Meta-Analiz: Finans Çalışmaları Üzerine Bir Tartışma

Yıl 2019, , 69 - 88, 26.08.2019

Değer Alper , Muhammed Fatih Aydemir

https://doi.org/10.25095/mufad.606002

Öz

Günümüzde gerek teknolojik imkanların artması, gerekse bilginin küreselleşmesi bilimsel araştırmaların nitelik ve kapsamını da olumlu etkilemiştir. Bu yönde önemli bir ilerleme sağlanmıştır. Bu sürecin getirdiği önemli bir gelişme ise belirli konularda yapılan araştırmaların artmasıyla birlikte karmaşık sonuçların elde edilebilmesidir. Sosyal bir bilim dalı olarak finans alanında yapılan çalışmaların konuları aynı olsa bile karmaşık sonuçlar ortaya çıkmaktadır. Bu durumda finans alanında yapılan çalışmaların bir araya getirilerek sadeleştirilmesi ve daha anlaşılabilir sonuçların çıkarılması gerekmektedir. Bu durum aynı zamanda bilimsel bulguların gözlemlenen olguları açıklayıcı bir niteliğe dönüşmesi için de gerekli olmaktadır. Meta-analiz, bu karmaşık sonuçların tekrar ele alınması ve kullanılan istatistiki yöntemler ile çalışmaları sentezleyici bir rol oynamaktadır. Belirli bir konuda yapılan bağımsız araştırmaların genel sonucunu vermesi yönüyle meta-analiz, karar verme açısından önemli bir analiz metodu olarak görülmektedir. Bu doğrultuda çalışmanın amacı meta-analiz süreci ve finans alanında meta-analiz yöntemi ile ilgi bir tartışmaya yer vermektir.

