Have Middle Eastern Leaders Learned from the Arab Uprisings? An Arabic Operational Code Approach

Yıl 2025, Cilt: 22 Sayı: 87, 123 - 145, 18.09.2025

Sercan Canbolat

https://doi.org/10.33458/uidergisi.1680774

Cited By: 2

Öz

How do individual leaders react to major political crises shaking their decision-making authority and challenging their political survival? What do political leaders learn from formative events transpiring on their watch? Riddled with protracted and multidimensional conflicts, the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) is a geographical unit where political learning, or the lack thereof, has been more crucial than ever. This study utilizes an actor-specific approach, i.e., operational code analysis, to examine the profiles and learning patterns of three Arab national leaders who have experienced different forms and magnitudes of political crisis in the post-2011 Arab Uprisings: 1) King Abdullah II bin al-Hussein of Jordan; 2) President Bashar al-Assad of Syria; and 3) Emir Sabah Al-Ahmad Al-Sabah of Kuwait. The case selection comports, by and large, with most different systems design (MDSD) where an individual leader’s operational code type functions as the independent variable while learning (or unlearning) is the dependent variable. This study’s temporal domain is three-pronged as I compartmentalize leaders’ political beliefs as follows: 1) each leader’s general operational code profile (aggregated) 2) before the Arab Uprisings (starting with the year each studied Arab leader came to power); 3) after the Arab Uprisings (2011-2018). I employ an original Arabic coding scheme for leadership analysis to study a group of understudied MENA leaders in their native language. This study lends to state-of-the-art leadership studies within foreign policy analysis and the broader International Relations discipline. It also carries policy relevance concerning regional and world powers’ foreign policy and military strategies toward the MENA region.

Anahtar Kelimeler

foreign policy , political beliefs , cooperation , conflict , elite decision-making

