THE ARROWHEADS TYPOLOGY OF OLD SMYRNA IN THE LIGHT OF NEW DATA

Öz

The archaeological records prove the existence of a continuous settlement in Bayrakli Mound, located northeast of Izmir Bay, from the Bronze Ages until the Hellenistic Period. Migration movements to the Western Anatolian coasts beginning in the 11th century BC revealed the benefits of economic growth in Old Smyrna's socio-cultural structure and the city's identity as a Greek Polis. However, due to the importance of its geopolitical position and the outcomes of political events, the city was vulnerable to invasions from different powers. The military actions in the city which was captured by Lydia and Persia and later sieged by Macedonians (?) can be clearly recognized with archaeological data. Arrowheads are one of the sources of information for this data and are unquestionably the essential reference source among ordnance. Arrowheads, found in many places from the Near East to Anatolia and the Greek Mainland, were not only used in warfare, but they were also popular as a votive item given in the sanctuary and as a funerary offering left in the graves during burial customs. In this study, arrowheads unearthed in Old Smyrna throughout the previous and recent excavations were examined in-depth, and classification was developed based on the arrowheads' shape and functional qualities. A total of 133 bronze and iron arrowheads were classified typologically and compared to similar samples acquired from nearby and distant sites. The arrowheads discovered in recent excavations, ongoing since 2014, have been dated together with the context. This study particularly emphasizes the correlation between the destructions associated with the military actions in the city and the arrowheads. Therefore, this study of bronze and iron arrowhead findings in Old Smyrna, one of the most important cities in Western Anatolia, will critically contribute to the literature.

Anahtar Kelimeler

• Old Smyrna
• Arrowhead
• Bronze
• Iron
• War
• Weapons

YENİ VERİLER IŞIĞINDA ESKİ SMYRNA OK UÇLARI TİPOLOJİSİ

Öz

İzmir Körfezi’nin kuzeydoğusunda yer alan Bayraklı Höyüğü’nde, Tunç Çağları’ndan Hellenistik Dönem’e kadar kesintisiz bir yerleşimin varlığı arkeolojik verilerle kanıtlanmıştır. MÖ 11. yüzyıldan itibaren Batı Anadolu kıyılarına gerçekleşen göç hareketleri sonrasında bir Yunan polisi kimliği ile ekonomik açıdan büyüyen Eski Smyrna, sosyo-kültürel yapısında bu ekonomik büyümenin getirilerini yüksek kültür seviyesi ile ortaya koymuştur. Fakat çevresinde meydana gelen siyasi hareketlerin sonuçlarından etkilenen kent, jeopolitik konumunun önemi nedeniyle farklı güçlerin saldırılarına maruz kalmıştır. Lydia ve Pers gibi iki güçlü devlet tarafından iki kez ele geçirilen ve sonrasında Makedon saldırısına (?) maruz kalan kentte, bu organizasyonların askeri hareketleri arkeolojik verilerle net bir şekilde okunmaktadır. Bu verilerin kaynaklarından biri olan savaş araç gereçleri ve unsurları arasında en önemli başvuru kaynağı hiç şüphesiz ok uçlarıdır. Yakındoğu’dan Anadolu’ya ve Kıta Yunanistan’ına birçok merkezde ele geçen ok uçları yalnızca bir savaş unsuru değil aynı zamanda kutsal alanlara bırakılan bir adak eşyası ve ölü gömme uygulamalarında ölen bireylerin mezarlarına bırakılan bir mezar hediyesi işleviyle de tercih edilmiş bir nesnedir. Bu çalışmada, hem eski hem de yeni dönemde Eski Smyrna’da gerçekleştirilen kazılarda bulunan ok uçları ayrıntılı bir şekilde incelenmiş, ok uçlarının biçimsel ve işlevsel özelliklerine göre bir sınıflandırma oluşturulmuştur. Bu sınıflandırmayı yaparken, özellikle genel tipolojiye bağlı kalınmıştır. Bronz ve demir olarak iki ana başlıkta incelenen 133 ok ucu, kendi arasında tipolojik olarak gruplandırılarak, yakın ve uzak çevredeki merkezlerden ele geçen benzer örneklerle karşılaştırılmıştır. 2014 yılından itibaren devam eden yeni dönem kazılarında tespit edilen ok uçları için, bulundukları kontekstler ile birlikte tarihlendirme önerileri getirilmiştir. Özellikle kentte meydana gelen askeri harekâtlarla ilişkili tahribatların ok uçlarıyla bağlantısı üzerinde durulmuştur. Özetle, Batı Anadolu coğrafyasının önemli kentlerinden biri olan Eski Smyrna’da bronz ve demir ok ucu buluntularının bu çalışmada yayınlanması literatüre kritik katkılar sağlayacaktır.

