James Bryce’ın Ermeni Sorunu’ndaki Rolü

Yıl 2024, Sayı: 83, 169 - 191, 02.08.2024

Fahriye Begüm Yildızeli

https://doi.org/10.26650/iutd.20241450659

Öz

Büyük Britanya tarihinin en ihtişamlı çağı olarak nitelendirilen Kraliçe Viktorya döneminde kültürel emperyalist politikaların uygulanmaya başlanması ile birlikte İngiliz aristokratlarının temel hedeflerinden biri Osmanlı İmparatorluğu’nda yaşayan gayrimüslimler olmuştur. İrlandalı akademisyen, diplomat ve politikacı James Bryce, Ermeni Sorunu ve Türk düşmanlığı üzerine ciddi bir kamuoyu oluşturulmasını sağlayan önemli propagandistlerdendir. 1870’li yıllardan itibaren İngiltere’nin Ermeni Sorunu’nda etkin olması için yaptığı çalışmaların yanı sıra 1893 yılında İngiliz-Ermeni Derneği’ni kurmuştur. 1915 yılında İngiliz Hükümeti’nin isteği üzerine Ermeni katliam iddialarını güçlendirmeyi amaçlayan Bryce, tarihçi Arnold J. Toynbee ile Blue Book (Mavi Kitap) isimli eseri yayımlayarak propaganda faaliyetlerinin sistematik bir biçimde ilerlemesine katkıda bulunan önemli bir aktördür. 84 yıllık yaşamı boyunca tarih, hukuk ve diplomasi ile ilgilenen James Bryce’ın çok yönlü politik kimliği onu Liberal Parti’nin önde gelen otoritelerinden biri haline getirmiştir. Siyasi kariyerinin yanı sıra Bryce, İngilizlerin Ermeni Sorunu politikasının psikolojik dinamiklerini gündemde tutmaya çalışmıştır. Bu çalışma, Bryce’in Ermeni Sorununun uluslararası düzeye taşınmasında düşüncelerini analiz ederek siyasal iletişim faaliyetlerinin İngiliz ve Amerikan kamuoyundaki etkilerini değerlendirecektir.

Anahtar Kelimeler

Ermeni Sorunu, Mavi Kitap, James Bryce, İngiliz-Ermeni Derneği

James Bryce’s Role in the Armenian Question

Öz

With the implementation of cultural imperialist policies during the reign of Queen Victoria, which is described as the most glorious era in the history of Great Britain, one of the main targets of the British aristocrats was the Christian minorities in the Ottoman Empire. Irish academician, diplomat, and politician James Bryce is one of the important propagandists who helped to create public opinion on the Armenian Question and Turkish hostility. In addition to his efforts to ensure that England was active in the Armenian Question since the 1870s, he founded the Anglo-Armenian Association in 1893. Bryce, who aimed to strengthen the so-called Armenian massacre allegations at the request of the British Government in 1915, is an important actor who contributed to the systematic advancement of propaganda activities by publishing the work called Blue Book with the historian Arnold J. Toynbee. James Bryce’s versatile political identity, who has been interested in history, law, and diplomacy throughout his 84 years of life, has made him one of the leading authorities of the Liberal Party. In addition to his political career, Bryce tried to keep the psychological dynamics of the British policy on the Armenian Question on the agenda. This study will analyse Bryce’s thoughts on bringing the Armenian Question to the international level and evaluate the effects of his political communication activities on the British and American public.

