Critical Thinking Skills and Dispositions of Turkish Pre-service Teachers: A Systematic Review of Research

Yıl 2022, Cilt: 15 Sayı: 3, 561 - 604, 31.07.2022

Özlem Yıldırım Taştı , Ali Yıldırım

https://doi.org/10.30831/akukeg.1062721

Cited By: 2

Öz

The purpose of this paper is to analyze the research literature on Turkish pre-service teachers’ critical thinking skills (CTS) and critical thinking dispositions (CTD) to identify the major knowledge claims and areas of further research. In this systematic review study, we examined both quantitative and qualitative studies conducted between 2010-2020 years in Turkey. The educational research regarding Turkish pre-service teachers’ CTS and CTD was investigated in electronic national and international databases including ERIC and TR Dizin. Considering our inclusion criteria, we included 88 studies in our review. Firstly, we completed descriptive analysis of the selected studies. Then, we analyzed their content. The descriptive analysis showed that quantitative research designs dominate the field. These studies report low-level of CTS of the participants. On the other hand, we presented our thematic analysis under two main themes: traditional perspectives and critical perspectives. We conclude that in the realm of traditional approaches, a few studies adopt a critical stand. Such a perspective, we argue, downgrades CT into a set of generic skills and neglects contextual and individual differences. It further diverges pre-service teachers from their roles as critical educators who actively participate in transformation of their society.

Anahtar Kelimeler

critical teachers, critical thinking, pre-service teachers, systematic review, Turkey.

Kaynakça

• Abrami, P. C., Bernard, R. M., Borokhovski, E., Wade, A., Surkes, M. A., Tamim, R., & Zhang, D. (2008). Instructional interventions affecting critical thinking skills and dispositions: A stage 1 meta-analysis. Review of Educational Research, 78(4), 1102-1134.
• Apple, M. W. (1993). What post‐modernists forget: cultural capital and official knowledge. Curriculum Studies, 1(3), 301-316.
• Apple, M. W. (2001). Markets, standards, teaching, and teacher education. Journal of Teacher Education, 52(3), 182-196.
• Apple, M. & Beane, J. (2007). Democratic schools: Lessons in powerful education (2nd ed.). Heineman.
• Arksey, H. & O'Malley, L. (2005). Scoping studies: towards a methodological framework. International Journal of Social Research Methodology, 8(1), 19-32.
• Aronowitz, S. & Giroux, H. A. (2003). Education under siege: The conservative, liberal and radical debate over schooling. Routledge.
• Atkinson, D. (1997). A critical approach to critical thinking in TESOL. TESOL Quarterly, 31, 71–94.
• Au, W. (2009). Social studies, social justice: W(h)ither the social studies in high-stakes testing? Teacher Education Quarterly, 36(1), 43-58.
• Auerbach, E. R. & Paxton, D. (1997). “It's not the English thing”: bringing reading research into the ESL classroom. Tesol Quarterly, 31(2), 237-261.
• Bailin, S., Case, R., Coombs, J. R., & Daniels, L. B. (1999). Conceptualizing critical thinking. Journal of Curriculum Studies, 31(3), 285-302.
• Bailin, S. & Siegel, H. (2003). Critical thinking. In Blake, N., Smeyers, P., Smith, R., & Standish, P. (eds), The Blackwell Guide to the Philosophy of Education (pp. 181–193). Blackwell.
• Baloche, L., Mauger, M. L., Willis, T. M., Filinuk, J. R., & Michalsky, B. V. (1993). Fishbowls, creative controversy, talking chips: exploring literature cooperatively. The English Journal, 82, 43–49.
• Barnett, R. (1997). Higher education: A critical business. McGraw-Hill Education.
• Belenky, M. F., Clinchy, B. M., Goldberger, N. R., & Tarule, J. M. (1986). Women's ways of knowing: The development of self, voice, and mind (Vol. 15). Basic books.
• Bernstein, B. (2003). Class, codes and control: Applied studies towards a sociology of language (Vol. 2). Psychology Press.
• Bonk, C. J. & Smith, G. S. (1998). Alternative instructional strategies for creative and critical thinking in the accounting curriculum. Journal of Accounting Education, 16(2), 261–293.
• Bourdieu, P. (1986). The forms of capital. Cultural theory: An anthology, 1, 81-93.
• Burbules, N. C. & Berk, R. (1999). Critical thinking and critical pedagogy: relations, differences, and limits. In T. S. Popkewitz, & L. Fendler (Eds.), Critical theories in education (pp. 45–65). Routledge.
• Casner-Lotto, J. & Barrington, L. (2006). Are they really ready to work? Employers' perspectives on the basic knowledge and applied skills of new entrants to the 21st century US workforce. Partnership for 21st Century Skills. 1 Massachusetts Avenue NW Suite 700, Washington, DC 20001.
• Council of Europe. (2018). Reference framework for democratic culture: Vol. 1. Contexts, concepts and model. Council of Europe Publishing.
• Cross, D. R. & Paris, S. G. (1988). Developmental and instructional analyses of children's metacognition and reading comprehension. Journal of Educational Psychology, 80(2), 131.
• Cüceloğlu, D. (1997). İyi düşün doğru karar ver. Sistem Yayıncılık.
• Çansoy, R., Parlar, H., & Polatçan, M. (2018). Teacher candidates' critical thinking tendencies research in turkey: a content analysis. Universal Journal of Educational Research, 6(9), 1974-1980.