Anahtar Kelimeler

Meta-analiz, Finans, Firma Performansı, Etki Büyüklüğü, Yayın Yanlılığı

Kaynakça

• Abramson, J. H. - Abramson, Z. H. (2001), “Making sense of data. A Self-Instruction manual on the interpretation of epidemiological data”, Oxford University Press, New York.
• Açıkel, Cengizhan (2009), “Meta-analiz ve Kanıta Dayalı Tıp'taki Yeri”, Klinik Psikofarmakoloji Bulteni, Cilt:19, Sayı:2, ss.164-172.
• Bakioğlu, Ayşen - Göktaş, Erkan (2018), “Bir Eğitim Politikası Belirleme Yöntemi: Meta Analiz”, Medeniyet Eğitim Araştırmaları Dergisi, Cilt:1-1, Sayı:2, ss.35-55.
• Bakioğlu, Ayşen - Özcan, Şafak (2016), Meta Analiz, Nobel Yayın, Ankara.
• Başol, Gülşah - Doğuyurt, Mehmet Fatih - Demir, Seda (2016), “Türkiye Örnekleminde Meta Analiz Çalışmalarının İçerik Analizi Ve Metodolojik Değerlendirilmesi”, International Journal Of Human Sciences, Cilt:13, Sayı:1, Ss.714-745.
• Bausch, Andreas - Fritz, Thomas - Boesecke, Kathrin (2007), “Performance Effects Of İnternationalization Strategies: A Meta-Analysis", In Regional Aspects of Multinationality And Performance, Emerald Group Publishing Limited, pp.143-176.
• Bausch, Andreas - Krist, Mario (2007), “The Effect Of Context-Related Moderators On The İnternationalization-Performance Relationship: Evidence From Meta-Analysis”, Management İnternational Review, Vol:47, No:3, pp.319-347.
• Biondi-Zoccai, Giuseppe - Lotrionte, M.- Landoni, G.- Modena, M. G. (2011), “The rough Guide To Systematic Reviews And Meta-Analyses”, HSR Proceedings İn İntensive Care & Cardiovascular Anesthesia, Vol:3, No:3, pp.161-173.
• Borenstein, M., Hedges, L., & Rothstein, H. (2007), “Meta-analysis: Fixed Effect Vs. Random Effects”, Meta-Analysis.Com (Access Date: 05.04.2018).
• Capon, Noel - Farley, John - Hoenig, Scott (1990) "Determinants of financial Performance: A Meta-Analysis." Management Science,Vol:36, No:10, pp.1143-1159.
• Card, Noel A. (2015), Applied Meta-Analysis For Social Science Research, Reprint Edition, The Guilford Press, New York.
• Chalmers, I. - Hedges, L. V. - Cooper, H. (2002), “A Brief History Of Research Synthesis”, Evaluation & the health professions, Vol:25, No:1, pp.12-37.
• Dan R. Dalton - Daily, Catherine M. - L. Johnson, Jonathan - Ellstrand, Alan E. (1999), “Number Of Directors And Financial Performance: A Meta-Analysis”, Academy of Management journal, Vol:42, No:6, pp.674-686.
• Dinçer, Serkan (2014), Eğitim Bilimlerinde Uygulamalı Meta-Analiz, Pegem Akademi, Ankara.
• Edeling, Alexander - Himme, Alexander (2018),“When Does Market Share Matter? New Empirical Generalizations from a Meta-Analysis of the Market Share-Performance Relationship”, Journal of Marketing, Vol:82, No:3, pp.1-24.
• Eisend, Martin (2017), “Meta-analysis in Advertising Research”, Journal of Advertising, Vol:46, No:1, pp. 21-35.
• Ellis, Paul .D. (2009), “Effect Size Equations”, http://www.polyu.edu.hk/mm/effectsizefaqs/effect_size_equations2.html (Access Date: 02.04.2018).
• Ellis, Paul D. (2010), The Essential Guide To Effect Sizes: Statistical Power, Meta-Analysis, And The İnterpretation Of Research Results, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
• Glass, Gene V. (1976), “Primary, Secondary, And Meta-Analysis Of Research”, Educational Researcher, Vol:5, No:10, pp.3-8.
• Göçmen, Gülşah Başol (2004), “Meta-analizin Genel Bir Değerlendirmesi”, Sakarya Üniversitesi Eğitim Fakültesi Dergisi, 7, ss.186-192.
• Haidich, Anna-Bettina (2010), “Meta-Analysis in Medical Research”, Hippokratia, Vol:14, No:1, pp.29–37.
• Hattie, John - Marsh, Herbert W. (1996), “The Relationship Between Research And Teaching: A Meta-Analysis”, Review of educational research, Vol:66, No:4, pp.507-542.
• Hedges, L. V. - Shymansky, J. A.- Woodworth, G. (1989), A Practical Guide To Modern Methods Of Meta-Analysis, National Science Teachers Association, Washington.
• Hemilä, Harri (2006), “Do Vitamins C and E Affect Respiratory İnfections?”, http://ethesis.helsinki.fi/julkaisut/laa/kansa/vk/hemila/dovitami.pdf (Access Date: 25.03.2018).
• Hofmann, Stefan G. - Sawyer, Alice T. - Witt, Asley A. - Oh, Diana (2010), “The Effect Of Mindfulness-Based Therapy On Anxiety And Depression: A Meta-Analytic Review”, Journal of Consulting And Clinical Psychology, Vol:78, No:2, pp.169-183.
• Hunter, John E. - Schmidt, Frank L. (2004), Methods of Meta-Analysis: Correcting Error And Bias İn Research Findings, Vol:2, Sage Publications, California.
• Johnson, Jeff S. - Jaramillo, Fernando (2018),” Meta-analyses in Sales Research”, Journal of Personal Selling & Sales Management, Vol:37, No:2, pp.134–152.
