Topics to be Considered in the Evaluation

1. Is the subject of the article suitable for the scope of the journal?

2. If the manuscript is a research article, is it up-to-date and original?

3. If the manuscript is a review article, is it up-to-date and innovative?

4. Is the purpose of the study clear? Are the results and interpretations consistent with the purpose and sufficiently supported by the data?

5. Is the manuscript title in line with the essence of the study?

6. Does the abstract of the study include the purpose, method of the study, and the results obtained?

7. What is the contribution of the work to science and/or practice?

8. Is expression sufficient in the manuscript?

9. Are most of the references not older than 10 years and relevant?

10. Are figures and tables written appropriately?