Harp Prensiplerini Yeniden Düşünmek

Öz

Askerî literatürde genel olarak “harp prensipleri” olarak yer alan ilkeler esas itibariyle askerî harekâtın sevk ve idaresine dairdir. NATO doktrininde daha önce “harp prensipleri olarak yer alan ilkeler “Müşterek ve Çok Uluslu Harekât Prensipleri” adıyla tanımlanmıştır. Ancak, halen uygulanan NATO doktrininde “Harp Prensipleri” başlığı altında ayrı bir tanımlamaya gidilmemiştir. Bu kapsamda, savaşı askerî harekâttan ayıran özellikler üzerinde yapılan akademik araştırmalar önem taşımaktadır. Bu makalenin amacı harp prensiplerinin neler olabileceği hususunda öneriler sunmaktır. Bu maksatla öncelikle genel kabul gören harekât prensipleri, tarihsel süreç ve devletler düzeyi itibariyle incelenmiştir. Müteakiben harp ve askerî harekât ayrımı üzerinden günümüzün güvenlik ortamı çerçevesinde hangi ilkelerin harp prensipleri olarak kabul edilebileceği açıklanmıştır. Makalenin harp ve harekât prensipleri ayrımını getirerek bu hususta başlattığı akademik tartışma ile literatüre katkı sağlaması amaçlanmıştır. Makalede nitel ve karşılaştırmalı araştırma yöntemi kullanılmıştır.

Anahtar Kelimeler

• Harp prensipleri
• Harekât prensipleri
• Harp
• Savaş
• Muharebe.

Rethinking the Principles of War

Öz

The principles generally referred to as “principles of war” in the military literature are primarily concerned with the conduct and management of military operations. In NATO doctrine, what were previously known as “Principles of War” are now termed the “Joint and Multinational Operational Principles.” However, in the NATO doctrine currently in effect, no separate definition has been provided under the heading of “Principles of War.” In this context, academic research on the characteristics that distinguish war from military operations is important. The purpose of this article is to propose what may constitute the principles of war. To achieve this, first, the generally accepted operational principles were examined in the context of the historical process and state-level considerations. Then, which principles could be accepted as principles of war within the framework of today’s security environment were explained through the distinction between war and military operations. The article aims to contribute to the literature by introducing the distinction between the principles of war and the principles of operations, thereby initiating an academic debate on this issue. The article employs a qualitative and comparative research method.

Anahtar Kelimeler

• Principles of war
• Operational principles
• War
• Warfare
• Battle

Kaynakça

1. Abel, J. (2016). The prophet Guibert. İçinde M. V. Leggiere (Ed.), Napoleon and the operational art of war: Essays in honor of Donald D. Horward. Brill.
2. AJP 10.1 Allied Joint Doctrine for Information Operations. (2023). NATO Standardization Office (NSO). https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/650c03bf52e73c000d9425bb/AJP_10_1_Info_Ops_UK_web.pdf
3. AJP 3.24 Allied Joint Doctrine for the Military Contribution to Peace Support. (2024). NATO Standardization Office (NSO). https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/65e8683f5b65240011f21a82/AJP-3_24_Peace_Support_EdA_V1-O.pdf
4. AJP-01 Allied Joint Doctrine (2017, December) (Edition E, Version 1). NATO Standardization Office (NSO). https://www.coemed.org/files/stanags/01_AJP/AJP-01_EDE_V1_E_2437.pdf
5. AJP-01 Allied Joint Doctrine (2022, December). (Edition F, Version 1). UK Ministry of Defence, NATO Standardization Office (NSO). https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/659ea238e96df5000df843f3/AJP_01_EdF_with_UK_elements.pdf
6. AJP-3 Allied Joint Doctrine for the Conduct of Operations. (2019, February) (Edition C, Version 1). NATO Standardization Office (NSO). https://www.coemed.org/files/stanags/01_AJP/AJP-3_EDC_V1_E_2490.pdf
7. AJP-3.20 Allied Joint Doctrine for Cyberspace Operations. (2020). (Edition A, Version 1). NATO Standardization Office (NSO). https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/5f086ec4d3bf7f2bef137675/doctrine_nato_cyberspace_operations_ajp_3_20_1_.pdf
8. AJP-3.4 (A) Allied Joint Doctrine for Non-Article 5 Crisis Response Operations. (XX 20XX) (Ratification Draft 1). NATO Standardization Office (NSO). https://www.ismllw-be.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/004.-ajp-3.4a-rd1.pdf

