Geç Antik Çağ Amphoralarında Görülen Yazıt ve Mühürler Işığında Annona Sistemi: LRA 1, LRA 2, LRA 3 ve Zeest 80

Yıl 2021, Sayı: 27, 65 - 79, 07.11.2021

Ülkü Kara

https://doi.org/10.51493/egearkeoloji.840265

Öz

Doğu Roma İmparatorluk Dönemi ekonomisinde uygulandığı sanılan ve artık varlığı pek çok araştırmacı tarafından kabul edilen, vergi toplama ve ayni dağıtma sistemi olan annonanın (annona civicia ve annona militaris) eylemlerinden biri “ürünün yer değiştirmesi/nakliyesi”dir. Vergi karşılığında toplanan ürünlerin denizaşırı ve uzak coğrafyalara aktarılması gibi önemli bir organizasyonda kullanılan amphoralar, kabın temin edilmesinden ürünün bozulmadan varışına kadar geçen süreçte oldukça önemlidir. Ayrıca, amphoranın formu kadar üzerindeki yazıtlar ve mühürler de kabı temsil eden öğelerdendir. Sözü edilen mühür ve yazı biçimleri (graffito ve dipinto) dönemin ekonomik, din ve dil özelliklerini yansıtmasının yanı sıra, annnona sisteminin uygulamaları olarak da kabul edilmektedir. Sunulan çalışmada; Doğu Roma İmparatorluğu’nun Geç Roma – Erken Bizans Dönemi boyunca annona organizasyonuna yönelik üretildiği sanılan ya da bunun için kullanıldığı düşünülen ve Akdeniz çevresinde yoğun olarak yayılım gösteren dört amphora tipi (LRA 1, LRA 2, LRA 3 ve Zeest 80); formları, üretimleri ve üzerinde görülen yazıt ve mühürler özelinde ele alınmış ve annona sistemi içinde yer alıp almadıkları irdelenmiştir.

Anahtar Kelimeler

Geç Antik Çağ, Amphora, Mühür, Dipinto, Graffito, Annona civicia, Annona militaris

Kaynakça

• Van Alfen 1996: P. G. van Alfen, “New light on the 7th-century Yassi Ada shipwreck. Capacities and standard sizes of LRA 1 amphoras”, JRA, 9. 189-213.
• Van Alfen 1996: P. G. van Alfen, “New light on the 7th-century Yassi Ada shipwreck. Capacities and standard sizes of LRA 1 amphoras”, JRA, 9. 189-213.
• Alkaç 2015: E. Alkaç, “Kanytellis Kazısından Late Roman 1 Amphoraları”, (ed. Ü. Aydınoğlu) Kanytellis (Kanlıdivane): Dağlık Kilikya’da bir kırsal yerleşimin arkeolojisi, İstanbul, 149-157.
• Alkaç 2015: E. Alkaç, “Kanytellis Kazısından Late Roman 1 Amphoraları”, (ed. Ü. Aydınoğlu) Kanytellis (Kanlıdivane): Dağlık Kilikya’da bir kırsal yerleşimin arkeolojisi, İstanbul, 149-157.
• Bass 1982: G. F. Bass, “Pottery”, (eds. G. F. Bass, F. H. Doorninck). Yassı Ada. College Station, 155-189.
• Bass 1982: G. F. Bass, “Pottery”, (eds. G. F. Bass, F. H. Doorninck). Yassı Ada. College Station, 155-189.
• Bezeczky 2013: T. Bezeczky, P. Scherrer, R. Sauer, The amphorae of Roman Ephesus, Wien.
• Bezeczky 2013: T. Bezeczky, P. Scherrer, R. Sauer, The amphorae of Roman Ephesus, Wien.
• Brennan vd. 2020: M. Brennan, D. Davis, A. Opaiţ, M. Stay, “Deep-water shipwrecks in the East Mediterranean: A microcosm of Late Roman exchange”, JRA, 33, 291-329.
• Brennan vd. 2020: M. Brennan, D. Davis, A. Opaiţ, M. Stay, “Deep-water shipwrecks in the East Mediterranean: A microcosm of Late Roman exchange”, JRA, 33, 291-329.
• Bowman 2018: A. K. Bowman, “The State and the Economy: Fiscality and Taxation”, Trade, commerce, and the state in the Roman world, 27-52.
• Bowman 2018: A. K. Bowman, “The State and the Economy: Fiscality and Taxation”, Trade, commerce, and the state in the Roman world, 27-52.
• Cankardeş - Şenol 2005: G. Cankardeş - Şenol, “Amphora Mühürlerinin Köken ve Sosyal Statünün Belirlenmesindeki Etkileri ve Kent Lokalizasyonun Tespitine Katkıları”, OLBA, 12, 139-164.
• Cankardeş - Şenol 2005: G. Cankardeş - Şenol, “Amphora Mühürlerinin Köken ve Sosyal Statünün Belirlenmesindeki Etkileri ve Kent Lokalizasyonun Tespitine Katkıları”, OLBA, 12, 139-164.
• Cankardeş - Şenol 2015: G. Cankardeş - Şenol, “Smyrna Kazılarında Ele Geçen Amphora Mühürleri: İlk Gözlemler”, (eds. A. Ersoy, G. Şakar), Smyrna/İzmir Kazı ve Araştırmaları: I. Çalıştay Bildirileri, 235-241.
