Unguentaria in the Edirne Arhaeology and Etnography Museum

Yıl 2022, , 149 - 174, 30.04.2022

Taylan Doğan

https://doi.org/10.51493/egearkeoloji.1059607

Cited By: 2

Öz

The subject of this study consists of 37 terracotta unguentaria which were brought to Edirne Archeology and Ethnography Museum in various ways such as seizure, confiscation, donation and purchase. The fact that they were not unearthed as a result of systematic excavations resulted in limited data regarding their findspots. Three samples were obtained from a well on Marmara Island, and one sample came from the Edirne Old Istanbul Street Foundation Excavation. The provenance of the other finds could not be determined. Although there are fractures in some samples, most of them are fully preserved. The shortest of the unguentaria is 8.2 cm and the longest is 19.6 cm. Archaeometric analyzes of the clay were not conducted. However, it can be suggested that some of them are hard and some of them are soft in structure and lime and grit-tempered. The clay colors are red, pink, gray, brown and in different tones of these colors. The mouth and the neck of the three samples and the entire surface of one specimen were covered with glaze. Additionally, on four samples the glaze was used as a decoration element in the form of strips. Unguentaria with handles, which are rarely encountered, are represented with a single sample here. The handles are in the form of non-functional basket handles. The limited information about the findspots and the fact that no analyzes were carried out regarding the material and the clay pits, and absence of a general analysis data did not make it possible to obtain information about the production center or the workshop. From the end of the 4th century BC to the end of the 2nd century AD, they continued their existence by undergoing changes in form. Considering the form differences occurred over the course of time, unguentaria were examined under two main types and ten groups. Although partially, it is possible to follow the chronological development of the groups regarding the dates of their emergence and discontinuation. However, the fact that some groups were used synchronously for a long time makes it difficult to make precise distinctions in dating. Numerous reasons such as the fashion of the period, necessities, demands, innovative and traditional craftsmen/workshops must have played a role in the form changes that did not occur sharply and in short time intervals.

Anahtar Kelimeler

Edirne Arhaeology and Etnography Museum, Unguentarium, Hellenistic, Roman.

Destekleyen Kurum

Muğla Sıtkı Koçman Üniversitesi

Proje Numarası

-

Teşekkür

-

Edirne Arkeoloji ve Etnografya Müzesi’ndeki Unguentariumlar

Öz

Edirne Arkeoloji ve Etnografya Müzesi’ne zor alım, el koyma, bağış, satın alma gibi çeşitli yollarla kazandırılan 37 adet pişmiş toprak unguentarium, çalışmanın konusunu oluşturmaktadır. Sistemli kazı çalışmaları sonucunda ortaya çıkarılmamaları, buluntu yerlerine ilişkin verilerin kısıtlı olmasına neden olmuştur. Üç örnek Marmara Adası’ndaki bir kuyudan, bir örnek ise Edirne Eski İstanbul Caddesi Temel Kazısı’ndan gelmiştir. Diğer buluntuların nereden geldiği tespit edilememiştir. Bazı örneklerde kırıklar olmakla birlikte, çoğu tam korunmuştur. Unguentariumların en kısası 8.2 cm, en uzunu ise 19.6 cm’dir. Kilin arkeometrik analizleri yapılmamıştır. Ancak, bazılarının sert, bazılarının ise yumuşak yapıda ve kireç ile taşçık katkılı oldukları belirtilebilir. Kil renkleri; kırmızı, pembe, gri ve kahverenginin farklı tonlarındadır. Üç örneğin ağız ve boynu, bir örneğin ise yüzeyinin tamamı firnis ile kaplanmıştır. Ayrıca dört örnek üzerinde firnis, bantlar biçiminde bezeme unsuru olarak kullanılmıştır. Nadir bir biçimde karşımıza çıkan kulplu unguentariumlar, burada tek örnek ile temsil edilmiştir. Kulplar, işlevsiz sepet kulp biçimindedir. Gerek buluntu yerleri hakkındaki sınırlı bilgiler, gerek malzeme, gerekse kil ocaklarına ilişkin analizlerin yapılmamış olması ve genel bir analiz datasının bulunmaması, üretim merkezi veya atölye hakkında bilgi edinilmesini olanaklı kılmamıştır. MÖ 4. yüzyılın sonundan MS 2. yüzyılın sonuna kadar form olarak, değişikliklere uğrayarak varlıklarını sürdürmüşlerdir. Süreç içinde gerçekleşen form farklılıkları dikkate alınarak, unguentariumlar iki ana tip ve on grup altında incelenmişlerdir. Grupların ortaya çıkış ve tedavülden kalkış tarihlerinde, kısmen de olsa kronolojik gelişimi takip etmek mümkündür. Ancak, bazı grupların uzun süre beraber kullanılmış olmaları, tarihlendirmelerde kesin ayrımları zorlaştırmaktadır. Kısa zaman aralıklarında ve keskin bir biçimde gerçekleşmeyen form değişimlerinden, dönemin modası, ihtiyaçlar, talepler, yenilikçi ve gelenekçi ustalar/atölyeler gibi birçok neden rol oynamış olmalıdır.

