A Review of Central Bank Digital Currency: Current Status and Changing Trends

Öz

Since the emergence of the Central Bank Digital Currency (CBDC), which digitally represents the legal currency of the country in which it is created, significant developments have been experienced in the global financial environment as a result of the changes brought about by the innovations. Although CBDCs offer various advantages, such as cost reduction, financial inclusion, and increasing the efficiency of payment systems, they may create some disadvantages, such as the risk of dysfunctionalization of the banking sector or decreasing the level of security. At this point, it is necessary to be aware of the possible risks it may create and to develop an optimum strategy in case such risks arise to establish a successful CBDC system and benefit from its advantages. In this context, the aim of this study is to analyze all aspects (emergence process, positive/negative sides, projects, use cases, and technical infrastructure to be used) of this digital currency and to make a comprehensive evaluation of CBDC applications around the world. The evaluations show that many countries are not indifferent to this new digital currency, which has a very high development potential, and continue their research intensively in order not to fall behind the steps taken in CBDC.

Anahtar Kelimeler

• central bank digital currency
• digital money revolution
• international financial system
• blockchain technology

Merkez Bankası Dijital Para Birimi Üzerine Bir Araştırma: Mevcut Durum ve Değişen Eğilimler

Öz

Oluşturulduğu ülkenin yasal para birimini dijital olarak temsil eden Merkez Bankası Dijital Para Birimi'nin (CBDC) ortaya çıkışından bu yana, yeniliklerin getirdiği değişimler sonucunda küresel finans ortamında önemli gelişmeler yaşanmıştır. CBDC'ler maliyetlerin azaltılması, finansal kapsayıcılık ve ödeme sistemlerinin etkinliğinin artırılması gibi çeşitli avantajlar sunmakla beraber bankacılık sektörünün işlevsizleşmesi riski ya da güvenlik seviyesinin düşmesi gibi bazı dezavantajlar da yaratabilmektedir. Başarılı bir CBDC sisteminin kurulması ve potansiyel avantajlardan faydalanılması noktasında ilgili sistemin yaratabileceği olası risklerin farkında olunması ve bu risklerin ortaya çıkması durumunda optimum bir strateji geliştirilmesi büyük önem arz etmektedir. Bu bağlamda çalışmada ilgili dijital para biriminin tüm yönlerinin (ortaya çıkış süreci, olumlu/olumsuz yanları, projeler, kullanım alanları, kullanılacak teknik altyapı) analiz edilmesi ve dünyadaki CBDC uygulamalarının kapsamlı bir değerlendirmesinin yaplması amaçlamaktadır. Yapılan değerlendirmeler, birçok ülkenin gelişme potansiyeli oldukça yüksek olan bu yeni dijital para birimine karşı kayıtsız kalmadığını ve CBDC konusunda atılan adımların gerisinde kalmamak için araştırmalarını yoğun bir şekilde sürdürdüğünü göstermiştir.

Anahtar Kelimeler

• Merkez bankası dijital para birimi
• dijital para devrimi
• uluslararası finansal sistem
• blokzincir teknolojisi

Kaynakça

1. Abogados, B. (2022). Developing a Mexico CBDC, Client Update, August 10th, 1-6, https://berdeja.com.mx/memos/Developing%20a%20Mexico%20CBDC.AUG10.22.pdf. (accessed May 13, 2023).
2. Acar Balaylar, N. (2023). Central Bank Digital Money and the Efficiency of Monetary Policy. Journal of Dogus University 24 (1): 199-216.
3. Adrian, T. and Mancini-Griffoli, T. (2021). A New Era of Digital Money. International Monetary Fund Finance and Development. https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/fandd/2021/06/online/digital-money-new-era-adrian-mancini-griffoli.htm. (accessed May 13, 2023).
4. Agur, I., Ari, A. and Dell’Ariccia, G. (2022). Designing Central Bank Digital Currencies. Journal of Monetary Economics, 125: 62-79.
5. Alfar, AJK., Kumpamool, C. and Nguyen, DTK. (2023). The Determinants of Issuing Central Bank Digital Currencies. Journal of Research in International Business and Finance, 64 (101884): 1-13.
6. Allen, F., Gu, X. and Jagtiani, J. (2022). Fintech, Cryptocurrencies, and CBDC: Financial Structural Transformation in China. Journal of International Money and Finance, 124 (102625): 1-13.
7. Arner, D., Auer, R. and Frost, J. (2020). Stablecoins: Risks, Potential and Regulation. Bank for International Settlements Working Papers, Monetary and Economic Department, 905, 1-28. Available at https://www.bis.org/publ/work905.pdf. (accessed May 14, 2023).
8. Bank for International Settlements. (2021). CBDCs: An Opportunity for the Monetary System. Annual Economic Report, June, 1-31, available at https://www.bis.org/publ/arpdf/ar2021e3.pdf. (accessed May 13, 2023).

