Cover Image
e-ISSN: 2687-3125

Ethical Principles and Publication Policy

Journal of Logical Studies (Mantık Araştırmaları Dergisi, MAD) follows the Core Practices and flowcharts of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) at every stage of the publication process, including COPE's international standards for editors, authors and publishers. The journal also complies with the Directive on Scientific Research and Publication Ethics of Higher Education Institutions in Türkiye. These principles bind authors, reviewers, editors, editorial board members and the publisher.

Regulations and Guidelines Adopted:

All work published in MAD must have been prepared in accordance with research and publication ethics. Authors confirm this at submission, and the confirmation is printed in the declarations of the published article. The use of generative AI tools is covered separately on the journal's AI Policy page.

1. Publication Policy

TopicPractice
PublisherErciyes University
FrequencyOne issue a year, every October, in electronic form only
ScopePrimarily logic, the history of logic and the philosophy of logic, and also other areas of philosophy
Types of contributionResearch articles, translations, book reviews, symposium reports and interviews
LanguagesTurkish, English and Arabic
Open access and licenseAll content is freely available from the date of publication, with no embargo. Works are published under CC BY-NC-ND. Details are given on the Open Access and Copyright Policy page.
FeesNo fees are charged for submission, review or publication.
ReviewManuscripts that pass the initial check are reviewed double-blind by at least two external reviewers from different institutions. The target for the initial check is 30 days, and reviewers are given 15 days. The stages are described on the Peer Review and Publication Process page, and actual average durations on the Statistics page.
ArchivingPublished content is permanently stored on DergiPark. Details are given on the Archiving Policy page.

2. Responsibilities of Authors

  • Submissions must be original. They must not have been published before and must not be under review elsewhere. Work developed from a conference paper is accepted if this is stated in the text.
  • Ideas, data, text and images taken from others must be cited. Material reused from the author's own earlier publications must be cited as well.
  • Copyright law must be respected for all intellectual and artistic works used. Scales, questionnaires, photographs, maps and similar material owned by others are used only with the permission of the rights holder, and this permission is stated in the article.
  • Only those who made a scholarly contribution to the work and take responsibility for it are listed as authors. In multi-author work, each author's contribution is stated in the declarations, by role and by percentage. Once review has begun, adding or removing an author or changing the order of authors requires a justified request to the editor, approved by all authors.
  • Authors must be registered with an ORCID iD.
  • At submission, authors provide statements on research and publication ethics, originality, author contributions, ethics committee approval, funding and conflicts of interest. These statements, together with any acknowledgements, are printed in the published article under the heading “Declarations”, before the bibliography. Submissions with missing statements are not reviewed.
  • Authors provide the ethics committee approval and any other permissions obtained for the research when the editor asks for them.
  • Authors who discover a significant error in their published work must inform the editor promptly and cooperate with the editor on a correction or retraction.

3. Responsibilities of Reviewers

  • Reviewers decline an invitation and inform the editor if they have a competing interest with the author or if the manuscript falls outside their expertise. Close collaboration at the same institution, a joint project, a supervisory relationship and family ties are examples of such interests.
  • Manuscripts under review are confidential. Reviewers may not share them with third parties, use them in their own work or upload them to AI tools.
  • Reviewers' identities are not disclosed to authors, and reviewers do not try to identify authors.
  • Reviews do not take into account the author's identity, institution, beliefs or opinions. A review is not limited to formal checks. Reviewers assess the research problem, the method, the consistency of the argument, command of the literature, use of sources and the contribution to the field, and they write their criticism in a reasoned and respectful way.
  • Reviewers submit their reports within the time set by the journal (15 days) and notify the editor in advance if they need more time.
  • Reviewers who recognise the author, or who suspect plagiarism, fabricated data or duplicate publication, report this to the editor.