• Kersten, R.- Harms, J.- Liket, K., - Maas, K. (2017), “Small Firms, Large Impact? A Systematic Review of the SME Finance Literature”, World Development, Vol:97, pp.330-348.
• Khlif, Hichem - Chalmers, Keryn (2015), “A Review Of Meta-Analytic Research in Accounting”, Journal of Accounting literature, Vol:35, pp.1-27.
• Kim, Chang-Soo (2017), “A Meta-Analysis in Finance”, International Journal of Management and Applied Science, Vol:3, No:3, pp.123-128.
• Kim, Hae-Yong (2015), “Statistical Notes For Clinical Researchers: Effect Size”, Restorative dentistry & endodontics, Vol:40, No:4, pp.328-331.
• Kirca, A. H. - Hult, G. T. M. - Roth, K. - Cavusgil, S. T. - Perryy, M. Z. - Akdeniz, M. B. - Miller, J. C. (2011),“Firm-specific Assets, Multinationality, And Financial Performance: A Meta-Analytic Review And Theoretical İntegration”, Academy of Management Journal, Vol:54, No:1, pp.47-72.
• Lakens, Daniël. (2013), “Calculating and Reporting Effect Sizes To Facilitate Cumulative Science: A Practical Primer For T-Tests And ANOVAs”, Frontiers in psychology, Vol:4, Article:863, pp.1-12.
• Lehmann, Donald R. (2018), “Meta Analysis in Marketing”, Handbook of Marketing Analytics, Edward Elgar Publishing, Massachusetts.
• Margolis, Joshua D. - Elfenbein, Hillary Anger – Walsh, James P. (2007), “Does it Pay To Be Good? A Meta-Analysis And Redirection Of Research On The Relationship Between Corporate Social And Financial Performance”, https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Hillary_Elfenbein/publication/237455609_Does_it_pay_to_be_good_A_meta-analysis_and_redirection_of_research_on_the_relationship_between_corporate_social_and_financial_performance/links/00b49535e5f375434a000000.pdf, (Access Date: 27.02.2019).
• Möser, Guido - Schmidt, Peter (2014), “Meta-analysis: An alternative to narrative reviews for synthesising social science research?”, https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Peter_Schmidt9/publication/228562111_Meta-analysis_An_alternative_to_narrative_reviews_for_synthesising_social_science_research/links/542008eb0cf203f155c29c76.pdf, (Access Date: 19.02.2019).
• Normand, Sharon‐Lise T. (1999), “Meta Analysis: Formulating, Evaluating, Combining, And Reporting”, Statistics İn Medicine, Vol:18, No:3, pp.321-359.
• Orlitzky, Marc - Schmidt, Frank L. - Rynes, Sara L. (2003), “Corporate Social And Financial Performance: A Meta-Analysis”, Organization studies, Vol:24, No:3, pp.403-441.
• Özsoy, Sibel - Özsoy, Gökhan (2013), “Effect Size Reporting in Educational Research”, İlköğretim Online, Cilt:12, Sayı:2, ss.334-346.
• Parks-Leduc, Laura - Feldman, Gilad – Bardi, Anat (2015), “Personality Traits And Personal Values: A Meta-Analysis”, Personality and Social Psychology Review, Vol:19, No:1, pp.3-29.
• Quintana, Daniel S. (2017) “Statistical Considerations For Reporting And Planning Heart Rate Variability Case Control Studies”, Psychophysiology, Vol:54, No:3, pp.344-349.
• Sağlam, Mustafa - Yüksel, İsmail (2015), “Program Değerlendirmede Meta-Analiz Ve Meta-Değerlendirme”, Dumlupınar Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Dergisi, Sayı:18, ss.175-188.
• Schmidt, F. L., - Hunter, J. E. (2014), Methods of meta-Analysis: Correcting Error And Bias İn Research Findings, Sage publications, California.
• Schwens, Christian - Zapkau, F. B. - Bierwerth, M. - Isidor, R. - Knight, G. - Kabst, R. (2018), “International Entrepreneurship: A Meta–Analysis on the Internationalization and Performance Relationship”, Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice, Vol:42, No:5, pp.734-768.
• Shannon, Harry (2016), “A Statistical Note On Karl Pearson’s 1904 Meta-Analysis”, Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine, Vol:109, No:8, pp.310-311.
• Spiegel, D. (2000), “The Price Of Abusing Children And Number”, Sexuality and Culture, Vol:4, pp.63–66.
• Şelli, Mehmet - Doğan, Zeki (2011), “Meta Analiz İle Tarımsal Verilerin Değerlendirilmesi”, Harran Tarım Ve Gıda Bilimleri Dergisi, Cilt:15, Sayı:4, ss.45-56.
• Şen, Sedat - Akbaş, Nihal (2016), “Çok dÜZEYLİ META-ANALİZ YÖNTEMLERİ ÜZERİNE BİR ÇALIŞMA”, Eğitimde ve Psikolojide Ölçme ve Değerlendirme Dergisi, Cilt:7, Sayı:1, ss.1-17.
• Thalheimer, Will - Cook, Samantha (2002), “How to calculate Effect Sizes From Published Research Articles: A Simplified Methodology”, Retrieved November 31, 2002 from http://work-learning.com/effect_sizes.htm. (Access Date: 25.10.2018).
