An assessment of the thirty year post-Soviet transition quality in Azerbaijan from an economic and social liberalization perspective

Abstract

Since the fall of the Soviet Union, Azerbaijan has faced numerous economic, political and administrative difficulties. One of them has been oil dependency of the national economy. The impact of the oil industry on the macroeconomic indicators such as the Gross Domestic Production (GDP) and inflation has been a popular theme in the case of the Azerbaijan economy. However, evidence of the extractive industry’s growing influence on Azerbaijan’s national economy in terms of the quality of the transition from a command economy to a market economy is sparse. In this study, we compare Azerbaijan’s transition process with other post-Soviet nations in terms of privatization, international trade and the social sphere, despite dominance by the oil sector. Poor economic diversity is said to be harming institutional quality and impairing long-term sustainable growth. Overall, it seems that Azerbaijan’s transformation is not yet complete. Its pace and quality are greatly influenced by oil prices and the domestic oil boom: when prices are high, the Azerbaijan government eases off and focuses on spending oil cash. When international commodity markets decline, Azerbaijan’s revenue drops, and the government increases its reform efforts. This approach induces economic unpredictability and underperformance and threatens its long-term growth and development. This vicious cycle-forming tendency should alert government bodies and decision-makers to be aware of the country’s excessive oil dependency and the need to diversify the country’s fiscal revenue. However, without political will and strategic planning, this cannot be achieved.

Keywords

• Azerbaijan economy
• international trade
• oil boom
• privatization
• transition process

Kaynakça

1. AHMADOV, V. (2020a). The Development of the Innovative SMEs in Slovakia in the Context of Macroeconomic Environment. Sosyal Araştırmalar ve Davranış Bilimleri, 6(12), 113-120.
2. AHMADOV, V. (2020b). The Development of Innovative SMEs in Post-Socialist Countries. Proceedings of the European Union’s Contention in the Reshaping Global Economy, University of Szeged, Doctoral School in Economics, Szeged, Eds. Udvari, B, 202-217. doi: 10.14232/eucrge.2020.proc.11
3. AHMADOV, V. (2022a). The Financial Policy of Oil-Exporting Azerbaijan. InterConf, Proceeding of the 4th International Scientific and Practical Conference, No. 99. 9-21. doi: 10.51582/interconf.19-20.02.2022.001
4. AHMADOV, V. (2022b). Comparative Study of Labour Market Development in Post-Socialist Hungary and Azerbaijan Since 1990. Regional Statistics, 12(02), 95-116. doi: 10.15196/RS120203
5. AHMADOVA, E., HAMIDOVA, L. and HAJIYEVA, L. (2021). Diversification of the Economy in the Context of Globalization (Case of Azerbaijan). In SHS Web of Conferences (92). EDP Sciences. doi: 10.1051/shsconf/20219207002
6. ALIRZAYEV, E. (2010). Analysis of Privatization Process in Azerbaijan. SSRN Electronic Journal. https://ssrn.com/abstract=2218335 [Accessed: 13.07.2022]
7. ALIYEV, I. (2005). Azərbaycan Respublikasında pul nişanlarının nominal dəyərinin və qiymətlər miqyasının dəyişdirilməsi (denominasiyası) haqqında Azərbaycan Respublikasi Prezidentinin Fərman [Decree of the President of the Republic of Azerbaijan on change of nominal value and price scale of banknotes in the Republic of Azerbaijan (denomination)]. http://www.e qanun.az/framework/7363 (in Azerbaijani) [Accessed: 01.02.2022]