• Cankardeş - Şenol 2015: G. Cankardeş - Şenol, “Smyrna Kazılarında Ele Geçen Amphora Mühürleri: İlk Gözlemler”, (eds. A. Ersoy, G. Şakar), Smyrna/İzmir Kazı ve Araştırmaları: I. Çalıştay Bildirileri, 235-241.
• Carreras - Monfort 2002: C. Carreras - Monfort, “The Roman military supply during the Principate: Transportation and staples”, The Roman army and the economy, 70-89.
• Carreras - Monfort 2002: C. Carreras - Monfort, “The Roman military supply during the Principate: Transportation and staples”, The Roman army and the economy, 70-89.
• Carrié 2012: J. M. Carrié, “Were Late Roman and Byzantine Economies Market economies?”, (ed. C. Morrisson) Trade and markets in Byzantium, Washington, D. C., 13-26.
• Carrié 2012: J. M. Carrié, “Were Late Roman and Byzantine Economies Market economies?”, (ed. C. Morrisson) Trade and markets in Byzantium, Washington, D. C., 13-26.
• Csiky ve Magyar - Hárshegyi 2015: G. Csiky, P. Magyar - Hárshegyi, “Wine for the Avar elite? Amphorae from Avar period burials in the Carpathian Basin”, The Danubian Lands Between the Black, Aegean and Adriatic Seas (7th century BC-10th century AD), (eds.) G. R. Tsetskhladze, A. Avram, J. Hargrave, Proceedings of the Fifth International Congress on Black Sea Antiquities (Belgrade – 17-21 September 2013), 175-182.
• Csiky ve Magyar - Hárshegyi 2015: G. Csiky, P. Magyar - Hárshegyi, “Wine for the Avar elite? Amphorae from Avar period burials in the Carpathian Basin”, The Danubian Lands Between the Black, Aegean and Adriatic Seas (7th century BC-10th century AD), (eds.) G. R. Tsetskhladze, A. Avram, J. Hargrave, Proceedings of the Fifth International Congress on Black Sea Antiquities (Belgrade – 17-21 September 2013), 175-182.
• Çibuk 2019: K. Çibuk, Kocaeli Müzesi Amphora Koleksiyonu, Kocaeli Üniversitesi, Sosyal Bilimler Enstitüsü, Kocaeli (Yayınlanmamış yüksek lisans tezi).
• Çibuk 2019: K. Çibuk, Kocaeli Müzesi Amphora Koleksiyonu, Kocaeli Üniversitesi, Sosyal Bilimler Enstitüsü, Kocaeli (Yayınlanmamış yüksek lisans tezi).
• Deligiannakis 2008: G. Deligiannakis, “The economy of the Dodecanese in late antiquity”, (eds. C. Papageorgiadou – Banis, A. Giannikouri), Μελετηματα 53: Sailing in the Aegean: Readings on the economy and trade routes, 209-233.
• Deligiannakis 2008: G. Deligiannakis, “The economy of the Dodecanese in late antiquity”, (eds. C. Papageorgiadou – Banis, A. Giannikouri), Μελετηματα 53: Sailing in the Aegean: Readings on the economy and trade routes, 209-233.
• Derda 1992: T. Derda, “Inscriptions with the Formula θεου χάρις κέρδος on Late Roman Amphorae”, ZPE, 94, 135-152.
• Derda 1992: T. Derda, “Inscriptions with the Formula θεου χάρις κέρδος on Late Roman Amphorae”, ZPE, 94, 135-152.
• Diamanti 2010: C. Diamanti, Local production and import of amphoras at Halasarna of Kos island (5th-7th c.): Contribution to the research of the production and distribution of the Late Roman/Proto-Byzantine amphoras of the Eastern Mediterranean, Atina. (Yunanca)
• Diamanti 2010: C. Diamanti, Local production and import of amphoras at Halasarna of Kos island (5th-7th c.): Contribution to the research of the production and distribution of the Late Roman/Proto-Byzantine amphoras of the Eastern Mediterranean, Atina. (Yunanca)
• Diamanti 2015: C. Diamanti, “Amphora Production at the Aegean Sea during the 5th-7th Centuries”, The Case of a Workshop at Paros Island: Preliminary Results, Tourner autour du pot: Les ateliers de potiers médiévaux du Ve au XIIe siècle dans l’espace européen : actes du colloque international de Douai (5-8 octobre 2010), Caen, 541-545. Diamanti 2016: C. Diamanti, “The Late Roman Amphora Workshops of Paros Island in the Aegean Saea” REI Acta, 44, 691-697.
• Diamanti 2015: C. Diamanti, “Amphora Production at the Aegean Sea during the 5th-7th Centuries”, The Case of a Workshop at Paros Island: Preliminary Results, Tourner autour du pot: Les ateliers de potiers médiévaux du Ve au XIIe siècle dans l’espace européen : actes du colloque international de Douai (5-8 octobre 2010), Caen, 541-545. Diamanti 2016: C. Diamanti, “The Late Roman Amphora Workshops of Paros Island in the Aegean Saea” REI Acta, 44, 691-697.
• Didimiou 2014: S. Didioumi, “Local pottery production in the island of Cos, Greece from the early Byzantine Period. A preliminary report”, LRCW 4, vol. I, 169-180.