Kaynakça

• Axelrod, Robert. 1976. Structure of Decision. New Jersey, Princeton University Press.
• Bonham, G. Matthew., Daniel Heradstveit, Ove Narvesen, and Michael J. Shapiro. 1978. A Cognitive Model of Decision-making: Application to Norwegian Oil Policy. Cooperation and Conflict 13, 2: 93-108.
• Boulding, Kenneth E. 1956. The Image. Ann Arbor, University of Michigan Press.
• Brams, Steven J. 1994. Theory of Moves. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
• Brummer, Klaus and Valerie M. Hudson. 2015. Foreign Policy Analysis Beyond North America. Boulder, Co., Lynne Rienner.
• Brummer, Klaus, Michael D. Young, Özgür Özdamar, Sercan Canbolat, Consuelo Thiers, Christian Rabini, Katharina Dimmroth, Mischa Hansel, and Ameneh Mehvar. 2020. Coding in tongues: Developing Non-English coding schemes for leadership profiling. International Studies Review 22, 4: 1039-1067.
• Byman, Daniel L., and Kenneth M. Pollack. 2001. Let Us Now Praise Great Men: Bringing the Statesman Back in. International Security 25, 4: 107-146.
• Canbolat, Sercan. 2020a. Profiling Leaders in Arabic. In Forum Coding in Tongues: Developing non- English Coding Schemes for Leadership Profiling. International Studies Review 22, 4: 1051-1055.
• Canbolat, Sercan. 2020b. Understanding Political Islamists’ Foreign Policy Rhetoric in Their Native Language: A Turkish Operational Code Analysis Approach. APSA MENA Politics Newsletter 3: 13-16.
• Canbolat, Sercan. 2021. Deciphering Deadly Minds in Their Native Language: The Operational Codes and Formation Patterns of Militant Organizations in the Middle East and North Africa. In Operational Code Analysis and Foreign Policy Roles, ed. Mark Schafer, Stephen G. Walker. New York, Routledge: 69-92.
• Canbolat, Sercan and Stephen B. Dyson. 2023. Dominating the Superpower: A Bounded Rationality Approach to Nuclear Proliferation and Inhibition in the U.S./North Korea Dyad. Uluslararası İlişkiler 20, 80: 49-71.
• Cottam, Martha L. 1985. The Impact of Psychological Images on International Bargaining: The Case of Mexican Natural Gas. Political Psychology 6, 3: 413-439.
• Cottam, Martha L. 1992. The Carter Administration’s Policy toward Nicaragua: Images, Goals, and Tactics. Political Science Quarterly 107,1: 123-146.
• Crichlow, Scott. 1998. Idealism or Pragmatism? An Operational Code Analysis of Yitzhak Rabin and Shimon Peres. Political Psychology 19, 4: 683–706.
• Dyson, Stephen B. 2014. Leaders in Conflict: Bush and Rumsfeld in Iraq. London, Manchester University Press.
• Duelfer, Charles A., and Stephen B. Dyson. 2011. Chronic Misperception and International Conflict: The US-Iraq Experience. International Security 36, 1: 73–100.
• George, Alexander L. 1969. The Operational Code. International Studies Quarterly 13, 2: 190-222.
• George, Alexander L. 1979. The Causal Nexus Between Cognitive Beliefs and Decision-Making Behavior. In Psychological Models in International Politics, ed. Lawrence S. Falkowski. Boulder, Westview Press: 95-124.
• Haas, Ernst B. 1991. Collective Learning: Some Theoretical Speculations. In Learning in U.S. and Soviet Foreign Policy, ed. George W. Breslauer and Philip E. Tetlock. Boulder, Westview Press: 62-99.
• Heper, Metin, and Sabri Sayari. 2002. Political Leaders and Democracy in Turkey. Lanham, MD: Lexington Books.
• Hermann, Charles F. 1990. Changing Course: When Governments Choose to Redirect Foreign Policy. International Studies Quarterly 34, 1: 3–21.
• Hermann, Margaret G. 1980. Explaining Foreign Policy Behavior Using the Personal Characteristics of Political Leaders. International Studies Quarterly 24, 1: 7-46.
• Hermann, Margaret G. 2005. Assessing Leadership Style: Trait Analysis. In the Psychological Assessment of Political Leaders, ed. Jerrold Post. Ann Arbor, University of Michigan Press: 178-212.
• Hinnebusch, Raymond. 2015. Foreign Policy Analysis and the Arab World. In Foreign Policy Analysis Beyond North America, ed. Klaus Brummer and Valerie M. Hudson. Boulder, Rienner: 77-100.
• Holsti, Ole R. 1977. The ‘Operational Code’ as an Approach to the Analysis of Belief Systems. Final Report to the National Science Foundation, Grant No. SOC 75-14368. Durham, Duke University Press.
• Hudson, Valerie M. 2005. Foreign Policy Analysis: Actor-Specific Theory and the Ground of International Relations. Foreign Policy Analysis 1, 1: 1–30.
• Jervis, Robert. 1976. Perception and Misperception in International Politics. Princeton, Princeton University Press.
• Larson, Deborah W. 1991. Learning in U.S.-Soviet Relations: The Nixon-Kissinger Structure of Peace. In Learning in U.S. and Soviet Foreign Policy, ed. George W. Breslauer and Philip E. Tetlock. Boulder, Westview Press: 350-399.
• Kaarbo, Juliet and Cameron Thies. 2024. The Oxford Handbook of Foreign Policy Analysis. New York, Oxford University Press.
• Kesgin, Barış. 2019. Uncharacteristic Foreign Policy Behavior: Sharon’s Decision to Withdraw from Gaza. International Area Studies Review 22, 1: 76-92.
