Approach Proposal for Energy-Efficient Retrofit of Historic Buildings with Comparative Analysis of EU Research Projects

Yıl 2025, , 21 - 52, 15.01.2025

Elvan Kumtepe , İdil Ayçam

https://doi.org/10.35674/kent.1485521

Öz

Within the framework of the building section, the existing building stock is a research area with a high potential for energy savings, as it is a crucial energy consumption source. Studies are being carried out on many existing building stocks to prevent and reduce the increasing energy consumption and negative situations due to climate change and global warming. It is seen that parameters such as energy efficiency are considered as a whole with conservation in intervention methods, especially in European countries, since only conservation is insufficient for historical buildings, which are one of the primary sources of important existing building stock. Preserving cultural identity values and energy efficiency are the primary intervention criteria. By considering these two intervention criteria in balance and as a whole, the permanence and sustainability of the buildings for future generations is ensured. In this regard, comprehensive, large-scale, and multinational projects supported by the European Union (EU), especially in European countries, are carried out. In line with the conclusions drawn from the detailed and systematic analysis, comparison, and evaluation of the projects, the study proposed an approach and intervention model for future studies. The determined projects were examined in detail regarding purpose, scope, target, strategy, content, and project outcome outputs. Systematic inferences were made through the analysis in line with the data obtained. Comparisons and evaluations were made on approach information, objectives, analysis methods, technology and software used, active-passive and renewable energy systems, monitoring and tracking systems, and project output data obtained at the project's end to make the intervention's effects sustainable. As a result, a comprehensive approach model for energy-efficient retrofitting intervention approaches has been proposed in line with the conclusions obtained from the analysis, comparison, and evaluations of energy-efficient retrofitting of historic buildings. Thus, the approach model obtained with the study will guide the creation of intervention models for the studies to be carried out on energy-efficient retrofits in historical buildings.

Anahtar Kelimeler

Historic buildings, Cultural heritage buildings, Energy-efficient retrofitting, Retrofitting methods, EU funded projects

AB Araştırma Projelerinin Karşılaştırmalı Analizi Doğrultusunda Tarihi Binaların Enerji Etkin İyileştirilmesi için Yaklaşım Önerisi

Öz

Bina sektörü çerçevesinde mevcut yapı stoku önemli enerji tüketim kaynaklarından olması sebebiyle enerji tasarrufu yapılabilme potansiyelinin yüksek olduğu araştırma alanlarındandır. İklim değişikliği ve küresel ısınma etkisi ile enerji tüketiminin giderek artması ve oluşan olumsuz durumların önlenip azaltılması amaçlı birçok mevcut yapı stokuna yönelik çalışmalar yapılmaktadır. Önemli mevcut yapı stoku ana kaynaklarından olan tarihi yapılar için sadece korumanın yetersiz kalması nedeniyle özellikle Avrupa ülkelerinde enerji etkinlik ve verimlilik gibi parametrelerin de müdahale yöntemlerinde koruma ile bütün olarak düşünüldüğü görülmektedir. Müdahaleler için kültürel kimlik değerlerinin korunması ve enerji verimliliğinin sağlanması ana kriterler olarak benimsenmektedir. Bu iki müdahale kriterinin dengede ve bir bütün olarak düşünülmesi ile yapıların gelecek nesiller için kalıcılığı ve sürdürülebilirliği sağlanmaktadır. Bu doğrultuda özellikle Avrupa ülkelerinde yapılan Avrupa Birliği (AB) tarafından desteklenen kapsamlı, büyük ölçekli ve çok uluslu projeler yürütüldüğü görülmektedir. Çalışma ile projelerin detaylı ve sistematik olarak analiz, karşılaştırma ve değerlendirmesi sonucunda elde edilen çıkarımlar doğrultusunda gelecek çalışmalar için yaklaşım ve müdahale model önerisi getirilmiştir. Belirlenen projeler amaç, kapsam, hedef, strateji, içerik ve proje sonucu çıktıları üzerinden detaylı olarak incelenmiştir. Elde edilen veriler doğrultusunda yapılan analiz ile sistematik şekilde çıkarımlar yapılmıştır. Tarihi yapılar için yapılan enerji verimli iyileştirme uygulamalarındaki yaklaşım bilgileri, hedefler, analiz yöntemleri, kullanılan teknoloji ve yazılımlar, aktif-pasif sistem ve yenilenebilir enerji sistemleri, izleme takip sistemleri ve proje sonucunda müdahalenin etkilerinin sürdürülebilir kılınması için elde edilen proje çıktıları verileri gibi veriler üzerinden karşılaştırma ve değerlendirme yapılmıştır. Sonuç olarak tarihi yapıların enerjilerinin verimli bir şekilde iyileştirilmesine yönelik yapılan analiz karşılaştırmaları ve değerlendirmeleri sonucunda elde edilen çıkarımlarla enerji verimliliği iyileştirme müdahale yaklaşımlarına dair kapsamlı bir yaklaşım modeli önerilmiştir. Böylece çalışma ile elde edilen yaklaşım modeli ile tarihi yapılarda enerji verimliliğine dair yapılacak çalışmalarda müdahale modellerinin oluşturulması için rehberlik edecektir.

