Ethical Principles and Publication Policy
1. General Publication Principles
Karamanoğlu Mehmetbey University International Journal of Art and Design is an international, peer-reviewed, open-access scholarly journal published by Karamanoğlu Mehmetbey University. The journal supports the production and dissemination of scientific knowledge in the fields of art and design and adheres to the principles of scientific originality, impartiality, transparency, and academic ethics throughout its publication processes.
The journal's publication policy is implemented in accordance with the international publication ethics principles established by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and recognized standards of scholarly publishing.
The journal accepts scholarly manuscripts written in Turkish and English. Until the end of 2026, the journal publishes two issues annually, in June and December. Beginning in 2027, the journal will adopt a continuous publication model.Under this model, manuscripts that have successfully completed the evaluation and publication processes and have been accepted for publication are published electronically without waiting for a predetermined publication period.
All submissions must meet the fundamental requirements of scientific originality, ethical compliance, and academic quality.
2. Scientific Originality and Publication Ethics
Manuscripts submitted to the journal must not have been previously published or be under simultaneous consideration for publication by another journal.
Submissions are expected to address an original research problem, be grounded in appropriate theoretical and methodological frameworks, and contribute to the existing body of scientific knowledge in the relevant field.
Practices that violate research and publication ethics, including plagiarism, data fabrication, data falsification, duplicate publication, salami slicing, inappropriate authorship, and the misleading use of references, are strictly prohibited.
Submitted manuscripts may be examined for scientific originality, and similarity detection software may be used when necessary. Similarity reports are evaluated not solely on numerical similarity scores but also on the nature of the similarities and compliance with scientific ethical principles.
3. Ethical Responsibilities of Authors
Authors are responsible for the scientific accuracy, originality, and ethical integrity of the manuscripts they submit to the journal.
Accordingly, authors are required to:
- Present research data and findings accurately, objectively, and without misleading manipulation.
- Properly acknowledge all sources used in their research in accordance with academic citation standards.
- Identify individuals who have made substantive scholarly contributions as authors and disclose their respective contributions.
- Obtain the necessary ethics committee approvals and informed consent from research participants, where applicable.
- Disclose funding sources, supporting institutions, and any potential conflicts of interest.
- Obtain the necessary permissions for the use of visual, audiovisual, and written materials belonging to third parties.
- Inform the journal's editorial office of any significant errors or ethical concerns identified during the review or publication process.
Authors are also responsible for responding to reviewers' and editors' comments in a scholarly manner and providing appropriate justifications for requested revisions.
4. Ethical Responsibilities of Reviewers
Reviewers must conduct their evaluations objectively, impartially, and constructively, in accordance with established scientific criteria.
Reviewers should decline review invitations for manuscripts outside their areas of expertise or where potential conflicts of interest exist. They must also maintain the confidentiality of all information and documents obtained during the review process.
Review reports are expected to provide a thorough assessment of the manuscript's scientific originality, theoretical and methodological adequacy, consistency of findings, and contribution to the relevant literature.
Reviewers must notify the journal's editorial office if they identify potential plagiarism, ethical violations, inadequate citation practices, or scientific inconsistencies.
5. Ethical Responsibilities of Editors
Editors are responsible for maintaining the scientific quality of the journal and ensuring that publication processes are conducted ethically, impartially, and transparently.
Editorial decisions must be based on the scientific merit, originality, and relevance of submitted manuscripts to the journal's aims and scope, regardless of the authors' academic titles, institutional affiliations, or personal characteristics.
Editors are responsible for maintaining confidentiality throughout the review process, selecting independent reviewers with appropriate expertise, managing potential conflicts of interest, and impartially investigating allegations of ethical misconduct.
Editors must recuse themselves from the evaluation and decision-making processes for manuscripts involving conflicts of interest.
6. Ethics Committee Approval and Research Ethics
Research requiring ethics committee approval must obtain the necessary authorization from the relevant ethics committee. Details of the approval must be clearly stated in the manuscript, and the required documentation must be submitted to the journal.
Studies involving data collection from human participants through surveys, interviews, focus groups, observations, experiments, or similar methods must comply with applicable ethical principles and relevant legislation.
Personal data, visual and audio recordings, and other information obtained from research participants must be handled in accordance with the principles of confidentiality, voluntary participation, and informed consent.
Authors are responsible for providing appropriate ethical declarations for studies that do not require ethics committee approval.
7. Ethical Principles in Art and Design Research
Karamanoğlu Mehmetbey University International Journal of Art and Design is committed to upholding ethical principles in scientific and artistic production, taking into account the distinctive research methods and forms of expression associated with art and design disciplines.
The sources of artworks, design products, drawings, photographs, audiovisual recordings, digital content, and other creative works used in manuscripts must be clearly acknowledged. Authors must fulfill all obligations relating to intellectual property and copyright when using materials belonging to third parties.
In studies involving artistic production, design practices, field research, or user experiences, research processes are expected to be scientifically transparent and ethically accountable.
Visual and audiovisual materials must not be manipulated in ways that misrepresent research findings or violate the principles of authorship and originality.
8. Ethical Violations, Appeals, and Post-Publication Procedures
Allegations of ethical misconduct concerning manuscripts submitted to or published in the journal are evaluated in accordance with the principles of research and publication ethics and the guidelines of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).
In cases involving plagiarism, data fabrication, data falsification, duplicate publication, inappropriate authorship, undisclosed conflicts of interest, or other violations of publication ethics, appropriate editorial action will be taken depending on the nature and severity of the violation.
If significant issues affecting scientific accuracy or publication ethics are identified in published articles, actions such as corrections, editorial statements, expressions of concern, or retractions may be implemented.
Authors and other relevant parties may submit reasoned appeals against editorial decisions or report suspected ethical violations to the journal's editorial office. Such submissions will be reviewed in accordance with the principles of confidentiality, impartiality, and scientific integrity.