TURKEY AND NATO: QUESTIONING THE SOLIDARITY

Yıl 2021, Cilt: 1 Sayı: 2, 130 - 148, 28.12.2021

Mehmet Seyfettin Erol Şafak Oğuz

Öz

Turkey and NATO have been going through a complex and complicated relation especially after Turkey has decided to buy first Chinese Air Defense Systems and then S-400 Air Defense Systems from Russian Federation. The Alliance's reaction with the expression of Secretary General Stoltenberg has been mild so far highlighting that the procurement of defence systems is a national decision. Individual member states, especially the US, however, have been vehemently opposing Turkey’s decision and the US has resorted to several measures, such as removing Turkey from the F-35 program or imposing sanctions under the Countering America's Adversaries Through Sanctions Act (CAATSA). Turkey’s main argument that member states, namely the US, denied selling Turkey Air Defense System, such as Patriots and they did not consider technological transfer to Turkey, which has been regarded by Turkey as a key factor for the procurement, was overlooked by Allies. The critics even included questioning Turkey's NATO membership.
Turkey’s cooperation in recent with the Russian Federation, including procurement of defence systems, has been criticized by the West as well as among scholars and politicians in Turkey. Turkish officials, including President Erdogan and Defense Minister Akar, however, insistently underlined Turkey’s position in the Alliance and Turkey’s decisiveness for the membership. This paper analyses the relations between Turkey and NATO in the light of the recent crisis and argues that Turkey, as clearly states by Turkish officials, does not question its membership.