• Didimiou 2014: S. Didioumi, “Local pottery production in the island of Cos, Greece from the early Byzantine Period. A preliminary report”, LRCW 4, vol. I, 169-180.
• Van Doorninck 1989: F. H. van Doorninck Jr., “The Cargo Amphoras on the 7th century Yassı Ada and 11th century Serçe Limanı Shipwrecks: Two Examples of a Reuse of Byzantine Amphoras as Transport Jars”, BCH Supll, 13, 247-257.
• Van Doorninck 1989: F. H. van Doorninck Jr., “The Cargo Amphoras on the 7th century Yassı Ada and 11th century Serçe Limanı Shipwrecks: Two Examples of a Reuse of Byzantine Amphoras as Transport Jars”, BCH Supll, 13, 247-257.
• Van Doorninck 2015: F. H. van Doorninck Jr., “The seventh-century Byzantine Ship at Yassıada and her final voyage: present thoughts”, (eds. D. N. Carlson, S. M. Kampbell, J. Leidwanger), Maritime studies in the wake of the Byzantine shipwreck at Yassıada, Turkey, Texas A&M University Press, 205-216.
• Van Doorninck 2015: F. H. van Doorninck Jr., “The seventh-century Byzantine Ship at Yassıada and her final voyage: present thoughts”, (eds. D. N. Carlson, S. M. Kampbell, J. Leidwanger), Maritime studies in the wake of the Byzantine shipwreck at Yassıada, Turkey, Texas A&M University Press, 205-216.
• Dumankaya 2018: O. Dumankaya, “Bandırma İlçesi Şirinçavuş Mahallesi Antik Liman, Yerleşim ve Batık Potansiyelinin Tespiti Araştırmaları/Survey for detection of potential Ancient Harbors, Settlements and Shipwrecks at the Şirinçavuş Quarter of Bandırma district”, TINA, 10, 127-132.
• Dumankaya 2018: O. Dumankaya, “Bandırma İlçesi Şirinçavuş Mahallesi Antik Liman, Yerleşim ve Batık Potansiyelinin Tespiti Araştırmaları/Survey for detection of potential Ancient Harbors, Settlements and Shipwrecks at the Şirinçavuş Quarter of Bandırma district”, TINA, 10, 127-132.
• Durliat ve Guillou 1984: J. Durliat, A. Guillou, “Le tarif d’Abydos, vers 492”, BCH, 108, 581-598.
• Durliat ve Guillou 1984: J. Durliat, A. Guillou, “Le tarif d’Abydos, vers 492”, BCH, 108, 581-598.
• Elton 2005: H. Elton, “The Economy of Southern Asia Minor and LR 1 amphorae”, LRCW 1, 691-695.
• Elton 2005: H. Elton, “The Economy of Southern Asia Minor and LR 1 amphorae”, LRCW 1, 691-695.
• Fournet ve Pieri 2008: J - L. Fournet, D. Pieri, “Les dipinti amphoriques d’Antinoopolis. (eds. G. Bastianini, R. Pitaudi), Antinoupolis I, Istituto papirologico G. Vitelli, 175-216.
• Fournet ve Pieri 2008: J - L. Fournet, D. Pieri, “Les dipinti amphoriques d’Antinoopolis. (eds. G. Bastianini, R. Pitaudi), Antinoupolis I, Istituto papirologico G. Vitelli, 175-216.
• Garnsey ve Whittaker 1998: P. Garnsey, C. R. Whittaker, “Trade, industry and the urban economy”, Cambridge Ancient History, vol. 13: The Late Empire, A.D. 337-425, Cambridge, 312-337.
• Garnsey ve Whittaker 1998: P. Garnsey, C. R. Whittaker, “Trade, industry and the urban economy”, Cambridge Ancient History, vol. 13: The Late Empire, A.D. 337-425, Cambridge, 312-337.
• Gerousi 2016: E. Gerousi, “The Commercial Relations Between Aegean and the Black Sea on the Basis of the Testimony of the Early Christian Amphoras”, Proceedings of the Symposium on City Ports from the Aegean to the Black Sea. (eds.) F. Karagianni, U. Kocabaş, Medieval-Modern Networks 22nd-29th August 2015, İstanbul, 127-136.
• Gerousi 2016: E. Gerousi, “The Commercial Relations Between Aegean and the Black Sea on the Basis of the Testimony of the Early Christian Amphoras”, Proceedings of the Symposium on City Ports from the Aegean to the Black Sea. (eds.) F. Karagianni, U. Kocabaş, Medieval-Modern Networks 22nd-29th August 2015, İstanbul, 127-136.
• Grant 2000: M. Grant, Roma’dan Bizans’a (Çev. Z. İlkgelen), İstanbul.
• Grant 2000: M. Grant, Roma’dan Bizans’a (Çev. Z. İlkgelen), İstanbul.
• Gregory 2008: T. E. Gregory, Bizans Tarihi, (Çev. E. Ermert), İstanbul.
• Gregory 2008: T. E. Gregory, Bizans Tarihi, (Çev. E. Ermert), İstanbul.
• Gündüz 2017: S. Gündüz, “Bursa’nın Antik Liman Kalıntıları”, Aktüel Arkeoloji, 57, 100-105.
• Gündüz 2017: S. Gündüz, “Bursa’nın Antik Liman Kalıntıları”, Aktüel Arkeoloji, 57, 100-105.