Anahtar Kelimeler

Edirne Arkeoloji ve Etnografya Müzesi, Unguentarium, Hellenistik, Roma.

Proje Numarası

-

Kaynakça

• AHRENS et al. 2008: A. Ahrens, E. Kozal, C. Kümmel, I. Laube, M. Novák, “Sirkeli Höyük-Kulturkontakte in Kilikien Vorbericht über die Kampagnen 2006 und 2007 der deutsch-türkischen Mission”, Istanbuler Mitteilungen 58, 67-107.
• ΑΛΛΑΜΑΝΗ and ΤΖΑΝΑΒΑΡΗ 1990: Β. Αλλαμανη, Κ. Τζαναβαρη, “Πήλινες πυξίδες από τη Βέροια. Χρονολογικές ενδείξεις”, Β’ Επιστημονικη Συναντησηση για την Ελληνιστικη Κεραμικη: Χρονολογικά προβλήματα της ελληνιστικής κεραμεικής, Ρόδος, 151-159.
• ΑΛΛΑΜΑΝΗ and ΤΖΑΝΑΒΑΡΗ 1994: Β. Αλλαμανη, Κ. Τζαναβαρη, “Σχηματα αγγειων της πρωιμης ελληιστικης εποχης απο ταφικα συνολα της Βεροιας”, In: Χ. Ευνολα Εργαστηρια (Ed.), Γ΄ Επιστημονικα Συναντηση Για την Εμηνιστικη Κεραμικη, Αθηναι, 90-103.
• ALMAGRO 1955: M. Almagro, Las Necrόpolis de Ampurias. Vol. II: Necrόpolis Romanas y Necrόpolis Indίgenas, Barcelona.
• ANDERSON-STOJANOVIĆ 1987: V. R. Anderson-Stojanović, “The Chronology and Function of Ceramic Unguentaria”, American Journal of Archaeology 91/1, 105-122.
• ARGUN 2019: S. Argun, Smyrna Unguentarium Buluntuları (2007-2014), (Unpublished Master Thesis), Dokuz Eylül University, İzmir.
• AYDIN 2000: Z. Aydın, Çanakkale Müzesi’nde Bulunan Troas Bölgesi Unguentariumları, (Unpublished Master Thesis), Atatürk University, Erzurum.
• AYDIN 2001: B. Aydın, Salihli Kordon Köyü Tümülüsü ve Buluntuları, (Unpublished Master Thesis), Ege University, İzmir.
• AYDIN TAVUKÇU 2006: Z. Aydın-Tavukçu, Parion Nekropolü 2005 Yılı Buluntuları, (Unpublished PhD Thesis), Atatürk University, Erzurum.
• BALDIRAN 2015: A. Baldıran, "Stratonikeia'dan Rulet Bezemeli Unguentariumlar", In: C. Şimşek, B. Duman, E. Konakçı (Eds.), Mustafa Büyükkolancı'ya Armağan, İstanbul, 71-83.
• BALDIRAN 2016: A. Baldıran, Roulette Decorated Hellenistic Unguentaria From Stratonikeia”, In: S. Japp, P. Kögler (Eds.), Tracking the Development of Pottery from the Late Classical to the Early Imperial Periods. Proceedings of the 1st Conference of IARPotHP, Berlin, 359-369.
• BİLGİN 2018: S. Bilgin, “Perge’de Bulunmuş Geç Roma Dönemi Damgalı Unguentariumları”, In: T. Kahya, A. Özdizbay, N. Tüner Önen, M. Wilson (Eds.), Uluslararası Genç Bilimciler Buluşması II: Anadolu Akdenizi Sempozyumu, Antalya, 117-132.
• BOEHRİNGER and KRAUSS 1937: E. Boehringer, F. Krauss, Das Temenos für den Herrscherkult Prinzessinnen Palais, Altertümer von Pergamon 9, Berlin.
