Volume: 16 Issue: 31, 11/30/22

Year: 2022

Articles

Reviews

Necrology

The aim of the journal of Dil Araştırmaları, original research, related to Turkish language, analysis, compilation and text studies in all sub-branches of historical and contemporary comparative linguistics, especially phonology, morphology, semantics, etymology, syntax, vocabulary, provided. In addition, to contribute to the Turcology research literature and to bring the journal to a point that represents Turkey in the world.

In line with its purposes, the publication focus of the Journal of Language Research (DA) includes the following subjects, provided that they are related to Turkish language:
1. Original research, analysis, compilation and text studies in all subbranches of historical and contemporary comparative linguistics
2. Translations of research and analysis studies conducted in all subbranches of historical and contemporary comparative linguistics, not exceeding 25% of the total volume of the journal.
3. Criticism and reviews about the book studies in the category in the first article
Regarding these three items
⌐ Studies of undergraduate students studying in the field of Turcology and those who have not studied in the field of Turcology are not accepted for publication with a single author. In such articles, it is expected that a faculty member has a scientific contribution and this faculty member should also be included as an author. However, studies of master’s and / or doctoral students / graduates can be accepted as a single author.
⌐ Studies involving themes other than Turkish language (history, literature, educational sciences, sociology, etc.) are not accepted.

Manuscripts submitted to the Journal of Dil Araştırmaları should not have been published anywhere before or should not be sent to another publication at the same time. Papers presented at a scientific meeting can be accepted, provided that they are separately stated and have not been published before. Only one article of an author can be published in the same year. The review process of the second article of the same author is not started before the first article is published.
Articles must be submitted in accordance with the criteria set out below. Minor corrections that are immaterial during publication can be made by the Editorial Unit. These corrections are based on the Türk Dil Kurumu spelling guide and dictionaries.
Translated articles can be published provided that permission is obtained from the author of the article to be translated and the place where it is published (book, journal, etc.). If 70 years have passed after the death of the author, this permission document is not required.
Reviews must contain original information concerning the publication. Articles for which publication is reviewed must provide original information about the publication in question. Articles that resemble advertisements or are in the form of a short summary of publications are not included in the agenda of the journal. Articles that do not express the remarkable aspects or deficiencies of the publication, and do not make objective evaluations about the publication in accordance with academic criteria are not included in the agenda of the journal either.
The copyright of the published articles is deemed to have been transferred to the Journal of Dil Araştırmaları. The intellectual and scientific responsibility of the articles and the legal responsibility of the translations belong to the authors/translators. In articles with two or more authors, the copyright of the article belongs to the first author. The articles and photographs published in the journal can be cited by showing the source.

Submission
Articles should be submitted by logging in at https://dergipark.org.tr/tr/pub/dilarastirmalari. This submission must be accompanied by the copyright transfer. The following principles regarding the writing order should be followed while submitting the article.

Page Layout
Program: Microsoft Office Word versions
Page size: A4 (29.7x21 cm.) vertical
Margins: 3 cm on all four sides (right, left, top, bottom)
Font: Times New Roman

Limitations
The main text of the article; Tables should not exceed 7750 words, including appendices and footnotes.
Article titles, abstracts, keywords and bibliography are excluded from this limit.
Articles exceeding this limit can be accepted up to 8000 words with an option of approximately 3% by the decision of the editor.
Articles exceeding 8000 words are returned without reference to the editorial decision.