Anahtar Kelimeler

Tarihi yapılar, Kültürel miras yapıları, Enerji etkin iyileştirme, İyileştirme yöntemleri, AB destekli projeler

Kaynakça

• Alpine Space. (2021). Alpine Space Project Overview and Outcomes. Retrieved June 30, 2024 from https://www.alpine-space.eu/project/atlas/
• Balsamo, D., Paci, G., Benini, L., & Davide, B. (2013). Long term, low cost, passive environmental monitoring of heritage buildings for energy efficiency retrofitting. In 2013 IEEE Workshop on Environmental Energy and Structural Monitoring Systems (pp. 1-6). IEEE.
• Becherini, F., Lucchi, E., Gandini, A., Barrasa, M. C., Troi, A., Roberti, F., ... & Bernardi, A. (2018). Characterization and thermal performance evaluation of infrared reflective coatings compatible with historic buildings. Building and Environment, 134, 35-46. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.buildenv.2018.02.034
• Birchall, S., Wallis, I., Churcher, D., Pezzutto, S., Fedrizzi, R., & Causse, E. (2014). Survey on the energy needs and architectural features of the EU building stock. BSRIA: Bracknell, UK, 235.
• Broström, T., Bernardi, A., Egusquiza, A., Frick, J., & Kahn, M. (2013). A method for categorization of European historic districts and a multiscale data model for the assessment of energy interventions. In Proceedings of the 3rd European Workshop on Cultural Heritage Preservation EWCHP (pp. 16-18).
• Broström, T., Eriksson, P., Liu, L., Rohdin, P., Ståhl, F., & Moshfegh, B. (2014). A method to assess the potential for and consequences of energy retrofits in Swedish historic buildings. The historic environment: policy & practice, 5(2), 150-166. https://doi.org/10.1179/1756750514Z.00000000055
• Cessari, L., & Gigliarelli, E. (2012). Heritage-led eco-regeneration: The case of Zhejiang water towns protection, restoration and preservation. In Progress in Cultural Heritage Preservation: 4th International Conference, EuroMed 2012, Limassol, Cyprus, October 29–November 3, 2012. Proceedings 4 (pp. 369-377). Springer Berlin Heidelberg.
• CO2OLBRICKS. (2012). Educational Situation and Labour Market Conditions in the Baltic Sea Region Baseline Study of Work Package 5. Retrieved March 30, 2024 from http://www.co2olbricks.de/fileadmin/Redaktion/Dokumente/Publications/BKM_01530_03_Baselinestudy_RZ_Fin.pdf
• CO2OLBRICKS. (2013a). Basic Project Information. Retrieved March 30, 2024 from http://www.co2olbricks.de/index.php?id=43
• CO2OLBRICKS. (2013b). Partners. Retrieved March 30, 2024 from http://www.co2olbricks.de/index.php?id=54
• CO2OLBRICKS. (2013c). Work packages. Retrieved March 30, 2024 from http://www.co2olbricks.de/index.php?id=59
• CO2OLBRICKS. (2013d). Improving the Energy Efficiency of Historic Buildings A handbook of best practice examples, technical solutions and research projects. Retrieved March 30, 2024 from http://www.co2olbricks.de/fileadmin/Redaktion/Dokumente/Publications/Brochure_06_Handbook_best_practice_safe.pdf
• CO2OLBRICKS. (2013e). Improving the Energy Efficiency of Historic Buildings The four pilot projects of Co2olBricks. Retrieved March 30, 2024 from http://www.co2olbricks.de/fileadmin/Redaktion/Dokumente/Publications/Brochure_07_Pilot_projects_safe.pdf
• CO2OLBRICKS. (2013f). Project Results. Retrieved March 30, 2024 from http://www.co2olbricks.de/index.php?id=177
• CO2OLBRICKS. (2013g). Windows The Heat Transfer Coefficient in Different Types of Windows. Retrieved March 30, 2024 from http://www.co2olbricks.de/fileadmin/Redaktion/Dokumente/Publications/WP4-OP06a_PL_Windows.pdf
