Bibliometric Analysis of Telemedicine Research With Visual Mapping Technique

Yıl 2021, Cilt: 14 Sayı: 2, 115 - 128, 30.04.2021

Fatma Mansur , İlknur Aydın

https://doi.org/10.17671/gazibtd.813629

Cited By: 2

Öz

Telemedicine is the remote provision of health services through information technologies. Determining trends in telemedicine literature helps to determine future directions of telemedicine research. Bibliometrics is used in quantitative analysis of the literatüre. 391 scientific publications indexed in the Web of Science database were examined with bibliometric analysis and illustrated with visual mapping technique. The research trends observed in the field of telemedicine are mostly in the fields of electrical-electronic engineering, telecommunication, computer/information systems, medical informatics. artificial intelligence, health sciences/services, radiology and ophthalmology. Publications are predominantly in the form of proceedings papers and articles. The rate of increase in scientific studies varies over the years, but it does not show a steady increase. The country that contributes the most to the literature is the United States of America. India, Italy, England and the Netherlands show similar effects. It is seen that the studies of the most cited authors are conducted in the fields of teleintensive care, teletrauma, teleophthalmology and telecardiology. It can be said that many fields such as neuroscience, neurology and occupational health are among the accelerating research areas for telemedicine technologies. This study was conducted to determine the research trends in telemedicine literatüre. It is thought that the findings will guide the studies on telemedicine and will contribute to the researchers about research activities in the future.

Anahtar Kelimeler

telemedicine, remote consultation, bibliometrics

Teletıp Araştırmalarının Görsel Haritalama Tekniği ile Bibliyometrik Analizi

Öz

Teletıp sağlık hizmetlerinin bilişim teknolojileri aracılığıyla uzaktan sunulmasıdır. Teletıp literatüründeki eğilimlerin belirlenmesi araştırmaların gelecekteki yönlerinin belirlenmesine katkı sağlamaktadır. Belirli bir literatür alanı içindeki yayın örüntülerini tanımlamada bibliyometrik çalışma metodolojisi kullanılmakta olup, bu çalışmada, Web of Science veri tabanında indekslenmiş 391 adet bilimsel yayın bibliyometrik analiz ile incelenmiş ve veriler görsel haritalama tekniğiyle resmedilmiştir. Bibliyometrik analizler sonucunda, teletıp alanında gözlemlenen araştırma eğilimlerinin en fazla elektrik-elektronik mühendisliği, telekomünikasyon, bilgisayar ve bilgi sistemleri, sağlık bilişimi, yapay zeka, sağlık bilimleri/hizmetleri, radyoloji ve oftalmoloji alanlarında yoğunlaştığı görülmektedir. Yayınlar ağırlıklı olarak bildiri ve makale türündedir. Teletıp alanında yapılan bilimsel çalışmaların artış oranı yıllara göre değişmekle birlikte istikrarlı bir artış göstermemektedir. Teletıp konusunda literatüre en fazla katkı sağlayan ülke Amerika Birleşik Devletleri olup, Hindistan, İtalya, İngiltere ve Hollanda’nın da katkıları bulunmaktadır. Teletıpın klinik uygulamaları açısından değerlendirildiğinde, en fazla atıf alan yazarlara ait çalışmaların teleyoğunbakım, teletravma, teleoftalmoloji ve telekardiyoloji alanlarında yapıldığı görülmektedir. Teletıp teknolojileri için, sinirbilim, nöroloji ve iş sağlığı gibi alanların ivme kazanan araştırma alanları arasında olduğu söylenebilir. Bu çalışma teletıp literatüründeki araştırma eğilimlerini belirlemek amacıyla yapılmıştır. Elde edilen bulguların konuyla ilgili yapılacak çalışmalara yol göstereceği ve teletıp alanında büyüme kaydeden araştırma alanları ile yakın gelecekte araştırma faaliyetlerinin odağı olmaya aday konular hakkında araştırmacılara katkı sağlayacağı düşünülmektedir.