9. Bank for International Settlements. (2021). Central Bank Digital Currencies: Financial Stability Implications. In a Series of Collaborations from A Group of Central banks, Report No. 4, September, pp. 1-27.
10. Bank for International Settlements. (2022). CBDCs in Emerging Market Economies. Monetary and Economic Department, Report No. 123, April, 1-210.
11. Bank for International Settlements Innovation Hub. (2022). International Settlements Using Multi-CBDCs (Project Dunbar), March, 1-61.
12. Bank for International Settlements, SIX Group and Swiss National Bank. (2022). Project Helvetia Phase II Settling tokenized assets in wholesale CBDC, January, https://www.snb.ch/en/mmr/reference/project_helvetia_phase_II_report/source/project_helvetia_phase_II_report.en.pdf. (accessed June 23, 2023).
13. Bank for International Settlements Innovation Hub. (2023). Project Icebreaker: Breaking New Paths in Cross-Border Retail CBDC Payments, March, 1-41. https://www.bis.org/publ/othp61.pdf. (accessed June 23, 2023).
14. Bank of Canada Media Relations. (2023). Bank of Canada Launches Public Consultations on a Digital Dollar, https://www.bankofcanada.ca/2023/05/bank-canada-launches-public-consultations-digital-dollar/May. (accessed June 23, 2023).
15. Bank of Jamaica. (2021). Ceremony for the First Minting of Jamaica’s Central Bank Digital Currency. Core Functions. https://boj.org.jm/core-functions/currency/cbdc/ceremonial-first-minting-of-boj-cbdc/. (accessed June 23, 2023).
16. Bank of Mauritius. (2023). The Central Bank Digital Currency: The Digital Rupee. Public Consultation paper, June 2, 1-4,
17. Bank of Mauritius. (2023). The Central Bank Digital Currency: The Digital Rupee, Public Notice, June 2.
18. Bank of Russia. (2020). A Digital Ruble. Central Bank of Russia Federation Consultation Paper, October, 1-44.
19. Bank of Russia. (2023). Law on Digital Ruble Adopted. Press Event, July 11.
20. Bank of Tanzania. (2023). Bank of Tanzania Progress on Central Bank Digital Currency. Public Notice, January 14. https://www.bot.go.tz/Adverts/PressRelease/en/2023011413181519.pdf. (accessed June 23, 2023).
21. Barrdear, J. and Kumhof, M. (2022). The Macroeconomics of Central Bank Digital Currencies. Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control, 142 (104148), 1-24.
22. Bech, M. and Garratt, R. (2017). Central Bank Cryptocurrencies. BIS Quarterly Review, September, 55-70.
23. Bilotta, N. and Botti, F. (2021). CBDCs: The (Near?) Future of a Cashless Economy, In the Near (Future) Of Central Bank Digital Currencies: Risks and Opportunities for the Global Economy and Society. Peter Lang Academic Publishers, 7 (1).
24. Boar, C. and Wehrli, A. (2021). Ready, steady, go? – Results of the Third BIS Survey on Central Bank Digital Currency. Bank for International Settlements Papers, Monetary and Economic Department, 114: 1-20.
25. Bouchaud, M., Lyons, T., Olive, MS. and Timsit, K. (2020). Central Banks and the Future of Digital Money. A Practical Proposal for Central Bank Digital Currencies on the Ethereum Blockchain. Contributors: Adinolfi, S., Calmejane, B., Dechaux, G. Fleuret, F. Grellet, V. Lia, J. and Singer, M., Consensys White Paper, 1-28.
26. Carstens, A. (2018). Money in the Digital Age: What Role for Central Banks. Bank for International Settlement, House of Finance, Goethe University, Frankfurt, February 6, 1-10.
27. Catalini, C. (2018). Blockchain Technology and Cryptocurrencies: Implications for the Digital Economy, Cybersecurity, and Government. Georgetown J of International Affairs, 19: 36-42.
28. Central bank of the Turkish Republic. (2021). Press Release on the Central bank Digital Turkish Lira RandD Project, September 15, 40.
29. Central Bank of the Turkish Republic. (2022). Use of Digital Turkish Lira, 29 December. Press Release, 55.
30. Chapman, J. (2022). Discussion of “The Macroeconomics of Central Bank Digital Currencies”. Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control, 142 (104149), 1-3.