Titles
Article Title
Each article should have a Turkish and English title. The title of the work should clearly reflect the content and be comprehensive. The title should not exceed 12 words, should be bold and written in 14-point font with capital letters, the second language equivalent should be in italics with the initials capitalized, in 12-point font, and placed just below the Turkish title.
Numbering
All headings, including the introduction, conclusion, appendices and bibliography, should be numbered. In the enumeration, the Entry must be specified with "0". The main headings should continue as “1, 2, 3”. Letters such as A, a, i, b and Roman numerals should not be used in numbering.
Main Titles
The main titles in the article should be numbered as “1, 2, 3” and should be written in 12 point bold and capital letters.
Subtitles
The subheadings in the article are gradually “1.1, 2.3, 3.2.2, 4.1.3.1 etc.” The figures should be numbered. Titles up to four digits must not end with a full stop (.), colon (:), or other punctuation marks.
Two-stage titles such as 1.2, 3.1, 5.2 should be written in 12 points and with capital letters.
Three-stage titles such as 1.2.1, 3.1.2, 5.2.4 should be written in 11 points, with capital letters.
Four-stage titles such as 1.2.1.3, 3.1.2.1, 5.2.4.2 should be written in 11 font size, capital letters and italics.
Starting from titles with more than four levels, a colon (:) must be placed at the end of the word where the title ends, and the text must continue after the colon.
Apart from these, in cases where special titles or special numbering are required, editing can be made by the decision of the editor.

Author name(s) and address(es)
Under the titles of the articles, author surname should be written in capital letters, in 11 font size, bold, and the institution, title, contact information and ORCID information of the author(s) should be indicated on the first page of the article in italic form with footnotes as “*”. In case of more than one author, the author's name(s) and surname(s) should be written one after the other, and the author's information should be indicated in footnotes with asterisk as "*, **, ***".

Öz / Abstract
At the beginning of the article, a blank line should be left after the author's information, followed by the Turkish abstract and English abstract sections. However, if the articles are prepared in German, French, Russian or modern Turkic languages, abstracts in Turkish, English and a third language, respectively, should be included in the article.
The öz and abstract must include at least 50 and at most 300 words. Quotations, references, figures, tables, etc. must not take part in öz and abstract.
The öz and the abstract must correspond in terms of content, and must be written with a font size of 10, with an indent of 1 cm from the left and right.

Anahtar kelimeler / Key words
“Keywords” should be given under the abstract. Keywords should consist of at least 3 and at most 8 words. Keywords should be compatible with the article content and should be inclusive. In keywords, very general expressions as “language, languages, etc.” should not be used. In keywords, each phrase should consist of no more than three words.

Main Text
The main text should be written with single line spacing and 11 points, paragraph spacing should be determined as 6 pt before and after.

Visuals
The pictures, photographs, maps, figures and tables in the article should be left aligned, italicized and numbered in 10 points (Picture 1., Map 2., Figure 1. etc.), followed by an explanatory statement.
e.g. Table 1. Vowel System in Turkish
Written expressions in tables and figures in the article should not exceed 10 points. Font size can be reduced to 8 in voluminous tables and figures.
Pictures and photographs should be placed in the article in high resolution.
The proportion of pictures, photographs, maps, figures and tables in the article should not exceed 50% of the main text of the article. The article should be planned according to these principles.

Citations and References
Direct quotations from the article should be given in quotation marks. Quotations less than 4 lines should be shown in between lines. Longer quotations on the 4th line should be placed 1 cm from the right and left of the line, in block form and with a single line spacing in 10 points.
References in the text should be written as follows, with the surname, year and page number in parentheses.

Single-author publications (Ercilasun 2016: 75)
Publications with two authors (Gülsevin and Boz 2004: 121)
Publications with more than two authors (Yılmaz et al. 2013: 18)
If the name of the cited author is mentioned in the text Korkmaz (2003: 142)
Indirect references to sources whose originals are not seen. Köprülü (1926, from Çelik 1998)
In online resources, by adding “e-” to the beginning of the web address and shortening it and together with the access date. For https://tr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Türkler (e-WT 11.2.2021)

For Güncel Türkçe Sözlük. https://sozluk.gov.tr/ (e-GTS)
If more than one source is cited at the same place in the text, the sources are separated with semicolons. (Köprülü 1966: 10; Kaplan 2004: 15; Tanpınar 1969: 20)
If an oral source is used, the source person information should be provided with Name, Surname, Date and Place of Interview. (Ahmet Yıldız 23.1.2020, Ankara)