• Haldon 2007: J. F. Haldon, “Primary Sources”, (eds. E. Jeffreys, J. F. Haldon, R. Cormack), The Oxford handbook of Byzantine studies, Oxford; New York, 21-30.
• Haldon 2007: J. F. Haldon, “Primary Sources”, (eds. E. Jeffreys, J. F. Haldon, R. Cormack), The Oxford handbook of Byzantine studies, Oxford; New York, 21-30.
• Hayes 1992: J. W. Hayes, Excavations at Saraçhane in Istanbul, vol. 2: Pottery, Princeton.
• Hayes 1992: J. W. Hayes, Excavations at Saraçhane in Istanbul, vol. 2: Pottery, Princeton.
• Hendy 1985: M. F. Hendy, Studies in the Byzantine monetary economy, c. 300-1450, Cambridge; New York.
• Hendy 1985: M. F. Hendy, Studies in the Byzantine monetary economy, c. 300-1450, Cambridge; New York.
• Hopkins 1980: K. Hopkins, “Taxes and Trade in the Roman Empire (200 B.C. - A.D. 400).”, JRS, 70, 1980, 101–125.
• Hopkins 1980: K. Hopkins, “Taxes and Trade in the Roman Empire (200 B.C. - A.D. 400).”, JRS, 70, 1980, 101–125.
• Iacomi 2010: V. Iacomi, “Some Notes on Late-Antique Oil and Wine Production in Rough Cilicia (Isauria) on the Light of Epigraphic Sources: Funerary Inscriptions from Korykos, LR 1 Amphorae Production in Elaiussa Sebaste and the Abydos Tariff”, (eds. Ü. Aydınoğlu, A. K. Şenol), Antik çağda Anadolu’da zeytinyağı ve şarap üretimi, 19-32.
• Iacomi 2010: V. Iacomi, “Some Notes on Late-Antique Oil and Wine Production in Rough Cilicia (Isauria) on the Light of Epigraphic Sources: Funerary Inscriptions from Korykos, LR 1 Amphorae Production in Elaiussa Sebaste and the Abydos Tariff”, (eds. Ü. Aydınoğlu, A. K. Şenol), Antik çağda Anadolu’da zeytinyağı ve şarap üretimi, 19-32.
• Jones 1964: A. H. M. Jones, The later Roman empire, 284-602: A social economic and administrative survey, vol. 2, Oxford.
• Jones 1964: A. H. M. Jones, The later Roman empire, 284-602: A social economic and administrative survey, vol. 2, Oxford.
• Kaçar 2005: T. Kaçar, “Eskiçağ Akdeniz dünyasında siyasal birliğin sonu: Romalılar ve kuzey komşuları”, Doğu Batı, 34, 203-222.
• Kaçar 2005: T. Kaçar, “Eskiçağ Akdeniz dünyasında siyasal birliğin sonu: Romalılar ve kuzey komşuları”, Doğu Batı, 34, 203-222.
• Kaegi 1985: W. Kaegi, “The annona militaris in the early seventh century”, Bυζαντινά. Eπιστημoνικóν óργανoν Kέντρoυ Bυζαντινών Eρευνών Φιλoσoφικής Σχoλής Aριστoτελείoυ Πανεπιστημίoυ Θεσσαλoνίκης, 13, 591-596.
• Kaegi 1985: W. Kaegi, “The annona militaris in the early seventh century”, Bυζαντινά. Eπιστημoνικóν óργανoν Kέντρoυ Bυζαντινών Eρευνών Φιλoσoφικής Σχoλής Aριστoτελείoυ Πανεπιστημίoυ Θεσσαλoνίκης, 13, 591-596.
• Kara 2015: Ü. Kara, “Yenikapı Limanı’nda Ele Geçen Damgalı Amphoralar”, (eds. A. Diler, A. K. Şenol, Ü. Aydınoğlu), Antikçağ’da Doğu Akdeniz’de Zeytinyağı ve Şarap Üretimi, İstanbul, 243-250.
• Kara 2015: Ü. Kara, “Yenikapı Limanı’nda Ele Geçen Damgalı Amphoralar”, (eds. A. Diler, A. K. Şenol, Ü. Aydınoğlu), Antikçağ’da Doğu Akdeniz’de Zeytinyağı ve Şarap Üretimi, İstanbul, 243-250.
• Kara 2016: Ü. Kara, “Küçükçekmece Göl Havzası Arkeolojik Kazılarında Yürütülen Amphora Çalışmaları”, TINA, 6, 50-63.
• Kara 2016: Ü. Kara, “Küçükçekmece Göl Havzası Arkeolojik Kazılarında Yürütülen Amphora Çalışmaları”, TINA, 6, 50-63.
• Kara 2017: Ü. Kara, “Küçükçekmece Göl Havzası (Bathonea?) Kazıları’nda Ele Geçen Dipintolu LR 2 ve Damgalı LR 13 Amphoraları”, (ed. Ş. Aydıngün), İstanbul Küçükçekmece Göl Havzası Kazıları / Excavations of Küçükçekmece Lake Basin (Bathonea), İstanbul, 277-285.
• Kara 2017: Ü. Kara, “Küçükçekmece Göl Havzası (Bathonea?) Kazıları’nda Ele Geçen Dipintolu LR 2 ve Damgalı LR 13 Amphoraları”, (ed. Ş. Aydıngün), İstanbul Küçükçekmece Göl Havzası Kazıları / Excavations of Küçükçekmece Lake Basin (Bathonea), İstanbul, 277-285.