8. ALIYEV, I. (2016a). Qeyri-neft məhsullarının ixracının stimullaşdırılması ilə bağlı əlavə tədbirlər haqqında Azərbaycan Respublikası Prezidentinin Sərəncamı [Order of the President of the Republic of Azerbaijan on additional measures to stimulate the export of non-oil products]. https://president.az/az/articles/view/17535 (in Azerbaijani) [Accessed: 01.02.2022]

9. ALIYEV, I. (2016b). . https://e-qanun.az/framework/ 31870 (in Azerbaijani) [Accessed: 01.02.2022]
10. ALIYEV, I. (2020a). Azərbaycan İnvestisiya Holdinqinin idarəetməsinə veriləcək dövlət şirkətlərinin və müəssisələrinin, habelə dövlət payı olan təsərrüfat cəmiyyətlərinin siyahısı [List of state companies and enterprises to be transferred to the management of Azerbaijan Investment Holding, as well as state-owned companies]. https://president.az/az/articles/view/45523 (in Azerbaijani) [Accessed: 01.02.2022]
11. ALIYEV, I. (2020b). Azərbaycan İnvestisiya Holdinqinin yaradılması haqqında Azərbaycan Respublikası Prezidentinin Fərmanı [Decree of the President of the Republic of Azerbaijan on the establishment of the Azerbaijan Investment Holding]. https://www.taxes.gov.az/az/post/1129 (in Azerbaijani) [Accessed: 01.02.2022]
12. ALIYEV, I. (2020d). Azərbaycan Respublikasının 2021-ciil dövlət büdcəsi haqqında Azərbaycan Respublikasının Qanunu [Law of the Republic of Azerbaijan on the state budget of the Republic of Azerbaijan for 2021]. http://www.e-qanun. az/framework/46590 (in Azerbaijani) [Accessed: 02.02.2022]
13. ALIYEV, I. (2021a). “Azərbaycan Hava Yolları” Qapalı Səhmdar Cəmiyyətinin Müşahidə Şurasının tərkibinin təsdiq edilməsi haqqında Azərbaycan Respublikası Prezidentinin Sərəncamı [Order of the President of the Republic of Azerbaijan on approval of the composition of the Supervisory Board of “Azerbaijan Airlines” Closed Joint-Stock Company]. https://president.az/az/articles/view/50966 (in Azerbaijani) [Accessed: 02.02.2022]
14. ALIYEV, I. (2021b). “BakuBus”Composition of the Supervisory Board of “BakuBus” Limited Liability Company]. https://president.az/az/articles/view/50965 (in Azerbaijani) [Accessed: 02.02.2022]
15. ALIYEV, I. (2021c). “Azərbaycan Dəmir Yolları” Qapalı Səhmdar Cəmiyyətinin Müşahidə Şurasının tərkibinin təsdiq edilməsi haqqında Azərbaycan Respublikası Prezidentinin Sərəncamı [Order of the President of the Republic of Azerbaijan on approval of the composition of the Supervisory Board of “Azerbaijan Railways” Closed Joint- Stock Company]. https://president.az/az/articles/view/50963 (in Azerbaijani) [Accessed: 13.02.2022]
16. ALIYEV, I. (2021d). “Bakı Metropoliteni” Qapalı Səhmdar Cəmiyyətinin Müşahidə Şurasının tərkibinin təsdiq edilməsi haqqında Azərbaycan Respublikası Prezidentinin Sərəncamı [Order of the President of the Republic of Azerbaijan on approval of the composition of the Supervisory Board of “Baku Metro” Closed Joint-Stock Company]. https://president. az/az/articles/view/50964 (in Azerbaijani) [Accessed: 12.03.2022]
17. APA – AZERI-PRESS AGENCY (2021a). Azərbaycanda indiyədək 2 mlrd. tondan çox neft hasil edilib [So far, more than 2 billion ton of oil was extracted in Azerbaijan]. https://apa.az/az/xeber/senaye-ve-energetika/azerbaycanda-indiyedek-2-mlrd-tondan-cox neft-hasil-edilib-664817 (in Azerbaijani) [Accessed: 02.03.2022]
18. APA – AZERI-PRESS AGENCY (2021b). Azərbaycanın 2021-2024-cü illərdə büdcə-vergi siyasətinin əsas istiqamətləri açıqlanıb [The main directions of the budget and tax policy of the Republic of Azerbaijan in 2021-2024]. https://apa.az/az/maliyye_xeberleri/Azrbaycanin-2021 2024-cu-illrd-budc-vergi-siyastinin-sas-istiqamtlri-aciqlanib-620992 (in Azerbaijani) [Accessed: 06.02.2022]
