Comparison of the Effects of Augmented Reality and Computed Tomography in the Assessment of Intra-articular Distal Humerus Fractures According to Years of Expertise

Öz

Objective: The aim of this study was to compare augmented reality (AR) and computed tomography (CT) in terms of diagnostic accuracy (DA), response time (RT), and surgical planning time (SPT) during the assessment of intra-articular distal humerus fractures by orthopedic and traumatology specialists and to evaluate the influence of specialist experience on these outcomes.

Materials and Methods: A total of 28 orthopedic and traumatology specialists from a single public training and research hospital were included in this comparative observational study. Participants were categorized according to experience after completion of specialty training: ≤5 years (Junior specialists (JUN), n=14) and >5 years (Senior specialists (SEN), n=14). Seven intra-articular distal humerus fracture cases classified according to the Jupiter and Milch systems were evaluated using CT images and CT-derived AR models. The cases were presented in randomized order within each modality; CT assessment was performed first, followed by AR assessment. Participants identified the fracture type and planned the surgical approach. DA, RT, and SPT were recorded and compared between modalities and experience groups.

Results: Mean DA was 86.8% with CT and 90.4% with AR, with no statistically significant difference (p=0.257). Mean RT was significantly shorter with AR than with CT (61.8±13.1 s vs. 77.0±21.4 s; p<0.05), whereas mean SPT did not differ significantly (197.0±63.8 s vs. 182.0±88.4 s; p=0.244). The SEN group demonstrated higher DA and shorter RT than the JUN group with both modalities. SPT with CT was shorter in the SEN group, whereas SPT with AR did not differ between experience groups.

Conclusion: AR produced no statistically significant difference in diagnostic accuracy compared with CT and was associated with a shorter response time. Because CT was always assessed before AR, the findings should be interpreted as the additional value of AR after standard CT review rather than as evidence of the independent superiority of AR. AR may serve as a complementary assessment tool, particularly for less experienced specialists.

Anahtar Kelimeler

• Augmented reality
• computed tomography
• distal humerus fractures
• diagnostic accuracy
• surgical planning
• orthopedic education

Kaynakça

1. Zakaria I. Assessing fracture detection: a comparison of minimal-resource and standard-resource plain radiographic interpretations. Diagnostics (Basel) 2025;15(7):876. google scholar
2. Fereidooni R. Diagnostic accuracy of plain radiographs compared to CT scans in classifying talus injuries. BMC Musculoskelet Disord 2025;26(1):891. google scholar
3. Misselyn D, Schepers T, Buckley R, Swords M, Matricali G, Nijs S. Three-dimensional imaging of displaced intra-articular calcaneal fractures correlates with the perioperative diagnosis. Foot Ankle Orthop 2021;6(3):24730114211019729. google scholar
4. Huflage H, Fieber T, Färber C, Knarr J, Veldhoen S, Jordan MC, et al. Interobserver reliability of scapula fracture classifications in intra- and extra-articular injury patterns. BMC Musculoskelet Disord 2022;23(1):189. google scholar
5. Mansour EZ, Saiz AM Jr. Feasibility of augmented reality in orthopedic trauma care: A narrative review of current applications. Cureus 2025;17(9):e92088. google scholar
6. Luigi-Martínez HE, Layuno-Matos JG, Fernández-Vélez NA, Fernández-Soltero R, Señeriz-Ortiz R. Artificial intelligence and augmented reality in orthopedic surgery: A narrative review of current applications and future directions. Cureus 2025;17(12):e100177. google scholar
7. Mastour H, Choubdaran E, Abbasi B, Khadem-Rezaiyan M. Augmented reality for training on commonly missed extremity fractures: A study on the efficacy of technology-enhanced health professions education in learning outcomes and experience. BMC Med Educ 2025;25(1):1239. google scholar
8. Coxe FR, Stauffer TP, Ast MP. Virtual reality simulation in orthopedic surgery education improves immediate procedural skill and knowledge acquisition, but evidence on cost-effectiveness and skill retention remains lacking. Curr Rev Musculoskelet Med 2025;18(10):363-78. google scholar

9. Matthews JH, Shields JS. The clinical application of augmented reality in orthopaedics: where do we stand? Curr Rev Musculoskelet Med 2021;14(5):316-9. google scholar
10. Montemagno M, Testa G, Panvini FMC, Puglisi G, Papotto G, Marchese E, et al. The novel impact of augmented reality and 3d printing in the diagnosis of complex acetabular fractures: A comparative randomized study in orthopedic residents. J Clin Med 2024;13(11):3059. google scholar
11. Colcuc C, Miersbach M, Cienfuegos M, Grüneweller N, Vordemvenne T, Wähnert D. Comparison of virtual reality and computed tomography in the preoperative planning of complex tibial plateau fractures. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg 2024;144(6):2631-9. google scholar
12. Bitschi D, Fürmetz J, Gilbert F, Jörgens M, Watrinet J, Pätzold R, et al. Preoperative mixed-reality visualization of complex tibial plateau fractures and its benefit compared to CT and 3D printing. J Clin Med 2023;12(5):1785. google scholar
13. Masouros PT, Mitrogiannis G, Antoniou G, Chatzidaki C, Kourtzis D, Garnavos C. Interobserver reliability of Schatzker, AO Foundation-Orthopaedic Trauma Association, and Luo Classifications for tibial plateau fractures: Does three-dimensional CT improve outcomes? Cureus 2022;14(2):e22227. google scholar
14. Karamian BA, Schroeder GD, Levy HA, Canseco JA, Benneker LM, Kandziora F, et al. The influence of surgeon experience and subspeciality on the reliability of the AO spine sacral classification system. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 2021;46(24):1705-13. google scholar
15. Vosoughi F, Menbari Oskouie I, Rahimdoost N, Kasaeian A, Sherafat Vaziri A. Intrarater and inter-rater reliability of tibial plateau fracture classifications: Systematic review and meta-analysis. JB JS Open Access 2024;9(4):e23.00181. google scholar
16. Dünki A, Polat Ö, Güney M. The effect of 3D models created with augmented reality on diagnosis and orthopedic resident education of tibial plateau fractures. Namik Kemal Med J 2025;13(3):287-92. google scholar
17. Dust T, Henneberg JE, Hartel MJ, Ballhause TM, Arras C, Strahl A, et al. Mixed reality enhances interobserver reliability in tibial plateau fracture classification compared to computed tomography, 3D computed tomography and 3D printing. J Exp Orthop 2025;12(4):e70474. google scholar
18. Jupiter JB, Mehne DK. Fractures of the distal humerus. Orthopedics 1992;15(7):825-33. google scholar
19. Milch H. Fractures and fracture-dislocations of the humeral condyles. J Trauma 1964;4(5):592-607. google scholar