• BOYSAL and KADIOĞLU 1999: Y. Boysal, M. Kadıoğlu, “1997 Yılı Stratonikeia Nekropol Çalışmaları”, Kazı Sonuçları Toplantısı 20/2, 215-228.
• BOZKOVA 1997: A. Bozkova, “La céramique des nécropoles hellénistiques de Cabylé”, In: Χ. Προβληματα, Κ. Συνολα-Εργαστηρα (Eds.), Δ' Επιστήμονική Συναντηση Για την Εμηνιστικη Κεραμικη, Αθηνα, 123-127.
• BRAUN 1994: K. Braun, “Frühhellenistische Brandgräber aus dem Theonichosbezirk”, In: Χ. Ευνολα Εργαστηρια (Ed.), Γ΄ Επιστημονικα Συναντηση Για την Εμηνιστικη Κεραμικη, Αθηναι, 23-34.
• BRUNEAU 1970: Ph. Bruneau, “Tombes d'Argos”, Bulletin de Correspondance Hellénique 94/2, 437-531.
• BUCOVALA 1967: M. Bucovala, Necropole elenistice la Tomis, Constanta.
• CAMILI 1997: A. Camili, “Note Per Una Tipologia Dei Balsamari Romani A Fondo Piatto”, AEspA 70, 125-148.
• CHINELLI 1995: R. Chinelli, “Vasellame in ceramica della collezionedi Toppo”, In: M. Buora (Ed.), Aquileia romana nella collezione di Francescodi Toppo, Milano, 88-105.
• CİVELEK 2001: A. Civelek, Tralleis Nekropolisi Buluntuları Işığında Hellenistik ve Roma Dönemi Seramiği, (Unpublished PhD Thesis), Ege University, İzmir.
• ÇELİK 2007: G. Çelik, Smyrna Agorası “I-J 16/17” Sondajı Hellenistik Dönem Malzemesi, (Unpublished Master Thesis), Dokuz Eylül University, İzmir.
• DEMİR 2020: A. Demir, “Giresun Müzesi’nde Bir Grup Pişmiş Toprak Unguentarium”, Arkeoloji Dergisi XXV, 131-147.
• DOĞAN and LEBE 2021: T. Doğan, F. Lebe, “A Group of Unguentaria Preserved at the Kahramanmaraş Museum: Chronological Value of the Changes in Form”, In: O. Dumankaya (Ed.), Arkeolojik Küçük Buluntular: Pişmiş Toprak, Metal, Kemik, Cam ve Taş Eserler, İstanbul, 363-403.
• DOTTERWEICH 1999: U. Dotterweich, Unguentarien mit kuppelförmiger Mündung aus Knidos. Knidos-Studien Band I, Möhnesee.
• ΔOYɅΓEPH INTZEΣIɅOΓɅOY 1994: A. Δουλγερη Ιντζεσιλογδου, “Τα Ελληνιστικα Λυχναρια των Φερων”, In: Χ. Ευνολα Εργαστηρια (Ed.), Γ΄ Επιστημονικα Συναντηση Για την Εμηνιστικη Κεραμικη, Αθηναι, 363-388.
• DROUGOU 1991: S. Drougou, Hellenistic Pottery from Macedonia, Thessaloniki.
• ΔPOYΓOY and TOYPATΣOΓɅOY 1994: Σ. Δρουγου, Γ. Τουράτσογλου, “Τά χρονολογημένα σύνολα ελληνιστικής κεραμικής άπό τή Μακεδονία”, In: Χ. Ευνολα Εργαστηρια (Ed.), Γ΄ Επιστημονικα Συναντηση Για την Εμηνιστικη Κεραμικη, Αθηναι, 128-137.
• DUSENBERY 1998: E. B. Dusenbery, Samothrace: The Nekropoleis, Princeton.
• DÜNDAR 2008: E. Dündar, Patara IV/1: Patara Unguentariumları, İstanbul.
• ERGÜRER 2012: H. E. Ergürer, Parion Roma Dönemi Seramiği (Unpublished PhD Thesis), Atatürk University, Erzurum.
