Manuscripts submitted to Journal of Logical Studies (Mantık Araştırmaları Dergisi, MAD) are prepared according to the rules below. These rules apply together with the journal's publication policy and ethical principles.
- Article Template: for articles written in English (Word)
- Article Template for Articles in Turkish: with the Extended Abstract section (Word)
- Title Page: author information and declarations form (Word)
- Copyright and License Agreement (Word)
- Publication Ethics and Policy
- Peer Review and Publication Process
- Open Access and Copyright Policy
- AI Policy
- ISNAD: ISNAD Citation Style, 2nd edition
1. General Principles
- MAD is an international peer-reviewed journal based in Kayseri, Türkiye. It is published annually (once a year), but special or supplementary issues may be released when necessary.
- MAD is an academic journal primarily focused on Logic, and also covers Philosophy, History of Philosophy, and Philosophy of Religion. It publishes scholarly articles, interviews, translations, review essays, and similar academic works.
- Uploading a scholarly article, interview, translation, or review essay to the journal's online system is considered an official submission and initiates the peer-review process.
- The languages of publication of MAD are Turkish, English, and Arabic.
- Submissions must not have been previously published elsewhere. Conference papers may be accepted only if the prior presentation is clearly indicated in the article.
- MAD is an exclusively electronic journal and does not publish in print.
2. Copyright and License
Authors retain the copyright of works published in MAD. Works are published under CC BY-NC-ND. Authors bear full legal responsibility for the content of their work.
At submission, the Copyright and License Agreement signed by all authors is uploaded as a “Copyright Form” file. Details are given on the Open Access and Copyright Policy page.
3. Title, Abstract and Keywords
| Language of the article | Required elements |
|---|---|
| Turkish | A Turkish abstract of 200 to 250 words and 3 to 5 Turkish keywords, together with an English title, an extended English abstract of at least 750 words and English keywords. |
| English | An English abstract of 200 to 250 words, a Turkish title and a Turkish abstract. |
| Arabic | An abstract in Arabic together with titles, abstracts and keywords in Turkish and English. |
The first keyword indicates the discipline to which the article belongs. In articles written in Turkish, the extended English abstract is placed after the bibliography, in the Extended Abstract section that begins on a new page. This section is ready in the template for articles in Turkish. Articles written in English have no extended abstract and are prepared on the Article Template for articles in English.
Manuscripts that do not meet these requirements are not published, even if they have passed peer review.
4. Submission and Peer Review
- Peer review is blind. The full text therefore contains no information that identifies the author. The imprint box, the author name in the running head and the declarations in the template are left as placeholders.
- The names, titles, affiliations, e-mail addresses and ORCID iDs of the authors and the declarations are given in the Title Page form. The form is uploaded as a “Title Page” file during submission and is not sent to reviewers. The editor adds this information to the article after peer review.
- Authors refer to their own works in the third person. Before uploading, personal information is removed from the document properties with Word's “Inspect Document” command.
- The editor or assistant editors review the manuscript for compliance with publication and formatting guidelines. Articles that pass this stage are assigned to at least two reviewers from different institutions who are experts in the relevant field.
- Manuscripts are submitted from the author's personal dashboard, accessed with the registered email address and password. Authors track the review of their submission on the same dashboard.
Only one revision is allowed. Authors should therefore not upload any revised version until reports from all reviewers have been received.
5. Author and Reviewer Registration
When registering as an author or reviewer for MAD, all required fields must be completed. In the “Biography” section, the author's or reviewer's areas of research and interest must be listed. In the “Department” field, the main discipline followed by the sub-discipline should be specified (e.g., Philosophy and Religious Studies / Logic).
6. Page Layout
Manuscripts are prepared in Microsoft Word on the journal template. The styles of the template carry the following settings:
| Setting | Value |
|---|---|
| Paper size | A4, portrait |
| Margins | Top 3 cm, bottom 3 cm, left 2.5 cm, right 2.5 cm |
| Font | Cambria |
| Font size | Main text 10.5; Turkish abstract 9; English abstract 10; footnotes 9; article title 16 |
| Paragraph spacing | Before 7 pt, after 0 pt |
| Paragraph indentation | 1 cm |
| Line spacing | Main text single; abstracts and bibliography 1.15 |
- If the article uses a special font that is not standard in Microsoft Word, the font file must be submitted alongside the article.
- The running heads, margin text and page numbers of the template are not changed. The editor sets them at the publication stage.
- Except where content-specific needs require otherwise, the Turkish Language Association's (TDK) orthographic and punctuation guidelines must be followed.
7. Citation and Bibliography
Articles follow the footnote version of the ISNAD Citation Style, 2nd edition. Every article ends with a bibliography, under the heading BIBLIOGRAPHY (KAYNAKÇA in articles written in Turkish), listing all works cited in the footnotes in alphabetical order of the authors' surnames. Surnames are not written in capitals.
| Type of source | Footnote | Bibliography |
|---|---|---|
| Book | Necati Öner, Klasik Mantık (İstanbul: Divan Kitap, 18th ed., 2021), 81. | Öner, Necati. Klasik Mantık. İstanbul: Divan Kitap, 18th ed., 2021. |
| Translation | Aristoteles, Metafizik, trans. Ahmet Arslan (İstanbul: Sosyal Yayınlar, 1996), 120. | Aristoteles. Metafizik. trans. Ahmet Arslan. İstanbul: Sosyal Yayınlar, 1996. |
| Article | First Name Surname, “Title of the Article”, Journal Title Volume/Issue (Year), page. | Surname, First Name. “Title of the Article”. Journal Title Volume/Issue (Year), page range. DOI, if any. |
| Book chapter | First Name Surname, “Title of the Chapter”, Title of the Book, ed. Editor's Name (Place: Publisher, Year), page. | Surname, First Name. “Title of the Chapter”. Title of the Book. ed. Editor's Name. Place: Publisher, Year. |
| Thesis | First Name Surname, Title of the Thesis (City: University, Institute, PhD Thesis, Year), page. | Surname, First Name. Title of the Thesis. City: University, Institute, PhD Thesis, Year. |
| Online source | First Name Surname, “Title” (Access date). | Surname, First Name. “Title”. Access date. URL. |
Articles written in Turkish use the Turkish forms of the abbreviations (çev., 18. Basım). Cases not covered by these examples follow the ISNAD guide.
8. Articles in Arabic
In articles written in Arabic, the title, abstract, keywords and bibliography are also given in Latin script. Arabic works in the bibliography are written in Latin script according to the transliteration system used by the journal. This also applies to references to works in Arabic script in articles written in other languages.
9. Headings, Tables and Figures
Headings have at most three levels, and headings of the same level are formatted the same way throughout the article. Tables and figures are numbered separately (Table 1, Figure 1). Table captions are placed above the table and figure captions below the figure. The source of any table or figure taken from another work is given below the caption.
10. Article Types
MAD publishes research articles, translations, book reviews, symposium reports and interviews. The type of each contribution is stated in the table of contents and on its first page. Book reviews begin with the bibliographic details of the book reviewed.
11. Declarations
- a statement that research and publication ethics were followed and that the work is original;
- author contributions and, for multi-author work, the share of each author;
- ethics committee approval, with the committee's name and the date and number of the decision where required;
- funding and support;
- conflicts of interest;
- the Sustainable Development Goals the study relates to, if any;
- acknowledgements, if any.
If generative AI was used, the statement required by the AI Policy is also given in the Title Page form.
12. Review and Publication Process
The review stages, reviewer criteria and target timelines are described on the Peer Review and Publication Process page, and the ethical rules in the Publication Ethics and Policy.