Besin Rehberleri: Beslenme Eğitiminde Görsel Bir Araç

Yıl 2011, Sayı: 25, 11 - 16, 01.02.2011

Nazan Aktaş

Öz

Sağlığın korunmasıve geliştirmesi, beslenme ile ilişkili hastalıkların önlenmesi amacıyla bilimsel temelli beslenme bilgilerinin topluma iletilmesinde besine dayalıbeslenme rehberleri ve besin rehberi görselleri kullanılmaktadır. Yeterli ve dengeli besin tüketimi ve sağlıklıbesin seçimine ilişkin önerilerin ülkelere özel görsellerle anlatıldığıbesin rehberlerinden müdahale çalışmalarında anahtar eğitim araçlarıolarak yararlanılmaktadır. Dünya Sağlık Örgütü ve Gıda Tarım Örgütü besine dayalıbeslenme rehberlerini ve besin rehberi görsellerinin geliştirilmesine yönelik çalışmalarıdesteklemekte, beslenme politikalarının önemli bir parçasıolarak kabul etmektedir. Besin kaynakları, beslenme alışkanlıkları, kültürel özellikler, besin temini ve beslenme ve sağlık sorunlarındaki farklılıklar ülkelerin kendilerine özgü besin rehberi geliştirmesini gerekli kılmıştır. Besin rehberi görseli olarak Türkiye’de dört yapraklıyonca, Amerika’da besin rehberi piramidi, Japonya’da besin rehberi topacı, Çin’de besin Pagodası, Tayland’da beslenme bayrağı, Macaristan’da besin evi, Fransa’da merdiven, Danimarka’da pusula, Almanya’da üç boyutlu piramit kullanılmaktadır. Belirli aralıklarla güncelleştirilmesi gereken besin rehberleri konusunda toplumda farkındalık oluşturulmasıve yaygınlaştırılmasında ilgili kurum, kuruluşve disiplinlere önemli görevler düşmektedir. Bu derleme makalede, besin rehberlerinin betimlenerek, amaç, özellik, geliştirilme ve yaygınlaştırma boyutunun incelenmesi amaçlanmıştır.

