VISION, REPRESENTATION AND THE DISCOURSE OF THE GAZE IN THE WAVES

Yıl 2013, Cilt: 1 Sayı: 1, 159 - 170, 20.03.2015

Tzu Yu Allison Lın

Öz

Bu makale Virginia Woolf’un The Waves adlı eserinde hem görsel semboller hem de bununla beraber sözlü semboller arasında olan ilişkiyi inceler. Bakışın anlatımı yoluyla, romanın hem iç hem de dış yapıları ressamsı bir görüş inşa eder ve bu durumu da sadece Jacques Lacan’ın psikolojik terimlerinde olduğu gibi değil, ayrıca Roland Barthes’ın semiyolojisinde de birer sembol olarak algılamak mümkündür. Bu arada bir yandan romanın karakterlerinin iç bakışları ve ayrıca yine bu karakterlerin arasındaki dikkatli bakışları, romanın iç metinsel biçimlerini ve dış metinsel biçimlerini gösterir ve buna ek olarak sözlü anlatımın da bir hayli uyumlu bir yapıya sahip olmasını sağlar. Ayrıca diğer bir yandan romanın perde arkasını biçimci unsurların bir ifadesi olarak da okuyabilmek mümkündür ve bununla beraber köklü bir manevi gerçekliği –ruh hali- göstermek için sanatsal görünümü ve sanatsal dizaynı bir araya getirir. Köklü olan sembol de kendisinin saf sanatsal yapısı ile örtüşür. Hem Duncan Grant’in Window, South of France adlı resmi gibi görsel bir sembolde hem de Virginia Woolf’un kelimelerle resim yapmış olduğu gibi, bir okuyucunun görünüm ve dizaynın uyumunu gösteren renkleri de, şekilleri de ve satırları da açıkça görebilmesi mümkündür. Hem sözlü anlatım biçimi hem de resmin kendisi insanlığın dalgalarında sanatsal oluşumun entelektüel ve duygusal yönlerini sentez yapmanın yollarıdır.

Anahtar Sözcükler: Bakış, Görünüm, Dizayn, Sembol, Biçim, Anlatım, Söylev.

VISION, REPRESENTATION AND THE DISCOURSE OF THE GAZE IN THE WAVES

Abstract: This article explores the relation between visual and verbal representation in Virginia Woolf’s The Waves (1931). Through the discourse of the Gaze, both the inner and outer forms of the novel are constructed as a painter-like vision, which can be seen as signs not only in Jacob Lacan’s psychological terms, but also in Roland Barthes’s semiotics. On the one hand, inward-gazes and inter-gazes of characters indicate the inner and the outer textual forms of the novel, providing a coherent structure of the verbal narrative. On the other hand, the interlude of the novel can be read as an expression of Formalist elements, combining artistic vision and design together, in order to show the essential spiritual reality which is known as “the state of mind”. The representation of the essential being is in its artistic pure form. In a visual representation, such as Duncan Grant’s painting, Window, South of France (1928), the reader can see the way in which colours, shapes and lines also demonstrate the harmony of vision and design in Woolf’s painting in words. Both verbal narrative form and the painting itself are ways to synthesise intellectual and emotional aspects of an artistic creation in the waves of humanity.

Keywords: Gaze, Vision, Design, Representation, Form, Narrative, Discours.