• Danvers, E. (2018). Who is the critical thinker in higher education? A feminist re-thinking. Teaching in Higher Education, 23(5), 548-562.
• Davidson, B. (1994). Critical thinking: A perspective and prescriptions for language teachers. The Language Teacher, 18(4), 20-26.
• Davies, M. (2011). Introduction to the special issue on critical thinking in higher education. Higher Education Research & Development, 30(3), 255-260.
• Davies, M. & Barnett, R. (Eds.). (2015). The Palgrave handbook of critical thinking in higher education. Springer.
• Daud, N. M. & Husin, Z. (2004). Developing critical thinking skills in computer‐aided extended reading classes. British Journal of Educational Technology, 35(4), 477-487.
• Dennick, R. G. & Exley, K. (1998). Teaching and learning in groups and teams. Biochemical Education, 26(2), 111- 115.
• Dixon-Woods, M. (2011). Systematic reviews and qualitative methods. In D. Silverman (Ed.), Qualitative research (pp. 331-346). Sage.
• Dixon-Woods, M., Agarwal, S., Jones, D., Young, B., & Sutton, A. (2005). Synthesising qualitative and quantitative evidence: a review of possible methods. Journal of Health Services Research & Policy, 10(1), 45-53.
• Doğanay, A., Taş, M. A., & Erden, Ş. (2007). Üniversite öğrencilerinin bir güncel tartışmalı konu bağlamında eleştirel düşünme becerilerinin değerlendirilmesi [Assessing university students’ critical thinking skills in the context of a current controversial issue]. Educational Administration: Theory and Practice, 52(52), 511-546.
• Doğanay, A. & Yağcı, R. (2011). İlköğretim beşinci sinif sosyal bilgiler öğretiminde öğretmenlerin eleştirel düşünme becerilerini geliştirmek için uyguladiklari etkinliklerin değerlendirilmesi [Evaluating activities which are performed by teachers in teaching social studies to the fifth grade students to improve their criticial thinking skills]. Education Sciences, 6(2), 1679-1702.
• Ennis, R.H. (1963). Needed: Research in critical thinking. Educational Leadership, 21(1), 17-20.
• Ennis, R.H. (1985). A logical basis for measuring critical thinking skills. Educational Leadership, 43(2), 44–48.
• Ennis, R.H. (1987). A taxonomy of critical thinking dispositions and abilities. In J. B. Baron, & R. J. Sternberg (Eds.), Teaching thinking skills (pp. 9–26). Freeman.
• Ennis, R.H. (1989). Critical thinking and subject specificity: Clarification and needed research. Educational Researcher, 18(3), 4–10.
• Ennis, R.H. (1991). Critical thinking: A streamlined conception. Teaching Philosophy, 14(1), 5-25.
• Ennis, R.H. (2011). Critical thinking: Reflection and perspective Part II. Inquiry: Critical Thinking Across the Disciplines, 26(2), 5-19.
• Ennis, R.H. (2013). Critical Thinking across the curriculum: the wisdom CTAC program.Inquiry: Critical Thinking Across the Disciplines, 28(2), 25–52.
• Ennis, R.H. (2015). Critical thinking: A streamlined conception. In The Palgrave handbook of critical thinking in higher education (pp. 31-47). Palgrave Macmillan.
• European Commission (2013). Supporting teacher competence development for better learning outcomes. Publications Office of the European Union.
• Evans, R.W. (2008). The (unfulfilled) promise of critical pedagogy. Journal of Social Studies Research, 32(2), 16–25.
• Facione, P. (1990). Critical thinking: a statement of expert consensus for purposes of educational assessment and ınstruction. Research findings and recommendations. The Delphi Report.
• Facione, P.A. (2000). The disposition toward critical thinking: Its character, measurement, and relation to critical thinking skill. Informal Logic, 20(1), 61–84.
• Facione, P.A., Giancarlo (Sánchez), C., Facione, N., & Gainen (Kurfiss), J. (1995). The disposition toward critical thinking. Journal of General Education, 44 (1), 1-25.
• Facione, P.A., Facione, N.C., & Giancarlo, C.A. (1996). The California critical thinking disposition inventory test manual. California Academic Press.
• Facione, P.A., Facione, N.C., & Giancarlo, C.A. (2000). The disposition toward critical thinking: its character, measurement, and relationship to critical thinking skill. Informal Logic, 20(1), 61-84.
• Farber, K.S. (1991). Feminist criticism and the reconceptualization of critical thinking. Journal of Thought, 74-81.
• Fernandez-Balboa, J.M. (1993). Critical pedagogy: Making critical thinking really critical. Analytic Teaching, 13(2), 61-72.
• Fisher, A. & Scriven, M. (1997). Critical thinking: Its definition and assessment. Edgepress.
• Freire, P. (2005). Pedagogy of the oppressed (M. Bergman-Ramos, & D. Macedo, Trans.). Continuum.
• Gashan, A.K. (2015). Exploring Saudi pre-service teachers' knowledge of critical thinking skills and their teaching perceptions. International Journal of Education and Literacy Studies, 3(1), 26-33.
• Giroux, H.A. (1985). Critical pedagogy, cultural politics, and the discourse of experience. Journal of Education, 167(2), 22-41.
• Giroux, H.A. (1988). Teachers as intellectuals: Toward a critical pedagogy of learning. Bergin Garvey.