Anahtar Kelimeler

S-400, Air Defense Systems, Turkey, NATO, CAATSA

Kaynakça

• "Bakan Akar'dan flaş NATO açıklaması: Türkiye'nin sorgulanması anlamsız", Milliyet, 09 Aralık 2020.
• Barışı Destekleme Harekatı, https://www.tsk.tr/Sayfalar?viewName=BarisiDestekleme, (Accessed on 23.04.2020).
• Bekdil, B. (15 October 2013). "Chinese air defences in Turkey a 'virus' for NATO", Hurriyet Daily News.
• Bekdil, B. (03 October 2013). "Turks may rethink China Missile Deal", Hurriyet Daily News.
• Chiacu, D. (03 April 2019). "U.S. VP Pence warns Turkey against buying Russian air defences", REUTERS.
• "Çavuşoğlu Lavrov'la görüştü! S-400 mesajı...", Milliyet, 15 February 2020.
• De Young, K. ( 19 March 2014). "Russia’s moves in Ukraine are ‘wake-up call,’ NATO’s Rasmussen says in speech", The New York Times.
• Dilek, M. S. ve Oğuz, Ş. (2021). “Trump Yönetiminin CAATSA Hamlesi (14 Aralık 2020) Ne Anlama Geliyor?”, Uluslararası Kriz ve Siyaset Araştırmaları Dergisi, 5(1), pp. 185 – 218.
• Duffield, J. S. "The Evolution of NATO's Strategy of Flexible Response: A Reinterpretation", Security Studies, Vol.1, Issue.1, 1991, pp.132-156.
• "Doorstep statement by NATO Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg ahead of the meeting of NATO Foreign Ministers", 04 April 2019, https://www.nato.int/cps/en/natohq/opinions_165209.htm?selectedLocale=en, (Accessed on 23.02.2020)
• Dursun-Özkanca, O. (2019). Turkey–West Relations: The Politics of Intra-alliance Opposition, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
• Egeli, S. (2014). "Füze Tehdidi ve NATO Füze Kalkanı: Türkiye Açısından Bir Değerlendirme", Uluslararası İlişkiler, 10(40), pp. 39-73.
• "Erdoğan'dan flaş füze açıklaması", Cumhuriyet, 08 September 2014.
• Ersöz, S. (07 January 2020). "S-400 nisanda hazır olacak", Milliyet.
• Fraende, M. (07 October 2013). "NATO head expresses concern about Turkey's Chinese missile deal", REUTERS.
• Friedman, T. L. (10 August 1990). “Confrontation in the Gulf; U.S. Says Turkey Plans To Cooperate on Iraq”. The New York Times.
• Gürcanlı, Z. (27 January 2020). "Kazık üzerine kazık", Sözcü.
• Haberman, C. (27 January 2020). "Turkey's Role in Air Assault sets off fear of retaliation", The New York Times.
• Hayatsever, H. (09 Kasım 2019). "İspanyol Patriotları kalıyor", Cumhuriyet.
• Hürkuş, S. (06 January 2020). "France ‘hampers Eurosam missile system due to political reasons’", Hurriyet Daily News.
• Inhofe, J., Reed, J., Risch, J. and Menendez, B. (09 April 2019). "A U.S. Fighter Jet or a Russian Missile System. Not Both", The New York Times.
• Johnston, S. A. (2017). How NATO Adapts: Strategy and Organization in the Atlantic Alliance Since 1950. Baltimore, John Hopkins University Press.
• London Declaration, Issued by the Heads of State and Government participating in the meeting of the North Atlantic Council in London 3-4 December 2019, https://www.nato.int/cps/en/natohq/official_texts_171584.htm?selectedLocale=en, (Accessed on 23.04.2020).
• "Macaristan'dan Barış Pınarı Harekatı'na destek mesajı", Hürriyet, 11 Ekim 2019.
• MC-14/3, https://www.nato.int/docu/stratdoc/eng/a680116a.pdf, (Accessed on 15.02.2020).
• Meick, E. (18 December 2013). "China’s Potential Air Defense System Sale to Turkey and Implications for the United States", U.S.-China Economic and Security Review Commission Staff Report. https://www.uscc.gov/sites/default/files/Research/Staff%20 Report_China's%20Potential%20Air%20Defense%20System%20Sale%20to%20Turkey%20and%20Implications %20 for%20the%20US.pdf, (Accessed on 05.05.2020).
• Molla, A. (2019). Soğuk Savaş Sonrası Körfez Krizleri ve Türkiye-ABD-NATO İlişkileri. Yönetim ve Ekonomi Araştırmaları Dergisi, 7(11), pp.29-45.
• Mueller, B. and Gibbons-Neff, T. (12 July 2019). "What Is the S-400? The Russian Missile System in Turkey That Irks the Pentagon", The New York Times.
• Muller, N. (18 October 2018). "EU urges Turkey to end Syria military operation after cease-fire announcement", Deutsche Welle, https://www.dw.com/en/eu-urges-turkey-to-end-syria-military-operation-after-cease-fire-announcement/a-50881115 (Accessed on 19.04.2020)
