Relationship Between Types of Aggression and Executive Functions: A Meta-Analysis Study

Öz

This meta-analysis systematically reviewed original research examining the relationship between executive function (EF) and different forms (physical and relational) and functions (reactive and proactive) of aggression. The primary aim was to clarify how cognitive control processes, such as inhibition, working memory, and cognitive flexibility, relate to distinct patterns of aggressive behavior. A systematic literature search was conducted in Medline, Scopus, and PsycINFO, including studies that assessed EF using validated measures and reported correlation coefficients with aggression variables. After screening according to PRISMA guidelines, 24 studies involving 10,181 participants met the inclusion criteria. Random-effects models were used to calculate pooled effect sizes, taking into account variability across studies. The results showed that the strongest average correlation was found between executive function and physical aggression (r = .14, p = .29), though this association did not reach statistical significance. The weakest correlation emerged between EF and reactive aggression (r = –.003, p = .97), suggesting virtually no relationship. Similarly, correlations between EF and proactive aggression (r = .14, p = .09) and relational aggression (r = .007, p = .93) were weak and non-significant. Considerable heterogeneity was observed across all models (I² > 95%), indicating that study differences in design, sample characteristics, and measurement tools may have influenced results. Overall, the findings reveal a complex and inconsistent pattern linking executive functioning and aggression.

Anahtar Kelimeler

• Executive function
• aggression
• meta-analysis

Saldırganlık Türleri ile Yürütücü İşlevler Arasındaki İlişki: Meta-Analiz Çalışması

Öz

Bu meta-analiz, yürütücü işlev (Yİ) ile saldırganlığın farklı biçimleri (fiziksel ve ilişkisel) ve işlevleri (reaktif ve proaktif) arasındaki ilişkiyi inceleyen özgün araştırmaları sistematik olarak gözden geçirmiştir. Birincil amaç, inhibisyon, çalışma belleği ve bilişsel esneklik gibi bilişsel kontrol süreçlerinin farklı saldırganlık örüntüleriyle nasıl ilişkili olduğunu açıklığa kavuşturmaktır. Sistematik literatür taraması Medline, Scopus ve PsycINFO veri tabanlarında yürütülmüş, yürütücü işlevleri geçerli ölçümlerle değerlendiren ve saldırganlık değişkenleriyle korelasyon katsayılarını rapor eden çalışmalar dahil edilmiştir. PRISMA yönergelerine göre yapılan tarama sonrasında, 10.181 katılımcıyı içeren toplam 24 çalışma dâhil edilme kriterlerini karşılamıştır. Çalışmalar arasındaki farklılıkları dikkate almak için rassal etkiler modeli kullanılarak birleştirilmiş etki büyüklükleri hesaplanmıştır. Sonuçlar, yürütücü işlev ile fiziksel saldırganlık arasındaki ortalama korelasyonun en yüksek olduğunu göstermiştir (r = .14, p = .29); ancak bu ilişki istatistiksel olarak anlamlı bulunmamıştır. En zayıf korelasyon ise yürütücü işlev ile reaktif saldırganlık arasında ortaya çıkmıştır (r = –.003, p = .97), bu da neredeyse hiçbir ilişki olmadığını göstermektedir. Benzer şekilde, yürütücü işlev ile proaktif saldırganlık (r = .14, p = .09) ve ilişkisel saldırganlık (r = .007, p = .93) arasındaki korelasyonlar da zayıf ve anlamlı değildir. Tüm modellerde önemli düzeyde heterojenlik gözlenmiştir (I² > 95%), bu da araştırma tasarımlarındaki, örneklem özelliklerindeki ve ölçüm araçlarındaki farklılıkların sonuçları etkilemiş olabileceğini göstermektedir. Genel olarak, bulgular yürütücü işlevler ile saldırganlık arasındaki ilişkinin karmaşık ve tutarsız bir örüntü sergilediğini ortaya koymaktadır.

