Worst of Friends, Best of Rivals: Agency vs Structure in Turkey-Russia Relations

Yıl 2023, Cilt: 20 Sayı: 79 - Guest Editor: Dimitar BECHEV | Russia and Turkey in a Changing Global Order, 5 - 32, 17.10.2023

Dimitar Bechev

https://doi.org/10.33458/uidergisi.1357630

Öz

The article studies the dynamics behind the unprecedented rapprochement between Turkey and Russia since the 2000s. It explains the growing degree of co-operation between Ankara and Moscow through the role of political leadership as well as to Turkey’s adjustment to the changing balance of power at the regional and global level. At the same time, the article highlights the competitive aspects of the relationship. It does so with reference to a series of case studies: the war in Syria, Turkey’s intervention in Libya since 2019, the purchase of S-400 surface to air missiles, energy security in the Black Sea the Southern Caucasus, and Turkey’s response to Russia’s full scale invasion of Ukraine in February 2022.

Anahtar Kelimeler

theory, history, security, regional conflict, energy, foreign policy

Kaynakça

• Aktürk, Şener (2006). “Turkish-Russian Relations After the End of the Cold War (1992-2002)”, Turkish Studies, Vol. 7, No 3, p. 337-364.
• Aktürk, Şener (2015). “The Fourth Style of Politics: Eurasianism as a pro-Russian Rethinking of Turkey’s Geopolitical Identity”, Turkish Studies, Vol. 16, No 1, p. 54-79.
• Aktürk, Şener (2016). “Relations Between Russia and Turkey Before, During, and After the Failed Coup of 2016”, Insight Turkey, Vol. 21, No 4, p. 97-113.
• Altıntaşbaṣ, Aslı (2016). “With Friends Like These: Turkey, Russia and the End of an Unlikely Alliance”, European Council on Foreign Relations, https://ecfr.eu/publication/with_friends_like_ these_turkey_russia_and_the_end_of_an_unlikely_7048/ (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• Arango, Tim and Ceylan Yeginsu (2016). “Turks Can Agree on One Thing: US is Behind Failed Coup”, New York Times, 3 August.
• Aydın-Düzgit, Senem, Evren Balta and Andrew O’Donohue (2020). “Turkey, Russia, and the West: Reassessing Persistent Volatility, Asymmetric Interdependence, and the Syria Conflict”, Istanbul Policy Centre.
• Aydın, Mustafa (2014). “Turkish Policy towards the Wider Black Sea and the EU Connection”, Journal of Balkan and Near East Studies, Vol. 16, No 3, p. 383-397.
• Aydıntaşbaş, Aslı (2020). “A New Gaza: Turkey’s Border Policy in Northern Syria”, Policy Brief, European Council on Foreign Relations, https://www.ecfr.eu/publications/summary/a_new_gaza_ turkeys_border_policy_in_northern_syria (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• Aydıntaşbaş, Aslı (2022). “Turkey and Armenia just Gave the World a Welcome Bit of Good News”, The Washington Post, 7 October, https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/10/07/turkeyarmenia-erdogan-pashinyan-meeting/ (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• Baev, Pavel (2019). “Turkey and Russia”, Alparslan Özerdem and Matthew Whiting (eds.), The Routledge Handbook of Turkish Politics. London, Routledge.
• Balta, Evren and Mitat Çelikpala (2021). “Turkey and Russia: Historical Patterns and Contemporary Trends in Bilateral Relations”, Güneş Murat Tezcür (ed.), The Oxford handbook of Turkish Politics. Oxford, Oxford University Press.
• Bazoğlu Sezer, Duygu (2000). “Turkish‐Russian Relations: the Challenges of Reconciling Geopolitical Competition with Economic Partnership”, Turkish Studies, Vol. 1, No 1, p. 59-82.
• Bechev, Dimitar (2017). Rival Power: Russia in Southeast Europe, New Haven, Yale University Press.
• Bechev, Dimitar (2023). “Sailing Through the Storm: Türkiye’s Black Sea Strategy Amidst the RussianUkranian War”, European Union Institute for Security Studies, https://www.iss.europa.eu/content/sailing-through-storm (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• Bechev, Dimitar (ed.) (2011). What does Turkey Think. European Council on Foreign Relations, https:// www.ecfr.eu/archive/page/-/ECFR35_TURKEY_AW.pdf (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• Bechev, Dimitar and Suat Kınıklıoğlu (2020). “Turkey and Russia: no Birds of the Same Feather”, Stiftung Wissenschaft und Politik, SWP Comment 24/2020, 24 May.