19. AZERTAG (2021). AZPROMO: İndiyədək Sahibkarlara 27 Milyon Manat İxrac Təşviqi Ödənilib [AZPROMO: So far, Entrepreneurs Have Been Allowed to Export 27 Million Manat]. https://azertag.az/xeber/AZPROMO_Indiyedek_sahibkarlara_27_milyon_manat_ixrac_tesviqi_ odenilib-1698859 (in Azerbaijani) [Accessed: 02.02.2022]
20. BRITISH PETROLEUM - BP. Əsrin müqaviləsi - milli uğur strategiyası [Contract of the Century – National Success Strategy]. https://www.bp.com/az_az/azerbaijan/home/who-we are/operationsprojects/acg2/_srin-mueqavil_si---milli-uur-strategiyas.html (in Azerbaijani) [Accessed: 02.02.2022]
21. BURAWOY, M. (2001). Transition Without Transformation: Russia’s Involutionary Road to Capitalism. East European politics and societies, 15(2), 269-290. doi: 10.1177/088832501766276407
22. CBAR – CENTRAL BANK OF THE REPUBLIC OF AZERBAIJAN (2015a). Statement of the Central Bank of the Republic of Azerbaijan. https://www.cbar.az/press-release-919/statement-of thecentral-bank-ofthe-republic-of-azerbaijan?language=en [Accessed: 21.02.2022]
23. CBAR – CENTRAL BANK OF THE REPUBLIC OF AZERBAIJAN (2015b). Statement of the Central Bank of the Republic of Azerbaijan. https://www.cbar.az/press-release-863/statement-of thecentral-bank-ofthe-republic-of-azerbaijan [Accessed: 21.03.2022]
24. CHAMBER OF ACCOUNTS OF THE REPUBLIC OF AZERBAIJAN (2020). “Azərbaycan Respublikasının 2021-ci il dövlət büdcəsi haqqında” Azərbaycan Respublikasının Qanun layihəsinə Azərbaycan Respublikası Hesablama Palatasının Rəyi [Opinion of the Chamber of Accounts of the Republic of Azerbaijan on the Draft Law of the Republic of Azerbaijan on the “state budget of the Republic of Azerbaijan for 2021”]. https://sai.gov.az/files/Rey_2021_final.pdf (in Azerbaijani) [Accessed: 25.03.2022]
25. CHUBRIK, A. and WALEWSKI, M. (2010). Oil Money vs. Economic crisis: The Case of Azerbaijan. CASE Network E-Briefs, (6), 1.
26. CIARRETA, A. and NASIROV, S. (2010). Analysis of Azerbaijan Oil and Gas Sector. United States Association for Energy Economics Research Paper Series, 43-46.
27. CIARRETA, A. and NASIROV, S. (2012). Development Trends in the Azerbaijan Oil and Gas Sector: Achievements and Challenges. Energy Policy, 40, 282-292. doi: 10.1016/j.enpol.2011.10.002
28. CORNELL, S. E. (2015). Azerbaijan Since Independence. Routledge, Routledge: New York. ISBN: 9781315706221
29. DE MELO, M., DENIZER, C., GELB, A. and TENEV, S. (2001). Circumstance and Choice: The Role of Initial Conditions and Policies in Transition Economies. The World Bank Economic Review, 15(1), 1-31. doi: 10.1093/wber/15.1.1
30. DOING BUSINESS 2004 (2003). World Bank Group. https://www.doingbusiness.org/en/reports/global-reports/doing-business-2004 [Accessed: 04 April 2022]
31. EASTERLIN, R. A. (2009). Lost in Transition: Life Satisfaction on the Road to Capitalism. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 71(2), 130-145. doi: 10.1016/j.jebo.2009.04.003
32. E-QANUN (2009). 2009-cu il martın 18-də keçirilmiş ümumxalq səsverməsinə (referenduma) yekun vurulması və yekunların elan edilməsi barədə Azərbaycan Respublikasi Mərkəzi Seçki (referendum) Komissiyasnın qərar[Decision of the Central Election (Referendum) Commission of the Republic of Azerbaijan on summing up and announcing the results of the nationwide voting (referendum) held on March 18, 2009]. https://e-qanun.az/framework/16448 (in Azerbaijani) [Accessed: 02.02.2022]
33. EBRD – EUROPEAN BANK OF RECONSTRUCTION AND DEVELOPMENT (1995). Transition Report 1995: Economic transition in Eastern Europe and the former Soviet Union. www.ebrd.com/documents/comms-and-bis/pdf-transition-report-1995-english.pdf blobnocache=true [Accessed: 03.02.2022]