• Dulnewa, J., Elvisto, T. A., Hahn, T., Harten, J., Menniks, M., Prahm, J., ... & Simpson, S. (2013). Improving the energy efficiency of historic buildings: the four pilot projects of Co2olBricks. Denkmalschutzamt.
• Economidou, M., Atanasiu, B., Despret, C., Maio, J., Nolte, I., Rapf, O., ... & Zinetti, S. (2011). Europe's buildings under the microscope. A country-by-country review of the energy performance of buildings.
• Economidou, M. (2012). Energy performance requirements for buildings in Europe. REHVA J, 92, 16-21.
• EFFESUS. (2016). Energy Efficiency İn European Historic Urban Districts A Practical Guidance. Retrieved March 30, 2024 from https://build-up.ec.europa.eu/sites/default/files/link-files/effesus_booklet_final-version.pdf
• EED. (2012). Energy Efficiency Directive 2012/27/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council, 25 October. https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=celex%3A32012L0027
• Egusquiza, A., Brostrom, T., & Izkara, J. L. (2022). Incremental decision making for historic urban areas’ energy retrofitting: EFFESUS DSS. Journal of Cultural Heritage, 54, 68-78. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.culher.2022.01.011
• Egusquiza, A., Prieto, I., & Romero, A. (2014). Multiscale information management for sustainable districts rehabilitation EFFESUS and FASUDIR projects. eWork and eBusiness in Architecture, Engineering and Construction ECPPM, 303-308.
• EPBD. (2002). Energy Performance of Buildings Directive 2002/91/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 16 December 2002 on the energy performance of buildings, Official Journal of the European Union. https://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=OJ:L:2003:001:0065:0071:EN:PDF
• EPBD. (2010). Energy Performance of Buildings Directive 2010/31/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council of 19 May 2010 on the Energy Performance of Buildings. https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=CELEX:32010L0031&from=EN
• EPBD. (2018). Energy Performance of Buildings Directive 2018/844/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council. https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=CELEX:32018L0844&from=EN
• Eriksson, P., Hermann, C., Hrabovszky-Horváth, S., & Rodwell, D. (2014). EFFESUS methodology for assessing the impacts of energy-related retrofit measures on heritage significance. The Historic Environment: Policy & Practice, 5(2), 132-149. https://doi.org/10.1179/1756750514Z.00000000054
• European Commission (EC). (2010). Europe 2020: A strategy for Smart, sustainable and inclusive growth. https://ec.europa.eu/eu2020/pdf/COMPLET%20EN%20BARROSO%20%20%20007%20-%20Europe%202020%20-%20EN%20version.pdf
• European Commission (EC). (2011). Roadmap for moving to a competitive low carbon economy in 2050. European Commission, Brussels. https://eurlex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=COM:2011:0112:FIN:en:PDF
• European Commission (EC). (2015a). Final Report Summary - CLIMATE FOR CULTURE (Damage risk assessment, economic impact and mitigation strategies for sustainable preservation of cultural heritage in the times of climate change). Retrieved March 30, 2024 from https://cordis.europa.eu/project/id/226973/reporting
• European Commission (EC). (2015b). Final Report Summary - 3ENCULT (Efficient ENergy for EU Cultural Heritage). Retrieved March 30, 2024 from https://cordis.europa.eu/project/id/260162/reporting
