Orta Çağ Devletleri Siyasî Sınırlara Sahip Miydi? Kudüs Haçlı Krallığı ve Müslüman Komşuları Arasındaki İktidar Limitleri, Kaleler ve Kolonizasyon Süreci

Abstract

Orta Çağ devletlerinin özü, iktidarlarının sınırları ve bu yapıların nasıl işledikleri üzerine uzun yıllardır ele alınan çalışmalar, sınır tartışmalarının popülerleşmesiyle birlikte son elli yılda farklı bir açıdan desteklenmiştir. Dönemin siyasi yapılarının merkezleri olarak nitelendirilen “saray” gücünün, modern devletlerin aksine oldukça kısıtlı bir hareket alanına sahip oluşu, bu siyasi yapıların üzerinde bulundukları topoğrafya, sosyopolitik çevre, dinî ve kültürel-etnik dağılımlarına dek geniş bir aktör ağı tarafından manipüle edilmelerine yol açıyordu. Bu çalışmada, mevzubahis etkenler tarafından çoğu Orta Çağ iktidarına kıyasla daha çok sınırlandırılmış bir yapı olan Kudüs Haçlı Krallığı üzerine yoğunlaşılacaktır. Haçlıların geldikleri andan itibaren tatbik ettikleri iktidar inşa sürecine dikkat çekilerek, Müslüman komşuları arasındaki savaş ortamının tarafların ulaşılabilir nüfuz alanlarını nereye dek sınırlandırdığı, Kudüs Haçlı Krallığı merkeze alınarak Orta Çağ devletlerinin sınır çizgilerine sahip olup olmadığı ve eğer yoksa politik limitlerin hangi sembolik ve pratik düzlemlerde tahayyül edildiği incelenecektir. Bu süreç son olarak Kudüs Haçlı Krallığı’nın XII. yüzyıldaki iki politikası üzerinden örneklendirilecektir. Bunlar ilk olarak Askâlan politikasındaki Fatımî iktidarıyla olan ilişkileri ve ardından Ürdünötesi Lortluğu’nun inşa süreciyle kalelerin buradaki mahiyeti üzerinedir. Kudüs Haçlı Krallığı’nın tarihini, XII. yüzyılın neredeyse tamamı boyunca adım adım kısıtlı kaynaklarla yürütülen bir kolonizasyon süreci olarak okumakla; kalelerin, orduların ve serhad bölgelerindeki yapılanmaların hangi perspektiften incelenmesi gerektiği üzerinde durulacak, sınır çizgileri olmayan bir “serhad” dünyasında iktidarların birbirlerinden ne şekilde ayrıldığı veyahut ayrılamadığı ortaya konacaktır.

Keywords

• Haçlı Devletleri
• Kudüs Haçlı Krallığı
• Sınır
• Serhad
• Kaleler

Did Medieval States Have Political Borders? The Limits of Power, Castles and Process of Colonization between the Kingdom of Jerusalem and its Muslim Neighbours

Abstract

Long-standing debates on medieval states, mostly focusing on their nature, limits of authorities and how these structures formed, have been fueled by the rising popularity of the frontier discussions in the last fifty years, along a new path. The power of the “palace”, regarded as center of the authority had a very limited field of action, unlike modern states. This allowed it to be manipulated by a huge range of influential actor, ranging across topographical, socio-political, religious and ethno-cultural dynamics where these polities were located. This work focuses on the Kingdom of Jerusalem, more deeply shaped by external actors than many other medieval polities. By examining state-building from its earliest phase, this study examine how extensively the war zone between them and their Muslim neighbours determined their sphere of influences -that each party could reach- whether the medieval states has borderlines arguing centred on Kingdom of Jerusalem, and if not, what symbolic and practical methods were used for imagining political distinction. The analysis will consider two twelfth-century policies: the Ascalon strategy in relations with the Fatimids, and the creation of the Transjordan lordship, while highlighting the role of castles in this process. Reading the Kingdom of Jerusalem’s history as a colonization process carried out gradually with limited sources across 12th century highlights the role of castles, armies, and structures in the border regions. This study examines how power relations unfolded in a “frontier” world without fixed boundaries, showing where forces succeeded—or failed—in maintaining political and territorial separation.

