Exploring the Impact of Flipped Classroom Model in Primary School: A Bibliometric and Content Analysis

Öz

Many recent studies have shown that the Flipped Classroom Model [FCM] significantly benefits students’ learning processes. This study used bibliometric analysis to evaluate the existing studies on using the flipped classroom model at the primary school level from a broad perspective. According to the results of the bibliometric analysis, it was found that the most frequently used keywords in articles on the use of FCM at the primary school level were flipped classroom, flipped learning, blending learning, primary school, motivation, and academic achievement, respectively. According to the co-citation analysis, Bergman, Hwang, Zainuddin, Lo, and Bishop are the most cited authors in this field. The most cited journals were Computers & Education, Educational Technology & Society. In the content analysis, researchers include 30 articles with the highest citations among the studies on using FCM in primary school. The findings reveal that the number of studies in this field increased between 2014 and 2021 but then decreased. On the other hand, results show that FCM can improve primary school students’ academic achievement, critical thinking, motivation, self-efficacy and self-regulation skills. The data provides promising evidence that the flipped classroom model can be effective at the primary school level. This study provides a general perspective for researchers who will conduct studies on the relevant section.

Anahtar Kelimeler

• Flipped classroom
• primary school
• bibliometric analysis
• content analysis

İlkokulda Ters Yüz Sınıf Modelinin Kullanımına İlişkin Yapılan Çalışmalardaki Eğilimler: Bibliyometrik ve İçerik Analizi

Öz

Son zamanlarda yapılan birçok çalışma, Ters Yüz Sınıf Modelinin [FCM] öğrencilerin öğrenme süreçlerine önemli ölçüde fayda sağladığını göstermiştir. Bu çalışmada, ters yüz sınıf modelinin ilkokul düzeyinde kullanımına ilişkin mevcut çalışmaları geniş bir perspektiften değerlendirmek için bibliyometrik analiz kullanılmıştır. Bibliyometrik analiz sonuçlarına göre, FCM’nin ilkokul düzeyinde kullanımıyla ilgili makalelerde en sık kullanılan anahtar kelimelerin sırasıyla ters yüz sınıf, ters yüz öğrenme, harmanlayarak öğrenme, ilkokul, motivasyon ve akademik başarı olduğu bulunmuştur. Ortak atıf analizine göre, Bergman, Hwang, Zainuddin, Lo ve Bishop bu alanda en çok atıf alan yazarlardır. En çok atıf alan dergiler ise Computers & Education, Educational Technology & Society’dir. İçerik analizinde araştırmacılar, ilkokulda FCM kullanımına ilişkin çalışmalar arasında en çok atıf alan 30 makaleye yer vermiştir. Bulgular, bu alandaki çalışmaların sayısının 2014-2021 yılları arasında arttığını ancak daha sonra azaldığını ortaya koyuyor. Öte yandan sonuçlar, FCM’nin ilkokul öğrencilerinin akademik başarılarını, eleştirel düşünme, motivasyon, öz yeterlilik ve öz düzenleme becerilerini geliştirebileceğini gösteriyor. Veriler, ters yüz sınıf modelinin ilkokul düzeyinde etkili olabileceğine dair umut verici kanıtlar sunmaktadır. Bu çalışma, ilgili bölümde çalışma yapacak araştırmacılar için genel bir bakış açısı sağlamaktadır.

