REFUGEES AND POLITICAL STABILITY IN LEBANON

Yıl 2014, Cilt: 6 Sayı: 1, 50 - 69, 01.07.2014

Benjamin Macqueen Kylie Baxter

Öz

This article compares the Palestinian and Syrian refugee crises on political stability in Lebanon. Debates over the “implantation” tawteen of the Palestinian refugee community, alongside the increasing militarization of the community after 1970 were key factors in the outbreak of civil war in Lebanon in 1975. The arrival of over 1 million Syrian refugees in Lebanon since 2011 has raised similar concerns of whether Lebanon will again witness political collapse and civil conflict. However, it is argued that whilst the current refugee crisis in Lebanon is broadly comparative to the events of the early 1970s, the scale of the current refugee crisis alongside the different profile of the refugee community has created different dynamics. Specifically, the blurring of lines between the host community and the refugee community through familial, personal, and other links makes the dynamics of refugee politics in Lebanon today markedly different from that of the early 1970s. In addition, where Lebanese political actors had initially sought to politicize the refugee issue, the scale of the crisis has made this a national, not political issue, serving to reduce the distance between political opponents in the country. This is not to argue that the current crisis does not pose potentially existential challenges to the Lebanese state. Instead, the nature of the crisis is such that efforts at isolating the refugee “problem”, as took place before and after the Lebanese civil war, are not possible today

Anahtar Kelimeler

Lebanon, Syria, Confessionalism, Refugees, Civil Conflict

LÜBNAN’DA SİYASİ İSTİKRAR VE MÜLTECİLER

Öz

Bu makale, Filistin ve Suriyeli mülteci krizinin Lübnan’daki siyasi istikrara etkisini karşılaştırmaktadır. Filistin mülteci topluluğunun 1970 sonrasında militarize olmasının yanı sıra bu topluluğun Lübnan toplumuna eklemlenmesi tawteen üzerindeki tartışmalar, 1975 yılında Lübnan’da iç savaşın patlak vermesinin temel etkenleriydi. 2011 yılından beri Lübnan’a göç eden Suriyeli mültecilerin sayısının 1 milyonu geçmesi, Lübnan’ın yine siyasi bir çöküş ve sivil çatışmaya tanıklık yapıp yapmayacağı konusundaki benzer endişeleri arttırmaya başlamıştır. Lübnan’daki mevcut mülteci krizi genel olarak 1970’lerdeki ile karşılaştırılabilecek nitelikte olsa da, mevcut mülteci krizinde mülteci topluluğunun profilinin değişiklik arz etmesinin, bunun yanı sıra krizin çok daha geniş bir ölçeğe sahip olmasının farklı dinamikleri ortaya çıkardığı iddia edilmektedir. Özellikle ev sahibi toplumun ve mülteci topluluğunun arasındaki çizgilerin ailesel, kişisel veya diğer bağlantılar yoluyla birbirine girmesi, Lübnan’da bugünkü mülteci siyasetinin dinamiklerini 1970’lerin başındakinden belirgin bir şekilde farklı kılmaktadır. Buna ek olarak, her ne kadar Lübnanlı siyasi aktörler başlangıçta mülteci sorununu siyasallaştırmaya çalışmışlarsa da, krizin ölçeği bunu siyasal değil, ülkedeki siyasi muhalifler arasındaki mesafeyi azaltmaya hizmet eden ulusal bir mesele haline getirmiştir. Bu durum mevcut krizin Lübnan devletine varoluşsal bir tehdit oluşturma ihtimali olmadığı anlamına gelmemektedir. Daha ziyade, bu krizin doğası öyle bir hal almıştır ki, Lübnan iç savaşının öncesinde ve sonrasında olduğu gibi mülteci sorununu tecrit etme çabaları, artık çok mümkün gözükmemektedir

Anahtar Kelimeler

Arap Baharı, Rusya, Suriye

Kaynakça

• Bahout, Joseph “Lebanon at the Brink: The Impact of the Syrian Civil War”, Middle East Brief (Crown Center for Middle East Studies), No. 76, January 2014.
• Brynen, Rex and Roula el-Rifai, Palestinian Refugees: Challenges of Repatriation and Development, (London, IB Tauris: 2007).
• Brynen, Rex, Sanctuary and Survival, the PLO in Lebanon, (Boulder: Westview Press, 1990).
• El Khazen, Farid, The Breakdown of the State in Lebanon, 1967-1976, (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 2000).
• Fincham, Kathleen, “Shifting Youth Identities and Notions of Citizenship in the Palestinian Diaspora: The Case of Lebanon” in Dina Kiwan (ed.) Naturalization Policies, Education and Citizenship: Multicultural and Multinational Societies in International Perspective, (London: Palgrave Macmillan, 2013.
• Haddad, Simon, The Palestinian Impasse in Lebanon: The Politics of Refugee Integration, (London, Sussex Academic Press, 2003)
• Kauri, Vidya, “Lebanon parliament fails to elect president”, Al Jazeera, 23 April, 2014
• Khalaf, Samir, Civil and Uncivil Violence in Lebanon: A History of the Internationalization of Communal Conflict, (New York: Columbia University Press, 2002).
• Khalidi, Muhammad Ali, Palestinian Refugees in Lebanon (Beirut: Institute for Palestinian Studies, 2002).
• MacQueen, Benjamin, An Introduction to Middle East Politics, (London: Sage, 2013).
• Political Culture and Conflict Resolution in the Arab World: Lebanon and Algeria (Melbourne: MUP, 2009).
• Meier, Daniel, “Al-tawteen: the implantation problem as an idiom of the Palestinian presence in post-civil war Lebanon”, Arab Studies Quarterly, Vol. 32, No. 3, 2010.
• Naufal, Hala, Syrian Refugees in Lebanon: the Humanitarian Approach under Political Divisions, (San Domenico di Fiesole: European University Institute, 2013/13).
• Peteet, Julie, “From refugees to a minority, Palestinians in post-war Lebanon”, Middle East Report, Issue 200 1996.
• Siklawi, Rami, “The Dynamics of Palestinian Political Endurance in Lebanon”, Middle East Journal, Vol. 64, No. 6, 2010.
• Sorby, Karol, “Lebanon and the 1969 Cairo Agreement”, Arichiv Orientalni, Vol. 80, No. 1, 2012.
• UNHCR, “Syrian Regional Refugee Response”
• UNRWA, “Resolution 302” , “Where we work”
• Viorst, Milton, UNRWA and Peace in the Middle East, (Washington DC: Middle East Institute, 1984).
• World Bank, Lebanon: Economic and Social Impact Assessment of the Syrian Conflict, (Washington DC: World Bank, September 2013).
• Zetter, Roger, Héloïse Ruaudel, Sarah Deardorff-Miller, Eveliina Lyytinen, and Cameron Thibos, The Syrian displacement crisis and a Regional Development and Protection Programme: Mapping and meta-analysis of existing studies of costs, impacts and protection (Copenhagen: Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Denmark, 4 February 2014).