References
The sources used in the article should be, between the main text and the appendices, listed alphabetically by last name. All sources used in the article should be listed under the "References" heading, documents and works that are not mentioned in the article should not be included. References must be written in the Latin alphabet.
In the sources written in other alphabets (Cyrillic, Arabic, Indian etc.), Latin letters should be given priority, then the original form should be given by using the “/” sign.
The name of the author must be indicated in the references. Authors' titles should not be shown. If the author's name is abbreviated in the work used, the abbreviation should be completed and shown in parentheses: e.g. Ercilasun, A(hmet) B(ican).
Since the information given by placing a colon after the city information in the sources will be the information of the publisher, there is no need to use the words "publications, publishing house, bookstore" for publishing houses.
Book and journal titles should be written in italics. Sources such as articles, book chapters, and papers should be shown in quotation marks. Page range information of publications such as articles, papers, encyclopedia articles, book chapters should also be added to the references.
If there is a translator, compiler, editor or editor of the book, its name should be given after the work information.
In the references, if an author has more than one publication of the same date, it should be indicated as (a, b).
When a thesis is cited, the surname and name of the thesis author should be followed by the date of the thesis, the full title of the thesis in italic characters, the type of the thesis, the name of the university and the city. Since theses published as a book or article fall into the category of books or articles, there is no need to use phrases such as "unpublished" in theses.

Manuscripts should be cited as Author. Title of Work. Library. Collection. catalog number. leaf. Access Date information must be given in references to an online study. In the references, these abbreviations should be used if necessary: “Trans.” for the translator, “Edt.” for the editor, “Comp.” for the compiler, “Prep.” for the preparer.

Author Information Examples

Single-author publications Ercilasun, Ahmet Bican (2016).
Publications with two authors Gülsevin, Gürer; Boz, Erdoğan (2004).
Publications with three authors Yılmaz, Emine; Demir, Nurettin; Küçük, Murat (2013).
Publications with more than three authors Akyüz, Kenan et al. (1958).
If the same author has more than one publication in the same year Ercilasun, Ahmet Bican (2014a).
Ercilasun, Ahmet Bican (2014b).
Prepared Prep. Ekrem Arıkoğlu
Translated Trans. Mehmet Akalın
Compiled by Comp. Astrid Menz - Christoph Schroder
Editor Edt. Ahmet Bican Ercilasun

REFERENCES EXAMPLES

Books
Single-author books ERCİLASUN, Ahmet Bican (2016). Türk Kağanlığı ve Türk Bengü Taşları. İstanbul: Dergâh.
KORKMAZ, Zeynep (2003). Türkiye Türkçesi Grameri (Şekil Bilgisi). Ankara: Türk Dil Kurumu.
GABAIN, Annemarie von (1988). Eski Türkçenin Grameri (Trans. Mehmet Akalın). Ankara: Türk Dil Kurumu.
Books with two authors GÜLSEVİN, Gürer; BOZ, Erdoğan (2004). Eski Anadolu Türkçesi. Ankara: Gazi.
Books by three authors YILMAZ, Emine; DEMİR, Nurettin; KÜÇÜK, Murat (2013). Kısas-ı Enbiya. Ankara: Türk Dil Kurumu.
Books with more than three authors (only with the surname of the first author) AKYÜZ, Kenan et al. (1958). Fuzulî Türkçe Dîvân. Ankara: İş Bankası.

Chapters
Book section (with editor information) ERSOY, Feyzi (2007). “Çuvaş Türkçesi”. Türk Lehçeleri Grameri (Edt. Ahmet Bican Ercilasun). Ankara: Akçağ, 1285-1340.
Arıkoğlu, Ekrem (2019). “Eski Türkçeden Tuvacaya”. Eski Türkçenin İzinde. Türkiye’de Eski Türkçe Çalışmaları (Edt. Hüseyin Yıldız). Ankara: Akçağ, 113-118.