Keywords

• Crusader States
• Kingdom of Jerusalem
• Border
• Frontier
• Castles

References

1. Birincil Kaynaklar
2. Albertus (Albericus) Aquensis, Historia Ierosolymitana, çev. Susan b. Edgington, Oxford: Clarendon, 2007.
3. Annales Bertianini, MGH SS. rr. Germ. V, ed. G. Waitz, Hannover, 1883.
4. Başkeşiş Danylo, The pilgrimage of the Russian abbot Daniel in the Holy Land, 1106-1107 A.D, çev. Charles W. Wilson, Londra: Palestine Pilgrims’ Text Society, 1888.
5. Cartulaire général de l'Ordre des Hospitaliers, I, ed. J. Delaville Le Roulx, Paris: 1894, 97-98, n. 116.
6. Charter Granted by King Henry II at Bridgenorth, NA/CHICTY/A/2/(3), Temmuz 1155.
7. Chronique d'Ernoul et de Bernard le Trésorier, çev. Ahmet Deniz Altunbaş, Haçlı Seferleri Tarihi: Selahaddin Eyyubi ve Haçlılar. İstanbul: Kronik Yayınları, 2019.
8. Çalışır, Abdurrahman Onur, “Saewulf’un Hac Seyahatnamesi, 1102-1103: Kudüs Krallığı’nın İlk Yıllarına Dair Bir Anlatı (Analiz, Çeviri ve Yeni Edisyon)”, MESOS, 3/3 (2021) 1-74.