Anahtar Kelimeler

• Eski Smyrna
• Ok ucu
• Bronz
• Demir
• Savaş
• Silahlar

Kaynakça

1. Hdt. (=Herodotos, Historia) Herodotos, Trans. A. D. Godley (Ed.), The Histories of Herodotus, Cambridge, Harvard University Press, 1920.
2. Strab. (= Strabon, Geographika) Strabon, Trans. H. L. Jones (Ed.), The Geography of Strabo, Harvard University Press, London, 1924.
3. AKAR TANRIVER, D. 2017A “Eski Smyrna’nın Keşfi”, SDÜ Fen-Edebiyat Fakültesi Sosyal Bilimler Dergisi 42, 67-77.
4. AKAR TANRIVER, D. 2017B “Eski Smyrna'da Savaşlar, Silahlar ve Askeri Teçhizatlar”, Arkeoloji ve Sanat 156, 77-92.
5. AKOK, M. 1965 “Afyon-Çavdarlı Hüyük Kazısı”, TAD XIV-1.2, 5-34.
6. AKURGAL, E. 1985 “Bayraklı 1983 Çalışmaları”, VI. Kazı Sonuçları Toplantısı, (16-20 Nisan 1984), 280-281, Ankara.
7. AKURGAL, E. 1997 Eski İzmir I: Yerleşme Katları ve Athena Tapınağı, Ankara.
8. AKURGAL, M. 2005 “The Archaic Period Wall of Smyrna”, Synergia: Festschrift für Friedrich Krinzinger II, (Ed. B. Brandt, V. Gassner, S. Ladstatter), 83-88, Wien.

9. AVILA, R. A. J. 1983 Bronzene Lanzen-und Pfeilspitzen der griechischen Spätbronzezeit, Prähistorische Bronzefunde V.1, München.
10. BAITINGER, H. 2001 Die Angriffswaffen aus Olympia, Olympische Forschungen XXIX, Berlin.
11. BAITINGER, H. 2016 Selinus V: Die Metallfunde aus Selinunt, Der Fundstoff aus den Grabungen des Deutschen Archäologischen Instituts auf der Agora, Wiesbaden.
12. BAMMER, A. / MUSS, U. 2009 “Deponien im Artemision von Ephesos”, Zurück zum Gegenstand: Festschrift für Andreas E. Furtwängler, (Ed. S. Lehmann, H. Löhr, R. Einicke), 391-408, Langenweissbach.
13. BAYKAN, D. 2017A ”Metal Buluntular ve Arkeometalürji Veriler”, Nif Dağı: Ballıcaoluk (2008-2016) Prof. Dr. Elif Tül Tulunay Onuruna, (Ed. M. Peker, C. Baykan, D. Baykan), 119-160, İstanbul.
14. BAYKAN, D. 2017B “Allianoi’da Bulunan Ok Uçları”, MASROP 10-14, 7-21.
15. BLAYLOCK, S. 2016 Tille Höyük 3 The Iron Age: 2. Pottery, Objects and Conclusions, The British Institute at Ankara Monograph 50, Ankara.
16. BLINKENBERG, C. 1931 Les Petits Objets, Lindos: Fouilles de L’acropole 1902-1914-I, Berlin.
17. BOARDMAN, J. 1967 Excavations in Chios 1952-1955: Greek Emporio, BSA Suppl. Vol. No: 6, 1-258.
18. BOEHLAU, J. 1898 Aus Ionischen und Italischen Nekropolen, Leipzig.
19. BOEHLAU, J. / SCHEFOLD, K. 1942 Larisa am Hermos: Die Ergebnisse der Ausgrabungen 1902-1934, III: Die Kleinfunde, Berlin. BOEHMER, R. M. 1972 Die Kleinfunde von Boğazköy: Aus Den Grabungskampagnen 1931-1939 und 1952-1969, Wissenschaftliche Veröffentlichung der Deutschen Orient-Gesellschaft 87, Boğazköy-Hattuşa VII, Berlin.
