Research Article
Book Review
Letter to Editor
Issue Editorial Board
Yakınçağ Osmanlı tarihi ve Avrupa tarihi alanında çalışmalar yapmaktadır.
Late Modern Balkan History, Late Modern Discoveries and Colonialism History, Late Modern Ottoman History
He received his doctorate from Marmara University, Istanbul, Turkey. He was appointed to Yıldız Technical University. Between 2014-2015, he conducted research as a visiting scholar at Indiana University-Bloomington in the United States of America with a TÜBİTAK scholarship. He currently continues his research as Prof. Dr. at Yıldız Technical University, Department of Turkish Language and Social Sciences Education.
Linguistic Structures (Incl. Phonology, Morphology and Syntax), Textlinguistics, Old Turkic Language (Orhon, Uyghur, Karahan), New Turkish Language (Turkish of Old Anatolia, Ottoman, Turkiye), Turkish Education
![Sekreterya [osmed]](https://dergipark.org.tr/media/cache/user_croped/e90e/235f/9faa/61648947cae2a.png)
Late Modern Ottoman History
Selim Hilmi Özkan is Professor of History at Yildiz Technical University. He is currently working on Ottoman diplomacy and Ottoman foreign policy. His most recent publications include “Reasons for Migration of Armenians in the Ottoman Empire before 1915”, African and Asian Studies, 19, 3, (2020), 282-305; and “Arms Smuggling across Ottoman Borders in the Second Half of the 19th Century” Journal of Balkan and Near Eastern Studies, 18, 3, (2016), 297-312. He is currently working on a book project: Migrations and Migration Routes from Cebel-i Lebanon to the United States of America, End of the Nineteenth Century. Also, he is included in a researcher working group on "COST Action CA18129 "Islamic Legacy: Narratives East, West, South, North of the Mediterranean (1350-1750)" and "COST Action CA18140, People in Motion: Entangled Histories of Displacement across the Mediterranean(1492-1923)."
I held postdoctoral positions at Arizona State University, AZ, USA, from 2023-2024; at Texas Tech University, Lubbock, TX, USA, from 2014-2015; and at the University of Wisconsin in 2012. My research has focused on Ottoman diplomacy, Ottoman foreign policy, and history education.
Ottoman Institutions and Civilization, Intellectual History of Ottoman, Ottoman Society, Late Modern Ottoman History, Ottoman history
Early Modern Ottoman History, Early Modern Urban History
History of Ottoman Education, Ottoman Field Service
Ottoman Institutions and Civilization (Other), Early Modern Urban History, Early Modern Ottoman History
History of Ottoman Socio-Economy
History Education, Ottoman history
History of Ottoman Economy, Ottoman Culture and Art, Ottoman Central Organization, History of Ottoman Socio-Economy
History of Ottoman Socio-Economy, Ottoman Society, Early Modern Military History
Paolo Girardelli completed his PhD at the University of Naples in 1996. His work focuses on European, Levantine, and non-Muslim presence in late Ottoman cities.
History of Architecture, Late Modern Mediterranean History
Dr Mrs Neeta M. Khandpekar holds the position of Professor in the Department of History at the University of Mumbai. She has wide teaching experience of over three decades. She was awarded D.Litt degree by the University of Sambalpur, Odisha. Her interests include Modern/ Maritime History and Christian Missionary History. She has visited several countries like USA, Canada, Italy, Malaysia, Indonesia & China with support from UGC and ICHR, New Delhi. A member of more than 14 professional academic bodies and was in the Board of Studies of University of Mumbai from 2004-10. The other distinctions include certificate of merit by Government of Maharashtra (1986), Mumbai University History Department Scholarship (1989), UGC Teacher Fellowship Award (1999) and UGC Postdoctoral research Award (2004). She has authored two books namely Konkan Coast: and other on Christian Missionaries. Recently she was deputed as ICCR Chair Professor at Victoria University of Wellington, New Zealand.