9. Die Urkunden der Lateinischen Könige von Jerusalem, MGH. DD. Jerus. I., ed. Hans Eberhard Mayer, Hannover 2010, I, 179, n. 49.
10. Die Urkunden der Lateinischen Könige von Jerusalem, MGH. DD. Jerus. I., ed. Hans Eberhard Mayer, Hannover 2010, I, 199-200, n. 65.
11. Die Urkunden Friedrichs I. 1168-1180, MGH, DD. F. I. III, ed. Heinrich Appelt, Hannover 1985, n. 693, 215.
12. Fulbertus Carnotensis, Tractatus Contra Judæos, Patrolagia Latina CXLI, ed. J. P. Migne, Paris: 1880.
13. Fulcherius Carnotensis, Historia Hierosolymitani, ed. Heinrich Hagenmayer, Heidelberg: Carl Winters, 1913.
14. İbn Kalânisî, Zeylü Târîhü Dımaşk, çev. Onur Özatağ, Şam Tarihine Zeyl: I-II. Haçlı Seferleri Dönemi, İstanbul: Türkiye İş Bankası Kültür Yayınları, 2015.
15. İbnü’l-Esir, İslam Tarihi XI, çev. Abdülkerim Özaydın. İstanbul: Bahar Yayınları, 1989.
16. Jacques de Vitry, Historia Hierosolymitana, Lewis E 138/Milan 1459, Free Library of Philadelphia Matthew of Edessa, Armenia and the Crusades: The Chronicle of Matthew of Edessa, çev. Ara Edmond Dostourian. Lanham: University Press of America, 1993.
17. Odo de Diogilo, De Profectione Ludovici VII in Orientem; II. Haçlı Seferi, VII. Louis’nin Doğu’ya Seyahati, çev. Caner Togaç, İstanbul: Kronik Kitap, 2021.
18. Oliverus scholasticus, Historia Damiatina, çev. Joseph J. Gavian, Christian Society and the Crusades, 1198-1229, ed. Edward Peters. Philedelphia: University of Philedelphia Press, 1971. 49-140.
19. Petrus Tudebodus, Historia de Hierosolymitano Itinere, RHC: Historiens occidentaux III, Paris 1866.
20. Reinhold Röhricht, Regesta regni Hierosolymitani (MXCVII-MCCXCI). Oeniponti: Libraria Acad. Wagneria 1893. no. 366, 96-97.
21. Rorgo Fretellus, Descriptio de locis sanctis, çev. J. R. Macpherson, Londra: Palastine Pilgrims’ Text Society, 1896.
22. Usame ibn Munkîz, İbretler Kitabı (Kitabü’l-İ’tibar), çev. Yusuf Ziya Cömert, İstanbul: Kitabevi Yayınları, 2018.
23. Willelmus Tyrensis, chronicon I-II, Corpvs Christianorvm Continuatio Mediaeulis LXIII/ ve LXIIIA, ed. R. B. C. Huygens, Turnholt: Brepols, 1986.
24. Ansiklopedi Maddeleri
25. Gabonis, Aryeh. “Nablus”, The Crusades: An Encyclopedia, III. ed. Alan V. Murray, (Santa Barbara): ABC-CLİO 2006. 863-864.
26. Pringle, Pringle, “Ramla”, The Crusades: An Encyclopedia, IV, ed. Alan V. Murray, (Santa Barbara): ABC-CLİO 2006. 1004-1005.
27. Tanner, Heather J. “Eustace III of Boulogne”, The Crusades: An Encyclopedia, II., ed. Alan V. Murray, (Santa Barbara): ABC-CLİO 2006. 416-417.
28. İkincil Kaynaklar
29. Abulafia, David ve Berend Nora (ed.) Medieval Frontiers: Concepts and Practices. Aldershot: Ashgate, 2002.
30. Anderson, Benedict. Imagined Communities:Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism, Londra - New York: Verso, 1991.
31. Ardealan F. N., Cîmpeanu L., Fodor G., Magina, L. (ed.), From Medieval Frontiers to Early Modern Borders in Central and South-Eastern Europe. Berlin: Peter Lang, 2022.
32. Armstrong, D. Kecskés A. Rozier C. Ve Kicks L. V. (ed.), Borders and the Norman World: Frontiers and Boundaries in Medieval Europe. Boydell&Brewer, 2023.
33. Barber, Malcolm. “The Challenge of State Building in the Twelfth Century: The Crusader States in Palestine and Syria”, Reading Medieval Studies, 36 (2010): 7-22.
34. Barber, Malcolm. A New Knighthood: A History of the Order of the Temple. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2000.
35. Barber, Malcolm. Haçlı Devletleri Tarihi, çev. Doğan Mert Demir, İstanbul: Kronik Kitap, 2020.
36. Bartlett, R.- MacKay, A. (ed), Medieval Frontier Societies Oxford: Clarendon, 1989.
37. Berend, Nora. “Medievalists and the Notion of the Frontier”, The Medieval History Journal II/1 (1999), 55-72.
38. Brett, Michael: The Fatimid Empire, Edinburg: Edinburgh University Press, 2017.
39. Brown, Robin M. “Petra Deserti (al-Karak) and the Landscape of Frankish Transjordan in European Cartography from the Twelfth through the Fifteenth Century”, Studies on the History and Archaeology of Jordan, 11 (2023): 703-733.