20. BRONEER, O. 1933 “Excavations on the North Slope of the Acropolis in Athens, 1931-1932”, Hesperia 2.3, 329-417.
21. BRONEER, O. 1935 “Excavations on the North Slope of the Acropolis in Athens, 1933-34”, Hesperia 4.2, 109-188.
22. CAHILL, N. 2010 “Sardeis’te Pers Tahribi / The Persian Sack of Sardis”, Lidyalılar ve Dünyalıları / The Lydians and Their World, (Ed. N. Cahill), 339-362, İstanbul.
23. CARAPANOS, C. 1878 Dodone Et Ses Ruines, Paris.
24. CHISTOV, D. / ILYINA, Iu. I. / EREMEEVA, A. A. / SHCHERBAKOVA, O. E. 2020 The Site of Berezan in the Studies of 2010–2014, (Ed. D. Chistov), Materials of the Berezan (Lower Bug) Archaeological Expedition, V. 3: (Archaeology at the Hermitage, V. 1), St. Petersburg.
25. CLEUZIOU, S. 1977 ”Les pointes de flèches scythiques au Proche et Moyen Orient”, Le Plateau Iranien et l'Asie centrale des origines à la conquête Islamique: Leurs relations à la lumière des documents archéologiques, CNRS 567 (Paris 22-24 mars 1976), 187-199, Paris.
26. CONZE, A. 1913 Stadt und Landschaft, Altertümer von Pergamon 1.2, Berlin.
27. COOK, J. M. 1958/59 “Old Smyrna, 1948-1951”, BSA 53/54, 1-34.
28. COOK, J. M. / NICHOLLS, R. V. / PYLE, D. M. 1998 Old Smyrna Excavation: The Temples of Athena, BSA Supp. Vol. No: 30, 1-214.
29. DAVIDSON, G. R. 1952 The Minor Objects, Corinth XII, New Jersey.
30. DAY, L. P. / COULSON, W. D. E. / GESELL, G. C. 1986 “Kavousi, 1983-1984: The Settlement at Vronda”, Hesperia 55/4, 355-387.
31. DERİN, Z. / MUSCARELLA, O. W. 2001 “Iron and Bronze Arrows”, Ayanis I: Ten Years' Excavations at Rusahinili Eiduru-Kai 1989-1998, (Ed. A. Çilingiroğlu, M. Salvini), Documenta Asiana VI, 189-217, Roma.
32. DOĞER, E. / GEZGİN, İ. 1998 “Arkaik ve Klasik Dönemde Smyrna’nın Dış Savunması Üzerine Gözlemler”, II. Uluslararası İzmir Sempozyumu, (Ed. N. Ülker), 7-30, İzmir.
33. DOĞER, E. 2006 İzmir’in Smyrna’sı Paleolitik Çağ’dan Türk Fethine Kadar, İstanbul.
34. DÖRPFELD, W. 1902 Troja und Ilion: Ergebnisse der Ausgrabungen in den vorhistorischen und historischen Schichten von Ilion 1870-1894, Athen: Beck & Barth.
35. DROOP, J. P. 1929 “The Bronzes”, The Sanctuary of Artemis Orthia at Sparta, (Ed. R. M. Dawkins), JHS Suppl. 5, 196-202, London.
36. DUGAS, C. 1921 “Le sanctuaire d'Aléa Athéna à Tégée avant le IVe siècle”, BCH 45, 335-435.
37. ERDMANN, E. 1973 “Die Sogenannten Marathonpfeilspitzen in Karsluhe”, AA 88, 30-58.
38. ERDMANN, E. 1977 Nordosttor und persische Belagerungsrampe in Alt-Paphos: Waffen und Kleinfunde, Ausgrabungen in Alt-Paphos auf Cypern 1, Konstanz.