Anahtar Kelimeler

Besin Rehberleri, Beslenme Eğitimi, Beslenme

Food Guides: Visual Aids in Nutrition Education

Öz

This review article is an attempt to examine the objectives, properties, development process and dissemination of food guides. To remain healthy and to prevent diseases, diet and healthy lifestyle are regarded to be the fundamental components. While malnutrition-related health problems resulting from protein-energy malnutrition, inadequate intake of vitamin and minerals are still remain to be the most important nutrition problems in some parts of the world, the spread of non-contagious but chronic diseases such as obesity, type II diabetes and hypertension is increasing rapidly all over the world. The call for duty by World Health Organization and Food Agriculture Organization to governments about Food Based Dietary Guidelines so that societies in general and individuals can be educated about adequate and balanced nutrition and improve their food pattern and make healthy food choices has played a significant role in development of Food Based Dietary Guidelines and food guide. Although families and societies are being taught about food and nutrition since the beginning of humanity, it is considered that formal nutrition education was introduced with the publication of food guides prepared by governments based on the findings of nutrition science. A food guide is the pictorial illustration of the amount and type of food items to be consumed so that community can understand easily. A great many food guides were developed in the 20th century to explain foods and new suggestions for nutrition and support adequate and balanced nutrition. Grouping of food items and their illustration in pyramid is significant in the development process of food guides. In the mid of 1950’s, a new food guide was released by United States Department of Agriculture nutrition specialists, which became widely known as the “Basic Four” recommended a minimum number of foods from each of four food groups: milk, meat, fruits and vegetables, and grain products. United States Department of Agriculture published a Food Guide Pyramid which depicts a hierarchical dietary pattern to help people apply the Guidelines to their own diets in 1992. The pyramid recommends daily food serving from the grain, vegetable, and fruit groups, with fewer serving from the milk and meat groups, and even fewer from foods high in fat and sugar. In the symbolic expression of food guides a variety of visuals such as pictures, graphics, posters and diagrams are used. The main aim in the development of guides is to improve healthy nutrition by providing people guidelines to choose healthy food and to take all food at adequate and balanced amounts for growth and for the prevention of nutrition related health problems. However, food guides also serves to other ends by being practical guide for nutrition education programs, by helping consumers understand the essentials of nutrition and contributing the development of healthy nutrition and meal planning. For food guides to reach these objectives, they are to be based on scientific nutrition knowledge, their qualitative and quantitative messages are to be easily understood, and they are to be country-specific, culturally acceptable, variety of foods, proportioned and to allow for nutritional needs and eating habits and to include recommended daily food types and amount. Furthermore, they are to make optimum nutrition suggestions and be based on the results of nutrition and health research results. For cultural acceptability, the symbols of the food guide are to be chosen by the individuals who represent the community the guide addresses to. Individuals who work in this process are to make their choices among the graphics drawn by national or local graphic artists by using cultural elements and by asking the following questions: “which one of these graphics make you think of your country?” and “In which one of these graphics would you like daily food groups to be presented?”. In the development of food guides, some complex issues such as to what extent and which criteria they are to meet emerge. These criteria include: the extend food guides reflect food availability and eating habits, and serve as a strategic means for nutrition education, and the extent they are understood and accepted by the society and reflect sustainable food consumption. In recent years, the number of food guides has been increasing but the basic aim and rationale behind them is not completely understood by the society as intended by their developers. It is known that there are problems related with the understanding of quantitative the portion of foods and qualitative food groups, food diversity information in food guides. The essential in food guides are recommended to be updated every five years so that latest findings in nutrition science and food and nutrition policies tally with. When food guides all over the world are examined, it is seen that differences in food intake, sources and nutrition situations, habits and requirements of societies make it necessary to develop country-specific food guides. Although the shape, food grouping and the recommendations included in formally accepted food guides of different countries vary, their common target is to disseminate scientific knowledge about food and eating habits to larger masses by converting them into basic concepts. Countries develop or update the food guides suitable for their societies based on the results of the studies they carry out to determine food availability, eating condition and eating standards.Although various graphics such as circles, tables and dishes are used as the food guide symbols, pyramid is a popular means of illustration in food guides since the early 1990. In order to deliver messages to society about healthy nutrition, four-leaf clover is used in Turkey, healthy food dish is used in the UK, threedimensional food pyramid is used in Germany, food guide Pagoda is used in China, rainbow is used in Canada, food flag in Thailand, and Japanese Food Guide Spinning Top is used in Japan. To increase the efficiency of education studies, food guides are to be developed for gender, age groups and special conditions. In many countries, the development and dissemination of food guides are handled within the scope of nutrition policies. In the development of food guides brochures, posters, leaflets, slights, advertisements, course books, food packages, cooking books, toys, specially designed computer games, means of press and mass media are used. Schools, public education centers, public health centers, sport halls, institution which provide catering services, restaurants, dormitories and school cafeterias, inner city transportation vehicles, religion centers are the most important places for the dissemination of food guides. Health professionals, especially dieticians and nutritionists, teachers, lecturers have important roles to play for the delivery of messages to the society. As a result, food guides which provide guidance to society and individuals about healthy nutrition, optimal food choice, meal planning are also means of education in nutrition education activities. Establishment of interdisciplinary cooperation in the development of food guides is crucial for the solution of the difficulties met in the process and for the accomplishment of the objectives. All professionals who work for the development of a healthy nutrition and lifestyle in the society are to make studies to raise awareness about food guides. For a successful dissemination, public and privates institutions, education and food sector are to cooperate