40. Buck, Andrew D. “The Castle and Lordship of Ḥārim and the Frankish-Muslim Frontier of Northern Syria in the Twelfth Century”, Al-Masāq 28/2 (2016), 113-31.
41. Buck, Andrew D. “Castles and the frontier: theorizing the borders of the principality of Antioch in the twelfth century”, Viator 50/2, (2019), 79-107.
42. Burns R. I., “The Significance of the Frontier in the Middle Ages”, Medieval Frontier Societies, ed. Robert Bartlett- Angus MacKay, Oxford: Clarendon, 1992.
43. Cédric Devais, “A Seigneury on the Eastern Borders of the Kingdom of Jerusalem: The Kingdom of Jerusalem: The Terre de Suète”, Studies in the Archeology of the Medieval Mediterranean, ed. James Goerge Schryver, Leiden: Brill Publishing, 2010.
44. Constable, Giles. “Frontiers in the Middle Ages”, Frontiers in the Middle Ages: Proceedings of the Third European Congress of Medieval Studies (Jyvaskylai, 10-14 June 2003), ed. Outi Merisalo, Louvain-la-neuve: Brepols, 2006, 3-28.
45. Curta, Florin (ed.). Borders, Barriers, and Ethnogenesis: Frontiers in Late Antiquity and the Middle Ages.Turnhout: Brepols Publishing, 2005.
46. Çeken, Muhittin. “Fortified positions of the Military Orders in the Amanos and Cilicia region: Baghras, Trapesac, Çalan, Amuda and Silifke Castles”, Military Orders VIII, ed. E. Buttigieg, C. A. Vidal, Abingdon: Routledge, 2025.
47. Çeken, Muhittin. “Tapınak Şövalyeleri ve Bağrâs Kalesi: Yayılma Stratejilerinin Askerî Örüntüleri”, Manisa Celal Bayar Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Dergisi, 20, s. 1 (2020), 151-171.
48. Demirkent, Işın. Urfa Haçlı Kontluğu Tarihi I, Ankara: TTK Yayınları, 1994.
49. Deschamps, Paul. Les Châteaux des croisés en Terre Sainte. Vol. II: La défense du Royaume de Jérusalem: étude historique, géographique et monumentale Bibliothèque archéologique et historique, Paris: Paul Gaunthier, 1939.
50. Deschamps, Paul., Les Châteaux des Croisés en Terre Sainte, Le Crac des Chevaliers. Paris: P. Gauthner, 1934.
51. Edgington, Susan B. Baldwin I of Jerusalem, 1100-1118, Abingdon: Routledge, 2019.
52. Ellenblum, Ronnie. “Were there Borders and Borderlines in the Middle Ages? The Example of the Latin Kingdom of Jerusalem”, Medieval Frontiers: Concepts and Practices, ed. D. Abulafia ve N. Berend, Londra: Routledge, 2002.
53. Ellenblum, Ronnie. Crusader Castles and Modern Histories, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2007.
54. Febvre, Lucien. “Frontière: The Word and the Concept,”, A New Kind of History: From the Writings of Lucien Febvre, ed. Peter Burke, New York: Harper & Row Publishing, 1973.
55. Fink, Harold S. “Foundations of the Latin States 1099-1118”, A History of the Crusades I: First Hundred Years, ed. Kenneth M. Setton, Medison, Milwauuke ve Londra: University of Wisconsin Press, 1969.
56. France, John, Victory in the East: A Military History of First Crusade, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1996.
57. France, John. “Warfare in the Mediterranean Region in the Age of Crusades: A Clash of Contrast”, Warfare, Crusade and Conquest in the Middle Ages, ed. John France, Routledge: Abingdon, 2015.
58. Giddens, Anthony. The Nation-State and Violence, Berkeley: University of California Press, 1987.
59. Hobsbawn, Eric. Milletler ve Milliyetçilik: Program, Mit, Gerçeklik, çev. Osman Akınhay, İstanbul: Ayrıntı Yayınları, 2010.
60. Hoch, Martin. “The Crusaders' Strategy Against Fatimid Ascalon and the ‘Ascalon Project’ of the Second Crusade”, The Second Crusade and the Cistercians, ed. Michael Gervers, Londra: Palgrave Macmillan, 1992.
61. Holdich, T.H. Frontiers and Boundary Making, Londra: Macmillan and Company, 1916.
62. Hourani, Albert. A History of the Arab Peoples, Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press, 1991.
63. Janeczek, Andrzej. “Frontiers and Borderlands in Medieval Europe. Introductionary Remarks”, Questiones Medii Aevi Novae, XVI: Frontiers and Borderlands, ed. A. Janeczek, Varşova: Societas Vistulana, 2011, 5-14.