Contemporary Asian History, Medieval History
Social and Humanities Education (Excluding Economics, Business and Management), Contemporary History of Middle East, Contemporary Russian History, History of The Republic of Turkiye, History of Ottoman Education
Philosophical and Social Foundations of Education, History of Ottoman Education
Language Studies, Translation Studies, Turkish Language and Literature
History of Ottoman Socio-Economy, Early Modern Ottoman History
Classical Turkish Literature Out of Ottoman Field, Classical Turkish Literature of Ottoman Field, Classical Turkish Literature
Early Modern European History
Ottoman Central Organization, History of Ottoman Socio-Economy, Ottoman Field Service, Ottoman Society, Early Modern Military History, Early Modern Balkan History, Early Modern Ottoman History, Ottoman history
History of Ottoman Education, Late Modern Military History, Late Modern Naval History, Late Modern Ottoman History, Late Modern Renewal History, Ottoman history
Population Trends and Policies, Migration History, Late Modern Balkan History, Late Modern Ottoman History, Ottoman history
Archive, Archival, Repository and Related Studies, Political and Civilization History of Islam, History of Ottoman Education, Ottoman Culture and Art, Ottoman Society, History of Islam, Late Modern Balkan History, Early Modern Ottoman History, Ottoman history, Sufism
Ottoman Society, Women's Studies
International History, Late Modern History, Late Modern Balkan History, Late Modern Russian History, Early Modern History, Early Modern Russian History
General Turkish History, History of The Republic of Turkiye, Ottoman Institutions and Civilization, History of Ottoman Education, Ottoman Central Organization, Ataturk's Principles History of Revolution, Biography, Late Modern African History, Late Modern Balkan History, Late Modern Ottoman History, Early Modern European History
Issue Reviewers
Late Modern History
History of Ottoman Socio-Economy, History of Ottoman Education, Ottoman Society
Early Modern Urban History, Early Modern Military History, Early Modern History, Early Modern Ottoman History
History of Muslim Turkish Countries and Societies, Medieval History, Medieval European History, Political and Civilization History of Islam
Protection, Restoration and Repair in Buildings, Environment, Habitation and Products, Built Environment and Design
Fine-Arts in Turkish Islamic Art, Line in Turkish Islamic Art, Architectural, Marbling, Islamic Arts, Turkish Islamic Arts (Other), Turkish-Islamic Arts History
Modern Turkish Literature in Turkiye Field
Ottoman Institutions and Civilization, Ottoman history, Early Modern Ottoman History, Ottoman Society, Ottoman Field Service, History of Ottoman Socio-Economy, Ottoman Central Organization
Kalam
Ceramic Glaze, Miniature, Ornamentation, Fine Arts
Early Modern Urban History, History of Ottoman Socio-Economy
Modern Turkish Literature in Turkiye Field
British and Irish Language, Literature and Culture, Late Modern Ottoman History, Late Modern European History, Ottoman history
History of Science
Classical Turkish Literature of Ottoman Field, Classical Turkish Literature
Architectural
Late Modern Press History, Late Modern Ottoman History, Late Modern History, Late Modern Renewal History, Early Modern Press History, Early Modern Renewal History
Prof. Dr.
Mehmet Nuri ÇINARCI
VAN YÜZÜNCÜ YIL ÜNİVERSİTESİ, EĞİTİM FAKÜLTESİ, ORTAÖĞRETİM SOSYAL ALANLAR EĞİTİMİ BÖLÜMÜ
Classical Turkish Literature, Classical Turkish Literature of Ottoman Field, Classical Turkish Literature Out of Ottoman Field, Turkish Language and Literature
Ottoman Society, Women's Studies
History of Ottoman Socio-Economy, Ottoman Society, Late Modern African History, Late Modern Mediterranean History, Late Modern Urban History, Late Modern Balkan History, Ottoman history, Late Modern Ottoman History
Ataturk's Principles History of Revolution
History of Architecture, Cultural and Natural Heritage, Visual Cultures, Islamic Arts, Medieval Age Archeology, Turkish-Islamic Archeology in the Middle Ages, Urban in Art History , Art History, Medieval Cities, History of Seljuk, Protection and Repair of Movable Cultural Heritage, Islamic Intellectual History, Medieval History, Turkish and Islamic Intellectual History, Aesthetics in Architecture
Kahramanmaraş İstiklal Üniversitesi İnsan ve Toplum Bilimleri Fakültesi Tarih Bölümü
Ottoman history, Archive, Early Modern Ottoman History, Early Modern Renewal History, Urbanization History, Library and Information Studies, Early Modern Urban History, History of Ottoman Socio-Economy, Ottoman Central Organization, Medieval Cities, History of Ottoman Economy, Regional Economy
Classical Turkish Literature of Ottoman Field, Classical Turkish Literature Out of Ottoman Field, Classical Turkish Literature
History of Architecture
Ottoman history, Political History, Late Modern Renewal History, Middle East Studies, Late Modern History, Late Modern History of Middle East, Early Modern Ottoman History
Ottoman Society, History of Ottoman Socio-Economy, Ottoman Field Service, Early Modern Balkan History
Early Modern Ottoman History, Urbanization History, Late Modern Ottoman History, History of Ottoman Socio-Economy, Intellectual History of Ottoman
