
21. Hilden, H. M., Rosenström, T., Karila, I., Elokorpi, A., Torpo, M., Arajärvi, R. ve Isometsä, E. (2020). Effectiveness of brief schema group therapy for borderline personality disorder symptoms: A randomized pilot study. Nordic Journal of Psychiatry, 75(3), 176-185. https://doi.org/10.1080/08039488.2020.1826050
22. Hutsebaut, J., Willemsen, E., Bachrach, N. ve Van, R. (2020). Improving access to and effectiveness of mental health care for personality disorders: The guideline-informed treatment for personality disorders (GIT-PD) initiative in the Netherlands. Borderline Personal Disord Emot Dysregulation, 7, 16. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40479-020-00133-7
23. Iyendo, T. O., Uwajeh, P. C. ve Ikenna, E. S. (2016). The therapeutic impacts of environmental design interventions on wellness in clinical settings: A narrative review. Complementary Therapies in Clinical Practice, 24, 174-188. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ctcp.2016.06.008
24. Jacob, G. A. ve Arntz, A. (2013). Schema therapy for personality disorders: A review. International Journal of Cognitive Therapy, 6(2), 171-185. https://doi.org/10.1521/ijct.2013.6.2.171
25. Kaufman, E. A., Perez, J., Lazarus, S., Stepp, S. D. ve Pedersen, S. L. (2020). Understanding the association between borderline personality disorder and alcohol-related problems: An examination of drinking motives, impulsivity, and affective instability. Personality Disorders: Theory, Research, and Treatment, 11(3), 213-221. https://doi.org/10.1037/per0000375
26. Kellogg, S. H. ve Young, J. E. (2006). Schema therapy for borderline personality disorder. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 62, 445-458. https://doi.org/10.1002/jclp.20240
27. Koppers, D., Van, H. L., Peen, J. ve Dekker, J. J. (2023). Exploring the effect of group schema therapy and comorbidity on the treatment course of personality disorders. Current Opinion in Psychiatry, 36(1), 80-85.
28. Laursen, J., Danielsen, A. ve Rosenberg, J. (2014). Effects of environmental design on patient outcome: A systematic review. HERD: Health Environments Research & Design Journal, 7(4), 108-119.
29. Lieb, K., Zanarini, M. C., Schmahl, C., Linehan, M. M. ve Bohus, M. (2004). Borderline personality disorder. Lancet, 364, 453-461. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(04)16770-6
30. Linehan, M. (1993). Cognitive-behavioral treatment of borderline personality disorder. Guilford Press.
31. Miller, A. E., Trolio, V., Halicki‐Asakawa, A. ve Racine, S. E. (2022). Eating disorders and the nine symptoms of borderline personality disorder: A systematic review and series of meta‐analyses. International Journal of Eating Disorders, 55(8), 993-1011. https://doi.org/10.1002/eat.23731
32. Moher, D., Liberati, A., Tetzlaff, J. ve Altman, D. G. (2009). Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: The PRISMA statement. BMJ, 339, 1-8.
33. Montgomery-Graham, S. (2016). DBT and schema therapy for borderline personality disorder: Mentalization as a common factor. Journal of Contemporary Psychotherapy, 46(1), 53-60. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10879-015-9309-0
34. Nordahl, H. M. ve Nysæter, T. E. (2005). Schema therapy for patients with borderline personality disorder: A single case series. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry, 36(3), 254-264. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbtep.2005.05.007
35. Piper, W. E. ve Ogrodniczuk, J. S. (2004). Brief group therapy. J. L. DeLucia-Waack, D. A. Gerrity, C. R. Kalodner ve M. T. Riva (Ed.), Handbook of group counseling and psychotherapy (s. 641-650) içinde. Sage Publications Ltd. https://doi.org/10.4135/9781452229683.n46
36. Piper, W. E. ve Rosie, J. S. (1999). Group treatment of personality disorders: The power of the group in the intensive treatment of personality disorders. In Session: Psychotherapy in Practice: Psychotherapy in Practice, 4(4), 19-34. https://doi.org/10.1002/(SICI)1520-6572(199924)4:4<19::AID-SESS3>3.0.CO;2-L
37. Rands, A. M., Benson, D., Rapacz, A. L. ve Lloyd, T. (2024). Evidence-based group therapy for severe mental illness (SMI): Treatment for schizophrenia and borderline personality disorder. Group Dynamics: Theory, Research, and Practice, 28(3), 178-198. https://doi.org/10.1037/gdn0000220