• “Boosting NATO’s Presence in the East and the Southeast”, NATO.int. Butler, Ed (2020). “Syrian Mercenaries Used as Cannon Fodder in Nagorno-Karabakh”, BBC, 10 December, https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/stories-55238803 (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• “Cumhurbaşkanlığı Sözcüsü İbrahim Kalın NTV‘de” (2020).NTV, 21 November, https://www.ntv.com.tr/ video/turkiye/cumhurbaskanligi-sozcusu-ibrahim-kalin-ntvde,jN7pBkGBBE6PPVRo37g05Q (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• Çagaptay, Soner (2019). Erdogan’s Empire: Turkey and the Politics of the Middle East. London, I.B. Tauris.
• Çolakoğlu, Selçuk (2019). “The Rise of Eurasniansim in Turkish Foreign Policy”, Middle East Institute, https://www.mei.edu/publications/rise-eurasianism-turkish-foreign-policy-can-turkey-changeits-pro-western-orientation (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• Coşkun, Alper (2021). “Turkey’s F-16 Gambit Is a Chance to Revive Turkish-U.S. Defense Cooperation”, Carnegie Endowment, 27 October.
• Dalay, Galip (2022). “Ukraine’s Wider Impact on Turkey’s International Future”, Chatham House.
• Dalay, Galip (2019). “After the S-400 Purchase: Where are Turkish-Russian Relations Heading?”, Stiftung Wissenschaft und Politik, 3 September. “Erdogan Says Turkey Won’t Be Silent Over Mercenaries in Libya” (2019). Reuters, 20 December, https://www.reuters.com/article/us-libya-turkey-russia-idUSKBN1YO1GD (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• Еsen, Berk and Şebnem Gümüşçü (2016). “Rising Competitive Authoritarianism in Turkey”, Third World Quarterly, Vol. 37, No 9, p. 1581-160.
• Faulconbridge, Guy and Michelle Nichols (2022). “UN Trying to Get Russian Ammonia to World through Ukraine”, Reuters, 14 September, https://www.reuters.com/markets/commodities/unproposed-ammonia-deal-ukraine-would-stabilise-grain-deal-diplomat-2022-09-13/ (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• FT Reporters (2022). “Surge in Turkish Exports to Russia Raises Western Fears of Closer Ties”, The Financial Times, 16 August, https://www.ft.com/content/caee1ae3-41c5-4c85-8d66-a8d3eea3112d (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• Gatopoulos, Alex (2020). “What Could Turkey’s Latest S-400 Missile Tests Mean?”, Al Jazeera, 12 October, https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2020/10/12/what-could-turkeys-latest-s-400-missiletests-mean (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• Gavin, Gabriel (2023). “Erdoğan Plays Energy Card in Turkish Election – with Putin’s Help”, Politico, 4 May, https://www.politico.eu/article/turkey-election-energy-recep-tayyip-erdogan-nucleargas-russia/ (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• Grigoriadis, Ioannis (2010). “Friends no More? The Rise of anti-American Nationalism in Turkey”, Middle East Journal, Vol. 64, No 1, p. 51-66.
• Hacaoğlu, Selcan (2020). “Turkey Seeks U.S. Patriot Missiles to Deter Russia in Syria”, Bloomberg, 20 February, https://www.bloomberg.com/ news/articles/2020-02-20/turkey-asks-u-s-for-patriotmissiles-to-deter-russia-in-idlib. (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• Hale, William (2000). Turkish Foreign Policy, 1774-2000. London, Frank Cass.
• Hale, William (2023). “The Turkey-Russia Relationship in Historical Perspective: Patterns, Change and Contrast”, Ulusarası İlişkiler, Vol. 20, No 78, p. 43-58.
• Harchaoui, Jalel (2021). “The Pendulum: How Russia Sways Its Way to More Influence in Libya”, War on the Rocks, 7 January, https://warontherocks.com/2021/01/the-pendulum-how-russia-swaysits-way-to-more-influence-in-libya/ (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• “High-ranking Turkish Delegation to Visit Russia on December 29” (2018). TASS, 26 December.