34. EBRD – EUROPEAN BANK OF RECONSTRUCTION AND DEVELOPMENT (2000). Transition Report 2000. www.ebrd.com/documents/comms-and-bis/pdf-transition-report-2000-english.pdf blobnocache=true [Accessed: 08.02.2022]
35. EBRD – EUROPEAN BANK OF RECONSTRUCTION AND DEVELOPMENT (2005). Transition Report 2005. www.ebrd.com/documents/comms-and-bis/pdf-transition-report-2005-english.pdf blobnocache=true [Accessed: 02.02.2022]
36. EBRD – EUROPEAN BANK OF RECONSTRUCTION AND DEVELOPMENT (2014). Transition Report 2014. https://www.ebrd.com/news/publications/transition-report/transition-report-2014.html [Accessed: 01.02.2022]
37. EBRD – EUROPEAN BANK OF RECONSTRUCTION AND DEVELOPMENT (2021). Transition Report 2021-22: System Upgrade: Delivering the Digital Dividend. https://www.ebrd.com/transition report [Accessed: 02.02.2022]
38. EBRD – EUROPEAN BANK OF RECONSTRUCTION AND DEVELOPMENT (1994). Transition Report 1994. https://www.ebrd.com/publications/transition-report-1994-english.pdf [Accessed: 02.02.2022]
39. EBRD – EUROPEAN BANK OF RECONSTRUCTION AND DEVELOPMENT (a). Transition indicators methodology 1989-2014. https://www.ebrd.com/transition-indicators-history [Accessed: 02.02.2022]
40. GASIMLI, F. (2007). Azerbaijan on the Way to the WTO: Later but Safer? The Caucasus & Globalization, 1(4), 48-56.
41. GULIYEV, F. (2005). Post-Soviet Azerbaijan: Transition to Sultanistic Semiauthoritarianism? An Attempt at Conceptualization. Demokratizatsiya: The Journal of Post-Soviet Democratization, 13(3), 393-435. doi: 10.3200/DEMO.13.3.393-436
42. HABIBOV, N. and FAN, L. (2007). Social Protection and Poverty in Azerbaijan, A Low‐Income Country in Transition: Implications of a Household Survey. International Social Security Review, 60(4), 47-68. doi:10.1111/j.1468-246X.2007.00280.x
43. HAJIYEV, N. and RUSTAMOV, A. (2019). How Oil Price Drops are Reflected by Imported Inflation in Azerbaijan? International Journal of Energy Economics and Policy, 9(2), 182-193.
44. HASANOV, F. (2013). Dutch Disease and the Azerbaijan Economy. Communist and Post Communist Studies, 46(4), 463-480.
45. HOLLEY, J., AKHUNDOV, O. and NOLTE, E. (2004). Health care systems in transition: Azerbaijan, Nolte, E, MacLehose, L., McKee, M. (Eds.). WHO Regional Office for Europe on behalf of the European Observatory on Health Systems and Policies, Copenhagen, Denmark. https://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/107613/HiT-6-8-2004-eng.pdf?sequence=16 [Accessed: 02.02.2022]
46. IBADOGHLU, G. (2021). Retrospective and Perspective View of the Next Stage of Privatization in Azerbaijan. SSRN Electronic Journal. http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3820963 [Accessed: 02.02.2022]
47. IBADOGHLU, G. (2021). What Has Azerbaijan Gained from ACG? SSRN Electronic Journal. http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3931367 [Accessed: 02.02.2022]
48. IMF – INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND. (1995). Azerbaijan: Recent Economic Developments. IMF Staff Country Reports, 1995(119). https://doi.org/10.5089/9781451802504.002 [Accessed: 02.02.2022]
49. KORNAI, J. (2000). What the Change of System from Socialism to Capitalism Does and Does Not Mean. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 14(1), 27-42.
50. KORNAI, J. (2008). From Socialism to Capitalism: Eight Essays. Central European University Press.
51. LAURILA, J. (1999). Power Politics and Oil as Determinants of Transition: the case of Azerbaijan. Bank of Finland Institute for Economies in Transition (BOFIT), No. 10.