9. AJP-3.4.4. Allied Joint Doctrine for Counterinsurgency (COIN). (2011, March) (Edition A, Version 1). NATO Standardization Office (NSO). https://info.publicintelligence.net/NATO-Counterinsurgency.pdf
10. Alger, J. I. (1975). A bibliographical survey, Antoine Henri Jomini. United States Military Academy.
11. Alger, J. I. (1982). The quest for victory. Greenwood Press.
12. Arquilla, J. ve Ronfeldt, D. (2000). Swarming and the future of conflict. RAND Corporation.
13. ATP 7-100.3 Chinese Tactics. (2021). Headquarters, Department of the Army. https://armypubs.army.mil/epubs/DR_pubs/DR_a/ARN34236-ATP_7-100.3-001-WEB-3.pdf
14. Baptiste, A. C. (2022, Yaz). What is the utility of the principles of war? Military Strategy Magazine, 8(1), 42-46. https://www.militarystrategymagazine.com/article/what-is-the-utility-of-the-principles-of-war/
15. Baş, M. F. (2024). Evrensel bir paradigma arayışı: Aydınlanma çağı Avrupası’nda askerî düşünce. İçinde E. Özdemir ve A. B. Varlık (Ed.), Askeri stratejinin temelleri: Kuramcılar (ss. 134-165). Kronik.
16. Baxter, W. (1986). Soviet AirLand battle tactics. Presidio Press. https://archive.org/details/sovietairlandbat00baxt/page/n1/mode/2up
17. Bingöl, O. ve Varlık, A. B. (2017). 15 Temmuz sonrası Türk ordusu: Kriz ve çıkış. Barış Kitabevi.
18. Bull, H. (2012). The anarchical society: A study of order in world politics (4. bs). Columbia University Press.
19. Burke, E. J., Gunness, K., Cooper III, C. A. ve Cozad, M. (2020). People's Liberation Army operational concepts. RAND Corporation. https://www.rand.org/pubs/research_reports/RRA394-1.html
20. China’s Military Strategy. (2015). The State Council Information Office of the People’s Republic of China.
21. Clausewitz, C. von. (1984). On war (M. Howard ve P. Paret, Ed. ve Çev.). Princeton University Press. (Orijinal eser basım tarihi 1832).
22. Cohen, G. A. (2003). Facts and principles. Philosophy and Public Affairs, 31(3), 211-245.
23. Condell, B. & Zabecki, D. T. (Ed. ve Çev.). (2001). On the German art of war: Truppenführung. Lynne Rienner Publishers.
24. De Guibert, J. (2005). Askerî yazılar (A. Şensılay, Çev.). Anahtar Kitaplar.
25. De Jomini, A. H. (2002). Savaş sanatının ana hatları (S. Koçak, Çev.). Doruk Yayıncılık.
26. Desportes, V. (2017). Quels principes pour la guerre? Défense et Sécurité Internationale (DSI), 131, 80–83.
27. Dilworth, C. (1994). Principles, laws, theories and the metaphysics of science. Synthese, 101(2), 223-247.
28. English.Gov.CN The State Council The People's Republic of China. (2015). https://english.www.gov.cn/archive/white_paper/2015/05/27/content_281475115610833.htm
29. Fallwell, M. L. (1955, Mayıs). The principles of war and the solution of military problems. Military Review, 48-62.
30. Finkelstein, D. M. (2021). The PLA’s new joint doctrine: The capstone of the new era operations regulations system. CNA.
31. FM 100-5 Operations. (1962). U.S.A. Government Printing Office.
32. FM 100-5 Operations (1968). U.S.A. Government Printing Office.
33. FM 100-5 Operations. (1993). U.S.A. Government Printing Office.
34. FM 3-0 Operations (2022, October, 01). Headquarters Department of the Army. https://irp.fas.org/doddir/army/fm3-0.pdf
35. Foch, F. (1920). The principles of war. Henry Holt and Company. https://archive.org/details/principlesofwar00foch/page/n19/mode/2up
36. Fox, A. C. (2021). On the principles of war: Reorganizing thought and practice for large-scale combat operations (Land Warfare Paper 138). The Association of the United States Army. www.ausa.org
37. Fravel, M. T., Ikenberry, G. J., Trachtenberg, M. ve Wohlforth, W. C. (2019). Active defense: China's military strategy since 1949. Princeton University Press. [şüpheli bağlantı kaldırıldı]