31. Chen, H. and Siklos, PL. (2022). Central Bank Digital Currency: A Review and Some Macro-Financial Implications. Journal of Financial Stability, 60 (100985), 1-19.
32. Citi GPS. (2023). Money, Tokens, and Games Blockchain’s Next Billion Users and Trillions in Value, Global Perspectives and Solutions, March, 1-161.
33. Cunha, PR., Melo, P. and Sebastião, H. (2021). From Bitcoin to Central Bank Digital Currencies: Making Sense of the Digital Money Revolution. Journal of Future Internet, 13 (165), 1-19.
34. Davoodalhosseini, SM. (2022). Central Bank Digital Currency and Monetary Policy. Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control, 142 (104150), 1-22.
35. Deloitte. (2022). Central Bank Digital Currencies: Building Block of the Future of Value Transfer. 1-34. https://www2.deloitte.com/content/dam/Deloitte/in/Documents/financial-services/in-fs-cbdc-noexp.pdf. (accessed May 18, 2023).
36. Fáykiss, P., Nyikes, A. and Szombati, A. (2022). CBDC – An Opportunity to Support Digital Financial Inclusion: Digital Student Safe in Hungary. Bank for International Settlements Papers Chapters, in: Bank for International Settlements (ed.), CBDCs in Emerging Market Economies, 123, 79-87.
37. Geroni, D. (2021a). Understanding the Types of Central Bank Digital Currencies (CBDC). September, https://101blockchains.com/types-of-central-bank-digital-currencies/. (accessed February 18, 2023).
38. Geroni, D. (2021b) Blockchain Solutions for Central Bank Digital Currency (CBDC). February, https://101blockchains.com/central-bank-digital-currency-cbdc-blockchain/. (accessed February 18, 2023).
39. Grischencko, V., Ponomarenko, A. and Seleznev, S. (2023). A Feasible Approach to Projecting Household Demand for the Digital Ruble in Russia. Bank of Russia Working Paper Series, 108, 1-41.
40. Han, X., Yuan, Y. and Wang, FY. (2019). A Blockchain-Based Framework for Central Bank Digital Currency. IEEE International Conference on Service Operations and Logistics, and Informatics (SOLI), 263-268.
41. Hong Kong Monetary Authority. (2022). e-HKD: A Technical Perspective. Whitepaper in Collaboration with BISIH Hong Kong Centre, 1-49.
42. Horvath, G. (2022). Monetary Sovereignty and Central Bank Digital Currency. Public Finance Quarterly (0031-496X) 67 (4): 539-552.
43. Huang, Y. and Mayer, M. (2022). Digital Currencies, Monetary Sovereignty, and U.S.–China Power Competition. Policy and Internet, June, 1-24.
44. International Monetary Fund. (2020). Digital Money across Borders: Macro-Financial Implications, IMF Staff Reports, October, 1-48.
45. International Monetary Fund. (2022). Towards Central Bank Digital Currencies in Asia and the Pacific Results of A Regional Survey. Fintech Notes, September, 009, 1-40.
46. International Monetary Fund. (2023). IMF Approach to Central Bank Digital Currency Capacity Development. Policy Papers, April, 1-22.
47. Kim, YK. and Kwon, O. (2023) Central Bank Digital Currency, Credit Supply, And Financial Stability. Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 55 (1), 297-321.
48. Kosse, A. and Mattei, I. (2022). Gaining Momentum – Results of the 2021 BIS Survey on Central Bank Digital Currencies. Bank for International Settlements Papers, 125, 1-23.
49. KPMG. (2020). A Global Look at Central Bank Digital Currencies from Iteration to Implementation. The Block Research White Paper, August 2020.
50. Kumhof, M. and Noone, C. (2021). Central Bank Digital Currencies— Design Principles for Financial Stability. Journal of Economic Analysis and Policy, 71, 553-572.
51. Ledger Insights. (2023). Jamaican Government to Incentivize JAM-DEX CBDC merchants. https://www.ledgerinsights.com/jamaica-cbdc-incentivize-merchants-jam-dex/. (accessed June 25, 2023).
52. Lee, Y., Son, B., Park, S., Lee, J. and Jang, H. (2021). A Survey on Security and Privacy in Blockchain-Based Central Bank Digital Currencies. Journal of Internet Services and Information Security, 11 (3), 16-29.