• Giroux, H.A. (2004). Cultural studies, public pedagogy, and the responsibility of intellectuals. Communication and Critical/Cultural Studies, 1(1), 59-79.
• Giroux, H.A. (2018). Teachers as transformative intellectuals. In Thinking about schools (pp. 183-189). Routledge.
• Gök, B., & Erdoğan, T. (2011). Sınıf öğretmeni adaylarının yaratıcı düşünme düzeyleri ve eleştirel düşünme eğilimlerinin incelenmesi [The investigation of the creative thinking levels and the critical thinking disposition of pre-service elementary teachers]. Journal of Faculty of Educational Sciences, 44(2).
• Halpern, D.F. (1998). Teaching critical thinking for transfer across domains: Dispositions, skills, structure training, and metacognitive monitoring. American Psychologist, 53(4), 449–455.
• Halpern, D.F. (1999). Teaching for critical thinking: Helping college students develop the skills and dispositions of a critical thinker. New Directions for Teaching and Learning, 80, 69-74.
• Halpern, D.F. (2001). Assessing the effectiveness of critical thinking instruction. The Journal of General Education, 50(4), 270-286.
• Harden, A. & Thomas, J. (2005). Methodological issues in combining diverse study types in systematic reviews. International Journal of Social Research Methodology, 8(3), 257-271.
• Heath, S.B. (1983). Ways with words: Language, life and work in communities and classrooms. Cambridge UniversityPress.
• Hennessey, M.G. (1999). Probing the dimensions of metacognition: Implications for conceptual change teaching-learning. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the National Association for Research in Science Teaching, Boston, MA.
• İşlek, D. & Hürsen, Ç. (2014). Evaluation of critical thinking studies in terms of content analysis. Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences, 131, 290-299.
• Kaplan, L.D. (1991). Teaching intellectual autonomy: The failure of the critical thinking movement. Educational Theory, 41(4), 361-370.
• Kennedy, M., Fisher, M. B., & Ennis, R. H. (1991). Critical thinking: Literature review and needed research. In L. Idol & B.F. Jones (Eds.), Educational values and cognitive instruction: Implications for reform (pp. 11-40). Lawrence Erlbaum & Associates.
• Keser, F., Akar, H., & Yildirim, A. (2011). The role of extracurricular activities in active citizenship education. Journal of Curriculum Studies, 43(6), 809-837.
• Kim, J. H. & Taylor, K. A. (2008). Rethinking alternative education to break the cycle of educational inequality and inequity. The Journal of Educational Research, 101(4), 207-219.
• Kirk, D. (1986). Beyond the limits of theoretical discourse in teacher education: Towards a critical pedagogy. Teaching and Teacher Education, 2(2), 155-167.
• Kong, S. L. (2001, December). Critical thinking dispositions of pre-service teachers in Singapore: A preliminary investigation. Paper presented at the AARE Conference, Fremantle, Australia.
• Kuhn, D. (1986). Education for thinking. Teachers College Record, 87(4), 495-512.
• Kuhn, D. (1999). A developmental model of critical thinking. Educational Researcher, 28(2), 16-46.
• Kuhn, D. & Dean, Jr, D. (2004). Metacognition: A bridge between cognitive psychology and educational practice. Theory into Practice, 43(4), 268-273.
• Lai, E.R. (2011). Critical thinking: A literature review. Pearson's Research Reports, 6(1), 40-41.
• Lee, V.E. & Burkam, D.T. (2002). Inequality at the starting gate: Social background differences in achievement as children begin school. Economic Policy Institute, 1660 L Street, NW, Suite 1200, Washington, DC 20036.
• Lewis, A. & Smith, D. (1993). Defining higher-order thinking. Theory into Practice, 32(3), 131-137.
• Lipman, M. (1988). Critical thinking—What can it be? Educational Leadership, 46(1), 38–43.
• Liu, O. L., Frankel, L., & Roohr, K. C. (2014). Assessing critical thinking in higher education: Current state and directions for next‐generation assessment. ETS Research Report Series, 2014(1), 1-23.
• McLaren, P. & Hammer, R. (1989). Critical pedagogy and the postmodern challenge: Toward a critical postmodernist pedagogy of liberation. Educational Foundations, 3(3), 29-62.
• McPeck, J.E. (1990). Critical thinking and subject specificity: A reply to Ennis. Educational Researcher, 19(4), 10–12.
• Miles, M.B., Huberman, A. M., & Saldaña, J. (2014). Qualitative data analysis. A methods sourcebook (3rd ed.). Sage.
• Ministry of National Education (1973). Law of national education. Available online at https://www.mevzuat.gov.tr/MevzuatMetin/1.5.1739.pdf
• Moore, T.J. (2011). Critical thinking and disciplinary thinking: A continuing debate. Higher Education Research & Development, 30(3), 261-274.
• Moss, P.A. & Koziol Jr, S. M. (1991). Investigating the validity of a locally developed critical thinking test. Educational Measurement: Issues and Practice, 10(3), 17-22.
• Okoli, C. & Schabram, K. (2010). A guide to conducting a systematic literature review of information systems research. Sprouts: Working Papers on Information Systems, 10(26), 1-50.
• Özdemir, S.M. (2005). Üniversite öğrencilerinin eleştirel düşünme becerilerinin çeşitli değişkenler açisindan değerlendirilmesi [Assessing university students’ critical thinking skills for some variables]. The Journal of Turkish Educational Sciences, 3(3), 297-316.