38. Frederick II. (1818). Military instructions from the King of Prussia to his generals (T. Foster, Çev.). J. Cruttwell. (Orijinal eser basım tarihi 1747). https://archive.org/details/militaryinstruc00prusgoog/page/n4/mode/2up
39. Fuller, J. F. C. (1914). Training soldiers for war. Hugh Rees.
40. Fuller, J. F. C. (1920). Gold medal (military) prize essay for 1919. Royal United Services Institution Journal, 65(458).
41. Fuller, J. F. C. (1923). The reformation of war. Hutchison & Co. https://archive.org/details/reformationofwar00fulluoft/reformationofwar00fulluoft/page/n5/mode/2up
42. Fuller, J. F. C. (1926). The foundations of the science of war. Hutchinson. (Tıpkıbasım 1993, Combat Studies Institute).
43. Galtung, J. (1990). Cultural violence. Journal of Peace Research, 27(3), 291–305.
44. Gat, A. (1991). The origins of military thought from the Enlightenment to Clausewitz. Oxford University Press.
45. Glenn, R. W. (1998). No more principles of war? Parameters, 28(1), 48-66.
46. Gray, C. S. (2007). War, peace, and international relations: An introduction to strategic history. Routledge.
47. Hanle, D. J. (1987). On terrorism: An analysis of terrorism as a form of warfare [Yüksek lisans tezi, Naval Postgraduate School].
48. Harré, R. (1970). The principles of scientific thinking. Palgrave Macmillan.
49. Huovinen, P. (2011). Hybrid warfare – Just a twist of compound warfare? Views on warfare from the United States Armed Forces perspective. National Defence University. https://www.doria.fi/bitstream/handle/10024/74215/E4081_HuovinenKPO_EUK63.pdf
50. JDP 0-01, UK Defence Doctrine. (2022). (Sixth Edition). https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/uk-defence-doctrine-jdp-0-01
51. Joint Chiefs of Staff, Doctrine for Joint Operations (1995, February, 1). U.S. Chief of Staff.
52. Joint Pub 3-07. Military Operations Other Than War. (1995). Washington D.C.: Joint Chiefs of Staff. (16 June 1995). https://cgsc.contentdm.oclc.org/digital/api/collection/p4013coll9/id/874/download
53. JP 1 Warfighting (2023, August, 27). (Volume 1) U.S. Joint Chiefs of Staff. https://keystone.ndu.edu/Portals/86/Joint%20Warfighting.pdf
54. JP 3-0 Doctrine for Joint Operations. (1995). U.S. Joint Chiefs of Staff.
55. JP 3-0 Joint Campaigns and Operations. (2022, June, 18). U.S. Joint Chiefs of Staff. https://www.dau.edu/sites/default/files/webform/documents/25566/JP%203-0%2C%20Joint%20Campaigns%20and%20Operations.pdf
56. JP 3-0 Joint Operations. (17 January 2017 Incorporating Change 1 22 October 2018). U.S. Joint Chiefs of Staff. https://irp.fas.org/doddir/dod/jp3_0.pdf
57. JP 3-0 Joint Operations. (2011, August, 11). U.S. Joint Chiefs of Staff.
58. Kainikara, S. (2011). Principles of war and air power (Working Paper 31). Royal Australian Air Force Air Power Development Centre. https://airpower.airforce.gov.au/sites/default/files/2021-03/WP31-Principles-of-War-and-Air-Power.pdf
59. Keegan, J. (1961, Aralık). On the principles of war. Military Review, 41.
60. Körpe, Ö. (2024). Kautilya (Çanakya, Vışnagapta): Dünyevi kazançlar bilimi (Arthaşastra). İçinde E. Özdemir ve A. B. Varlık (Ed.), Askeri stratejinin temelleri: Kuramcılar (ss. 81-106). Kronik.
61. Leonhard, R. (1998). The principles of war for the information age. Presidio Press.
62. Liang, Q. ve Xiangsui, W. (1999). Unrestricted warfare. PLA Literature and Arts Publishing House.
63. Lind, W. S. (2004). Understanding fourth generation war. Military Review, 84(5), 12-16.
64. Lind, W. S., Nightengale, K., Schmitt, J. F. ve Sutton, J. W. (1989, Aralık). The changing face of war: Into the fourth generation. Marine Corps Gazette.
