СЛОЖНОСТЬ РОЛЕЙ: ПОЛИТИКА ИЗРАИЛЯ В ОТНОШЕНИИ КОНФЛИКТА МЕЖДУ РОССИЕЙ И УКРАИНОЙ

Abstract

Российско-украинский конфликт значительно изменил глобальные геополитические динамики, вынуждая средние и малые державы балансировать между давлением мировых сверхдержав. В данном исследовании анализируется внешняя политика Израиля в контексте российско-украинского конфликта, начавшегося в 2022 году и продолжающегося по сей день, через призму Теории ролей с особым акцентом на Национальные ролевые концепции (НРК). Исследование выделяет три ключевые НРК — Поставщик гуманитарной помощи, Посредник и Стратегический союзник, которые являются центральными для понимания осторожного и многогранного подхода Израиля к этому конфликту. Эти роли отражают усилия Израиля по балансированию между историческими союзами с Западом и стратегическими договоренностями с Россией, особенно в контексте региональной безопасности на Ближнем Востоке. Исследование опирается на качественный контент-анализ официальных заявлений акторов, включая премьер-министров и высокопоставленных оборонных чиновников, с целью выявить, как НРК влияют на принятие внешнеполитических решений в условиях противоречивых внешних ожиданий и внутренних политических динамик. Роль поставщика гуманитарной помощи подчеркивает приверженность Израиля своим моральным обязательствам и исторической идентичности, что находит отражение в предоставлении гуманитарной помощи Украине. Роль посредника демонстрирует попытки Израиля использовать свои уникальные отношения как с Россией, так и с Украиной для содействия диалогу и снижения напряженности, хотя эти усилия имели ограниченный успех. В то же время роль стратегического союзника подчеркивает стремление Израиля поддерживать свои обязательства перед западными партнерами, особенно перед Соединенными Штатами, одновременно осторожно управляя своей зависимостью от России в сфере безопасности в Сирии. Это исследование восполняет пробел в существующей литературе, применяя Теорию ролей к внешней политике Израиля в контексте российско-украинского конфликта. Оно предоставляет ценные аналитические инструменты для понимания того, как средние державы, подобные Израилю, маневрируют в условиях сложных международных кризисов, уравновешивая противоречивые ожидания и обеспечивая стратегическую гибкость. Результаты исследования способствуют как теоретическому развитию применения НРК в анализе внешней политики, так и практическим рекомендациям для политиков, сталкивающихся с аналогичными геополитическими вызовами. В конечном итоге, это исследование углубляет наше понимание поведения средних держав в условиях растущей многополярности и неопределенности международного порядка.

Keywords

• Россия
• Израиль
• Российско-украинская война
• теория ролей
• ролевые концепции
• внешняя политика

COMPLEXITY OF ROLES: ISRAEL’S POLICYMAKING TOWARDS THE RUSSIA-UKRAINE WAR

Abstract

The Russia-Ukraine War has significantly reshaped global geopolitical dynamics, compelling middle and small powers to navigate the competing pressures of global superpowers. This study examines Israel’s foreign policy towards the Russia-Ukraine War, which began in 2022 and continues to this day, through the lens of Role Theory, with a particular focus on National Role Conceptions (NRCs). The research identifies three key NRCs—Humanitarian Aid Provider, Mediator, and Strategic Ally—as central to understanding Israel’s nuanced and cautious approach to the conflict. These roles reflect Israel’s efforts to balance historical alliances with the West and its strategic arrangements with Russia, particularly in the context of regional security dynamics in the Middle East. The study employs qualitative content analysis of official statements made by key actors, including prime ministers and defense officials, to uncover how NRCs guide foreign policy decisions amidst conflicting external pressures and internal political dynamics. The Humanitarian Aid Provider role highlights Israel’s commitment to its moral obligations and historical identity, evident in its provision of humanitarian assistance to Ukraine. The Mediator role demonstrates Israel’s attempt to leverage its unique relationships with both Russia and Ukraine to facilitate dialogue and reduce tensions, albeit with limited success. Meanwhile, the Strategic Ally role underscores Israel’s efforts to maintain its commitments to Western partners, particularly the United States, while carefully managing its security dependencies on Russia in Syria. This study addresses a gap in the existing literature by applying Role Theory to Israel’s foreign policy in the context of the Russia-Ukraine conflict. It provides valuable insights into how middle powers, like Israel, navigate complex international crises by balancing competing expectations and pursuing strategic flexibility. The findings contribute both theoretically, by advancing the application of NRCs in foreign policy analysis, and practically, by offering recommendations for policymakers facing similar geopolitical challenges. Ultimately, this research enhances our understanding of middle power behavior in an increasingly multipolar and uncertain international order.

