Analitik Hiyerarşi Süreci ve Analitik Ağ Süreci Yöntemlerinde Grup Kararı Verilmesi Aşamasına İlişkin Bir Örnek Uygulama

Yıl 2013, Cilt: 18 Sayı: 3, 47 - 70, 01.09.2013

  Doç.Dr.Nuri Ömürbek Doç.dr.m. Zihni Tunca

Öz

Ownvu/etuvqtuc,fqeuuuqp,ocwups,oqvtqfu,cuo,vq,tqnr,fqeuuuqp,ocwqtu,vq,suxq,dqvvqt,fqeuuuqpu,d…,rtqxufups,crrtqrtucvq,etquequ.,ƒtqp,vtqtq,ctq,wpeqtvcupuv….,eqornq„uv…,cpf,fuuetqrcpe…,up,cnvqtpcvuxq,fqeuuuqpu0,Mpcn…vue,Juqtctet…,Rtqequu/MJR,cpf,Mpcn…vue,Pqvƒqtw,Rtqequu/MPR,ctq,ƒufqn…,ceeqrvqf,ownvu,etuvqtuc,fqeuuuqp,ocwups,oqvtqfu0,,MJR,uuspuruecpvn…,tqnru,fqeuuuqp,ocwqtu,qp,ownvu/etuvqtuc,cpf,ownvu/cnvqtpcvuxq,rtqdnqou,vq,rupcnu†q,vtq,fqeuuuqp,rtqequu0,Kv,uu,cp,qrrqevuxq,oqvtqf,vq,tqnr,stqwru,cpf,upfuxufwcnu,qp,eqodupups,swcnuvcvuxq,cpf,swcpvuvcvuxq,rcevqtu,fwtups,fqeuuuqp,ocwups,rtqequu0,Mpcn…vue,Pqvƒqtw,Rtqequu.,uu,tqƒqxqt.,c,oqtq,sqpqtcnu†qf,rqto,qr,MJR,vtcv,cnnqƒu,rqtoups,eqornq„,tqncvuqpu,coqps,fqeuuuqp,nqxqnu,cpf,vtqut,cvvtudwvqu,ƒtunq,MJR,qpn…,cnnqƒu,qpq/ƒc…,tqncvuqputur0,Jqpeq.,MJR.,ƒtuet,uu,ƒufqn…,wuqf,up,vtq,nuvqtcvwtq.,uu,c,urqeucn,rqto,qr,MPR0,`tq,ocvqt,furrqtqpeq,dqvƒqqp,MPR,cpf,MJR,uu,vtq,wuq,qr,cp,upvqtcevuxq,tuqtctetuecn,uvtwevwtq,up,MPR.,ƒtunq,MJR,wvunu†qu,c,vqr/vq/fqƒp,tuqtctetuecn,uvtwevwtq0,MPR,cnuq,tcu,rqqfdcew,cpf,upfqrqpfqpeq,cvvtudwvqu0,MPR,rtqxufqu,oqtq,qrrqevuxq,cpf,oqtq,tqcnuuvue,uqnwvuqpu,up,fqeuuuqp,ocwups0,Kp,vtuu,uvwf….,stqwr,fqeuuuqp,ocwups,rtqequuqu,qr,MJR,cpf,MPR,tcxq,dqqp,eqorctqf,up,c,ecuq,uvwf…,vq,uqnqev,vtq,oquv,ufqcn,tqcf…/ou„qf,eqpetqvq,ocpwrcevwtqt,rqt,eqpuvtwevuqp0,Kp,qtfqt,vq,eqorctq,rqwt,cnvqtpcvuxq,ocpwrcevwtqtu.,q„rqtv,qrupuqpu,tcxq,dqqp,eqpuufqtqf,qp,ruxq,etuvqtuc.,ƒtuet,ctq,swcnuv….,rtueq.,rc…oqpv,eqpfuvuqpu.,nqecvuqp,cpf,eqorcp…,uocsq0,`tq,uvwf…,tcu,dqqp,eqpfwevqf,qxqt,uqxqp,eqpuvtwevuqp,eqorcpuqu.,tcxups,cevuxuvuqu,up,Kurctvc,euv…0,Rctvueurcpvu,tcxq,dqqp,cuwqf,vq,ocwq,rcutqf,eqorctuuqpu,qr,vtq,tqcf…/ou„qf,eqpetqvq,ocpwrcevwtqtu0,`tq,rupfupsu,qr,vtq,eqorctuuqpu,tcxq,dqqp,eqodupqf,vq,fqvqtoupq,vtq,qrvuowo,tqcf…/ou„qf,eqpetqvq,ocpwrcevwtqt0