Anahtar Kelimeler

Armenian Question, Blue Book, James Bryce, British-Armenian Association

Kaynakça

• Hansard House of Commons (HC) ve House of Lords (HC) Parliamentary Debates Arşivi, Online versiyon, http://hansard.millbanksystems.com/ (Erişim Tarihi: 03.03 2024). google scholar
• HC Deb 07 April 1884 vol 286 c1789 “Turkey in Asia-American Schools in Armenia” google scholar
• HC Deb 28 May 1889 vol 336 cc1309-24 “Cruelties in Armenia” google scholar
• HC Deb 21 August 1895 vol. 36, col. 475, “Armenian Christians” google scholar
• HL Deb 13 November 1918 vol 32 cc34-42, “Armenia and Cilicia” google scholar
• HL Deb 17 December 1919 vol 38 cc279-300 “Turkish Rule in Armenia” google scholar
• The National Archives (TNA) google scholar
• C932, INF 4, Ministry of Information and Predecessors: War of 1914 to 1918 Information Services, 19151943. google scholar
• Eastern Question Association: Report of Proceedings of the National conference at St. James Hall, London Direction of the Committe by James Clarke & Co., 13&14 Fleet Street, s. a-2. google scholar
• “The Case for the Armenians: with an introduction by F.S. Stevenson ... and a full report of the speeches delivered at the Banquet in honour of the Right Hon. J. Bryce ... May 12th, 1893”, The Anglo-Armenian Association, Harrison and Sons, printers in ordinary to her Majesty, St. Martins’s Lane., London 1893. google scholar
• “Armenians and Baku”, Letters exchanged between Lord Robert Cecil and Viscount Bryce., Reprinted from The Daily Telegraph 1918. google scholar
• George, Lloyd, Clemenceau, M., Balfour, A. J., Cecil, Lord Robert, Bryce, Viscount and Allenby, General, “Armenia’s Charter, An Appreciation of the Services of Armenians to the Allied Cause”, (Letters exchanged between Lord Robert Cecil and Viscount Bryce Reprinted from the Westminster Gazette 1918. google scholar
• Avşar, Servet, Birinci Dünya Savaşı’nda İngiliz Propagandası, Kim Yayınları, Ankara 2004. google scholar
• Bağçeci, Yahya, “İngiltere Başbakanı Lord Salisbury ve Ermeni Meselesi”, Erciyes Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Enstitüsü Dergisi, sayı 1(35) (2013), s.190-208. google scholar
• Bayrakdar, Bayram, “Tarih ve Propaganda: Morgenthau’nun Öyküsü ve Mavi Kitap Örneği”, Çağdaş Türkiye Tarihi Araştırmaları Dergisi, XVI/33 (2016-Güz), 135-161. google scholar
• Bryce, James, The Holy Roman Empire, The Macmillian Company, London 1904. google scholar
• ____, James, “On Armenia and Mount Ararat”, Proceedings of the Royal Geographical Society of London, sayı 22, No. 3 (1877 - 1878), 169-186. google scholar
• _____, James, Transcaucasia and Ararat: Being Notes of a Vacation Tour in the Autumn of 1876, Macmillan and Co. Publishing, London 1896. google scholar
• _____, James, The American Commonwealth, Macmillan and Co., 3 vols., London 1888. google scholar
• _____, James, “Report of the Committee on Alleged German Outrages [and Appendix, Great Britain. Committee on Alleged German Outrages”, H.M. Stationery Off., Eyre and Spottiswoode, Ltd., printers, London 1915. google scholar
• _____, James, “The Future of Armenia”, The Contemporary Review Sayı 114(1918), 604-611, google scholar
• Boyajian, Zabelle C-Raffi, Aram, Armenian Legends and Poems, The Project Gutenberg EBook, 2017. google scholar
• Buenos, Tal, “Social Darwinizm and the Eastern Question”, Review of Armenian Studies, sayı 12(Ankara 2012), 7-23. google scholar
• Çabuk, Mustafa, “İngiltere’nin Birinci Dünya Savaşı’nda ABD’de de yürüttüğü Ermeni propagandası”, Celal Bayar Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Dergisi, (Mart 2019), 307-330. google scholar
• Çeken, Mehmet Batuhan, “1894 Sason İsyanı’nın İngiliz Basınına Yansımaları”, OTAM, sayı 51(2022), s.75-98. google scholar
• Encyclopedia Britannica, The Encyclopedia Britannica Company, Sayı 30, London & New York 2016. google scholar
• Engin, Vahdettin, “Sultan II. Abdülhamid’e Düzenlenen Ermeni Suikasti ve Bu Sebeple Belçika ile Yaşanan Diplomatik Kriz”,Belleten, Sayı 59, 1995, 413-428. google scholar