Anahtar Kelimeler

Food Guides, Nutrition Education, Nutrition

Kaynakça

• Albert, J. (2007). “Global Patterns and Country Experiences with the Formulation and Implementation of Food- Based Dietary Guidelines” Ann Nutr Metab, 51(S2):2–7.
• Aksoy, M. (2007).Ansiklopedik Beslenme, Diyet ve Gıda Sözlüğü, Yazarı M. Aksoy, I.basım, Hatipoğlu yayınları, Ankara.
• Anonim, (2007).Türkiye’ye Özgü Beslenme Rehberi. Sağlık Bakanlığı Temel Sağlık Hizmetleri Genel Müdürlüğü. Ankara.
• Anonymous, (2000). Food and Nutrition Guidelines for Namibia. Available at: [Erişim tarihi: 08.01.2011].
• Anonymous, (2003). Dietary Guidelines for Australian Adults and for Children and Adolescents in Australia Available at: Erişim tarihi: [21.08.2010].
• Baysal, A. (2002). Genel Beslenme. Hatiboğlu Yayınları:14. 11.Baskı.
• Contento, R. I. (2011). Nutrition Education Linking Research, Theory and Practice Massachusetts: Jones and Bartlett Publishers.
• EUFIC, (2009).Food-based dietary guidelines in Europe.Available at:, [Erişim tarihi: 09.10.2010].
• FAO, (2007). A Manual from the English-speaking Caribbean Developing Food-based Dietary Guidelines [Erişim tarihi: 02.01.2011].
• Hunt P, Strong M. and Poulter, J. (2004). “Evaluating a new food selection guide”. British Nutrition Foundation Nutrition Bulletin, 29: 19–25
• Keyou ,G., Jianbin, J., & Hong, L., (2007). “Food-Based Dietary Guidelines in China”. Ann Nutr Metab,51(S2):26–31.
• Krishnaswamy, K (2008). “Developing and implementing dietary guidelines in India”. Asia Pac J Clin Nutr, 17 ( S1): 66-69.
• Murphy, P S. (2008).“Using DRIs as the basis for dietary guidelin s”.Asia Pac J Clin Nutr, 17( S1): 42-54
• Murphy P S and Barr S (2007). “Food Guides Reflect Similarities and Differences in Dietary Guidance in Three Countries (Japan, Canada, and the United States)”. Nutrition Reviews, 65 ( 4): 141–148.
• Nestle, M. (1998). “In defense of the USDA food guide pyramid”. Nutr Today, 33:189–97. Available at: , [Erişim tarihi:05.10.2010].
• Painter J, Rah JH, Lee Y. (2002). “Comparison of international food guide pictorial representations.” J Am Diet Assoc, (102): 483–489.
• Rodrigues SS, Franchini B, Graca P, Almeida MD. (2006). “A new food guide for the Portuguese population: development and technical considerations”. J. Nutr. Educ. Behav, 38:189–195.
• Safavi, S.M., Omidvar, N., Djazayery, A., Minaie., M., Hooshiarrad., A., & Sheikoleslam., R. (2007). “Development of Food-Based Dietary Guidelines for Iran: A Preliminary Report” Ann Nutr Metab, 51(S2) suppl 2:32–35
• Sirichakwal P P and Sranacharoenpong K. (2008). “Practical experience in development and promotion of food- based dietary guidelines in Thailand”. Asia Pac J Clin Nutr, 17( S1): 63–65.
• Stehle, P. (2007). “Dissemination of Nutritional Knowledge in Germany – Nutrition Circle, 3D Food Pyramid and 10 Nutrition Guidelines”. Ann Nutr Metab, 51(S2):21–25.
• Tzeng, M.S. (2008). “From dietary guidelines to daily food guide: the Taiwanese experiences”. Asia Pac J Clin Nutr, 17( S1):59–62.
• Welsh, S. (1994). “Atwater to the Present: Evolution of Nutrition Education”. J. Nutr. 124:1799S-1807S. Available at :,[Erişim tarihi:02.01.2011].
• Welsh, S., Davis C., Shaw, A. (1993).USDA’s Food Guide Background and Development. Availableat: , [Erişim tarihi:18.01.2011].
• WHO/FAO, (1996). Preparation and use of Food-Based Dietary Guidelines. Report of a Joint FAO/WHO Consultation. WHO Technical Report series 880. Geneva. Erişim linki < www.fao.org/docrep/X0243E/x0243e00.htm >[Erişim tarihi:26.08.2010].
• WHO (2003). Diet, Nutrition and the Prevention of Chronic Diseases. Report of a Joint WHO/FAO Expert Consultation. Tech Rep Ser No 916. Geneva. Erişim linki: [ Erişim tarihi:10.11.2010].
• Willett W C and McCullough M L. (2008). “Dietary pattern analysis for the evaluation of dietary guidelines”. Asia Pac J Clin Nutr, 17( S1): 75-78.
• Yoshiike, N., Hayashi, F., Takemi, Y., Mizoguchi, K., & Seino F. (2007). “A new food guide in Japan: The Japanese Food Guide Spinning Top”. Nutr Rev, (65):149–154.