Current Issue

Volume: 24 Issue: 2, 12/17/24

Year: 2024

Research Article

Commentary

Condensed Dissertation

Book Review

Late Modern Mediterranean History, Late Modern Asian History, Late Modern European History, Late Modern Urban History, Late Modern Discoveries and Colonialism History, Late Modern Russian History, Late Modern Renewal History
Res. Assist. Dr. Şima DOĞAN EGE ÜNİVERSİTESİ, TÜRK DÜNYASI ARAŞTIRMALARI ENSTİTÜSÜ, TÜRK DÜNYASI EDEBİYATI ANABİLİM DALI 0000-0001-8213-4405
North-East (Altai, Khakas, Tuva, Sakha/Yakut) Turkic Dialects and Literatures
Res. Assist. Dr. Seçil ÖRAZ BEŞİKÇİ EGE ÜNİVERSİTESİ, TÜRK DÜNYASI ARAŞTIRMALARI ENSTİTÜSÜ 0000-0002-3501-0968
Political Science, European Studies, Studies of the Turkic World, International Relations Theories

Definition
The Journal of Turkish World Studies (TDİD for short) is an open-access publication of Ege University Institute of Turkic World Studies, which covers studies in the field of social sciences related to Turkic peoples, is published twice a year in Summer and Winter periods, uses the blind refereeing method in the scientific control process, and accepts articles written in Turkish and other Turkish dialects, English and Russian.
Objective
TDİD strives to publish studies that will contribute to the accumulation of scientific knowledge in the fields of social sciences, arts, and humanities related to Turkic peoples, revise the existing accumulation, deepen the problematics, make the studies in this field visible and prepare the fields of dissemination. In particular, it aims to create a discussion ground for studies on historical and spatial continuity and ruptures among Turkic peoples.

 

Scope
TDİD publishes research, case presentation, compilation, publication from thesis, translation, transfer, book review and necrology type studies in the fields of social sciences, arts and humanities related to Turkic peoples; reviews on scientific publications in this field and studies on teaching Turkish to foreigners. 