• Kara 2019: Ü. Kara, Geç Antik Çağ’da (M.S. 4. - 7. yüzyıl) Doğu Akdeniz’de Üretilen Ticari Amphoralarda Dipinti, Graffiti ve Mühür Kullanımı, Ege Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Enstitüsü Arkeoloji Anabilim Dalı, İzmir (Yayınlanmamış Doktora Tezi).
• Kara 2019: Ü. Kara, Geç Antik Çağ’da (M.S. 4. - 7. yüzyıl) Doğu Akdeniz’de Üretilen Ticari Amphoralarda Dipinti, Graffiti ve Mühür Kullanımı, Ege Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Enstitüsü Arkeoloji Anabilim Dalı, İzmir (Yayınlanmamış Doktora Tezi).
• Karagiorgou 2001: O. Karagiorgou, “LR 2: A container for the military annona on the Danubian border?”, (eds. S. Kingsley, M. Decker), Economy and exchange in the East Mediterranean during late antiquity, Proceedings of a conference at Somerville College, Oxford – 29th May, 1999, 129-166.
• Karagiorgou 2001: O. Karagiorgou, “LR 2: A container for the military annona on the Danubian border?”, (eds. S. Kingsley, M. Decker), Economy and exchange in the East Mediterranean during late antiquity, Proceedings of a conference at Somerville College, Oxford – 29th May, 1999, 129-166.
• Kazdan 1991: (ed. A. Kazdan) The Oxford dictionary of Byzantium, New York; Oxford.
• Kazdan 1991: (ed. A. Kazdan) The Oxford dictionary of Byzantium, New York; Oxford.
• Kingsley 2001: S. Kingsley, “The Economic Impact of the Palestinian Wine Trade in Late Antiquity”, (eds. S. Kingsley, M. Decker), Economy and Exchange in the East Mediterranean during Late Antiquity, Proceedings of a Conferance at Somerville College, Oxford, 29th May 1999, 44-68.
• Kingsley 2001: S. Kingsley, “The Economic Impact of the Palestinian Wine Trade in Late Antiquity”, (eds. S. Kingsley, M. Decker), Economy and Exchange in the East Mediterranean during Late Antiquity, Proceedings of a Conferance at Somerville College, Oxford, 29th May 1999, 44-68.
• Kingsley 2013: S. Kingsley, “Late antique trade. Research methodologies and field practices”, Theory and practice in late antique archaeology, 113-138.
• Kingsley 2013: S. Kingsley, “Late antique trade. Research methodologies and field practices”, Theory and practice in late antique archaeology, 113-138.
• Kingsley ve Decker 2001: S. Kingsley, M. Decker, “New Rome, New Theories on Inter-Regional Exchange. An Introduction to the East Mediterranean Economy in Late Antiquity”, Economy and Exchange in the East Mediterranean during Late Antiquity, (eds.) S. Kingsley, M. Decker, Proceedings of a Conferance at Somerville College, Oxford, 29th May 1999, 1-27.
• Kingsley ve Decker 2001: S. Kingsley, M. Decker, “New Rome, New Theories on Inter-Regional Exchange. An Introduction to the East Mediterranean Economy in Late Antiquity”, Economy and Exchange in the East Mediterranean during Late Antiquity, (eds.) S. Kingsley, M. Decker, Proceedings of a Conferance at Somerville College, Oxford, 29th May 1999, 1-27.
• Ladstätter 2011: S. Ladstätter, “Bizans Döneminde Ephesos”, (eds. F. Daim, S. Ladstätter), Bizans Döneminde Ephesos, İstanbul, 3-28.
• Ladstätter 2011: S. Ladstätter, “Bizans Döneminde Ephesos”, (eds. F. Daim, S. Ladstätter), Bizans Döneminde Ephesos, İstanbul, 3-28.
• Laiou 2002: A. E. Laiou, “Economic and Non-Economic Exchange”, (ed. A. E. Laiou), The economic history of Byzantium: From the seventh through the fifteenth century, Washington D. C., 665-680.
• Laiou 2002: A. E. Laiou, “Economic and Non-Economic Exchange”, (ed. A. E. Laiou), The economic history of Byzantium: From the seventh through the fifteenth century, Washington D. C., 665-680.
• Lauffer 1971: G. A. V. 2 Diocletianus, (Çev. S. Lauffer), Diokletians Preisedikt, Berlin.
• Lauffer 1971: G. A. V. 2 Diocletianus, (Çev. S. Lauffer), Diokletians Preisedikt, Berlin.
• Leidwanger 2014: J. Leidwanger, “A preliminary archaeometric analysis of the Late Roman 1 amphoras from the cargo of the seventh-century Yassiada shipwreck, Turkey” LRCW 4, vol. 2, 897-906.
• Leidwanger 2014: J. Leidwanger, “A preliminary archaeometric analysis of the Late Roman 1 amphoras from the cargo of the seventh-century Yassiada shipwreck, Turkey” LRCW 4, vol. 2, 897-906.
• Long ve Volpe 1998: L. Long, G. Volpe, “Le chargement de l’épave 1 de la Palud (VIe s.) à Port-Cros (Var). Note préliminaire”, Fouilles à Marseille: Les mobiliers (1er-7e siècles ap. J.-C.), 317-342.