Sanatçı/ Akademisyen 2004 yılında Atatürk Üniversitesi Güzel Sanatlar Fakültesi, Geleneksel Türk Sanatları bölümünü kazandı. 7 Temmuz -7 Ekim 2007 tarihleri arasında İtalya/Floransa Palozzo Spınellı L’arte E Il Restouro Assocıazıone No Profit Enstitüsünde çizim ve decorasyon dersleri aldı. 2008 yılında tezhip anasanat dalında lisans öğrenimini tamamlayarak aynı yıl Atatürk Üniversitesi, Sosyal Bilimler Enstitüsü, Geleneksel Türk Sanatları Bölümünde yüksek lisansa başladı. 2013 yılında Gazi Üniversitesi, Güzel Sanatlar Enstitüsü, Geleneksel Türk Sanatları bölümünde Sanatta Yeterlik programına yerleşerek 2017 yılında tamamladı. 2013-2018 yılları arasında Gaziosmanpaşa Üniversitesi, Güzel Sanatlar Fakültesi, Geleneksel Türk Sanatları Bölümünde Öğr. Gör. ve Dr. Öğr. Üyesi olarak görev yaptı. 2019 yılından bu yana İzmir Demokrasi Üniversitesi Güzel Sanatlar Fakültesi, Geleneksel Türk Sanatları Bölümünde görev yapan sanatçı halen İzmir Demokrasi Üniversitesi, Güzel Sanatlar Fakültesi, Geleneksel Türk Sanatları bölümünde Doç. Dr. olarak çalışmalarına devam etmektedir.
Miniature, Ornamentation
Ottoman history, Late Modern Russian History, Late Modern Urban History, Late Modern Renewal History, Late Modern Discoveries and Colonialism History, Late Modern Ottoman History
Early Modern Ottoman History, Ottoman history, Ottoman Institutions and Civilization (Other), Ottoman Society, Ottoman Field Service, History of Ottoman Socio-Economy, Ottoman Culture and Art, History of Ottoman Education
Middle East Studies
Ottoman Society
Early Modern Ottoman History, Early Modern Urban History
Aim & Scope
The Journal of Ottoman Civilization Studies [OSMED] presents a scientific inventory of the interaction studies between individuals and societies in the Ottoman State. Its scope is to publish authentic studies about Ottoman Empire societies and cultures written by social scientists related to anthropology, sociology, history, and political sciences. The journal focuses on problems and possibilities, as well as the past and the future. The comparisons between cultures and societies are made as far as possible. Articles must be predicated on authentic research and analysis.
The Journal of Ottoman Civilization Studies [OSMED] was adopted as a principle for publishing in fields related to Ottoman History, Ottoman Civilization, and Ottoman geography.
JOCS organizes or supports in-country or abroad academic conferences, symposiums, workshops, etc. It includes the full versions of the proclamations submitted in these studies only if it is not published elsewhere.
The journal presents a scholarly account of studies of individuals and societies in Ottoman Civilization. Its scope is to publish original research by social scientists in anthropology, sociology, history, political science, and related social sciences about Ottoman Empire societies and cultures and their relationships. The journal focuses on problems, possibilities, and the past and future. Where possible, it compares cultures and societies. Articles should be based on original research and can be co-authored.
Author Guidelines
For all first-time users, please click the "Register Now" button in the login section above and enter the requested information. When you register, you must select e-mail as your preferred contact method. When you register, you will receive an e-mail message with your username and password. If you have any trouble registering, please don't hesitate to contact the editorial office.
All repeat users: If you have already received an e-mail message from us with an assigned username and password, you do not need to register again. You can enter your access codes into the login frame above. You do not need to re-register, even if your role changes (e.g., from author to reviewer).
Authors: Please enter your username and password into the designated fields above and log into the system as an "Author." Please submit your manuscript and track its progress through the system. Please download the Author's Manual for detailed guidelines on the manuscript submission process.
Reviewers: Please enter your access codes into the login frame above and log into the system as a "Reviewer." You can view and download manuscripts assigned to you for review and then submit your comments to the editor. For further information, please download the Reviewer's Manual.
To change your contact information, username, or password, Log into the system, select "Update My Information" from the menu above, and follow the directions.
Did you forget your password? To have your username and password mailed to your registered e-mail address, please click on the "Send Username/Password" link in the login section and enter the requested information (first name, last name, and email address) exactly as you entered it when you registered. If everything matches, the e-mail will be sent.
The author(s) are responsible for the ideas and viewpoints in the scientific articles published in The Journal of Ottoman Civilization Studies [JOCS]. The articles sent to be published are sent to at least two experts in their fields using the two-sided blind referee principle. In the case of one of the referee's negative assessments, the text is sent to a third referee. The last is the journal advice, and the publication board makes decisions. To execute the two-sided blind referee method, the authors need not include any information in their text that shows their identity information before adding their texts to the system. Author information will be added later by the editors in the correction step.