Articles
If the journal does not have volume information KARAHAN, Leylâ (1997). “Fiil-Tamlayıcı İlişkisi Üzerine”. Türk Dili, 549: 209-213.
If the journal has volume information ERCİLASUN, Ahmet Bican (2019). “Dede Korkut Kitabı’nın Yeni Nüshası ve Üzerindeki Yayınlar”. Millî Folklor, 16/123: 5-22.
If the translation is an article SCHÖNİG, Claus (2013). “Modern Türk Dillerinin Eş Zamanlı Tasnifi ve Tarihsel Yönleri” (Trans. İsa Sarı). Dil Araştırmaları, 12: 221-257.

Publications with unknown author
Publications with unknown author Türk Dili ve Edebiyatı Ansiklopedisi (1977). İstanbul: Dergâh.

Other Resources

Article in Encyclopedia article

İPEKTEN, Haluk (1991). “Azmî-zâde Mustafa Hâletî”. İslâm Ansiklopedisi, 4, İstanbul: Türkiye Diyanet Vakfı, 348-349.

Theses

YILDIZ, Hüseyin (2016). Eski Uygurcada Mental Fiiller. Doktora Tezi. Ankara: Gazi Üniversitesi.

Manuscript

ÂSIM. Zeyl-i Zübdetü'l-Eş‘âr. Millet Kütüphanesi. A. Emirî Efendi. No. 132, 1b-45a.

Printed work

EBÜZZİYA TEVFİK (1306). Lûgat-ı Ebüzziya. İstanbul: Ebüzziya Matbaası.

Archive

BAO (Başbakanlık Osmanlı Arşivi). Name-i Hümayun Defteri (10)

Online resources

e-GTS = Türk Dil Kurumu (2021). Güncel Türkçe Sözlük. https://sozluk.gov.tr/ (Access Date: 12.01.2021)
e-Ortaylı 2019 = Ortaylı, İlber (29.12.2019). “Türk Dil Bayramı’nın komşu adresi: Makedonya”. Hürriyet. https://www.hurriyet.com.tr/yazarlar/ilber-ortayli/turk-dil-bayraminin-komsu-adresi-makedonya-41408084 (Access Date: 12.01.2021).
e-WT = Wikipedia (2021). “Türkler”. https://tr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Türkler (Access Date: 12.1.2021)
e-books AYÇİÇEĞİ, B. (2018). Behiştî Ahmed’in İskender-nâmesi (İnceleme-Metin). Link: https://ekitap.ktb.gov.tr/TR-206269/behisti-ahmed-iskender-name.html.

Papers

ERCİLASUN, Ahmet Bican (2018). “Türk Bengü Taşları Üzerine Genel Bir Değerlendirme”. Köktürk Yazısının Okunuşunun 125. Yılında Orhun’dan Anadolu’ya Uluslararası Türkoloji Sempozyumu. 1-7 Haziran 2018. Ulanbator-Moğolistan. (Edt. Şaban Doğan - Melis Sezen Güneş). İstanbul: Kesit, 720-725.

Source person (compilation)

ÂŞIK MEHMET EFE (19.5.2015). Ankara / Kızılcahamam. 58 year-old.

Legal entity

TÜRK DİL KURUMU (2012). Yazım Kılavuzu. Ankara: Türk Dil Kurumu.

Footnotes
Explanations that are not related to the main subject of the article directly, can be made by using footnotes starting from "1". Footnotes should be written in 10 points at the bottom of the page.

Appendixes
Appendixes tables, figures, graphics and pictures should be given on a new page after the bibliography. Each appendix; should be numbered as Appendix 1, Appendix 2 and titled separately. Appendixes should be written with single line spacing, 10 points.

The author(s) are responsible for complying with the criteria for Actions Contrary to Scientific Research and Publication Ethics in the second part of the Interuniversity Board Scientific Research and Publication Ethics Directive ((https://www.uak.gov.tr/Documents/mevzuat/2021/%C3%9CN%C4%B0VERS%C4%B0TELERARASI%20KURUL%20B%C4%B0L%C4%B0MSEL%20ARA%C5%9ETIRMA%20VE%20YAYIN%20ET%C4%B0%C4%9E%C4%B0%20Y%C3%96NERGES%C4%B0-29012021.pdf)).