52. LUSSAC, S. (2010). The State as a (oil) Company? The POLITICAL ECONOMY of Azerbaijan. GARNET Working Paper, (74/10).
53. MASHALLI, T. (2021). Unemployment in Azerbaijan: Official Statistics and Reality. JAM News. https://jamnews.net/unemployment-in-azerbaijan-official-statistics-and-reality/ (in Azerbaijani) [Accessed: 02.02.2022]
54. MINISTRY OF FINANCE OF REPUBLIC OF AZERBAIJAN (2021). Information on the Implementation of the State and Consolidated Budget of the Republic of Azerbaijan for 2020. http://maliyye.gov.az/news/5516/azerbaycan-respublikasinin-2020-ci-il-dovlet-ve-icmal- budcesinin-icrasina-dair-melumat (in Azerbaijani) [Accessed: 02.02.2022]
55. MINISTRY OF FINANCE OF THE REPUBLIC OF AZERBAIJAN (2021). 2022–2015-ci ill[Disclosure of the macrophysical framework for 2022–2015 and summary and preliminary indicators of the state budgets for 2022]. http://maliyye.gov.az/scripts/pdfjs/web/viewer.html?file=/ uploads/news_files/6138cbdb2ca14.pdf (in Azerbaijani) [Accessed: 02.02.2022]
56. PANAHOV, M. (2009). 2009-cu il martın 18-də keçirilmiş ümumxalq səsverməsinə (referenduma) yekun vurulması və yekunların elan edilməsi barədə Azərbaycan Respublikas. http://e-qanun.az/framework/16448 (in Azerbaijani) [Accessed: 02.02.2022]
57. PEJOVICH, S. S. (2003). Understanding the Transaction Costs of Transition: It’s the Culture, Stupid. The review of Austrian economics, 16(4), 347-361.
58. RASIZADE, A. (2003). Azerbaijan in Transition to the “New Age of Democracy”. Communist and Post-Communist Studies, 36(3), 345-372.
59. SIEGELBAUM, J. P., SHERIF, K., BORISH, M. and CLARKE, G. (2002). Structural Adjustment in the Transition: Case Studies from Albania, Azerbaijan, Kyrgyz Republic, and Moldova.
60. SOFAZ – STATE OIL FUND OF THE REPUBLIC OF AZERBAIJAN – (2021). Azəri-Çıraq-Günəşli və Şahdəniz üzrə gəlirlər – 01 sentyabr 2021-ci il tarixinə [Revenues from Azeri-Chirag-Guneshli and Shah Deniz - as of September 1, 2021]. https://oilfund.az/fund/pressroom/news archive/1502 (in Azerbaijani) [Accessed: 01.03.2022]
61. SOFAZ – STATE OIL FUND OF THE REPUBLIC OF AZERBAIJAN (2019) – Annual Report - 2019. https://www.oilfund.az/report-and-statistics/get-downloadfile/7_2019_tam_en.pdf [Accessed: 11.03.2022]
62. SSCRA – STATE STATISTICAL COMMITTEE OF THE REPUBLIC OF AZERBAIJAN (2022). System of national accounts and balance of payments. https://www.stat.gov.az/source/system_nat_accounts/?lang=en [Accessed: 02.03.2022]
63. SSCRA – STATE STATISTICAL COMMITTEE OF THE REPUBLIC OF AZERBIAJAN (2022b). Budget of Households. https://www.stat.gov.az/source/budget_households/?lang=en [Accessed: 02.02.2022]
64. SSCRA – STATE STATISTICAL COMMITTEE OF THE REPUBLIC OF AZERBIAJAN (2022a). Labor market statistics. https://www.stat.gov.az/source/labour/ [Accessed: 02.02.2022]
65. STATE SERVICE ON PROPERTY ISSUES UNDER THE MINISTRY OF ECONOMY OF THE REPUBLIC OF AZERBAIJAN (2019). “Daşkəsən Filizsaflaşdırma” ASC-nin özəlləşdirilməsi istiqamətində əhatəli tədbirlər görülür [Comprehensive measures are being taken to privatize ‘Dashkasan Filizsaflidirma’ OJSC]. https://emlak.gov.az/news/view/613-%E2%80%9CDa%C5%9Fk%C9%99s%C9%99n-Filizsafla%C5%9Fd%C4%B1rma%E2%80%9DASCnin-%C3%B-
66. z%C9%99ll%C9%99%C5%9Fdirilm%C9%99si-istiqam%C9%99tind%C9%99-%C9%99hat%C9%-99li-t%C9%99dbirl%C9%99r-g%C3%B6r%C3%BCl%C3%BCr- (in Azerbaijani)[Accessed: 02.02.2022]
67. SULEYMANOV, E. and YUSIFOV, S. (2014). Problems Encountered During the Transition to Market Economy in Azerbaijan and Solution Attempts.Expert Journal of Economics, 2(2), 45-54.