The articles are only submitted by the open journal system.
Authors should upload their articles to the system after they write or edit their writings according to the journal article template.
*Cases such as name similarities, surname changes, names of Turkish letters, different spellings, and institution changes may create problems in publication/citation searches made by the author's name. Researchers need to obtain their depiction or identity/number (ID). For this reason, all of our writers are required to register for ORCID. It is recommended that our authors should request their ORCID information and include this information in journals/articles since ORCID is going to be used to ensure standardization and in the joint studies that are going to be carried out with YOK.
*ORCID is the abbreviation of Open Researcher and Contributor ID. ORCID is a 16-digit, numbered URI compatible with the ISO Standard (27729), the International Standard Name Identifier (ISNI).
You can create a free registration for an individual ORCID at http://orcid.org.
* Authors should upload their articles to the system after they write or edit their writings according to the journal article template.
The studies sent to the journal are expected to be between 5,000 and 12,000 words. Books and other promotions should be at most 1,500 words.
The editorial board reviews the articles uploaded to the system by the authors and then decides whether to include them in the assessment.
The editors check every article submitted to the Journal of Ottoman Civilization Studies in terms of their resemblance and plagiarism, using similarity programs such as iThenticate, Turnitin, and İntihal. Articles with more than %25 plagiarism are returned to the author without being taken to the assessment process. If the resemblance is not apparent in the articles or other works to the degree of %25 and above, the studies are sent to the two referees who are experts in the field. Regarding the positive report that referees receive, the article is published. In the case of one of the referees' adverse reports, depending on the report's content, if it is seen as necessary by the editor, the article is sent to a third referee. If the third referee's report is positive, the article is published; otherwise, it is not published. If the article is not assessed within the time given to the referee, the article is sent to another referee. A single referee report is deemed satisfactory for book reviews. It is forwarded to a second referee in the event of a need.
Text
1. The journal text should be written in Times New Roman type font, with 12 font size, with a 2,5 cm gap from all of the edges, with only one column, with 1 line gap, and in the size of A4.
2. Paragraphs should start with one indentation; there should be no gap between paragraphs.
3. When stress is needed within the text, it should be done with italics.
4. there should be 6 pt gaps before and after the paragraphs.
5. There should be no information about the author within the text.
6. The studies sent to the journal are expected to be between 5,000 and 12,000 words. The book and other promotions should be at most 1,500 words.
The Article Title
1. The title should clearly define the article's subject, field, and the limits of its problems.
2. The title should be in bold and centered, with the expectation of its conjunctions in uppercase in its first letters and in 12 font size (Times New Roman).
Abstract/Keywords
1. every article should have a Turkish and English abstract at the beginning.
2. The abstract should contain the purpose of the article, its essential findings, and conclusions.
3. The abstract should be justified[150-200 words] and written in a manner that does not exceed 200 words.
4. The abstract and keywords should be written in Times New Roman font type, 10 font size, and with single line spacing.
5. At the bottom of the abstract, there should be a minimum of 3 and a maximum of 5 keywords that describe the article's content.
Title and Sub-titles
1. All titles should be written in Times New Roman font style, with 12 font sizes.
2. In the section titles, the first letters of the words should be upper case, while the others should be lower case, with centered and bold letters.
3. In the sub-title section, the first letters of the words should be upper case, while the others should be lower case, with left centered and bold.
4. In the third or fourth-level titles, the first letters of the words should be uppercase, while the others should be lowercase using the paragraph title.
The Display of Table and Figure/Visual
1. Tables and figures should be prepared to be published and used when indicated in the text.
2. Tables and titles should be in Times New- Roman, with 10 font sizes and single spacing.
3. In the title of the tables, the first letter of every word should be upper case.
4. The texts in the table should be single-spaced, with a gap of 0 pt before and after, and written without adding spaces between paragraphs of the same style.
5. There should be no vertical lines in the table.
6. The width of the lines within the table should be measured according to a width of 1 / 2 pt.
7. there should be a 12-point gap before and after the table.
8. In the display of the table's title and the table's number, the table's number should be bold and left center, and the table's title should be the standard and left center. E.g., Table 1.The Information about the Gender of the Participants
9. In displaying the titles of the figures and visuals, the number of the figure/visual should be bold and centered, and the title of the figure/visual should be regular and centered. E.g., Figure 1. Turkey Cities Map
CHICAGO FOOTNOTE-REFERENCE SYSTEM
CHICAGO NOTES AND BIBLIOGRAPHY STYLE
Presidential Ottoman Archive [BOA]
BOA, BEO, 1655/124078; 3549/266169; 4174/313019; 4181/313547.