Anahtar Kelimeler

• Yürütücü işlev
• Saldırganlık
• Meta-analiz

Kaynakça

1. Anderson CA, Bushman BJ (2002) Human aggression. Annu Rev Psychol, 53:27-51.
2. Andreou E (2006) Social preference, perceived popularity and social intelligence: Relations to overt and relational aggression. Sch Psychol Int, 27:339-351.
3. Baker ER, Jensen CJ, Tisak MS (2019) A closer examination of aggressive subtypes in early childhood: Contributions of executive function and single-parent status. Early Child Dev Care, 189:733-746.
4. Barker ED, Séguin JR, White HR, Bates ME, Lacourse E, Carbonneau R et al. (2007) Developmental trajectories of male physical violence and theft: Relations to neurocognitive performance. Arch Gen Psychiatry, 64:592-599.
5. Bergeron TK, Valliant PM (2001) Executive function and personality in adolescent and adult offenders vs non-offenders. J Offender Rehabil, 33:27-45.
6. Best JR, Miller PH (2010) A developmental perspective on executive function. Child Dev, 81:1641-1660.
7. Björkqvist K, Lagerspetz KM, Kaukiainen A (1992) Do girls manipulate and boys fight? Developmental trends in regard to direct and indirect aggression. Aggress Behav, 18:117-127.
8. Borenstein M, Cooper H, Hedges L, Valentine J (2009) Effect sizes for continuous data. In The Handbook of Research Synthesis and Meta-Analysis, 2nd ed. (Eds H Cooper, LV Hedges, JC Valentine):221-235. New York, Russell Sage Foundation.