68. SWIETOCHOWSKI, T. (1999). Azerbaijan: Perspectives from the Crossroads. Central Asian Survey, 18(4), 419- 434.
69. TARIFF COUNIL (2005). “Qiymətləri (tarifləri) dövləttərəfindən tənzimlənən malların (işlərin, xidmətlərin) Siyahısı”nıni haqqında [On approval of the “List of Prices (tariffs) of goods (works, services) regulated by the state”]. http://www.tariffcouncil.gov.az/documents/NK-1.pdf (in Azerbaijani) [Accessed: 10.02.2022]
70. THE CONSTITUTION OF THE REPUBLIC OF AZERBAIJAN (1995). The Constitution of The Republic of Azerbaijan. https://e-qanun.az/framework/897#_edn3 (in Azerbaijani) [Accessed: 06.02.2022]
71. THE MILLI MAJLIS OF THE REPUBLIC OF AZERBAIJAN (2009). 02.02.2009 - tarixli iclasın stenoqramı [Transcript of the meeting dated 02.02.2009]. https://meclis.gov.az/news-cari.php?id=100&lang=az (in Azerbaijani) [Accessed: 07.02.2022]
72. THE STATE AGENCY ON MANDATORY HEALTH INSURANCE. Xidmətlər Zərfi [Services Envelope]. https://its.gov.az/page/xidmetler-zerfi-2 (in Azerbaijani) [Accessed: 19.03.2022]
73. THE STATE CUSTOMS COMMITTEE OF AZERBAIJAN REPUBLIC (2020). Customs Statistics. https://customs.gov.az/en/faydali/gomruk-statistikasi/xarici-ticaretin-veziyyeti-haqqinda [Accessed: 16.03.2022]
74. THE WORLD BANK (2017). Azərbaycan Respublikası: Dövlətə məxsus Müəssisələrdə Korporativ İdarəetmə və Mülkiyyət [The Republic of Azerbaijan: Corporate Governance and Property in State-Owned Enterprises]. https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/ru/741211532553730650/pdf/AUS0000257-Ajarb PUBLIC-2018-JUNE-AZE-Final-Technical-Note-AZ-SOEs-FINAL.pdf (in Azerbaijani) [Accessed: 14.03.2022]
75. THE WORLD BANK (2019). South Caucasus in Motion. https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/614351556553124178/pdf/South-Caucasus-in Motion.pdf?fbclid=IwAR3I2Li-Kg-yDrKUKxM5f-5IyJiFwFRiewRF3t-S1UZMv9L6yhWtP1FQXgc [Accessed: 12.03.2022]
76. THE WORLD BANK (2003). Memorandum of the President of the International Bank for Reconstruction and Development and the International Development Association to the Executive Directors on a Country Assistance Strategy of the World Bank Group for the Azerbaijan Republic, No. 25790-A2. The World Bank. doi: https://doi.org/10.1596/978-1-4648 0484-7 [Accessed: 20.03.2022]
77. WTO.AZ. Müraciət və Üzvolma Xronologiyas [Application and Membership Chronology]. https://wto.az/azerbaycan-ve-utt/muraciet-ve-uzvolma-xronologiyasi/(in Azerbaijani) [Accessed: 22.03.2022]
78. ZAOSTROVTSEV, A. (2016). From Marxist Economics to Post-Soviet Nationalism. In V. Barnett & J. Zweynert (Eds.), Economics in Russia: Studies in Intellectual History (173-185). Routledge, New York. doi: 10.4324/9781315578743-12