39. ERDMANN, E. 1982 “Vierkantige Pfeilspitzen aus Eisen von der Saalburg”, SaalJb 38, 5-11.
40. FOÇA, S. 2020 “Kyme (Aiolis) Batı Liman Nekropolisi’nden Klasik ve Hellenistik Dönem Mezarlar”, TUBA-AR 27, 195-215.
41. GAITZSCH, W. 2005 Eisenfunde Aus Pergamon Geräte, Werkzeuge Und Waffen, Pergamenische Forschungen 14, (Ed. W. Radt), Berlin.
42. GJERSTAD, E. / LINDROS, J. / SJÖQVIST, E. / WESTHOLM A. 1935 The Swedish Cyprus Expedition: Finds And Results of the Excavations in Cyprus 1927-1931, Vol. II, Stockholm.
43. GJERSTAD, E. / LINDROS, J. / SJÖQVIST, E. / WESTHOLM A. 1937 The Swedish Cyprus Expedition: Finds And Results of the Excavations in Cyprus 1927-1931, Vol. III, Stockholm.
44. GOLDMAN, H. 1963 “Metals”, Excavations at Gözlü Kule, Tarsus III: The Iron Age, (Ed. H. Goldman), New Jersey.
45. GREENEWALT, C. H. Jr. 1997 “Arms and Weapons at Sardis in the Mid Sixth Century B.C. / M.Ö. VI. Yüzyıl Ortasında Sardis’te Askeri Teçhizat ve Silahlar”, Arkeoloji ve Sanat 79, 2-20.
46. GREENEWALT, C. H. JR. / RAUTMAN, M. L. 1998 “The Sardis Campaigns of 1994 and 1995”, AJA 102.3, 469-505.
47. HANČAR, A. 1972 “Die Bogenwaffe der Skythen”, Mitteilungen der Anthropologischen Gesellschaft in Wien 102, 3-25.
48. HASPELS, C. H. E. 1951 La Cité de Midas: Céramique et Trouvailles Diverses, Phrygie III, Paris.
49. HELD, W. 2000 Das Heiligtum der Athena in Milet, Milesische Forschungen 2, Mainz.
50. HELLMUTH, A. 2010 Bogenschützen des Pontischen Raumes in der Älteren Eisenzeit: Typologische Gliederung, Verbreitung und Chronologie der skytischen Pfeilspitzen, Teil 1-2, Universitätsforschungen zur Prähistorischen Archäologie 177, Bonn.
51. HERZHOFF, S. 2017 Die Pfeilspitzen von Milet: Eine Einordnung in den eisenzeitlichen Pfeilspitzenhorizont, Yayınlanmamış Yüksek Lisans Tezi, Ruhr-Universität Bochum, Bochum.
52. HOMMEL, P. 1967 “Funde von der Oberburg”, Panionion und Melie, 23. Ergh. Jdl, 133-158, Berlin. HUBER, S. 2003 L'Aire sacrificielle au nord du Sanctuaire d'Apollon Daphnéphoros, Vol. I-II, Eretria XIV: Fouilles et recherches, Ecole suisse d'archéologie en Grèce.
53. ISLER, H. P. 1978 Das Archaische Nordtor und Seine Umgebung im Heraion von Samos, Samos IV, Bonn.
54. IVANTCHIK, A. 2016 “Arrowheads From A Survey in Celaenae–Apameia”, Kelainai–Apameia Kibotos: une métropole achéménide, hellénistique et romaine, (Ed. A. Ivantchik, L. Summerer, A. von Kienlin), KELAINAI II, 473-489, Bordeaux.
55. İLASLI, A. 1996 “Seyitömer Höyüğü 1993 Yılı Kurtarma Kazısı”, VI. Müze Kurtarma Kazıları Semineri, (24-26 Nisan 1995, Didim), 1-19, Ankara.
56. JACOPI, G. 1932-1933 Esplorazione Archeologica Di Camiro II, Clara Rhodos VI-VII. I, Rodi.
57. JAMES, S. 2004 The Arms and Armour and other Military Equipment, Excavations at Dura-Europos 1928-1937, Final Report VII, London.
58. KASAR, Ö. / İREN, K. 2020 “Leaded Bronze Arrowheads at Daskyleion”, Adalya 23, 175-204.
59. KASAR, Ö. 2021 Daskyleion Metal Silah ve Teçhizatlar: İşlev, Üretim ve Süreçsel Farklılaşma, Yayınlanmamış Doktora Tezi, Muğla Sıtkı Koçman Üniversitesi, Muğla.