Anahtar Kelimeler

• Ters yüz sınıf
• ilkokul
• bibliyometrik analiz
• içerik analizi

Kaynakça

1. Abeysekera, L., & Dawson, P. (2015). Motivation and cognitive load in the flipped classroom: Definition, rationale and a call for research. Higher Education Research and Development, 34(1), 1-14.
2. Afshari, T., Farajollahi, M., Mazloumian, S., & Zanjani, N. K. (2021). Curriculum design in the flipped classroom for elementary math lesson. International Journal of Nonlinear Analysis and Applications, 12(Special Issue), 495-518.
3. Aidinopoulou, V., & Sampson, D. G. (2017). An action research study from implementing the flipped classroom model in primary school history teaching and learning. Educational Technology and Society, 20(1), 237-247.
4. Akçayır, G., & Akçayır, M. (2018). The flipped classroom: A review of its advantages and challenges. Computers & Education, 126, 334-345.
5. Anderson, L. W., & Krathwohl, D. R. (2001). A taxonomy for learning, teaching, and assessing: A revision of Bloom’s taxonomy of educational objectives. Longman.
6. Atwa, Z., Sulayeh, Y., Abdelhadi, A., Jazar, H. A., & Eriqat, S. (2022). Flipped classroom effects on grade 9 students’ critical thinking skills, psychological stress, and academic achievement. International Journal of Instruction, 15(2), 737-750.
7. Baker, J. W. (2000). The “classroom flip”: Using web course management tools to become the guide by the side. 11th International Conference on College Teaching and Learning. Jacksonville: Florida Community College.
8. Bauer, M. W. (2003). Classical content analysis: A review. In M. W. Bauer & G. Gaskell (Eds.), Qualitative researching with text, image and sound (pp. 131-151). Sage.