BOA, DH.EUM.4.Şb, 8/20.
BOA, DH.EUM.KLU, 9/12.
Single-author book:
In footnote:
Erol Köroğlu, Türk Edebiyatı ve Birinci Dünya Savaşı, 1914-1918: PropagandadanMilli Kimlik İnşasına (İstanbul: İletişim Yayınları, 2004), 35.
In reference:
Surname, Name, Work name. The work's publication place/city: The establishment that published it, Publication date.
In reference:
Köroğlu, Erol. Türk Edebiyatı ve Birinci Dünya Savaşı, 1914-1918: Propagandadan Milli Kimlik İnşasına. İstanbul: İletişim Yayınları, 2004.
Two Authors Book:
In footnote:
İnci Enginün ve Zeynep Kerman, Bütün Eserleri/Ahmet Haşim (İstanbul: Dergah Yayınları,1991), 25-28.
In reference:
Enginün, İnci ve Zeynep Kerman. Bütün Eserleri/Ahmet Haşim. İstanbul: Dergah Yayınları, 1991.
Three Authors Book:
In footnote:
İrfan Dağdelen, Hüseyin Türkmen ve Nergis Ulu, Türk Kütüphaneciliğinden İzdişümler: Nail Bayraktara Armağan (İstanbul: Büyükşehir Belediye Başkanlığı - Kültürel ve Sosyal İşler Daire Başkanlığı - Kütüphane ve Müzeler Müdürlüğü, 2005 ).
In reference:
Dağdelen, İrfan, Hüseyin Türkmen ve Nergis Ulu. Türk Kütüphaneciliğinden İzdişümler: Nail Bayraktara Armağan. İstanbul: Büyükşehir Belediye Başkanlığı, Kültürel ve Sosyal İşler Daire Başkanlığı, Kütüphane ve Müzeler Müdürlüğü, 2005.
Four or More Authors Book:
In reference:
Günay Kut vd., Boğaziçi Üniversitesi Kandilli Rasathanesi ve Deprem Araştırma Enstitüsü Astronomi Astroloji Matematik Yazmaları Kataloğu: Kandilli Rasathanesi El Yazmaları (İstanbul: Boğaziçi Üniversitesi, 2007), 104.
In reference:
Kut, Günay, Hatice Aynur, Cumhure Üçer ve Fatma Büyükkarcı. Boğaziçi Üniversitesi Kandilli Rasathanesi ve Deprem Araştırma Enstitüsü Astronomi Astroloji Matematik Yazmaları Kataloğu: Kandilli Rasathanesi El Yazmaları. İstanbul: Boğaziçi Üniversitesi, 2007.
Book That has a Person That Prepared the Book for the Publication with the Author:
In footnote:
Ahmet Mithat, Ahbar-ı Âsara Tamim- Enzar: (1307-1890) Edebi Eserlere Genel Bir Bakış, haz., Nüket Esen (İstanbul: İletişim Yayınevi, 2003). 46.
In reference:
Ahmet Mithat. Ahbar-ı Âsara Tamim-i Enzar: (1307-1890) Edebi Eserlere Genel BirBakış. Haz., Nüket Esen. İstanbul: İletişim Yayınevi, 2003. (If the author's surname is apparent, it was written before.)
Book That has a Translator with the Author:
In footnote:
Norman Hampson, Aydınlanma Çağı, çev., Jale Parla (İstanbul: Hürriyet Vakfı Yayınları, 1991), 150.
In reference:
Hampson, Norman. Aydınlanma Çağı. Çev., Jale Parla. İstanbul: Hürriyet Vakfı Yayınları, 1991.
If its author or who it was prepared by is not apparent, the name of the person who prepared it or the translator's name is written before the work's name in the footnote or reference part according to its style, and then it is written such as haz.,/Haz., or çev.,/Çev.
In footnote:
Özdemir Nutku, çev., Romeo ve Juliet (İstanbul: Remzi Kitabevi, 1984), 25.
In reference:
Nutku, Özdemir, Çev. Romeo ve Juliet. İstanbul: Remzi Kitabevi, 1984.
A Part From the Book:
In footnote:
Halid Ziya Uşaklıgil, “Bölüm 22,” Aşk-ı Memnu, 8. bs., haz., Muharrem Kaya ve Rahim Tarım (İstanbul: Özgür Yayınları, 2007), 43.
In reference:
Uşaklıgil, Halid Ziya. “Bölüm 22.” Aşk-ı Memnu, 8. bs., Muharrem Kaya ve Rahim Tarım. İstanbul: Özgür Yayınları, 2007.