TÜBİTAK ULAKBİM TR DİZİN RULES AND ETHICS COMMITTEE PERMISSION
It is important for all authors to pay attention to the following issues within the scope of the rules regarding the Ethical Principles announced by TR Index in 2020:
Studies that require the approval of the Ethics Committee are as follows:
* All kinds of research conducted with qualitative or quantitative approaches that require data collection from the participants by using survey, interview, focus group work, observation, experiment, interview techniques,
* Use of humans and animals (including material/data) for experimental or other scientific purposes,
* Clinic researches on humans and animals, ,
* Retrospective studies in accordance with the personal data protection law.
Moreover; stating that an “informed consent form” was taken in case reports; obtaining permission from the owners for the use of scales, questionnaires, photographs belonging to others and indicating this; It should be stated that copyright regulations are complied with for the intellectual and artistic works used.
In case the articles that meet the above conditions and require the permission of the Ethics Committee are sent to the Journal of Language Studies, the official Ethics Committee permission documents must be sent as an attachment to the journal.

Publication Ethics
The way to be followed in the journal of Dil Araştırmaları (hereinafter DA) regarding publication ethics, research ethics, legal / special permission is described in the following items.
⌐ Articles must comply with national and international publication and research ethics.
⌐ Although the issue of publication ethics in the articles sent to DA is under the responsibility of the author(s), the author(s) are obliged to check the article with Turnitin or iThenticate programs, which are plagiarism prevention software, and send the similarity report to the journal in the article application. Articles with a similarity rate of 20% or more will not be evaluated. Articles are subjected to plagiarism review (Turnitin or iThenticate) if deemed necessary by the editor. With this process, it is aimed to increase the originality and scientific quality of the articles and to prevent plagiarism.
⌐ The opinions and thoughts expressed in the articles bind the author(s) and do not reflect the views of our journal; All scientific and legal responsibility of the articles belongs to the author(s).
⌐ It is expected that the works submitted by the author(s) will be original. If the author(s) benefit from or use other studies, they must cite and/or quote completely and accurately.
⌐ If the article has more than one author, persons who do not contribute to the content intellectually in the creation of the study should not be specified as author(s). The authors of the candidate article should be limited to those who made significant contributions to the presented study. The authors of the article are determined before submitting the article. It is unacceptable to include the names of noncontributors in the candidate article (gift authorship) or not to include the names of contributors (ghost authorship). Changing the author responsibilities of a study whose evaluation process has started (such as adding authors, changing author order, removing authors) cannot be proposed.
⌐ The situations and relationships of all studies that may constitute a conflict of interest, if any, must be explained.
⌐ Editors may request raw data regarding their articles within the framework of evaluation processes, in such a case, the author(s) should be ready to present the expected data and information to the editorial board and scientific board.
⌐ In the following cases requiring legal / special permission, permission is requested from the author from the articles sent to DA. In the articles to be published, the permission of the ethics committee and whether legal / special permission is required is stated in the title footnote of the article. If these permissions are required, the author or authors are asked to clearly present the permission from which institution, on what date and with which decision or issue number and is published as an “Appendix” at the end of the article. The author(s) must have a document showing that they have the rights to use the data used, the necessary permissions for the research / analysis, or that the consent of the experimental subjects has been obtained.
⌐ Author(s) must obtain permission from their owners for the use of scales, questionnaires, photographs belonging to others in the works they submit, and must state that this condition and copyright regulations are complied with for the ideas and works of art used. If the study requires the use of subjects (human and animal), the study should be included in an international declaration, guide, etc. proper execution must be declared by the author(s).
⌐ The author(s) are obliged to declare the institutions that support the studies, financial resources, and the “Acknowledgment” part of the title footnote.
⌐ In the event that the author(s) notices a mistake or error in their published work, early appearance or evaluation stage, the journal editor or publisher has an obligation to cooperate with the editor in informing, correcting or withdrawing.
⌐ Although the studies presented at scientific meetings and the studies forming a part of the theses are not accepted without revision or further study for DA by 2021; It is obligatory to obtain permission from the author / consultant for thesis publications and from the symposium committee for papers, which are believed to have scientific contribution with the permission of the editor, provided that a footnote is included regarding the progress of the submitted paper or the written / defended thesis.
⌐ Author(s) cannot submit their work to more than one journal at the same time. Each submission can be started following completion of the previous application. A study published in another journal cannot be sent to DA.
⌐ Author(s) should not present the results of a research as separate publications in academic appointments and promotions by disassembling the results of the research in an inappropriate manner and by dismembering them in multiple issues. For this reason, articles numbered “1”, “2” cannot be sent to DA.
⌐ When a writer detects a material error in his article published in the DA, he must notify the editor of the journal immediately and cooperate with the editor to retract or correct the article.