EGE UNIVERSITY JOURNAL OF TURKIC WORLD STUDIES PUBLICATION PRINCIPLES AND WRITING RULES

Acceptance and Evaluation of Manuscripts

Manuscripts submitted to the Journal of Turkish World Studies should not have been published in any previous publications or submitted to another publication simultaneously. Papers presented at a scientific meeting may be accepted in the case that they are separately stated and have not been published before.
The Journal of Turkish World Studies exclusively accepts submissions from doctoral candidates and Ph.D. graduates. Submissions from undergraduate or master’s level students, as well as those who have completed these programs, are not considered for publication.
Manuscripts should be submitted in accordance with the following criteria. Minor corrections that are not essential at the publication stage can be made by the Editorial Department. These corrections are based on the Turkish Language Association spelling guide and dictionaries.
Ethical Principles, Publication Policy and Ethics Committee Permission (Approval) Document
The author(s) are responsible for complying with the criteria for Actions Contrary to Scientific Research and Publication Ethics in the second part of the Interuniversity Council Directive on Scientific Research and Publication Ethics.
It is important that all authors pay attention to the following points within the scope of the rules regarding Ethical Principles announced by TR Index in 2020:
Researches that require Ethics Committee approval are as follows:
- All kinds of research conducted with qualitative or quantitative approaches that require data collection from participants using survey, interview, focus group, observation, experiment, interview techniques,
- Use of humans and animals (including materials/data) for experimental or other scientific purposes,
- Clinical trials in humans and animals,
- Retrospective studies in accordance with the law on the protection of personal data
In addition, if the work is a case presentation, then it should be stated that the “informed consent form” has been obtained; permission should be obtained from the owners for the use of scales, questionnaires, photographs belonging to others and this should be stated; it should be stated that copyright regulations are complied with for the intellectual and artistic works used.
If the manuscripts that meet the above mentioned conditions and require Ethics Committee permission are submitted to the Journal of Turkish World Studies, the official Ethics Committee permission documents must be sent to the journal as an additional file during submission.
For translated articles, the article must have a certain number of citations (at least 5) in the original language in order to be considered.
The translated manuscript can be published provided that permission is obtained from the author and the place of publication (book, journal, etc.). In order to publish the translation of the work in the Journal of Turkish World Studies, a signed permission letter must be obtained and this document must be uploaded to the files section as “.pdf” extension (This should be stated in the first footnote). All copyright costs of translated articles belong to the translator. In addition, the “.pdf” formats of the original texts of the translated articles should be shared with the editor of the Journal of Turkish World Studies. If 70 years have passed after the death of the author, this permission is not required.
Example: [This work has been translated with the permission of the author and publisher (xxx Publishing House) of the article titled “xxx xxx xxx” (Journal name volume/number (year), page range) written by xxx xxx].
The citation system used in the original text, in-text notes and bibliography should be reorganized according to APA 7 citation system.
In addition, an asterisk (*) should be added at the end of the name of the author of the translated article and the title, institution/university, city, country, department/division, if any. This and similar information about the translator should also be given by adding (**).
The editorial board of the journal has deemed it appropriate to include a maximum of two translations in one issue. Accordingly, translations more than the specified number are reserved for the next issue.
In book review articles, original information about the publication in question should be presented in detail. The publication taken as the basis for the review must have been published within two years from the date of preparation if it is published in Turkish in Turkey, and within three years if it is published in a different language abroad. The text of the book review should not exceed 2500 words. Manuscripts that resemble an advertisement or a short summary of the publications, do not express the noteworthy aspects or shortcomings of the publication, and do not make objective evaluations about the publication in accordance with academic criteria are not included in the journal agenda.
TDİD conducts manuscript acceptance and evaluation processes through DergiPark (http://dergipark.gov.tr/egetdid). Manuscripts submitted to the journal for publication are examined by the editor/editors and/or the Editorial Board in terms of publication principles and spelling rules, ethical control in the iThenticate system and scientific evaluation in general terms. If no problems are detected in these processes, the manuscript is sent to two referees who are experts in the field, taking into account the recommendations of the Editorial Board, to be evaluated by the editor/editors without the information of the author(s) in the manuscript (also applies to the processes related to the Editorial Board). The name of the author is not shared with the referees and the name of the referee is not shared with the authors. If one of the referee reports is positive and the other is negative, the manuscript may be sent to a third referee, or the editors and/or the Editorial Board may review the referee reports and make a final decision. Authors are expected to take into account the criticisms and suggestions of the referees and the editor/editors and the Editorial Board. If the authors disagree with these criticisms and suggestions, they should send their objections with their justifications and/or their revised manuscripts in line with the referee reports, editor(s) and Editorial Board opinions to the journal via http://dergipark.gov.tr/egetdid. The revised manuscript will be resubmitted for peer review upon the request of the referees and the opinion of any of the editors and the Editorial Board. Manuscripts that pass the evaluation process carried out by the editors, Editorial Board and referees with approval are placed in the publication queue. Manuscripts that are not approved in these processes are not published. The Journal of Turkish World Studies does not require a transfer of copyright for articles accepted for publication. All articles published in the journal are open access, and authors are granted permission to reuse their work in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International (CC BY-NC 4.0) open access license policy. All legal responsibility of the published articles belongs to the authors/translators. In articles with two or more authors, the copyright responsibility of the article belongs to the first author. Articles and photographs published in the journal can be cited with reference.
