Inferences from Criminal Cases of Individuals Diagnosed with Schizophrenia: A Retrospective Document Analysis

Abstract

Objective: This study aims to examine the criminal characteristics of individuals diagnosed with schizophrenia involved in criminal behavior. Method: This study employed retrospective document analysis as a qualitative research method. Data were obtained from the website of the Court of Cassation of the Republic of Turkey. In July 2022, searches were conducted using the keyword “schizophrenia”. All published criminal case files directly related to individuals diagnosed with schizophrenia and reviewed by the criminal divisions of the Court of Cassation were examined. A total of 426 case files were analyzed (N = 426). Results: Criminal cases from 2010-2021 were categorized by offender’s age, legal interest, crime type, violence of crime, and victim. Most cases involved adults. About 25% of individuals diagnosed with schizophrenia committed "crimes against property" and "crimes against liberty," with “theft, intentional injury, and threats” being the most common offenses. The crimes were generally moderately violent, and the victims were often individuals unknown to the offender. Conclusion: This study sheds light on the role of individuals diagnosed with schizophrenia who are involved in crime within the criminal justice system. In this context, it is recommended that mental health professionals be involved in all judicial processes to assess the mental state, conduct risk assessments, determine appropriate treatment approaches, and better understand the key characteristics related to criminal behavior in individuals with schizophrenia. Additionally, tailoring rehabilitation programs according to the type of crime and training people working in the legal field in mental health can significantly improve the care and management of these individuals.

Keywords

• Crime
• criminal behaviour
• schizophrenia

Şizofreni Tanılı Bireylerin Ceza Davalarından Çıkarımlar: Retrospektif Bir Döküman Analizi

Öz

Amaç: Bu çalışmanın amacı suça karışmış şizofreni tanısı almış bireylerin suç özelliklerini incelemektir. Yöntem: Bu çalışmada nitel araştırma yöntemi olarak retrospektif doküman analizi kullanılmıştır. Veriler Türkiye Cumhuriyeti Yargıtay'ının web sitesinden elde edilmiştir. Temmuz 2022 tarihinde "şizofreni" anahtar kelimesi kullanılarak taramalar yapılmıştır. Şizofreni tanısı almış bireylerle doğrudan ilişkili olup Yargıtay ceza daireleri tarafından incelenen ve yayımlanmış tüm ceza dava dosyaları incelenmiştir. Toplam 426 dava dosyası analiz edilmiştir (N = 426). Bulgular: 2010-2021 yılları arasındaki ceza davaları failin yaşı, hukuki değer, suç tipi, şiddet düzeyi ve mağdura göre kategorize edilmiştir. Vakaların çoğu yetişkinleri içermektedir. Şizofreni tanısı almış bireylerin yaklaşık %25'i malvarlığına ve hürriyete karşı suçlar işlemiş olup, en yaygın suç tipleri hırsızlık, kasten yaralama ve tehdit olmuştur. Suçlar genellikle orta şiddettedir ve mağdurlar çoğunlukla failin tanımadığı kişilerdir. Sonuç: Bu çalışma, suça karışan şizofreni tanısı almış bireylerin ceza adalet sistemi içindeki rolüne ışık tutmaktadır. Bu bağlamda, ruhsal sağlığı profesyonellerinin; ruhsal durumu değerlendirmek, risk değerlendirmesi yapmak, uygun tedavi yaklaşımlarını belirlemek ve şizofreni tanılı bireylerde suç davranışıyla ilgili temel özellikleri daha iyi anlamak için yargılama sürecin tamamına dahil edilmeleri önerilmektedir. Ek olarak rehabilitasyon programlarını suç tipine göre uyarlamak ve hukuk alanında çalışan kişileri ruh sağlığı konusunda bilgilendirmek bu bireylerin bakımını ve yönetimini önemli ölçüde iyileştirebilir.

Anahtar Kelimeler

• suç
• suç davranışı
• şizofreni

Kaynakça

1. Alish Y, Birger M, Manor N, Kertzman S, Zerzion M, Kotler M et al. (2007) Schizophrenia sex offenders: a clinical and epidemiological comparison study. Int J Law Psychiatry,30:459-466.
2. Anwar S, Långström N, Grann M, Fazel S (2011) Is arson the crime most strongly associated with psychosis?—a national case-control study of arson risk in schizophrenia and other psychoses. Schizophr Bull, 37:580-586.
3. Belli H, Ozcetin A, Ertem U, Tuyluoglu E, Namli M, Bayik Y et al. (2010) Perpetrators of homicide with schizophrenia: sociodemographic characteristics and clinical factors in the eastern region of Türkiye. Compr Psychiatry, 51:135-141.
4. Bowen GA (2009) Document analysis as a qualitative research method. Qual Res J, 9:27-40.
5. Daci J (2010) Legal principles, legal values and legal norms: are they the same or different? Academicus Int Sci J, 1:109-115.
6. Demirbaş T (2021) Ceza Hukuku Genel Hükümler, 9th ed. Ankara, Seçkin Yayınevi.
7. Drake CR, Pathe M (2004) Understanding sexual offending in schizophrenia. Crim Behav Ment Health, 14:108-120.
8. Fazel S, Gulati G, Linsell L, Geddes JR, Grann M (2009) Schizophrenia and violence: systematic review and meta-analysis. PLoS Med, 6:e1000120.