• Hill, Fiona and Ömer Taşpınar (2006). “Turkey and Russia: Axis of the Excluded?”, Survival, Vol. 48, No 1, p. 81-92.
• “Where Does the Syrian Regime Get Foreign Currency From?” (2020). Enab Baladi, 8 July, https:// english.enabbaladi.net/archives/2020/07/where-does-the-syrian-regime-get-foreign-currencyfrom/ (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• İṣçi, Onur (2019). Turkey and the Soviet Union During World War II: Diplomacy, Discord and International Relations. London, Bloombsbury.
• Jones, Sam and Kathrin Hille (2016). “Russia’s Military Ambitions Make Waves in the Black Sea”, Financial Times, 13 May.
• Kadıoğlu, Ayşe, Kerem Öktem and Mehmet Karlı (eds.) (2012). Another Empire?: A Decade of Turkey’s Foreign Policy under the Justice and Development Party. Istanbul, Bilgi University Press.
• Karako, Tom (2019). “Coup-proofing? Making Sense of Turkey’s S-400 Decision”, CSIS, 15 July, https://www.csis.org/analysis/coup-proofing-making-sense-turkeys-s-400-decision (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• Kasapoğlu, Can (2017). “Turkey’s S-400 Dilemma”, EDAM, 31 July, https://edam.org.tr/en/turkeys-s- 400-dilemma/ (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• Katz, Brian and Joseph Bermudez Jr. (2020). “Moscow’s Next Front: Russia’s Expanding Footprint in Libya”, Center for Strategic and International Studies, 17 June.
• Katz, Mark (2006). “Primakov Redux? Putin’s Pursuit of ‘Multipolarism’ in Asia”, Demokratizatsiya, Vol. 14, No 1, p. 144-152.
• Keohane, Robert (1984). After Hegemony: Cooperation and Discord in the World Political Economy. Princeton, Princeton University Press.
• Kirişci, Kemal (2012). “Turkey’s Engagement with Its Neighborhood: a ‘Synthetic and Multidimensional Look at Turkey’s Foreign Policy Transformation”, Turkish Studies, Vol. 13, No 3, p. 319- 341.
• Kınıklıoğlu, Suat (2018). “Turkey’s Russia Affair”, Institute for Security and Development Policy, 23 September, https://isdp.eu/publication/turkeys-russia-affair/ (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• Kınıklıoğlu, Suat and Valeriy Morkva, (2007). “An Anatomy of Russian-Turkish Relations”, Journal of Southeast European and Black Sea Studies, Vol. 7, No 1, p. 533-553.
• Kolobov, Oleg, Fatih Özbay and Aleksandr Kornilov (2004). Sovremennye rossiysko-tureckie otnosheniya: problem sotrudnichestva i perspektivy razvitiya. Nizhni Novgorod, Nizhni Novgorod University.
• Koru, Selim (2018). “The Resiliency of Turkey-Russia Relations”, Foreign Policy Research Institute.
• Köstem, Seçkin (2020). “Russian-Turkish Cooperation in Syria: Geopolitical Alignment with Limits”, Cambridge Review of International Affairs, Vol. 34, No 6, p. 795-817.
• Kubicek, Paul (2021). “Strictly Pragmatism?: Prospects for Russian-Turkish partnership”, Journal of Balkan and Near Eastern Studies, Vol. 23, No 2, p. 233-250.
• Levitsky, Stephen and Lucan Way (2010). Competitive Authoritarianism: Hybrid Regimes after the Cold War. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
• “Libyan Factions Sign ‘Permanent’ Ceasefire, Erdoğan Casts Doubt” (2020). The Arab Weekly, 23 October, https://thearabweekly.com/libyan-factions-sign-permanent-ceasefire-Erdoğan-castsdoubt (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• Lister, Charles (2019). “Assad Hasn’t Won Anything”, Foreign Policy, 11 July.
• Makovsky, Alan (2015). “Turkey’s Growing Energy Ties to Russia”, Center for American Progress, 6 May, https://www.americanprogress.org/issues/security/reports/2015/05/06/112511/turkeysgrowing-energy-ties-with-moscow/ (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• “Mehmet Şimşek‘ten Rusya İtirafı: ‚9 milyar dolar‘” (2015). Cumhuriyet, 7 December.