Spelling Rules
Manuscripts should be submitted by logging in at http://dergipark.gov.tr/egetdid. The type of work should be selected as a research article, case report, publication derived from a thesis, review or other. For translations and transpositions, a copy of the original text from which the translation or transposition was made should also be submitted.
“Copyright Agreement Form” and “Declaration of Responsible Author Regarding the Article” from the Forms and Documents (https://dergipark.org.tr/tr/pub/egetdid/page/16361) section on TDİD’s DergiPark page during submission. All of the forms must be completed and signed in. All correspondence and processes related to articles are realized through DergiPark and archived in DergiPark. The following principles regarding the layout of the manuscript should be followed in manuscript submission.
Page Layout and Article Text
In Microsoft Office Word versions, it should be prepared vertically in A4 (29.7x21 cm.) size, with 2.5 cm margins on all four sides (right, left, top, bottom), and should be written in Times New Roman font, 11 point font size (footnotes in 9 point font size), single line and 2 pt. paragraph spacing.
Limitation
The main text of the article should not exceed 8000 words including tables, appendices and footnotes. Article titles, abstracts, keywords and bibliography are excluded from this limit. Articles exceeding 8500 words will be returned without any editorial decision. (For articles written in foreign languages, this limit may be increased by 20% due to the structure of the relevant languages).
There are limitations related to the author. For the authors who are evaluated in the studies sent to the Journal of Turkish World Studies and who are evaluated positively or negatively; it is required one year; for the author whose article is published, four issues must pass after the previous one to upload another article to the journal system. These limitations also apply to manuscripts with more than one author. Studies rejected after the evaluation process will not be included in the process again and will not be published.
Title
Each article should have a title in Turkish and English that is compatible with the content. The title should not exceed 12 words, only the first letters should be capitalized and bolded, in Times New Roman font and 11-point font size. The English title should be italicized and written in 11-point font size and should be placed immediately below the Turkish title. All headings except introduction, conclusion, appendices and bibliography should be numbered. Main headings should continue as “1, 2, 3” and letters such as A, a, i, b and Roman numerals should not be used in numbering.
Publication Derived from Another Scientific Work
Studies produced from any work (project, thesis, book) should be indicated in the footnote (*) based on the article title. Example:
*This article is derived from his doctoral dissertation titled “...” prepared at Ege University, Institute of Social Sciences, Department of Turkish History.
Name-Surname and Title of Author(s)
Under the title, right justified, 11-point font size, the first letter of the first name should be capitalized and the surname should be written in all capital letters. The institution, title, contact information and ORCID information of the author(s), if any, should be indicated in the footnote with a (*) sign in 9-point font size.
Abstract / Abstract
At the beginning of the manuscript, one line space should be left after the author information, followed by the Turkish abstract and English abstract sections. The abstract and abstract, which should be no less than 150 words and no more than 200 words, should not contain quotations, references, figures, charts, etc. The abstract and abstract should be identical in terms of content and should be written in 9-point Times New Roman font, indented 1 cm from left and right.
Turkish articles should include an English translation of the abstract; articles written in Turkish dialects other than Turkish, English and Russian should include an abstract and abstract prepared in Turkish, English and the third language.
Keywords / Key Words
In the languages and dialects required by the rules defined in the abstract, keywords consisting of at least five and at most eight words should be given under the abstract and abstract, taking into account the terminology of the relevant field of science.
Extended Summary / Extended Summary
The Journal of Turkish World Studies will also include extended summaries in English of articles written in Turkish, Turkish dialects other than Turkish and Russian. Extended abstracts are not required for articles written in English.
The extended abstract will not be requested from the authors during the initial submission of the manuscript to the Journal, but after the acceptance decision if the manuscript is accepted for publication.
However, authors may add the extended abstract in English at the end of the article during submission.
The extended abstract should preferably be 600-800 words in length. In the extended abstract, the purpose, problem, method, findings and results of the research should be clearly written under relevant headings. The subheadings in the extended abstract may vary according to the type of study. Any findings or results that are not included in the research text should not be included in the extended abstract.
Conflict of Interest, Acknowledgment, Contribution
At the end of the text, if any, the “Responsible Author Declaration Regarding the Article” uploaded to the system during the submission of the study. The “Conflict of Interest”, “Support and Acknowledgment” information specified by the responsible author’s statement in the form should be added. In studies with multiple authors, the “Contribution Share” ratio should be indicated by the authors. “Ethics Committee Decision”, if any, should be given together with the institution, date and protocol number.