• Tosi, Henry L. – Werner, Steve - Katz, Jeffrey P., - Gomez-Mejia, Luis R. (2000), “How Much Does Performance Matter? A Meta-Analysis of CEO Pay Studies”, Journal of Management, Vol:26, No:2, pp.301-339.
• Ülbegi, İlksun Didem - Yalçın, Azmi (2016), “Örgütsel Bağlılık Ve İş Doyumu İlişkisinin Meta Analiz Yöntemiyle İncelenmesi”, Türk Psikoloji Dergisi, Cilt:31, Sayı:77, ss.77-80.
• Wang, Morgan C. - Bushman, Brad J. (1998), “Using the Normal Quantile Plot To Explore Meta-Analytic Datasets”, Psychological Methods, Vol:3, No:1, pp.46-54.
• Wolf, Fredrich M. (1986), Meta-analysis: Quantitative Methods For Research Synthesis, Sage Publications, California.
• WOS (2019), “Number of Researches involving Meta-Analysis”, http://proxy.uludag.deep-knowledge.net/MuseSessionID=0210iral3/MuseProtocol=http/MuseHost=apps.webofknowledge.com/MusePath/RAMore.do?product=WOS&search_mode=GeneralSearch&SID=F2Vr23lp8wI8mGR9EIW&qid=1&ra_mode=more&ra_name=PublicationYear&colName=WOS&viewType=raMore (Access Date: 09.02.2019).
• Daily, Catherine M. - Trevis Certo, S. - Dalton, Dan R. - Roengpitya, Rungpen (2003), “IPO Underpricing: A Meta–Analysis and Research Synthesis”, Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice, Vol:27, No:3, pp.271-295.
• Krist, Mario (2009), Internationalization and firm Performance: The Role Of İntangible Resources, Springer Science & Business Media, Wiesbaden.
• Awe, A. Olajumoke - Kulangara, Nisha - Henderson, Demetria F., (2018), "Outsourcing and Firm Performance: A Meta-Analysis", Journal of Strategy and Management, Vol:11, No:3, pp.371-386.
• Fernandes, Daniel - Lynch Jr, John G. - Netemeyer, Richard G. (2014),”Financial Literacy, Financial Education, And Downstream Financial Behaviors”, Management Science, Vol:60, No:8, pp.1861-1883.
• Liang, Ting-Peng - Jun-Jer You, - Chih-Chung Liu, (2010),“A Resource-Based Perspective On İnformation Technology And Firm Performance: A Meta Analysis”, Industrial Management & Data Systems, Vol:110, No:8, pp.1138-1158.
• Yılmaz, Kürşat - Altınkurt, Yahya - Yıldırım, Hatice (2015), “Türkiye’deki Öğretmenlerin Örgütsel Vatandaşlık Davranışlarına Cinsiyet, Kıdem Ve Branş Değişkenlerinin Etkisi: Bir Meta Analiz Çalışması”, Eğitim ve Bilim, Cilt:40, Sayı:178, ss.285-304.
• Zhao, Shanyang (1991), “Metatheory, Metamethod, Meta-Data-Analysis: What, Why, And How?”, Sociological perspectives, Vol:34, No:3, pp.377-390. Simplice A. Asongu (2015), “Finance and growth: New Evidence From Meta-Analysis”, Managerial Finance, Vol:41 No:6, pp.615-639.
• Boyd, Brian K. (1991), “Strategic Planning And Financial Performance: A Meta Analytic Review”, Journal of management studies, Vol:28, No:4, pp.353-374.
• Wagner, Dominik - Block Joern H. - Miller, Danny - Schwens, Christian - Xi, Guoqian (2015), “A meta-analysis of the Financial Performanceo of Family Firms: Another Attempt”, Journal of Family Business Strategy, Vol:6, No:1, pp.3-13.
• Greenwald, Rob - Hedges, Larry V. - Laine, Richard D. (1994), “When Reinventing The Wheel İs Not Necessary: A Case Study İn The Use Of Meta-Analysis İn Education Finance”, Journal of Education Finance, Vol:20, No:1, pp.1-20.
• Gallardo-Vázquez, D. - Barroso-Méndez, M. J. - Pajuelo-Moreno, M. L. - Sánchez-Meca, J. (2019), “Corporate Social Responsibility Disclosure and Performance: A Meta-Analytic Approach”, Sustainability, Vol:11, No:4, pp.1115.
• Geyer-Klingeberg, Jerome - Hang, Markus - Rathgeber, Andreas (2018), “Corporate Financial Hedging And Firm Value: A Meta-Analysis”, Available at SSRN 3221718.
• Dalton, Dan R. - Daily, Catherine M. - Certo, S. Trevis - Roengpitya, Rungpen (2003), “Meta-analyses of Financial Performance And Equity: Fusion Or Confusion?”, Academy of Management Journal, Vol:46, No:1, pp.13-26.
• Albertini, Elisabeth - Berger-Remy, Fabienne (2019), “Intellectual Capital and Financial Performance: A Meta-Analysis and Research Agenda”, M@n@gement, Vol:22, No:2, pp.216-249.
• O'Boyle, Ernest H. - Patel, Pankaj C., - Gonzalez‐Mulé, Erik (2016), “Employee Ownership And Firm Performance: A Meta Analysis”, Human Resource Management Journal, Vol:26, No:4, pp.425-448.
• Hansen, Christopher - Block, Jorn H. - Neuenkirch, Matthias (2018), “Family Firm Performance over the Business Cycle: A Meta-Analysis”, Research Papers in Economics, No:6/18.
• Nothnagel, Katja (2008), Empirical Research Within Resource-Based Theory: A Meta-Analysis Of The Central Propositions, Springer Science & Business Media. (https://sakaluk.wordpress.com/2016/02/16/7-make-it-pretty-plots-for-meta-analysis/, Access Date: 18.02.2019).