53. Li, Z., Yang, C. and Huang, Z. (2022). How Does The Fintech Sector React to Signals from Central Bank Digital Currencies?. Finance Research Letters, 50 (103308), 1-5.
54. Lyons, RK. and Viswanath-Natraj, G. (2023). What Keeps Stablecoins Stable?. Journal of International Money and Finance, 131 (102777), 1-20.
55. Mancini-Griffoli, T., Soledad Martinez Peria, M., Agur, I., Ari, A., Kiff, J., Popescu, A., Rochon, C. contributions from Fabio Comelli, Federico Grinberg, Ashraf Khan, and Kristel Poh (2018). Casting Light on Central Bank Digital Currency. International Monetary Fund Staff Discussion Note.
56. Maynard, N. and Tetnowski, D. (2023) CBDCs A New Wave in Payments. Juniper Research White Paper, March 2023: 1-8.
57. Mzoughi, H., Benkraiem, R.. and Guesmi, K. (2022). The Bitcoin Market Reaction to the Launch of Central Bank Digital Currencies. Research in International Business and Finance, 63 (101800), 1-9.
58. Nakamoto, S. (2008). Bitcoin: A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System. https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf.
59. National Bank of Georgia. (2023). Project DGEL. Public Note, February. https://nbg.gov.ge/en/media/news/the-national-bank-of-georgia-advances-digital-lari-project-and-finalizes-expression-of-int. (accessed October 25, 2023)
60. Nepal Rastra Bank Currency Management Department. (2022). Central Bank Digital Currency (CBDC): Identifying Appropriate Policy Goals and Design for Nepal. A Concept Report (Released for Public Consultation), August, 1-78, https://www.nrb.org.np/contents/uploads/2022/10/CBDC-for-Nepal.pdf. (accessed June 19, 2023)
61. Nolting, C., Heinz, G. and Köhling, S. (2020) Central Bank Digital Currencies: Money Reinvented. Deutsche Bank Wealth Management CIO Special, September, 1-15.
62. Opare, EA. and Kim, AK. (2020). A Compendium of Practices for Central Bank Digital Currencies for Multinational Financial Infrastructures. IEEE Access, Special Section on Blockchain Technology: Principles and Applications, 8: 110810-110847.
63. Ozili, PK. (2022). Can Central Bank Digital Currency Increase Financial Inclusion? Arguments for and Against. Sood, K., Balusamy, B., Grima, S. and Marano, P. (Ed.) Big Data Analytics in the Insurance Market (Emerald Studies in Finance, Insurance, and Risk Management), Emerald Publishing Limited, Bingley, 241-249.
64. Ozili, PK. (2023). ENaira Central Bank Digital Currency (CBDC) For Financial Inclusion in Nigeria. In Springer Book titled: Digital Economy, Energy and Sustainability: Opportunities and Challenges, 41-54. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-22382-2_3.
65. Payment and Settlement Systems Department. (2023). Central Bank Digital Currency Experiments Results and Findings from “Proof Of Concept Phase 2”, Bank of Japan, May, 1-29. https://www.boj.or.jp/en/paym/digital/dig230529a.pdf. (accessed July 20, 2023).
66. Payments Canada. (2017). Bank of Canada and R3 (2017) Project Jasper. White Paper, 1-67, https://payments.ca/sites/default/files/2022-09/jasper_report_eng.pdf. (accessed February 28, 2023)
67. Perret, V. (2019). Money of the Digital Era, the Central Bank Opportunities, Risks and Impacts in Digital Currencies. Geneva: Observatoire de la finance, 1-40.
68. Popowicz, JE. (2023). The Winners of the 2023 Fintech Regtech Global Awards. https://www.centralbanking.com/awards/7958962/the-winners-of-the-2023-fintech-regtech-global-awards. (accessed July 18, 2023).
69. Presidency of the Republic of Turkey, Presidency of Strategy and Budget (2020). Eleventh Development Plan (2019-2023), 100th Year Turkey Plan, Ankara, Available via https://www.sbb.gov.tr/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Eleventh_Development_Plan_2019-2023.pdf. (accessed May 15, 2023).
70. Priyadarshini, D. and Kar, S. (2021). Central Bank Digital Currency (CBDC): Critical Issues and The Indian Perspective. IEG Working Papers, 444, 1-18.