• ERGÜRER 2018: H. E. Ergürer, “Roman Pottery of Parion Necropolis”, In: D. Katsonopoulou (Ed.), Paros IV: Parosand Its Colonies, Athens, 189-198.
• EROL and TAMER 2018: A. F. Erol, D. Tamer, “Fatsa/Cıngırt Kayası 2012-2014 Sezonu Kazılarından Ele Geçen Unguentariumlar”, SEFAD 39, 267-292.
• FIRAT 2012: M. Fırat, “Isparta Müzesi Seramik Koleksiyonu: Unguentaria”, In: B. Hürmüzlü, M. Fırat, A. Gerçek (Eds.), I. Uluslararası Pisidia Araştırmaları Sempozyumu, Isparta, 294-311.
• FOÇA 2019: S. Foça, Teos Batı Nekropolisi: Mezar Tipolojisi ve Buluntular (Unpublished PhD Thesis), Dokuz Eylül University, İzmir.
• ΓIANNIKOYPH 1994: Α. Γιαννικουρη, “'Υδρίες Hadra μέλευκό βάθος άπό τή Ρόδο. Μία πρώτη προσέγγιση”, In: Χ. Ευνολα Εργαστηρια (Ed.), Γ΄ Επιστημονικα Συναντηση Για την Εμηνιστικη Κεραμικη, Αθηναι, 302-310.
• GOLDMAN 1940: H. Goldman, “The Acropolis of Halae”, Hesperia 9/4, 381-514.
• GOLDMAN 1950: H. Goldman, Excavation at Gözlü Kule, Tarsus: The Hellenistic and Roman Periods, Princeton.
• GÜRBÜZER 2016: M. Gürbüzer, “Menias’ın İdyma’daki Oda Mezarı”, Arkeoloji Dergisi XXI, 105-125.
• GÜRLER 1994: B. Gürler, Metropolis’in Hellenistik Dönem Seramiği (Unpublished PhD Thesis), Ege University, İzmir.
• GWIAZDA 2013: M. Gwiazda, “Les miscellanea de la collection du père Jean Mécérian”, Mélanges: de l’Université Saint-Jose, Beyrouth, 455-485.
• HAUSMANN 1996: U. Hausmann, Olympische Forschungen 27: Hellenistische Keramik: eine Brunnenfüllung nördlich von Bau C und Reliefkeramik verschiedener Fundplätze in Olympia, Berlin.
• HAYES 1971: J. W. Hayes, “A New Type of Early Christian Ampulla”, British School at Athens 66, 243-248.
• HAYES 2008: J. W. Hayes, The Athenian Agora XXXII: Roman Pottery Fine-Ware Imports, Princeton.
• HELLSTRÖM 1965: P. Hellström, Labraunda II/1: Pottery of Classical and Later Date Terracotta Lamps and Glass, Lund.
• HERBERT 1997: S. C. Herbert, (1997). Tel Anafa II/i: The Hellenistic and Roman Pottery: The Plain Wares and The Fine Wares, Ann Arbor.
• INDGJERD 2014: H. Indgjerd, The Grave Goods of Roman Hieropolis: An Analysis of The Finds from Four Multiple Burial Tombs (Unpublished Master Thesis), Conservation and History University of Oslo. Oslo.
• JOVANOVIĆ 2014: J. Jovanović, “Hellenistic ware from Salona-unguentaria”, In: G. Németh (Ed.), Miscellanea Historiae Antiquitatis: Proceedings of The First Croatian-Hungarian PHD Conference on Ancient History, Budapest. 89-110.
• KASAPOĞLU 2008: H. Kasapoğlu, Parion 2006 Yılı Seramik Buluntuları, (Unpublished Master Thesis), Atatürk University, Erzurum.