Anahtar Kelimeler

Mpcn…vue, Juqtctet…, Rtqequu., Mpcn…vue, Pqvƒqtw, Rtqequu., Stqwr, Pqeuuuqp, Ocwups., Tqcf…/Ou„qf, Oqpetqvq

ANALİTİK HİYERARŞİ SÜRECİ VE ANALİTİK AĞ SÜRECİ YÖNTEMLERİNDE GRUP KARARI VERİLMESİ AŞAMASINA İLİŞKİN BİR ÖRNEK UYGULAMA

Öz

Anahtar Kelimeler

Analitik Hiyerarşi Süreci, Analitik Ağ Süreci, Grup Karar Verme, Hazır Beton

Kaynakça

• =0 MNR`QMİP,P0,*><=<+.,•Mpcnuvuw,Mğ,_þtqeu,ecwncşımı İnq,`þtwu…q”fq, Nq…c†,Qş…c,_qwvİtþpþp,Rc†ct,Rc…ı,`ctoupu–.,Pqğuş, Þpuxqtuuvquu, Pqtsuuu.,==,*=+.,u0,=:/>90,
• >0 MPKM,\0,*><<9+.,Pqupq,eİpqnuonu,ec†ılıo,Punnqtupup,Mpcnuvuw,Ju…qtctşu, xq,Mpcnuvuw,Pqvƒqtw,Rtququu,unq,Mctşıncştırınocuı,xq,Pqğqtnqpfutunoquu., ec…ıpncpocoış,eþwuqw,Nuucpu,`q†u.,Sc†u,Þpuxqtuuvquu.,Rqp,Nunuonqtu, Qpuvuvþuþ.,Mpwctc0,
• ?0 M_NMP,P0,*><<A+.,Mpcnuvuw,Pqvƒqtw,Rtququu.,ec…ıpncpocoış,eþwuqw, Nuucpu,`q†u.,eınfı†,`qwpuw,Þpuxqtuuvquu.,Rqp,Nunuonqtu,Qpuvuvþuþ., İuvcpdwn0,
• @0 Me`ÞTM,_0,*><<8+.,Muwqtu,_cxwpoc,_uuvqonqtupfq,Mpcnuvuw,Ju…qtctşu, xq,Mpcnuvuw,Şqdqwq,Rtququu,unq,Jcrur,Ocwupqnu,`þrqw,_qéuou., ec…ıoncpocoış,eþwuqw,Nuucpu,`q†u.,Sc†u,Þpuxqtuuvquu.,Rqp,Nunuonqtu, Qpuvuvþuþ.,Mpwctc0,
• A0 NMPTK,O0M0,*=;;;+.,•Oqodupups,vtq,Mpcn…vue,Juqtctet…,Rtqequu,cpf, Sqcn,Rtqstcooups,rqt,Snqdcn,Rceunuv…,Nqecvuqp/Mnnqecvuqp,Rtqdnqo–., Kpvqtpcvuqpcn,Lqwtpcn,qr,Rtqfwevuqp,Qeqpqoueu.,bqn,8>.,u0,>?9/>@:0,
• 80 NMŞMMeM,\0,xq,Mwct,O0,*><<A+.,•Þtþp,Mnvqtpcvuru,_qéuoupfq,Mpcnuvuw, Ju…qtctşu,_þtqeu<,`qwuvun,İşnqvoquu,Øtpqğu–.,Mpcfqnw,Þpuxqtuuvquu.,_qu…cn, Nunuonqt,Pqtsuuu.,><<A;=.,u0>9?/>:80,
• 90 NTaPQ,S0.,Qurquuvq,Q0.,Sqpqxquq,M0,cpf,Rcuuctq,T0,*><=>+.,•`tq, Mpcn…vuecn,Juqtctet…,Rtqequu,up,`tq,_wrrnuqt,_qnqevuqp,Rtqdnqo–., ƒƒƒ0fqeuvqe0eqo;fqeu;;=9?9:<?.,qtuşuo,vctutu<,>?0<A0><=>0,
• :0 NaNa`,M0,xq,_q…nw,N0,*><<;+.,•Øğtqvuo,ޅqnqtupup,İş,eþwþ, _qxu…qnqtupup,Nut,Mpcnuvuw,Mğ,Oqfqnu,İnq,Pqğqtnqpfutunoquu<,Oþtqpfuunuw, Rcwþnvquupfq, Nut, a…swncoc–., Qteu…qu, Þpuxqtuuvquu, Rqp, Nunuonqtu, Qpuvuvþuþ,Pqtsuuu. >A,*=/>+.,u0,=A</=890,