64. Kaldellis, Anthony. ‘Byzantine Borders were State Artifacts, not ‘Fluid Zones of Interaction’,’ D. G. Tor ve A. D. Beihammer, (ed.), The Islamic-Byzantine Border in History: From the Rise of Islam to the End of the Crusades. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, 2023.
65. Karaca, Sevtap Gölgesiz. Kudüs Haçlı Krallığı Tarihi, Ankara: TTK Yayınları, 2022.
66. Karp, Hans-Jürgen, Grenzen in Ostmitteleuropa während des Mittelalters: Ein Beitrag zur Entstehungsgeschichte der Grenzlinie aus dem Grenzsaum, Viyana: Böhlau Verlag, 1972.
67. Kedar, Benjamin Z. “Civitas and Castellum in the Latin Kingdom of Jerusalem: Contemporary Frankish Perceptions”, Burgen und Schlösser, 50/4 (2009): 199-210.
68. Kennedy, Hugh. Crusader Castles, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1995.
69. Lay, Stephen. The Reconquest Kings of Portugal: Political and Cultural Reorientation on the Medieval Frontier. Londra: Palgrave Macmillan, 2009.
70. Lewis, Archibald R. “The Closing of the Medieval Frontier 1250-1350”, Speculum, 33/4 (1958): 475-485.
71. Lewis, Kevin James. “Shifting Borders in the Latin East: The Case of the County of Tripoli”, Crusader Landscapes in the Medieval Levant: The Archaeology and History of the Latin East, ed. M. Sinibaldi, K. J. Lewis, B. Major, J. A. Thompson, Cardiff: University of Wales Press, 2016, 103-116.
72. Mayer, Hans Eberhard, The Crusades, 2nd edition, çev. John Gillingham, Oxford: Clarendon Press, 2009.
73. Mayer, Hans Eberhard. Die Kreuzfahrerherrschaft Montréal (Šōbak): Jordanien im 12. Jahrhundert, Wiesbaden: Harrassowitz Verlag, 1990.
74. Mayer, Hans Eberhard. “Die Herrschaftsbildung in Hebron”, Zeitschrift des Deutschen Palästina-Vereins, 101/1 (1985): 64-81.
75. Mayer, Hans Eberhard. “The Origins of the Lordships of Ramla and Lydda in the Latin Kingdom of Jerusalem”, Speculum, 60/3, (1985), 537-552.
76. Micaela Sinibaldi, “The Crusader Lordship of Transjordan (1100–1189): Settlement Forms, Dynamics and Significance”, Levant, 54/1 (2022): 124-154.
77. Morton, Nicholas. Crusader States and their Neigbhbours: A Military History 1099-1187, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2020.
78. Murray, Alan V. (ed.) The North-Eastern frontiers of Medieval Europe: The expansion of Latin christendom in the Baltic lands, Farnham: Routledge, 2014.
79. Murray, Alan V. ‘‘Franks and Indigenous Communities in Palestine and Syria (1099–1187): A Hierarchical Model of Social Interaction in the Principalities of Outremer’’, East Meets West in the Middle Ages and Early Modern Times: Transcultural Experiences in the Premodern World, ed. Albrecht Classen, Berlin: De Gruyter, 2013.
80. Murray, A. V., The Crusader Kingdom: A Dynastic History 1099-1125, Prosopograhica et Genealogica 2000.
81. Murray, A. V. “Daimbert of Pisa, the Domus Godefridi and the Accession of Baldwin I of Jerusalem”, From Clermont to Jerusalem: The Crusades and Crusader Societies 1095-1500, ed. Alan V. Murray, Turnhout: Brepols, 1998.
82. Nail, Thomas, Thomas Nail, Theory of the Border, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2016.
83. Outi Merisalo (ed.). Frontiers in the Middle Ages: Proceedings of the Third European Congress of Medieval Studies, Louvain-la-Neuve: Brepols Publishing, 2006.
84. Pohl, Walter, Wood, Ian ve Reinitz Helmuth. (ed.), The Transformation of Frontiers. From Late Antiquity to the Carolingians, Leiden: Brill, 2000.
85. Pounds, N. G. “The Origin of the Idea of Natural Frontiers in France”, Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 41/2 (1951): 146-157.
86. Power, Daniel. The Norman Frontier in the Twelfth and Early Thirteenth Centuries, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2004.
87. Power, Daniel. Ve Standen Naomi. (ed). Frontiers in Question: Eurasian Borderlands, 700-1700. Basingstoke: Red Globe Press, 1999.
88. Prawer, Joshua. Prawer, The Crusaders’ Kingdom: European Colonialism in the Middle Ages. New York: Praeger Publishers, 1972.
89. Pringle, Deyns. “Castles and Frontiers in the Latin East”, Norman Expansion: Connections, contunieties and contrast, ed. Keith J. Stringer ve Andrew Jotischky. Abingdon: Routledge, 2016.