9. Bergmann, J., & Sams, A. (2012). Flip your classroom: Reach every student in every class every day. International Society for Technology in Education.
10. Bergmann, J., & Sams, A. (2015). The flipped learning for elementary instruction. International Society for Technology in Education.
11. Bi, J., Bigdeli, H., & Izadpanah, S. (2023). The effect of the flipped classroom on reflective thinking, academic self-efficacy, and achievement motivation in language learners in intermediate level. Education and Information Technologies, 28(9), 11589-11613.
12. Birgili, B., Seggie, F. N., & Oğuz, E. (2021). The trends and outcomes of flipped learning research between 2012 and 2018: A descriptive content analysis. Journal of Computers in Education, 8(3), 365-394.
13. Bishop, J., & Verleger, M. A. (2013, June 23-26). The flipped classroom: A survey of the research. 2013 ASEE Annual Conference & Exposition. Atlanta, Georgia.
14. Bloom, B. S. (1976). Human characteristics and school learning. McGraw-hill.
15. Bond, M. (2020). Facilitating student engagement through the flipped learning approach in K-12: A systematic review. Computers & Education, 151, 103819.
16. Botella, Á. G., García-Martínez, S., García, N. M., Olaya-Cuartero, J., & Ferriz-Valero, A. (2021). Flipped learning to improve students’ motivation in physical education. Acta Gymnica, 51, Article e2021.012.
17. Cai, Q., Zhang, H., & Cai, L. (2023). The role of the art of chinese calligraphy and music in developing creative thinking skills in preschoolers using flipped technology. Journal of Psycholinguistic Research, 52(6), 1973-1987.
18. Campión, R. S. (2019). Conectando el modelo flipped learning y la teoría de las Inteligencias múltiples a la luz de la taxonomía de Bloom. Magister: Revista miscelánea de investigación, 31(2), 45-54.
19. Cevikbas, M., & Kaiser, G. (2023). Can flipped classroom pedagogy offer promising perspectives for mathematics education on pandemic-related issues? A systematic literature review. ZDM-Mathematics Education, 55(1), 177-191.
20. Chang, S. C., & Hwang, G. J. (2018). Impacts of an augmented reality-based flipped learning guiding approach on students’ scientific project performance and perceptions. Computers and Education, 125, 226-239.
21. Chang, Y. H., Yan, Y. C., & Lu, Y. Te. (2022). Effects of combining different collaborative learning strategies with problem-based learning in a flipped classroom on program language learning. Sustainability, 14(9), 5282.
22. Chen, J., & Mokmin, N. A. M. (2024). Enhancing primary school students’ performance, flow state, and cognitive load in visual arts education through the integration of augmented reality technology in a card game. Education and Information Technologies, 29(12), 15441-15461.
23. Chen, S. C., Yang, S. J., & Hsiao, C. C. (2016). Exploring student perceptions, learning outcome and gender differences in a flipped mathematics course. British Journal of Educational Technology, 47(6), 1096-1112.
24. Cheng, S. C., Hwang, G. J., & Chen, C. H. (2023). Fostering students’ scientific literacy by reflective questioning: An identification, summarization, self-reflective questioning, and application (ISSA)-based flipped learning approach. Education and Information Technologies, 29, 7081-7104.
25. Chen-Hsieh, J. S., Wu, W. C. V., & Marek, M. W. (2017). Using the flipped classroom to enhance EFL learning. Computer Assisted Language Learning, 30(1), 1-21.
26. Chuang, H. H., Weng, C. Y., & Chen, C. H. (2018). Which students benefit most from a flipped classroom approach to language learning? British Journal of Educational Technology, 49(1), 56-68.
27. Creswell, J. W. (2013). Qualitative inquiry and research design: Choosing among five approaches. Sage.
28. Cruickshank, V., Pill, S., & Mainsbridge, C. (2021). Just do some physical activity’: Exploring experiences of teaching physical education online during Covid-19. Issues in Educational Research, 31(1), 76-93.
29. Cui, J., & Yu, S. (2019). Fostering deeper learning in a flipped classroom: Effects of knowledge graphs versus concept maps. British Journal of Educational Technology, 50(5), 2308-2328.
30. Cui, T., & Coleman, A. (2020). Investigating students’ attitudes, motives, participation and performance regarding out-of-class communication (OCC) in a flipped classroom. Electronic Journal of E-Learning, 18(6), 550-561.
31. del Arco, I., Mercadé-Melé, P., Ramos-Pla, A., & Flores-Alarcia, Ò. (2022). Bibliometric analysis of the flipped classroom pedagogical model: Trends and strategic lines of study. Frontiers in Education, 7, 1022295.