• ;0 NaTPaTNa,Q0,xq,Qvfqt,Q0,*><<?+.,•Nqecvuqp,Otqueq,Rqt,Rwtpuvwtq, Kpfwuvt…,Rutou,N…,auups,Mpcn…vue,Juqtctet…,Rtqequu,*MJR+,Oqvtqf–., Sc†u,Þpuxqtuuvquu.,Rqp,Nunuonqtu,Qpuvuvþuþ,Pqtsuuu.,=8*>+.,u0,?8;/?9?0,
• =<0 OJMP,R0`0_0.,Mwoct,P0,cpf,Otq…,M0N0,*><<9+.,•Pqeuuuqp,Ocwups, Mrrtqcet,rqt,`tq,Puuvtudwvuqp,Oqpvtq,Nqecvuqp,Rtqdnqo,Kp,c,_wrrn…, Otcup,Pqvƒqtw,auups,vtq,Rw††…/Ncuqf,Juqtctetuecn,Oqpeqrv–., Rtqeqqfups,qr,`tq,Kpuvuvwvuqp,qr,Oqetcpuecn,Qpsupqqtu.,Rctv,N.,Lqwtpcn, qr,Qpsupqqtups,Ocpwrcevwtq.,bqn,>>=.,Pq,@.,u0,9>A/9?;0,
• ==0 PQĞMP.,N0,*><<@+.,Mctct,bqtoqfq,Éqw,Mtuvqtnu,Nut,ecwncşıo,Oqfqnu, Qnctcw,Mpcnuvuw,Ju…qtctşu,_þtqeu,xq,Oc…ıp,Mxncoc,Sqouuu,_qéuoupfq, Mpcnuvuw,Ju…qtctşu,eİpvqoupup,a…swncpocuı.,Pqpu†,Jctr,Qwwnw.,Pqpu†, Nunuonqtu,xq,Oþtqpfuunuğu,Qpuvuvþuþ.,ec…ıpncpocoış,eþwuqw,Nuucpu, `q†u.,İuvcpdwn0,
• =>0 QPPKQ,c0N0.,Nu,J0,cpf,ew,N0.,*><<A+.,•`tq,Mpcn…vue,Pqvƒqtw,Rtqequu, *MPR+,Mrrtqcet,vq,Nqecvuqp,_qnqevuqp<,M,_tqrrups,Ocnn,Knnwuvtcvuqp–., Oqpuvtwevuqp,Kppqxcvuqp.,bqn0,A.,u0,:?/;90,
• =?0 Q_OQNMT,O0`0,cpf,Oqtqpq/Luoëpq†,L0O0,*><<9+.,•Msstqscvuqp,qr, Kpfuxufwcn,Rtqrqtqpeq,_vtwevwtqu,up,Mtr/Stqwr,Pqeuuuqp,Ocwups–., Stqwr,Pqeuuuqp,cpf,Pqsqvucvuqp, bqnwoq,=8.,Pwodqt,@.,u0,>:9/?<=0,
• =@0 RQNQM,_0.,ewnwğwwtcn,e0,xq,Mncfcğ,\0,*><<9+.,•Oqdun,İnqvuşuo, _qwvİtþpfq,Rc†ct,Rc…ncşımınıp,`ctoupupfq,MJR,xq,MPR,eİpvqonqtupup, Kı…cuncpocuı–., Ocwupq,Oþtqpfuunqtu,Qfcuı,Qpfþuvtu,Oþtqpfuunuğu, Pqtsuuu.,Ounv,=:.,_c…ı,=.,u0,8/>>0,
• =A0 RQTOMP,Q0.,_qnn…,O0M0,*><<>+.,Pqeuuuqp,N…,Qdvqevuxqu., cqtnf, _euqpvurue,Rwdnuutups.,_upscrqtq0,
• =80 GİTSİPQT,P0,xq,Mc…sısı†,\0,*><<;+.,•İuvcvuuvuwuqn,ec†ılıo,_þtqeupfq, Mpcnuvuw,Ju…qtctşu,_þtqeu,xq,</=,Jqfqr,Rtqstconcoc,eİpvqonqtupup, Nutnuwvq,Mwnncpımı–.,Quocpsc†u,Þpuxqtuuvquu.,_qu…cn,Nunuonqt,Pqtsuuu., Ounv,=<.,_c…ı,=.,u0,>==/>??0,,,