9. Broomhall L (2005) Acquired sociopathy: A neuropsychological study of executive dysfunction in violent offenders. Psychiatry Psychol Law, 12:367-387.
10. Caporaso JS, Marcovitch S, Boseovski JJ (2021) Executive function and the development of social information processing during the preschool years. Cogn Dev, 58:101018.
11. Card NA, Stucky BD, Sawalani GM, Little TD (2008) Direct and indirect aggression during childhood and adolescence: A meta-analytic review of gender differences, intercorrelations, and relations to maladjustment. Child Dev, 79:1185-1229.
12. Cooley JL, Fite PJ (2016) Peer victimization and forms of aggression during middle childhood: The role of emotion regulation. J Abnorm Child Psychol, 44:535-546.
13. Crick NR, Dodge KA (1994) A review and reformulation of social information-processing mechanisms in children's social adjustment. Psychol Bull, 115:74-101.
14. Crick NR, Grotpeter JK (1995) Relational aggression, gender and social-psychological adjustment. Child Dev, 66:710-722.
15. Crick NR, Ostrov JM, Kawabata Y (2007) Relational aggression and gender: An overview. In The Cambridge Handbook of Violent Behavior and Aggression (Eds DJ Flannery, I Waldman, A Vazsonyi):243-258. Cambridge, Cambridge Univ Press.
16. Crick NR, Werner NE, Casas JF, O’Brien KM, Nelson DA, Grotpeter JK et al. (1999) Childhood aggression and gender: A new look at an old problem. In Nebraska Symposium on Motivation (Ed D Bernstein):75-141. Lincoln, University of Nebraska Press.
17. Crick NR, Werner NE, Casas JN, O’Brien KM, Grotpeter JK, Markon K (1999) Gender and aggression: A new look at an old problem. In Gender and Motivation, Vol 45 (Ed D Bernstein):75-143. Lincoln, University of Nebraska Press.
18. Cruz AR, de Castro-Rodrigues A, Barbosa F (2020) Executive dysfunction, violence and aggression. Aggress Violent Behav, 51:101380.
19. DerSimonian R, Kacker R (2007) Random-effects model for meta-analysis of clinical trials: An update. Contemp Clin Trials, 28:105-114.
20. Diamantopoulou S, Rydell AM, Thorell L, Bohlin G (2007) Impact of executive functioning and symptoms of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder on children’s peer relations and school performance. Dev Neuropsychol, 32:521-542.
21. DipT SP (2024) Forms and functions of aggression in preschool-age children: the roles of executive function and emotion understanding (Doctoral dissertation). Canterbury, University of Canterbury.
22. Dodge KA, Lochman JE, Harnish JD, Bates JE, Pettit GS (1997) Reactive and proactive aggression in school children and psychiatrically impaired chronically assaultive youth. J Abnorm Psychol, 106:37-51.
23. Egger M, Smith GD, Schneider M, Minder C (1997) Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test. BMJ, 315:629-634.
24. Ellis ML, Weiss B, Lochman JE (2009) Executive functions in children: Associations with aggressive behavior and appraisal processing. J Abnorm Child Psychol, 37:945-956.
25. Ersan C (2019) Physical aggression, relational aggression and anger in preschool children: The mediating role of emotion regulation. J Gen Psychol, 147:18-42.
26. Friedman NP, Rhee SH, Ross JM, Corley RP, Hewitt JK (2021) Genetic and environmental relations of executive functions to antisocial personality disorder symptoms and psychopathy. Int J Psychophysiol, 163:67-78.
27. Giancola PR, Moss HB, Martin CS, Kirisci L, Tarter RE (1996) Executive cognitive functioning predicts reactive aggression in boys at high risk for substance abuse: A prospective study. Alcohol Clin Exp Res, 20:740-744.
28. Granvald V, Marciszko C (2016) Relations between key executive functions and aggression in childhood. Child Neuropsychol, 22:537-555.
29. Hancock M (2014) Executive Dysfunction: A Contributor to Subtypes of Violence or General Criminality? London, University of Western Ontario.
30. Hancock M, Tapscott JL, Hoaken PNS (2010) Role of executive dysfunction in predicting frequency and severity of violence. Aggress Behav, 36:338-349.
31. Hawley PH (1999) The ontogenesis of social dominance: A strategy-based evolutionary perspective. Dev Rev, 19:97-132.