Printed Article:
In footnote:
Köksal Seyhan, “Yunus Emre’nin Bir Şiirinde Şehir Alegorisi,” Türklük Bilgisi Araştırmaları Journal of Turkish Studies 24/II (2000): 240.
In reference:
Seyhan, Köksal. “Yunus Emre’nin Bir Şiirinde Şehir Alegorisi.” Türklük Bilgisi Araştırmaları Journal of Turkish Studies 24/II (2000): 231 - 280.
Electronic Article:
In footnote:
Nezihe Seyhan, "Resurrection Day in Divan Literature," Literature & Theology: An International Journal of Religion, Theory, and Culture, 18:1 (2004 Mar), 64. (erişim 12.08.2009)
In reference:
Seyhan, Nezihe. "Resurrection Day in Divan Literature." Literature & Theology: An International Journal of Religion, Theory, and Culture. 18:1 (2004 Mar), 62-76. (erişim 12.08.2009)
Encyclopedia Matter:
In footnote:
Osman Eskicioğlu, “Fakir”, TDV İslâm Ansiklopedisi, XII (İstanbul 1995), s. 129.
In reference:
Eskicioğlu, Osman. “Fakir”, TDV İslâm Ansiklopedisi, XII (İstanbul 1995), ss. 129-131.
Web Page:
In footnote:
“Google Gizlilik Politikası,” son güncelleme 19 Ağustos, 2015, https://www.google.com/intl/tr_tr/policies/privacy/.
In reference:
Google. “Google Gizlilik Politikası”. Son güncelleme 19 Ağustos, 2015. https://www.google.com/intl/tr_tr/policies/privacy/.
In footnote:
“McDonald’s Happy Meal Toy Safety Facts,” McDonald’s Corporation, erişim 19 Temmuz, 2008, http://www.mcdonalds.com/corp/about/factsheets.html.
In reference:
McDonald’s Corporation. “McDonald’s Happy Meal Toy Safety Facts.” Erişim 19 Temmuz, 2008. http://www.mcdonalds.com/corp/about/factsheets.html.
Thesis:
In footnote:
Zeynep Sabuncu, “Mihr ü Mah: A Mathnawi of Mustafa Âli” (yüksek lisans tezi, Boğaziçi Üniversitesi, 1983), 112.
In reference:
Sabuncu, Zeynep. “Mihr ü Mah: A Mathnawi of Mustafa Âli.” Yüksek lisans tezi, Boğaziçi Üniversitesi, 1983.
Unpublished Conference:
In footnote:
Mustafa Akdağ ve Hidayet Tok, “Geleneksel Öğretim ile Power Point Destekli Öğretimin Öğrenci Erişisine Etkisi” (XIII. Ulusal Eğitim Bilimleri Kurultayı’ında Sunulan Bildiri, İnönü Üniversitesi Eğitim Fakültesi, Malatya, Temmuz 06-09, 2004).
In reference:
Akdağ, Mustafa ve Hidayet Tok. “Geleneksel Öğretim ile Power Point Destekli Öğretimin Öğrenci Erişisine Etkisi” XIII. Ulusal Eğitim Bilimleri Kurultayı’ında Sunulan Bildiri, İnönü Üniversitesi Eğitim Fakültesi, Malatya, Temmuz 06-09, 2004.
Ethical Principles and Publication Policy
Ethical Principles and Publication Policy
The Journal of Ottoman Civilization Studies (Publication Ethical Principles)
The Journal of Ottoman Civilization Studies has adopted the principle of publishing by universal publication rules.
The Journal of Ottoman Civilization Studies is a peer-reviewed journal. In studies prepared according to scientific rules, all components of the publication process, including the publisher, editors, authors, and readers, should comply with ethical principles. The journal's publication ethics and open-access policy require this compliance with the open-access guides and guidelines published by the Committee of Publication Ethics (COPE).
Suppose situations such as manipulating, distortion, or fabricating the data used in the articles are detected. In that case, this will be reported through an official channel to the corporation where the author works, and the article will be rejected. Our journal has the right to request output files from the authors concerning the assessments given by the editor(s) and/or the referees.
The Ethical Responsibilities of The Publisher
The Journal of Ottoman Civilization Studies is a nonprofit publication establishment.
The Journal of Ottoman Civilization Studies has been published since 2014 in the framework of universal rules.
The Editors Council of the Journal of Ottoman Civilization Studies comprises experts in their fields, whether in the country or abroad. Experts in Ottoman History, Culture, and Civilization are members of the Editorial Council. Depending on the article's subject, the editor can, when necessary, send an article to faculty members who are not members of the Editors Council for them to analyze as field editors.