• European Commission (EC). (2017a). Final Report Summary - EFFESUS (ENERGY EFFICIENCY FOR EU HISTORIC DISTRICTS SUSTAINABILITY). Retrieved March 30, 2024 from https://cordis.europa.eu/project/id/314678/reporting
• European Commission (EC). (2017b). EFFESUS (ENERGY EFFICIENCY FOR EU HISTORIC DISTRICTS SUSTAINABILITY). Objective. Retrieved March 30, 2024 from https://cordis.europa.eu/project/id/314678
• European Commission (EC). (2019). Damage risk assessment, economic impact and mitigation strategies for sustainable preservation of cultural heritage in the times of climate change Objective. Retrieved March 30, 2024 from https://cordis.europa.eu/project/id/226973
• Fraunhofer. (2014). CLIMATE FOR CULTURE Cultural Heritage Protection in Times of Climate Change. Retrieved March 30, 2024 from https://www.imw.fraunhofer.de/en/research/technology-transfer/innovation-acceptance/projects/completed-projects/ClimateforCulture.html
• Friese, M., & Worch, I. A. (2013). Current state of the debate about wall heating systems. Report for Co2ol Bricks Project.
• Gerbitz, J. (2013). Perspektiven für das “Rote Hamburg “–zwischen Erhalt, Sanierung und Neubau. Mauerwerk, 17(2), 109-117.
• Gigliarelli, E., Calcerano, F., & Cessari, L. (2018). Analytic hierarchy process: a multi-criteria decision support approach for the improvement of the energy efficiency of built heritage. In The 3rd International Conference on Energy Efficiency in Historic Buildings (EEHB2018), Visby, Sweden, September 26th to 27th, 2018. (pp. 216-225). Uppsala University.
• Gigliarelli, E., Cessari, L., & Cerqua, A. (2011). Application of the analytic hierarchy process (AHP) for energetic rehabilitation of historical buildings. In 11th Int. Symp. on the AHP, Creative Decision Foundation, Pittsburgh.
• Haas, F., Exner, D., Herrera-Avellanosa, D., Hüttler, W., & Troi, A. (2021). Making deep renovation of historic buildings happen learnings from the Historic Buildings Energy Retrofit Atlas. In IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science (Vol. 863, No. 1, p. 012017). IOP Publishing.
• Hermann, C., & Rodwell, D. (2015). Heritage significance assessments to evaluate retrofit impacts: From heritage values to character defining elements in praxis. How To Assess Built Heritage, 169-190.
• Herrera-Avellanosa, D., Rose, J., Thomsen, K. E., Haas, F., Leijonhufvud, G., Brostrom, T., & Troi, A. (2024). Evaluating the Implementation of Energy Retrofits in Historic Buildings: A Demonstration of the Energy Conservation Potential and Lessons Learned for Upscaling. Heritage, 7(2), 997-1013. https://doi.org/10.3390/heritage7020048
• Hiberatlas. (2021). Historic Building Energy Retrofit Atlas. Retrieved June 30, 2024 from https://www.hiberatlas.com/en/welcome-1.html
• Hibertool. (2021a). Historic Building Energy Retrofit Tool for Windows. Retrieved June 30, 2024 from https://www.tool.hiberatlas.com/en/welcome/kind-of-windows-991.html
• Hibertool. (2021b). Historic Building Energy Retrofit Tool for Wall. Retrieved June 30, 2024 from https://www.tool.hiberatlas.com/en/welcome/walls-structure-951.html
• Hibertool. (2021c). Historic Building Energy Retrofit Tool for Solar Airtightness. Retrieved June 30, 2024 from https://www.tool.hiberatlas.com/en/welcome/ventilation-935.html
• Hibertool. (2021d). Historic Building Energy Retrofit Tool for Solar Thermal. Retrieved June 30, 2024 from https://www.tool.hiberatlas.com/en/welcome/photovoltaics-solar-thermal-1345.html