Anahtar Kelimeler

Teletıp, Telekonsültasyon, Bibliyometrik analiz

Kaynakça

• E. M. Strehle, N. Shabde, “One Hundred Years of Telemedicine: Does This New Technology Have A Place in Pediatrics?”, Archives of Disease in Childhood, 91(12), 956-959, 2006.
• C. A. Olson, J. T. Thomas, “Telehealth No Longer an Idea for the Future”, Advances in Pediatrics, 64: 347–370, 2017.
• S. Ertek, “Endokrinolojide Tele-Sağlık ve Tele-Tıp Uygulamaları”, Acıbadem Üniversitesi Sağlık Bilimleri Dergisi, (3):126-30, 2011.
• World Health Organization, M health: New Horizons for Health Through Mobile Technologies, Geneva, Switzerland, 2011.
• World Health Organization (WHO), Telemedicine: Opportunities and Developments in Member States: Report On The Second Global Survey On Ehealth 2009, Switzerland: WHO Press, 2010.
• M. M. Constantin, A. Raducan, E. Poenaru, T. Constantin, “Teledermatology Concepts and Applications in Medicine”, Revista Medicala Romana, Lxii(2), 99-104, 2015.
• The American Telemedicine Association (ATA), Telemedicine, Telehealth, and Health Information Technology. An ATA Issue Paper, 2006.
• S. Ryu, “History of Telemedicine: Evolution, Context, and Transformation”, Journal of Healthcare Informatics Research, 16(1), 65-66, 2010.
• J. Craig, V. Patterson, “Introduction to The Practice of Telemedicine”, Journal of Telemedicine and Telecare, 11(1), 3–9, 2005.
• Y. T. Yang, U. Igbal, J. H. Ching, J. B. Ting, H. T. Chiu, H. Tamashiro, Y. H. Hsu, “Trends in The Growth of Literature of Telemedicine: A Bibliometric Analysis”, Computer Methods and Programs in Biomedicine, 122(3), 471-9, 2015.
• D.A.Perednia, A.Allen, “Telemedicine Technology and Clinical Applications”,The Journal of the American Medical Association, 273(6), :483-488,1995.
• W.M.Sweileh,S.W.Al-Jabi, A.S. AbuTaha, S.H. Zyoud, F.M.A. Anayah, A.F., “Bibliometric analysis of worldwide scientific literature in mobile - health: 2006–2016”, BMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making, 17(72), 2017.
• A. H. Işık, İ. Güler, “Teletıpta Mobil Uygulama Çalışması ve Mobil İletişim Teknolojilerinin Analizi”, Bilişim Teknolojileri Dergisi, 3(1):1-10, 2010.
• J. H. Thrall, G. Boland, ”Telemedicine in Practice”, Seminars in Nuclear Medicine, 28(2), 145-57, 1998.
• J.H Thrall, ”Teleradiology Part I. History and Clinical Applications 1”, Radiology, 243(3):613-7, 2007.
• W. Backman, D.Bendel, R.Rakhit, “The Telecardiology Revolution: Improving the Management of Cardiac Disease in Primary Care”, Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine, 103(11): 442–446, 2010.
• G. Demiris, S. Speedie, S, Finkelstein, “A Questionnaire for The Assessment of Patients' Impressions of The Risks And Benefits of Home Telecare” Journal of Telemedicine and Telecare, 6(5):278-84, 2000.
• H. C. Noel, D. C. Vogel, J. .J. Erdos, D. Cornwall, F. Levin, “Home Telehealth Reduces Healthcare Costs”, Telemedicine Journal and E-Health, 10(2):170-83, 2004.
• C. Wainwright, R. Wootton, “Review of Telemedicine and Asthma”, Disease Management and Health Outcomes, 11(9), 557-63, 2012.
• N. Pérez-Ferre, M. Galindo, M. D. Fernández, V. Velasco, M. J. Cruz, P. Martín, et al, “A Telemedicine System Based On Internet And Short Message Service As A New Approach in The Follow-Up of Patients With Gestational Diabetes”, Diabetes Research and Clinical Practice, 87(2), 15-17, 2010.