• Erdagöz, Hakan, “Reading the Eastern Question through the Prism of Orientalism: Hubris, Founding Genealogy and James Bryce”, Journal of Muslim Minority Affairs, Sayı 39:3(2009), 317-342. google scholar
• Fisher, Herbert, James Bryce, vol. II, Macmillan Company, New York 1927. google scholar
• Gürün, Kâmuran, Ermeni Dosyası, Rüstem Yayınları, Lefkoşa 2001. google scholar
• Hacobian, A. P., Armenia and the War: An Armenian’s Point of View, With an Appeal to Britain and the Coming Peace Conference, G. H. Doran Company, New York 1917. google scholar
• Kılıç, Osman, “Mavi Kitap: Ermeni İddialarının Kutsal Kitabı”, Ermeni Araştırmaları Dergisi, sayı 31(2008), 81-103. google scholar
• McCarthy, Justin, “I. Dünya Savaşı’nda İngiliz Propagandası ve Bryce Raporu”, ed. Hasan Celal Güzel Osmanlı’dan Günümüze Ermeni Sorunu, Yeni Türkiye Yayınları, İstanbul 2006, 23-39. google scholar
• ________, Justin, “İngiliz Propagandası, Wellington Evi ve Türkler’’, Türkler, Cilt XIII, Yeni Türkiye Yayınları, Ankara 2002. google scholar
• Özdemir, Hikmet, “Arnold Toynbee’nin Ermeni Sorununa Bakışı”, Türkiye Bilimler Akademisi Forumu 34(2005). google scholar
• Özgiray, Ahmet, “Arnold J. Toynbee ve James Bryce’nin Hazırladığı “Treatment of the Armenıans in the Ottoman Empire (1915-1916)” adlı Kitap Üzerine”, Atatürk Araştırma Merkezi Dergisi, sayı 53(2002), 713-27. google scholar
• Uras, Esat, Tarihte Ermeniler ve Ermeni Meselesi, İstanbul 1987. google scholar
• Robbins, Keith G. , “Lord Bryce and the First World War”, The Historical Journal, sayı 10(1967), 255-278. google scholar
• Ryley, Jameson, “The Historian Who Sold Out: James Bryce and the Bryce Report”, Iowa Historical Review, Sayı 1, 60-85. google scholar
• Sonyel, Salâhi R., “Birinci Dünya Savaşı Günlerinde Türk-Ermeni İlişkileri ve İngiliz Propagandası”, Belleten, vol. 58(1994), 377-80. google scholar
• _____; Salahi R., “The Centenary of Cyprus Convention, “In The Light of British Foreign Office Documents: How Abdulhamit, The Ottoman Sultan, Leased Cyprus To Britain Within Forty- Eight Hours”, Belleten, sayı 42(1978), 745-760. google scholar
• Startt, James, “James Bryce and the Promise of the American Press, 1888-1921”, eds. Joel H Wiener, Mark Hampton, Anglo-American Media Interactions, 1850-2000, Palgrave Macmillan, London 2007. google scholar
• Steinberg, Oded Y., “The Confirmation of the Worst Fears: James Bryce, British Diplomacy and the Armenian Massacres of 1894-1896”, Etudes armeniennes contemporaines, sayı 11(2018), 1-34. google scholar
• _______, Oded, “The Origins of the Armenian Question”, Journal of Levantine Studies(Winter 2015). google scholar
• Şahin, Enis, “Bir Ermeni Propaganda Klasiği: Mavi Kitap (Blue Book),” (Erişim Tarihi: 22.08.2019, http:// turksandarmenians.marmara.edu.tr google scholar
• Toynbee, Arnold-Bryce, James, The Treatment of Armenians in the Ottoman Empire, 1915-16 : Documents Presented to Viscount Grey of Fallodon, Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs, by Viscount Bryce. Boston Public Library. H.M. Stationery Off., Sir Joseph Causton and Sons Great Britain. Foreign Office, London 1916. google scholar
• _______, Arnold J., Armenian Atrocities: The Murder of a Nation, Hodder and Stoughton, London 1915. google scholar
• _______, Arnold J., The Western Question in Greece and Turkey, A Study in the Contact of Civilisations, London 1922. google scholar
• Wilson, Trevor, “Lord Bryce’s Investigation into Alleged German Atrocities in Belgium, 1914-15”. Journal of Contemporary History, Sayı 14(July 1979), 369-383. google scholar
• Wirtwein, Walter W., Britain and the Balkan Crisis 1875-1878, Columbia University Press, London 1935. google scholar
• Yavuz, Fikrettin-İskifeyeli, Zeynep, “İstanbul Ermeni Patrikhanesi’nin Berlin Kongresi’ne Gönderdiği Heyetin Avrupa’daki Faaliyetleri”, Belleten, sayı 84 (299)(Nisan 2020), 357-398. google scholar