Regional Cooperation And Security Issues In Central Asia

Yıl 2017, Cilt: 3 Sayı: 2, 41 - 70, 04.10.2017

Yerkebulan Sapıyev

Öz

This article examines the regional cooperation and security issues in Central

Asia in the framework of New Regionalism and Liberal Institutionalism

theories. The aim of this article is to determine Kazakhstan’s role in

strengthening cooperation in the context of Central Asian regional

cooperation and security issues. Central Asian regional cooperation and

security problems and Kazakhstan’s initiatives with regard to these topics

have also been discussed. Moreover, this study emphasizes the important

factors of cultural, psychological and communicative closeness of Central

Asian states, which are necessary for strengthening the integration and

determining common interests.

Anahtar Kelimeler

Central Asian Turkic Republics, Integration, Security Issues, Economic Cooperation

Kaynakça

• [1] Aben E.M. 1999, “Diplomatya Geopoliticheskogo Pragmatizma: KVoprosu Ob Osnovax Vneshnepoliticheskoy Strategii Kazakhstana v XXI veke”, Sayasat (Almati), no.11-12, pp.6-9. [2] Allison R. 2004a, “Strategic Reassertion in Russia’s Central Asia Policy”, International Affairs, Vol. 80, no. 2, pp. 277-293. [3] Allison R. 2004b, “Regionalism, Regional Structures and Security Management in Central Asia”, International Affairs, Vol. 80, no. 3, pp. 463-483. [4] Bayalinov K. 1994, “Ferganskaya Dolina Jdet Svoego Eskobara”, Moskovskie Novosti, no.52. 30 September. [5] Bazhanov E.P., Shustov L.D., Kabanen P.G. & Razvin P.L. 2000, Ukreplenie Bezopasnosti v Evrope/Evrazii, Moscow: Dip Akademia MID Rossi. [6] Blank S.J. 2006, “The Eurasian Energy Triangle: China, Russia, and the Central Asian States”, The Brown Journal of World Affairs, Vol.12, no. 2, pp. 53-67. [7] CII MFA RK 2011, Building a Nuclear Safe World: The Kazakhstan Way, Astana: Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Kazakhstan. [8] Cohen A. 2006, “U.S. Interests and Central Asia Energy Security”, Backgrounder, no. 1984, pp.1-11. [9] Dorian J.P. 2006, “Central Asia: A Major Emerging Energy Player in the 21st Century”, Energy Policy, Vol. 34, no.5, pp.544-555. [10] Dugin A. 2004, Evraziiskaya missiya Nursultana Nazarbayeva, Evraziya, Moscow. [11] Engvall J., & Cornell, S.E., 2015, Asserting Statehood: Kazakhstan’s Role in International Organizations, Washington DC-Stockholm: Central Asia-Caucasus Istitute/Silk Road Studies Programme. [12] Fawcett L. 2012, “History and Concept of Regionalism”, European Society of International Law Confe¬rence Paper Series Conference, Paper No. 4, pp. 2-17. [13] Golunov S. 2001, “Postsovetskie Granitsy Tsentralnoy Azii v Kontekste Bezopasnosti I Sotrudnichestva”, Tsentralnaya Azia I Kavkaz, Vol.5, no.168. pp.27-43. [14] Grieco J. 1990. Cooperation Among Nations: Europe, America, and Non-Tariff Barriers to Trade. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press. [15] Harris L.C. & Xijiang 1993, “Central Asia and the Implications for China’s Policy in Islamic World”, The China Quarterly, Vol. 2, no.133, pp.111-129. [16] Karayanni M. 2003, “Energetika – Stanovy Hrebet Politiki Rossii v Tsentralnoy Azii”, Tsentralnaya Azia I Kavkaz, no.4 (28), pp.94-105. [17] Kassenov U. 1995, “The Institutions and Conduct of the Foreign Policy of Postcommunist Kazakhstan”, in Adeed Dawisha and Karen Dawisha (Eds.), The Making of Foreign Policy in Russia and the New States of Eurasia, M.E. Sharpe, Armonk, NY. [18] Kassenov U. 1997, “Novaya “Bolshaya Igra” v Tsentralnoy Azii”, Tsentralnaya Azya I Kavkaz, no.8, pp.62-75. [19] Kharitonova N. & Vlasov A. 2007, Put k Liderstvu: Sotsialno- Ekonomicheskie I Politicheskie Reformy v Kazakhstane, Moscow: Boslen. [20] Khlupin V. 1997, Respublika Kazakhstan: Geopoliticheskie Ocherki, Moscow: Biblioteka. [21] Klimenko A. 2009, Strategia Razvitia Shanhaiskoy Organizatsii Sotrudnitchestva: Problema oborony I Bezopasnosti.Moscow: Institut Dalnego Vostoka. [22] Kim K. 2014, Lessons of Transformation for Korean Unification: Research on Unification Costs and Benefits.Seoul: Korea Institute for National Unification. [23] Koshanov A. & Khusainov B. 2001, “Problemy Integratsii Gosudarstv Tsentralnoy Azii”, Tsentralnaya Azia i Kavkaz, no.13. [24] Laumulin M. 2007, “Strategia I Politika SSHA v Tsentralnoy Azii”, Tsentralnaya Azia I Kazkaz, no. 4 (52), pp.51-63. [25] Lunev S. 1999, Vyzovy Bezopasnosti Yujnyh Granits Rossi, Moscow: Moskovski Obshestvenny Fond. [26] Mansurov T. 1997, Kazakhstan i Rossiya: Suverenizatsiya, Integratsiya Opyt Strategicheskogo Partnerstva, Russkii Raritet, Moscow. [27] Maslov V. 2000, Regionalnaya Bezopasnost, Moscow-Bishkek: Biblioteka. [28] Menon R. 2003, “The New Great Game in Central Asia”, Survival, Vol.45, no.2, pp.187-204. [29] Mukhamedjanov D. 2011, Kazakhstan i Mejdunarodnie Integratsyonnie Protsessy, KISI Under President of Kazakhstan, Almaty. [30] Mukhamedov M. 1997, Formirovanie Osnovnih Prioritetov Vneshnei Politiki Kazakhstana, Almaty: KAZGUU. [31] Narynski M.M. & Malgin A.V. 2003, Yujny Flang SNG. Tsentralnaya Azia-Kaspi-Kavkaz: Vozmojnosti i Vizovy Dlya Rossii, Logos, Moscow. [32] Nazarbayev N. 1994, Rynok I Sotsyalno-Ekonomicheskoe Razvitiye, Moscow, Ekonomika. [33] OECD 2013, Review of Agricultural Policies: Kazakhstan 2013, OECD Publishing. [34] Olimat M.S. 2015, China and Central Asia in the Post-Soviet Era: A Bileateral Approach.London: Lexington Books. [35] Olklot M.B. & Malashenko A. 2000, Mnogomernye Granitsy Tsentralnoy Azii, Moscow: Moskovski Tsentr Karnegi. [36] Powell R. 1991. “Absolute and Relative Gains in International Relations Theory”, American Political Science Review, Vol. 85, no. 4, pp. 1303-1320. [37] Sultanov B. 2005, Stanovlenie Vneshnei Politiki Kazakhstana, Almaty: Istorya. [38] Sultanov B & Muzaparova L. 2003, “Great Power Policies and Interests in Kazakhstan”, in Robert Legvold (Ed.), Thinking Strategically: The Major Powers, Kazakhstan, and the Central Asian States, MIT Press, Cambridge. pp. 187-217. [39] Sultanov B. 2013, Tamojenny Soyuz i Ekonomicheskoe Prostranstvo: Problemy Ekonomicheskoy Integratsii. KISI under President of Kazakhstan, Almaty. [40] Soderbaum F. & Shaw T.M. 2003, Theories of New Regionalism, Basingstoke: A Palgrave Reader. [41] Star S.F. 2005, “A Partnership for Central Asia”, Foreign Affairs, July/August. [42] Snidel D. 1991, “Relative Gains and the Pattern of International Cooperation”, American Political Science Review, Vol.85, no.3, pp. 701- 726. [43] Tokayev K. 1997, Pod Styagom Nezavisimosti, Almaty: MID RK [44] Tokayev K. 2001, Diplomatya Respubliki Kazakhstan, Astana, Elorda. [45] Tokayev K. 2011, “S Mneniem i Pozitsii Strany Stchitaetsya Vse Mejdunarodnoe Soobshestvo... Dorogi k Pobedam”, Kazakhstan’s state newspaper «Kazakhstanskaya Pravda» 16 December. [46] Tomberg I.R. 2006, “Tsentralnaya Azia I Kaspiyiski Region: Novy Etap “Bolshoy Energeticheskoy Igry”, Tsentralnaya Azya I Kavkaz, no.5 (47), pp. 23-41. [47] Tursunov S. 2000, Dialog Kazakhstana s OBSE, Moscow: Russki mir. [48] Vasilyeva N.A. & Lagutina M.L. 2016, The Russian Project of Eurasian Integration: Geopolitical Prospects, Maryland: Rowman & Littlefield. [49] Weitz R. 2008, Kazakhstan and The New International Politics of Eurasia, Silk Road Paper, Washington DC. [50] Yudanov Y.I. 2000, “Tsentralnaya Azia – Novy Favorit Inostrannix Investorov”, Mirovaya Ekonomika i Mejdunarodnie