9. Fazel S, Smith EN, Chang Z, Geddes JR (2018) Risk factors for interpersonal violence: an umbrella review of meta-analyses. Br J Psychiatry, 213:609-614.
10. Franzke AS, Muis I, Schäfer MT (2021) Data ethics decision aid (deda): a dialogical framework for ethical inquiry of AI and data projects in the Netherlands. Ethics Inf Technol, 23:551-567.
11. Gough K, Churchward S, Dorkins E, Fee J, Oxborrow S, Parker J et al. (2007) Audit of the NICE Guidelines for Schizophrenia in an NHS forensic psychiatric service. Br J Forensic Pract, 9:28-34.
12. Hammarström L, Devik SA, Hellzén O, Häggström M (2020) The path of compassion in forensic psychiatry. Arch Psychiatr Nurs, 34:435-441.
13. He Y, Gu Y, Yu M, Li Y, Li G, Hu Z (2022) Research on interpersonal violence in schizophrenia: based on different victim types. BMC Psychiatry, 22:172.
14. Heinrichs RW, Sam EP (2012) Schizophrenia and crime: how predictable are charges, convictions and violence? Int J Ment Health Addict, 10:122-131.
15. Hodgins S, Klein S (2017) New clinically relevant findings about violence by people with schizophrenia. Can J Psychiatry, 62:86-93.
16. Howner K, Andiné P, Engberg G, Ekström EH, Lindström E, Nilsson M et al. (2020) Pharmacological treatment in forensic psychiatry—a systematic review. Front Psychiatry, 10:963.
17. Hörberg U (2018) The art of understanding in forensic psychiatric care–From a caring science perspective based on a lifeworld approach. Issues Ment Health Nurs, 39:802-809.
18. Hörberg U, Dahlberg K (2015) Caring potentials in the shadows of power, correction, and discipline—Forensic psychiatric care in the light of the work of Michel Foucault. Int J Qual Stud Health Well-being, 10:28703.
19. İnan S, Yıldızhan E, Öncü F (2018) The disease history, sociodemographics, and criminal features of the homicidal forensic psychiatric patients. Turk Psikiyatri Derg, 29:258-268.
20. Kim AM (2019) Crimes by people with schizophrenia in Korea: comparison with the general population. BMC Psychiatry, 19:377.
21. Koca M, Üzülmez İ (2024) Türk Ceza Hukuku Genel Hükümler, 17. ed. Ankara, Seçkin Yayınevi.
22. Krešić M (2020) About non-positivist perspective on legal values in international law. Bratislava Law Rev, 4:31-48.
23. Lam AA, Penney SR, Simpson AI (2023) Serious mental illness and sexual offending in forensic psychiatric patients. Sex Abuse, 35:103-126.
24. Lamberti JS (2007) Understanding and preventing criminal recidivism among adults with psychotic disorders. Psychiatr Serv, 58:773-781.
25. Lok P, Dijk S (2019) Violence and mental illness: five minutes with...Seena Fazel. BMJ, 366:l5199.
26. Eriksson Å, Romelsjö A, Stenbacka M, Tengström A (2011) Early risk factors for criminal offending in schizophrenia: a 35-year longitudinal cohort study. Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol, 46:925-932.
27. McGrath J, Saha S, Chant D, Welham J (2008) Schizophrenia: a concise overview of incidence, prevalence, and mortality. Epidemiol Rev, 30:67-76.
28. Nielssen O, Bourget D, Laajasalo T, Liem M, Labelle A, Häkkänen-Nyholm H et al. (2011) Homicide of strangers by people with a psychotic illness. Schizophr Bull, 37:572-579.
29. Silverstein SM, Del Pozzo J, Roché M, Boyle D, Miskimen T (2015) Schizophrenia and violence: realities and recommendations. Crime Psychol Rev, 1:21-42.
30. Slamanig R, Reisegger A, Winkler H, De Girolamo G, Carrà G, Crocamo C et al. (2021) A systematic review of non-pharmacological strategies to reduce the risk of violence in patients with schizophrenia spectrum disorders in forensic settings. Front Psychiatry, 12:618860.
31. Sonnweber M, Lau S, Kirchebner J (2024) Exploring characteristics of homicide offenders with schizophrenia spectrum disorders via machine learning. Int J Offender Ther Comp Criminol, 68:713-732.
32. Taylor PJ (1985) Motives for offending among violent and psychotic men. Br J Psychiatry, 147:491-498.
33. Ural C, Öncü F, Belli H, Soysal H (2013) Violent behavior variables among patients with schizophrenia under forensic psychiatric process: a case-control study. Turk Psikiyatri Derg, 24:17-24.
34. Uygur N, Işıklı M, Ögel K, Çeliker AR (1992) Suç işlemiş şizofrenlerin demografik özellikleri ve suç profili. Dusunen Adam, 5:5-9.
35. Vasic N, Segmiller F, Rees F, Jäger M, Becker T, Ormanns N et al. (2018) Psychopharmacologic treatment of in-patients with schizophrenia: comparing forensic and general psychiatry. J Forens Psychiatry Psychol, 29:1-15.
36. Vinokur D, Levine S, Roe D, Krivoy A, Fischel T (2014) Age of onset group characteristics in forensic patients with schizophrenia. Eur Psychiatry, 29:149-152.
37. Völlm BA, Clarke M, Herrando VT, Seppänen AO, Gosek P, Heitzman J et al. (2018) European psychiatric association (epa) guidance on forensic psychiatry: evidence based assessment and treatment of mentally disordered offenders. Eur Psychiatry, 51:58-73.
38. Whiting D, Gulati G, Geddes JR, Fazel S (2022) Association of schizophrenia spectrum disorders and violence perpetration in adults and adolescents from 15 countries: a systematic review and meta-analysis. JAMA Psychiatry, 79:120-132.
39. Whiting D, Lichtenstein P, Fazel S (2021) Violence and mental disorders: a structured review of associations by individual diagnoses, risk factors, and risk assessment. Lancet Psychiatry, 8:150-161.