32. Doğan, Y., Batdı, V., & Yaşar, M. D. (2023). Effectiveness of flipped classroom practices in teaching of science: A mixed research synthesis. Research in Science and Technological Education, 41(1), 393-421.
33. Ekici, M. (2021). A systematic review of the use of gamification in flipped learning. Education and Information Technologies, 26(3), 3327-3346.
34. Enfield, J. (2013) Looking at the impact of the flipped classroom model of instruction on undergraduate multimedia students at CSUN. Tech Trends, 57(6), 14-27.
35. Erbil, D. G., & Kocabaş, A. (2020). Flipping the 4th grade social studies course in a cooperative way: Effects on academic achievement and motivation. Studies in Educational Evaluation, 66, 100878.
36. Flipped Learning Network [FLN]. (2014). The four pillars of F-L-I-P™. Retrieved January 1, 2024, from http://flippedlearning.org//site/Default.aspx?PageID=92FLN
37. Fornons, V., & Palau, R. (2021). Flipped classroom in the teaching of mathematics: A systematic review. Education in the Knowledge Society, 22, 11-20.
38. Galindo-Dominguez, H. (2021). Flipped classroom in the educational system: Trend or effective pedagogical model compared to other methodologies? Educational Technology & Society, 24(3), 44-60.
39. Gao, X., & Hew, K. F. (2023). A flipped systematic debugging approach to enhance elementary students’ program debugging performance and optimize cognitive load. Journal of Educational Computing Research, 61(5), 1064-1095.
40. Girmen, P., & Kaya, M. F. (2019). Using the flipped classroom model in the development of basic language skills and enriching activities: Digital stories and games. International Journal of Instruction, 12(1), 555-572.
41. Gómez-García, G., Marín-Marín, J. A., Romero-Rodríguez, J. M., Navas-Parejo, M. R., & Jiménez, C. R. (2020). Effect of the flipped classroom and gamification methods in the development of a didactic unit on healthy habits and diet in primary education. Nutrients, 12(8), 1-15.
42. Hamdan, N., McKnight, P., McKnight, K., & Arfstrom, K. M. (2013). The flipped learning model: A white paper based on the literature review titled a review of flipped learning. Pearson.
43. Han, F. (2023). Relations between students’ study approaches, perceptions of the learning environment, and academic achievement in flipped classroom learning: Evidence from self-reported and process data. Journal of Educational Computing Research, 61(6), 1252-1274.
44. Hao, Y. (2016). Exploring undergraduates’ perspectives and flipped learning readiness in their flipped classrooms. Computers in Human Behavior, 59, 82-92.
45. Hinojo-Lucena, F. J., Lopez Belmonte, J., Fuentes Cabrera, A., Trujillo Torres, J. M., & Pozo Sanchez, S. (2020). Academic effects of the use of flipped learning in physical education. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 17(1), 276.
46. Hsu, C.-Y., & Wu, T.-T. (2023). Application of business simulation games in flipped classrooms to facilitate student engagement and higher-order thinking skills for sustainable learning practices. Sustainability, 15(24), 16867.
47. Hui, Y. K., Mai, B., Qian, S., & Kwok, L. F. (2018). Cultivating better learning attitudes: A preliminary longitudinal study. Open Learning, 33(2), 155-170.
48. Hultén, M., & Larsson, B. (2018). The flipped classroom: Primary and secondary teachers’ views on an educational movement in schools in Sweden today. Scandinavian Journal of Educational Research, 62(3), 433-443.
49. Hung, H. T., & Yeh, H. C. (2023). Augmented‐reality‐enhanced game‐based learning in flipped English classrooms: Effects on students’ creative thinking and vocabulary acquisition. Journal of Computer Assisted Learning, 39(6), 1786-1800.
50. Hwang, G. J., & Lai, C. L. (2017). Facilitating and bridging out-of-class and in-class learning: an interactive e-bookbased flipped learning approach for math courses. Educational Technology & Society, 20(1), 184-197.
51. Hwang, G. J., Chang, S. C., Song, Y., & Hsieh, M. C. (2021). Powering up flipped learning: An online learning environment with a concept map-guided problem-posing strategy. Journal of Computer Assisted Learning, 37(2), 429-445.
52. Ibáñez, M. B., & Delgado-Kloos, C. (2018). Augmented reality for STEM learning: A systematic review. Computers & Education, 123, 109-123.
53. Jin, B., Wu, X. A., & Du, S. Da. (2020). Top 100 most frequently cited papers in liver cancer: A bibliometric analysis. ANZ Journal of Surgery, 90(1-2), 21-26.
54. Khodabandeh, F. (2023). Exploring the viability of augmented reality game-enhanced education in whatsapp flipped and blended classes versus the face-to-face classes. Education and Information Technologies, 28(1), 617-646.