Transfer of Copyright
(via https://dergipark.org.tr/en/pub/dilarastirmalari):
⌐ For the mutual benefit and protection of author(s) and publishers, author(s) are required to submit a written permission to our journal before the publication of their work.
⌐ Authors are obliged to fill in and upload the copyright transfer agreement in the system while uploading their articles via the DERGİPARK system (https://dergipark.org.tr/en/pub/dilarastirmalari).

Publication Frequency

⌐ DA, an international refereed journal, is published biannually.
⌐ Only two special issues can be published in a year, provided that it is planned and announced at least four months in advance. Special topic Turkish studies can be guided.

Publication Language
⌐ In the main broadcasting language of DA is Turkish. In addition, articles can be submitted in English, German, French, Russian or modern Turkic languages. Submitted article must comply with the grammatical rules of the relevant language and the relevant scientific literature.


Publication Review

Blind Review and Evaluation Process
⌐ Blind refereeing is a method applied for publishing scientific publications with the highest quality and forms the basis of the objective evaluation process of scientific studies and is preferred by many scientific journals.
⌐ All studies sent to DA are evaluated through blinding according to the following stages.

Blind Review Type
⌐ DA uses the double blind method in the evaluation process of all studies. In the double blind method, the identities of the authors and referees of the studies are hidden.

Initial Evaluation Process
⌐ Studies submitted to DA are first evaluated by the editors.
⌐ At this stage, studies that do not comply with the purpose and scope of the journal, are weak in terms of language and expression rules in Turkish and English, contain scientific critical errors, do not have original value and do not meet the publication policies are rejected.
⌐ Authors of rejected works are informed within two months from the date of submission.
⌐ Studies deemed appropriate are sent to referees who are expert of the field for evaluation.

Referee Assignment Process
⌐ Referees are appointed according to the content of the studies and the expertise of the referees. Two referees are determined from the DA referee team according to their field of expertise by the editors who examine the study and the studies are submitted to the referees.
⌐ Referees must guarantee that they will not share any process and document about the work they evaluate.

Referee Reports
⌐ Referee evaluations generally concentrate on studies’ originality, method, compliance with ethical rules, consistent presentation of findings and results, and examination of the literature.
⌐ This examination is made according to the following factors:
1. Introduction and literature: The evaluation report includes an opinion about the presentation and objectives of the problem dealt with in the study, the importance of the subject, the scope of the relevant literature, its currency and originality of the study.
2. Method: The evaluation report includes information on the suitability of the method used, the selection and characteristics of the research group, validity and reliability, as well as an opinion on the data collection and analysis process.
3. Findings: The evaluation report includes opinions about the presentation of the findings obtained within the framework of the method, the accuracy of the analysis methods, the consistency of the findings reached with the purposes of the research, the necessary tables, figures and visuals, and the conceptual evaluation of the tests used.
4. Evaluation and discussion: The evaluation report includes discussion of the subject based on the findings, compliance with the research question(s) and hypothesis(es), generalizability and applicability.
5. Conclusion and suggestions: The evaluation report includes contribution to the literature, opinions on suggestions for future studies and practices in the field.
6. Style and expression: The evaluation report includes the opinion about the content of the study title, the use of Turkish in accordance with the rules, and the submission of references and references in accordance with the APA 6 rules.
7. General evaluation: The evaluation report includes an opinion about the originality of the study as a whole and its contribution to the concerned literature and practices in the field.
⌐ During the evaluation process, the referees are not expected to make adjustments according to the typographical features of the study.