Keywords

• Russia
• Israel
• Russia-Ukraine War
• role theory
• role conceptions
• foreign policy

ROLLERİN KARMAŞIKLIĞI: İSRAİL’İN RUSYA-UKRAYNA SAVAŞI’NA YÖNELİK POLİTİKA YAPIMI

Abstract

Rusya-Ukrayna Savaşı, küresel jeopolitik dinamikleri önemli ölçüde yeniden şekillendirerek orta ve küçük güçleri küresel süper güçlerin baskıları arasında hassas bir denge kurmaya zorlamıştır. Bu çalışma, 2022’de başlayan ve hâlâ devam eden Rusya-Ukrayna Savaşı sırasında İsrail’in dış politikasını Rol Teorisi çerçevesinde incelemekte ve özellikle Ulusal Rol Kavramları’na (URK) odaklanmaktadır. Araştırma, İsrail’in bu ihtilaftaki temkinli ve incelikli yaklaşımını anlamada üç temel URK’yi öne çıkarmaktadır: İnsani Yardım Sağlayıcı, Arabulucu ve Stratejik Müttefik. Bu roller, İsrail’in Batı ile olan tarihi ittifaklarını ve Orta Doğu’daki güvenlik dinamikleri bağlamında Rusya ile kurduğu stratejik düzenlemelerini dengeleme çabalarını yansıtmaktadır. Çalışma, başbakanlar ve savunma yetkilileri gibi kilit aktörlerin yaptığı resmî açıklamaların nitel içerik analizini kullanarak, URK’ların dış politika kararlarını iç ve dış baskılar arasındaki çatışmalar ışığında nasıl şekillendirdiğini ortaya koymaktadır. İnsani Yardım Sağlayıcı rolü, İsrail’in ahlaki yükümlülüklerine ve tarihsel kimliğine olan bağlılığını vurgulamakta ve Ukrayna’ya sağlanan insani yardımlarda somutlaşmaktadır. Arabulucu rolü, İsrail’in Rusya ve Ukrayna ile olan benzersiz ilişkilerini kullanarak diyalog kurma ve gerilimi azaltma çabalarını göstermekte, ancak bu çabalar sınırlı başarı sağlamaktadır. Öte yandan, Stratejik Müttefik rolü, İsrail’in özellikle Amerika Birleşik Devletleri gibi Batılı ortaklarına olan taahhütlerini sürdürme çabalarını yansıtırken, aynı zamanda Suriye’deki güvenlik bağımlılıkları nedeniyle Rusya ile ilişkilerini dikkatli bir şekilde yönetmesini gerektirmektedir. Bu çalışma, Rol Teorisi’ni Rusya-Ukrayna Savaşı bağlamında İsrail dış politikasına uygulayarak literatürdeki bir boşluğu doldurmaktadır. Araştırma, orta güçlerin İsrail örneğinde olduğu gibi karmaşık uluslararası krizlerde çelişen beklentileri nasıl dengelediklerine ve stratejik esnekliği nasıl sürdürdüklerine dair değerli içgörüler sunmaktadır. Bulgular, hem teorik olarak URK’lerin dış politika analizine uygulanmasını ilerleterek hem de pratik olarak benzer jeopolitik zorluklarla karşılaşan politika yapıcılara öneriler sunarak katkıda bulunmaktadır. Sonuç olarak, bu araştırma artan çok kutuplu ve belirsiz uluslararası düzende orta güçlerin davranışlarını anlamamıza önemli bir katkı sağlamaktadır

Keywords

• Rusya
• İsrail
• Rusya-Ukrayna Savaşı
• rol teorisi
• rol kavramları
• dış politika