71. Ree, J. (2023). Nigeria’s eNaira, One Year After. International Monetary Fund Working Papers, WP/23/104, 1-43.
72. Rehman, MA. Irfan, M., Naeem, MA., Lucey, B. and Karim, S. (2023). Macro-Financial Implications of Central Bank Digital Currencies. Research in International Business and Finance, 64 (101892), 1-12.
73. Reserve Bank of Australia and DFCRC. (2022). Australian CBDC Pilot for Digital Finance Innovation. White Paper, September, 1-14, rba.gov.au/payments-and-infrastructure/central-bank-digital-currency/pdf/australian-cbdc-pilot-for-digital-finance-innovation-white-paper.pdf. (accessed October 4, 2023).
74. Rojas-Breu, M (2022). Discussion of “Central Bank Digital Currency and Monetary Policy”. Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control, 142, (104151): 1-3.
75. Sethaput, V. and Innet, S. (2023). Blockchain Application for Central Bank Digital Currencies (CBDC). Cluster Computing, Springer, Published online on January 16.
76. Shen, W. and Hou, L. (2021). China’s Central Bank Digital Currency and Its Impacts on Monetary Policy and Payment Competition: Game Changer or Regulatory Toolkit?. Computer Law and Security Review, 41 (105577), 1-12.
77. Soderberg, G. in collaboration with Marianne Bechara, Wouter Bossu, Natasha Che, Sonja Davidovic, John Kiff, Inutu Lukonga, Tommaso Mancini-Griffoli, Tao Sun, and Akihiro Yoshinaga. (2022). Behind The Scenes Of Central Bank Digital Currency Emerging Trends, Insights, And Policy Lessons. Fintech Notes (International Monetary Fund), 004, February, 1-27.
78. Sveriges Riksbank. (2023). E-Krona Pilot, Phase 3. E-krona Report, 1-34. https://www.riksbank.se/globalassets/media/rapporter/e-krona/2023/e-krona-pilot-phase-3.pdf. . (accessed March 5, 2023).
79. Syed, M. (2023) The Design and Deployment of CBDCs on Blockchain Based Technology, https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/design-deployment-cbdcs-blockchain-based-technology-mustafa-syed/. (accessed June 11, 2023).
80. Tan, BJ. (2023). Central Bank Digital Currency and Financial Inclusion. International Monetary Fund Working Paper, WP/23/69, March 2023, 1-52. https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/WP/Issues/2023/03/18/Central-Bank-Digital-Currency-and-Financial-Inclusion-531104. (accessed October 14, 2023).
81. Tata, F. (2023). Proposing an Interval Design Feature to Central Bank Digital Currencies. Research in International Business and Finance, 64 (101898), 1-13.
82. Terták, E. and Kovács, L. (2022). The Motives for Issuing Central Bank Digital Currency and the Challenges of Introduction Thereof. Public Finance Quarterly, 491-505.
83. Turkey Informatics Foundation. (2022). New Forms of Trade: Centre Bank Evaluation Report on Digital Currency. Blockchain Turkey, Banking, Finance and Insurance Working Group, November, 1-23. https://bctr.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/11/MBRaporuV03.pdf. (accessed March 15, 2023).
84. Williamson, SD. (2022). Central Bank Digital Currency and Flight to Safety. Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control, 142 (104146), 1-25.
85. Xia, H., Gao, Y. and Zhang, ZJ. (2023). Understanding the Adoption Context of China’s Digital Currency Electronic Payment. Journal of Financial Innovation, 9 (63), 1-27.
86. Zhang, T. and Huang, Z. (2022). Blockchain and Central Bank Digital Currency. ICT Express, 8, 264-270.
87. https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/cbdctracker/ (accessed February 15, 2023).
88. https://cbdctracker.org/ (accessed February 28, 2023).
89. https://cbdctracker.org/currency/sweden-e-krona. (accessed March 5, 2023).
90. https://cbdctracker.org/currency/israel-e-shekel. (accessed March 11, 2023).
91. https://www.centralbanking.com/awards/7958962/the-winners-of-the-2023-fintech-regtech-global-awards. (accessed August 13, 2023).
92. https://data.worldbank.org/country. (accessed October 24, 2023).
93. https://www.ledgerinsights.com/jamaica-cbdc-incentivize-merchants-jam-dex/. (accessed June 19, 2023)