32. Hecht LK, Latzman RD (2018) Exploring the differential associations between components of executive functioning and reactive and proactive aggression. J Clin Exp Neuropsychol, 40:62-74.
33. Heilbron N, Prinstein MJ (2008) A review and reconceptualization of social aggression: Adaptive and maladaptive correlates. Clin Child Fam Psychol Rev, 11:176-217.
34. Higgins JPT, Thompson SG (2011) Cochrane Handbook for Conducting Systematic Reviews. Hoboken, NJ, Wiley.
35. Holley SR, Ewing ST, Stiver JT, Bloch L (2017) The relationship between emotion regulation, executive functioning, and aggressive behaviors. J Interpers Violence, 32:1692-1707.
36. Hubbard JA, Dodge KA, Cillessen AHN, Coie JD, Schwartz D (2001) The dyadic nature of social information processing in boys’ reactive and proactive aggression. J Pers Soc Psychol, 80:268-280.
37. Hubbard JA, Romano LJ, McAuliffe MD, Morrow MT (2010) Anger and the reactive–proactive aggression distinction in childhood and adolescence. In International Handbook of Anger (Eds M Potegal, G Stemmler, CD Spielberger):231-239. New York, Springer.
38. Humenik AM, Grounds ZK, Mayer HM, Dolan SL (2020) A systematic review of executive cognitive function in intimate partner violent offenders. Aggress Violent Behav, 54:101407.
39. Ishikawa SS, Raine A, Lencz T, Bihrle S, Lacasse L (2001) Autonomic stress reactivity and executive functions in successful and unsuccessful criminal psychopaths from the community. J Abnorm Psychol, 110:423-432.
40. Kempes M, Matthys W, de Vries H, van Engeland H (2005) Reactive and proactive aggression in children: A review of theory, findings and the relevance for child and adolescent psychiatry. Eur Child Adolesc Psychiatry, 14:11-19.
41. Kempes M, Matthys W, Maassen G, van Goozen S, van Engeland H (2006) A parent questionnaire for distinguishing between reactive and proactive aggression in children. Eur Child Adolesc Psychiatry, 15:38-45.
42. King AR, Breen CM, Russell TD, Nerpel BP, Pogalz CR (2018) Self-reported executive functioning competencies and lifetime aggression. Appl Neuropsychol Adult, 25:400-409.
43. Kyranides MN, Mirman JH, Sawrikar V (2024) Verbal, physical and relational aggression: Individual differences in emotion and cognitive regulation strategies. Curr Psychol, 43:17673-17683.
44. Lam BY, Raine A, Fung AL, Gao Y, Lee TM (2020) Caregivers’ grit moderates the relationship between children’s executive function and aggression. Front Psychol, 11:636.
45. Li Q, Gao M, Deng Y, Zhou Z, Wang J (2023) Parental attachment and proactive-reactive aggression in adolescence: The mediating role of self-control and perspective taking. Psychol Res Behav Manag, 16:3437-3446.
46. Li Z, Xu X, Xing X (2023) The intergenerational transmission of executive function: The mediating effect of parental harsh discipline. Child Abuse Negl, 136:106019.
47. Little TD, Henrich CC, Jones SM, Hawley PH (2003) Disentangling the “whys” from the “whats” of aggressive behaviour. Int J Behav Dev, 27:122-133.
48. Liu M, Chen X, Rubin KH, Zheng S, Cui L, Li D et al. (2005) Autonomy-vs connectedness-oriented parenting behaviours in Chinese and Canadian mothers. Int J Behav Dev, 29:489-495.
49. McQuade JD (2017) Peer victimization and changes in physical and relational aggression: The moderating role of executive functioning abilities. Aggress Behav, 43:503-512.
50. McQuade JD, Breaux RP, Miller RH, Mathias L (2016) Executive functioning and engagement in physical and relational aggression among children with ADHD. J Abnorm Child Psychol, Advance online publication.
51. McQuade JD, Breaux RP, Miller R, Mathias L (2017) Executive functioning and engagement in physical and relational aggression among children with ADHD. J Abnorm Child Psychol, 45:899-910.
52. McQuade JD, Murray-Close D, Shoulberg EK, Hoza B (2013) Working memory and social functioning in children. J Exp Child Psychol, 115:422-435.
53. Micai M, Kavussanu M, Ring C (2015) Executive function is associated with antisocial behavior and aggression in athletes. J Sport Exerc Psychol, 37:469-476.
54. Mol B, Van den Bos P, Derks Y, Egger J (2009) Executive functioning and the two factor model of psychopathy: No differential relation? Int J Neurosci, 119:124-140.