• Kesgin, Barış. 2023. The Operational Codes of Pacific Island Countries’ Leaders: Beliefs about the World amidst Climate Change. Foreign Policy Analysis 19, 4: p.orad019.
• Leites, Nathan C. 1951. The Operational Code of the Politburo. New York, McGraw-Hill.
• Leites, Nathan C. 1953. A Study of Bolshevism. New York, Free Press.
• Levy, Jack S. 1994. Learning and Foreign Policy: Sweeping a Conceptual Minefield. International Organization 48, 2: 279–312.
• Malici, Akan. 2006. Reagan and Gorbachev: Altercasting at the End of the Cold War. In Beliefs and Leadership in World Politics, ed. Mark Schafer and Stephen G. Walker. New York, Palgrave Macmillan: 127-149.
• Malici, Akan. 2008. When Leaders Learn and When They Don’t. Albany, Suny Press.
• Malici, Akan and Johnna Malici. 2005. When Will They Ever Learn? An Examination of Fidel Castro and Kim Jong-Il’s Operational Code Beliefs. Psicologia Politico 31: 7–22.
• Malici, Akan and Allison L. Buckner. 2008. Empathizing with Rogue Leaders: Mahmoud Ahmadinejad and Bashar al-Assad. Journal of Peace Research 45, 6: 783-800.
• Malici, Akan and Stephen G. Walker. 2017. Role Theory and Role Conflict in U.S.-Iran Relations: Enemies of Our Own Making. New York, Routledge.
• Nye, Joseph S. 1987. Nuclear Learning and U.S.-Soviet Security Regimes. International Organization 41, 3: 371–402.
• Özdamar, Özgür and Sercan Canbolat. 2018. Understanding New MENA Leadership: An Operational Code Approach. Political Research Quarterly 71, 1: 19-31.
• Özdamar, Özgür and Sercan Canbolat. 2023. Leaders in the Middle East and North Africa: How Ideology Shapes Foreign Policy. New York, Cambridge University Press.
• Özdamar, Özgür, Sercan Canbolat, and Michael D. Young. 2020. Profiling Leaders in Turkish. In Forum Coding in Tongues: Developing non-English Coding Schemes for Leadership Profiling. International Studies Review 22, 4: 1045–1049.
• Özdamar, Özgür, B. Toygar Halistoprak, and Michael D. Young. 2023. Do Campaign Speeches Predict Foreign Policy? An Operational Code and Leadership Trait Analysis of Donald Trump’s MENA Policies. Uluslararası İlişkiler 20, 80: 73-91.
• Pratkanis, Anthony R. and Melissa D. Gliner. 2004. And When Shall a Little Child Lead Them? Evidence for an Altercasting Theory of Source Credibility. Current Psychology 23: 279-304.
• Renshon, Jonathan. 2008. Stability and Change in Belief Systems: The Operational Code of George W. Bush. Journal of Conflict Resolution 52, 6: 820–849.
• Schafer, Mark and Stephen G. Walker. 2006. Beliefs and Leadership in World Politics: Methods and Applications of Operational Code Analysis. New York, Palgrave-Macmillan.
• Snyder, Glenn H. and Paul Diesing. 1977. Conflict Among Nations. Princeton, Princeton University Press.
• Stein, Janice G. 1994. Political Learning by Doing: Gorbachev as Uncommitted Thinker and Motivated Learner. International Organization 48, 2: 153–183.
• Stein, Janice G. 2002. Psychological Explanations of International Conflict. In Handbook of International Relations, ed. Walter Carlsnaes, Thomas Risse, and Beth A. Simmons. London, Sage: 293-308.
• Suedfeld, Peter and Dennis A. Rank. 1976. Revolutionary Leaders: Long-term Success as A Function of Changes in Conceptual Complexity. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 34, 2: 169–178.
• Suedfeld, Peter and Philip E. Tetlock. 1977. Integrative Complexity of Communication in International Crisis. Journal of Conflict Resolution 21, 1: 168–184.
• Tetlock, Philip E. 1991. In Search of an Elusive Concept. in Learning in U.S. and Soviet Foreign Policy, ed. George Breslauer and Philip E. Tetlock. Boulder, Westview: 20-61.
• Thies, Cameron G. and Marijke Breuning. 2012. Integrating Foreign Policy Analysis and International Relations through Role Theory. Foreign Policy Analysis 8, 1: 1-4.
• Vertzberger, Yaacov Y. I. 1990. The World in Their Minds: Information Processing, Cognition, and Perception in Foreign Policy Decision-making. Stanford, Stanford University Press.
• Walker, Stephen G. 1990. The Evolution of Operational Code Analysis. Political Psychology 11, 2: 403-418.
• Walker, Stephen G. 2000. Forecasting the Political Behavior of Leaders with the Verbs in Context System of Operational Code Analysis. Social Science Automation: Hilliard, OH.
• Walker, Stephen G. 2014. Role Theory and the Cognitive Architecture of British Appeasement Decisions: Symbolic and Strategic Interaction in World Politics. London, Routledge.
• Walker, Stephen G., Akan Malici and Mark Schafer. 2011. Rethinking Foreign Policy Analysis: States, Leaders, and the Microfoundations of Behavioral International Relations. New York, Routledge.
• Walker, Stephen G., Mark Schafer and Michael D. Young. 1998. Systematic Procedures for Operational Code Analysis. International Studies Quarterly 42, 1: 173-188.
• Stephen G. Walker, Mark Schafer, Joshua Lambert, “Individual Leaders and the State: The Case of Israel as a Complex Adaptive System”, Uluslararası İlişkiler, Advanced Online Publication, 21 January 2025, pp. 1-18.