References

1. Aaron Boxerman and Jacob Magid, "European diplomat criticizes Israeli balancing act on Ukraine invasion", Times of Israel, Erişim. 18.12.2022, https://www.timesofisrael.com/european-diplomat-criticizes-israeli-balancing-act-on-ukraine-invasion/
2. Ahronheim, Anna. "Israel won’t give Ukraine weapons, will help make missile warning system - Gantz." The Jerusalem Post (10.19.2022). Erişim 15.11.2024. https://www.jpost.com/breaking-news/article-720028
3. Akbaba, Yasemin & Özgür Özdamar. Role Theory in the Middle East and North Africa: Politics, Economics and Identity. London: Routledge, 2019.
4. Amir, Merav. "The Israeli reaction to the war in Ukraine." The Institute for Human Sciences (2022). Erişim 15.11.2024. https://www.iwm.at/publication/iwmpost-article/the-israeli-reaction-to-the-war-in-ukraine
5. Ammon, Aran. Israeli Foreign Policy since the End of the Cold War. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2020.
6. Aronoff, Yael S. The Political Psychology of Israeli Prime Ministers: When Hard-Liners Opt for Peace. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2014.
7. Barak Ravid, " Israel's Bennett emerges as key mediator between Putin and Zelensky, Axios(09.03.2022), Erişim 18 Aralık 2024, https://www.axios.com/2022/03/09/bennett-mediator-russia-ukraine-putin-zelensky".
8. Bar-Siman-Tov, Yaacov. Israel, the Superpowers, and the War in the Middle East. New York: Praeger Pub Text, 1987.