• McKernan, Bethan and Hussein Akoush (2020). “2000 Syrian Fighters Deployed to Libya to Support Government”, Guardian, 15 January, https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/jan/15/exclusive-2000-syrian-troops-deployed-to-libya-to-support-regime (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• Nougarède, Nathalie (2014). “The Two Angry Men on Europe’s Borders: Loud, Proud and Impossible to Ignore”, The Guardian, 29 October, https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/ oct/29/europe-two-angry-men-west-vladimir-putin-recep-tayyib-erdogan-russia-turkey (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• “Obama Rejects Attempted Military Coup in Turkey” (2016). Politico, 15 July, https://www.politico. com/story/2016/07/barack-obama-turkey-coup-225642 (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• Ozberk, Tayfun (2022). “Turkish Shipyard Launches Ukraine’s 1st MILGEM Corvette”, Naval News, 3 October, https://www.navalnews.com/naval-news/2022/10/turkish-shipyard-launches-hetmanivan-mazepa/ (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• Öniş, Ziya and Şuhnaz Yılmaz (2016). “Turkey and Russia in a Shifting Global Order: Cooperation, Conflict and Asymmetric Interdependence in a Turbulent Region”, Third World Quarterly, Vol. 37, No 1, p. 71-95.
• Özcan, Gencer, Evren Balta and Burç Beşgül (eds.) (2017). Kuşku ile Komşuluk: Türkiye ve Rusya İlişkilerinde Değişen Dinamikler. İstanbul, İletişim.
• Özdil, Eser (2020). “How Turkey Benefits from the Global LNG Glut”, Atlantic Council, 7 May, https:// www.atlanticcouncil.org/blogs/turkeysource/how-turkey-benefits-from-global-lng-glut/ (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• Özel, Soli (2020). “Whiter Turkey-Russia Relations?”, Robert Bosch Academy, https://www.robertboschacademy.de/de/perspectives/whither-turkey-russia-relations (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• Pope, Hugh and Nigar Göksel (2020). “Turkey Does Its Own Thing”, Chatham House, 1 December.
• “President Erdoğan Attends Moscow Central Mosque Opening Ceremony” (2015). Turkish Presidency, 23 September, https://www.tccb.gov.tr/en/news/542/35424/cumhurbaskani-erdogan-moskovamerkez-camisinin-acilis-torenine-katildi (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• “Putin Calls Erdogan to Express Condolences for the Victims of the Coup Attempt” (2016). Daily Sabah, 17 July, https://www.dailysabah.com/diplomacy/2016/07/17/putin-calls-erdogan-expresscondolences-for-the-victims-of-coup-attempt (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• Reynolds, Michael (2019). “Turkey and Russia: a Remarkable Rapprochement”, War on the Rocks, 24 October, https://warontherocks.com/2019/10/turkey-and-russia-a-remarkable-rapprochement/ (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• “Russia and Turkey in the Black Sea and the South Caucasus” (2018). International Crisis Group, Europe and Central Asia Report, No 250, 28 June, https://www.crisisgroup.org/europe-central-asia/ western-europemediterranean/turkey/250-russia-and-turkey-black-sea-and-south-caucasus (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• “Russian Propaganda Outlets Prosper in Turkey” (2019). Economist, 28 February.
• Sezer, Can (2022). “Turkey’s State Banks Suspend Use of Russian Mir Payment System – Finance Minister”, Reuters, 29 September, https://www.reuters.com/business/finance/turkeys-ziraatbank-suspends-use-russian-mir-payment-system-ceo-2022-09-29/ (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• Shaffer, Brenda (2020). “Turkey’s Westward Energy Shift”, Middle East Institute, 15 January.
• Soylu, Ragıp (2022). “Turkey Supplied Laser-guided Missiles to Ukraine”, Middle East Eye, 23 November, https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/turkey-supplied-laser-guided-missiles-ukraine (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• Soylu, Ragıp (2020). “Turkish F-16s Kept in Azerbaijan ‘as Deterrent against Armenian Attacks’”, Middle East Eye, 8 October, https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/turkey-armenia-azerbaijan-f16- deterrent-against-attacks. (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• Starodubtsev, Ivan (2017). Rossiya-Turtsiya: 500 let besspokoynogo sosedstva. Moscow, Eksmo.