Visuals
Pictures, photographs, maps, figures and tables in the article should be given in 8-point font size, centered under Picture 1., Map 2., Figure 1. etc. with a descriptive expression, and the source description from which the information is taken should be written in parentheses. Tables, graphics and illustrations should not exceed 8 pages. Pictures and photographs should be included in the article in high resolution.
Quotations and References
Direct quotations in the article should be in quotation marks. Quotations of less than 4 lines should be given between the lines; quotations extending to the 4th line and longer should be given 1 cm from the right and left of the line, in block form and single-spaced, 11-point font.
Footnote
Explanations other than referencing and indirectly related to the main subject of the article can be made by using footnotes starting from one. Footnotes should be written in 9-point font at the bottom of the page where they are given.
Source
The works in the bibliography must be written in Latin alphabet. Cyrillic, Arabic, Indian, etc. Latin-letter forms of sources written in other alphabets should be given with Turkish transliteration.
Attachments
Additional tables, figures, graphs and pictures should be given on a new page after the bibliography. Each appendix should be categorized as Appendix 1, Appendix 2 and titled separately. Appendices should be single-spaced, 9-point font.
Source Citation
Submitted manuscripts should be prepared in the American Psychological Association 7 (APA 7) style in terms of reference system, citation format and bibliography, and references should be prepared as internal notes instead of footnote system. In the references given in the text, the surname of the author, year of publication and page number will be given as follows.
In-text Citation
In direct quotations, if the quotation is less than 40 words, enclose it in double quotation marks:
“Dönüşüm kavramı zihindeki bir bilginin çeşitli işlemlerden geçilerek sunulmasını içerir” (Kerimoğlu, 2016, s. 77).
For direct quotations of 40 or more words, indent 0.5 inches from the left in blocks without quotation marks:
Birinci ve ikinci tarzdaki bildirme ifadelerinde fiil kullanılmadığı için bunların birleşik fiil ile karışmasından bahsedilemez. Bildirmenin üçüncü şekli olarak verdiğimiz örneklerde er-, tur-, bol- fiilleri cümle ile ilgili bir iş görmüşler; cümlenin kuruluşunda vazife almışlardır. O halde bu kullanılışları, birleşik fiil içinde mütalaa etmemek lazımdır (Ercilasun, 2014, s. 75).
If the Author’s Name is in the Text
If the author’s name is mentioned in the text, the date is given in parentheses after the author’s name. The page number is written after the quoted sentence:
Ahmet B. Ercilasun (2010), “Eski Oğuz Türkçesinin en önemli ses özelliği, küçük ünlü uyumunun mevcut olmayışıdır” (s. 459).
If the Author Name is not mentioned in the text
(Yazar soyadı, yıl, s.)
“Eski Oğuz Türkçesinin en önemli ses özelliği, küçük ünlü uyumunun mevcut olmayışıdır” (Ercilasun, 2010, s. 459).
Anonymous Study
If the author of the cited study is not known, the name of the study is written. If the name of the study is given in the text, it should be italicized. If the name of the study is long, it is abbreviated in the in-text citation.
Diğer bir kaynakta (Dünyada Memurlar ve Sendika, 1996, s. 55) da belirtildiği gibi…
The author’s name can also be accepted as “Anonymous” in works with unknown authors. In this case, “Anonymous” can be also used in the bibliography.
Diğer bir kaynakta (Anonim, 1996, s. 55)’da belirtildiği gibi…
If a general reference is made in the text
(Yazar soyadı, yıl)
Gramerleşme, gramatikal yapıların süreç içerisinde nasıl ortaya çıktıklarını göstermektedir (Gökçe, 2013).
Multiple Studies by the Same Author
Ahmet B. Ercilasun, Bengü taşların, Köktürklerin ikinci döneminden kalmış olan yazılı anıtlar olduğunu (2016, s. 339), bu yazıtlardan da Çoyr yazıtının tarihi bilinen en eski Türk yazıtı olduğunu belirtmektedir (2010, s. 128).
Different Works by the Author in the Same Year
When referring to more than one work of the author published in the same year, phrases such as “a, b, c” should be placed after the publication date.
Oğuz boylarının her birinin özgün ağız özelliklerini belirleyebilmenin bugün çok daha zordur (Gülsevin, 2010a, s. 1077).
Study with Two Authors
If the author’s name is mentioned in the text:
Doğan ve Koç, Kazak Türkçesinde 9 adet ünlü bulunduğunu belirtir (2013, s. 18).
If the author’s name is not mentioned in the text:
“Kazak Türkçesinde 9 adet ünlü bulunmaktadır” (Doğan ve Koç, 2013, s. 18).
Study with Multiple Authors
In studies with two authors, the surname of both authors is given:
(Doğan ve Koç, 2013, s. 44).
In studies with three or more authors, it should be indicated as “surname of the first author and et al.”:
(Ali ve ark., 2017, s. 65).
Indirect/Secondary Quotations
If an indirect citation is to be made, the original source person is written in the text; the secondary source person is indicated in parentheses.
Salsalname’yi Gülşehrî’den önce de birisinin yazmış olduğu düşünülmektedir (Köprülü, 1991’den aktaran Ercilasun, 2010, s. 439).
Multiple Studies
If more than one study is cited: They are given in alphabetical order of the surnames of the authors, separated by a dotted vigula:
(Dilaçar, 2016, s. 30; Güner, 2021, s. 45; Kerimoğlu, 2015, s. 90).
Corporate Author
The institution conducting the study is indicated: (Türk Dil Kurumu, 2011, s. 65). If the name of the institution is to be abbreviated, it should also be abbreviated in the text:
(TDK, 2011, p. 65).
Authors with the Same Surname
(First letter of the author’s name. Surname, year, p.).
Türk destanlarında aile algısında ad verme ve ad biliminde ad verme…
(H. İ. Şahin, 2012, s. 118; İ. Şahin, 2015, s. 45).
Hardcover Study
Page number and date are indicated. Only the cited volume is written:
Hümâ was also the epitome of beauty (Ögel, 2014, s. 123).
In multi-volume works:
(Pflanze, 1963-1990).
Reprint/Publication of a Previous Edition
For reprinted and republished works, both dates should be given in the in-text citation. It should be ordered as year of first publication / year of republication: (Ercilasun, 1984/2014, s. 35).
Anthology Work
The work is mentioned directly, not the anthology or the editor:
“Antolojinin adı” (yıl).
Güneydeki yoksulluk Hurston’un otobiyografisi olan “Karayolundaki Toz İzleri” (1982)’nde ele alınmaktadır.
Encyclopedias
(Balkans: History, 1987).
Dictionaries
(Develioğlu, 2013, s. 45).
Electronic Texts
Video or Movie