• Paul, R.W. (1992). Critical thinking: What, why, and how? New Directions for Community Colleges, 77, 3–24.
• Paul, R.W. (1994). Teaching critical thinking in the strong sense. In Kerry S. Walters (ed), Re-thinking reason: New perspectives in critical thinking (pp. 181-198). SUNY Press.
• Paul, R.W. & Binker, A.J.A. (1990). Critical thinking: What every person needs to survive in a rapidly changing world. Center for Critical Thinking and Moral Critique.
• Paul, R.W. & Elder, L. (2006). Critical thinking: The nature of critical and creative thought. Journal of Developmental Education, 30(2), 34–35.
• Paul, R., Elder, L., & Bartell, T. (1997). California teacher preparation for instruction in critical thinking: Research findings and policy recommendations. ERIC Document #437 379.
• Peters, M.D.J., Godfrey, C.M.RN., Khalil, H.B.M., McInerney, P., Parker, D., & Soares, C.B. (2015). Guidance for conducting systematic scoping reviews. International Journal of Evidence-Based Healthcare, 13(3), 141–146.
• Pithers, R.T. & Soden, R. (2000) Critical thinking in education: a review. Educational Research. 42(3), 237-249.
• Raths, I.E., Wasserman, S., Jonas, A., & Rothstein, A. (1966). Teaching for critical thinking: theory and application. Charles-Merrill.
• Rudd, R. D. (2007) Defining critical thinking. Techniques, October, 46–47.
• Scriven, M. & Paul, R. (1987). Defining critical thinking. The 8th Annual International Conference on Critical Thinking and Education Reform, Summer. Retrieved from http://www.criticalthinking.org/pages/defining-critical-thinking/766, on the 3rd of January, 2021.
• Seferoğlu, S.S., & Akbiyik, C. (2006). Eleştirel düşünme ve öğretimi [Teaching critical thinking]. Hacettepe University Journal of Education, 30(30), 193-200.
• Semerci, N. (2000). Kritik düşünme ölçeği [Critical thinking scale]. Education and Science, 25(116).
• Severiens, S. & ten Dam, G. (1998). Gender and learning: comparing two theories. Higher Education, 35, 329–350.
• Sibbett, L.A. (2016). Toward a transformative criticality for democratic citizenship education. Democracy and Education, 24(2), Article 1.
• Siegel, H. (1999). What (good) are thinking dispositions?. Educational Theory, 49(2), 207-221.
• Sternberg, R.J. (1986). Critical thinking: Its nature, measurement, and improvement National Institute of Education. Retrieved from http://eric.ed.gov/PDFS/ED272882.pdf.
• Sternberg, R.J. (1987). Teaching critical thinking: eight ways to fail before you begin. Phi Delta Kappan, 68(6), 456–459.
• ten Dam, G. & Volman, M. (2004). Critical thinking as a citizenship competence: Teaching strategies. Learning and Instruction, 14(4), 359-379.
• Thayer-Bacon, B.J. (2000). Transforming critical thinking: Thinking constructively. Teachers College Press.
• Twale, D. & Sanders, C.S. (1999). Impact of non-classroom experiences on critical thinking ability. Naspa Journal, 36(2), 133-146.
• Üredi, L., & Kösece, P. (2020). Investigating the relationship between critical thinking skills and mathematical problem solving achievements of secondary education students. European Journal of Educational Sciences, 7(2), 186-202.
• Wheary, J. & Ennis, R. H. (1995). Gender bias in critical thinking: Continuing the dialogue. Educational Theory, 45(2), 213-224.
• Willingham, D.T. (2008). Critical thinking: Why is it so hard to teach?. Arts Education Policy Review, 109(4), 21-32.
• Xiao, Y. & Watson, M. (2019). Guidance on conducting a systematic literature review. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 39(1), 93-112.
• Yildirim, A. (2013). Teacher education research in Turkey: Trends, issues and priority areas. Education and Science, 38(169), 175-191.
• Yücel-Toy, B. & Ok, A. (2012). Incorporating critical thinking in the pedagogical content of a teacher education programme: does it make a difference? European Journal of Teacher Education, 35(1), 39-56.
• 1Açışlı, S. (2015). Investigation of teacher candidates' learning styles and critical thinking dispositions. Necatibey Faculty of Education Electronic Journal of Science & Mathematics Education, 9(1), 23-48.
• 2Açışlı, S. (2016). Investigation of class teacher candidates' learning styles and critical thinking dispositions. Elementary Education Online, 15(1), 273-285.
• 3Akar, C. (2017). The predictive level of preservice classroom teachers' multicultural values of critical thinking disposition. Ahi Evran Üniversitesi Kırşehir Eğitim Fakültesi Dergisi (KEFAD), 18(1), 741-762.
• 4Akçalı, A. (2019). An action research for developing critical thinking skills of history teacher candidates. Kastamonu Education Journal, 27(1), 231-246.
• 5Akgün, A. & Duruk, U. (2016). The Investigation of Preservice Science Teachers' Critical Thinking Dispositions in the Context of Personal and Social Factors. Science Education International, 27(1), 3-15.
• 6Akyüz, H. İ., Samsa Yetik, S., & Keser, H. (2015). Effects of metacognitive guidance on critical thinking disposition. Online Submission, 5(2), 133-148.