55. Morgan AB, Lilienfeld SO (2000) A meta-analytic review of the relation between antisocial behavior and neuropsychological measures of executive function. Clin Psychol Rev, 20:113-156.
56. Moya-Albiol L, Romero-Martínez Á (2020) Neurocriminología. Madrid, Piramide.
57. Mullin BC, Hinshaw SP (2007) Emotion regulation and externalizing disorders in children and adolescents. In Handbook of Emotion Regulation (Ed JJ Gross):523-541. London, Guilford Press.
58. Noback CR, Demarest RJ (1975) The Human Nervous System, 2nd ed. New York, McGraw-Hill.
59. Ogilvie JM, Stewart AL, Chan RC, Shum DH (2011) Neuropsychological measures of executive function and antisocial behavior: A meta-analysis. Criminology, 49:1063-1107.
60. Ollendick TH, Jarrett MA, Wolff JC, Scarpa A (2009) Reactive and proactive aggression: Cross-informant agreement and the clinical utility of different informants. J Psychopathol Behav Assess, 31:51-59.
61. Ostrov JM, Houston RJ (2008) The utility of forms and functions of aggression in emerging adulthood: Association with personality disorder symptomatology. J Youth Adolesc, 37:1147-1158.
62. Ostrov JM, Murray-Close D, Perry KJ, Blakely-McClure SJ, Perhamus GR, Mutignani LM et al. (2023) The development of forms and functions of aggression during early childhood: A temperament-based approach. Dev Psychopathol, 35:941-957.
63. O'Toole SE, Monks CP, Tsermentseli S (2017) Executive function and theory of mind as predictors of aggressive and prosocial behavior and peer acceptance in early childhood. Soc Dev, 26:907-920.
64. Özdoğan AÇ, Haspolat NK, Çelik O, Yalçın RÜ (2021) Ergenlerde reaktif-proaktif saldırganlık ve bilişsel esneklik: Öfkenin aracı rolü. Anadolu Journal of Educational Sciences International, 11:826-851.
65. Pahlavan F, Mouchiroud C, Nemlaghi-Manis E (2012) Does experience of failure decrease executive, regulatory abilities and increase aggression? Affective-cognitive regulation of aggressive behaviors. Glob J Health Sci, 4:60.
66. Paschall MJ, Fishbein DH (2002) Executive cognitive functioning and aggression: A public health perspective. Aggress Violent Behav, 7:215-235.
67. Patwardhan I, Guo Y, Hamburger ER, Sarwar S, Fleming CB, James TD et al. (2023) Childhood executive control and adolescent substance use initiation: The mediating roles of physical and relational aggression and prosocial behavior. Child Neuropsychol, 29:235-254.
68. Pennuto TO (2007) Executive functioning, psychopathy, and moral reasoning among male offenders (Doctoral dissertation). Stockton, Pacific Graduate University.
69. Peterson J, Welch V, Losos M, Tugwell PJ (2011) The Newcastle-Ottawa Scale (NOS) for assessing the quality of nonrandomised studies in meta-analyses. Ottawa, Ottawa Hospital Research Institute.
70. Poland SE, Monks CP, Tsermentseli S (2016) Cool and hot executive function as predictors of aggression in early childhood: Differentiating between the function and form of aggression. Br J Dev Psychol, 34:181-197.
71. Porter CL, Hart CH, Yang C, Robinson CC, Olsen SF, Zeng Q et al. (2005) A comparative study of child temperament and parenting in Beijing, China and the western United States. Int J Behav Dev, 29:541-551.
72. Poulin F, Boivin M (2000) Reactive and proactive aggression: Evidence of a two-factor model. Psychol Assess, 12:115-122.
73. Raine A (2019) A neurodevelopmental perspective on male violence. Infant Ment Health J, 40:84-97.
74. Ramírez JM (2010) The usefulness of distinguishing types of aggression by function. Int Soc Sci J, 61:263-272.
75. Renouf A, Brendgen M, Parent S, Vitaro F, Zelazo PD, Boivin M et al. (2010) Relations between theory of mind and indirect and physical aggression in kindergarten: Evidence of the moderating role of prosocial behaviors. Soc Dev, 19:535-555.
76. Rohlf HL, Holl AK, Kirsch F, Krahé B, Elsner B (2018) Longitudinal links between executive function, anger, and aggression in middle childhood. Front Behav Neurosci, 12:27.
77. Romero-Martínez A, Sarrate-Costa C, Moya-Albiol L (2022) Reactive vs proactive aggression: A differential psychobiological profile? Conclusions derived from a systematic review. Neurosci Biobehav Rev, 136:104626.