• Long ve Volpe 1998: L. Long, G. Volpe, “Le chargement de l’épave 1 de la Palud (VIe s.) à Port-Cros (Var). Note préliminaire”, Fouilles à Marseille: Les mobiliers (1er-7e siècles ap. J.-C.), 317-342.
• C. Mango 2008: C. A. Mango, Bizans Yeni Roma İmparatorluğu. (Çev. G. Ç. Güven), İstanbul.
• C. Mango 2008: C. A. Mango, Bizans Yeni Roma İmparatorluğu. (Çev. G. Ç. Güven), İstanbul.
• M. Mango 2009: M. M. Mango, “Byzantine Trade: Local, Regional, Interregional and International”. (ed. M. M. Mango), Byzantine Trade, 4th-12th Centuries. The Archaeology of Local Regional and International Exchange, Papers of the Thirty-eight Spring Symposium of Byzantine Studies. St. John’s College University of Oxford, March 2004, 3-14.
• M. Mango 2009: M. M. Mango, “Byzantine Trade: Local, Regional, Interregional and International”. (ed. M. M. Mango), Byzantine Trade, 4th-12th Centuries. The Archaeology of Local Regional and International Exchange, Papers of the Thirty-eight Spring Symposium of Byzantine Studies. St. John’s College University of Oxford, March 2004, 3-14.
• Maria 2011: P. Maria, “Diocletian’s Edict on Maximum Prices of 301 AD. A fragment found in Aigeira”, Historia.scribere 3, 360-398.
• Maria 2011: P. Maria, “Diocletian’s Edict on Maximum Prices of 301 AD. A fragment found in Aigeira”, Historia.scribere 3, 360-398.
• MacMullen 1980: R. MacMullen, “How big was the Roman army?”, Klio, 62,2, 451-460.
• MacMullen 1980: R. MacMullen, “How big was the Roman army?”, Klio, 62,2, 451-460.
• Minchev 2011: A. Minchev, “Early Byzantine Amphorae with Graffiti and Christian Stamps from a Shipwreck in the Bay of Varna (Bulgaria)”, (eds. C. Tzochev, T. Stoyanov, A. Bozkova), Patabs 2, Acts of the International round table held in Kiten, Nessebar and Sredetz September 26-30, 2007, 143-159.
• Minchev 2011: A. Minchev, “Early Byzantine Amphorae with Graffiti and Christian Stamps from a Shipwreck in the Bay of Varna (Bulgaria)”, (eds. C. Tzochev, T. Stoyanov, A. Bozkova), Patabs 2, Acts of the International round table held in Kiten, Nessebar and Sredetz September 26-30, 2007, 143-159.
• Mitchell 2016: S. Mitchell, Geç Roma İmparatorluğu Tarihi M.S. 284-641, (Çev. T. Kaçar), Ankara.
• Mitchell 2016: S. Mitchell, Geç Roma İmparatorluğu Tarihi M.S. 284-641, (Çev. T. Kaçar), Ankara.
• Opait 1987: A. Opait, “Amfore romane de mare capacitate. Consideraţii tipologice”, Studii şi cercetări de istorie veche şi arheologie, 38, 245–258.
• Opait 1987: A. Opait, “Amfore romane de mare capacitate. Consideraţii tipologice”, Studii şi cercetări de istorie veche şi arheologie, 38, 245–258.
• Opait 2004: A. Opait, Local and imported ceramics in the Roman province of Scythia (4th-6th centuries AD): Aspects of economic life in the province of Scythia. Oxford.
• Opait 2004: A. Opait, Local and imported ceramics in the Roman province of Scythia (4th-6th centuries AD): Aspects of economic life in the province of Scythia. Oxford.
• Opait, baskıda: A. Opait, LRCW 6 (Yayın aşamasında)
• Opait, baskıda: A. Opait, LRCW 6 (Yayın aşamasında)
• Opait ve Diamanti 2014: A. Opait, C. Diamanti, “Imperial stamps on Early Byzantine amphoras: The Athenian Agora examples”, RCRF Acta, 43, 55-61.
• Opait ve Diamanti 2014: A. Opait, C. Diamanti, “Imperial stamps on Early Byzantine amphoras: The Athenian Agora examples”, RCRF Acta, 43, 55-61.
• Öniz 2016: H. Öniz, Doğu Akdeniz’de Amphoralar. İstanbul.
• Öniz 2016: H. Öniz, Doğu Akdeniz’de Amphoralar. İstanbul.
• Paterson 2010: J. Paterson, Roma Dünyasında Ticaret ve Tüccarlar: Ölçek, Yapı ve Örgütlenme”, Ticaret, Tüccarlar ve Antik Kent (Çev. Ö. Harmanşah), İstanbul, 136-151.
• Paterson 2010: J. Paterson, Roma Dünyasında Ticaret ve Tüccarlar: Ölçek, Yapı ve Örgütlenme”, Ticaret, Tüccarlar ve Antik Kent (Çev. Ö. Harmanşah), İstanbul, 136-151.