55. Khodabandeh, F., & Mombini, A. (2024). Exploring the effect of augmented reality technology on high school students’ vocabulary learning, personality traits, and self-efficacy in flipped and blended classes. Education and Information Technologies, 29(12), 16027-16050.
56. Lage, M. J., Platt, G. J., & Treglia, M. (2000). Inverting the classroom: A gateway to creating an inclusive learning environment. The Journal of Economic Education, 31(1), 30-43.
57. Lai, C. L., & Hwang, G. J. (2016). A self-regulated flipped classroom approach to improving students’ learning performance in a mathematics course. Computers and Education, 100, 126-140.
58. Latorre-Cosculluela, C., Suárez, C., Quiroga, S., Sobradiel-Sierra, N., Lozano-Blasco, R., & Rodríguez-Martínez, A. (2021). Flipped classroom model before and during COVID-19: Using technology to develop 21st century skills. Interactive Technology and Smart Education, 18(2), 189-204.
59. Lee, G. G., Jeon, Y. E., & Hong, H. G. (2021). The effects of cooperative flipped learning on science achievement and motivation in high school students. International Journal of Science Education, 43(9), 1381-1407.
60. Lin, H. C., Hwang, G. J., & Hsu, Y. D. (2019). Effects of ASQ-based flipped learning on nurse practitioner learners’ nursing skills, learning achievement and learning perceptions. Computers & Education, 139, 207-221.
61. Lo, C. K. (2020). Systematic reviews on flipped learning in various education contexts. In O. Zawacki-Richter, M. Kerres, S. Bedenlier, M. Bond & K. Buntins (Eds.), Systematic reviews in educational research: Methodology, perspectives and application (pp.129–143). Springer.
62. Lo, C. K., & Hew, K. F. (2017). A critical review of flipped classroom challenges in K-12 education: Possible solutions and recommendations for future research. Research and Practice in Technology Enhanced Learning, 12(1), 1-22.
63. Loizou, M., & Lee, K. (2020). A flipped classroom model for inquiry-based learning in primary education context. Research in Learning Technology, 28, 1-18.
64. Ma, Y. (2023). Exploration of flipped classroom approach to enhance critical thinking skills. Heliyon, 9(11), 1-21.
65. Mazur, E. (1997). Peer instruction: A user’s manual. Prentice-Hall.
66. McEvoy, C. S., Cantore, K. M., Denlinger, L. N., Schleich, M. A., Stevens, N. M., Swavely, S. C., Odom, A. A., & Novick, M. B. (2016). Use of medical students in a flipped classroom programme in nutrition education for fourth-grade school students. Health Education Journal, 75(1), 38-46.
67. McLaughlin, J. E., White, P. J., Khanova, J., & Yuriev, E. (2016). Flipped classroom implementation: A case report of two higher education institutions in the United States and Australia. Computers in the Schools, 33(1), 24-37.
68. O’Flaherty, J., & Phillips, C. (2015). The use of flipped classrooms in higher education: A scoping review. Internet and Higher Education, 25, 85-95.
69. Page, M. J., McKenzie, J. E., Bossuyt, P. M., Boutron, I., Hoffmann, T. C., Mulrow, C. D., Shamseer, L., Tetzlaff, J. M., & Moher, D. (2021). Updating guidance for reporting systematic reviews: Development of the PRISMA 2020 statement. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, 134, 103-112.
70. Parra-Giménez, F. J. (2017). La taxonomía de Bloom en el modelo aula invertida. Publicaciones Didácticas, 86, 176-179.
71. Phillips, C. R., & Trainor, J. E. (2014). Millennial students and the flipped classroom. Journal of Business and Educational Leadership, 5, 102-112.
72. Pinto, M., Fernández-Pascual, R., Caballero-Mariscal, D., Sales, D., Guerrero, D., & Uribe, A. (2019). Scientific production on mobile information literacy in higher education: A bibliometric analysis (2006-2017). Scientometrics, 120(1), 57-85.
73. Sáez-López, J. M., & Cózar-Gutiérrez, R. (2017). Programación visual por bloques en educación primaria: Aprendiendo y creando contenidos en ciencias sociales. Revista Complutense de Educacion, 28(2), 409-426.
74. Şahin, Ş. N., & Tavil, Z. M. (2023). The effect of flipped classroom model on the vocabulary learning and retention of young EFL learners. The Journal of Language Teaching and Learning, 13(1), 42-58.
75. Sánchez, S. P., Belmonte, J. L., Guerrero, A. J. M., & Núñez, J. A. L. (2019). Impact of educational stage in the application of flipped learning: A contrasting analysis with traditional teaching. Sustainability, 11(21), 5968.
76. Strelan, P., Osborn, A., & Palmer, E. (2020). The flipped classroom: A meta-analysis of effects on student performance across disciplines and education levels. Educational Research Review, 30, 100314.