• 7Alkın-Şahin, S., Tunca, N., & Ulubey, Ö. (2014). The relationship between pre-service teachers’ educational beliefs and their critical thinking tendencies. Elementary Education Online, 13(4), 1473-1492.
• 8Alper, A. (2010). Critical thinking disposition of pre-service teachers. Education and Science, 35(158), 14-27.
• 9Arsal, Z. (2015). The effects of microteaching on the critical thinking dispositions of pre-service teachers. Australian Journal of Teacher Education (Online), 40(3), 140-153.
• 10Arslangilay, A. S. (2019). 21st century skills of CEIT teacher candidates and the prominence of these skills in the CEIT undergraduate curriculum. Educational Policy Analysis and Strategic Research, 14(3), 330-346.
• 11Aşkın Tekkol, İ. & Bozdemir, H. (2018). An investigation of reflective thinking tendencies and critical thinking skills of teacher candidates. Kastamonu Education Journal 26(6), 1897-1907.
• 12Aybek, B. & Aslan, S. (2017). An investigation of educational philosophies adopted and critical thinking disposition in terms of varios variables. Gaziantep University Journal of Social Sciences, 16(2), 373-385.
• 13Aybek, B. (2018). An examination of the relationship between the critical thinking dispositions of prospective teachers and their attitudes toward multicultural education. Journal of Higher Education (Turkey), 8(3), 282-292.
• 14Aybek, B. (2007). Konu ve beceri temelli eleştirel düşünme öğretiminin öğretmen adaylarının eleştirel düşünme eğilimi ve düzeyine etkisi [The effect of content-based and skill-based critical thinking teaching on prospective teachers’ critical thinking dispositions and level]. Çukurova Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Enstitüsü Dergisi, 16(2), 43-60.
• 15Bağcı, H. & Şahbaz, N. (2012). Türkçe öğretmeni adaylarının eleştirel düşünme becerileri üzerine bir değerlendirme [An analysis of the turkish teacher candidates' critical thinking skills]. Mersin Üniversitesi Eğitim Fakültesi Dergisi, 8(1), 1-12.
• 16Barin, M. (2019). Pre-service teachers' attitudes towards English courses and their critical thinking skills. World Journal of Education, 9(2), 46-55.
• 17Bayram, D., Kurt, G., & Atay, D. (2019). The implementation of webquest-supported critical thinking ınstruction in pre-service English teacher education: the Turkish context. Participatory Educational Research, 6(2), 144-157.
• 18Beşoluk, Ş. & Önder, İ. (2010). Investigation of teacher candidates' learning approaches, learning styles and critical thinking dispositions. Elementary Education Online, 9(2).
• 19Bulgurcuoglu, A. N. (2016). Relationship between critical thinking levels and attitudes towards reading habits among pre-service physical education teachers. Educational Research and Reviews, 11(8), 708-712.
• 20Bulut, R. & Ocak, G. (2017). Eleştirel düşünme eğilimi ile öğrenme stratejileri arasındaki ilişkinin incelenmesi [An investigation of the relationship between critical thinking disposition and learning strategies]. Ahi Evran Üniversitesi Kırşehir Eğitim Fakültesi Dergisi , 18 (3) , 1010-1031.
• 21Çakmak Güleç, H. (2010). Evaluation of prospective primary and pre-school teachers' critical thinking level. Education and Science, 35(157), 3-14.
• 22 Çekin, A. (2013). Din kültürü ve ahlak bilgisi öğretmen adaylarının eleştirel düşünme becerilerinin bazı değişkenler açısından incelenmesi [The examination of critical thinking skills of religious culture and ethics teacher candidates ın terms of some variables]. Amasya Üniversitesi İlahiyat Fakültesi Dergisi, (1), 25-46.
• 23 Çelik, Ö., Çokçaliskan, H., & Yorulmaz, A. (2018). Investigation of the effect of pre-service classroom teachers' critical thinking disposition on their media literacy. International Journal of Evaluation and Research in Education, 7(3), 194-202.
• 24 Certel, Z., Çatıkkaş, F., & Yalçınkaya, M. (2011). Beden eğitimi öğretmen adaylarının duygusal zekâ ile eleştirel düşünme eğilimlerinin incelenmesi [Analysis of the emotional ıntelligence levels and critical thinking dispositions of physical education teacher candidates] Selçuk Üniversitesi Beden Eğitimi Ve Spor Bilim Dergisi, 13(1), 74-81.
• 25 Çetinkaya, Z. (2011). Türkçe öğretmen adaylarinin eleştirel düşünmeye ilişkin görüşlerinin belirlenmesi [Determination of Turkish education teacher candidates’ views related to critical thinking]. Ahi Evran Üniversitesi Kırşehir Eğitim Fakültesi Dergisi, 12(3), 93-108.
• 26 Çinici, A. & Ergin, B. (2019). The effects of discussion and decision-making based activities concerning GMOs on critical thinking dispositions of teacher candidates. Necatibey Faculty of Education Electronic Journal of Science & Mathematics Education, 13(2), 735-758.
• 27 Coşkun, M. (2013). Din kültürü ve ahlak bilgisi öğretmen adaylarının eleştirel düşünme eğilimleri (ilahiyat-eğitim dkab karşılaştırması [Critical thinking level and dispositions of pre-service teachers of religious culture and ethics knowledge]. Atatürk Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Enstitüsü Dergisi, 17(1), 143-162.