(Name of the movie, year) (Deli ve Dahi, 2019).
When referring to any hour, minute or second of a video or movie, it is given as: (00:02:15-00:02:35)
Podcast/ YouTube
If there is video/podcast author name, title, recording date, it should be indicated. When it is desired to be referenced in hours, minutes, seconds, it should be given as follows: (00:02:15 00:02:35).
Orçun Madran “BBY 262 Web tasarımı dersi uygulaması” (2015)’nda web sayfası tasarımının nasıl olacağı ile ilgili bilgi vermektedir.
(Tunç, 2020).
Lecture/Panel/Conference
Teplin ve ark. tarafından Psikoloji-Hukuk, Toplum Toplantısı (2005)’nda gençlerde karşılaşılan şiddet eğilimi ve intihar oranları ele alınmaktadır.
Other Sources
Newspaper
Ali Yüksel çocuk gelinlerin sayısındaki artışın çok yüksek oranlara ulaştığını dile getiriyor (Cumhuriyet, 2014).
For detailed information on in-text citations:
https://apastyle.apa.org/style-grammar-guidelines/citations

Preparation of Bibliography
The bibliography should start on a new page and should be organized in alphabetical order according to the surnames of the authors or the titles of the sources whose authors are unknown.
When indicating the publishing houses that published the works in the bibliography, words such as publishing house and publishing should not be used. Imge, not Imge Publishing House.
If more than one publishing house is indicated, all should be indicated by placing a semicolon between them.
Page numbers should be fully indicated in the articles.
Basic format: Author’s Surname, Initial (Date of Publication). Title of the Book. Publisher/Publishing House.
Ögel, B. (2001). Dünden bugüne Türk kültürünün gelişme çağları. Türk Dünyası Araştırmaları Vakfı.
Single Author Book
Togan, Z. V. (1981). Umumi Türk tarihine giriş. Enderun.
Multi-author Book
Yakıcı, A., Yücel, M., Doğan, M. ve Yelok, V. S. (2017). Üniversiteler için Türkçe- 1 yazılı anlatım. Yargı.
Two or More Works by the Same Author:
Sorted by year.
İnan, A. (1954). Tarihte ve bugün şamanizm materyaller ve araştırmalar. TTK.
İnan, A. (1976). Eski Türk dini tarihi. Kültür Bakanlığı.
Two Works by the Same Author Published in the Same Year
İnan, A. (1976a). Eski Türk dini tarihi. Kültür Bakanlığı.
İnan, A. (1976b). Tarihte ve bugün şamanizm materyaller ve araştırmalar. TTK.
Book with DOI number
Çakıcı, A. (2020). DEHB ve alternatif tedavi türleri. Pegem Akademi. https://doi.org/10.14527/9786257228138
Anonymous Book
If the author is unknown, the title of the work is given. Manas (1995). TIKA.
Translation Book
Ligeti, L. (1986). Bilinmeyen iç Asya. (Sadrettin Karatay, Çev.). TDK.
Translation Article
Erdurucan, S. M. (2020). Tarihin suret-i tedrisi (S. N. Erdurucan, Çev.). Türk Tarih Eğitimi Dergisi, 9(2), 647-664). https://doi.org/10.17497/tuhed.785963 (Çalışmanın ilk yayımı 1910’da yapılmıştır)
Edited Book
Ekşi, H. ve Yüksel, M. (Ed.). (2018). Rehberlik ve psikolojik danışma. Nobel.
Chapter in an Edited Book
Maden, A. (2021). Yazma eğitiminde bellek ve özellikleri. M. N. Kardaş (Ed.), Yazma eğitimi içinde (2. bs., s. 83-100). Pegem Akademi. https://doi.org/10.14527/9786257676335
Book with Multiple Editions
Kafesoğlu, İ. (2016). Türk Millî Kültürü (40. bs.). Ötüken.
Electronic Printed Book Only
O’Keefe, E. (t.y.). Egoism & the cnsts in Western values. http://www.onlineoriginals.com/showitem.asp litem I 135
Electronic Version of the Book
Moran, B. (2015). Türk romanına eleştirel bir bakış 3. https://books.google.com.tr/books?id=p38wDwAAQBAJ&printsec=frontcover&dq=bilge+karasu&hl=tr&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwi8qZLz9KThAhWl0KYKHZ2FBI0Q6AEILjAB#v=onepage&q=bilge%20karasu&f=false
Web page on a website with an access date
Türk Psikologlar Derneği. (t.y.). Klinik Psikoloji Diploma Tescili Süreç Takibi. 17 Şubat 2020’de https://www.psikolog.org.tr/tr/haberler/www/klinik-psikoloji-diploma-tescili-surec-takibi-x176/ adresinden edinilmiştir.