60. KENYON, K. M. 1957 Chapter XV “Miscellaneous Objects in Metal, Βοne and Stone”, In: J. W. Crowfoot, G. M. Crowfoot ve K. M. Kenyon, The Objects From Samaria, Samaria-Sebaste; Reports of the work of the Joint Expedition in 1931-1933 and of the British Expedition in 1935, No: 3, London, 439-468.
61. KILIAN-DIRLMEIER, I. 2002 Kleinfunde aus dem Athena Itonia-Heiligtum bei Philia (Thessalien), Monographien /Römisch-Germanisches Zentralmuseum Mainz, Forschungsinstitut für Vor- und Frühgeschichte 48, Bonn.
62. KLEBINDER-GAUß, G. 2007 Bronzefunde aus dem Artemision von Ephesos, Forschungen in Ephesos XII/3, Wien
63. KOHLER, E. L. 1995 The Lesser Phrygian Tumuli Part 1: The Inhumations, The Gordion Excavations (1950-1973) Final Reports Volume II, Philadelphia.
64. KOUKOULIDOU, C. / MAZARAKIS AINIAN, A. / THEODOROPOULOU, T. / TOULOUMITZIDOU, A. / VARVARINOU-VAI, D. / ZIMI, E. / PAPADOPOULOU, Z. 2017 “Small Finds from the Sanctuary of Kythnos”, Les Santuaires Archaïques des Cyclades, (Ed. A. Mazarakis Ainian), 193-216, Rennes.
65. KÕIV, M. 2007 “Cimmerians in the Western Anatolia: A Chronological Note”, Studien zu Ritual und Sozialgeschichte im Alten Orient / Studies on Ritual and Society in the Ancient Near East, (Ed. T. C. Kämmerer), Tartuer Symposien 1998-2004, 153-170, Berlin and New York.
66. LAMB, W. 1934/1935 “Excavations at Kato Phana in Chios”, BSA 35, 138-164.
67. LÖWE, W. 1996 “Die Kasseler Grabung 1894 in der Nekropole der archaischen Stadt”, Samos — die Kasseler Grabung 1894, 24-107.
68. LUBOS, M. 2008 Waffenweihungen aus dem Apollonheiligtum von Didyma, Yayınlanmamış Yüksek Lisans Tezi, Martin-Luther Universität, Halle/Saale.
69. LUBOS, M. 2009 “Weihungen griechischer Söldner in Didyma”, Zurück Zum Gegenstand: Festschrift Für Andreas E. Furtwängler, Band II, (Ed. R. Einicke, S. Lehmann, H. Löhr, G. Mehnert, A. Mehnert, A. Slawisch), Langenweißbach, 405-414.
70. MACALISTER, R. A. S. 1912 The Excavation of Gezer 1902-1905 and 1907-1909, Vol: III, London. MAIER, F. G. 2008 Nordost-Tor und persische Belagerungsrampe in Alt-Paphos: III, Grabungsbefund und Baugeschichte, Ausgrabungen in Alt-Paphos auf Cypern VI, Mainz.
71. MARINATOS, S. 1951 Thermopylae. An Historical and Archaeological Guide, Athens.
72. McCLELLAN, J. A. 1975 The Iron Objects from Gordion, A Typological and Functional Analysis, Unpubl. Ph.d. Dissertation, Universty of Pennsylvania, Pennsylvania.
73. McCOWN, C. C. 1947 Tell En-Naşbeh: Excavated under the Direction of the Late William Frederic Badé, I: Archaeological and Historical Results, The Palestinian Institute of Pacific School of Religion, Berkeley.
74. MILLER, S. G. 1977 “Excavations at Nemea, 1976”, Hesperia 46.1, 1-26.
75. MILLER, S. G. 1978 “Excavations at Nemea, 1977”, Hesperia 47.1, 58-88.
76. MILLER, S. G. 1979 “Excavations at Nemea, 1978”, Hesperia 48.1, 73-103.
77. MILLER, S. G. 1980 “Excavations at Nemea, 1979”, Hesperia 49.2, 178-205.
78. MILLER, S. G. 1984 “Excavations at Nemea, 1983”, Hesperia 53.2, 171-192.
79. MILTNER, F. / MILTNER, H. 1932 “Bericht über eine Voruntersuchung in Alt-Smyrna”, Jahreshefte des Österreichischen Archäologischen Instituts in Wien XXVII, 127-188.