• 28Demir, S. (2015). Evaluation of critical thinking and reflective thinking skills among science teacher candidates. Journal of Education and Practice, 6(18), 17-21.
• 29Demir, S. (2015). Perspectives of science teacher candidates regarding scientific creativity and critical thinking. Journal of Education and Practice, 6(17), 157-159.
• 30Demirbag, B., Unisen, A., & Yesilyurt, A. (2016). Training of critical thinking skills in teacher candidates and placebo effect: A quasi-experimental study. Eurasian Journal of Educational Research, 63, 375-392.
• 31 Deringöl, Y. (2017). Öğretmen adaylarının eleştirel düşünme standartlarının belirlenmesi [Determining critical thinking standards of teacher candidates]. Igdir University Journal of Social Sciences, (13).
• 32 Dinçer, B., Yavuz, A., & Eren, S. (2019). Rehberlik ve psikolojik danışmanlık bölümü öğrencilerinin sosyal değer algıları ve eleştirel düşünme standartları arasındaki ilişkinin incelenmesi [investigation of the relationship between the social values perception and critical thinking standards from the guidance and psychological counseling department students.] Uluslararası Türkçe Edebiyat Kültür Eğitim (TEKE) Dergisi, 8(4), 2300-2321.
• 33 Durukan, E. & Maden, S. (2010). Türkçe öğretmeni adaylarının eleştirel düşünme eğilimleri üzerine bir araştırma [A study on the evaluation of Turkish pre-service teachers’ critical thinking tendency]. Dumlupınar Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Dergisi, 1(28), 25-33.
• 34 Ekinci, Ö. & Aybek, B. (2010). Analysis of the empathy and the critical thinking disposition of the teacher candidates. Elementary Education Online, 9(2), 816-827.
• 35 Erdoğan, F. (2020). The relationship between prospective middle school mathematics teachers’ critical thinking skills and reflective thinking skills. Participatory Educational Research, 7(1), 220-241.
• 36Erdoğan, İ. (2015). Din kültürü ve ahlak bilgisi öğretmen adaylarının eleştirel düşünme eğilim düzeylerinin incelenmesi [The examining of critical thinking dispositions of religious culture and ethics teacher candidates.] Marife Dini Araştırmalar Dergisi, 15(2), 321-342.
• 37Erişti, B. & Erdem, C. (2018). Öğretmen adaylarinin medya okuryazarliği beceri düzeyleri ile eleştirel düşünme eğilimleri arasindaki ilişki [The relationship between prospective teachers’ levels of media literacy skills and critical thinking dispositions]. Elektronik Sosyal Bilimler Dergisi, 17(67), 1234-1251.
• 38Fettahlıoğlu, P. & Kaleci, D. (2018). Online argumentation ımplementation in the development of critical thinking disposition. Journal of Education and Training Studies, 6(3), 127-136.
• 39Geçit, Y. & Akarsu, A. H. (2017). Critical thinking tendencies of geography teacher candidates in Turkey. Universal Journal of Educational Research, 5(8), 1362-1371.
• 40Genç, G. (2017). The relationship between academic achievement, reading habits and critical thinking dispositions of Turkish tertiary level EFL learners. Educational Research Quarterly, 41(2), 43-73.
• 41Gökkuş, İ. & Delican, B. (2016). Sınıf öğretmeni adaylarının eleştirel düşünme eğilimleri ve okuma alışkanlığına ilişkin tutumları [Critical thinking tendencies and attitudes toward reading habits of pre-service classroom teachers]. Cumhuriyet Uluslararası Eğitim Dergisi, 5(1), 10-28.
• 42Gül, M. D. & Akçay, H. (2020). Structuring a new socioscientific issues (SSI) based instruction model: impacts on pre-service science teachers' (PSTs) critical thinking skills and dispositions. International Journal of Research in Education and Science, 6(1), 141-159.
• 43 Hayırsever, F. & Oğuz, E. (2017). Öğretmen adaylarının eğitim inançlarının eleştirel düşünme eğilimlerine etkisi [Effects of teacher candidates’ educational beliefs on their critical thinking tendencies]. Abant İzzet Baysal Üniversitesi Eğitim Fakültesi Dergisi, 17(2), 757-778.
• 44 Ekici, D. İ. (2017). The effects of online communities of practice on pre-service teachers’ critical thinking dispositions. Eurasia Journal of Mathematics, Science and Technology Education, 13(7), 3801-3827.
• 45Kandemir, M. A. (2017). Sınıf ve ilköğretim matematik öğretmen adaylarının eleştirel düşünme eğilim düzeylerinin bazı değişkenlere göre incelenmesi [Investigation of critical thinking tendency levels of classroom and elementary mathematics teacher candidates in terms of some variables]. International Periodical for the Languages, Literature and History of Turkish or Turkic, 12(6), 453-474.
• 46 Karademir, Ç. A., & Saracaloğlu, A. S. (2017). Öğretmen adaylarinin sorgulama ve eleştirel düşünme becerilerinin öğretmen öz yeterlik düzeyine etkisi [The effect of pre-service teachers’ inquiry and critical thinking skills on teacher self-efficacy]. International Periodical for the Languages, Literature and History of Turkish or Turkic, 12(33), 261-290.
• 47Karagöl, İ. & Bekmezci, S. (2015). Investigating academic achievements and critical thinking dispositions of teacher candidates. Journal of Education and Training Studies, 3(4), 86-92.