Electronic Articles
Karadağ, E. (2020). Kalitenin standardını belirlemek: Türk üniversite sıralama sistemlerinin Berlin prensiplerine göre incelenmesi. Yükseköğretim Dergisi, 10(3). 260-268. doi:10.2399/yod.19.020000
Electronic News Articles
Arat, Ş. (2013, 13 Mart). En iyi 120 liseliye üniversite hayatları boyunca yarım burs. Hürriyet. https://www.hurriyet.com.tr/egitim/en-iyi-120-liseliye-universite-hayatlari-boyunca-yarim-burs-22852138
Multi-Volume Studies
Pflanze, O. (1963-1990). Bismarc and the development of Germany (Cilt 1-3). Princeton University Press.
Chapter in a Volume of a Multi-Volume Work
Bozanoğlu, S. (2014). Akademik güdülenme destek programı. S. Erkan ve A. Kaya (Ed.), Deneysel olarak sınanmış grupla psikolojik danışma ve rehberlik programlar: C. 3. (5. Bs., s. 1-58). Nobel.
New Edition of a Previous Edition
Frazer, James G. (2004). Altın dal dinin ve folklorun kökleri 1. Payel. (Orijinal çalışma 1991 yılında yayımlanmıştır)
Single Authored Article in a Scientific Journal
İnan, A. (1959). Manas destanı üzerine notlar. Belleten, 8(7), 125-159.
Multi-authored Article in a Scientific Journal
Malatyalı, M. K. Ve Sunal, A. B. (2020). Evli çiftlerde bağlanma boyutları ile evlilik doyumu arasındaki ilişkide evlilik gücünün aracı rolü. Türk Psikoloji Dergisi, 35(85), 65-78. https://doi.org/10.31828/tpd1300443320181219m000016
Electronic Journal Article
Arslan, A. (2014). Atatürk Döneminde Romanya’dan Türk Göçleri ve Göçmenlerin Türkiye’de İskanları. Turkish Studies, 9 (4). http://dx.doi.org/10.7827/TurkishStudies.6813
Newspaper and Magazine Articles with Identified Authors
Özbaşaran, N. (2008, 4 Kasım). Küresel iklim savaşçıları: Solucanlar. Bilim ve Teknik.
Unpublished Theses, Posters, Proceedings
Boyalı, C. (2020). Öz-kontrol ile akademik erteleme arasındaki ilişkide akıllı telefon bağımlılığının aracı rolünün incelenmesi [Yayımlanmamış yüksek lisans tezi]. Marmara Üniversitesi.
If master’s and doctoral theses are included in a database;
Karadağ, E. (2009). Türkiye’de eğitim bilimleri alanında yapılmış doktora tezlerinin tematik ve metodolojik açıdan incelenmesi: Bir durum çalışması (Tez No. 250896) [Doktora tezi, Marmara Üniversitesi]. Yükseköğretim Kurulu Ulusal Tez Merkezi.
Atılgan, B., Tuncel, B. ve Turan, S. (2020, 12-14 Ekim). “Hekimliği öğreniyorum” programının tıp fakültesi öğrencilerinin üniversite yaşamı uyumuna etkisi [Poster sunumu]. Ulusal Tıp Eğitimi Kongresi, İstanbul, Türkiye. https://cutt.ly/ek2mNZg
Alpaydın, Y. (2019, 10-12 Ekim). Yükseköğretim mezunlarının istihdam edilebilirliğini artırmada kullanılacak politika araçları için gerekli olan veri ihtiyacının değerlendirilmesi [Bildiri sunumu]. 4. Uluslararası Yükseköğretim Çalışmaları Konferansı, Çanakkale, Türkiye.
Encyclopedia
Zalta, E. N. (Ed.). (2019). The Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy (Summer 2019 ed.). Stanford University. https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/sum2019/
Dictionaries
Türk Dil Kurumu. (t.y.). Güncel Türkçe sözlük. 15 Şubat, 2021 tarihinde https://sozluk.gov.tr/ adresinden edinilmiştir.
Report of a Government Agency or Other Organization
Strateji Geliştirme Başkanlığı. (2009). Kamuda verimli aydınlatmaya geçiş raporu (Yayım No. 2009-19). T.C. Enerji ve Tabii Kaynaklar Bakanlığı. http://www.enerji.gov.tr/yayinlar_raporşar/KVAG_Raporu.pdf
News Article
Güçlü, A. (2013, 2 Şubat). Matematik ve fen eğitiminin analizi yapıldı. Milliyet, s. 17.
Movie/Series
Ceylan, N. B. (Yönetmen). (2018). Ahlat ağacı [Film]. Zeynofilm; Memento Films Production.
Güven, B. (Yapımcı). (2007-2011). Arka sıradakiler [Televizyon dizisi]. MinT Prodüksiyon; Best Prodüksiyon.
For detailed information on citations in the bibliography:
https://apastyle.apa.org/style-grammar-guidelines/referenc