• T. Lamb, N.A. Pachana, N. Dissanayaka, “Update of Recent Literature on Remotely Delivered Psychotherapy Interventions for Anxiety and Depression”, Telemedicine Journal and E Health ,25(8), 671-677, 2018.
• A. C. Seghers, K. H. Seng, M. T. Chio., et al. “A Prospective Study on Use of Teledermatology in Psychiatric Patients with Chronic Skin Diseases”, Australasian Journal of Dermatology, 56(3):170-4, 2015.
• R. S. Azfar, J. L. Weinberg, G. Cavric., et al. “HIV-Positive Patients in Botswana State that Mobile Teledermatology is an Acceptable Method for Receiving Dermatology Care”, Journal of Telemedicine and Telecare, 17(6):338-40, 2011.
• H.Yıldız, Ö. K. Abuaf, M.E.Bilgili, “Türkiye’de Dermatologların Günlük Pratiklerinde Teledermatoloji Kullanımı”, Turkish Journal of Dermatology, 1: 7-11, 2014.
• B. Delgoshaei, M. Mobinizadeh, R.Mojdekar, E.Afzal, J.Arabloo, E.Mohamadi, “Telemedicine: A systematic review of economic evaluations”, Medical Journal of the Islamic Republic of Iran,31:113, 2017.
• J. Morrison, N. K. Bergauer, D. Jacques, S.K.Coleman, G.J. Stanziano, “Telemedicine: Cost-Effective Management of High-Risk Pregnancy, Managed Care, 10(11):42-6, 48-9, 2001.
• A. Darkins, C.H. Dearden, L.G. Rocke, J.B. Martin, L.Sibson, R. Wootton. “An evaluation of telemedical support for a minor treatment centre”, Journal of Telemedicine and Telecare; 2:93–9, 1996.
• P. J. Heinzelmann, N. E. Lugn, J. C. Kvedar, “Telemedicine in the Future”, Journal of Telemedicine and Telecare, 11(8), 384–390 ,2005.
• M. G. C. Kasemodel, F. Makishi, R. C. Souza, V. L. Silva, “Following The Trail of Crumbs: A Bibliometric Study On Consumer Behavior in The Food Science and Technology Field”, International Journal of Food Studies, 5(1), 73-83, 2006.
• S.Thanuskodi, “Journal of Social Sciences: A Bibliometric Study”, Journal of Social Sciences, 24 (2), 77–80, 2010.
• E.Gall, G.Millot, C. Neubauer, “French Lag in Scientific Research On Organic Farming: A Scientometric Approach”, Innovations Agronomiques, 4, 363-375, 2009.
• N. J. Van Eck, L. Waltman, “Software Survey: VOSviewer, A Computer Program For Bibliometric Mapping”, Scientometrics, 84(2), 523-538, 2009.
• P. L. Moser, H. Hauffe, I. H. Lorenz, M. Hager, “Publication Output in Telemedicine During The Period January 1964 To July 2003”, Journal of Telemedicine and Telecare, 10:72–7, 2004.
• R. Istepanian, E. Jovanov, Y. T. Zhang, “Introduction to The Special Section on M-Health: Beyond Seamless Mobility and Global Wireless Health-Care Connectivity”, IEEE Transactions on Information Technology Biomedicine, 8(4):405–414, 2004.
• W. M. Sweileh, S. W. Al-Jabi, A. S. AbuTaha, S. H. Zyoud, F. M. A. Anayah, A. F. “Bibliometric analysis of worldwide scientific literature in mobile - health: 2006–2016”, BMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making, 17(72), 2017.
• X. Liang, Q. Wang, X. Yang, J. Cao, J. Chen, J .Huang, et al, “Effect of Mobile Phone Intervention for Diabetes on Glycaemic Control: A Meta‐Analysis”, Diabet Medicine, 28(4):455–63, 2011.