9. BBC. “We fight to defend Europe’s way of life – Zelensky.” (09.02.2023). Erişim 15.11.2024. https://www.bbc.com/news/live/uk-politics-64580204
10. Berman, Lazar. "Bennett refrains from condemning Russia in first remarks since invasion of Ukraine." The Times of Israel (24.02.2022). Erişim 15.11.2024. https://www.timesofisrael.com/bennett-refrains-from-condemning-russia-in-first-remarks-since-invasion-of-ukraine/
11. Britain Israel Communications and Research Centre. "Israeli efforts at mediation set to continue." (2022). Erişim 15.11.2024. https://www.bicom.org.uk/news/israeli-efforts-at-mediation-set-to-continue/.
12. Cashman, Greer Fay. "Herzog joins call for Israelis to immediately leave Ukraine." The Jerusalem Post (2022). Erişim 15.11.2024. https://www.jpost.com/israel-news/politics-and-diplomacy/article-698557
13. CNN. "One-on-one interview with Israeli PM Netanyahu." (31.01.2023). Erişim 15.11.2024. https://transcripts.cnn.com/show/se/date/2023-01-31/segment/01.
14. Dahlia Scheindlin, Should Israel Arm Ukraine? Israeli Generals Speak Out, Haaretz, Erişim, 18.12.2014, https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2022-03-16/ty-article-opinion/.highlight/should-israel-arm-ukraine-israeli-generals-speak-out/00000180-5bb5-db1e-a1d4-dff5d2af0000.
15. Defense Security Cooperation Agency. "Major non-NATO allies." Erişim 15.11.2024. https://samm.dsca.mil/glossary/major-non-nato-allies.
16. Doğan Akkaş, Betül. “Bahraini-Turkish Relations.” Insight Turkey 26/2 (2024): 205-228.
17. Dunne, Charles. "Arab and Israeli positions on Ukraine war continue to frustrate the US." Arab Center Washington DC (18.01.2023). Erişim 15.11.2024. https://arabcenterdc.org/resource/arab-and-israeli-positions-on-ukraine-war-continue-to-frustrate-the-us/
18. Dupeyron, Catherine. "Ukraine war sparks divisions among Israel’s Russian population." Worldcrunch (01.08.2022). Erişim 15.11.2024. https://worldcrunch.com/focus/the-great-dilemma-of-russian-speaking-israelis
19. Elgström, Ole & Michael Smith. The European Union’s Roles in International Politics: Concepts and Analysis. London: Routledge, 2006.
20. Folz, Rachel. “Does EU membership matter?.” In Role Theory in International Relations, edited by Sebastian Harnisch, Cornelia Frank & Hanns W. Maull, 147-164. London: Routledge, 2011.
21. Frantzman, Seth J. "U.S., Israel, and Russia focus on Syria." Middle East Forum (07.20.2022). Erişim 15.11.2024. https://www.meforum.org/us-israel-and-russia-focus-on-syria
22. Freilich, Charles D. “National security decision-making in Israel: Improving the process.” Middle East Journal 67/2 (2013): 257-266.
23. Gelvin, James L. The Israel-Palestine Conflict: One Hundred Years of War. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2005.
24. Glod, Katia. "Europe’s dark future: How might a protracted conflict between Russia and Ukraine affect Europe?." European Leadership Network (03.05.2024). Erişim 15.11.2024. https://europeanleadershipnetwork.org/commentary/europes-dark-future-how-might-a-protracted-conflict-between-russia-and-ukraine-affect-europe/
25. Gordis, Daniel. Israel: A Concise History of a Nation Reborn. New York: HarperCollins Publishers, 2016.
26. Grossman, Michael, Francis Schortgen & Gordon M. Friedrichs. National Role Conceptions in a New Millennium: Defining a Place in a Changing World. London: Routledge, 2022.
27. Hokayem, Emil. "The Gulf states, Israel and Turkiye: Reactions to the war in Ukraine." International Institute for Strategic Studies (21.02.2023). Erişim 15.11.2024. https://www.iiss.org/online-analysis/online-analysis/2023/02/the-gulf-states-israel-and-turkiye-reactions-to-the-war-in-ukraine/ Holsti, Kalevi. "National role conceptions in the study of foreign policy." International Studies Quarterly 14/3 (1970): 233-309.
28. İletişim Başkanlığı. “Cumhurbaşkanı Erdoğan: ‘Dünyanın neresinde bir mazlum, mağdur, garip, hakkı hukuku ihlal edilen insan varsa tüm gücümüzle biz onların yanındayız.’” (10.12.2019). Erişim 15.11.2024. https://www.iletisim.gov.tr/turkce/haberler/detay/cumhurbaskani-erdogan-dunyanin-neresinde-bir-mazlum-magdur-garip-hakki-hukuku-ihlal-edilen-insan-varsa-tum-gucumuzle-biz-onlarin-yanindayiz Iordache, Ruxandra. "Israel’s Netanyahu concerned its defense systems may reach Iran if sent to Ukraine."
29. CNBC (29.06.2023). Erişim 15.11.2024. https://www.cnbc.com/2023/06/29/israels-netanyahu-concerned-its-defense-systems-may-reach-iran-if-sent-to-ukraine.html
30. Jones, Clive & Emma C. Murphy. Israel: Challenges to Identity, Democracy, and the State. London: Routledge, 2002.
31. Kaarbo, Juliet. "Influencing Peace: Junior Partners in Israeli Coalition Cabinets." Cooperation and Conflict 31/3 (1996): 243-284.