90. Pringle, Denys. “Castles and Frontiers in the Latin East”. Norman Expansion, ed. K. Stringer ve A. Jotischky, Farnham: Ashgate, 2013.
91. Pringle, Denys. Pilgrimage to Jerusalem and the Holy Land, 1187-1291, Londra: Routledge, 2012.
92. Pringle, Denys. Secular Buildings in the Crusader Kingdom of Jerusalem: An Archeological Gazetteer. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1997.
93. Prutz, Hans. Kulturgeschichte der Kreuzzüge, Berlin: Verlag E.S. Mittler & Sohn GmbH, 1883.
94. Ralph W. Brauer, “Boundaries and Frontiers in Medieval Muslim Geography”, Transactions of the American Philosophical Society, 85/6 (1995): 1-73.
95. Ratzel, Friedrich. Politische Geographie, Leipzig: R. Oldenbourg Verlag, 1897.
96. Rey, Emmanuel-Guillaume. Études sur les Monuments de l’architecture militaire des Croisés en Syrie et dans l'lle de Chypre, Paris: Imprimerie Nationale, 1871.
97. Reynolds, Susan. “There were States in Medieval Europe: A Response to Rees Davies”, Journal of Historical Sociology, 16/4 (2003): 550-555.
98. Reynolds, Susan. Fiefs and Vassals: The Medieval Evidence Reinterpreted, Oxford: Clarendon, 1994.
99. Runciman, Steven. Haçlı Seferleri Tarihi I, çev. Fikret Işıltan, Ankara: TTK Yayınları 1989.
100. Sahlins, Peter. Boundaries: The Making of France and Spain in the Pyrenees, Berkeley: University of California Press, 1989.
101. Schenk, J. G., “Nomadic Violence in the First Latin Kingdoms of Jerusalem and the Military Orders”, Medieval Studies, 36 (2010): 39-55.
102. Sinibaldi, Micaela. Settlement in Crusader Transjordan (1100–1189): A Historical and Archaeological Study, Yayımlanmamış Doktora Tezi. Cardiff University, 2014.
103. Smail, R. C. “Crusaders' Castles of the Twelfth Century”, The Cambridge Historical Journal, 10/2 (1951): 133-149.
104. Riley-Smith, Jonathan. The First Crusaders 1100-1131, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1997.
105. Sylvia Schraut, Kartierte Nationalgeschichte: Geschihtsatlanten im internationalen Vergleich 1860-1960, Frankfurt: Campus Verlag, 2011.
106. Şahan, Onuralp. Kuzey Suriye ve Küçük Asya’daki Haçlı Devletleri’nin Sınırları: XII. Yüzyılda İktidar İnşa Süreci, Yayımlanmamış Yüksek Lisans Tezi. Mimar Sinan Güzel Sanatlar Üniversitesi İstanbul 2024.
107. Şeşen, Ramazan. Selâhaddin Eyyûbî ve Dönemi, İstanbul: Bilge Kültür Sanat, 2018.
108. Tezcan, Selim. “Haçlı Seferleri- Tanımı ve Ötesi: Avrupa Orta Çağ Tarihçiliğinde Haçlı Seferleri Üzerine Süregiden Tartışmalar”, Orta Çağ’a Yeni Yaklaşımlar: Ekonomi, Savaş, Kilise, Yaşam, ed. Zeynep Kocabıyıkoğlu Çeçen, İstanbul: Tarih Vakfı Yurt Yayınları 2019.
109. Tibble, Steve. The Crusader Strategy: Defending the Holy Land 1099-1187, New Haven: Yale University Press, 2020.
110. Tibble, Steve. Monarchy and Lordship in the Latin Kingdom of Jerusalem, Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1989.
111. Turner, Frederick Jackson, The Significance of the Frontier in the American History. New York: Henry Holt Company, 1921.
112. Usta, Aydın. Haçlı Seferlerinde Kuşatma, İstanbul: Yeditepe Yayınevi, 2015.
113. Vandekerckhhove, Dweezil. Medieval Fortifications in Cilicia: The Armenian Contribution to Military Architecture in the Middle Ages, Leiden: Brill, 2020.
114. Vannini, Guido ve Desideri, Andrea Vanni. “Archeological research on Medieval Petra: A priliminary report, Annual of the Department of Antiquities of Jordan, 39 (1995), 509-540.
115. Vannini, Guido ve Tonghini, Christina. “Medieval Petra. The Stratigraphic Evidence from Recent Archeological Excavations at al-Wu’ayra”, Studies in the History and Archeology of Jordan, 4 (1997): 371-384.
116. Walker, Bethany J. “Mamluk Investment in Transjordan: a ‘Boom and Bust Economy’, Mamluk Studies Review, 8/2 (2004), 119-148.
117. Wojciech, Iwańczak. ‘‘Borders and Borderlines in Medieval Cartography’’, Frontiers in the Middle Ages: Proceedings of the Third European Congress of Medieval Studies, ed. O. Merisalo, Louvain-la-Neuve: Brepols Publishing, 2006.