• KATSIOTI and NIKOLAOS 2018: “A. Katsioti, M. Nikolaos, Aspects of Pilgrimage in the Eastern Mediterranean During the Early Byzantine Period. Archaeological Evidence from Rhodes”, In: D. Ariantzi, I. Eichner (Eds.), Für Seelenheil und Lebensglück: Das byzantinische Pilgerwesen und seine Wurzeln, Mainz. 83-95.
• KHAIRY 1980: N. I. Khairy, “Nabatean Piriform Unguentaria”, The Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research 240, 85-91.
• KÖRSULU 2011: H. Körsulu, “Nagidos Unguentariumları”, Türkiye Bilimler Akademisi Arkeoloji Dergisi 14, 69-86.
• KÜÇÜKGÜNEY and TUNÇ ALTUN 2009: Z. Küçükgüney, P. Tunç Altun, “İDÇ Liman Kurtarma Kazısı (İzmir İli, Aliağa İlçesi, Çakmaklı Köyü, Kendirci Mevkii, 613 ve 68 Parsellere Ait)”, Müze Çalışmaları ve Kurtarma Kazıları Sempozyumu 17, 53-74.
• LAFLI 2003: E. Laflı, Studien zu Hellenistischen, Kaiserzeitlichen und Spätantikfrühbyzantinischen Tonunguentarien aus Kilikien und Pisidien (Südtürkei): Der Forschungsstand und eine Auswahl von Fundobjekten aus den Örtlichen Museen, (Unveröffentlichte Doktorarbeit), Universität zu Köln, Köln.
• LAFLI 2012: E. Laflı, “Roman and Late Roman Terracotta Unguentaria: 1988–2005”, In: C. S. Lightfoot, E. A. Ivison (Eds.), Amorium Reports 3: The Lower City Enclosure. Finds Reports and Technical Studies, İstanbul, 181-192.
• MARZEC 2011: E. Marzec, “Domed-mouth unguentaria from Cyprus”, In: E. Papuci Władyka (Ed.), Studies in Ancient Art and Civilization 15, Krakow, 1-158.
• McFADDEN 1946: G. H. McFadden, “A Tomb of the Necropolis of Ayios Ermoyenis at Kourion”, American Journal of Archaeology 50/4, 449-489.
• METZGER 1997: I. R., Metzger, “Die Keramik aus dem Raum B von Gebaude I in Eretria”, In: Χ. Προβληματα, Κ. Συνολα-Εργαστηρα (Eds.), Δ' Επιστήμονική Συναντηση Για την Εμηνιστικη Κεραμικη, Αθηνα, 32-40.
• MITSOPOULOS LEON 1991: V. Mitsopoulos Leon, Forschungen in Ephesos IX 2/2: Die Basilika am Staatsmarkt in Ephesos Kleinfunde: Keramik Hellenistischer und Römischer Zeit, Wien.
• MÜMİN 2009: G. Mümin, Naim Arnas Koleksiyonu Hellenistik ve Roma Dönemi Seramik Eserleri, (Unpublished Master Thesis), Trakya University, Edirne.
• ΩNAΣOΓɅOY 1994: Α. Ωναςογλου, “Νεκροταφείο των Όπουντίων Λοκρών στήν Τριανταφυλλιά Λειβανατών. Οί ελληνιστικοί τάφοι”, In: Χ. Ευνολα Εργαστηρια (Ed.), Γ΄ Επιστημονικα Συναντηση Για την Εμηνιστικη Κεραμικη, Αθηναι, 56-70.
• ÖZDİLEK 2016: B. Özdilek, “2009-2012 Andriake Kazılarından Ele Geçen Unguentarium, Şişe, Lykion ve Mortar Örnekleri”, Olba XXIV, 217-265.