32. Keller Lynn, Carrie. "100 tons of humanitarian aid en route from Israel to Ukraine." The Times of Israel (2022). Erişim 15.11.2024. https://www.timesofisrael.com/100-tons-of-humanitarian-aid-en-route-from-israel-to-ukraine/
33. Kelner, Shaul. "As Russia threatens to shutter Jewish Agency, many hear echoes of the past." The Times of Israel (01.03.2022). Erişim 15.11.2024. https://www.timesofisrael.com/as-russia-threatens-to-shutter-jewish-agency-many-hear-echoes-of-the-past/
34. Khalidi, Rashid I. The Hundred Years’ War on Palestine: A History of Settler Colonialism and Resistance, 1917-2017. Picador, 2020.
35. Lazaroff, Tovah & Lahav Harkov. "Israel to condemn Russia’s invasion of Ukraine at UNGA - Lapid." The Jerusalem Post (28.02.2022). Erişim 15.11.2024. https://www.jpost.com/international/article-698867
36. Lazer Berman, "Israel focusing on closing loopholes, not imposing Russia sanctions, officials say", The Times of Israel, Erişim, 18.12.2024, https://www.timesofisrael.com/israel-not-about-to-impose-sanctions-on-russia-or-oligarchs-officials-say/
37. Le Prestre, Philippe G. Role Quests in the Post-Cold War Era: Foreign Policies in Transition. Montreal: McGill-Queen’s University Press, 1997.
38. Lis, Jonathan & Liza Rozovsky. "PM Netanyahu slams ‘disgraceful’ Palestinian-led UN vote on ICJ: ‘Does not bind Israel’." Haaretz (31.12.2022). Erişim 15.11.2024. https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2022-12-31/ty-article/.premium/netanyahu-asked-zelenskyy-to-vote-against-palestinian-un-request-ukrainian-official-says/00000185-692a-d6a2-adf5-69ea465a0000
39. Loera-Gonzalez, Omar A. Role Theory and Mexico’s Foreign Policy. London: Routledge, 2023.
40. Magen, Amichai. “Comparative assessment of Israel’s foreign policy response to the ‘Arab Spring’." Journal of European Integration 37/1 (2015): 113-133.
41. Magid, Jacob. "Condemning Russia on global stage, Israel at UN says Ukraine invasion must end." The Times of Israel (02.03.2022). Erişim 15.11.2024. https://www.timesofisrael.com/condemning-russia-on-global-stage-israel-at-un-says-ukraine-invasion-must-end/
42. Malici, Akan & Stephen G. Walker. Role Theory and Role Conflict in U.S.-Iran Relations: Enemies of Our Own Making. London: Routledge, 2016.
43. Maull, Hanns W. "Germany and Japan: The new civilian powers." Foreign Affairs 69/5 (1990/91): 91-106.
44. Mayring, Philip. Einführung in die Qualitative Sozialforschung. Weinheim und Basel: Beltz Verlag, 1999.
45. Meduza. "120,000 dead and counting: A new estimate from Meduza and Mediazona shows the rate of Russian military deaths in Ukraine is only growing." (05.07.2024). Erişim 15.11.2024. https://meduza.io/en/feature/2024/07/05/a-new-estimate-from-meduza-and-mediazona-shows-the-rate-of-russian-military-deaths-in-ukraine-is-only-growing
46. Milton-Edwards, Beverley. The Israeli-Palestinian Conflict: A People’s War. London: Routledge, 2008.
47. Ministry of Foreign Affairs Israel, For the first time since the beginning of the war in Ukraine, an Israeli Foreign Minister is visiting Kyiv, 16.02.2023, Retrieved from https://www.gov.il/en/departments/news/fm-cohen-diplomaticvisit-to-kiev.
48. Ministry of Foreign Affairs. "Government approves establishing a field hospital in Ukraine." (14.03.2022). Erişim 15.11.2024. https://www.gov.il/en/pages/government-approves-field-hospital-in-ukraine-14-mar-2022
49. Ministry of Foreign Affairs. "Israel condemns attack in Ukraine." (24.02.2022). Erişim 15.11.2024. https://www.gov.il/en/pages/israel-condemns-attack-in-ukraine-24-feb-2022.
50. Ministry of Foreign Affairs. "Israel to host 25,000 Ukrainian citizens until the danger subsides in their country." (08.03.2022). Erişim 15.11.2024. https://www.gov.il/en/pages/israel-to-host-25000-ukrainian-citizens-8-3-2022
51. Poroskoun, Georgy & Yaron Gamburg. "Changing Israel’s policy on Russia and Ukraine." Institute for National Security Studies (03.01.2024). Erişim 15.11.2024. https://www.inss.org.il/publication/russia-ukraine-israel/
52. Prime Minister’s Office. "PM Bennett attends BGI Airport departure ceremony for the Israeli aid delegation that will establish a field hospital in Ukraine." (25.02.2022). Erişim 15.11.2024. https://www.gov.il/en/pages/event_hospital210322
53. Prime Minister’s Office. "PM Bennett speaks with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky." (2022). Erişim 15.11.2024. https://www.gov.il/en/pages/spoke_ukraine
54. Rakov, Dov. "Israel’s Russia-Ukraine dilemma." Australia/Israel & Jewish Affairs Council (2023). Erişim 15.11.2024. https://aijac.org.au/australia-israel-review/israels-russia-ukraine-dilemma/
