Dr.Osman Şevki Uludağ disputes Professor Fuat Köprülü’s review of Science among the Ottoman Turks by A.Adıvar

Yıl 2007, Cilt: 8 Sayı: 2, 90 - 109, 01.06.2007

Nuran Yıldırım

Öz

When published in 1943, Dr. Adnan Adıvar’s Osmanlı Türklerinde İlim
(Science among the Ottoman Turks) met favorable criticism, especially from
Professor Dr. M. Fuat Köprülü who praised Adıvar’s work for his objectivity.
On the other hand, Köprülü pointed out that some authors, devoid of criticism,
used to describe Ottoman history of science and medicine as imaginary and
nationalistic. The medical historian Dr. Osman Sevki Uludağ whose works were
referred to by Dr. A.Adıvar in his Science among the Ottoman Turks, published
in the daily Tasvîr-i Efkâr a series of articles pointing to Adıvar’s shortcomings
regarding Turkish medical history. In these articles Dr. Osman Şevki also
responded to Fuat Köprülü’s general assessment of studies on Turkish history of medicine to date. The present paper aims to bring to light the criticism
forwarded by F.Köprülü, A.Adıvar and O.Ş. Uludağ and re-evaluate based on
present day researches.

Anahtar Kelimeler

sman Şevki Uludağ, Adnan Adıvar, Fuat Köprülü, Science among the Ottoman Turks, Turkish medical history

Osmanlı Türklerinde İlim Üzerinden O. Şevki Uludağ - Fuat Köprülü Tartışması ve O. Şevki Uludağ’dan A. Adnan Adıvar’a Eleştiriler

Öz

When published in 1943, Dr. Adnan Adıvar’s Osmanlı Türklerinde İlim (Science among the Ottoman Turks) met favorable criticism, especially from Professor Dr. M. Fuat Köprülü who praised Adıvar’s work for his objectivity. On the other hand, Köprülü pointed out that some authors, devoid of criticism, used to describe Ottoman history of science and medicine as imaginary and nationalistic. The medical historian Dr. Osman Sevki Uludağ whose works were referred to by Dr. A.Adıvar in his Science among the Ottoman Turks, published in the daily Tasvîr-i Efkâr a series of articles pointing to Adıvar’s shortcomings regarding Turkish medical history. In these articles Dr. Osman Şevki also responded to Fuat Köprülü’s general assessment of studies on Turkish history of medicine to date. The present paper aims to bring to light the criticism forwarded by F.Köprülü, A.Adıvar and O.Ş. Uludağ and re-evaluate based on present day researches.

Anahtar Kelimeler

Osman Şevki Uludağ, Adnan Adıvar, Fuat Köprülü, Osmanlı Türklerinde İlim, Türk tıp tarihi

Kaynakça

• -