Referee Evaluation Process
⌐ Editors can request corrections and improvements for articles in the evaluation process in DA.
⌐ The time given to referees for the evaluation process is 6 weeks. Correction suggestions from referees or editors must be completed by the authors within 1 month in line with the “correction rules”. Referees can review the revisions of a work and decide whether it is appropriate or, if necessary, request corrections more than once.
⌐ The author(s) are obliged to complete corrections and improvements in a complete, explanatory and timely manner, with the awareness that the requested correction and improvement suggestions are objective and increase the originality of the study.

Evaluation Result
⌐ Comments from referees are reviewed by editors within 2 weeks at the latest. As a result of this review, the editorial office determines its final decision to submit to the editorial board.

Editorial Board Decision
⌐ Editors prepare the editorial board decision about the study based on the referee opinions. The decision prepared is forwarded to the author(s) within 1 week at the latest, together with the referee recommendations.
⌐ The works with negative opinions during this process are rejected.
⌐ The works with positive opinions are queued according to submission date after the latest review.

How Long Does the Evaluation Process Take?
⌐ It is considered that the publication of the studies sent to DA will be concluded approximately within 4 months.
⌐ However, the period between the date when the referees or editors request a correction from the author (s) and the date when the author (s) complete the corrections are not included in this 4 month period.
⌐ DA editorial board; in case of suspicion of copyright and plagiarism related to a published, online-first or under evaluation work, are supposed to initiate an investigation into the work.
⌐ If the editorial board determines that there is copyright and plagiarism in the study at the evaluation stage, it withdraws the work from evaluation and returns the detected situations to the authors by citing detailed sources. If the editorial board detects a copyright infringement and plagiarism in a published or early-view work, it will take the following recalls and notifications within one week at the latest.

Objection to the Evaluation Result
⌐ If the author(s) do not want to make some of the requested corrections and improvements; it has to present it to the editorial office with its reasons as a report. The editorial office will share this report with the referees and the final decision for corrections and improvements will be reflected in the referee reports.
⌐ The author(s) reserves the right to object to the editorial board and scientific committee opinions that are forwarded to the author(s) as a result of the evaluation in the DA. The author(s) should send their objection regarding their opinions and comments to dilarastirmalari@gmail.com in a scientific language and by referring to their basis. The objections made are examined by the editorial board and the editorial board within one month at the latest, and a positive or negative response is provided to the author(s). If the objection of the author(s) to the evaluation result is found positive, the editorial board restarts the evaluation process by making new referees in accordance with the subject area of the study.


Publication Policy
⌐ Studies accepted as a result of evaluation in DA, respectively; It goes through the processes of checking for plagiarism, organizing bibliography, citation and citation, layout and typesetting, giving the DOI number and opening it for early viewing.
⌐ Studies published in early view are published in volumes and numbers approved by the editorial board.
⌐ There is no source of income as DA does not charge article processing fee (evaluation fee or printing fee) and subscription fee for accessing the articles.
⌐ No royalty is paid to the author(s) for the articles published in DA.
⌐ All articles published in DA are also available in full text on the web address http:// www.dilarastirmalari.com/ as open access.
⌐ DA cares about spreading current and original information. In this context, studies that are accepted by completing the evaluation phase and whose processes are completed after acceptance are published electronically in early view. Studies published in early view are published by giving the number of volumes and number of pages approved by the editorial board and removed from early view. Early view works may not be the last version to be published in the normal issue. Minor edits of the works can be made if they are to be published recently.

The printing/distribution expenses of the journal are covered by the Avrasya Yazarlar Birliği. The publication of articles and the execution of article processes in the journal are free of charge. No processing fee is charged for articles submitted to the journal or accepted for publication.