EGE UNIVERSITY
JOURNAL OF TURKISH WORLD STUDIES
PUBLICATION ETHICS AND DECLARATION OF MISCONDUCT IN PUBLICATION

The Statement on Publication Ethics and Misconduct in Publication is based on the Code of Conduct and Best-Practice Guidelines for Journal Editors (Committee on Publication Ethics, 2011).

1. RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE JOURNAL AUTHOR
Editorial Independence
The Journal of Turkish World Studies is committed to ensuring the independence of editorial decisions without the influence of any person or commercial partners.
Intellectual Property and Copyright
The Journal of Turkish World Studies licenses the articles published in the journal under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International (CC BY-NC 4.0) license and maintains a record of each published version. The journal ensures the integrity and transparency of every published article.
Scientific Misconduct
The Journal of Turkish World Studies always takes appropriate measures against fraudulent publication or publisher plagiarism.

2. RESPONSIBILITIES OF EDITORS AND EDITORIAL BOARD
Fair Conduct and Editorial Independence
The editors evaluate the submitted manuscripts on the basis of their academic merit (importance, originality, validity, clarity) as well as their suitability for the scope of the journal. In making this assessment, the editors do not take into account the author’s race, gender, sexual orientation, ethnic origin, nationality, religious beliefs, political views, or institutional affiliation.
The editors have full responsibility and authority to accept or reject an article. The Editor has full authority over all editorial content of the journal and the timing of its publication.
Editors should reject incomplete and inaccurate research that does not comply with the journal policy, publication rules and level without any influence.
Privacy
The editors ensure that articles are evaluated by at least two reviewers via double blind review system and keep the reviewers confidential.
Publication Decisions
The editors ensure that all submitted articles, except news, translations and book reviews, are considered for publication and peer-reviewed by at least two referees who are experts in the field. The editor is responsible for deciding which of the manuscripts submitted to the journal will be published, based on the approval of the work in question, its importance to researchers and readers, the comments of the referees and such legal requirements.
Disclosure and conflicts of interest
The editor of the Journal of Turkish World Studies does not allow any conflicts of interest between parties such as authors, referees and editors. Unpublished material in an article submitted to the journal should not be used by anyone without the express written consent of the author.
Impartiality Articles submitted to the journal are always evaluated out of any bias.

3. RESPONSIBILITIES OF REFEREES
Reviewers evaluate manuscripts irregardless of the origin, gender, sexual orientation or political philosophy of the authors. Reviewers also ensure a fair blind review process for the evaluation of manuscripts submitted to the journal.
Support to the Editor
Reviewers help editors in decision-making and can also assist authors in improving manuscripts.
Quickness
A reviewer who is not qualified to review the research reported in a manuscript or who knows that it will be impossible to review it in a short period of time should immediately inform the editor and ask to be excused from the review process so that a new reviewer can be assigned.
Privacy
All information regarding the manuscripts submitted to the journal is kept confidential. Reviewers should not discuss with others except ones who are authorized by the editor.
Neutrality
An objective assessment of the decision is always made by the arbitrators. The arbitrators express their views clearly, with appropriate supporting arguments.
Recognition of Resources
Reviewers should be familiar with published work that is not cited by the authors. Any statement that is an observation, derivation or discussion reported in earlier publications should be accompanied by the relevant citation. A reviewer should also inform the editors of any significant similarities or overlaps between the manuscript in question and any other manuscript (published or unpublished) for which they have personal knowledge. For this purpose, he/she may also make use of similarity reporting software to deepen his/her review.
Disclosure and Conflicts of Interest
Invited reviewers should immediately decline the invitation to review and notify the editors if a conflict of interest (competitive, collaborative, or other relationships with any of the authors, companies, or institutions) arises in relation to the manuscripts they review.
Unpublished material contained in a submitted manuscript should not be used by a reviewer in his or her own research without the express written consent of the authors. Privileged information or ideas obtained through peer review should be kept confidential and not used for the personal advantage of the reviewer. This also applies to reviewers who decline an invitation to review.

