Revisiting Through Marx Ethnicity, Nationalism and Class Dialectics

Yıl 2022, , 387 - 411, 08.04.2022

Seda Yücel

https://doi.org/10.33629/auhfd.939998

Öz

As the revolutionary wave created by the mass movements of 1848 began
to lose its influence in the Continental Europe, Marx, who took refuge in
England, began the years of exile, which he would spend as a "brilliant, holy,
cursed, but still no wonder, illegal immigrant" throughout his life. This phase of Marx's life as a political immigrant corresponds to a period in which he

formulated brilliant and equally sacred ideas of criticism of political economy,

as well as new discoveries of thought embellished with the facts of ethnicity,
race and nationality, with his increasing interest in non-Western societies.
This study aims to demonstrate Marx's disregarded thoughts, through this
period of his life. In order to do so, we are going to explore from his
manuscripts, journalism works, letters, manifests for S. International and
notebooks. Hence, we are aiming to understand and demonstrate Marx's way
of thinking in a thorough way. Finally, the core objective of this study is to
explain ethnicity- nationalism and class in Marx's modern world where 'All
That is Solid Melts Into Air'.

Anahtar Kelimeler

Ethnicity, Nationalism, Marx, Class

ETNİSİTE, ULUSÇULUK – SINIF DİYALEKTİĞİNDE MARX’I YENİDEN OKUMAK

Öz

1848 kitle hareketlerinin yarattığı devrimci dalganın Kıta Avrupası’nda etkisini yitirmeye başlamasıyla birlikte İngiltere’ye sığınan Marx için ‘parlak, kutsal, lanetlenmiş, fakat yine de hayatı boyunca hiç şaşmamacısına, kaçak bir göçmen’ olarak geçireceği sürgün yılları da başlamış oldu. Marx’ın siyasi bir göçmen olarak geçirdiği hayatının bu evresi, ekonomi politiğin eleştirisine ilişkin parlak ve bir o kadar da kutsal olan düşünce tasarılarını kurguladığı bir döneme tekabül ettiği gibi, Batı dışı toplumlara dair artan ilgisiyle birlikte etnisite, ırk ve ulus olgularıyla bezenmiş yeni düşünce keşiflerine çıktığı bir süreci de içermiştir. Bu çalışma, Marx’ın yaşamının bu evresinde çıktığı düşünce yolculuklarına ait olan Elyazmaları, gazetecilik çalışmaları, mektupları, Enternasyonal için yazdığı örgüt manifestoları ve defterlerinin gizil sayfalarında kalmış notlarını ön plana çıkararak, ünlü düşünürün ihmal edilmiş ya da görmezden gelinmiş derinlikli kuramsal dünyasını keşfetmeyi amaçlamaktadır. Gayemiz, katı olan her şeyin buharlaşıp yok olduğu Marx’ın modern dünyasında, etnisite - ulus - sınıf diyalektiğini yeniden okumaya çalışmaktır.

Anahtar Kelimeler

Etnisite, Ulusçuluk, Marx, Sınıf

Kaynakça

• Marx, Karl ve Frederich Engels (1858), Karl Marx And Frederich Engels Letters (1856- 1859), Marx and Engels Collected Works, Cilt 40, s. 248-250.
• Marx, Karl ve Friedrich Engels (1848). “On the Polish Question”, Marx and Engels Collected Works, Cilt 6, s. 545-552.
• Marx, Karl ve Friedrich Engels (1880). “To The Meeting in Geneva Held To Commemorate the 50th Anniversary of the Polish Revolution of 1830”, Marx and Engels Collected Works, Cilt 24, s.343-345.
• Marx, Karl ve Engels Friedrich (1848). Manifesto of the Communist Party, Marx and Engels Collected Works, Cilt 6, s.477- 519.
• Marx, Karl (1864). “A Correction”, Marx and Engels Collected Works, Cilt 20, s.97-98.
• Marx, Karl (1864). “Confidential Communication”, Marx and Engels Collected Works, Cilt 21, s.112-124.
• Marx, Karl (1857). “English Atrocities in China”, Marx and Engels Collected Works, Cilt 15, s. 232-235.
• Marx, Karl (1864). “Inaugural Address of the Working Men's International”, Marx and Engels Collected Works, Cilt 20, s.5-13.
• Marx, Karl (1857). “İndian News”, Marx and Engels Collected Works, Cilt 15, s. 314-317.
• Marx, Karl (1847). “On Poland. Speeches at the International Meeting Held in London on November 29, 1847 to Mark the 17th Anniversary of the Polish Uprising of 1830”, Marx and Engels Collected Works, Cilt 6, s.388-389.
• Marx, Karl (1867). “Outline of a Report on the Irish Question Delivered to the German Workers' Educational Society in London”, Marx and Engels Collected Works, Cilt 21, s. 194-206. Marx, Karl (1858). “Political Parties in England.— Situation in Europe”, Marx and Engels Collected Works, Cilt 15, s. 566-569.
• Marx, Karl (1867). “Record of a Speech on the Irish Question Delivered by Karl Marx to the German Workers' Educational Society in London”, Marx and Engels Collected Works, Cilt 21, s.317-319.
• Marx, Karl (1856). “Revelations of the Diplomatic History of the 18th”, Marx and Engels Collected Works, Cilt 15, s.25-96.
• Marx, Karl (1853). “Revolution in China and in Europe”, Marx and Engels Collected Works, Cilt 12, s. 93-100.
• Marx. Karl (1853). “The British Rule in India”, Marx and Engels Collected Works, Cilt 12, s. 125-133.
• Marx, Karl (1858), “The Emancipation Question”, Marx and Engels Collected Works, Cilt 16, s. 139-147.
• Marx, Karl (1853). “The Future Results Of British Rule in India”, Marx and Engels Collected Works, Cilt 12, s 217-222.
• Marx, Karl (1853). “The Indian Question”, Marx and Engels Collected Works, Cilt 12, s.157-162.
• Marx, Karl (1857). “The Indian Revolt”, Marx and Engels Collected Works, Cilt 15, s. 353-356.
• Marx, Karl (1856). Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels Letters (1856- 1859), Marx and Engels Collected Works, Cilt 40, s. 85-87.
• Marx, Karl (1863). Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels Letters (1860-1864), Marx and Engels Collected Works, Cilt 41, s. 453.
• Marx, Karl (1867). Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels Letters (1864-1868), Marx and Engels Collected Works, Cilt 42, s. 484-486.
• Marx, Karl (1869). Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels Letters (1868-1870), Marx and Engels Collected Works, Cilt 43, s.389-391.
• Marx, Karl (1870). Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels Letters (1868-1870), Marx and Engels Collected Works, Cilt 43, s.471-476.