80. MOOREY, P. R. S. 1980 Cemeteries of the First Millennium B.C. at Deve Hüyük, near Carchemish. Salvaged by T.E. Lawrence and C.L. Woolley in 1913, (with a catalogue raisonné of the objects in Berlin, Cambridge, Liverpool, London and Oxford), Oxford.
81. NAUMANN, R. / TUCHELT, K. 1963/64 “Die Ausgrabung im Südwesten des Tempels von Didyma 1962”, IstMitt 13/14, 15-62.
82. NICHOLLS, R. V. 1958/59 “Old Smyrna: The Iron Age Fortifications and Associated Remains on the City Perimeter”, BSA 53/54, 35-137.
83. OMURA, S. 1991 “1990 Yılı Kaman-Kalehöyük Kazıları”, XIII. Kazı Sonuçları Toplantısı I, (24-28 Mayıs 1991), 319-336, Ankara.
84. OMURA, S. 1994 “1992 Yılı Kaman-Kalehöyük Kazıları”, XV. Kazı Sonuçları Toplantısı I, (24-28 Mayıs 1993), 271-292, Ankara.
85. OMURA, S. 1995 “1993 Yılı Kaman-Kalehöyük Kazıları”, XVI. Kazı Sonuçları Toplantısı I, (30 Mayıs-2 Haziran 1994), 313-330, Ankara.
86. ÖZYİĞİT, Ö. 1994 “The City Walls of Phokaia”, Revue des Études Anciennes 96. 1-2, (Ed. P. Debord, R. Descat) Fortifications et défense du territoire en Asie Mineure occidentale et méridionale, Table ronde CNRS, (Istanbul 20-27 mai 1993), 77-109.
87. PAPADIMITRIOU, J. 1949 “Le sanctuaire d'Apollon Maléatas à Épidaure”, BCH 73, 361-383.
88. PAPADOPOULOS, S. 1998 “Mια ‘Oισθοδρομικη’ Εγκατασταση Αρχαϊκων Χρονων Στον Αγιο Ιωαννη Της Θασουπ”, ΤΟ ΑΡΧΑΙΟΛΟΓΙΚΟ ΕΡΓΟ ΣΤΗ ΜΑΚΕΔΟNIΑ ΚΑΙ ΘΡΑΚH 12, 55-65.
89. PAYNE, H. 1940 Perachora: The Sanctuaries of Hera Akraia and Limenia, Excavations of the British School of Archaeology at Athens 1930-1933. Architecture, Bronzes, Terracottas, Oxford. PETRIE, W. M. F. 1888 Nebesheh (Am) and Defenneh (Tahpanhes), Tanis II, London.
90. ROBINSON, D. M. 1941 Metal and Minor Miscellaneous Finds, Excavations at Olynthus X, Baltimore.
91. ROLLEY, C. 2002 “Le travail du bronze à Delphes”, BCH 126-1, 41-54.
92. SCHLIEMANN, H. 1880 Ilios: The City and Country of Trojans: The Results of Researches and Discoveries on the site of Troy and Throughout the Troad in the years 1871, 72, 73, 78, 79, London.
93. SCHMIDT, E. F. 1929 “Test Excavations in the City on Kerkenes Dagh”, The American Journal of Semitic Languages and Literatures XLV. 4, 221-274.
94. SCHMIDT, E. F. 1932 The Alishar Hüyük Seasons of 1928 and 1929 Part I, (Ed. J. H. Breasted, T. G. Allen), Researches in Anatolia, Vol: IV, The University of Chicago Oriental Institute Publications, Vol: XIX, Chicago.
95. SCHMIDT, E. F. 1933 The Alishar Hüyük Seasons of 1928 and 1929 Part II, (Ed. J. H. Breasted, T. G. Allen), Researches in Anatolia, Vol: V, The University of Chicago Oriental Institute Publications, Vol: XX, Chicago.
96. SCHMIDT, E. F. 1939 The Treasury of Persepolis and Οther Discoveries in the Hοmeland of the Achaemenians, (Ed. J. A. Wilson, T. G. Allen), Oriental Institute Communications 21, Chicago.