• A. Kollmann, M.Riedl, P.Kastner, G.Schreier, B.Ludvik, “Feasibility of A Mobile Phone-Based Data Service for Functional Insulin Treatment of Type 1 Diabetes Mellitus Patients”, J Med Internet Res, 9(5):e36, 2007.
• M. V. M. Figueredo, J. S. Dias, “Mobile Telemedicine System for Home Care and Patient Monitoring”, The 26 th Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society, San Francisco, USA, 3387-90, September 2004.
• F. Avcu, A. Kavak, A. Inner, “QRS Detection on IOS Platform Based on Single Channel Practical ECG Measurement for Remote Patient Monitoring”, 26th IEEE Signal Processing and Communications Applications Conference (SIU), 1-4, İzmir, 2018.
• D. M. Pacis, E. D. Subido, N. T. Bugtai, “Trends in Telemedicine Utilizing Artificial Intelligence”, 2nd Biomedical Engineering’s Recent Progress in Biomaterials, Drugs Development and Medical Devices, AIP Conference Proceedings 1933, 040009-9, 2018.
• F. Gorunescu, “Intelligent Decision Systems in Medicine ? A Short Survey on Medical Diagnosis And Patient Management”, E-Health and Bioengineering Conference (EHB), Romania, 1–9, 2015.
• E. Enginkaya, “Sağlık sektöründe Dijital Dönüşüm”, Dijital Dönüşüm Ekseninde İşletme Uygulamaları, 1.Baskı, Editör: Babacan, M., Detay Yayıncılık, Ankara, 401-425, 2019.
• I. A. Kakadiaris, M. Vrigkas, A. A. Yen, et al. “Machine Learning Outperforms ACC/AHA CVD Risk Calculator in MESA”, Journal of the American Heart Association, 7(22):e009476, 2018.
• Pakdemirli.E, “Artificial intelligence in radiology: friend or foe? Where are we now and where are we heading?” Acta Radiologica, 8(2):1–5, 2019.
• Gampala, V. Vankeshwaram, S. S. Gadula, “Is Artificial Intelligence the New Friend for Radiologists? A Review Article”, Cureus, 24;12(10):e11137, 2020.
• Internet: Sağlık Bakanlığı, Teletıp ve Teleradyoloji Birimi Genelgesi 2019/16, https://sbsgm.saglik.gov.tr/TR,56635/teletip-ve-teleradyoloji-birimi-genelgesi-201916.html, 29.01.2021.
• S.K. Pal, G.S. Pandey, A.Kesari, G.Choudhuri, B.Mittal, “Telemedicine: E-health and Hospital of the Future”, Journal of scientific and Industrial Research, 61, 414-422, 2002.
• H. Zhu, S. Mavandadi, A. F. Coskun, O. Yaglidere, A. Ozcan, “Optofluidic Fluorescent Imaging Cytometry on a Cell Phone”, Analytical Chemistry, 83(17), 6641–6647, 2011.
• E. J. Thomas, J. F. Lucke, L. Wueste, L. Weavind, B. Patel. 2009, “Association of Telemedicine for Remote Monitoring of Intensive Care Patients With Mortality, Complications, and Length of Stay”, The Journal of the American Medical Association. 23;302(24): 2671-8, 2009.
• Y. Chu, A. Ganz, “Mobile Teletrauma System Using 3G Networks”, IEEE Transactions on Information Technology in Biomedicine. 8(4):456-62, 2004.
• A. Vinekar, C. Gilbert, M. Dogra, M. Kurian, G. Shainesh, B,Shetty, et al, “The KIDROP Model Of Combining Strategies for Providing Retinopathy of Prematurity Screening in Underserved Areas in India Using Wide-Field Imaging, Tele-Medicine, Non-Physician Graders and Smart Phone Reporting”, Indian Journal of Ophthalmology, 62(1): 41:9, 2014.
• E. Bozdemir, İ. A. Çilhoroz, “Alzheimer Hastalığı Maliyetinin Bibliyometrik Analizi”. 2.Uluslararası 12. Ulusal Sağlık ve Hastane İdaresi Kongresi, 1031-1050, Muğla, 2018.