• ÖZHANLI and FIRAT 2011: M. Özhanlı, M. Fırat, Side Unguentariumları Işığında Dinin Kapların Kullanım Alanları Üzerindeki Etkileri, SDÜ Sosyal Bilimler Dergisi 23, 7-30.
• ÖZÜDOĞRU and DÜNDAR 2007: Ş. Özüdoğru, E. Dündar, “Kibyra Geç Roma-Erken Doğu Roma Dönemi Mühürlü Unguentariumları”, Olba XV, 145-177.
• ΠΑΠΑΚΩΝΣΤΑΝΤΙΝΟΥ 1997: Μ. Φ. Παπακωνσταντινου, “Ελληνιστική κεραμική από τη Λαμία”, In: Χ. Προβληματα, Κ. Συνολα-Εργαστηρα (Eds.), Δ' Επιστήμονική Συναντηση Για την Εμηνιστικη Κεραμικη, Αθηνα, 50-58.
• PEMBERTON 1985: E. G. Pemberton, “Ten Hellenistic Graves in Ancient Corinth”, Hesperia 54/3, 271-307.
• RIFE et al. 2007: J. L. Rife, M. Moore Morrison, A. Barbet, R. K. Dunn, D. H. Ubelaker, F. Monier, “Life and Death at a Port in Roman Greece: The Kenchreai Cemetery Project, 2002-2006”, Hesperia 76/1, 143-181.
• ROBINSON 1959: H. S. Robinson, The Athenian Agora V: Pottery of The Roman Period: Chronology, Princeton.
• ROTROFF 1997: S. I. Rotroff, The Athenian Agora XXIX: Hellenistic Pottery: Athenian and Imported Wheelmade Table Ware and Related Material, Princeton.
• ROTROFF 2006: S. I. Rotroff, Agora XXXIII: Hellenistic Pottery: The Plain Wares, The Athenian, Princeton.
• ROTROFF and OLIVER 2003: S. I. Rotroff, A. Jr. Oliver, The Hellenististic Pottery from Sardis: The Finds Through 1994, Cambridge.
• SARAÇOĞLU 2011: A. Saraçoğlu, “Hellenistic and Roman Unguentaria from The Necropolis of Tralleis”, Anadolu/Anatolia 37, 1-42.
• SCHLÖRB VIERNEISEL 1966: B. Schlörb Vierneisel, “Eridanos – Nekropole, I. Gräber und Opferstellen hS 1-204”, Mitteilungen des Deutschen Archäologischen Instituts. Athenische Abteilung 81, 4-111.
• SLANE 2017: K. W. Slane, Corinth 21: Tombs, Burials, and Commemoration in Corints’s Nothern Cemetery, Princeton.
• SLANE and JONES 1980: K. W. Slane, R. E. Jones, “A Tiberian Pottery Deposit from Corinth”, Hesperia 49/2, 135-177.
• SMETANA SCHERER 1982: R. Smetana Scherer, “Spatklasische und hellenistische Keramik”, In: E. Walter Karydi, W. Felten, R. Smetana Scherrer (Eds.), Alt-Agina II.1: Ostgriechische Keramik, Mainz/Rhein, 56-91.
• SÖNMEZ 2015: B. E. Sönmez, “Nevşehir Müzesi’nde Bulunan Pişmiş Toprak Unguentariumlar”, 9. Uluslararası Eskişehir Pişmiş Toprak Sempozyumu, Eskişehir, 261-279.
• STOYANOV 2018: R. Stoyanov, “Pale swan in the darkness: Unguentaria from the necropolis of Tauric Chersonesos in the Crimea”, In: E. Laflı, G. Kan Şahin (Eds.), Unguentarium. A terracotta vessel form and other related vessels in the Hellenistic, Roman and early Byzantine Mediterranean, An international symposium, Izmir, 68-69.