38. Reiss, N., Lieb, K., Arntz, A., Shaw, I. A. ve Farrell, J. (2014). Responding to the treatment challenge of patients with severe BPD: Results of three pilot studies of inpatient schema therapy. Behavioural and Cognitive Psychotherapy, 42(3), 355-367. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1352465813000027
39. Roelofs, J., Muris, P. ve Lobbestael, J. (2016). Acting and feeling like a vulnerable child, an internalized “bad” parent, or a healthy person: The assessment of schema modes in non-clinical adolescents. Journal of Personality Disorders, 30(4), 469-482. https://doi.org/10.1521/pedi_2015_29_209
40. Sempertegui, G. A., Karreman, A., Arntz, A. ve Bekker, M. H. (2013). Schema therapy for borderline personality disorder: A comprehensive review of its empirical foundations, effectiveness and implementation possibilities. Clinical Psychology Review, 33(3), 426-447. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cpr.2012.11.006
41. Setkowski, K., Palantza, C., van Ballegooijen, W., Gilissen, R., Oud, M., … Cuijpers, P. (2023). Which psychotherapy is most effective and acceptable in the treatment of adults with a (sub) clinical borderline personality disorder? A systematic review and network meta-analysis. Psychological Medicine, 53(8), 3261-3280. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0033291723000685
42. Shah, A. Q., Prasad, D., Caropreso, L., Frey, B. N. ve de Azevedo Cardoso, T. (2023). The comorbidity between borderline personality disorder (BPD) and Generalized Anxiety Disorder (GAD): A systematic review and meta-analysis. Journal of Psychiatric Research, 164, 304-314. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpsychires.2023.06.009
43. Sharma, N., Srivastav, A. K. ve Samuel, A. J. (2020). Randomized clinical Trial: gold standard of experimental designs-importance, advantages, disadvantages and prejudices. Revista Pesquisa em Fisioterapia, 10(3), 512-519. https://doi.org/10.17267/2238-2704rpf.v10i3.3039
44. Simonsen, S., Bateman, A., Bohus, M., Dalewijk, H. J., Doering, S., … Mehlum, L. (2019). European guidelines for personality disorders: Past, present and future. Borderline Personality Disorder and Emotion Dysregulation, 6, 1-10. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40479-019-0106-3
45. Smith, R., Killgore, W. D. ve Lane, R. D. (2018). The structure of emotional experience and its relation to trait emotional awareness: A theoretical review. Emotion, 18(5), 670-692. https://doi.org/10.1037/emo0000376
46. Stoffers-Winterling J. M., Storebø O. J., Kongerslev M. T., et al. (2022). Psychotherapies for borderline personality disorder: a focused systematic review and meta-analysis. The British Journal of Psychiatry, 221(3), 538-552. https://doi.org/10.1192/bjp.2021.204
47. Stoffers-Winterling, J., Völlm, B. ve Lieb, K. (2021). Is pharmacotherapy useful for treating personality disorders? Expert Opinion on Pharmacotherapy, 22(4), 393-395. https://doi.org/10.1080/14656566.2021.1873277
48. Tan, Y. M., Lee, C. W., Averbeck, L. E., Brand-de Wilde, O., Farrell, J., … Arntz, A. (2018). Schema therapy for borderline personality disorder: A qualitative study of patients’ perceptions. PloS One, 13(11), e0206039. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0206039
49. Taylor, C. D. J. ve Arntz, A. (2016). Schema Therapy. A. M. Wood ve J. Johnson (Ed.), The Wiley handbook of positive clinical psychology, 1st ed., (s. 461-476) içinde. John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
50. Tracy, M., Penney, E. ve Norton, A. R. (2024). Group schema therapy for personality disorders: Systematic review, research agenda and treatment implications. Psychotherapy Research, 1-20. https://doi.org/10.1080/10503307.2024.2361451
51. Wetzelaer, P., Farrell, J., Evers, S. M., Jacob, G. A., Lee, C. W., … Arntz, A. (2014). Design of an international multicentre RCT on group schema therapy for borderline personality disorder. BMC Psychiatry, 14, 1-15. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12888-014-0319-3
52. Yalom, I. D. ve Leszcz, M. (2005). The theory and practice of group psychotherapy (5th Ed.). Basic Books.
53. Young, J. E. (1990). Cognitive therapy for personality disorders: A schema-focused approach. Professional Resource Exchange, Inc.
54. Young, J., Klosko, S. ve Weishaar, M. E. (2003). Schema therapy: A practitioner’s guide. Guilford.