• Huijbregts, Z., Schellen, H., Martens, M., & van Schijndel, J. (2015). Object damage risk evaluation in the European project Climate for Culture. Energy Procedia, 78, 1341-1346. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.egypro.2015.11.151
• Kikira, M., & Gigliarelli, E. (2010). Energy Efficiency in Historic Buildings, the case study of the National Theatre of Rhodes, Greece and of the Zena Castle, Italy. IEECB Focus 2010, 341.
• Leissner, J., Kaiser, U., & Kilian, R. (2014). Built cultural heritage in times of climate change. Fraunhofer-Center for Central and Eastern Europe MoEZ: Leipzig, Germany.
• Leissner, J., Kilian, R., Kotova, L., Jacob, D., Mikolajewicz, U., Broström, T., ... & Vyhlídal, T. (2015). Climate for Culture: Assessing the impact of climate change on the future indoor climate in historic buildings using simulations. Heritage Science, 3, 1-15. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40494-015-0067-9
• López, C. P., Bettini, A. M., Khoja, A., Davis, A. M., Hatt, T., Braun, M., ... & Haas, F. (2021). Strategies and tools for potential assessment of Renewables (RES) in Alpine Space areas valid for historic buildings and sites. In IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science (Vol. 863, No. 1, p. 012007). IOP Publishing.
• López, C. S. P., & Frontini, F. (2014). Energy efficiency and renewable solar energy integration in heritage historic buildings. Energy Procedia, 48, 1493-1502.
• Misiopecki, C., Grynning, S., & Gustavsen, A. (2023). Thermal improvements of box-window using shading attachments. Hot-box measurements. Developments in the Built Environment, 16, 100185. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.dibe.2023.100185
• Prieto, I., Izkara, J. L., & Egusquiza, A. (2017). Building stock categorization for energy retrofitting of historic districts based on a 3D city model. DYNA-Ingeniería e Industria, 92(5). https://doi.org/10.6036/8147
• Rasmussen, T. V. (2013). Danmark: Elmehuset, Copenhagen. In Improving the Energy Efficiency of Historic Buildings: A handbook of best practice examples, technical solutions and research projects (pp. 54-56). Co2olBricks.
• Rajčić, V., Skender, A., & Damjanović, D. (2018). An innovative methodology of assessing the climate change impact on cultural heritage. International Journal of Architectural Heritage, 12(1), 21-35. https://doi.org/10.1080/15583058.2017.1354094
• Rieser, A., Leonardi, E., Haas, F., & Pfluger, R. (2021). A new decision guidance tool for the adoption of energy retrofit solutions in historic buildings. In IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science (Vol. 863, No. 1, p. 012016). IOP Publishing.
• Roberti, F., Oberegger, U. F., Lucchi, E., & Troi, A. (2017). Energy retrofit and conservation of a historic building using multi-objective optimization and an analytic hierarchy process. Energy and Buildings, 138, 1-10.
• Rodriguez-Maribona, I., & Grün, G. (2016). Energy Efficiency in European historic urban districts-a practical guidance.
• Shukla, A., & Sharma, A. (2018). Sustainability through Energy-Efficient Buildings (1st ed.). CRC Press. https://doi.org/10.1201/9781315159065
• Troi, A., & Bastian, Z. (Eds.). (2015). Energy Efficiency solutions for historic buildings: a handbook. De Gruyter.
• Troi, A., Herrera, D., Leonardi, E., Rieser, A., & Pfluger, R. (2023). The HiBERtool: How to find the suitable Historic Building Energy Retrofit solution for your house.