78. Rose AJ, Swenson LP, Waller EM (2004) Overt and relational aggression and perceived popularity: Developmental differences in concurrent and prospective relations. Dev Psychol, 40:378-387.
79. Rosenthal R (1991) Meta-Analytic Procedures for Social Research. Newbury Park, Sage.
80. Schippell PL, Vasey MW, Cravens-Brown LM, Bretveld RA (2003) Suppressed attention to rejection, ridicule, and failure cues: A unique correlate of reactive but not proactive aggression in youth. J Clin Child Adolesc Psychol, 32:40-55.
81. Séguin JR, Zelazo PD (2005) Executive function in early physical aggression. In Developmental Origins of Aggression (Eds RE Tremblay, WW Hartup, J Archer):307-329. New York, Guilford Press.
82. Skvarc DR, Harries T, Harris N, Hyder S, Patafio B, Howard D et al. (2023) Cognitive control moderates the maturation of relational aggression in adults. Pers Individ Dif, 212:112267.
83. Smith RL, Rose AJ, Schwartz-Mette RA (2010) Relational and overt aggression in childhood and adolescence: Clarifying mean-level gender differences and associations with peer acceptance. Soc Dev, 19:243-269.
84. Su X, Li W, Hu C, Liu H, Lian R (2024) The longitudinal relationship between executive dysfunction and reactive and proactive aggression in adolescents: Impulsivity as a mediator and sex differences. Front Psychiatry, 15:1484340.
85. Thomson ND, Centifanti LC (2018) Proactive and reactive aggression subgroups in typically developing children: The role of executive functioning, psychophysiology, and psychopathy. Child Psychiatry Hum Dev, 49:197-208.
86. Topham N (2022) Understanding relationships between executive function and aggression in early childhood (Master’s thesis). Canterbury, University of Canterbury.
87. Underwood MK, Galen BR, Paquette JA (2001) Top ten challenges for understanding gender and aggression in children: Why can’t we all just get along? Soc Dev, 10:248-266.
88. Utendale WT, Hubert M, Saint-Pierre AB, Hastings PD (2011) Neurocognitive development and externalizing problems: The role of inhibitory control deficits from 4 to 6 years. Aggress Behav, 37:476-488.
89. Viechtbauer W (2010) Conducting meta-analyses in R with the metafor package. J Stat Softw, 36(3):1-48.
90. Vitaro F, Barker ED, Boivin M, Brendgen M, Tremblay RE (2006) Do early difficult temperament and harsh parenting differentially predict reactive and proactive aggression? J Abnorm Child Psychol, 34:685-695.
91. Vitaro F, Brendgen M, Barker ED (2006) Subtypes of aggressive behaviors: A developmental perspective. Int J Behav Dev, 30:12-19.
92. Volavka J (1999) The neurobiology of violence: An update. J Neuropsychiatry Clin Neurosci, 11:307-314.
93. Waller R, Hyde LW, Baskin-Sommers AR, Olson SL (2017) Interactions between callous-unemotional behaviors and executive function in early childhood predict later aggression and lower peer-liking in late childhood. J Abnorm Child Psychol, 45:597-609.
94. Welz T, Doebler P, Pauly M (2022) Fisher transformation-based confidence intervals of correlations in fixed and random-effects meta-analysis. Br J Math Stat Psychol, 75:1-22.
95. Weyandt LL (2005) Executive function in children, adolescents, and adults with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder: Introduction to the special issue. Dev Neuropsychol, 27:1-10.
96. White BA, Jarrett MA, Ollendick TH (2013) Self-regulation deficits explain the link between reactive aggression and internalizing and externalizing behavior problems in children. J Psychopathol Behav Assess, 35:1-9.
97. Zelazo PD, Carlson SM (2020) The neurodevelopment of executive function skills: Implications for academic achievement gaps. Psychol Neurosci, 13:273.
98. Zelazo PD, Müller U (2002) Executive function in typical and atypical development. In Handbook of Childhood Cognitive Development (Ed U Goswami):445-469. Oxford, Blackwell.
99. Zelazo PD, Qu L, Müller U (2005) Hot and cool aspects of executive function: Relations in early development. In Young Children's Cognitive Development: Interrelationships among Executive Functioning, Working Memory, Verbal Ability, and Theory of Mind (Eds W Schneider, R Schumann-Hengsteler, B Sodian):71-93. Mahwah, NJ, Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.