Anahtar Kelimeler

Bakış, Görünüm, Dizayn, Sembol, Biçim, Anlatım, Söylev

VISION, REPRESENTATION AND THE DISCOURSE OF THE GAZE IN THE WAVES

Öz

model. The essential character Percival holds the coherence of the whole novel. He is an abstract model, because the reader can only perceive Percival via other characters’ eyes. The image of this essential character has been shaped by multi-layered vision among other characters. In other words, Percival reveals the inter-subjectivity, which constructs the inner form of the novel. As the representation of the multi-layered vision, this character also reinforces the inter-subjectivity. Tamar Katz claims that the reader is able to find two kinds of concept, in order to define subjectivity in The Waves – one is the philosophical self – which is abstract and essential, and is detached from social, economical and cultural surroundings. The other self is defined by social codes, such as gender and class (1995: 234). Woolf’s “I” in this novelis a metaphor of “multiple subject positions” (Greene, 1999: 217).Here, I would argue, the “I” in The Waves indicates the “eye”. The narrator “I” can be seen as a way to perceive the external world. Barthes’s and Lacan’s theories of the Gaze also help to contribute to the theoretical development of the discourse of the Gaze, which is quite useful to observe the textual form of The Waves, in terms of vision and representation. In “Right in the Eyes”, Roland Barthes defined the formation of “the Gaze” (1991: 237). First of all, Barthes claimed that the Gaze is not a sign – because the sign repeats itself, so that the viewer is able to recognize it, while the sign

Anahtar Kelimeler

-

Kaynakça

• Barthes, R. (1991). Right in the Eyes. The Responsibility of Forms:Critical
• Barthes, R. (1991). Right in the Eyes. The Responsibility of Forms:Critical
• Essays on Music, Art, and Representation. Trans. Richard Howard. Berkeley: University of California Press. Bell, C. (1947). Art. London: Chatto and Windus.
• Fry, R. (1920). Vision and Design. London: Chatto and Windus.
• _____. (1996). A Roger Fry Reader. Ed. Christopher Reed. London: The University of Chicago Press.
• _____. (1998). ‘Giotto’. Vision and Design. New York: Dover.
• Falkenheim, J. V. (1973). Roger Fry and the Beginnings of Formalist Art
• Criticism. Ann Arbor: UMI Research Press. Goldman, J. (1998). The Waves: Purple Buttons and White Foam. The Feminist
• Aesthetics of Virginia Woolf: Modernism, Post-Impressionism, and the Politics of the Visual. New York: Cambridge University Press. Greene, S. (Ed.). (1999). Virginia Woolf: Reading the Renaissance. Athens:
• Ohio University Press. Johnstone, J. K. (1963). The Bloomsbury Group: A Study of E. M. Forster,
• Lytton Strachey, Virginia Woolf, and Their Circle. New York: Noonday. Katz, T. (1995). “Modernism, Subjectivity, and Narrative Form: Abstraction in
• The Waves”. Narrative 3, 232-51. Lacan, J. (1979). The Four Fundamental Concepts of Psycho-Analysis. Trans:
• Alan Sheridan. London: Penguin. _____. (1988). The Seminar of Jacques Lacan: Book I. Trans. John Forrester.
• Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Middleton, P. (1992). The Inward Gaze: Masculinity and Subjectivity in
• Modern Culture. London: Routledge. Reed, C. (1993). “Through Formalism: Feminism and Virginia Woolf’s
• Relation to Bloomsbury Aesthetics”. The Multiple Muses of Virginia Woolf. Ed. Diane F. Gillespie. Columbia: University of Missouri Press. Roe, S. (1995). The Mind in Visual Form: Sketching The Waves. QWERTY:
• Arts, Littérature and Civilisations du Monde Anglophone 5, 241-251. Shone, R. (Ed.). (1999). The Art of the Bloomsbury. London: Tate Gallery Publishing.
• Stewart, J. F. (1982). “Spatial Form and Color in The Waves”. Twentieth
• Century Literature 28, 86-107. Wallace, M. L. (2000). “Theorizing Relational Subjects: Metonymic Narrative in The Waves”. Narrative Columbus 8.3, 294-323.
• Williams, R. (1980). “The Significance of ‘Bloomsbury’ as a Social and Cultural Group”. Keynes and the Bloomsbury Group: the Fourth Keynes
• Seminar held at the University of Kent at Canterbury 1978. Eds. Derek Crabtree and A. P. Thirlwall. London: MacMillian.
• Woolf, V. (1931). The Waves. London: Harcourt.
• _____. (1947). The Moment and Other Essays. London: The Hogarth Press.
• VISION, REPRESENTATION AND THE DISCOURSE OF THE GAZE IN THE WAVES Abstract: This article explores the relation between visual and verbal representation in Virginia Woolf’s The Waves (1931). Through the discourse of the Gaze, both the inner and outer forms of the novel are constructed as a painter-like vision, which can be seen as signs not only in