The Responsibilities of the Editors Council of The Journal of Ottoman Civilization Studies
• The Editors Council of the Journal is responsible for all of the articles submitted to The Journal of Ottoman Civilization Studies, in fact, from all of the processes after its publication, and the editors' council is aware of this responsibility. This responsibility requires independent decision-making from all personal gain and only thinking about public welfare in the decisions that are being made about the journal. The relationship between the publisher and the Editors Council is based on the independence principle, and all of the decisions that are going to be made by the editors are independent of the publisher and the other person and establishments.
• The Editors Council of the Journal of Ottoman Civilization Studies strives to develop the journal and elevate its publication quality continually.
• The Editors Council of The Journal of Ottoman Civilization Studies ensures the determination and implementation of journal policies such as publication, blind review, the assessment process, ethical principles, etc.
• The Editors Council of The Journal of Ottoman Civilization Studies protects the copyright of the article author published in the journal.
• The Editors Council of the Journal of Ottoman Civilization Studies is responsible for taking precautions regarding intellectual property rights, non-scientific-ethical behaviors, plagiarism, and reference (attribution) gangsterism in the article and journal publication process.
• The Editors Council of the Journal of Ottoman Civilization Studies keeps records of every article and correspondence about the journal, written or printed, through Dergipark and its means.
The Ethical Responsibilities of the Editors, Editors Facilitators, and Field Editors
• Editors try to accommodate the information needs of the referees, author(s), researchers, and readers, provide feedback when necessary, manage the publishing process, and make corrections according to the principle of clarity in subjects where an explanation is needed.
• Editors are attentive to the article's authenticity and contributions to the scientific literature, reader, researcher, and operators while deciding on the publication of the articles.
• Editors consider the authentic value of the article, its contribution to the field, the validity and trustworthiness of its research method, the clarity of its verbalism, and the purpose and extent of the journal while making a positive or negative decision about the article.
• Editors, if the submitted articles do not have a significant issue, consider the articles in the pre-evaluation stage, be attentive to the positive referee suggestions, and if it does not have a severe problem, won't change the decisions that were taken by the previous editor(s).
• Editors perform the blind review and evaluation process policies present in the journal's publication policies, keep the referees' identity information classified, and ensure that every article is assessed in a non-biased way and assessed within its time.
• Editors send the articles by being attentive to the professionality of the field editors and referees, and they support the evaluations to be made non-biased and independent.
• Editors, for a non-biased evaluation of the article, consider the conflict of interest-unity of interest between the referees and author(s).
• Editors are searching for the creation of a wide range of referees that are constantly updated.
• Editors block evaluations that are not aligned with academic etiquette and are non-scientific.
• Editors make sure that journal publication processes are aligned with publishing policies and guides, inform those whore are involved in the process about the developments of the publishing policies and prepare a training program if it is necessary.
• Editors communicate effectively with everyone involved in the publication process and organize meetings periodically.
• Editors ensure that the personal data are protected in the evaluated journals; they protect the personal data of the author, referee, and readers.
• Editors are attentive to the protection of the rights of humans and animals in the article; they care about the documentation of the open confirmation of the article's participants; if the ethical council approval about the journal's participants shows that they are not allowed in experimental researches, they reject the article.
• Editors take precautions for malpractice. If it is suspected that malpractice may be the case, they share the data about the subject through an objective investigation.
• Editors ensure that the errors, desultoriness, or misleadings in the articles are corrected.
• Editors protect the intellectual property rights of published articles, and in the case of a breach, they defend the rights of the journal and the author(s). Also, they take necessary precautions regarding the articles' contents and whether they breach other publications' intellectual property rights; they conduct an originality-similarity audit.
• Editors are attentive to the critics intended for articles published in the journal, and they give a right to respond to the author(s) of the criticized articles.
• Editors consider the works that contain adverse outcomes as well.
• Editors analyze the remonstrances related to the Journal and make the necessary explanations.
The Ethical Responsibilities of the Referees
In the article evaluation process of The Journal of Ottoman Civilization Studies, it is applied a two side blind referee principle where the author(s) don't know the referees and the referees don't know the authors; the referees can't communicate directly with the authors; the article evaluation forms and the wish the correct which is specified on the text is conveyed to the author(s) through journal administration system by the editors. The referees that are going to evaluate the articles that are submitted to The Journal of Ottoman Civilization Studies should carry these ethical responsibilities:
• Referees should only accept and evaluate articles related to their specialty.