• =90 SØTQPQT.,M0,*><==+.,•Nþvþpnqşuw,MPR/bıwqt,ecwncşımı İnq,QTR, ec†ılımı,_qéuou–.,Jcxceılıw,bq,a†c…,`qwpqnqvunqtu,Pqtsuuu.,Ounv,A.,_c…ı, =.,,u0,;9/==<0,
• =:0 SØTQPQT.,M0,*><<;+.,•Mquueu,`cwıo,`qfctuwéuuu,_qéuoupfq,Mpcnuvuw, Ağ,_þtqeupup,Mwnncpımı–.,Jcxceılıw,xq,a†c…,`qwpqnqvunqtu,Pqtsuuu.,Ounv, @.,_c…ı,=.,u0,;;/==<0,
• =;0 SÞPQT,O0,xq,eþeqn,Ø0,*><<9+.,•Mqprqwuu…qp,Þtqvuoupfq,`qoqn, Mtuvqtnqtup,Ju…qtctşuw,Oqfqnnqpoquu,İnq,Þtqvunqeqw,Qp,a…swp,Þtþpþp, Nqnutnqpoquu–., Sc†u, Þpuxqtuuvquu., Oþtqpfuunuw, Ouoctnıw, Rcwþnvquu, Pqtsuuu.,Ounv,>>.,Pq,=.,u0,9?/9;0,,,,,
• ><0 SÞTNQT,İ0.,Sþnqt,O0Q0,xq,`qrq…cp,O0,*><==+.,•bqtuonu,xq,Qwqpqouw, Mnuoc,_uuvqonqtupup,_qéuoupfq,Nwncpıw,MJR,Oqvqfw–.,Rupcpu.,Rqnuvuw, (,Qwqpqouw,eqtwonct,Pqtsuuu.,Ounv,@:.,_c…ı,AA=.,u0,A=/A:0,
• >=0 JMJP,Q0P0,*><<?+.,•Pqeuuuqp,Ocwups,ƒuvt,apeqtvcup,Lwfsqoqpvu<,M, _vqetcuvue,Rqtowncvuqp,qr,`tq,Mpcn…vue,Juqtctet…,Rtqequu–.,Pqeuuuqp, _euqpequ.,bqn,?@.,Pq,?.,*Mwswuv+.,u0,@@?/@880,
• >>0 JaK\KPSJ.,Q0M0T0Q0,cpf,btqnuvuw.,J0O0L0,*=;;9+.,•Q„vqpfups,vtq, Mrrnuecdunuv…,qr,vtq,Mpcn…vue,Juqtctet…,Rtqequu–.,, _qeuq/Qeqpqoue, Rncppups,_euqpeq.,bqn0?=.,Pq<=.,u0,>;/?;0,
• >?0 JcMPS,J0_0.,Oqqp,O0.,Otwcps,O0N0,cpf,Sqcp,O0L0,*><<A+.,•_wrrnuqt, _qnqevuqp,Rncppups,Oqfqn,auups,MJR–.,Kpvqtpcvuqpcn,Lqwtpcn,qr,vtq, Kprqtocvuqp,_…uvqou,rqt,Nqsuuvueu,cpf,Ocpcsqoqpv.,bqn,=.,Pq,=.,u0,@9/ A?0,, ,
• >@0 MMJTMOMP.,O0.,Twcp,P0,cpf,Pqğcp.,K0,*><<?+.,•Rw††…,Stqwr, Pqeuuuqp/Ocwups,Rqt,Rceunuv…,Nqecvuqp,_qnqevuqp–.,Kprqtocvuqp,_euqpeq., bqn,=A9.,u0,=?A/=A?0, 8:, 8;,
• A>0 eKNOM\,_0,*><<8+.,aécw,_qéuoupfq,Mtuvqtnqtup,Pqğqtnqpfutunoquupfq, MJR,xq,Nwncpıw,MJR,a…swncocuı.,ec…ıpncpocoış,eþwuqw,Nuucpu,`q†u., Yınfı†,`qwpuw,Þpuxqtuuvquu.,Rqp,Nunuonqtu,Qpuvuvþuþ.,İuvcpdwn0,
• A?0 \MJKT,O0_0,*=;;=+.,•Kpeqtrqtcvups,`tq,apeqtvcupv…,qr,Pqeuuuqp, Lwfsqoqpvu,up,`tq,Mpcn…vue,Juqtctet…,Rtqequu–.,Qwtqrqcp,Lqwtpcn,qr, Qrqtcvuqpcn,Tquqctet.,bqn,A?.,Pq,>.,u0,><8/>=80,