• Troi, A., & Lollini, R. (2011). Interdisciplinary research: FP7 project “3ENCULT–Efficient Energy for EU Cultural Heritage”. In Proceedings of the International Conference Energy Management in Cultural Heritage (Vol. 6, No. 8.4).
• URL 1. https://www.slideserve.com/liam/read-more-powerpoint-ppt-presentation Retrieved June 30, 2024.
• Zagorskas, J., Mykolas Paliulis, G., Burinskiene, M., Venckauskaite, J., & Rasmussen, T. V. (2013). Energetic Refurbishment of Historic Brick Buildings: Problems and Opportunities. Scientific Journal of Riga Technical University. Environmental and Climate Technologies, 12, 20-27. https://doi.org/10.2478/rtuect-2013-0012
• Zagorskas, J., Zavadskas, E. K., Turskis, Z., Burinskienė, M., Blumberga, A., & Blumberga, D. (2014). Thermal insulation alternatives of historic brick buildings in Baltic Sea Region. Energy and buildings, 78, 35-42. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enbuild.2014.04.010
• 3ENCULT. (2014a). Project Info. Retrieved March 30, 2024 from http://www.3encult.eu/en/project/Info.html
• 3ENCULT. (2014b). Project Work Packages Case Studies. Retrieved March 30, 2024 from http://www.3encult.eu/en/casestudies/default.html
• 3ENCULT. (2014c). Project Work Packages Analysis of Built Heritage. Retrieved March 30, 2024 from http://www.3encult.eu/en/project/workpackages/builtheritageanalysis/default.html
• 3ENCULT. (2014d). Project Work Packages. Retrieved March 30, 2024 from http://www.3encult.eu/en/project/workpackages/default.html
• 3ENCULT. (2014e). Project Work Packages Monitoring & Control. Retrieved March 30, 2024 from http://www.3encult.eu/en/project/workpackages/monitoringcontrol/default.html
• 3ENCULT. (2014f). Project Work Packages Energy Efficiency Solutions. Retrieved March 30, 2024 from http://www.3encult.eu/en/project/workpackages/energyefficientsolutions/default.html
• 3NCULT. (2014g). The 3ENCULT Project Methodology – Final Report. Retrieved June 30, 2024 from chrome-extension://efaidnbmnnnibpcajpcglclefindmkaj/http://www.3encult.eu/en/project/workpackages/builtheritageanalysis/Documents/3ENCULT_2.4.pdf
• 3NCULT. (2014h). The 3ENCULT Project Documentation of Each Study Case Report - Public Weigh House, Bolzano. Retrieved June 30, 2024 from chrome-extension://efaidnbmnnnibpcajpcglclefindmkaj/http://www.3encult.eu/en/casestudies/Documents/3ENCULT_Case%20Study%201.pdf
• 3NCULT. (2014i). The 3ENCULT Project Documentation of each study case Report - Engineering School of Béjar, Salamanca. Retrieved June 30, 2024 from chrome-extension://efaidnbmnnnibpcajpcglclefindmkaj/http://www.3encult.eu/en/casestudies/Documents/3ENCULT_Case%20Study%207.pdf
• 3NCULT. (2014k). The 3ENCULT Project Report on Methodology and Checklist. Retrieved June 30, 2024 from chrome-extension://efaidnbmnnnibpcajpcglclefindmkaj/http://www.3encult.eu/en/project/workpackages/builtheritageanalysis/Documents/3ENCULT_2.5.pdf
• 3NCULT. (2014l). The 3ENCULT Project Technical guidance on energy efficient renovation of historic. Retrieved June 30, 2024 from chrome-extension://efaidnbmnnnibpcajpcglclefindmkaj/http://www.3encult.eu/en/project/workpackages/energyefficientsolutions/Documents/3ENCULT_3.6.pdf
• 3NCULT. (2014m). Educational Material for University Studies. Retrieved June 30, 2024 from chrome-extension://efaidnbmnnnibpcajpcglclefindmkaj/http://www.3encult.eu/en/deliverables/Documents/BLL-Lesson%201.pdf