• Referees should evaluate in a non-biased and confidential way. By this principle, they should dispel the articles they analyze after the evaluation process and use them after publication. Nationality, gender, religious belief, political belief, and commercial concerns should not corrupt the evaluation's neutrality.
• When referees understand a conflict of interest-unity of interest, they should not evaluate the article and inform the editors.
• Referees should evaluate in alliance with academic etiquette, using constructive language, and avoid personal commentaries involving defamation and enmity.
• Referees should evaluate the article that they accepted to evaluate within the given time.
The Ethical Responsibilities of the Authors
The ethical responsibilities of the author(s) that submitted an article to The Journal of Ottoman Civilization Studies:
• Author(s) should not submit an article that they published or submitted to be published in another place; they should not submit more than one article of their own at the same time to The Journal of Ottoman Civilization Studies.
• Author(s) should submit authentic articles to The Journal of Ottoman Civilization Studies.
• Author(s) should attribute (reference) to the resources that they benefitted from the article while writing it correctly and in alliance with the ethical principles.
• Authors who did the article should not be listed, and the processes of changing them, omitting an author, and supplementing an author's position should not be suggested in a not contribute ted.
• They should inform the editors about the people with conflicts of interest or unity of interest in an article submitted for publication.
• If information or crude data is requested from the author(s) related to their articles during the evaluation process, they should present the expected information to the Editors.
• Author(s) should document the verification of the right of use of the data they used in their articles, the allowances related to research analysis, or the confirmation of the participants they researched.
• Author(s) should communicate with the editor when they realize an error in the evaluation or early appearance or their article published in a digital setting article that is in the process of informing, correcting, or retracting.
• The author(s) should obtain the ethics committee approval for studies that require data collection through quantitative or qualitative methods such as experiments, questionnaires, scales, interviews, observations, and focus group studies, which require an ethics committee decision; ethics committee name, decision date, and number should be stated on the first and last page of the article and in the method section, and the document showing the ethics committee decision should be uploaded to the system with the application of the article. In addition, the article should include information about obtaining the informed approval/consent form in the case reports.
• The author(s) should present evidence within the article related to their being attentive to the ethical principles in the data gathering process (for example, getting approval from someone to use their documents such as scale, survey, and photograph). The article should state that it is in alliance with the regulation of research and publication ethics and copyright of intellectual and art products. If the research is conducted on human or animal subjects, it should be informed that it is performed in the alliance international notices and guides, etc.
• The ethical council approval is not requested from the author(s) for compilation articles. With that, in the articles that do not require an ethical council decision, the situation of the non-requested ethical council decision should also be included on the journal's first page and in the methods section.
Informing the Editor of the Situation That is Not Complying with the Ethical Principles
In The Journal of Ottoman Civilization Studies, unethical behavior that is related to the editors, referees, and authors or in the case of encountering a non-ethical situation relating to an article that is in the process of evaluation, early appearance stage, or a published one, its intimation to the ijoses@hotmail.com address through a message will enrich our publication quality.
The resources that are used in the process of preparation and the adaptation of the policies:
Budapeşte Açık Erişim Bildirgesi
ICMJE (International Committee Of Medical Journal Editors)
Creative Commons
COPE (Committee on Publication Ethics)
DOAJ Principles Of Transparency And Best Practice In Scholarly Publishing
YÖK Bilimsel Araştırma ve Yayın Etiği Yönergesi
P.S.: While the Publication Policies (Publication Ethical Principles) of The Journal of Ottoman Civilization Studies were in preparation, it benefitted from the Ankara University Faculty of the Educational Sciences' publication processes page regarding content and form. See https://dergipark.org.tr/tr/pub/auebfd/policy
Price Policy
The Journal of Ottoman Civilisation Studies charges a fee at the publication stage under Article 20 of the Interuniversity Board [ÜAK] Associate Professorship Criteria Frequently Asked Questions.
Note 1: Do not deposit the fee until you receive an e-mail from the journal secretariat or publisher. For the articles whose preliminary review is completed, the journal secretariat or publisher will be informed separately about the fee.
Note 2: Fee receipts deposited after the notification should be sent to osmed@idealkultur.com and osmanlimedeniyeti@hotmail.com.
Indexes
SCOPUS, TÜBİTAK/ULAKBİM TR DİZİN [SBVT]
INDEX COPERNİCUS [ICI], ISAM, SOBIAD and Scilit.
Unless otherwise stated, the articles published in our magazine are licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0) license. All authors and translators who submit texts for publication in the journal are expected to be the sole copyright holders of the submitted text or to have obtained the necessary permissions. By submitting texts to the journal, authors and translators implicitly accept that these texts will be licensed under CC BY 4.0 unless explicitly stated otherwise to the editors at the outset.