• "NATO backs Turkey in standoff with Syria", The Guardian, 09 October 2012, https://www.theguardian.com/world/2012/oct/09/nato-turkey-syria (Accessed on 16.04.2020) National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2014, 26 December 2013, Public Law 113–66 113th Congress, https://www.congress.gov/113/plaws/publ66/PLAW-113publ66.pdf, (Accessed on 24.02.2020)
• Özer, V. (2019). "Understanding the 'S-400 crisis", Aljazeere, 05 August 2019, https://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/opinion/understanding-400-crisis-190801201222608. html, (Accessed on 01.04.2020).
• Pedlow, G. W. "NATO Strategy Documents 1949-1969", https://www.nato.int/docu/stratdoc/eng/intro.pdf, (Accessed on 02.02.2020).
• Peel , M. and Milne, R. (28 November 2019). "Macron warns Turkey not to undermine NATO allies’ solidarity", Financial Times.
• "Polonya’dan Hulusi Akar’a savunma planı yanıtı", Sözcü, 10 Aralık 2019.
• "Pre-Ministerial press conference by NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg", 09 February 2016, https://www.nato.int/cps/en/natohq/opinions_127757.htm?selectedLocale=en (Accessed on 28.04.2020).
• "Press conference by NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg following the meeting of the North Atlantic Council in Defence Ministers session", 08 October 2015, https://www.nato.int/cps/en/natohq/opinions_123522.htm?selectedLocale=en (Accessed on 19.04.2020)
• "Readiness Action Plan", NATO Official Website, https://www.nato.int/cps/en/natohq/topics_119353.htm, (Accessed on 21.03.2020)
• Riza, B. A. and Brannen, S. J. (08 October 2013). "Turkey looks to China on Air and Missile Defense?", Center for Strategic and International Studies, https://www.csis.org/analysis/turkey-looks-china-air-and-missile-defense, (Accessed on 11.05.2020).
• Rogers, K., Callimachi, R. and Cooper, H. (28 February 2019). "Trump Declares ISIS ‘100%’ Defeated in Syria. ‘100% Not True", Ground Reports Say", The New York Times.
• "Rusya'dan açıklama! Erdoğan ve Putin anlaştı", Akşam, 16 Mart 2017.
• Seren, M. (05 Ağustos 2015). "Türkiye’nin Füze Savunma Sistemi: İhale Süreci, Temel Dinamikler ve Aktörler", A Report prepared by SETA, http://file.setav.org/Files/Pdf/20150916125435_fuze-rapor-16-9-15.pdf, (Accessed on 27.04.2020).
• "Statement by the NATO Secretary General after the extraordinary NAC meeting", 24 November 2015, https://www.nato.int/cps/en/natohq/news_125052.htm (Accessed on 22.04.2020)
• "Statement by NATO Foreign Ministers on Assurance to Turkey", 01 December 2015, https://www.nato.int/cps/en/natohq/official_texts_125486.htm?selectedLocale=en (Accessed on 28.04.2020).
• "S-400 Uzun Menzilli Bölge Hava ve Füze Savunma Sisteminin İntikali", Written Statement by the Ministry of Turkish Defense, 12 July 2017, https://www.msb.gov.tr/SlaytHaber/1272019-78857, (Accessed on 28.02.2020)
• "S-400'ler karar aşamasında", Yeni Şafak, 14 April 2017.
• "S-400 is bilateral problem of US, Turkey, not NATO: Turkish envoy", Hurriyet Daily News, 25 June 2019.
• "Turkey’s China deal on missile system not finalized, says President Gül", Hurriyet Daily News, 30 September 2013.
• "Turkey's S-400 purchase 'national decision’: NATO chief", Hurriyet Daily News, 15 September 2018.
• "Turkey has right to act in self-defence in Afrin, NATO chief Stoltenberg says", Daily Sabah, 25 January 2019.
• "Turkey's Erdogan calls Macron's NATO comments 'unacceptable'", France24, 13 October 2019, https://www.france24.com/en/20191113-turkey-s-erdogan-calls-macron-s-nato-comments-unacceptable, (Accessed on 12.04.2020).
• "Türkiye'nin hava ve füze savunma ihalesini Çin kazandı", Akşam, 26 September 2013.
• "US frets on the nuclear link in Turkey-China missile deal: US Ambassador Ricciardone", Hurriyet Daily News, 02 October 2013.
• "The US sets Turkey deadline to give up Russian missile deal", Deutsche Welle, 07 June 2019, https://www.dw.com/en/us-sets-turkey-deadline-to-give-up-russian-missile-deal/a-49108079, (Accessed on 01.03.2020).
• Wales Summit Declaration of 05 September 2014, https://www.nato.int/cps/en/natohq/official_texts_112964.htm, (Accessed on 02.04.2020)
• Varat, B. (2008). "Point of Departure: A Reassessment of Charles de Gaulle and the Paris Summit of May 1960", Diplomacy and Statecraft, 19(1), pp.96-124.
• "1990-1991 Operation Anchor Guard", NATO Official Web Site, https://awacs.nato.int/operations/past-operations, (Accessed on 22.03.2020).