• Papanikolaou 2014: P. Papanikolau, Impressions of Authority. Iconography and Prosopography of the Eparchs on Early Byzantine Stamped Amphorae, Σοφία Άδολος, Τιμητικός τόμος στον Ιω. Παπαχριστοδούλου, Rodos, 171-194. (Yunanca)
• Papanikolaou 2014: P. Papanikolau, Impressions of Authority. Iconography and Prosopography of the Eparchs on Early Byzantine Stamped Amphorae, Σοφία Άδολος, Τιμητικός τόμος στον Ιω. Παπαχριστοδούλου, Rodos, 171-194. (Yunanca)
• Peacock 1984: D. P. S. Peacock, “Amphorae: Typology and Chronology”, (eds. M. G. Fulford, D. P. S. Peacock), The avenue du President Habib Bourguiba, Salammbo: 2. (1. The avenue du President Habib Bourguiba, Salammbo), Sheffield, 116-128.
• Peacock 1984: D. P. S. Peacock, “Amphorae: Typology and Chronology”, (eds. M. G. Fulford, D. P. S. Peacock), The avenue du President Habib Bourguiba, Salammbo: 2. (1. The avenue du President Habib Bourguiba, Salammbo), Sheffield, 116-128.
• Peacock ve Williams 1986: D. P. S. Peacock, D. F. Williams, Amphorae and the Roman economy: An introductory guide. London: Longman.
• Peacock ve Williams 1986: D. P. S. Peacock, D. F. Williams, Amphorae and the Roman economy: An introductory guide. London: Longman.
• Pieri 2005: D. Pieri, Le commerce du vin oriental à l’époque byzantine (Ve-VIIe siècles): Le témoignage des amphores en Gaule, Beyrouth.
• Pieri 2005: D. Pieri, Le commerce du vin oriental à l’époque byzantine (Ve-VIIe siècles): Le témoignage des amphores en Gaule, Beyrouth.
• Pieri 2007: D. Pieri, "Béryte dans le grand commerce méditerranéen (Ve-VIIe s. apr. J.-C.)”, (ed. M. Sartre), Productions et échanges dans la Syrie gréco-romaine. Actes du 2e colloque international sur la Syrie antique (Tours, 12-13 juin 2003), suppl. Topoi, 8, 297-327.
• Pieri 2007: D. Pieri, "Béryte dans le grand commerce méditerranéen (Ve-VIIe s. apr. J.-C.)”, (ed. M. Sartre), Productions et échanges dans la Syrie gréco-romaine. Actes du 2e colloque international sur la Syrie antique (Tours, 12-13 juin 2003), suppl. Topoi, 8, 297-327.
• Pieri 2012: D. Pieri, “Regional and Interregional Exchanges in the Eastern Mediterrnean during the Early Byzantine Period”, (ed. C. Morrison), Trade and markets in Byzantium, Washington, 28-49.
• Pieri 2012: D. Pieri, “Regional and Interregional Exchanges in the Eastern Mediterrnean during the Early Byzantine Period”, (ed. C. Morrison), Trade and markets in Byzantium, Washington, 28-49.
• Pollard 2006: N. Pollard, “The Roman Army”, (ed. D. S. 1. Potter), A companion to the Roman Empire, Malden, Mass, 206-227.
• Pollard 2006: N. Pollard, “The Roman Army”, (ed. D. S. 1. Potter), A companion to the Roman Empire, Malden, Mass, 206-227.
• Reynolds 2018: P. Reynolds, “The Supply Networks of the Roman East and West: Interaction, Fragmentation, and the Origins of the Byzantine Economy”, Trade, commerce, and the state in the Roman world, 353-395.
• Reynolds 2018: P. Reynolds, “The Supply Networks of the Roman East and West: Interaction, Fragmentation, and the Origins of the Byzantine Economy”, Trade, commerce, and the state in the Roman world, 353-395.
• Riley 1979: J. A. Riley, “The coarse pottery from Berenice”, Excavations at Sidi Khrebish, Benghazi (Berenice), 2, 91-467.
• Riley 1979: J. A. Riley, “The coarse pottery from Berenice”, Excavations at Sidi Khrebish, Benghazi (Berenice), 2, 91-467.
• Riley 1981: J. A. Riley, “The pottery from the cisterns 1977. 1, 1977. 2, 1977. 3.”, Excavations at Carthage conducted by the University of Michigan, 6, 85-124.
• Riley 1981: J. A. Riley, “The pottery from the cisterns 1977. 1, 1977. 2, 1977. 3.”, Excavations at Carthage conducted by the University of Michigan, 6, 85-124.
• Robinson 1959: H. S. Robinson, Pottery of the Roman period: Chronology. Princeton, 1959.
• Robinson 1959: H. S. Robinson, Pottery of the Roman period: Chronology. Princeton, 1959.
• Roth 1994: J. Roth, “The size and organization of the Roman imperial legion”, Historia (Stuttgart), 43, 1-4, 346-362.
• Roth 1994: J. Roth, “The size and organization of the Roman imperial legion”, Historia (Stuttgart), 43, 1-4, 346-362.
• Sarnowski 2015: T. Sarnowski, “Danubian Provinces”, (eds. Y. Le Bohec, G. Brizzi), The encyclopedia of the Roman Army, West Sussex, 279-290.
• Sarnowski 2015: T. Sarnowski, “Danubian Provinces”, (eds. Y. Le Bohec, G. Brizzi), The encyclopedia of the Roman Army, West Sussex, 279-290.
• Scorpan 1977: C. Scorpan, “Contribution à la connaissance de certains types céramiques romano-byzantins (4e – 7e siècles) dans l’espace istro-pontique”, Dacia, 21, 269-298.