4. Responsibilities of Editors

  • Editors base acceptance and rejection on the scholarly quality and originality of the work, its fit with the journal's scope and the reviewers' reports.
  • Editors choose qualified reviewers from different institutions and make sure that reviewers have no competing interest with the author.
  • Editors maintain double-blind review. They do not share information about submissions with anyone other than the author, the reviewers and the editors handling the manuscript, and they do not use manuscripts under review in their own research.
  • An editor with a competing interest in a submission withdraws from it, and the submission is reassigned to another editor. Submissions by editors and editorial board members go through the same review process, handled by an editor with no connection to the author.
  • For research that requires ethics committee approval, editors make sure that approval was obtained before the research began and ask for the approval document when necessary.
  • If the reviewers disagree, the editor obtains the opinion of a third reviewer or makes a reasoned decision after assessing the reports.
  • Editors keep reviewer reports and review records for at least five years after publication.
  • Editors investigate and resolve allegations of misconduct following the COPE flowcharts.

5. Responsibilities of the Publisher

Erciyes University, the publisher of the journal, respects the independence of the editors and does not interfere in editorial decisions. It provides the resources needed for the journal to be published regularly, archived and kept accessible. It works with the editors when allegations of misconduct are investigated.

6. Similarity Screening

Submissions with a similarity rate above 20%, excluding the bibliography and properly marked quotations, are returned to the author without review.

Every submission is screened with iThenticate during the initial check. A rate below this limit is not sufficient on its own. The editor reads the report in detail and may also return a submission that shows heavy overlap with a single source, uncited borrowing or repetition of the author's earlier published texts. Similarity reports are kept with the review records.

7. Ethics Committee Approval and Other Permissions

Research that does not require ethics committee approvalResearch that requires ethics committee approval before it begins
  • Conceptual, historical and text-based studies
  • Discussion papers
  • Systematic reviews
  • Secondary analyses of properly anonymised data sets
  • All qualitative and quantitative research that collects data from participants through surveys, interviews, focus groups, observation, experiments or similar techniques
  • Research that uses humans or animals, including their materials and data, for experimental or other scientific purposes
  • Clinical research on humans
  • Research on animals
  • Retrospective studies that fall under personal data protection law

For research that requires approval, the name of the committee and the date and number of the approval are stated both in the section describing the method and in the declarations of the article. For case studies, the article states that informed consent was obtained. If the research was carried out in an institution, such as a ministry, a school or an archive, the permission obtained from that institution is also stated. For research that does not require approval, the ethical status is nevertheless stated explicitly.

Sample declaration (no approval required): “Ethics committee approval is not required.”

Sample declaration (approval required): “Approval for this study was obtained from the [Name of Committee] Ethics Committee, decision no. [Number], dated [Date].”

8. Conflicts of Interest, Funding and Acknowledgements

Authors declare all financial and personal relationships that could affect the results or interpretation of their work. For work supported by a project, grant or institution, the funding statement names the funder and, where applicable, the project number. If there is no conflict of interest or funding, this is stated explicitly. People who contributed to the work but are not listed as authors are named in the acknowledgements.

9. Research and Publication Misconduct

The following count as misconduct:
  • plagiarism;
  • fabrication of data;
  • falsification of data or findings;
  • duplicate publication, or simultaneous submission to more than one journal;
  • splitting one study into several publications without good reason;
  • listing as authors people who did not contribute, or omitting people who did;
  • failing to acknowledge funders or contributors;
  • carrying out or publishing research that requires ethics committee approval without obtaining it;
  • breaching the confidentiality of the review process as a reviewer or editor;
  • citation manipulation.

In suspected cases the editor asks the author for a written explanation and follows the COPE flowcharts. If misconduct is established, a submission under review is rejected and a published article is retracted. Where appropriate, the author's institution is informed.

10. Corrections and Retractions

If an error that does not affect the conclusions is found in a published article, the journal publishes a correction notice. If an error invalidates the findings or conclusions, or if misconduct has been established, the article is retracted in line with the COPE Retraction Guidelines. Retracted articles are not deleted. They remain available, marked “retracted” and accompanied by a notice explaining the reason. While an investigation is under way, the editor may publish an expression of concern to alert readers.

11. Appeals and Complaints

Authors may appeal an editorial decision with a reasoned letter within 30 days of being notified. Appeals go to the Editor-in-Chief, who reviews them with an editor not involved in the original decision and may seek an additional review. The outcome is communicated to the author with reasons and is final.

Complaints about the publication process or a published work, and reports of misconduct, should be sent to the Editor-in-Chief through the address on the journal's Contact page. The identity of the person making the report is kept confidential.

Version: 1.0
Last Update Time: 30 October 2026