Otnoshenya, no.3, pp.102-110. [51] Zhulamanov N. 2013, Okhrana Granitsy – Prioritet Natsyonalnoy Bezopasnosti, Astana. [52] Internet Sources [53] Alshanov R. 2015, “Integratsya Kazakhstana i Korrektsya Ekonomicheskoy Politiki”, NOMAD, viewed 6 July 2017, <http://www. nomad.su/?a=4-201510020033>. [54] Aris S. 2013, The Foreign and Security Policies of the Central Asian States, Johnson’s Russia List, viewed 20 April 2017, <http://russialist.org/ the-foreign-and-security-policies-of-the-central-asian-states/>. [55] Chorshanbiyev P. 2014, “Rahmon, Nazarbayev decide to intensify activities of Kazakh-Tajik joint investment fund”, Asia-Plus, viewed 07 April 2017, <http://www.asiaplus.tj/en/news/rahmon-nazarbayev-decideintensify- activities-kazakh-tajik-joint-investment-fund>. [56] Dulac J. 2014, “Think Globally, Act Locally”, Apples Are From Kazakhstan?, viewed 19 April 2017, <https://gvalife.wordpress. com/2014/12/19/think-globally-act-locally/>. [57] Egorin M. 2015, “Nazarbayev: Evraziystvo – Obyedinyayushaya Ideya Dlya Vseh Jiteley Kazakhstana”, RIA Novosti, viewed 6 July 2017, <https://ria.ru/world/20150311/1051931691.html>. [58] Joshua K. 2013, “Why Did Kazakhstan Give Up Its Nukes?”,EurasiaNet.org, viewed 15 April 2017, <http://www.eurasianet. org/node/66967>. [59] Laumulin M, 2004, “Mnogovektornost Vneshney Politiki Kazakhstana – Plyusov Bolshe, Chem Minusov”, Tsentr Azia, viewed 6 July 2017, <http://www.centrasia.ru/newsA.php?st=1078126740>. [60] Laumulin M, 2006, “Geopoliticheskoe Polojenie Tsentralnoy Azii i Kazakhstana na Sovremennom Etape”, KISI, viewed 6 July 2017, <http:// kisi.kz/ru/categories/geopolitika-i-mezhdunarodnye-otnosheniya/posts/ geopoliticheskoe-polozhenie-central-noy-azii-i-kazahsta>. [61] Laumulin M. 2010, “Soyuzniki ili Partnery? Interesy Kazakhstana i Rossii v Tsentralnoy Azii”, Kontur, viewed 6 July 2017, <http://www. contur.kz/node/1508>. [62] Medetbekov A. 2011, “Ugrozy Terrorizma i Religioznogo Ekstremizma v Tsenralno-Aziatskom Regione”, Tsentr Azia, viewed 4 May 2017, <http://www.centrasia.ru/news2.php?st=1296021720>. [63] MFARK 2014, “Shanghai Cooperation Organization”, viewed 20 April 2017, <http://www.mfa.kz/index.php/en/foreign-policy/global-andregional- security/sco> [64] Naumova V. 2008, “Third Unit of Russian-Built Power Plant Introduced Into Operation”, Media Group/Tajikistan Asia-Plus, viewed 16 April 2017, <http://news.tj/en/news/tajikistan/20081105/third-unitrussian- built-power-plant-introduced-operation>. [65] Nazarbayev N. 2011, “Address by President of Kazakhstan Nursultan Nazarbayev at the 38th OIC Council of Foreign Ministers (Astana, June 28, 2011)”, viewed 07 April 2017,<http://www.akorda.kz/en/page/address-bypresident- of-kazakhstan-nursultan-nazarbayev-at-the-38th-oic-councilof- foreign-ministers-astana-june-28-2011_1341926800#page>. [66] Ramesh J. 2016, “August 29 Reminder of the UN’s Unfinished Agenda”, International Press Syndicate, viewed 30 March 2017, <http:// www.indepthnews.net/index.php/global-governance/un-insider/624- august-29-reminds-of-the-un-s-unfinished-agenda>. [67] Seidimbetov E. 2012, “O Poslanii Prezidenta RK Strategia Kazakhstan-2015: Novy Politicheskiy Kurs Sostoyavshegosya Gosudarstva”, Ministry of Justice of Kazakhstan, viewed 2 July 2017, <http://www.adilet.gov.kz/ru/node/41935>. www.adilet.gov.kz [68] World Food Program 2011, “A Regional View of Wheat Markets and Food Security in Central Asia with a Focus on Afganistan and Tajikistan”, Available at: <http://www.wfp.org/content/regional-view-wheat-marketsand- food-security-central-asia-july-2011>. [69] Zhdanov A. 2016, “Most Mejdu Vostokom i Zapadom”, Vecherny Almaty, viewed 6 July 2017, <http://vecher.kz/incity/most-mezhduvostokom- i-zapadom>.