77. Teo, T., Khazaie, S., & Derakhshan, A. (2022). Exploring teacher immediacy-(non) dependency in the tutored augmented reality game-assisted flipped classrooms of English for medical purposes comprehension among the Asian students. Computers & Education, 179, 104406.
78. Tsai, C. W., Shen, P. Di, & Lu, Y. J. (2015). The effects of problem-based learning with flipped classroom on elementary students’ computing skills: A case study of the production of Ebooks (EJ1168174). ERIC. https://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ1168174
79. Turan, Z., & Akdag-Cimen, B. (2020). Flipped classroom in English language teaching: A systematic review. Computer Assisted Language Learning, 33(5-6), 590-606.
80. Turan, Z., & Göktaş, Y. (2016). The flipped classroom: Instructional efficiency and impact of achievement and cognitive load levels. Journal of e-Learning and Knowledge Society, 12(4), 51-62.
81. Tutal, Ö., & Yazar, T. (2021). Flipped classroom improves academic achievement, learning retention and attitude towards course: A meta-analysis. Asia Pacific Education Review, 22(4), 655-673.
82. van Eck, N. J., & Waltman, L. (2010). Software survey: VOSviewer, a computer program for bibliometric mapping. Scientometrics, 84(2), 523-538.
83. Vicente, F. R., Linares, A. Z., & Sánchez, N. M. (2020). “Sustainable city”: A steam project using robotics to bring the city of the future to primary education students. Sustainability, 12(22), 1-21.
84. Wright, G. W., & Park, S. (2022). The effects of flipped classrooms on K-16 students’ science and math achievement: A systematic review. Studies in Science Education, 58(1), 95-136.
85. Yang, C. C. R., & Chen, Y. (2020). Implementing the flipped classroom approach in primary English classrooms in China. Education and Information Technologies, 25(2), 1217-1235.
86. Ye, X. D., Chang, Y. H., & Lai, C. L. (2019). An interactive problem-posing guiding approach to bridging and facilitating pre- and in-class learning for flipped classrooms. Interactive Learning Environments, 27(8), 1075-1092.
87. Yilmaz, R. (2017). Exploring the role of e-learning readiness on student satisfaction and motivation in flipped classroom. Computers in Human Behavior, 70, 251-260.
88. Zainuddin, Z. (2018). Students’ learning performance and perceived motivation in gamified flipped-class instruction. Computers & Education, 126, 75-88.
89. Zainuddin, Z., Zhang, Y., Li, X., Chu, S. K. W., Idris, S., & Keumala, C. M. (2019). Research trends in flipped classroom empirical evidence from 2017 to 2018: A content analysis. Interactive Technology and Smart Education, 16(3), 255-277.
90. Zan, B. U. (2019). Evolution of research subjects based on direct citation, cocitation and bibliographical coupling approaches. Social Sciences Researches Journal 14(2), 501-516.
91. Zawacki-Richter, O., & Latchem, C. (2018). Exploring four decades of research in Computers & Education. Computers & Education, 122, 136-152.
92. Zhao, J., Hwang, G. J., Chang, S. C., Yang, Q. fan, & Nokkaew, A. (2021). Effects of gamified interactive e-books on students’ flipped learning performance, motivation, and meta-cognition tendency in a mathematics course. Educational Technology Research and Development, 69(6), 3255-3280.
93. Zheng, L., Bhagat, K. K., Zhen, Y., & Zhang, X. (2020). The effectiveness of the flipped classroom on students’ learning achievement and learning motivation. Journal of Educational Technology & Society, 23(1), 1-15.
94. Zhu, G. (2021). Is flipping effective? A meta-analysis of the effect of flipped instruction on K-12 students’ academic achievement. Educational Technology Research and Development, 69, 733-761.
95. Zou, D. (2020). Gamified flipped EFL classroom for primary education: Student and teacher perceptions. Journal of Computers in Education, 7(2), 213-228.
96. Zou, D., & Zhang, R. (2021). Flipped primary EFL classrooms: Impact, feasibility, and potential. ELT Journal, 75(3), 267-277.
97. Zou, D., Luo, S., Xie, H., & Hwang, G. J. (2022). A systematic review of research on flipped language classrooms: Theoretical foundations, learning activities, tools, research topics and findings. Computer Assisted Language Learning, 35(8), 1811-1837.
98. Županec, V. S., Radulović, B. N., Pribićević, T. Z., Miljanović, T. G., & Zdravković, V. G. (2018). Determination of educational efficiency and students’ involvement in the flipped biology classroom in primary school. Journal of Baltic Science Education, 17(1), 162-176.
99. Zupic, I., & Čater, T. (2015). Bibliometric methods in management and organization. Organizational Research Methods, 18(3), 429-472.