97. SCHMIDT, E. F. 1957 Persepolis II: Contents of Treasury and Other Discoveries, The University of Chicago Oriental Institute Publications LXIX, Chicago.
98. SCHMITT, H. O. 2007 “Die Angriffswaffen”, Kalapodi: Ergebnisse der Ausgrabungen im Heiligtum der Artemis und des Apollon von Hyampolis in der antiken Phokis. Band II, 423-551, Mainz.
99. SIMON, C. G. 1986 The Archaic Votive Offerings and Cults of Ionia, Yayınlanmamış Doktora Tezi, University of California, Berkeley.
100. SMIRNOV, K. F / PETRENKO V. G. 1963 Савроматы, Поволжья и Южного Приуралья, АРХЕОЛОГИЯ СССР Д 1-9, МОСКВA.
101. SNODGRASS, A. 1964 Early Greek Armour and Weapons: From the end of the Bronze Age to 600 b.c., Edinburgh.
102. SNODGRASS, A. M. 1996 “The Objects”, Chapter 12, “Iron”, Knossos North Cemetery Early Greek Tombs, Vol. II, (Ed. J. N. Coldstream, H. W. Catling), Hesperia Supp. Vol. 28, 575-597.
103. STEFANAKIS, M. I. / WEST III, W. C. / HAGGIS, D. C. / MOOK, M. S. / FITZSIMONS, R. D. / SCARRY, C. M. / SNYDER, L. M. 2007 “Excavations at Azoria 2003-2004, Part I: The Archaic Civic Complex”, Hesperia 76. 2, 243-321.
104. TANRIVER, C. / AKAT ÖZENİR, S. / AKAR TANRIVER, D. S. / ERDEM OTMAN, A. Ü. / ERDOĞAN, A. 2017 “Eski Smyrna (Bayraklı Örenyeri / Tepekule) Kazısı 2014-2015”, 38. Kazı Sonuçları Toplantısı III (23-27 Mayıs 2016), 95-114, Ankara.
105. THOMPSON, H. A. 1940 The Tholos of Athens and Its Predecessors, Hesperia Suppl. IV, Athens.
106. THOMPSON, H. A. 1958 “Activities in the Athenian Agora: 1957”, Hesperia 27.2, 145-160.
107. VAN LOON, M. N. 1980 “The other Early Iron Age finds”, Korucutepe: Final Report on the Excavations of the Universities of Chicago, California (Los Angeles) and Amsterdam in the Keban Reservoir, Eastern Anatolia 1968-1970, (Ed. M. N. Van Loon), Vol: 3, Studies in Ancient Civilization, Allard Pierson Foundation, Amsterdam.
108. VOKOTOPOULOU, I. 1986 Bίτσα: τα νεκρoταφεία μιάς μoλoσσικής κώμης, Demosieumata tou Archaiologiku Deltiou 33, Athena.
109. VON DER OSTEN, H. H. 1937A The Alishar Hüyük Seasons of 1930-1932, Part I, (Ed. J.A. Wilson, T.G. Allen), Researches in Anatolia, Vol: VII, The University of Chicago Oriental Institute Publications, Vol: XXVIII, Chicago.
110. VON DER OSTEN, H. H. 1937B The Alishar Hüyük Seasons of 1930-1932, Part II, (Ed. J.A. Wilson, T.G. Allen), Researches in Anatolia, Vol: VIII, The University of Chicago Oriental Institute Publications, Vol: XXIX, Chicago.
111. VON GRAEVE, V. 1986 “Grabung auf dem Kalabaktepe”, IstMitt 36, 37-51.
112. WALDBAUM, J. C. 1983 Metalwork from Sardis: The Finds Through 1974, Archaeological Exploration of Sardis, Monograph 8, Cambridge.
113. WOOLEY, C. L. 1921 Carchemish: Report on the Excavations at Jerablus on Behalf of the British Museum, Part II The Town Defences, London.
114. YALÇIKLI, D. 2006 Eisenzeitliche Pfeilspitzen aus Anatolien, Universitätsforschungen zur prähistorischen Archäologie 128, Bonn.
115. YOUNG, R. S. 1953 “Making History at Gordion”, Archaeology 6. 3, 159-166.