• C. L. Wittson, D. C. Affleck, V. Johnson, “Two-way Television Group Therapy”, Mental Hospitals, 12(10), 22-23, 1961.
• R.A. Benschoter, C. L. Wittson, C. G, Ingham, “Teaching and Consultation by Television: I. Closed-Circuit Collaboration”, Hospital and Community Psychiatry Journal, 16:99–100, 1965.
• R. L. H. Murphy, K. T. Bird, “Telediagnosis: A New Community Health Resource. Observations On The Feasibility of Telediagnosis Based On 1000 Patient Transactions”, American Journal of Public Health, 64(2):113-119, 1974.
• T. Hayes, A. Kinsella, N.A Brown, D.A. Perednia, “The Telemedicine Information Exchange”, Journal of Telemedicine and Telecare, 2(1):20-7, 1996.
• T.Kılıç, “e-Sağlık, İyi Uygulama Örneği; Hollanda”, Gümüşhane Üniversitesi Sağlık Bilimleri Dergisi; 6(3): 203-217, 2017.
• S. P. Sood, J. S. Bhatia, “Development of Telemedicine Technology in India: ‘‘Sanjeevani’’—An Integrated Telemedicine Application”, Journal of Postgraduate Medicine, 51, 308-11, 2005.
• S. P. Sood, J. S. Bhatia, “Development of Telemedicine Technology in India: ‘‘Sanjeevani’’—An Integrated Telemedicine Application”, Journal of Postgraduate Medicine, 51, 308-11, 2005.
• R. Ö. Doğan, T. Kayıkçıoğlu, "Remote Patient Monitoring and Electronic Health Record System Based on Web Services," 24th Signal Processing and Communication Application Conference (SIU), 1785-1788, Zonguldak, 2016. A. Vinekar, C. Jayadev, S. Mangalesh, B. Shetty, D. Vidyasagar, “Role of Tele-Medicine in Retinopathy of Prematurity Screening in Rural Outreach Centers in India - A Report of 20.214 Imaging Sessions in The KIDROP Program”, Seminars in Fetal and Neonatal Medicine, 20(5):335-45, 2015.
• A. Vinekar, S. Mangalesh, C. Jayadev, C. Gilbert, M. Dogra, B. Shetty. “Impact of Expansion of Telemedicine Screening for Retinopathy of Prematurity in India”, Indian Journal of Ophthalmology, 65(5): 390–395, 2017.
• N. D. Brunetti, L. De Gennaro, P. L. Pellegrino, G. Dellegrottaglie, G. Antonelli, M. Di Biase, “Atrial Fibrillation With Symptoms Other Than Palpitations: Incremental Diagnostic Sensitivity With At-Home Tele-Cardiology Assessment for Emergency Medical Service”, European Journal of Preventive Cardiology. 19(3): 306-13, 2012.
• N. D. Brunetti, G. Dellegrottaglie, G. Di Giuseppe, C. Lopriore, T. Loiacono, G. Gardini, et al, “YOUng Football Italian Amateur Players Remote Electrocardiogram Screening with Telemedicine (YOU FIRST) Study: Preliminary Results”, International Journal of Cardiology, 20; 176(3):1257-8, 2014.
• G. Molinari, G. Reboa, M. Frascio, M. Leoncini, A. Rolandi, C. Balzan, et al, “The Role of Telecardiology in Supporting The Decision-Making Process of General Practitioners During The Management of Patients with Suspected Cardiac Events”, Journal of Telemedicine and Telecare, 8(2):97-101, 2002.
• Internet: Journal of Telemedicine and Telecare, https://journals.sagepub.com/home/jtta, 20.05.2020.
• Internet: Ophthalmology, https://www.aaojournal.org/ 21.05.2020.
• P.Varkey, P. T. Hagen, W. Wimsett, W. Buchta, “Telemedicine Applications in Occupational Medicine, Minnesota Medicine, 89(11):46-8, 2006.
• J. M. HatcherMartin, J. L. Adams, E. R. Anderson, R. Bove, T. M. Burrus, M.Chehrenama, et al, “Telemedicine in neurology.” Neurology, 94 (1), 30-38, 2020.