4. RESPONSIBILITIES OF AUTHORS
Reporting Standards
A manuscript submitted to the journal must be original and authors must ensure that the manuscript has not been previously published in any journal. The data of the research should be fully described in the article. A manuscript submitted to the journal should include sufficient detail and references to allow others to derive the work.
Data Access and Detention
Authors may be asked to provide the raw data of their study in manuscript form for editorial review and should be prepared to make the data publicly available, if applicable. In any case, authors should ensure that these data are available to other authorized professionals at least 10 years after publication (preferably through an institutional or subject-based repository or other data center), provided that the confidentiality of participants can be maintained. Legal rights to proprietary data do not prevent publication.
Originality and Plagiarism
Authors should ensure that they write and submit only entirely original work and that, if they have used the work and/or statements of others, this is indicated by appropriate attribution. Publications that are influential in determining the quality of the work reported in the article should also be mentioned. Plagiarism takes many forms, from writing someone else’s publication as the author’s, to copying significant parts of others’ work (without attribution) or, in other words, taking the results of research conducted by others. Plagiarism in any form constitutes unethical publishing behavior and is unacceptable.
Actions against scientific research and publication ethics are as follows:
a) Plagiarism: Presenting the ideas, methods, data, applications, writings, forms or works of others as one’s own work in whole or in part without citing the authors in accordance with scientific rules,
b) Forgery: Producing data that is not based on research, editing or modifying a submitted or published work based on untrue data, reporting or publishing them, presenting a research that has not been conducted as if it has been conducted,
c) Distortion: Falsifying research records and data obtained, falsifying methods, devices and materials that were not used in the research, excluding data that are not in accordance with the research hypothesis, manipulating data and/or results to fit relevant theories or assumptions, falsifying or shaping research results in line with the interests of the persons and organizations receiving support,
d) Re-publication: Presenting more than one work containing the same results of a research as separate works for associate professorship exam evaluations and academic promotions or for other purposes,
e) Slicing: Inappropriately dividing the results of a research into parts in a way that disrupts the integrity of the research and presenting them as separate works in associate professorship exam evaluations and academic promotions or for other purposes by making a large number of publications without citing each other,
f) Unfair authorship: Including persons without active contribution among the authors, not including persons with active contribution among the authors, changing the order of authors in an unjustified and inappropriate manner, omitting the names of active contributors from the work during publication or in subsequent editions, using his/her influence to have his/her name included among the authors even though he/she has not made an active contribution,
g) Other types of ethical violations: Failure to clearly indicate the persons, institutions or organizations that provided support and their contributions to the research in the publications of the research conducted with support, failure to comply with ethical rules in research on humans and animals, failure to respect patient rights in publications, sharing the information contained in a work assigned to review as a referee with others before publication, misuse of resources, spaces, facilities and devices provided or allocated for scientific research, making completely groundless, unwarranted and deliberate accusations of ethical violations (YÖK Scientific Research and Publication Ethics Directive, Article 8).
Plagiarism Policy
Every review submitted to our journal is scanned by the “iThenticate” plagiarism program. Editors, referees and authors are obliged to comply with international publication ethics rules and the articles must comply with the spelling rules.
Multiple, Duplicate, Redundant or Concurrent Submissions / Publications
The same study should not be published in more than one journal or primary publication. Therefore, authors should not submit an article for review that has already been published in another journal. Submitting an article to more than one journal at the same time is unethical publishing behavior and is unacceptable.
It is sometimes necessary for some articles (such as clinical guidelines, translations) to be published in more than one journal, provided that certain conditions are met. The authors and editors of the journals involved must accept the secondary publication, which should reflect the same data and interpretation of the main document. The primary reference must be cited in the secondary publication.
Multiple Authors
If the manuscript has more than one author, individuals who did not contribute intellectually to the content of the manuscript should not be listed as author(s). Authors of the candidate paper should be limited to those who have made a significant contribution to the submitted work. The authors of the manuscript are finalized before the submission of the manuscript. It is unacceptable to include the names of those who have not contributed to the work in the candidate article (gift authorship) or to omit the names of those who have contributed (ghost authorship). Changing the author responsibilities (such as adding authors, changing the order of authors, removing authors, etc.) cannot be proposed for a study whose evaluation process has started.
Legal / Special Permission Required for Articles
The following cases require legal / special permission from the articles sent to TDID, thus a permission document is requested from the author. In the articles to be published, it is stated in the title footnote of the article whether ethics committee permission, legal / special permission is required. If it is necessary to obtain these permissions, it is requested from the author(s) to clearly state that the permission was obtained from which institution, on which date and with which decision number and it is published as an “Appendix” at the end of the article. The author(s) must have a document showing that they have the rights to use the data obtained, the necessary permissions for the research/analyses, or that the consent of the experimental subjects.
Early View or Assessment Phase
In the event that the author(s) becomes aware of an inaccuracy or error in a published, early view, or under review manuscript, the author(s) has an obligation to notify the journal editor or publisher and to cooperate with the editor in correcting or withdrawing the manuscript.
However, if an author identifies a significant inaccuracy in an article published in TDID, he/she must immediately notify the editor of the journal and cooperate with the editor to retract or correct the article.

5. RELIEF
The editors and editorial board are not responsible for the views expressed by the authors and the content of the articles published in the journal. Originality, proofreading and errors are the responsibility of individual authors. All manuscripts submitted for review and publication in the Journal of Turkish World Studies are subjected to double-blind review for originality, ethical issues and useful contributions. The decisions of the referees are the only means of publication in the journal and are final.

TDİD is a publication of Ege University Institute of Turkish World Studies. It does not receive any payment from authors and other stakeholders and cannot make any payment to authors, referees and other stakeholders.

by-nc.png  Journal of Turkish World Studies is licensed under a Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International license.