• SULAN 2018: S. Sulan, Parion Oda Mezarları, (Unpublished Master Thesis), On dokuz Mayıs University, Samsun.
• SÜZER 2019: H. Süzer, Hellenistik ve Roma Dönemleri Sinop Unguentariumları, (Unpublished Master Thesis), Selçuk University, Konya.
• ŞAHİN and ÖZBEY 2017: M. Şahin, A. S. Özbey, Apollonia a. R. Araştırmaları/Apollonia a. R. Studies-I: Nekropol Kazıları 2016-2017, İstanbul.
• ŞİMŞEK and DUMAN 2007: C. Şimşek, B. Duman, (2007). “Laodikeia’da Bulunan Geç Antik Çağ Unguentariumları”. Adalya X, 285-307.
• TEKOCAK and YILDIZ 2015: M. Tekocak, V. Yıldız, “Akşehir Nasreddin Hoca Arkeoloji ve Etnoğrafya Müzesi’nde Bulunan Bir Grup Pişmiş Toprak Vazo”, In: E. Okan, C. Atilla (Eds.), Prof. Dr. Ömer Özyiğit’e Armağan, İstanbul, 413-432.
• TELLİ 2019: E. Telli, “Unguentarium As A Ceramic Vessel”, 1st International Aromatic Plants and Cosmetics Symposium, Iğdır. 18-23.
• THOMPSON 1934: H. A. Thompson, “Two Centuries of Hellenistic Pottery”, Hesperia 3/4, 311-476.
• TΣIMΠIΔOY AYɅΩNITH 1994: Μ. Τςιμπιδου Αυλωνιτη, “Σύνολα κεραμικής άπό τό ελληνιστικό νεκροταφείο τής Θεσσαλονίκης”, In: Χ. Ευνολα Εργαστηρια (Ed.), Γ΄ Επιστημονικα Συναντηση Για την Εμηνιστικη Κεραμικη, Αθηναι, 80-89.
• ΤΖΑΝΑΒΑΡΗ and ΤΣΙΜΠΙΔΟΥ ΑΥΛΩΝΙΤΗ 2018: K. Τζαναβάρη, M., Τσιμπίδου Αυλωνίτη, “Επείσακτη και τοπική κεραμική στη Θεσσαλονίκη των ελληνιστικών χρόνων”, Θ΄ Επιστημονικη Συναντηση Για την Εμηνιστικη Κεραμικη, 9th Scientific Meeting on Hellenistic Pottery, Θεσσαλονικη, 75-94.
• TULUK 1999: G. G. Tuluk, “Die Unguentarien im Museum von Izmir”, Anatolia Antiqua VII, 127-166.
• TULUNAY 2008: E. Tulunay, “Nif (Olympos) Dağı Kazı ve Araştırma Projesi: 2006 Yılı Kazısı”, Kazı Sonuçları Toplantısı 29/3, 79-98.
• VARMAZ 2015: Ş. Varmaz, Patara Su Yolu Çalışmalarında Ele Geçen Hellenistik Dönem Seramikleri (Unpublished Master Thesis), Pamukkale University, Denizli.
• VESSBERG and WESTHOLM 1959: O. Vessberg, A. Westholm, The Hellenistic and Roman Periods in Cyprus, The Swedish Cyprus Expedition IV/3, Stockholm.
• YAŞAR 2010: A. Yaşar, Milet Müzesi’nde Bulunan Hellenistik ve Roma Dönemi Unguentariumları (Unpublished Master Thesis), Adnan Menderes University, Aydın.
• YILDIZ 2016: V. Yıldız, “Akhisar Arkeoloji Müzesi’nde Bulunan Unguentariumlar”, CBÜ Sosyal Bilimler Dergisi 14/1, 1-24.
• YURTSEVEN 2006: F. Yurtseven, “Tarsus Köylü Garajı Mezarı Buluntuları”, Anadolu/Anatolia 31, 91-121.