65. Litton, L. G. (t.y.). The information-based RMA and the principles of war. Air University. https://www.airuniversity.af.edu/Portals/10/ASPJ/journals/Chronicles/Litton.pdf
66. Mallick, P. K. (2009). Principles of war: Time for relook (Manekshaw Paper No. 12). Centre for Land Warfare Studies. https://www.claws.in/static/MP12_Principles-of-War-Time-for-Relook.pdf
67. Mallick, P. K. (2020). Principles of war. ResearchGate. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/344326033_PRINCIPLES_OF_WAR
68. Marx, K. (1963). The poverty of philosophy. International Publishers.
69. McDonald, H. P. (2009). Principles: The principles of principles. The Pluralist, 4(3), 98-126.
70. MCDP 1. Warfighting, Marine Corps Doctrine Publication 1 (1997). Headquarters United States Marine Corps. https://coloradofirecamp.com/usfs_doctrine/usmc_forward_preface.htm
71. Military Doctrine of the Russian Federation. (2010). https://carnegie-production-assets.s3.amazonaws.com/static/files/2010russia_military_doctrine.pdf
72. Military Doctrine of the Russian Federation. (2014). https://web.archive.org/web/20180501051233id_/https:/www.offiziere.ch/wp-content/uploads-001/2015/08/Russia-s-2014-Military-Doctrine.pdf
73. Phillips, T. R. (Ed.). (2005). Roots of strategy: The 5 greatest military classics of all time. Stackpole Books.
74. Pichichero, C. (2017). The military enlightenment: War and culture in the French Empire from Louis XIV to Napoleon. Cornell University Press.
75. Pokrant, M. (2021). New principles of war: Enduring truths with timeless examples. Potomac Books.
76. Starkey, A. (2003). War in the age of enlightenment 1700–1789. Praeger.
77. Strachan, H. (2007). Clausewitz and the dialectics of war. İçinde H. Strachan ve A. Herberg-Rothe (Ed.), Clausewitz in the twenty-first century. Oxford University Press.
78. Tardy, T. (2013). NATO and the comprehensive approach: Weak conceptualization, political divergences, and implementation challenges. İçinde G. P. Herd ve J. Kriendler (Ed.), Understanding NATO in the 21st century: Alliance strategies, security and global governance. Routledge.
79. Toffler, A. ve Toffler, H. (1993). War and anti-war: Survival at the dawn of the 21st century. Little, Brown and Company.
80. Trevor, D. (1990). Understanding defeat: How to recover from loss in battle to gain victory in war. Paragon House.
81. Van Creveld, M. (1999). The rise and decline of the state. Cambridge University Press.
82. Varlık, A. B. (2012). Savaş sanatı: Sun Tzu. İçinde A. B. Varlık (Ed.), Strateji, harp ve askeri harekât üzerine dünya klasikleri öz inceleme dizini (ss. 1-62). Kara Harp Okulu Matbaası.
83. Varlık, A. B. (2013). Savaş tanımlamak: Terminolojik bir yaklaşım. Avrasya Terim Dergisi, 1(2), 114-119.
84. Varlık, A. B. (2022). Bilgi savaşımı. İçinde O. Bingöl ve A. B. Varlık (Ed.), Güvenlik çalışmaları (Cilt-II): Güvenlik sektörleri ve sorunları (ss. 137-164). Hiper Yayın.
85. Varlık, A. B. (2024). Niccolo Machiavelli: Prens ve savaş sanatı. İçinde E. Özdemir ve A. B. Varlık (Ed.), Askeri stratejinin temelleri: Kuramcılar (ss. 107-133). Kronik.
86. Varlık, A. B. (2025a). Harekât prensipleri. Anafarta, 20, 102-107.
87. Varlık, A. B. (2025b). [Dr. (E) Korgeneral Tahir Bekiroğlu ile yayınlanmamış mülakat].
88. Varlık, A. B. ve Bingöl, O. (2020). Savaş kavramı: Terminolojik bir yaklaşım. İçinde A. B. Varlık ve O. Bingöl (Ed.), Güvenlik çalışmaları (Cilt-I): Kuramsal yaklaşımlar (ss. 183-220). Hiper Yayın.
89. Wanjuan, X. S. (2022). On askerî ilkenin diyalektik sonuçları ve zamana aydınlatıcı etkileri. Çin Komünist Partisi. https://cpc.people.com.cn/n1/2022/0728/c443712-32487665.html
90. Yasuyuki, S. (2022). NIDS China security report 2022: The PLA’s pursuit of enhanced joint operations capabilities. NIDS.