• Scorpan 1977: C. Scorpan, “Contribution à la connaissance de certains types céramiques romano-byzantins (4e – 7e siècles) dans l’espace istro-pontique”, Dacia, 21, 269-298.
• Swan 2007: V. G. Swan, “Dichin (Bulgaria): Interpreting the ceramic evidence in its wider context”, The transition to Late Antiquity on the Danube and beyond, 251-280.
• Swan 2007: V. G. Swan, “Dichin (Bulgaria): Interpreting the ceramic evidence in its wider context”, The transition to Late Antiquity on the Danube and beyond, 251-280.
• Swan 2010: V. G. Swan, “Dichin (Bulgaria): the destruction deposits and the dating of Black Sea amphorae in the fifth and sixth Centuries A.D.”, Patabs 1, Actes de la Table Ronde internationale de Batoumi et Trabzon, 27-29 avril 2006. Istanbul, 107-118.
• Swan 2010: V. G. Swan, “Dichin (Bulgaria): the destruction deposits and the dating of Black Sea amphorae in the fifth and sixth Centuries A.D.”, Patabs 1, Actes de la Table Ronde internationale de Batoumi et Trabzon, 27-29 avril 2006. Istanbul, 107-118.
• Sztetyllo ve Borkowski 1986: Z. Sztetyllo, Z. Borkowski, “Un timbre céramique byzantin de l’éparque de Constantinople”, BCH Supll, 13, 649-653.
• Sztetyllo ve Borkowski 1986: Z. Sztetyllo, Z. Borkowski, “Un timbre céramique byzantin de l’éparque de Constantinople”, BCH Supll, 13, 649-653.
• Şenol 2003: A. K. Şenol, Marmaris Müzesi Ticari Amphoraları, Ankara, 2003.
• Şenol 2003: A. K. Şenol, Marmaris Müzesi Ticari Amphoraları, Ankara, 2003.
• Şenol 2005: A. K. Şenol, “Antik Dönem Ekonomisinin Kurgusunda Seramik Buluntuların Yeri, Sorunlar”, OLBA, 12, 125-138.
• Şenol 2005: A. K. Şenol, “Antik Dönem Ekonomisinin Kurgusunda Seramik Buluntuların Yeri, Sorunlar”, OLBA, 12, 125-138.
• Şenol 2009: A. K. Şenol, AETAM (Arslan Eyce Taşucu Amphora Müzesi)’da Bulunan Ticari Amphoralar ve Akdeniz’de Ticaretin İzleri, Mersin.
• Şenol 2009: A. K. Şenol, AETAM (Arslan Eyce Taşucu Amphora Müzesi)’da Bulunan Ticari Amphoralar ve Akdeniz’de Ticaretin İzleri, Mersin.
• Şenol 2018: A. K. Şenol, Commercial amphoras in the Graeco-Roman Museum of Alexandria, Alexandrie.
• Şenol 2018: A. K. Şenol, Commercial amphoras in the Graeco-Roman Museum of Alexandria, Alexandrie.
• Treadgold 2015: W. T. Treadgold, “Economy and the Army: Late Empire”, (eds. Le Y. Bohec, G. Brizzi), The encyclopedia of the Roman Army, West Sussex, 362-366.
• Treadgold 2015: W. T. Treadgold, “Economy and the Army: Late Empire”, (eds. Le Y. Bohec, G. Brizzi), The encyclopedia of the Roman Army, West Sussex, 362-366.
• Ward - Perkins 2001: B. Ward – Perkins, “Specialisation, Trade, and Prosperity: an Overview of the Economy of the Late Antique Eastern Mediterranean”, (eds. S. Kingsley, M. Decker), Economy and exchange in the East Mediterranean during late antiquity, Proceedings of a conference at Somerville College, Oxford – 29th May, 1999, 167-178.
• Ward - Perkins 2001: B. Ward – Perkins, “Specialisation, Trade, and Prosperity: an Overview of the Economy of the Late Antique Eastern Mediterranean”, (eds. S. Kingsley, M. Decker), Economy and exchange in the East Mediterranean during late antiquity, Proceedings of a conference at Somerville College, Oxford – 29th May, 1999, 167-178.
• Williams ve Friell 1999: S. Williams, G. Friell, “Imperial Wealth and Expenditure”, The Rome that did not fall: The survival of the East in the fifth century. London, 115-135.
• Williams ve Friell 1999: S. Williams, G. Friell, “Imperial Wealth and Expenditure”, The Rome that did not fall: The survival of the East in the fifth century. London, 115-135.
• Whittaker ve Garnsey 1998: C. R. Whittaker, P. Garnsey, “Rural life in the later Roman empire”, Cambridge Ancient History, vol. 13, 277-311.
• Whittaker ve Garnsey 1998: C. R. Whittaker, P. Garnsey, “Rural life in the later Roman empire”, Cambridge Ancient History, vol. 13, 277-311.
• Zeest 1960: I. B. Zeest, Keramicheskaya Tara Bospora. Issledorani po arkheologia, SSSR. (Rusça)
• Zeest 1960: I. B. Zeest, Keramicheskaya Tara Bospora. Issledorani po arkheologia, SSSR. (Rusça)
• Zemer 1978: A. Zemer, Storage jars in ancient sea trade, Haifa.
• Zemer 1978: A. Zemer, Storage jars in ancient sea trade, Haifa.