55. Rakov, Dov. "The Netanyahu Government’s Approach to Russia and Ukraine." Washington Institute (28.02.2023). Erişim 15.11.2024. https://www.washingtoninstitute.org/policy-analysis/netanyahu-governments-approach-russia-and-ukraine
56. Ravid, Barak. "Inside Israel’s failed Ukraine-Russia mediation efforts." Axios (02.03.2023). Erişim 15.11.2024. https://www.axios.com/2023/02/22/israel-russia-invasion-ukraine-bennett-mediation-failure
57. Ravid, Barak. "Israeli foreign minister promises Zelenskiy more aid, rebuilding help." Reuters (22.02.2023). Erişim 15.11.2024. https://www.reuters.com/world/israeli-foreign-minister-ukraine-first-time-since-war-began-2023-02-16/
58. Robert O. Freedman, Israel’s Tightrope between Russia and Ukraine, Middle East Forum,Erişim, 12.12.2024, https://www.meforum.org/middle-east-quarterly/israel-tightrope-between-russia-and-ukraine
59. Rose, Emily. "Israel offers help with air-attack alerts, but Ukraine wants interceptors." Reuters (10.19.2022). Erişim 15.11.2024. https://www.reuters.com/world/israel-edges-toward-air-defence-assistance-ukraine-2022-10-19/
60. Roundtree, Cheyenne. "Israeli prime minister breaks Sabbath to meet with Putin in effort to de-escalate Ukraine crisis." The Daily Beast (05.03.2022). Erişim 15.11.2024. https://www.thedailybeast.com/israeli-prime-minister-naftali-bennett-breaks-sabbath-to-meet-putin-in-effort-to-de-escalate-ukraine-crisis
61. Sandler, Shmuel. "Judaism: State and foreign policy." In Routledge Handbook of Religion and Politics, edited by Jeffrey Haynes, 128-141. London: Routledge, 2016.
62. Shlaim, Avi. The Iron Wall Israel and the Arab World. London: Penguin Books, 2000.
63. Stahl, Julie. "Israeli Field Hospital Provides ‘Hope Without Boundaries’ in Western Ukraine." CBN (23.04.2022). Erişim 15.11.2024. https://cbn.com/news/news/israeli-field-hospital-provides-hope-without-boundaries-western-ukraine
64. Stand With Us. "Israeli Aid to Syria." Erişim 15.11.2024. https://www.standwithus.com/factsheets-israeli-aid-to-syrians
65. The Times of Israel, Report: Bennett’s political partners warned him Ukraine mediation could backfire, 17.03.2022, https://www.timesofisrael.com/report-bennetts-political-partners-warned-him-ukraine-mediation-could-backfire/.
66. The White House. "Remarks by President Biden at the Summit for Democracy Virtual Plenary on Democracy Delivering on Global Challenges." (29.03.2023). Erişim 15.11.2024. https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/speeches-remarks/2023/03/29/remarks-by-president-biden-at-the-summit-for-democracy-virtual-plenary-on-democracy-delivering-on-global-challenges/
67. Times of Israel ,Bennett empathizes with Zelensky, rejects Holocaust parallel, says mediation ongoing, 21.03.2022.
68. Times of Israel, Israeli lawmakers seethe at Zelensky’s ‘outrageous’ Holocaust comparisons, 20.03.2022.
69. Times of Israel. "Bennett declined Zelensky’s request for military aid, report says." (28.02.2022). Erişim 15.11.2024. https://www.timesofisrael.com/bennett-declined-ukrainian-request-for-military-aid-report-says/
70. Times of Israel. "US charges four Russian agents with hacking energy infrastructure around world." (24.03.2022). Erişim 15.11.2024. https://www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog-march-24-2022/
71. U.S. Embassy in Israel. "Secretary Blinken’s Meeting with Israeli Prime Minister Bennett." (25.08.2021). Erişim 15.11.2024. https://il.usembassy.gov/secretary-blinkens-meeting-with-israeli-prime-minister-bennett/ UALosses. "Ukraine’s losses in the war." (2024). Erişim 15.11.2024. https://ualosses.org/soldiers/
72. Van Hollen, Chris. "Van Hollen, Graham push for additional U.S. support of Ukrainian air defense." Chris Van Hollen (06.23.2023). Erişim 15.11.2024. https://www.vanhollen.senate.gov/news/press-releases/van-hollen-graham-push-for-additional-us-support-of-ukrainian-air-defense
73. Walker, Stephen G. "National role conceptions and systemic outcomes." In Psychological Models in International Politics, edited by Lawrence S. Falkowski, 169-210. Boulder: Westview Press, 1979.
74. Wendt, Alexander. Social Theory of International Politics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1999.
75. Wish, Naomi B. "Foreign policy makers and their national role conceptions." International Studies Quarterly 24/4 (1980): 532-554.
76. Zaig, Gadi. "Most Israelis back government’s policy on Ukraine-Russia war - survey." The Jerusalem Post (26.03.2022). Erişim 15.11.2024. https://www.jpost.com/israel-news/article-702351
77. Zinchenko, Stanislav. "How the Russia-Ukraine war has impacted logistics routes and supply chains." GMK Center (2024). Erişim 15.11.2024. https://gmk.center/en/posts/how-the-russia-ukraine-war-has-impacted-on-logistics-routes-and-supply-chains/