• Stein, Aaron (2019). “The Russian Missile that Could End the U.S.-Turkish Alliance”, War on the Rocks, 12 March, https://warontherocks.com/2019/03/the-russian-missile-that-could-end-the-us-turkish-alliance/ (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• Stein, Aaron (2019). “Why Russia Turned Its Back on the West and Embraced Russia?”, Foreign Affairs, 6 July.
• Stein, Aaron and Robert Hamilton (2020). “How America’s Experience with Pakistan Can Help It Deal with Turkey”, War on the Rocks, 25 August, https://warontherocks.com/2020/08/how-americasexperience-with-pakistan-can-help-it-deal-with-turkey/ (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• Tanrısever, Oktay (2004). “Turkey and Russia in Eurasia”, Dimitris Keridis and Lenore Martin (eds.), The Future of Turkish Foreign Policy. Cambridge, MIT Press, p. 127-155.
• Taussig, Torrey (2017). “The Serpentine Trajectory of Turkish-Russian Relations”, Brookings Institution, 4 October, https://www.brookings.edu/blog/order-from-chaos/2017/10/04/the-serpentinetrajectory-of-turkish-russian-relations/ (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• Tol, Gönül (2017). “Why is Turkey Silent on Russia’s with the Syrian Kurds?”, War on the Rocks, 19 December, https://warontherocks.com/2017/12/why-is-turkey-silent-on-russias-cooperationwith-the-syrian-kurds/ (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• Torbakov, Igor (2008). “The Georgia Crisis and Russia-Turkey Relations”, Jamestown Foundation.
• Trenin, Dmitri (2013). “The Astonishing Likeness of Turkey and Russia”, Carnegie Endowment, 14 June.
• Trenin, Dmitri (2011). “Post-Imperium: A Eurasian Story”, Carnegie Endowment.
• Trenin, Dmitri (2018). What is Russia up to in the Middle East. Cambridge, Polity.
• “Turkey Upgrades Russia to ‘Strategic Partner’” (2018). Ahval, 24 August, https://ahvalnews.com/russia-turkey/turkey-upgrades-russia-strategic-partner (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• “Turkey Wades into Libya’s Troubled Waters” (2020). International Crisis Group, Report 257, 30 April, https://www.crisisgroup.org/europe-central-asia/western-europemediterranean/turkey/257-turkey-wades-libyas-troubled-waters (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• “Turkey’s New LNG Storage, Regasification Unit to Dock in İzmir Today” (2019). Daily Sabah, 5 July, https://www.dailysabah.com/energy/2019/07/05/turkeys-new-lng-storage-regasification-unitto-dock-in-izmir-today (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• “Turkey’s Syrian Refugees: Defusing Metropolitan Tensions” (2018). International Crisis Group, Report 248, 29 January, https://www.crisisgroup.org/europe-central-asia/western-europemediterranean/turkey/248-turkeys-syrian-refugees-defusing-metropolitan-tensions (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• “Turkish Intelligence Chief Holds Meeting with Syrian Counterpart in Moscow” (2020). Daily Sabah, 14 January, https://www.dailysabah.com/politics/2020/01/14/turkish-intelligence-chief-holdsmeeting-with-syrian-counterpart-in-moscow (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• “Turkish, Ukrainian Cooperation Deepens: Erdoğan” (2020). Hürrıyet Daily News, 17 October, https:// www.hurriyetdailynews.com/turkish-ukrainian-cooperation-deepens-erdogan-159215 (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• Ülgen, Sinan (2020). “A Weak Economy Won’t Stop Turkey’s Activist Foreign Policy”, Foreign Policy, 6 October.
• Waltz, Kenneth (1979). Theory of International Politics. Reading, Addison-Wesley.
• Wendt, Alexander (1999). Social Theory of International Politics. Cambridge University Press.
• Yuruk, Betul (2022). “UN Says 10 Million Tons of Grain Shipped in 3 Months as It Urges Renewal of Ukraine Deal”, Anadolu Agency, 3 November, https://www.aa.com.tr/en/world/un-says- 10-million-tons-of-grain-shipped-in-3-months-as-it-urges-renewal-of-ukraine-deal/2728965 (Accessed 24 August 2023).
• Zarakol, Ayşe (2011). After Defeat: How the East Learned to Live with the West. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.