• 48Karaoğlan-Yilmaz, F. G., Yilmaz, R., Üstün, A. B., & Keser, H. (2019). Examination of critical thinking standards and academic self-efficacy of teacher candidates as a predictor of metacognitive thinking skills through structural equation modelling. Journal of Theoretical Educational Science, 12(4), 1239-1256.
• 49Karaoğlan-Yılmaz, F.G. & Yılmaz, R. (2020). The impact of feedback form on transactional distance and critical thinking skills in online discussions. Innovations in Education and Teaching International, 57(1), 119-130.
• 50 Karasakaloğlu, N., Saracaloğlu, S., & Özelçi, S. (2012). Türkçe öğretmeni adaylarinin okuma stratejileri, eleştirel düşünme tutumlari ve üst bilişsel yeterlilikleri [Turkish prospective teachers’ reading strategies, critical thinking attitudes and metacognitive competencies] Ahi Evran Üniversitesi Kırşehir Eğitim Fakültesi Dergisi, 13(1), 207-221.
• 51Kartal, T. (2012). İlköğretim fen bilgisi öğretmen adaylarinin eleştirel düşünme eğilimlerinin incelenmesi [Exploring of dispositions toward critical thinking in pre-service elementary science teachers]. Ahi Evran Üniversitesi Kırşehir Eğitim Fakültesi Dergisi, 13(2), 279-297.
• 52 Kesicioglu, O. S. & Deniz, U. (2014). Investigation of pre-school children's perception of teacher in their drawings. Online Submission, 5, 606-613.
• 53Kilic, I., Yazici, T., & Topalak, S. I. (2017). Critical thinking disposition of music teachers. Eurasian Journal of Educational Research, 17(72), 185-202.
• 54Kizilet, A. (2017). Investigation of Critical Thinking Attitudes and Reading Habits of Teacher Candidates. Educational Research and Reviews, 12(6), 323-328.
• 55Koçak Macun, B., Kurtlu, Y., Ulaş, A. H., & Epçaçan, C. (2015). Sinif öğretmeni adaylarinin eleştirel düşünme düzeyleri ve okumaya yönelik tutumlari arasindaki ilişki [Examining of the elementary class teachers' critical thinking levels and their attitudes towards reading]. Ekev Akademi Dergisi, (61), 211-228.
• 56 Kozikoglu, İ. (2019). Investigating critical thinking in prospective teachers: metacognitive skills, problem solving skills and academic self-efficacy. Journal of Social Studies Education Research, 10(2), 111-130.
• 57Küçükoğlu, A. & Koçyiğit, S. (2015). The effectiveness of community service-learning in teacher training. Eğitimde Kuram ve Uygulama, 11(2), 610-629.
• 58Kutluca, A. Y., Yılmaz, A., &. İbiş, E. (2018). Öğretmen adaylarının eleştirel düşünme tutumlarının çeşitli değişkenler açısından incelenmesi [Examination of teacher candidates’ critical thinking attitudes in terms of various variables] Kastamonu Eğitim Dergisi, 26(6), 2045-2055.
• 59Mete, D. E. (2020). Fostering critical thinking skills in ELT through video-based reflection. Journal of Language and Linguistic Studies, 16(1), 104-125.
• 60Nalcaci, A. (2012). The relationship between the individual values and critical thinking skills of prospective social sciences teachers. International Journal of Progressive Education, 8(1), 22-34.
• 61Namlı Altıntaş, İ. & Karaaslan, H. (2019). Peer assessment and active learning experiences of social studies teacher candidates. Review of International Geographical Education Online, 9(2), 319-345.
• 62Ocak, G., Eğmir, E., & Ocak, İ. (2016). Öğretmen adaylarının eleştirel düşünme eğilimlerinin çeşitli değişkenler açısından incelenmesi [Investigation of pre service teachers’ critical thinking tendencies in terms of different variables]. Erzincan Üniversitesi Eğitim Fakültesi Dergisi, 18(1), 63-91.
• 63Oguz, A. & Sariçam, H. (2016). The relationship between critical thinking disposition and locus of control in pre-service teachers. Journal of Education and Training Studies, 4(2), 182-192.
• 64Kutlu, M. O. & Schreglmann, S. (2011). Konu temelli eleştirel düşünme öğretiminin öğretmen adaylarinin eleştirel düşünme becerileri üzerine etkisi [The effect of content-based critical thinking program on critical thinking skills]. Journal of the Cukurova University Institute of Social Sciences, 20(1), 165-176.
• 65Özdemir, Y., Buyruk, H., & Güngör, S. (2018). Öğretmen adaylarının eleştirel düşünme eğilimi ile liderlik yönelimleri arasındaki ilişki [The relationship between teacher candidates' critical thinking tendency and leadership orientations]. Mersin Üniversitesi Eğitim Fakültesi Dergisi, 14(2), 548-571.
• 66Özelçi, S.Y. & Çaliskan, G. (2019). What is critical thinking? a longitudinal study with teacher candidates. International Journal of Evaluation and Research in Education, 8(3), 495-509.
• 67 Özen Uyar, R., Genc, M. M. Y., & Yasar, M. (2018). Prospective preschool teachers’ academic achievements depending on their goal orientations, critical thinking dispositions and self-regulation skills. European Journal of Educational Research, 7(3), 601-613.
• 68Özgür, H. (2013). Bilişim teknolojileri öğretmen adaylarının eleştirel düşünme eğilimleri ile bireysel yenilikçilik özellikleri arasındaki ilişkinin çeşitli değişkenler açısından incelenmesi [Exploring of the relationship between critical thinking dispositions and individual innovativeness of ict pre-service teachers in terms of various variables]. Mersin Üniversitesi Eğitim Fakültesi Dergisi, 9(2), 409-420.
• 69 Piji Küçük, D. & Uzun, Y. B. (2013). Müzik öğretmeni adaylarinin eleştirel düşünme eğilimleri [critical thinking tendencies of music teacher candidates]. Ahi Evran Üniversitesi Kırşehir Eğitim Fakültesi Dergisi, 14(1), 327-345.
• 70 Saka, M. (2016). Öğretmen adaylarının çevre etiği yaklaşımlarının yordayıcısı olarak eleştirel düşünme eğilimlerinin incelenmesi [A study of pre service teacher’ critical thinking dispositions as predictors of environmental ethics approaches]. Sakarya University Journal of Education, 6(3), 100-115.
• 71Samanci, N. K. (2015). A study on the link between moral judgment competences and critical thinking skills. International Journal of Environmental and Science Education, 10(2), 135-143.
• 72Semerci, Ç. & Elaldı, Ş. (2014). The roles of metacognitive beliefs in developing critical thinking skills. Bartın University Journal of Faculty of Education, 3(2), 317-333.
• 73Sendag, S., Erol, O., Sezgin, S., & Dulkadir, N. (2015). Preservice teachers’ critical thinking dispositions and web 2.0 competencies. Contemporary Educational Technology, 6(3), 172-187.
• 74Serin, O. (2013). The critical thinking skills of teacher candidates Turkish republic of Northern Cyprus sampling. Eurasian Journal of Educational Research, 53, 231-248.
• 75Tok, E. & Sevinç, M. (2010). Düşünme becerileri eğitiminin eleştirel düşünme ve problem çözme becerilerine etkisi [The effects of thinking skills education on the critical thinking and problem solving skills of preschool teacher candidates]. Pamukkale Üniversitesi Eğitim Fakültesi Dergisi, 27(27), 67-82.
• 76Topoğlu, O. & Ünal Öney, E. (2013). Eğitim fakültesi güzel sanatlar eğitimi bölümü öğrencilerinin eleştirel düşünme eğilimlerinin çeşitli değişkenlerle ilişkisinin incelenmesi [Investigation of the relationship between critical thinking dispositions and miscellaneous variables of the students of the faculty of education the department of fine arts education]. Electronic Turkish Studies, 8(8), 1301-1312.
• 77Tosuncuoglu, I. (2018). English language and literature students' perceptions of critical thinking. International Journal of Higher Education, 7(5), 20-28.
• 78Tümkaya, S. (2011). Fen bilimleri öğrencilerinin eleştirel düşünme eğilimleri ve öğrenme stillerinin incelenmesi [Comparison of college science major students’ learning styles and critical thinking disposition]. Ahi Evran Üniversitesi Kırşehir Eğitim Fakültesi Dergisi, 12(3), 215-234.
• 79Turan, H. (2016). Comparison of critical thinking dispositions of prospective teachers. Educational Research and Reviews, 11(8), 867-876.
• 80Ulger, K. (2018). The effect of problem-based learning on the creative thinking and critical thinking disposition of students in visual arts education. Interdisciplinary Journal of Problem-Based Learning, 12(1), Article 10.
• 81Unlu, Z. K. & Dökme, I. (2017). Science teacher candidates’ epistemological beliefs and critical thinking disposition. Eurasian Journal of Educational Research, 17(72), 203-220.
• 82Uslu, S. (2020). Critical thinking dispositions of social studies teacher candidates. Asian Journal of Education and Training, 6(1), 72-79.
• 83Uzunöz, F. S., İlker, G. E., Arslan, Y., & Demirhan, G. (2018). The effect of different teaching styles on critical thinking and achievement goals of prospective teachers. SPORMETRE Beden Eğitimi ve Spor Bilimleri Dergisi, 16(2), 80-95.
• 84Yenice, N. (2012). Öğretmen adaylarinin öz-yeterlik düzeyleri ile problem çözme becerilerinin incelenmesi [Investigating the self-efficacy and problem solving skills of preservice teachers]. Elektronik Sosyal Bilimler Dergisi, 11(39), 36-58.
• 85Yorgancı, S. (2016). Critical thinking dispositions of pre-service mathematics teachers. Participatory Educational Research, 3(3), 36-46.
• 86Yücel Toy, B. & Ok, A. (2012). Incorporating critical thinking in the pedagogical content of a teacher education programme: does it make a difference? European Journal of Teacher Education, 35(1), 39-56.
• 87Yüksel, G. & Alcı, B. (2012). Self-efficacy and critical thinking dispositions as predictors of success in school practicum. International Online Journal of Educational Sciences, 4(1), 81-90.
• 88Ersoy, E. & Başer, N. (2014). İstatistik ve olasılık dersinin senaryo ile öğretim süreci sonunda öğrencilerin eleştirel düşünme eğilimlerindeki değişim [The alteration in students‟ tendency to critical thinking at the end of the teaching process of “statistics and probability” subject via scenario]. Ondokuz Mayıs Üniversitesi Eğitim Fakültesi Dergisi, 33(1), 207-230.